The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
N. Kumar, J.:— These writ, appeals are filed against the order passed by 1 the learned single judge declining to entertain the writ petitions, which is filed challenging the order passed by the assessing authority on the ground that the petitioner has an alternate and efficacious remedy by way of statutory appeal.
2. The appellant-assessee is a public limited company engaged in the busi-ness of software development and export and providing software services. The assessee is a registered dealer under the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act; 2003 (hereinafter referred to as, “the KVAT Act”) and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, (hereinafter referred to as, “the CST Act”, for short).; The assessee has been filing its VAT returns in form VAT 100 in L VO-045 regularly. The assessee is also registered under section 69 of Chapter V of the Finance Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as, “the Act”) for the purpose of payment of service tax and has been paying service tax on its service turnover from the date of applicability. The place of business of the assessee was visited by the Commercial Tax Officer for the purpose of inspection on June 8, 2010. Subsequently the case was assigned for audits. The assessee produced all its books. The Commercial Tax Officer audited the books of account for the period from 2009-10. Subsequently a notice was issued under sections 39(1), 72(2) and 36 of the KVAT Act. On August 9, 2010 in the course of verification of the monthly returns it was observed that the assessee has provided software development and claimed exemption on exports. In support Of his case he had filed copies of invoices and the purchase orders for verification. In the course of verification it was found that in addition to export of software the assessee has also rendered services to one M/s. Alcatei-Lucent Technologies, (-2) M/s. Motorola, (3) M/s. Texas Instruments, (4) M/s. Nokia. They also noticed that the assessee had entered into agreements with the above companies regarding the business activities. After setting out the nature of the activities carried out by the assessee, he concluded that the company dealt in high-end work of development in various fields and thus executed works contract. This development activity of software attracts tax under works contract as per section 4(1) (c) of the KVAT Act at four per cent. As per the provisions of rule 3(2) of the KVAT Rules, 2005, the labour charges at 25 per cent is allowed as exemption. Verification of VAT 100 filed by the dealer revealed that the exempted sales turnover includes export also. For computation of tax liability the VAT 100's are considered. In the light of the above it was proposed to re-assess under section 39(1) of the KVAT Act for the tax period from April 2009 to March, 2010 month wise based on the information available on records by rejecting the monthly returns filed by the assessee as incorrect and incomplete. It was also proposed to impose interest and penalty. On receipt of the said notice the assessee filed his objections. The assessee submitted that it is in the business of rendering software development service and have been accordingly paying service tax under the Act, on its turnover from the date of applicability. The company pays service tax under the head “information technology software services”. Section 65(105) of Chapter V of the Act, includes within its ambit the taxable service in the nature of information technology software under sub-clause (zzzze). Given the fact that the company is providing services and hence liable to service tax, the payment or levy of VAT on the same turnover does not arise. They also pointed out that the observations made in respect of the agreements are incorrect and they have set out in the nature of reply, the nature of services rendered to each of their clients and also pointed out the different clauses in the said agreements. Then they contended that they provide the information technology services and the clients owned all the intellectual property developed during the course of the performance of the agreement. They have assumed the deliverables only as a work for hire. At no point of time the assessee owns in any manner whatsoever any copyright or any other right in the work. Obviously the assessee cannot sell what it does not own. Hence there cannot be any transfer of property in goods. They contended that the assessee provides only services under the agreement and the service is solely related to information technology software services. The assessee never owns at any point of time any intellectual property of inventions or discoveries or new developments made during the course of the performance of the agreements. All the intellectual property or inventions or discoveries or new developments are the exclusive property of the customer at all times. The assessee has contracted under the agreement to render services as per the specifications of the customer and hence did not have ownership of any software developed under the agreements. Their case squarely falls within the circumstances described in part (4) of the circular No. 17/2006/07 issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes. They have extracted the circular. Therefore they sought for dropping of the proceedings.
3. However on consideration of the aforesaid material the assessing authority in the impugned order has held that whether the assessee-com-pany is a software development company making deemed sale of software or they are mere service providers or solution providers has to be understood on the strength of the agreements with the client companies. The agreements specify the deliverables/customers/maintenance, etc., the meaning of these are nothing other than the code writing or further development of the software. Irrespective of the mode of payment as either lump sum/based on man hours the entire receipts are towards the development of software only. There has been a misconception in the understanding of the circular issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Tax (Karnataka), Bangalore. The sum and substance of development of software either in the company's premises or elsewhere will end up through the deliverables. The objections filed are found to be general in nature and they are not supported by the provisions of the Act nor any judgments to prove credence. So the Objections filed were rejected. The only explanation of reversal of turnovers was considered as per the books of accounts. Therefore ultimately they upheld the demand and also imposed interest and penalty. Aggrieved by the said order the assessee preferred a writ petition before this court.
4. However the learned single judge was of the view that whether the con-tract in question is a service contract or not and whether if it is a works contract, it is not possible to come to any definite conclusion unless each agreement between the parties is carefully examined. Moreover a statutory appeal is provided against the impugned order. In that view of the matter, he declined to entertain the writ petitions and dismissed the same. Aggrieved by the said order the assessee is before this court in appeal.
Rival contentions
5. The learned counsel appearing for the assessee contended that the con-tract in question is a contract of service simplicitor. There is no element of sale in the execution of contract between the parties. The assessee has paid the service tax in respect of the entire consideration received under the agreement. Therefore, once the field is covered by the Central legislation, the Parliament has exclusive power to make any law with respect to any matter not enumerated in the concurrent List or State List, the State has no power to enact a law or transgress the law enacted by the Parliament and levy tax under the guise that it involves sale of goods. As is clear from the terms of the agreement entered into between the parties there is no sale of any goods or deemed sale. Reliance placed by the assessing authority on the balance sheet to contend that in execution of the contract, as the assessee has purchased the software and the said software is transferred in terms of the contract there is a deemed sale, is without any substance. Though in the balance sheet the software purchase is shown, the said software is used as a tool by the assessee in executing the contract and the said tools are not transferred. The agreement and the other material on record clearly show the assessee has rendered its services to find a solution to the problem of the customer and even before the said solution is found, the assessee has given up his right in the copyright or the proprietary right in such goods, which may emerge as a final product and therefore seen from any angle there is no element of sale of goods which attracts sales tax. Therefore he submits that, the order of the assessing authority levying sales tax is ex facie illegal, one without jurisdiction and liable to be set aside,
6. Per contra, the learned Government Advocate supporting the impugned order contended that software is now held to be goods. Though it is intangible or incorporeal, what the assessee does by employing its labour is to produce the customized software and once the end-product is put on a material object and transferred to the customer it amounts to Sale of software and therefore Sales tax is attracted. Even in executing the said contract the software is purchased. It is on the software which is purchased, the developmental activities take place and that value added addition to the software is transferred to the customer. It is a works contract, which falls under clause (b) of article 366(29A), it is a deemed sale which attracts the sales tax and therefore no case for interference is made out.
7. From the aforesaid facts and rival contentions, the point that arises for our consideration in these appeals is as under:
“Whether the contract for development of a software falls within the mischief of a “works contract”, and when the software so developed, vests with the customer from day one does it amount to deemed sale under article 366(29A)(b) of the Constitution of India?”
Is it a works contract
8. On behalf of the Revenue, it was contended that, a Constitution Bench of the apex court in the case of Tata Consultancy Services v. State of Andhra Pradesh, [2004] 137 SC 620 (SC); (2004) 271 ITR 401 (SC) has held that software is a goods which is capable of being bought and sold, capable of abstraction, consumption and use and carl be transmitted, transferred, delivered, stored, possessed, etc., as such, in a contract for rendering service to develop a software, when the software is transferred to the customer, it amounts to sale of goods and liable to sales tax.
9. The question which arose for consideration in Tata Consultancy Services, [2004] 137 SC 620 (SC) is, whether the canned software sold by the assessee can be termed to be “goods” and as such assessable to sales tax under the Act.
10. The apex court relied on the judgment of the American Court in the case of Advent Systems Limited v. Unisys Corporation, 925 F 2d 670 (3rd Circuit 1991) where it was held that, computer programs are the product of an intellectual process, but once implanted in a medium they are widely distributed to computer owners. An analogy can be drawn to a compact-disc recording of an orchestral rendition. The music is produced by the artistry of musicians and in itself is not a goods, but when transferred to a laser-readable disc it becomes a readily merchantable commodity. Simi-larly, when a professor delivers a lecture, it is not a goods, but, when transcribed as a book, it becomes a goods. That a computer program may be copyrightable, as intellectual property does not alter the fact that once in the form of a floppy disc or other medium, the program is tangible, movable and available in the market place. The fact that some programs may be tailored for specific purposes need not alter their status as “goods” because the code definition includes “specially manufactured goods”. Thereafter, at para 24, they proceeded to hold as under (pages 640 and 641 in 137 STC):
“24. In our view, the term ‘goods’ as used in article 366(12) of the J Constitution of India and as defined under the said Act are very wide and include all types of movable properties, whether those properties be tangible or intangible. We are in complete agreement with the observations made by this court in Associated Cement Companies Ltd., [2001] 124 STC 59 (SC); (2001) 4 SCC 593. A software programme may consist of various commands which enable the com-puter to perform a designated task. The copyright in that programme may remain with the originator of the programme. But the moment copies are made and marketed, it becomes goods, which are susceptible to sales tax. Even intellectual property, once it is put on to a media, whether it be in the form of books or canvas (in case of painting) or computer discs or cassettes, and marketed would become goods'. We see no difference between a sale of a software pro-gramme on a CD/floppy disc from a sale of music on a cassette/CD or a sale of a film on a video cassette/CD. In all such cases, the intellectual property has been incorporated on a media for purposes of transfer. Sale is not just of the media which by itself has very little value. The software and the media cannot be split up. What the buyer purchases and pays for is not the disc or the CD. As in the case of paintings or books or music or films the buyer is purchasing the intellectual property and not the media, i.e, the paper or cassette or disc or CD. Thus a transaction sale of computer software is clearly a sale of ‘goods’ within the meaning of the term as defined in the said Act. The term all materials, articles and commodities' includes both tangible and intangible/incorporeal property which is capable of abstraction, consumption and use and which can be transmitted, transferred, delivered, stored, possessed, etc. The software programmes have all these attributes.
In so far as the distinction between a branded and unbranded software is concerned, it was held in both cases, the software is capable of being abstracted, consumed and used. In both cases, the software can be transmitted, transferred, delivered., stored, possessed, etc. Thus, even unbranded software, when it is marketed/sold, may be goods. We, however, are not dealing with this aspect and express no opinion thereon because in case of unbranded software other questions like situs or contract of sale and/or whether the contract is a service contract may arise.”
11. From the aforesaid judgment, it is clear that a software-is “goods” as defined under article 366(12) of the Constitution of India and therefore, there is no dispute about the said legal position. But the question for consideration in these cases is, whether a contract that is entered into for developing a software, is it a service contract or a composite contract including service and sale of goods.
12. The apex court after holding that even unbranded software, when it is marketed/sold, may be goods, made it very clear that, in the aforesaid deci-sion, they are not dealing with this aspect and expressed no opinion because in case of unbranded software “whether the contract is a service contract” or “contract of sale is also involved”, may arise. That is precisely the question that has to be decided in these cases. Therefore, said judgment does not come in the way of this court going into the said question, as the Supreme Court has not expressed their opinion on the said issue. Therefore, the field is open. In order to justify, the imposition of value added tax, the Revenue contends that it is a composite contract, a works contract. There is an element of service and transfer of goods, consequently a deemed sale.
13. The word “works contract” has been defined under the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 as under:
“2. (37) ‘Works contract’ includes any agreement for carrying out for cash, deferred payment or other valuable consideration, the building, construction, manufacture, processing, fabrication, erection, installation, filling out, improvement, modification, repair or commissioning of any movable or immovable property.”
14. The Revenue contends, works contract includes an agreement for improvement. In other words, their case is, the assessee has purchased software from the market. Then the said software is improved by rendering service according to specification to meet the requirements of the client. Then the software so developed is embedded in the software which is on a media and then transferred to the customer. Therefore, there is a deemed sale. If the material on record discloses as a matter of fact that the assessee purchased software embedded on a media which is admittedly goods, and any improvement is made on such goods and then sold to the customer, maybe it falls within the definition of a “works contract”. But in the entire agreement between the parties, there is no indication to support the said contention. In fact, reliance is placed by the Revenue not on the terms of the contract, but on the balance sheet. The balance sheet in these cases discloses that the assessee has incurred an expenditure of Rs. 183.19 lakhs towards software expenses, which according to the, Revenue is the consideration paid by the assessee for purchase of software. The assessee points out, in the very balance sheet, they have spent a sum of Rs. 21,404.07 lakhs towards salaries and bonus. It is the specific case of the assessee that the software expenses referred to therein is the software which they have purchased and used as a tool in the development of a software according to the specification of the customer. It is not a software on which they have made any improvement. Having regard to the amount mentioned in the balance sheet, towards salaries and bonus, the amounts spent on purchase of software will be less than one per cent of the amount spent on salaries and bonus. Their specific case is that they have developed a software to meet the requirements of their customer, which software at all point of time, exclusively belonged to customer. There is no sale of software involved in the entire transaction.
15. In order to appreciate the rival contentions and to find out whether the contract in question is a works contract, or an indivisible-contract, arid what is the dominant nature of the contract and what is the intention of the parties, it is necessary to see the relevant and material terms of the contract. The same is extracted hereunder: