AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was preferred under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the judgment and award dated 11-09-1991. On 23-12-1988 at about 17:30 hours an accident occurred on the Poona-Bangalore Road near Hitni cross in village Kanagala involving truck No. MEG 7669 driven by respondent 1, owned by respondent 2 and insured by respondent 3. The claimant-appellant sustained serious injuries: fractures of the collar bone and right leg and amputation of the left leg from the knee. The claimant alleged permanent disability and inability to work; his claim sought Rs. 3,50,000/- in compensation.

On notice, respondents filed objections: respondent 3 (the Insurance Company) pleaded contributory negligence on the claimant (who was carrying fodder on his head) and that the claimed amount was excessive; the insurer also stated its maximum liability under the policy was Rs. 1,50,000/-. The Tribunal framed three issues (set out below), heard the claimant (who examined himself and produced Exhibits P-1 to P-17), and recorded that respondents produced no evidence except the insurance policy (marked Ex. D-1 by consent).

The Tribunal found the truck driver's rash and negligent driving solely responsible for the accident and rejected respondent contentions of contributory negligence. The Tribunal held the claimant is permanently handicapped and awarded Rs. 75,000/- (broken down in the text), less interim compensation of Rs. 7,500/-, resulting in Rs. 67,500/- payable. The claimant appealed, contending the award was meagre.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner proved that he sustained personal injuries in an accident on 23-12-1988 due to the rash and negligent driving of truck MEG 7669 driven by respondent 1?
  2. Whether the respondents proved that the petitioner contributed to the accident and that it did not occur solely due to the truck driver's rash and negligent driving?
  3. What is the quantum of compensation to which the petitioner is entitled and from which of the respondents?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The compensation awarded for loss of earnings (Rs. 50,000/-, computed at Rs.10 per day and a multiplier of 14) is unjust and incorrect; the Tribunal erred in taking Rs.10/- per day as average earnings.
  • The claimant's evidence shows variable higher earnings: Rs. 40-45/- per day for about four months, Rs. 30/- per day during sugarcane season, and Rs. 15-20/- per day otherwise. An average of at least Rs.20-25/- per day should be used; multiplier should be higher (the counsel even suggested '18').
  • The Tribunal undervalued medical expenses and conveyance charges: the claimant was hospitalized for about three months and incurred about Rs.10,000/- for treatment and nourishment and about Rs.2,200-2,500/- for conveyance; the Tribunal's Rs.5,000/- award for medical expenses is insufficient.
  • Amounts awarded for pain and suffering (Rs.10,000/-) and loss of amenities (Rs.10,000/-) are insufficient and should be increased, at least doubled according to the appellant.
  • The appellant sought the full amount claimed (Rs.3,50,000/-) or, at minimum, substantial enhancement of various heads.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondents contested the appellant's earnings evidence as exaggerated; the claimant's daily income could not have exceeded Rs.15/- per day.
  • The awards for pain and suffering (Rs.10,000/-) and loss of amenities (Rs.10,000/-) are reasonable and do not require enhancement.
  • Conveyance expenses claimed lack documentary proof.
  • If any interference is warranted, it should be limited to the head of loss of earnings only; otherwise the Tribunal's overall award (Rs.75,000/-) is just and proper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jyothsna Dey v. State of Assam, 1987 ACJ 172 SC The Supreme Court observation that span of life should be taken as 70 years in view of increased expectancy of life. The court referenced this authority when discussing life expectancy; however, the court ultimately treated expectancy at 60 years (resulting in about 28–30 remaining working years for a 32-year-old claimant) for its calculations.
Concord of India Insurance Company Limited v. Smt. Nirmala Devi, 1979 4 SCC 365 The Supreme Court's observation that determination of compensation quantum must be liberal, not niggardly, because the law values life and limb in generous scales. The court invoked this principle to justify a more liberal (enhanced) award for permanent disability and lifelong suffering, rejecting a niggardly approach to assessment.
Pushpa Thakur v. Union of India, 1984 ACJ 559 SC In an amputation case the Supreme Court enhanced compensation from Rs.50,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/-. The court relied on this decision as supportive precedent when enhancing the award for future loss of earnings (awarding Rs.1,10,000/- for that head), noting similarity in permanent disability (amputation) context.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the Tribunal's findings and the evidence, applying established principles regarding assessment of compensation in permanent disability cases:

  1. The Tribunal's primary findings (accident due solely to respondents' negligent driving; no contributory negligence by the claimant) were accepted and form the factual basis for compensation enhancement.
  2. The court emphasised the need for a liberal approach in assessing compensation for permanent disabilities, invoking the Supreme Court's direction that assessment must not be niggardly (Concord of India Insurance Co.).
  3. On life expectancy, the court noted the Supreme Court's observation in Jyothsna Dey that span of life may be taken as 70 years, but for purposes of this case the court applied an expectancy of 60 years, yielding roughly 28–30 years of future disability for a claimant found to be 32 years old.
  4. For loss of future earnings the court analysed the claimant's own testimony (P.W.1) about variable wages: Rs.40–45/- per day for about four months, Rs.30/- per day in the sugarcane season, and Rs.15–20/- per day generally. The court adopted an average daily income of Rs.20/-, producing an annual loss of Rs.7,300/-. The court applied a multiplier of 15 (instead of the Tribunal's 14) to account for future years, resulting in an enhanced figure of around Rs.1,09,500/-, rounded and awarded as Rs.1,10,000/- for loss of earnings.
  5. The court marginally increased awards for pain and suffering and loss of amenities from Rs.10,000/- each to Rs.12,500/- each, stating the original amounts required a marginal increase.
  6. The court accepted that conveyance expenditure to and from hospital had been incurred and increased an award for this head to Rs.2,500/-, noting the Tribunal had not considered this part of P.W.1's evidence.
  7. Medical expenses were enhanced from Rs.5,000/- to Rs.7,500/-, to include assistance, attendance and nourishment expenses not accounted for by the Tribunal.
  8. The court summed the enhanced heads to a total of Rs.1,45,000/-, noted the interim payment of Rs.7,500/- already paid is adjustable (deductible), and ordered balance payment of Rs.1,37,500/-. The court increased interest from 6% (as previously awarded) to 9% from the date of appeal until payment.
  9. The court clarified the insurer's policy liability is limited to Rs.1,50,000/-; any amount beyond the policy limit is recoverable from the truck owner and the insurer need not indemnify such excess.
  10. The court awarded the costs of the Court below to the claimant; appellate costs were described in the order (the text states "the cost of appeal in this Court are made easy").

Holding and Implications

Final Ruling: The appeal was partly allowed and disposed of accordingly.

The court revised the compensation award as follows:

  • For loss of earnings (present and future): Rs. 1,10,000/-
  • For pain and suffering: Rs. 12,500/-
  • For loss of amenities: Rs. 12,500/-
  • For conveyance charges: Rs. 2,500/-
  • For medical expenses (including assistance, nourishment, attendance): Rs. 7,500/-
  • Total awarded: Rs. 1,45,000/- (inclusive of general and special damages)
  • Less interim payment already made: Rs. 7,500/-
  • Balance payable to claimant: Rs. 1,37,500/- with interest at 9% from the date of appeal until payment.

Additional directions and implications:

  • The insurer's maximum liability under the policy is clarified at Rs. 1,50,000/-; any amount not covered by the policy may be recovered from the truck owner.
  • The costs of the Court below are awarded to the claimant; appellate costs are addressed in the order (as noted in the opinion).

On broader legal implications: the opinion applies and relies on Supreme Court principles advocating a liberal approach to compensation in permanent disability and references prior authority for life expectancy and the need for liberal awards. The judgment does not purport to create new precedent beyond its application of those principles to the facts of this case; its direct effect is the enhancement of the claimant's award and the procedural directions summarized above.

    Ramu Kallappa Kiwada Alias Kiwadyagol v. U. Ramadas Naik And Others

    1. This appeal under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, has been preferred by the claimant-appellant, from the judgment and award dated 11-9-1991 and the grievance of the appellant is that the compensation awarded to him is unjust and too meagre and insufficient.

    2. The facts of the case in brief are that, on 23-12-1988 injuries were caused to the claimant-appellant in the accident, that according to the claimant-appellant, occurred on account of rash and negligent driving of the truck bearing registration No. MEG 7669 driven by the respondent 1 and belonging to the respondent 2 and insured by the respondent 3. The accident occured on 23-12-1988 at 17-30 hours (5.30 p.m) at Poona-Bangalore Road near Hitni cross in village Kanagala. The claimant's case has been that, as a result of the occurrence, the claimant suffered injuries including fractures of collar bone and right leg as well as resulting in amputation of his left leg from knee. The claimant's case has been that on account of these injuries the claimant has been permanently disable. In the claim petition it was averred that the age of the claimant at the time of the occurrence was 30 years and immediately earlier to the occurrence or incident the claimant was healthy and used to work as a coolie worker and was earning Rs. 30/- to Rs. 40/- per day. But, on account of the injuries and amputation of his left leg, he has become permanently disabled to do any work and his future life has become miserable and the life of members of his family has also become miserable. So the claimant claim compensation to the tune of Rs. 3,50,000/-. On notice being issued, the objections were filed by the respondent 3 i.e, the Insurance Company and the respondents 1 and 2 have adopted the objections of the respondent 3. The respondent 3 in his reply took a plea that there has been contributory negligence on the part of the claimant as he was careless and negligent while carrying the fodder on his head. A further plea that was taken is to the effect that the amount claimed is excessive and exorbitant. In the additional objections, the respondent 3 i.e, the Insurance Company contended that the liability, if any, under the policy is to the tune of Rs. 1,50,000/- and if the Tribunal comes to the conclusion that this respondent is liable to pay any amount of compensation, the maximum liability of respondent 3 is up to Rs. 1,50,000/-. The Tribunal framed the following three issues:—

    1. Whether the petitioner proves that he sustained personal injuries in an accident that occurred on 23-12-1988 due to the rash and negligent driving of the truck MEG 7669 driven by respondent 1?

    Whether the respondents prove that the petitioner has also contributed to the accident and that the accident did not occur solely due to the rash and negligent driving of the truck?

    2. What is the quantum of compensation to which the petitioner is entitled and from which of the respondents?

    3. What Order?

    3. In support of his claim, the petitioner filed the evidence and examined himself in evidence. Ex. P-1 to P-17 are the documentary evidence furnished on behalf of the claimant. On behalf of the respondents, no evidence has been adduced. It is only the Insurance Policy that has been filed and has been marked as Ex. D-1 by the consent of the parties.

    4. The Tribunal recorded the following findings:—

    (1) That the accident occurred solely due to the rash and negligent driving of the truck No. MEG 7669 which was driven by the respondent 1-U. Ramadas Naik, driver of the truck, owned by respondent 2 and insured by respondent 3.

    (2) That the respondents failed to prove any contributory negligence on the part of the claimant.

    5. Thus having considered and recorded the findings, the Tribunal further held that the nature of the injuries sustained by the claimant-petitioner reveal that he is permanently handicapped and he has to lead a crippled life. It has also held that there is permanent disfigurement and the injured i.e, the claimant has now to use crutches for movements and there is future pecuniary loss also. The Tribunal awarded the compensation as under:—

    For pecuniary loss — Rs. 50,000-00 Towards medical treatment and other expenses — Rs. 5,000-00 For pain and suffering — Rs. 10,000-00 For loss of amenities — Rs. 10,000-00

    6. Thus, in total, the Tribunal found that Rs. 75,000/- would be just and reasonable compensation payable to the claimant. It further found that a sum of Rs. 7,500/- had already been paid towards interim compensation. So that sum is adjustable and deductable from the sum of Rs. 75,000/-. Thus, according to the Tribunal, finally the amount payable to the claimant would be Rs. 67,500/-.

    7. Having felt aggrieved from this judgment and award and feeling that the compensation awarded is inadequate and insufficient, the claimant has come up with an appeal before this Court.

    8. I have heard Smt. Sona Vakkund, learned Counsel for the appellant, and Sri Chikkeurs, learned Counsel for respondents 2 and 3.

    9. Smt. Sona Vakkund, learned Counsel for the appellant, submitted that the compensation that has been awarded to the tune of Rs. 50,000/- for loss of earnings at the rate of Rs. 10/- per day i.e, Rs. 3,600/- per year multiplied by ‘14’ is not just or correct. The learned Counsel submitted that the learned Judge or the Member of the Tribunal was not justified in taking the average earnings of the claimant to be Rs. 10/- per day. The learned Counsel has taken me through the evidence to indicate that for the first four months he use to earns Rs. 40-45/- per day, then for subsequent period i.e, during the sugarcane cutting season he used to get labour charge at Rs. 30/- per day and during other days he earns Rs. 15-20/- per day. The learned Counsel submitted that there is no scaling down of his earning to Rs. 10/- per day. He submitted that in every case if income has to be put to an average per day, it should not have been less than Rs. 25/- or Rs. 20/- per days multiplier of ‘14’ is very low. The learned Counsel submitted that at least when the life span has been increased to 60 years, the person will have to carry the malady of disability caused and the malady of disfigurement for whole life, for almost thirty years or twenty-eight years, as the Court has found that the claimant was of 32 years, then even up to 60 years he has to carry the malady of disfigurement as well as disability caused on account of amputation of his one leg and fracture of other leg and so in every case the multiplier of ‘18’ should be applied for. The learned Counsel for the petitioner contended that the evidence on record per se discloses that a sum of Rs. 2,200/- or more has been spent by the claimant on conveyance charges, to and from the hospital and for visiting three to four times as well. It may go up, but the evidence shows that Rs. 2,500/- has been spent towards the conveyance charges. Smt. Sona Vakkund further submitted that the medical expenditure which has been awarded to the tune of Rs. 5,000/- is also insufficient. The claimant has been hospitalised for almost three months and as per the deposition on oath, the claimant has incurred expenditure to the tune of Rs. 10,000/- for medical treatment and nourishment. The learned Counsel further submitted that the sums awarded to the tune of Rs. 10,000/- towards pain and suffering as well as Rs. 10,000/- towards loss of amenities of life are also insufficient. She submitted that at least double of the amount should have awarded under the head “loss of amenities as well as for pain and suffering”. The learned Counsel submitted that the claimant has been entitled to the compensation to the extent he claimed.

    10. These contentions of the learned Counsel for the appellant have been hotly contested by Sri B. Chikkeurs, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of respondents 2 and 3. The learned Counsel submitted that, no doubt it may be urged that the calculations of loss of earnings at the rate of Rs. 10/- may be said to be too meagre, but, there is exaggeration in the evidence of P.W 1. His daily income could not be more than Rs. 15/- per day. The learned Counsel further submitted that with reference to the pain and suffering Rs. 10,000/- has been awarded. It is just and proper and it does not require enhancement. He also submitted that for loss of amenities the Tribunal has awarded Rs. 10,000/- and that amount appears to be reasonable and just and proper and it does not call for any interference. The learned Counsel submitted no doubt there is something in the statement of P.W 1 that a sum of Rs. 2,000/- has been spent on conveyance, but there is no documentary proof thereof. The learned Counsel for the respondents finally submitted that the total compensation awarded i.e, Rs. 75,000/- appears to be just and proper or if at all it requires enhancement it may be only with respect to loss of earnings as the Tribunal has assessed petitioner's earnings at Rs. 10/- per day and Rs. 3,600/- per year multiplied by ‘14’. Otherwise, the order of the Tribunal is well and justified.

    11. I have applied my mind to the contentions made by the learned Counsel for the parties, and have been taken through the records. The person who suffers disability on account of injuries, total or partial disabilities, carry those disabilities for their whole life. They will be subjected to suffering for the whole life from the date of occurrence till their death. Span of life is also assessed at 60 to 70 years as have been found by the Supreme Court in the case of Jyothsna Dey v. State of Assam . 1987 ACJ 172 SC.. That the Supreme Court has been pleased to observe that the span of life should be 70 years in view of the high raise in expectancy of life. In the case of Concord of India Insurance Company Limited v. Smt. Nirmala Devi . 1979 4 SCC 365, the Supreme Court observed that the determination of the quantum must be liberal, not niggardly since the law values life and limb in free country in generous scales. We have to keep in mind that the person who suffers such a disability as amputation of leg which is a permanent disability or fracture of other bones resulting in disfigurement or the like they have to bear it for their whole life with the malady caused by disability or disfigurement and in such matter and while assessing the compensation, a liberal approach is needed and more liberal than in cases where injuries results in death because injured has to suffer for few days in hospital and he has to suffer the malady for whole of life. Keeping these basic principles in view, in my opinion, the compensation that has been awarded appears to be insufficient and too meagre. As regards the loss of earnings, three factors have to be taken into consideration. Firstly, the age of the petitioner at the time of occurrence and as per the finding of the Tribunal the petitioner was of 32 years, while according to him as given age in the petition he was of 30 years. I take 32 years to be the age of the petitioner as determined by the Tribunal that at the time of occurrence he was of 32 years. As expectancy of life is taken to be at least 60 years and not 70 years, the claimant will have to suffer and bear the malady of disability for at least 28 to 30 years. Keeping the evidence of P.W 1 regarding his earnings that for about four months he used to earn at the rate of Rs. 40-45/- per day and later during sugarcane crushing season he used to get Rs. 30/- per day and thereafter during general season his earnings would be running between Rs. 15-20/- per day, I take average income of the claimant at Rs. 20/- per day. Rs. 20/- per day will bring out the yearly loss to be Rs. 7,300/- per year. If the multiplier instead of ‘14’ being applied, I think it would be proper to apply the multiplier of ‘15’ to the yearly income, then loss of earnings may come to Rs. 1,09,500/- or so. In this view of the matter, in my opinion, the claimant can be said to be entitled to get the compensation to the tune of Rs. 1,10,000/- for loss of earnings instead of Rs. 50,000/- as awarded by the Tribunal. The appellant, as such, is held to be entitled to a sum of Rs. 1,10,000/- as compensation for loss of future earnings. When I so award, I find support also from the view expressed by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of Pushpa Thakur v. Union of India . 1984 ACJ 559 SC., where in cases as amputation of right leg, their Lordships of the Supreme Court enhanced the compensation from Rs. 50,000/- to Rs. 1,00,000/-. So award of Rs. 1,10,000/- towards compensation for loss of earnings on that account appears to be justified. As regards pain and suffering the compensation which has been awarded to the tune of Rs. 10,000/- requires a marginal increase and so marginal increase is required with reference to loss of amenities. Instead of Rs. 10,000/- under each of the accounts, I think it would be proper to award the compensation to the tune of Rs. 12,500/- for pain and suffering and Rs. 12,500/- for loss of amenities. The evidence of P.W 1 discloses that he had incurred an expenditure of more than Rs. 2,000/- for the conveyance as the claimant had to move to and from the hospital at times again and the Tribunal has not taken into consideration this aspect of the matter nor this part of the evidence of P.W 1. I think it would be just and proper to award Rs. 2,500/- as compensation for expenditure towards conveyance and other charges incurred in taking to hospital etc. for times again. With reference to medical expenditure simply the Court has awarded Rs. 5,000/- but has not taken the question of assistance or attendance which was provided to the claimant and that of his nourishment also.

    12. In such a case, I think it is proper to enhance the amount of compensation with reference to medical expenses, nourishment and attendance expenditure to the tune of Rs. 7,500/- instead of Rs. 5,000/-. Thus, the total amount of compensation the claimant is entitled to is as under:—

    For loss of earnings (present and future) — Rs. 1,10,000-00 For pain and suffering — Rs. 12,500-00 For loss of amenities — Rs. 12,500-00 For conveyance charges (i.e to and from hospital) — Rs. 2,500-00 For medical expenses (towards assistance, nourishment etc.) — Rs. 7,500-00 —————— Thus in Total — Rs. 1,45,000-00 ——————

    13. This figure of Rs. 1,45,000-00 includes in itself the general and special damages. The sum that had been paid in advance to the tune of Rs. 7,500/- will be adjustable, that it shall be deductable from that amount. The interest that has been awarded at the rate of 6% appears to be very low and it appears to be proper to make it 9%. Now the claimant is entitled to a sum of Rs. 1,37,500/-, as the balance payable to the claimant, with interest at the rate of 9% from the date of appeal up to date. The cost of the Court below shall also be payable to the claimant, but the cost of appeal in this Court are made easy. It is also clarified that the liability of the Insurance Company is Rs. 1,50,000/- in all. The amount not covered by the policy shall in every case be recoverable from the owner of the truck and the company may not be required to indemnify that amount.

    14. The appeal is finally disposed of as partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramu Kallappa Kiwada Alias Kiwadyagol v. U. Ramadas Naik And Others
    (Dec 2, 1996)