AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judicial Opinion (Industrial Dispute No. 48 of 1958)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ proceeding was initiated by the petitioner (represented by Mr. K. P. Abraham) challenging an award of the Industrial Tribunal, Alleppey, in Industrial Dispute No. 48 of 1958. The petitioner attacked (a) the Tribunal's jurisdiction to inquire into the matter dealt with in Issue No. 1, and (b) the findings recorded under Issues Nos. 6 and 7. The petitioner also advanced a general procedural attack based on Section 17(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, contending that the State Government failed to publish the award within the 30‑day period prescribed by that sub‑section. The award is dated 25‑6‑1960, was received by the State Government on 29‑6‑1960, but was published only on 2‑8‑1960. The court dealt first with the Section 17(1) objection and then with the challenges to Issues 1, 6 and 7. The opinion confines its decision to those matters; other issues decided by the Tribunal were not pressed before the court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether non‑publication of the Tribunal's award within the 30‑day period specified in Section 17(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act renders the award void or illegal.
  2. Whether the Industrial Tribunal had jurisdiction to enquire into and award relief on Issue No. 1 (payment of wages for certain days in March, June, July and August 1957) where the management had earlier reached a conciliation settlement with another union that, according to the petitioner, included a waiver of the same claim.
  3. Whether the relief granted under Issue No. 1 should have been limited to lay‑off compensation under Section 25 (read with the definition in Section 2(k)) rather than full wages.
  4. Whether a conciliation settlement between the management and one union is binding on a different union representing the same class of employees (i.e., the scope and operation of Section 18(3), including clause (d)).
  5. Whether the Tribunal exceeded its reference or jurisdiction in framing gratuity schemes under Issue No. 6 (gratuity to dependents of deceased workmen) and Issue No. 7 (gratuity to aged and disabled workmen), and whether particular clauses (notably clause 6 concerning dismissal for misconduct causing financial loss) were legally permissible.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Petitioner) — Mr. K. P. Abraham

  • Section 17(1) required mandatory publication of the award within 30 days of receipt; failure to do so renders the award void and unenforceable.
  • On Issue No. 1, even if there was a refusal to give employment for the periods in question, the legal consequence should be lay‑off compensation under Section 25 (and Section 2(k)), not an award of full wages; the union itself only insisted on compensation.
  • A conciliation settlement entered into between the management and the High Range Estate Employees Association (one union) — in which that union did not press the claim covering Issue No. 1 — is binding on the present union (Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union), so the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to reopen the matter.
  • Issues 6 and 7 were limited by the terms of reference: “dependents of deceased workmen” should be understood with reference to definitions in the Workmen’s Compensation Act; the Tribunal went beyond its reference by providing gratuity to heirs/executors/nominees and framed a general scheme rather than limiting relief to those classes identified in the reference.
  • Clause 6 of the gratuity scheme (denying gratuity when a workman is dismissed for misconduct involving financial loss) was objectionable.

Respondents — Government Pleader and Union Counsel (Mr. M. P. Menon)

  • Government Pleader: the use of the word “shall” in Section 17(1) is not necessarily mandatory; the publication requirement is directory and failure to publish within 30 days does not render the award void. He also raised a procedural point that the Tribunal did not explicitly consider whether the conciliation settlement pleaded in this case was a settlement “as defined” under the Act and questioned whether the Assistant Labour Officer (who signed the settlement) was competent to effect conciliation (a point not previously contested before the Tribunal).
  • Mr. M. P. Menon (for the union): even if there was an agreement between the management and the High Range Estate Employees Association, that agreement could be void under the Minimum Wages Act; this aspect was not considered by the Tribunal and, according to him, could be taken into account by the Court to uphold the Tribunal's award.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P. v. Babu Ram Illustration that the mere use of “shall” in a statutory provision is not conclusive proof that the provision is mandatory; the court must consider the scheme and effect of the provision. Used to support the view that Section 17(1)'s use of “shall” does not automatically render the publication requirement mandatory; the court examined the statutory scheme before concluding the provision is directory in effect.
Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin Construction of Section 18 (esp. sub‑section (3)): a conciliation settlement which has become enforceable binds all categories of parties listed in Section 18(3), and a settlement arrived at in conciliation proceedings can bind workmen even if they belong to rival unions; the policy is to give extended operation to conciliation settlements. The court relied heavily on this Supreme Court decision to hold that a conciliation agreement between the management and one union (High Range Estate Employees Association) in respect of common matters would bind other unions (Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union) whose members form part of the same class of employees. That precedent drove the conclusion that the Tribunal's award on Issue No. 1 could not be sustained.
Trichy District Motor Workers' Union v. T.S.T. Company (Madras Industrial Tribunal decision) A tribunal decision (cited by the Industrial Tribunal) that supported the view that a conciliation settlement which did not include a particular union would not bind that union. The court declined to follow the reasoning of that Madras Tribunal decision in view of the Supreme Court's ruling in Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin, and stated the Madras reasoning to be incorrect on the relevant principles.
Associated Cement Companies Ltd., Porbander v. Their Workmen Referenced as one of the earlier Supreme Court decisions considered relevant when construing statutory provisions relating to the effect of settlements (mentioned in the Ramnagar judgment). Referred to by the Supreme Court in Ramnagar; the present court cited Ramnagar (which itself cited Associated Cement) to support the extended operation of conciliation settlements under Section 18(3).
New Indian Motors (P.) Ltd. v. K. T. Morris Referenced as another decision of the Supreme Court dealing with related questions of statutory construction referenced in Ramnagar. Referred via the Ramnagar discussion; used as part of the chain of authority validating the broad scope of conciliation settlements under Section 18(3).
Garment Cleaning Works v. Its Workers Held that gratuity is not a purely gratuitous payment; if gratuity is earned by long and meritorious service it is difficult to justify denying it because of later misconduct; the view was that gratuity, once earned, ordinarily should not be denied even on dismissal for misconduct. The court applied that principle to decline interference with clause 6 of the Tribunal's gratuity scheme (which denied gratuity where dismissal involved financial loss), observing that the Supreme Court's reasoning made interference unnecessary.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the contested points in a structured way:

  1. Section 17(1) publication delay:
    • The award was dated 25‑6‑1960, received by the State Government on 29‑6‑1960, and published only on 2‑8‑1960 — later than 30 days after receipt.
    • The court considered whether the statutory direction to publish within 30 days (Section 17(1), which uses “shall”) rendered the award void if not complied with. Citing jurisprudence that the mere use of “shall” is not determinative, the court examined the scheme of the Industrial Disputes Act.
    • The court concluded that nothing in the Act indicates that late publication “goes to the root” of the award or makes it illegal or void. Late publication postpones finality under Section 17(2) and the date on which the award becomes enforceable under Section 17‑A, but produces no other consequences. Therefore, Section 17(1) is directory rather than mandatory for purposes of invalidating the award.
    • Result: the petitioner's general contention that the award was void for late publication was rejected.
  2. Issue No. 1 (payment of wages for specific days) — lay‑off compensation vs. full wages:
    • The petitioner argued alternatively that, even assuming refusal of employment for the days in question, the entitlement would at most be lay‑off compensation under Section 25 (read with Section 2(k)), and the union itself sought only compensation. The Tribunal, however, recorded that the management's precise plea was that alternative employment had been offered but not accepted; the Tribunal found the employer had not proved that offer.
    • Because the Tribunal found the employer failed to prove the offer of alternative employment, the court was not prepared to accept the petitioner's subsidiary contention that compensation only should have been awarded; the Tribunal's award of full wages on this factual basis was acceptable.
  3. Issue No. 1 — jurisdiction in light of conciliation settlement with another union:
    • The petitioner’s main contention was that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction because the management had conciliated with the High Range Estate Employees Association, which had agreed not to press the wage claim; the petitioner argued that such a conciliation agreement should bind the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union too.
    • The court described the factual matrix: three unions functioned in the estate, and all tappers and factory workers were members of one or another union. The conciliation settlement was signed by the parties and by the Assistant Labour Officer.
    • The Tribunal had given reasons for not treating the conciliation as binding on the Akhila Kerala union: (a) the High Range union's demand came only after the present union made demands (court found this irrelevant), (b) the Akhila Kerala union did not attend the conciliation, and (c) it was not a party to the settlement. The court found reasons (b) and (c) to be the Tribunal's main reliance but subjected them to legal analysis.
    • The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin construing Section 18(3): a conciliation settlement that has become enforceable binds all parties specified in Section 18(3) and may bind workmen who belong to rival unions where the settlement pertains to common matters of employees of the establishment. The policy of Section 18 is to give extended effect to conciliation settlements to avoid disturbance of industrial peace.
    • Applying Ramnagar, the court concluded that the fact the Akhila Kerala union was not a party to the conciliation, or did not attend the conciliation, did not prevent the settlement from binding that union on common matters. The Tribunal's contrary reasoning (and reliance on a Madras Tribunal award) was held to be incorrect in light of the Supreme Court authority.
    • Result: the Tribunal's award in respect of Issue No. 1 could not be sustained because the conciliation settlement bound the employees/unions in the relevant categories; the petitioner's contention on this ground was accepted.
  4. Issues Nos. 6 and 7 (gratuity to dependents; gratuity to aged and disabled):
    • The court recited the modern understanding of gratuity as an "allotment claim" that a workman can make and which in proper cases may give rise to an industrial dispute; gratuity is paid after retirement, whether by superannuation or physical disability.
    • The petitioner argued that the Tribunal exceeded its reference by framing a scheme that extended benefits beyond the precise words used in the reference (e.g., treating “dependents” as heirs/executors/nominees, and framing general gratuity rules rather than limiting to “aged and disabled” alone).
    • The court rejected the petitioner's contention: the references in Issues 6 and 7 raise general questions of gratuity payable to the workmen of the concern, and the Tribunal had jurisdiction to frame an appropriate scheme, taking into account the employer's financial capacity. The Tribunal had adverted to the employer's financial condition before framing the scheme.
    • The court addressed clause 6 (denial of gratuity where dismissal involved misconduct causing financial loss). Citing Garment Cleaning Works v. Its Workers, the court noted that the Supreme Court found difficulty in denying gratuity that is earned by long and meritorious service simply because of later misconduct; on that authority interference with clause 6 was unnecessary.
    • Result: the court did not accept the objections to the Tribunal's jurisdiction on Issues 6 and 7 and did not find the scheme unlawful, except to remark on clause 6 which, given higher authority, required no modification by the court.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ petition is ALLOWED in part and DISMISSED in part. Concretely, the court quashed and cancelled the Industrial Tribunal's award (Ext. P.1) insofar as it related to the findings recorded or directions given in respect of Issue No. 1. In all other respects the writ petition fails and the remainder of the Tribunal's award is confirmed. Parties will bear their own costs.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the award on Issue No. 1 (payment of wages for the specific days identified) is quashed because the conciliation settlement between the management and the High Range Estate Employees Association binds the class of employees and thus precluded the Tribunal from awarding on that issue; the remainder of the award (including the gratuity scheme under Issues 6 and 7) stands confirmed.
  • On Section 17(1): the court held that failure by the State to publish the award within the 30‑day period is directory in the sense explained in the judgment — it postpones finality and enforceability dates but does not invalidate the award — so the petitioner's challenge on that ground was rejected.
  • On conciliation settlements and Section 18(3): the court followed the Supreme Court authority (Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin) and applied the principle that conciliation settlements, once enforceable, may bind workmen beyond the particular union that signed the settlement where the settlement concerns common matters of the employees of the establishment.
  • No suggestion is made in the opinion that the court intended to lay down a novel rule of law; the court applied existing Supreme Court decisions to the facts and limited its intervention to quashing the Tribunal's decision on Issue No. 1 while upholding the Tribunal's scheme on gratuity (subject to the reasoning already articulated from Supreme Court precedent).

This summary is prepared exclusively from the content of the provided opinion. No facts, rulings, or principles beyond those expressly contained in the opinion have been added.

    Supdt., Erumeli Estate v. Industrial Tribunal, Alleppey And Other

    Vaidialingam, J.:— In this writ proceeding, Mr. K.P Abraham, learned counsel for the writ petitioner, challenges the award of the Industrial Tribunal Alleppey in Industrial Dispute No. 48 of 1958. In particular, the learned counsel attacks the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to embark upon an enquiry, which is the subject matter of issue No. 1; and there are also attacks made on the findings recorded under issues Nos. 6 and 7. The other questions decided under the various issues other than these issues do not arise for decision by this court.

    2. Before I go into the merits of the attack relating to the findings recorded on issues 1, 6 and 7, I will deal with a general attack made by Mr. K.P Abraham, learned counsel, based upon the provisions of Section 17 of the Industrial Disputes Act. That is, according to the learned counsel, the award has not been published by the State Government within the period mentioned in sub-section (1) of Section 17 of the Act. The award itself is dated 25-6-60 and it is seen from Ext. P-1 that the award has been received by the State Government on 29-6-60. Under the provisions of subsection (1) of Section 17, it is provided that the award is to be publishtd in such manner as the Government may Think fit within a period of 30 days from the date of its receipt. Therefore, the State Government should have published it within 30 days of the receipt by it, namely, 29-7-1960. But actually it is seen that the award was published only in the State Gazette dated 2nd August, 1960. Therefore, the contention of Mr. K.P Abraham, learned counsel, is inasmuch as there has been a violation of the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 17, which, according to him, is mandat ory, the result will be that the award itself is void and therefore no action can be taken on the basis of this award.

    3. This contention could very well have been avoided to say frankly, if the State Government had been a little more diligent and had published the award, as they could have done and as they are ordinarily bound to do, within the time mentioned in sub-section (1) of Section 17. But the question is whether the non-publication of the award within the period mentioned in Section 17(1) really invalidates the award itself. The learned Government Pleader appearing for the State has urged that notwithstanding the use of the expression “shall” in sub-section (1) of Section 17 and notwithstanding the further direction about the publication within a particular time mentioned therein, the award cannot be considered to be either void or illegal because, according to him, these provisions are mere directory and not certainly mandatory. The use of the word “shali” by itself, it has been held in several decisions of the Supreme Court itself including the recent decision in State of U.P v. Babu Ram(1), is not conclusive. Therefore, the court will have to consider the general scheme of the Act, as well as the result that will follow from placing a construction one way or other regarding the use of the expression “shall” on the provision made in sub-section (1) of Section 17.

    4. After considering the contentions of Mr. K.P Abraham and those of the learn ed Government Pleader, I am not inclined to accept the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the mere non-publication within the time mentioned in sub-section (1) of Section 17 invalidates the award itself. There is nothing in the Act itself to indicate that a publication con trary to the provisions of sub-section (1) will go to the root of the award itself or will make the award illegal or void. In order to bring into operation the further provisions of sub-section 2 of Section 17 and the pro visions of Section 17(A) it is highly desir able that the award is published within the time mentioned in Section 17(1) because it is only on such publication that it becomes final under sub-section (2) and it becomes enforceable under Sec. 17-A after the expiry of 30 days from the date of its publication under Section 17(1), Excepting that a slight delay, in publishing the award under Section 17(1) results in postponing its finality under Section 17(2) or its becoming enforceable under Section 17(A), no other consequences flow from the delay and therefore, in my view, the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 17 should be considered only to be merely directory and not certainly, mandatory. In this view, the first general contention of Mr. K.P Abraham has to be rejected.

    5. The other contentions, as I mentioned earlier, are really based upon the findings recorded under issues 1, 6 and 7. Issue No. 1 related to “payment of wages for a certain number of days in March, June, July and August, 1957.” There is a subsidiary contention regarding the finding recorded under issue No. 1 and it is based really upon the provisions of Section 2(k) read with Section 25 of the Industrial Disputes Act. That is according to the learned counsel even assuming there has been a refusal to give employment for the periods in question, it will amount at the most only to this, that the employer will be bound to pay compensation on the basis that there has been a lay off. In this case, it is also the contention of Mr. K.P Abraham, that the union itself insisted only on a compensation being paid on this basis. Therefore, Mr. Abraham alternatively urged under this head of attack, that in any event, the Tribunal erred in awarding full wages for all these days during the months in question instead of fixing compensation on the basis of a lay off. At this stage I may mention that in the view that I take about Mr. Abraham's contention on issue No. 1 a consideration of this question may not become necessary. But even other wise, if it becomes necessary, I am not inclined to accept his contention for this reason. The plea that was advanced, before the Tribunal by the management was not that the employees will be entitled, if at all, to compensation under Section 25 of the Industrial Disputes Act but a more specific case was pleaded, namely, that during the days when there was no work due to the rainy weather the employer offered alternative employment to the workmen which was not accepted. That, ontention, according to the Tribunal, the employer has not been able to prove. Therefore, if I am not accepting the main contention of Mr. Abraham on issue No. 1 the subsidiary contention will stand rejected and the award will have to be confirmed in that respect also.

    6. The main ground of attack urged by Mr. Abraham is that the Industrial Tribunal had no jurisdiction to enquire into this matter covered by issue No. 1 and pass an award inasmuch as there has been a conciliation settlement between the members represented by one of the Unions, namely, the High Range Estate Employees Association, on this matter. In that settlement proceeding, the said association has not pressed its right to claim wages for this particular period covered by issue No. I. Therefore, Mr. Abraham urged that the conciliation agreement entered into by the management with one of the unions which consists of some of the tappers and factory workers of this estate, will nevertheless be binding on the present union also which has raked up the matter, namely, the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union also.

    7. In order to appreciate this contention of Mr. K.P Abraham, certain facts will have to be stated. There is no controversy that in this estate there are three unions functioning, namely. (1) the High Range Estate Employees Association, (2) the Thirucochi Thottam Thozhilali Union, and (3) the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union. There is alto no dispute that all the tappers and factory workers employed in this estate are members of one or the other of these three unions. It is the case of Mr. K.P Abraham that when several other questions including the question of payment of wages for the periods covered by issue No. 1 was raised by the High Range Estate Employees Association, there was a conciliation proceeding and in the conciliation proceeding there was an agreement arrived at by the management and the said union in and by which the said union, so far as this claim is concerned agreed not to press the same. Therefore, Mr. K, P. Abraham urges that the Tribunal in this case has no jurisdiction to consider the matter again. In support of tnis contention Mr. Abraham drew my attention to the recent decision of the Supreme Court reported in Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin(2) and he also urged that the decision of the Industrial Tribunal at Madras reported in Trichy District Motor Workers' Union v. T.S.T Company(3) and relied upon by the Industrial Tribunal in this case is not correct in view of the Supreme Court decision adverted to earlier. I will advert to the decision of the Supreme Court presently.

    8. The learned Government Pleader appearing for the State and Mr. M.P Menon, learned counsel appearing for the Union, in view of this decision of the Supreme Court, found considerable difficulty in supporting the award, relating at any rate to issue No. 1. But the learned Government Pleader urged that the question as to whether the conciliation settlement pleaded in this case can be considered to be a settlement as defined under the provisions of this Act has not been gone into by the Tribunal. Mr. M.P Menon, on the other hand, adopted a different line of approach, namely, that even assuming there has been an agreement between the High Range Estate Employees Association and the management which included also giving up the wages for the particular period in question, that agreement, according to him will be void under the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act and that aspect, though not adverted to by the Tribunal, can be taken into account by this Court to uphold the award.

    9. I have no hesitation in rejecting the contention raised by both the Government Pleader as well as Mr. M.P Menon. That settlement stated to nave been effected between the High Range Estate Employees; Association and the management in this case, apart from containing the signature of the parties is also signed by the Assistant Labour Officer. The question raised by the learned Government Pleader as to whether the Assistant Labour Officer is a person competent to effect conciliation is a matter which does not appear to have been in controversy before the Tribunal. Again, the contention raised by Mr. M.P Menon that the conciliation should be considered to be void because of the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act does not also appear to have been raised before the Tribunal. Therefore, I will have to proceed on the basis that parties assumed that there has been a conciliation settlement entered into between the management and the High Range Estate Employees Association.

    10. Therefore, the question will be what is the effect of the conciliation settle ment entered into, no doubt between only the High Range Estate Employees Associa tion and the Management regarding the contention now urged by the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union which was not a direct party to the settlement proceedings. That is a pure question of law.

    11. The grounds on which the Tribu nal has attempted to get over the effect of the settlement are: (1) the High Range Estate Employees Union had made the de mand only subsequent to the demand made by the present Union. This reasoning does not at all appeal to me and it has abso lutely no relevancy to the question to be con sidered; (2) in the conciliation conference that preceded the settlement the wor kers represented by the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union were not present. (As a statement of fact this is correct. What is the effect in law has not been appreciated by the Tri bunal and it will be considered by me pre sently); (3) the third reason given by the Tribunal is that the Akhila Kerala Planta tion Labour Union was not a party to the aforesaid settlement. This is practically a subsidiary reason given under heading No. 2. That is, reasons (2) and (3) are to the effect that the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union was not present before the Concilia tion Officer and was not a party to the ag reement entered into by the management with the High Range Estate Employees Union. Therefore, the legal effect of the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union not appearing before the conciliation officer or the fact that it is not a party, to the conci liation agreement will have to be considered by me.

    12. No doubt, the Industrial Tribunal refers to a decision of Mr. Ramaswami Gounder as Industrial Tribunal in Madras whose award is reported in Tricky District Motor Workers' Union v. T.S.T Company(4). In view of the Supreme Court decision, to which I am going to make a reference, it is really unnecessary for me to refer to the decision of the Madras Industrial Tribunal. No doubt, the reasoning contained in the decision of Mr. Ramaswami Gounder does support the view adopted by the Tribunal in this case that the effect of the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union not being a party to the conciliation proceedings is that the conciliation proceedings will not bind the association also. It is not really necessary for me to consider the reasons given by Mr. Ramaswami Gounder and T should say that those reasons should be stated to be incorrect in view of the principles laid down by the derision of the Supreme Court in Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin(5).

    13. I may immediately consider the decision of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. v. Jatin(). No doubt the question that arose before their Lordships was as to whether a particular set of workers who went on strike can be considered to have gone on strike when the conciliation proceedings were pending. If they had struck work when the conciliation proceedings were pending they will certainly be guilty of going on an illegal strike under the provisions of Section 24 of the Industrial Disputes Act read with Seelion 22 or Section 23 In order to exactly appreciate the scope of the decision of their Lordships the circumstances under which the matter came before their Lordships wilt have to be stated. In the Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Co. which is the management in that case there were two unions functioning, namely the Ramnagar Cane and Sugar Company Employees' Union, which is described by the learned Judges as the Employees' Union and another set of workmen belonging to a rival union called the Ramnagar Sugar Mills Workers' Union called the Workers' Union and I will also use the same expression when describing those Unions in this judgment.

    14. The Workers' Union appears to have presented a charter of demands to the management on 9th December, 1953. The Employees' Union again made a charter of demands on January 20, 1954. On the same day, i.e, 20-1-1954 the Workers' Union served a notice on the management in that case, of strike. On the 1st February, 1954 a meeting was held by the conciliation officer which was attended by the management and the Employees' Union alone though notice had been served also on the Workers' Union. Subsequently, the management appears to have suggested to the conciliation officer that it may be desirable to discuss the subject of the dispute separately with the representatives of the two Unions. But it is seen that the Workers' Union did not agree to the suggestion and as such they proceeded on the basis that the conciliation proceedings had failed, Consequently, on 3-2-1954, the conciliation officer sent a report under Section 12, sub-section (4) of the Act about the failure of conciliation with the Workers' Union only. Nothwith-standing this report, the proceedings by way of conciliation with the Employees' Union and the management continued and on 25-2-54 the management and the Employees' Union in that case arrived at a settlement which was recorded in due form by way of an agreement. In the meanwhile, that is, on 13-2-1954, the Workers' Union commenced a strike. It was this strike which, according to the management was illegal. Naturally action was sought to be taken under Section 11 of the provisions of the West Bengal Security Act. Therefore, the question that had to be considered was as to whether when the members of the Workers' Union commenced a strike on 13-2-1954, the strike was pending conciliation proceedings. The contention on behalf of the Workers' Union was that inasmuch as they had already withdrawn from the conciliation proceedings from 3-2-1954 they were not parties to any further conciliation proceedings and therefore when they went on strike there were no conciliation proceedings pending and in consequence the strike itself is not illegal. This contention found favour both with the Magistrate as well as the High Court at Calcutta. But by special leave the matter was taken to the Supreme Court by the management. It is in considering this question that their Lordships had to advert to the scheme of the Industrial Disputes Act and in particular to the provisions of Section 18 of the Act. In this case, the contention of Mr. K.P Abraham is that a conciliation settlement, no doubt, entered into by the High Bange Estate Employees' Union with the management will, nevertheless be binding on the Union which has taken up the cause by virtue of clause (d) of sub-section (3) of Section 18 of the Industrial Disputes Act. The matter, if I may say so with great respect, has been put pointedly by Mr. Justice Gajendragadkar delivering judgment on behalf of the Court. Regarding the scope of Section 18, at page 1015, the learned Judge observes:

    “It is now well settled an industrial dispute can be raised in regard to any matter only when it is sponsored by a body of workmen acting through a Union or otherwise. When an industrial dispute in thus raised and decided either by settlement or by an award the scope and effect of its operation is prescribed by Section 18 of the Act. Section 18(1) provides that a settlement arrived at by agreement between the employer and the workman otherwise than in the course of conciliation proceeding shall be binding, on the parties to the agreement; whereas Section 18(3) provides that a settlement arrived at in the course of conciliation proceedings which has become enforceable shall be binding on all the parties specified in clauses (a), (b), (c) and (d) of sub-section (3). Section 13(3)(d) makes it clear that where a party referred to in clause (a) or (b) is composed of workmen, all persons who were employed in the establishment or part of the establishment as the case may be, to which the dispute relates on the date of the dispute and all persons who subsequently became employed in that establishment or part, would be bound by the settlement. In other words, there can be no doubt that the settlement arrived at between the appellant and the Employees' Union during the course of conciliation proceedings on 25-2-1954, would bind not only the members of the said Union but all workmen employed in the establishment of the appellant at that date. That inevitably means that the respondents would be bound by the said settlement even though they may belong to the rival Union. In order to bind the workmen it is not necessary to show that the said workmen belong to the Union which was a party to the dispute before the conciliation. The whole policy of Section 18 appears to be given an extended operation to the settlement arrived at in the course of conciliation proceedings, and that is the object with which the four categories of persons bound by such settlement are specified in Section 18, sub-section (3). In this connection we may refer to two recent decisions of this Court where similar questions under Section 19(6) and Section 33(1)(a) of the Act have been considered. Vide Associated Cement Companies Ltd., Porbander v. Their Workmen(6), Civil Appeal No. 404 of 1953 dated 3-3-1960 and New Indian Motors (P.) Ltd. v. K.T Morris(7), Civil Appeal No. 124 of 1950, dated 22-3-1960.”

    15. Therefore it will be seen from the extract quoted above that according to their Lordships, in order that a conciliation agreement may bind the warkmen it is not really necessary to say that the said workmen belonged to a union which was actually a party to the dispute before the conciliator and it is the further view of their Lordships that the whole policy of Section 18 is to give an extended operation to the settlement arrived at in the case of conciliation proceedings and that is the object with which the four categories bound by the settlement are specified in sub-section 3 of Section 18. Again, the learned Judges at page 1015 observe:

    “In our opinion, his construction would be consistent with the specific provisions as to the effect of conciliation settlements prescribed by Section 18(3)(a) and is harmonious with the general policy of the Act; otherwise, it will unnecessarily disturb industrial peace, if one union employed in a public utility service is allowed to go on strike even though demands common to the members of the said union as well as the rest of the workmen are being considered in conciliation proceedings between the said employer and his other employees represented by another Union.”

    16. Therefore, it will follow that the fact that the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union was not a party to the conciliation agreement entered into between the management and the High Range Estate Employees' Association will not in any way make the conciliation agrtement not binding on this Labour Union as such. It will also follow that according to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court that a conciliation agreement in respect of common matters pertaining to the employees of the establishment though settled between one Union and the management will be binding on all other Unions in which the class of employees are more or less the same. Therefore, the various reasons given by the Industrial Tribunal in this case for coming to the conclusion that the conciliation agreement is not binding on the Akhila Kerala Plantation Labour Union fall to the ground and hence I have to hold that the award of the Industrial Tribunal regarding issue No. 1 cannot be sustained. Therefore Mr. K.P Abraham's contention in this regard will have to be accepted.

    17. The further attack that is made by Mr. K.P Abraham, as I mentioned earlier, is on the findings recorded by the Tribunal on issues 6 and 7. Issue No. 6 related to payment of gratuity to the dependents of deceased workmen and issue No. 7 related to payment of gratuity to the aged and disabled workmen. It is really unnecessary for me to reiterate what exactly is the principle underlying the provision being made for gratuity and framing of schemes of gratuity because those matters have been already considered by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in earlier eases. After referring to all these decisions I have also considered this matter in O.P No. 245 of 1958. It has to be borne in mind that the true character of gratuity, though it was treated as a payment gratuitously made by an employer at his pleasure, is now at any rate as a result of a long series of decisions that term has now come to be regarded as an allotment claim which the workmen can make and in proper cases can even give rise to an industrial dispute. It must also be remembered that gratuity is paid to a workman after retirement whether the retirement is due to superannuation or physical disability. Having due regerd to the various principles referred to above, the question is when the Industrial Tribunal framed the scheme for gratuity under these two different heads it has acted in any way illegally or without jurisdiction.

    18. Mr. K.P Abraham urged that the jurisdiction of the Industrial Tribunal is very much limited and that should be found in the terms of reference made to the Tribunal by the order of the Government. In this case, Mr. K.P Abraham stated that the issue that is referred is tegarding gratuity to the dependents of deceased workmen. That expression “dependents of deceased workmen”, according to Mr K.P Abraham, must really have relation to the definition of the “dependents” found in the Workmen's Compensation Act. Although that was the specific issue raised, Mr. K.P Abraham urged that the scheme that is framed by the Tribunal goes far beyond the terms of reference and directs payments of gratuity to the heirs, executors or nominees. It is not possible for me to accept this contention of Mr. K.P Abraham. Whatever may be the definition of the expression “dependent” in the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, that in my opinion, has no relevancy when considering the terms of reference under issue No. 6. In my opinion what is intended is a general provision of gratuity for the heirs of the deceased workmen and that is what exactly has been provided for in clause (1) of the scheme framed by the Industrial Tribunal as such.

    19. The further contention of Mr. K.P Abraham is that issue No. 7 again limits the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to consider the question of payment of gratuity to the aged and disabled workmen whereas according to Mr. K.. P. Abraham here the Tribunal committed an illegality in framing a general scheme for gratuity not to aged and disabled workmen alone but really to all the workmen concerned. Even here I am not inclined to accept the contention of Mr. K.P Abraham. Both issues 6 and 7, in my view, raise the general questions of gratuity payable to workmen of this concern though, no doubt, the expiession “aged and disabled workmen” or the expression “dependents of deceased workmen” is used in Issue No. 7 and Issue No. 6 respectively. But that, in any view, does not really take away the jurisdiction of the Industrial Tribunal especially when it has to deal with a provision being made for gratuity as such. No doubt, Mr. K.P Abraham, placed before me certain decisions to show that the jurisdiction will not extend to such matters under Section 10(4) of the Industrial Disputes Act. I am not inclined to accept this contention either. In fact, when a similar contention was urged before me, in O.P No. 245 of 1958 I was not there also inclined to accept that contention and in my view in the circumstances of this case being referred, the Tribunal has certainly got jurisdiction to frame a proper scheme having due regard to the financial condition of the employer. In this case, it has adverted to the financial capacity of the employer and it is only after a consideration of the realevant materials placed before it that it has ultimately framed a scheme which, in my view, is not only necessary but highly desirable also to prevent any possible friction between an employer and the employees. No doubt, Mr. K.P Abraham made some attack against the particular clauses in the scheme also. The only clause which I thought requires some modification is clause 6 which related to gratuity being payable to any workman who is dismissed for misconduct involving financial, loss to the Estate. But the Supreme Court in its decision rendered in Garment Cleaning Works v. Its Workers(8) had to consider the scope of a clause wherein it was provided that if the workman is dismissed or discharged for misconduct causing financial loss gratuity to the extent of the loss should not be paid to the workman concerned. In considering that clause the learned Judges observe:

    “If gratuity is earned by an employee for long and meritorious service, it is difficult to understand why the benefit thus earned by long and meritorious service should not be available to the employee and even though at the end of such service he may have been found guilty of misconduct which enables his dismissal”.

    20. Their Lordships further reiterate the position that gratuity is noc paid to the employee gratuitously and it is paid to him for the service rendered by him to the employer, and when it is once earned it is difficult for their Lordships to understand why it should necessarily be denied to him, whatever may be the nature of misconduct for his dismissal. In view of this decision referred to above, any interference with cleuse 6 in this case as it stands does not also become necessary.

    21. In the result, the writ petition is allowed to this extent, namely, the award of the Industrial Tribunal Ext. P. 1 in so far as it relates to the findings recorded or directions given in respert of issue No. 1 will stand quashed and cancelled. In all other respects the writ petition fails and parties will bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Supdt., Erumeli Estate v. Industrial Tribunal, Alleppey And Other
    (Jul 14, 1961)