Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sections 159 and 161 of the Indian Companies Act
  • provisions contained in section 159, 160
  • sections 477, 478, 539, 543, 545, 621, 625
  • not.5. Section 2(26)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sections 159 and 161 of the Indian Companies Act
  • provisions contained in section 159, 160
  • sections 477, 478, 539, 543, 545, 621, 625
  • not.5. Section 2(26)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These two revision petitions arise from complaints filed by the Registrar of Companies against The Hindustan Corporation (P.) Ltd. and certain directors, including the petitioner who was the governing director. The first case involved failure to submit returns as required under sections 159 and 161 of the Indian Companies Act, punishable under section 162. The second case concerned failure to file the balance-sheet and profit and loss account as required by section 220, punishable under section 220(3). The District Magistrate found all accused guilty and imposed fines. The petitioner appealed to the Sessions Judge of Ernakulam, who confirmed the conviction and sentence, leading to the present revision petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner’s resignation as a director, submitted by letter on 7th August 1961, effectively terminated his liability for failure to submit company returns and financial statements due after that date.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s role as governing director, manager, or officer under the Indian Companies Act imposed continuing responsibilities despite the resignation letter.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that he resigned as director on 7th August 1961 and thus was no longer liable for the defaults occurring after that date.

Other Accused’s Arguments

  • Accused Nos. 3 and 4 admitted the defaults but argued that the petitioner was in control of the books and accounts and was responsible for sending the returns.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul Huq v. Katpadi Industries Ltd. (1960) 73 M.L.W 106 Resignation of an ordinary director and its effect The court held this precedent inapplicable as it concerned only ordinary directors, whereas the petitioner was a governing director with managerial responsibilities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the petitioner’s dual capacity as both a director and the governing director (manager) under the Indian Companies Act. It referred to statutory definitions of “manager” (Section 2(24)), “managing director” (Section 2(26)), and “officer” (Section 2(30)) to clarify the petitioner’s status. The court emphasized that resignation as a director by written notice under article 21(f) of the company’s articles of association does not automatically terminate the managerial or officer responsibilities unless the company accepts the resignation and relieves the individual of duties.

The court noted documentary evidence including returns signed by the petitioner as governing director and a letter from the petitioner acknowledging that despite his resignation letter, he had not been relieved of duties and was still responsible for submitting the audited balance-sheet and returns. This demonstrated that the petitioner continued to act in a managerial capacity and was liable for the defaults.

The court rejected reliance on the Abdul Huq case, distinguishing it on the basis that it dealt only with ordinary directors, not governing directors or managers.

Accordingly, the court found the conviction and sentence proper and declined to interfere.

Holding and Implications

The court dismissed the revision petitions, upholding the conviction and sentence imposed on the petitioner and other accused.

The direct consequence is that the petitioner remains liable for the offences committed due to failure to submit returns and financial statements despite his resignation letter, as he was not formally relieved of his managerial responsibilities. No new precedent was established beyond affirming the interpretation of the petitioner’s continuing liability under the Act.

    Achutha Pai v. Registrar Of Companies

    1. These two revision petitions can be disposed of by a common judgment as the point involved is the same. The Registrar of Companies had filed two complaints. The first accused in each of these cases being the company—The Hindustan Corporation (P.) Ltd.—second accused the petitioner here, the governing director of the company and accused Nos. 3 and 4 being; ordinary directors. The subject-matter of the charge in the case in Criminal Revision Petition No. 286 of 1964 was for failure to submit returns as required by sections 159 and 161 of the Indian Companies Act (shortly stated the Act), offence punishable under section 162 of the Act. In Criminal Revision Petition No. 287 of 1964, it was for failure to file the balance-sheet and profit and loss account as required by section 220 of the Act, offence punishable under section 220(3) of the Act. Learned District Magistrate on the evidence found all the accused guilty as charged. The company and the petitioner were each sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 50 and accused Nos. 3 and 4 were sentenced each to pay Rs. 25. Out of the fine collected Rs. 10 each was awarded as costs from accused Nos. 1 and 2 and Rs. 5 each from accused Nos. 3 and 4. In appeal by the petitioner to the Sessions Judge of Ernakulam, the conviction and sentence were confirmed and he has therefore come up in revision.

    2. That the returns were not sent and the balance-sheet and profit and loss account was not filed is admitted. According to the petition he had resigned his director's place on 7th August, 1961, and was, thereafter not liable to send up the returns, the default of which has given rise to the prosecution. Accused Nos. 3 and 4 admitted that the returns were not sent, but they would say that the petitioner was in control and charge of the books and accounts and that he was the person who ought to have sent up the returns.

    3. Admittedly, returns became due after 7th August, 1961, the date on which the petitioner had sent up his letter of resignation and the only question for decision is whether by merely sending up the resignation letter the liability of the petitioner could be considered to have ceased. Reference was made to exhibit P-2, the articles of association of the company, and reliance was placed on clause (f) of article 21 which states that one of the ways in which the office of the director shall be vacated is by notice in writing. But here the position of the petitioner was not merely that of a director, but he was the governing director of the company. His position under the Act is that of the manager of the company because he was in management, control and supervision of the affairs of the company.

    4. The definition of the term “manager” in the Act may be looked into. Section 2(24) says:

    “‘Manager’ means an individual (not being the managing agent) who, subject to the superintendence, control and direction of the board of directors, has the management of the whole, or substantially the whole, of the affairs of a company, and includes a director or any other person occupying the position of a manager, by whatever name called, and whether under a contract of service or not.”

    5. Section 2(26) defines who is a “managing director”. It says:

    “‘Managing director’ means a director who, by virtue of an agreement with the company or of a resolution passed by the company in genera] meeting or by its Board of directors or, by virtue of its memorandum or articles of association, is entrusted with substantial powers of management which would not otherwise be exercisable by him, and includes a director occupying the position of a managing director, by whatever name called.”

    6. We have also to see the definition of “officer” under section 2(30), which says:

    “‘Officer’ includes any director, managing agent, secretaries and treasurers, manager or secretary, and also includes—

    (a) where the managing agent, the secretaries and treasurers or the secretary is or are a firm, any partner in the firm;

    (b) where the managing agent or the secretaries and treasurers is or are a body corporate, any director or manager of the body corporate;

    (c) where the secretary is a body corporate, any director, managing agent, secretaries and treasurers or manager of the body corporate;

    but, save in sections 477, 478, 539, 543, 545, 621, 625 and 633 does not include an auditor.”

    7. Section 162 of the Act under which action is taken reads:

    “(1) If a company fails to comply with any of the provisions contained in section 159, 160 or 161, the company, and every officer of the company who is in default, shall be punishable with fine which may extend to fifty rupees for every day during which the default continues.

    (2) For the purposes of this section and sections 159, 160 and 161, the expressions ‘officer’ and ‘director’ shall include any person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the Board of directors of the company is accustomed to act.”

    8. The petitioner has, therefore, two capacities combined in him, one that of a director and the other that of a manager or an officer. His capacity as manager cannot be terminated by mere sending of two resignations but it must be duly accepted by the company and he should be relieved of his duties and responsibilities.

    9. In this connection, I will refer to one or two documents produced in this case. In exhibit P-4, the returns sent by the company on 11th February, 1960, the petitioner has been shown as the governing director and he has signed the return as the governing director. Exhibit P-13 is another very important document. It is a letter written by the petitioner and it is stated therein that even though he had sent his resignation letter on 7th August, 1961, the other directors have not taken charge and relieved him and he has stated that the audited balance-sheet and the returns would be submitted to the Registrar as early as possible and requesting that no action may be taken. It is, therefore, practically admitted that the petitioner continues as the governing director and has not been relieved of that post.

    10. The decision referred to by the learned counsel in Abdul Huq v. Katpadi Industries Ltd. 1960 73 M.L.W 106, cannot help the petitioner as it refers only to the resignation of an ordinary director.

    11. The conviction of the accused in the two cases is, therefore, proper and no interference is called for. The revision petitions are dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Achutha Pai v. Registrar Of Companies
    (Nov 16, 1965)