Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • English Companies Act of 1948 (s. 455).
  • Companies Act, 1956, in s. 2(12)
  • s. 256(1) of the I.T Act, 1961,
  • s. 80J of the I.T Act, 1961.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • English Companies Act of 1948 (s. 455).
  • Companies Act, 1956, in s. 2(12)
  • s. 256(1) of the I.T Act, 1961,
  • s. 80J of the I.T Act, 1961.
Smart Summary

Summary of Judgment: Income-tax Reference No. 77 of 1977 (Decided June 9, 1982)

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference arose under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, made by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, from its disposal of appeals involving the assessee, Cochin Refineries Ltd., and the Department for the assessment year 1971-72. The Tribunal referred two questions to this Court concerning (1) whether two medium-term U.S. dollar loans (one of Rs. 90,00,000 and another of Rs. 1,31,86,875) should be treated as "debentures" for the purpose of granting relief under section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961; and (2) whether interest income from bank deposits should be treated as business income for the purposes of section 80J.

Relevant factual background (as stated in the opinion): the assessee had entered into Loan and Note Purchase Agreements dated July 1, 1964 (with various financiers) and December 31, 1967 (with Philips Petroleum International Corporation). Under the 1964 agreement the company authorised issuance of secured notes (series A and B) amounting to U.S. dollars; the notes were to be issued under a mortgage and trust deed; the 1964 agreement specified that the term "notes" was intended to have the same meaning as "debentures" under Indian law. The 1967 agreement provided for issuance of 6% notes to evidence borrowings from Philips Petroleum; no mortgage/trust deed accompanied the 1967 agreement, but there was a guarantee by the President of India (and also a Reserve Bank guarantee to U.S. lenders) guaranteeing punctual payment of principal and interest.

Procedural history as recited in the opinion: the Assessing Officer (ITO) treated the two dollar loans as liabilities and deducted them in computing capital employed under rule 19A (leading to a smaller relief under s.80J than claimed by the assessee). The assessee treated the loans as debentures (and therefore did not deduct them when computing capital employed). The first appellate authority (AAC) rejected the assessee's contention. On further appeal, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal accepted the assessee's contention that the loans were debentures. The Tribunal then referred the two questions to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, and on an interpretation of the agreements entered into by the company with certain financiers, the Tribunal was right in law in treating the medium term dollar loan amounting to Rs. 90,00,000 and dollar loan amounting to Rs. 1,31,86,875 as debentures for the purpose of granting relief under section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in law in treating the interest income from bank deposits as business income of the assessee for the purpose of section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (as recorded)

  • The assessee contended that the two dollar loans evidenced by the notes were, in substance, debentures and ought to be treated as such for purposes of computing capital employed under s.80J (and therefore the amounts should not be deducted as borrowed money when arriving at capital employed).
  • The agreements and notes (including features such as issuance under common seal, transferability, being in a series, and the 1964 agreement's explicit statement equating "notes" with "debentures") supported the characterisation of the loans as debentures.

Revenue's Position (as recorded)

  • The Revenue and the ITO treated the two dollar loans as liabilities (i.e., borrowed moneys) and deducted them when computing capital employed under rule 19A, resulting in a smaller relief under s.80J than claimed by the assessee.
  • The Revenue proceeded on the basis that the notes issued under the 1964 agreement were not different in character from the notes under the 1967 agreement, and that the notes were not debentures (the opinion records that the Revenue had no case that the 1964 notes differed from the 1967 notes).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Cochin Refineries Ltd., [1982] 135 ITR 278 Held that interest from bank deposits was not income "derived from" the industrial business for purposes of s.80J (i.e., income from deposits of surplus cash is not income derived from the business activity itself). The Court relied on this earlier decision to answer Question No. 2 against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue, adopting the principle that interest from deposits is not income falling within s.80J.
British India Steam Navigation Co. v. IRC, [1881] 7 QBD 165 (Lindley J.) Illustrated the absence of a precise legal definition of "debenture" and showed the variety of instruments commonly called debentures (mortgage debentures, bonds, acknowledgements of indebtedness, etc.). The Court quoted Lindley J.'s observations to show that the meaning of "debenture" is not fixed and may encompass varied instruments; used this to support a broad, substance-focused approach to classification.
Levy v. Abercorris Slate and Slab Co., [1888] 37 Ch D 260 (Chitty J.) Noted lack of a precise legal definition for "debenture" and that it is not strictly a term of art. Quoted to reinforce the point that "debenture" is a flexible commercial term and must be identified by examining the instrument's substance.
Edmonds v. Blaina Furnaces Co., [1887] 36 Ch D 215 Observed that a debenture generally imports a debt or an acknowledgment of a debt, often accompanied by an obligation to pay and frequently by some charge or security. Quoted to support the proposition that a debenture denotes an instrument acknowledging indebtedness and usually containing an obligation to pay (often with security), which aided the Court's assessment of the notes' character.
Laxman Bharmaji v. Emperor, AIR 1946 Bom 18; 16 Comp Cas 31 Stated that one must look at the substance of the instrument rather than be bound by the label used by the issuing company when deciding whether an instrument is a debenture. Applied to emphasize that the Court must examine the substance of the notes (not merely their label) to decide whether they are debentures; supported the Court's analysis and conclusion that the notes were debentures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed the two referred questions separately.

Question No. 2 (interest from bank deposits)

The Court answered Question No. 2 against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue by applying its prior decision in CIT v. Cochin Refineries Ltd. ([1982] 135 ITR 278) concerning the same assessee for the assessment year 1970-71. The Court quoted the earlier decision which held that income by way of interest from deposits represents income generated by depositing a business asset (surplus cash) and is not money derived from the industrial business activity itself; therefore, such interest does not fall within the meaning of "derived from" for the purposes of s.80J. On that basis, the Court declined to treat interest from bank deposits as business income for s.80J purposes.

Question No. 1 (whether the dollar loans are debentures)

The Court began by observing that the Income-tax Act does not define "debenture", but the Companies Act, 1956 (s.2(12)) contains an inclusive definition that "debenture" includes debenture stock, bonds and any other securities of a company, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company or not. The Court referred to authoritative commentary (Palmer) and to a series of English and Indian decisions underscoring that "debenture" is an elastic commercial term without a precise technical definition and that the substance of the instrument must be examined.

The Court then examined the instruments and surrounding circumstances described in the agreements:

  • The notes acknowledged the company's indebtedness and were issued under the company's common seal.
  • The Controller of Capital Issues had consented to issuance of the notes.
  • The 1964 agreement expressly stated the intention that "notes" should have the same meaning as "debentures" under Indian law; the wording of the notes under both the 1964 and 1967 agreements was essentially identical except for minor changes.
  • The notes were transferable and issued in a series (transferability and series-character were assured by the agreements and the wording of the notes).
  • Guarantees were provided (President of India unconditionally guaranteed punctual payment of principal and interest; Reserve Bank also gave a guarantee to the U.S. lenders for the 1967 loan similar to that for the 1964 loan).
  • The Revenue had not argued that the 1964 notes differed from the 1967 notes.

Applying the principles cited (elastic commercial meaning of "debenture", substance-over-label, instruments that acknowledge indebtedness and carry obligation to pay, transferability and being in a series), the Court concluded that the Tribunal was correct to treat the two dollar loans as debentures for the purpose of granting relief under section 80J of the Income-tax Act. The Court therefore answered Question No. 1 in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core rulings):

  • Question No. 1: Answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue — the two medium-term dollar loans/notes were to be treated as debentures for the purposes of section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
  • Question No. 2: Answered against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue — interest income from bank deposits is not to be treated as business income for the purposes of section 80J (following the Court's prior decision).

Direct consequences and practical effect on the parties (as reflected in the opinion):

  • Because the two dollar loans were treated as debentures, the assessee is entitled to the relief claimed under section 80J that depends on the computation of "capital employed" where debentures need not be deducted (the assessee had not deducted the debenture amounts when computing capital employed; the ITO had treated them as liabilities and deducted them, yielding a smaller relief).
  • The decision on Question No. 2 confirms that interest from bank deposits will not qualify as income "derived from" the industrial undertaking for s.80J purposes, consistent with the earlier decision in [1982] 135 ITR 278.

The opinion does not state any broader precedential innovations beyond applying existing authorities and the Court's prior decision; the outcome concerns the parties' tax computations for the assessment year and a copy of the judgment under the seal of the High Court (signed by the Registrar) was to be sent to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Cochin Refineries Ltd.

    Income-tax Reference No. 77 of 1977

    Decided on June 9, 1982

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Chandrasekhara Menon, J.:— Two questions have been referred to this court under s. 256(1) of the I.T Act, 1961, by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, which are said to arise from an order of the Tribunal disposing of the appeals filed by the assessee, Cochin Refineries Ltd., Ambalamugal, and the Department for the assessment year 1971-72. The two questions are:

    “(1) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, and on an interpretation of the agreements entered into by the company with certain financiers, the Tribunal is right in law in treating the medium term dollar loan amounting to Rs. 90,00,000 and dollar loan amounting to Rs. 1,31,86,875 as debentures for the purpose of granting relief under section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

    (2) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal is right in law in treating the interest income from bank deposits as business income of the assessee for the purpose of section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961?”

    2. At the outset itself we might state that we answer question No. 2 against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue in view of the decision of this court in regard to the same assessee in respect of the assessment year 1970-71, when the same question was referred to this court in I.T Rs. Nos. 71 and 72 of 1977. This court said there (the decision is reported in [1982] 135 ITR 278—CIT v. Cochin Refineries Ltd.) (p. 287):

    “The derivation of the income must be directly connected with the business in the sense that the income is generated by the business. It would not be sufficient if it is generated by the exploitation of a business asset. In the case before us, the income by way of interest from the deposits is no doubt an income derived by investing surplus cash of the assessee generated as profits of the industrial undertaking. But, it is not money derived from the business activity of the industrial undertaking but by the business activity of deposit of the business asset in banks. Within the meaning of the term ‘derived from’ it will not be possible to hold that the income so generated is the income falling within s. 80J.”

    3. We may now refer to the relevant facts necessary for a consideration of the first question. The assessee is a public limited company in which the Govt. of India is a shareholder. The assessee had entered into agreements with financiers in the United States called Loan and Note Purchase Agreements on July 1, 1964, and on December 31, 1967. The agreement on July 1, 1964, was with different financiers. The agreement in 1967 was with Philips Petroleum International Corporation. According to the agreement of 1964 the assessee-company will authorise issuance and sale of 12 million U.S dollars as ¾% secured notes series A and the borrowing of 6 million U.S dollars at the same rate but known as secured notes series B. The notes were to be issued and secured by a deed of trust and mortgage dated July 1, 1964, the mortgage being between the company and the First National City Bank as the trustee and the creditors. The notes would be dated, should mature and should bear interest which shall be payable on such terms and provisions as provided in the mortgage deed and guaranteed by the Govt. of India in pursuance of the terms of the guaranteed agreements dated July 1, 1964. The Controller of Capital Issues has consented to the issue. It is specifically defined in the agreement that the term “notes” shall mean any note authenticated and delivered under the said indenture, it being the intention that the expression shall have the same meaning as “debentures” under Indian law. As per the agreement of 1967 the assessee-company agreed to borrow from the Philips Petroleum Company up to U.S Dollars 2,500,000 in accordance with the terms of the agreement and to issue its 6% notes in the total principal amount to evidence such borrowings. The notes were in the form attached thereto as Ex. 1 to the agreement. They would be guaranteed by the Govt. of India pursuant to the terms of the guarantee agreement. As per the guarantee agreement, the President of India unconditionally guaranteed the holder of the notes the due and punctual payment of, (i) the principal, whether at maturity, upon acceleration of maturity or otherwise, and the interest on, and the premium, if any, on payment thereof, (ii) any additional sums payable on account of any “income-tax” as defined therein, (iii) any amounts payable by the company under the Loan and Note Purchase Agreement, and (iv) any expense incurred in the protection of the rights of the holder. It was also provided by the guarantor that the agreement is made for the benefit of PPIC and of the several holders from time to time of the notes and it may be enforced directly by the holders of such notes or by any of them, from time to time as often as occasion may arise, as well as by PPIC. No doubt this agreement is addressed to one financier and after the commissioning of the business. To that extent it is different from the 1964 agreement. Verbal changes are there on account of this fact. The 1964 agreement has been followed by a mortgage and trust deed. There is no such deed in respect of 1967 agreement, but as noted earlier, there is a guarantee by the President of India as the holder of the majority of the stock of the company. The President of India had unconditionally guaranteed the holder of the note the punctual payment of the interest and the repayment of the principal. There is no difference at all in the wordings in both the guarantee agreements excepting as required by the change in situations. The Reserve Bank had also given a guarantee to the U.S lenders, PPIC, which guarantee is also identical in words and context with that given by the Reserve Bank for the loans in 1964. The notes are also identically worded excepting for some minor changes. We might note here that the Revenue has also proceeded on the basis that the notes issued as per both the agreements are not debentures and there is no difference in respect of the notes as per the 1964 agreement with that of the notes as per the 1967 agreement.

    4. In claiming relief under s. 80J of the I.T Act and giving computation of the capital employed, the assessee-company did not treat the two dollar loans aforementioned as liabilities under r. 19A of the I.T Rules. It may be pointed out here that s. 80J allows a deduction from the income, in respect of newly established industrial undertakings, an amount representing 6% of the capital employed. As per r. 19A of the Rules dealing with the computation of the capital, the aggregate of the amounts of borrowed moneys and debts due by the assessee are deducted in ascertaining the capital employed. It is also, however, provided that in the case of companies, the amount of its debentures need not be deducted as a debt to ascertain the capital. Treating the two dollar loans as debentures, the company did not deduct the amount as per these. The ITO, however, treated them as liabilities and deducted these loan amounts from the aggregate value of the assets in the ascertainment of capital. Thus the relief under s. 80J was worked out on a smaller figure than what was claimed by the assessee.

    5. The assessee-company appealed as, according to them, the two loans represented debentures. Their contention was, however, rejected and the appeals were dismissed by the AAC. However, on further appeal by the assessee-company to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, the Tribunal found that both these loans are debentures and the assessee's contention was accepted. This decision gave rise to the application for reference and the subsequent reference of the question by the Tribunal to this court.

    6. The short question that really arises for our consideration is what is a debenture. Are the loans in the real sense of the term debentures? The I.T Act does not define a debenture. The Companies Act, 1956, in s. 2(12) gives an inclusive definition. It states that “debenture” includes debenture stock, bonds and any other securities of a company, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company or not. The same is the meaning given in the English Companies Act of 1948 (s. 455). Palmer would state that the term securities in the definition clause is apparently used in a sense slightly in excess of its strict legal meaning.

    7. Lindley J. observed in an early case British India Steam Navigation Co. v. IRC, [1881] 7 QBD 165 at pp. 172-173:

    “What the correct meaning of ‘debenture’ is I do not know. I do not find anywhere any precise definition of it. We know that there are various kinds of instruments commonly called debentures. You may have mortgage debentures, which are charges of some kind on property. You may have debentures which are bonds; ……You may have a debenture which is nothing more than an acknowledgment of indebtedness. And you may have a thing like this, which is something more; it is a statement by two directors that the company will pay a certain sum of money on a given day, and will also pay interest half-yearly at certain times and at a certain place, upon production of certain coupons by the holder of the instrument.”.

    8. Chitty J. said in Levy v. Abercorris Slate and Slab Co., [1888] 37 Ch D 260 at p. 264:

    “I cannot find any precise legal definition of the term, it is not either in law or commerce a strictly technical term, or what is called a term of art.”

    9. Palmer quotes the same judge stating in another case, Edmonds v. Blaina Furnaces Co., [1887] 36 Ch D 215 at p. 219:

    “The term itself imports a debt—an acknowledgment of a debt—and speaking of the numerous and various forms of instruments which have been called debentures without anyone being able to say the term is incorrectly used, I find that generally, if not always, the instrument imports an obligation or covenant to pay. This obligation or covenant is in most cases at the present day accompanied by some charge or security.”

    10. After quoting these decisions the learned author states (Palmer's Company Law, 20th Edn., pp. 367-368):

    “In modern commercial usage a debenture denotes an instrument issued by the company, normally—but not necessarily—called on the face of it a debenture, and providing for the payment of, or acknowledging the indebtedness in, a specified sum—say, £100—at a fixed date, with interest thereon. It usually—but not necessarily—gives a charge by way of security, and is often—though not invariably expressed to be one of a series of like debentures.

    11. But the term, as used in modern commercial parlance, is of extremely elastic character, for

    (1) it is sometimes used, both by lawyers and businessmen, to describe an instrument which is not called, on the face of it, a debenture, e.g, a bond;

    (2) it is used of an instrument which is not one of a series. A single debenture may be issued to one man;

    (3) it is not the less a debenture because

    (a) it is not under seal; or

    (b) it does not contain a charge; or

    (c) it does not provide for payment at any fixed date but only in the event of winding up, or on some contingency; or

    (d) there is no personal liability on the company to pay but the company charges its property as security for the debt of another person.

    Although the modern meaning of the term ‘debenture-’ is thus very wide, it would go too far to assert that every document creating or acknowledging an indebtedness of the company is a debenture. Commercial men and lawyers would certainly not use this term when referring to bills of exchange or other negotiable instruments, deeds of covenant and many other documents in which a company stipulates to pay a sum of money.”

    12. A debenture is certainly a document which either creates a debt or acknowledges it. While it may usually be one of a series, it need not necessarily be so. As Palmer has pointed out, a single debenture may be issued to one party. As Chitty J. in Edmond's case, [1887] 36 Ch D 215 and a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Laxman Bharmaji v. Emperor, AIR 1946 Bom 18; 16 Comp Cas 31, 34 point out:

    “In determining what is or is not a debenture within the section we are not bound to hold that an instrument is a debenture because it is called a debenture by the company issuing it, nor to hold it is hot a debenture because it is not so called by the company. We must look at the substance of the instrument itself, and, without the assistance of any precise legal definition form the best opinion we can whether the instrument is or is not a debenture.”

    13. Turning to this case we find that the secured notes concerned, issued as per the agreements, acknowledge the indebtedness of the company. They are issued under the common seal of the company. The Controller of Capital Issues, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India, had consented to the issuance of the notes. In respect of the notes issued in pursuance of the 1964 agreement it is specifically provided that it is the intention that the expression “notes” shall have the same meaning as “debentures” in Indian law. However, as noted earlier, the notes issued as per both the agreements are worded identically except for some minor changes. And as we have pointed out earlier, the Revenue has no case that the notes issued as per the 1964 agreement are in any way different from the notes issued as per the 1967 agreement. The “notes” are transferable. They are in a series. The transferability of each note is assured from the agreement and from the wording of the “note”. In the circumstances, the Tribunal was right in treating the dollar loans as debentures for the purpose of granting relief under s. 80J of the I.T Act, 1961. Therefore, we answer question No. 1 in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

    14. A copy of the judgment under the seal of the High Court and the signature of the Registrar will be sent to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Cochin Refineries Ltd.
    (Jun 9, 1982)