AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Code of Civil Procedure reviewing Order VIII Rule 9 by Central Act 22 of 2002. The CPC Amendment Act, 2002
  • summons.3. Order VIII Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter referred
  • provisions of Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code
  • Rule 1 and 9 of Order VIII of the Code,
  • Order VIII Rule 10. Order VIII Rule 10
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Order VIII Rule 9 of the old Code
  • Rule 1 and Rule 9 in Rule 10.15.
  • Rules 1, 9 and 10 of Order VIII
  • Order Vill Rule 1 of the Code
  • Order 8 Rule 1, 9 of the Code.
  • Code.14. Order VIII Rule 10
  • Order VIII Rule 10
  • Order VIII Rule 9
  • Order VIII Rule 1
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Code of Civil Procedure reviewing Order VIII Rule 9 by Central Act 22 of 2002. The CPC Amendment Act, 2002
  • summons.3. Order VIII Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter referred
  • provisions of Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code
  • Rule 1 and 9 of Order VIII of the Code,
  • Order VIII Rule 10. Order VIII Rule 10
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Order VIII Rule 9 of the old Code
  • Rule 1 and Rule 9 in Rule 10.15.
  • Rules 1, 9 and 10 of Order VIII
  • Order Vill Rule 1 of the Code
  • Order 8 Rule 1, 9 of the Code.
  • Code.14. Order VIII Rule 10
  • Order VIII Rule 10
  • Order VIII Rule 9
  • Order VIII Rule 1
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Kumar Rajaratnam, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition concerns a defendant (the petitioner) seeking permission to file a written statement after the period allowed under Order VIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The petition was taken up for final disposal with the consent of counsel on both sides. The specific suit in which this controversy arose was O.S. No. 79/01 in the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.), Maddur, where the respondent plaintiff sought cancellation of the registration of a Trust Deed dated 15.11.95 (No. 15/95-96) and a declaration that formation of the Trust by the defendant was not binding on the plaintiff.

Procedurally: after related writ petitions (WP No. 4198/02 and WP Nos. 46883-904/01) were filed and disposed of, O.S. No. 79/01 was posted on 22.10.2002 for filing of the written statement. On that date the Trial Court recorded "written statement not filed" and posted the matter for the plaintiff's evidence. The petitioner claims various reasons for delay and filed a written statement along with an interlocutory application (I.A.1) under Section 151 (noting also reference to Order VIII Rule 1), which the Trial Court rejected by order dated 7.1.2003. The petitioner challenged that order in this revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court can permit filing of a written statement by the defendant beyond the period of ninety days from the date of service of summons under the Code of Civil Procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner advanced reasons for failing to file the written statement within time: the relevant records were in the custody of the petitioner's counsel in Bangalore and some original documents were misplaced.
  • The petitioner was under the bona fide belief that the Civil Procedure Code (Amendment) Act, 2002 would have prospective effect.
  • The petitioner had been appearing in connected writ petitions (one of which had an interim order) and therefore had ongoing engagement in those proceedings.
  • On 7.1.2003 the petitioner filed the written statement along with I.A.1 seeking permission to file the same, but the Trial Court rejected that interlocutory application under Section 151 without considering the provisions of Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code.
  • The petitioner submitted that no useful purpose would be served by denying acceptance of the written statement, that the petitioner had given compelling reasons for delay, and that the issue had not yet been framed in the Trial Court so acceptance would serve the interests of both parties.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any arguments advanced by the respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kali Pado Sharma v. Surendra Nath Mahatha, AIR 1975 Patna 24 Cited for the proposition that Order VIII Rule 9 invests the Court with wide discretion to accept a written statement filed subsequently even after settlement of issues. The Court noted that the Patna High Court in this case (relying on Binda Prasad) took the view that Rule 9 confers the widest possible discretion; this authority was relied upon by the petitioner and accepted as applicable to the amended Code subject to compelling reasons to be recorded in writing.
Binda Prasad v. United Bank of India, AIR 1961 Patna 152 Relied upon (by Kali Pado Sharma) to support the wide discretion under Order VIII Rule 9 of the old Code. The judgment was referenced as precedent underlying the Patna High Court's approach; the Court in the present opinion accepted that the earlier decisions under the old Code remain relevant to the amended Code, subject to the requirement of compelling reasons recorded in writing.
S. Sridevi v. S. Vijay & Another, 1989 1 K.L.J. 100 Applied for the proposition that under Rule 1 and Rule 9 of Order VIII there is scope for the Court to permit additional written statements where there is no prejudice to the plaintiff; such allowance should not be denied merely for the sake of denial. The Court accepted the approach in S. Sridevi that the trial court has wide powers and discretion under Order VIII Rule 1 and Rule 9 to permit amendments or additional written statements if no prejudice is likely; this supports the view that the power can be exercised in appropriate cases under the amended Code.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the statutory scheme and proceeded by reference to the relevant provisions of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure:

  • Order VIII Rule 1: Mandates that the defendant shall present a written statement within thirty days from the date of service of summons; the proviso allows the Court to permit filing later for reasons to be recorded in writing, but not later than ninety days from service.
  • Order VIII Rule 10: Provides the consequence where a written statement required by Rule 1 or Rule 9 is not presented within the time permitted — the Court "shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit" and on pronouncement a decree shall be drawn up. The Court emphasized that if the plaint makes out a case, the Court will have no alternative except to pronounce judgment.
  • Order VIII Rule 9 (as amended by the CPC Amendment Act, 2002, effective 1 July 2002): Introduces 'subsequent pleadings' language and empowers the Court in extraordinary and rare circumstances to require a written statement or additional written statement from any party and to fix a time of not more than thirty days for presenting the same.

From these provisions the Court derived the following analytical points:

  • There is a clear hierarchy of time-limits: initial 30-day period (Rule 1), an extended but ultimate limit of 90 days under the proviso to Rule 1, and, under Rule 9 as amended, a further limited power to require additional written statements with an outer time-limit of 30 days from the date of the Court's order.
  • Rule 10 cross-refers to Rules 1 and 9, which demonstrates that Rule 9 is not confined to set-off or counter-claim situations; it has broader application.
  • Order VIII Rule 9 is to be read in two parts: (a) limiting subsequent pleadings unless leave is given; and (b) empowering the Court to require written or additional written statements within a newly fixed 30-day period.
  • The amended Rule 9 narrows judicial discretion compared to the old Code by imposing an outer limit of 30 days for an additional written statement fixed by the Court; thus the power under Rule 9 is the "last reservoir" of permission to file a written statement and must be exercised sparingly.
  • The Court emphasized that the power under Rule 9 should be used only in exceptional cases and for reasons recorded in writing; the exercise must be judicial, not capricious, and consistent with the object of the amended Code to curtail delay.
  • The Court accepted that earlier decisions under the old Code (including the cited authorities) remain applicable but that under the amended Code the requirement of compelling reasons recorded in writing must be satisfied.

Application to the present facts: the Court considered the petitioner's stated reasons for delay (documents with counsel in Bangalore; misplacement of originals; bona fide belief about prospective effect of amendment; involvement in related writ petitions) and noted that the petitioner had filed the written statement and an interlocutory application which was rejected by the Trial Court without addressing the Rule 9 provisions. Given that the issue had not yet been framed and in the interest of justice, the Court concluded that refusal to permit the written statement would serve no useful purpose.

The Court therefore allowed the revision petition subject to conditions stated in the order and provided guidance that Trial Courts must exercise the limited power under Order VIII Rule 9 with caution in light of the amended Code's object to reduce delay.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The revision petition is allowed.

The Court directed that the petitioner shall deposit Rs. 500/- in the Trial Court to be paid to the respondent plaintiff within three weeks. Upon such deposit, the Trial Court is requested to accept the written statement filed by the petitioner (defendant) and to proceed to dispose of the suit in accordance with law.

Implications

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner is permitted to have the previously filed written statement accepted by the Trial Court subject to payment of Rs. 500 to the respondent within three weeks; the Trial Court is to accept the written statement and continue disposal of the suit as per law.
  • On legal principle: The Court reiterated the limits of judicial discretion under the amended Order VIII Rule 9 — it remains a narrow, exceptional power to permit filing of written or additional written statements (within the 30-day outer limit fixed by the Court) and should be exercised for compelling reasons recorded in writing. Trial Courts must exercise this power cautiously because the amended Code was enacted to reduce delays.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a broad new precedent beyond applying the amended statutory scheme and the principles summarised; it emphasizes careful, judicial, non-capricious exercise of Rule 9 powers in exceptional cases.

    Prasanna Parvathamba Vaidyanatheshwara Trust v. M.S. Radhakrishna Dixit

    Kumar Rajaratnam, J.:—

    With the consent of the learned Counsel appearing on both sides, this petition is taken up for final disposal.

    2. The only question that arises for consideration in this petition is whether the Court can permit filing of written statement by the defendant beyond the period of 90 days from the date of service of summons.

    3. Order VIII Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter referred to as Code) reads as follows:—

    “1. Written statement. The defendant shall, within thirty days from the date of service of summons on him, present a written statement of his defence:

    Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be allowed to file the same on such other day, as may be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing, but which shall hot be later than ninety days from the date of service of summons.”

    4. There is a clear mandate under the Code that written statements must be filed within 30 days from the date of service of summons. The proviso to Order VIII Rule 1 indicates that where the defendant fails to file written statement within the said period of 30 days, the Court may allow him to file the same on some other day as may be specified by the Court for the reasons to be recorded in writing but which shall not be later than 90 days from the date of service of summons.

    5. What happens if the written statement is not filed within 90 days from the date of service of summons is clearly set out under Order VIII Rule 10. Order VIII Rule 10 reads as under:—

    “Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by Court:

    Where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.”

    If no written statement is filed within 90 days, the Code mandates that the Court shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order as the Court thinks fit.

    6. In other words, the Code clearly indicates that if a case is made out in the plaint, the Court will have no alternative except to pronounce judgment. The words in Order VIII Rule 10 are to the effect that the Court shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.

    7. An amendment was brought to the Code of Civil Procedure reviewing Order VIII Rule 9 by Central Act 22 of 2002. The CPC Amendment Act, 2002 came into force on 1st of July, 2002. By the amendment of Order VIII Rule 9, the following amendment was introduced under the nomenclature of ‘subsequent pleadings’.

    “9. Subsequent pleadings — No pleading subsequent to the written statement of a defendant other than by way of defence to set off or counter-claim shall be presented except by the leave of the Court and upon such terms as the Court thinks fit; but the Court may at any time require a written statement or additional written statement or from any of the parties and fix a time of not more than thirty days for presenting the same.”

    8. From a perusal of Order VIII Rule 9, it appears that the Court has got power under extraordinary and rare circumstances to require at any time written or additional written statements to be filed in a case within the outer limit of 30 days to be fixed by the Court. The question also arises for consideration as to whether Order VIII Rule 9 would relate only to set off and counter claim or would relate to other cases as well.

    9. The answer to this question need not detain us for too long. Order VIII Rule 9 consists of two parts viz.,:

    (a) A party can file pleadings subsequent to the filing of written statement other than by way of defencse to set off or counter claim except by the leave of the Court and upon such terms as the Court thinks fit.

    (b) The Court may at any time require a written statement or additional written statement from any of the parties and fix a time of not more than thirty days for presenting the same.

    10. Mr. Mahesh R. Uppin, learned Counsel for the petitioner relied on a judgment of the Patna High Court reported in Kali Pado Sharma v. Surendra Nath Mahatha . AIR 1975 PATNA 24.. In that case, relying on a judgment reported in Binda Prasad v. United Bank of India . AIR 1961 PATNA 152., the Patna High Court took the view that Order VIII Rule 9 invests the Court with the widest possible discretion and enables it to accept a written statement filed subsequently even after the settlement of issue, upon such terms as the Court thinks fit.

    11. Reliance was also placed on a judgment of this Court by Mr. Uppin. This Court in S. Sridevi v. S. Vijay & Another . 1989 1 K.L.J 100. has held that under Rule 1 and 9 of Order VIII of the Code, there is ample scope for the Court to apply its mind in each case to permit or not to permit additional written statement. It should not be denied for sake of mere denial. It should be allowed if there is no prejudice likely to be caused to the plaintiff or any of the parties. In that view of the matter it was only a formal application of a legal right already available to the I defendant and the Court should have allowed the amendment having regard to the wide powers and discretion vested in the trial Court under Order 8 Rule 1, 9 of the Code. (See 1989 K.L.J (1) page 100)

    12. Although the judgments cited at the Bar by Mr. Uppin are with respect to the old Code, these judgments will apply to the new Code as well but however for compelling reasons to be recorded in writing. Order VIII Rule 9 of the old Code reads as follows:—

    “9. Subsequent pleadings — No pleading subsequent to the written statement of a defendant other than by way of defence to a set off or counter-claim shall be presented except by the leave of the Court and upon such terms as the Court thinks fit, but the Court may at any time require a written statement or additional written statement from any of the parties and fix a time for presenting the same.”

    The amended Code has been extracted in the earlier part of the judgment.

    13. The only difference between the old Code and the new Code as far as Order VIII Rule 9 is concerned is that no time limit is fixed in the old code and discretion is given to the Court to fix the time for presenting the written statement. In the amended code, the Court may permit filing of written statement or additional written statement from any of the parties, but the Court must fix an outer limit of not more than 30 days for presenting the same. In other words, once the time is fixed by the Court and the written statement is not filed within that time, the defendant loses his right to file his written statement. This appears to be the last reservoir of power given to the Court for permitting the defendant to file his written statement. I am of the view that this power under Order VIII Rule 9 should be used only in exceptional cases and for reasons recorded in writing and cannot be exercised by a defendant as a matter of right. Such exercise of discretion must be judicial and not capricious and such right must be in keeping with the spirit of the amended Code.

    14. Order VIII Rule 10 also makes reference to Rules 1 and 9 of Order VIII. When such is the position, obviously, Rule 9 is not confined only to set off or counter claim. If that be so, there would not be a reference to Rule 1 and Rule 9 in Rule 10.

    15. A harmonious reading of Rules 1, 9 and 10 of Order VIII would indicate that Rule 9 in extraordinary cases gives the Court judicial discretion to permit the defendant to file a written statement within the outer span of 30 days from the date of passing the order for reasons recorded in writing.

    16. Coming to the facts of the case, it was submitted by Mr. Uppin that the respondent filed O.S No. 79/01 in the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.), Maddur seeking cancellation of the registration of the Trust Deed dated 15.11.95 numbered as 15/95-96 registered in the Office of the Sub-Registrar, Maddur Taluk, Mandya District and to declare that the formation of the Trust by the defendant is not binding on the plaintiff. In that suit, the petitioner appeared through an advocate.

    17. Subsequently, the respondent plaintiff filed WP No. 4198/02 in respect of the very same subject matter. Further, a public interest litigation was also filed in this Court numbered as WP 46883-904/01. WP Nos. 46883-904/01 were dismissed on 13.01.03 and WP 4198/02 was disposed of on 4.3.03

    18. In the meanwhile, O.S No. 79/01 was posted before the Trial Court on 22.10.2002 for filing written statement. On that day, the Trial Court passed an order as ‘written statement not filed’ and the matter was posted for plaintiff's evidence. Mr. Uppin submitted that the petitioner defendant could not file the written statement on the said day for various reasons. All the records pertaining to O.S No. 79/01 were in the custody of the petitioner's counsel at Bangalore. Some of the original relevant documents were misplaced. The suit was instituted before the Civil Procedure Code (Amendment) Act came into force. The petitioner defendant was under the bona fide belief that the amendment Act will have prospective effect. The petitioner defendant used to appear regularly in the Writ Petitions as there was an interim order in one of the petitions.

    19. Counsel further submitted that on 7.1.2003 the petitioner defendant filed written statement along with I.A.I under Order Vill Rule 1 of the Code seeking permission to file the same. The learned Civil Judge without considering the provisions of Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code passed the impugned order dated 7.1.03 rejecting the I.A filed under Section 151 of the Code. In these circumstances, the petitioner defendant has come up in this revision petition.

    20. Along with I.A.I, the petitioner defendant has already filed his written statement. No useful purpose will be served in the facts and circumstances of this case, if the defendant is denied the right to file his written statement. The petitioner has given the compelling reasons for not being able to file his written statement within time. It will be in the interest of both parties that the written statement is accepted by the Court since the issue has not been framed as yet.

    21. Accordingly, the revision petition is allowed. The petitioner shall deposit Rs. 500/- in the Trial Court to be paid to the respondent plaintiff within three weeks. On such deposit by the petitioner defendant, the Trial Court in requested to accept the written statement filed by the respondent and dispose of the suit in accordance with law.

    22. Before parting with this case, it is necessary to observe that cannot be forgotten that the new Code was enacted by the Parliament in order to cut short delays at various levels. These salutary provisions were introduced in the new Code for speedy disposal of cases in consonance with fair play and justice. Therefore, Trial Courts must be extremely cautious in exercising powers under Order VIII Rule 9.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prasanna Parvathamba Vaidyanatheshwara Trust v. M.S. Radhakrishna Dixit
    (Apr 17, 2003)