AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act
  • Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act
  • Section 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  • Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act
  • Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act
  • Section 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  • Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This dispute arises between Krone Communication Ltd. (respondent) and Mr. M.L. Thukral (appellant), a director of Sterling Transtel Ltd. Sterling is the main distributor for telecommunication products manufactured by Krone under a distributorship agreement originally for three years which was extended in practice. The appellant claims to be a promoter-director and an 11% shareholder of Krone and challenges the management of Krone alleging, inter alia, unjustified repatriation of large amounts of money and conduct amounting to mismanagement. He filed a petition under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act before the Company Law Board (CLB).

The appellant sought interim relief from the CLB restraining Krone (and its Board) from terminating the distributorship agreement with Sterling. The CLB, by an interim order dated 1-2-1995, refused that interim relief on the ground that the dispute over the distributorship agreement was outside the ambit of Sections 397 and 398, but it granted inspection and advanced the hearing of the main petition to 27-3-1995. The appellant appealed that interim order to this Court, seeking, among other things, an order restraining the Board of Directors from deciding to terminate the distributorship agreement.

The present opinion addresses that appeal, the CLB's decision not to exercise jurisdiction over the distributorship dispute, and whether this Court should restrain the Board from acting in relation to the distributorship agreement pending the CLB proceedings. Following hearing, the appeal was dismissed and the CLB's position was upheld; after judgment the respondents agreed to defer any steps they contemplated for two weeks and that statement was recorded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Company Law Board (CLB) had jurisdiction under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act to entertain and grant relief concerning the termination of an external distributorship agreement between the company (Krone) and a distributor (Sterling), where the relief sought primarily protects the distributor's commercial interests.
  2. Whether this Court should intervene by restraining the Board of Directors of Krone from taking a decision to terminate the distributorship agreement pending the CLB's hearing of the petition.
  3. Whether a person who is both a shareholder/director of a company and a party with separate commercial interests (dual status) can invoke Sections 397/398 to protect non-company business interests that would be affected by corporate decisions.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced through Mr. Ganesh)

  • The appellant alleged gross mismanagement by Krone's Board and Managing Director, including unjustified large-scale repatriation of funds and exclusion of the appellant from information and decision-making, amounting to oppression and mismanagement under Sections 397/398.
  • Sterling was the principal distributor and had produced substantial sales growth; termination of the distributorship would cause severe loss (claimed to be very large and to affect jobs of 300 employees), and would be a vindictive response to the appellant's complaint to the CLB.
  • The appellant sought interim relief to restrain termination of the distributorship pending CLB adjudication, arguing that judicial intervention was necessary to prevent oppressive consequences and to protect joint-venture-like interests.
  • Reliance was placed on a Division Bench decision (M/S Synchron Machine Tools Private Ltd. v. U.M. Suresh Rao, 1994 79 Company Cases 868), on Ramaiya's commentary on the Companies Act, and on equitable principles illustrated by Westbourne Galleries — all to support the proposition that courts have wide powers to craft just and equitable interim reliefs in oppression/mismanagement petitions.

Respondent's Arguments (as advanced through Mr. Ashok Desai)

  • The dispute over termination of the distributorship agreement is extraneous to the reliefs available under Sections 397/398 because it principally concerns the contractual/business relationship between Krone and Sterling and not the internal corporate governance rights of the appellant qua shareholder/director.
  • The allegations of oppression/exclusion were denied; the appellant remains a director and no vindictive actions had yet been taken.
  • Civil courts (and by analogy the CLB) should not adjudicate on the wisdom of terminating a distributorship; reliance was placed on Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Amritsar Gas Service (1991 1 SCC 533) which disapproved interference with distributorship/arbitration matters by civil courts.
  • Authorities such as Re JE Cade & Son Ltd. and a Butterworths Company Law case were cited to support the proposition that a member cannot use company-oppression remedies to protect interests that are distinct from the member's rights in the company.
  • The Board of Directors is presumed to act in the company's best interests, and the decision whether to terminate a distributorship is a matter within its discretion unless and until the CLB orders otherwise in the main petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M/S Synchron Machine Tools Private Ltd. v. U.M. Suresh Rao, 1994 79 Company Cases 868 Courts have wide powers to grant just and equitable reliefs in cases of oppression and mismanagement; such reliefs may be moulded to suit the circumstances. The appellant relied on this decision to argue for interim protection. The Court recorded the reliance but found the principle inapplicable to the distributorship issue because that issue was extraneous to Sections 397/398.
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Amritsar Gas Service, 1991 1 SCC 533 Disapproval of civil court interference with matters of distributorship/arbitration; courts should not sit in judgment over such contractual/commercial decisions where other fora or principles apply. The respondent relied on this decision; the Court agreed that it was not appropriate to interfere with the Board's decision on distributorship and that civil adjudication of that commercial decision is unsuitable in the present context.
Re JE Cade & Son Ltd. (Chancery Division) Where the interests sought to be protected are different from the petitioner's interests as a member of the company, it is not permissible to consider the petition under company-oppression remedies. The respondent relied on this authority to support the CLB's refusal; the Court accepted the reasoning as supporting refusal to exercise jurisdiction over a dispute protecting non-company business interests.
Butterworths Company Law (reported case referred to in the opinion) Relief under company-oppression provisions is declined where a member seeks to protect interests distinct from his rights as a member. Relied upon by the respondent; the Court treated this as corroborative authority for the proposition that the distributorship dispute was outside Sections 397/398.
Westbourne Galleries (case cited by appellant) Equitable considerations may support relief where a party in a joint venture or similar arrangement is unfairly excluded from participation in major decisions. The appellant invoked this case to argue for interim protection. The Court noted the reliance but concluded the distributorship issue was separable and extraneous to the company-oppression petition, and therefore Westbourne Galleries did not warrant intervention here.
Ramaiya's Commentary on the Companies Act (textbook) Commentary noting that excluding a joint venture participant from major decisions can be unfairly prejudicial. The appellant relied on selected passages. The Court recorded the reliance but did not find it sufficient to extend Sections 397/398 to protect the separate distributorship interests of Sterling.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning addressed primarily the narrow question whether the CLB was justified in refusing to exercise jurisdiction over the distributorship dispute and whether this Court should prevent the Board from deciding to terminate the distributorship agreement.

Key steps in the Court's analysis, stated as found in the opinion:

  1. The Court emphasised the prophylactic and supervisory nature of Sections 397 and 398 — they are directed to prevention of oppression and mismanagement within the company and are intended to protect rights that relate to the company itself. The forum must be circumspect because allegations in such petitions are often false or motivated.
  2. The Court accepted the factual premise that the appellant has a dual status: a shareholder/director of Krone and a director/interested party in Sterling (the distributor). The Court considered whether a person with such dual status may invoke company-oppression remedies to protect the separate commercial interests of the distributor.
  3. The Court held that the relief sought by the appellant — protecting Sterling from termination of its distributorship agreement — related exclusively to anticipated loss to Sterling and not to the appellant's rights qua shareholder or director of Krone. Sections 397/398 are circumscribed to situations where the interest concerned is in relation to the company itself.
  4. The Court accepted that the distributorship matter had been cleverly interwoven into the petition, but concluded that it was distinctly separable and therefore properly excluded from the CLB's jurisdiction under the company-oppression provisions.
  5. The Court further reasoned that even if the Board's decision to terminate the distributorship were erroneous, the composite dispute was pending before the CLB and that forum remained competent to direct corrective action in due course; it would not be appropriate for this Court to pre-emptively restrain the Board on the present record.
  6. The Court reviewed the authorities and commentary relied upon by both sides: while recognising that courts have broad equitable powers in appropriate cases (Synchron, Westbourne Galleries, Ramaiya), and that members should be protected from unfair exclusion, the Court found those principles inapplicable to a dispute that principally concerned separate contractual/distributorship interests outside the corporate interest of Krone.

On these bases, the Court concluded that the CLB was justified in refusing to exercise jurisdiction in respect of the distributorship agreement and that no interference via this appeal was warranted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal fails and is dismissed. The Court upheld the CLB's decision that the CLB should not exercise jurisdiction under Sections 397 and 398 in respect of the dispute concerning the distributorship agreement between Krone and Sterling.

Implications and direct effects as stated in the opinion:

  • The CLB's exclusion of the distributorship dispute from the scope of Sections 397/398 is affirmed: relief under those sections is limited to matters affecting the interests in the company itself and does not extend to protecting separate commercial interests of third-party businesses (here, Sterling) even where the petitioner has a dual status.
  • The Board of Directors retains the discretion to decide on the distributorship; this Court declined to restrain the Board from acting. If the Board acts and a grievance remains, the CLB (in the main petition) remains the appropriate forum to consider corrective measures in due course.
  • No order as to costs was made in favor of either party; the appeal was dismissed without costs.
  • Post-judgment, the respondents stated they would defer any steps they contemplated for a period of two weeks; that statement was recorded by the Court.
  • The opinion confined its decision to the particular question of CLB jurisdiction over the distributorship issue and did not purport to enlarge Sections 397/398 beyond their company-focused scope; the Court did not indicate the setting of a novel broad principle beyond applying existing authorities to the facts at hand.

This summary has been prepared exclusively from the text of the provided opinion. No information beyond that opinion has been added or inferred.

    M.L Thukral And Others v. Krone Communication Limited, Bangalore And Others

    1. An unusual dimension of the law in relation to Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act has arisen in this case. Chapter VI of the Act basically deals with cleansing action or, more correctly defined, with the supervisory powers of the Company Law Board directed towards maintenance of purity of administration and functioning of a company which is why, the chapter has rightly been titled ‘Prevention of Oppression & Mismanagement’. A member of the Company is entitled to apply for relief in cases of oppression and similarly, in cases of mismanagement. What is important is that the section deal with the concept of preventive action essentially in order to forestall the damaging effects of such wrongful activity. In this regard therefore, it is essential that the legislative intent namely that the relief should be prophylactic rather than curative requires to be emphasised. While considering pleas of this type, the Co. Law Board and the court will have to be extremely circumspect because allegations are often false, exaggerated, misconceived, contrived or mischievous and in those of the cases where this appears to be the position such complaints will have to be shot down as often times, the genesis of such complaints is motivated. Similarly, the forum before which such a complaint is made must be on guard and just as in appropriate cases it is necessary to pierce the veil of the Company, while dealing with this category of cases, it is equally essential to sift out the chaff from the grain and ascertain the true nature and genuineness of the complaint and more importantly, whether it qualifies for a relief or action under Sections 397 or 398. In this regard, the real issue posed is as to whether, in a case where a share holder or for that matter a director seeks a relief in relation to a dispute and a grievance that is totally and completely extraneous to the fair exercise of his rights under Section 397 and 398 of the Companies Act. Whether at all the Co. Law Board would have jurisdiction to entertain such a complaint howsoever adroitly it may be presented or interlinked and intertwined with other issues that may come within the ambit of Chapter VI. The answer is undisputedly no.

    2. This appeal assails the correctness of an interim order dated 1-2-1995 passed by the Company Law Board (hereinafter referred to as ‘CLB’), Prl. Bench, New Delhi. The dispute basically is one between Mr. Krone Communication Ltd. and Mr. M.L Thukral who is a Director of a Company by the name of Sterling Transtel Limited. The latter company is the main distributor of the telecommunication products manufactured by Krone Ltd. The present appellant claims to be a promoter Director of the company and it is his case that the entire venture was started as a joint venture between the Germans and him. Pursuant to the setting up of the company, Sterling has been marketing its products under a distributorship agreement which was valid initially for a period of 3 years but which has been extended. Under the terms of the agreement, Krone is required to give six months' notice if the agreement is to be terminated. The appellant has, as will be indicated below, filed a petition under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act before the C.L.B wherein he has made serious allegations in respect of the manner in which the company is being managed inter alia to the effect that abnormally large amounts of money have been unjustifiably repatriated outside the country and according to the appellant, because of this action, a decision is imminent whereby the distributorship agreement will be terminated. He had applied for interim reliefs to the C.L.B and the same have been rejected on the ground that the nature of the dispute is outside the scope of Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act and it is against this order that the present appeal has been filed. In support of the appeal, Mr. Ganesh, on behalf of the appellant took me through certain relevant parts of the record. He sought to demonstrate that effectively, the business being carried on by the company was initially conceived of as a joint venture in so far as the appellant possesses not only certain expertise in relation to the telecommunication products in question but is also well acquainted with equipment for distribution of these products in the Indian market. With this background, Mr. Ganesh submitted that the appellant is a 11% share holder and that he was, right from the very inception not only a Director of the company but was instrumental in achieving impressive results as far as the sales are concerned through his company Sterling Transtel Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as ‘Sterling’) which was the main distributor for the products in question. Mr. Ganesh thereafter pointed out to me, on the basis of figures that the sales through Sterling had increased from 1990 when the figure showed approximately Rs. 9 Million to Rs. 93 Millions in 1994. He also relied on certain extracts from the records of the respondent company Krone to indicate that the performance of the appellant and Sterling had been very much appreciated by the Board of Directors. According to Mr. Ganesh, in the month of June 1994 he was required to file a composite petition before the C.L.B asking for certain reliefs. Principally, the appellant had contended that several decisions and Acts on the part of the Board of Directors of the company, and the Managing Director individually, were not in the interest of the company and that they could be construed as indication of gross mismanagement. The appellant had also contended that the Board of Directors of the company is not correctly constituted and that consequently, he as a minority director was virtually being sidelined. Another charge was that several of the decisions were being taken without these matters having been formally referred to the Board and even in those instances when such a reference was made for decision, that the result was a foregone conclusion, because of the lopsided nature of the Board. Even though the appellant was still a Director of the Company, relevant information and document on crucial issues was either not supplied to him or, worse that he was kept in the dark in respect of other important developments. The appellant had basically made out a case of mismanagement and he therefore sought for appropriate reliefs from the C.L.B It is material to mention here that in the original petition filed before the C.L.B, one of the reliefs asked for is that the non-exclusive distributorship agreement between the appellant's company Sterling and Krone should not be terminated. I need to record in passing that this agreement was for a period of 3 years which have elapsed in the year 1994 and that according to Mr. Ganesh, the record will demonstrate that it was to be renewed and that it was only because of his complaint to the C.L.B that it is very clear that the same will be terminated. Even though the agreement in question was not formally renewed, it is still in operation and is being acted upon by the parties as the same has been extended and for that matter not formally terminated. In sum and substance, among other things, the company will be required to give the appellant a clear six months notice under the terms of that agreement which will be effective on and from the date on which the decision is taken to terminate the agreement.

    3. Mr. Ganesh submitted that he is entitled to invoke the provisions of Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act in so far as the facts of this case will indicate that the company and its directors and in particular, the Managing Director have, never hit back at the appellant who has approached the legally constituted authority for corrective action, and that they have virtually decided to use an arm twisting approach by terminating the distributorship agreement. According to Mr. Ganesh, Sterling is the best known and the most important distributor for these products and that such a step would be disastrous to the interest of the company. Despite this according to him the action in question is being contemplated and he alleges serious mala fides on the part of the respondents because he submits that in the background of the impressive record of Sterling, that it is more than crystal clear that the interests of the company are being sacrificed in order to take a revenge against the appellant. A strong plea was made that any such action must be stayed as otherwise, nobody would be able to apply for legal redress.

    4. It is unnecessary for this Court to go into the areas of dispute because the petition is pending before the C.L.B and was scheduled to be heard in the month of May, 1995. The appellant made an urgent application to the C.L.B for interim orders whereupon, after hearing the parties the C.L.B passed an order dated 1-2-1995 rejecting the prayer of the applicant that the Board of Directors should be restrained from taking a decision in relation to the distributorship agreement between the company and Sterling. The C.L.B however granted the application for inspection etc. and advanced the hearing of the main petition to 27th March, 1995. In sum and substance, the C.L.B upheld the position that the dispute in relation to the distributorship agreement was outside the ambit and scope of Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act and therefore refused to exercise jurisdiction in respect thereof. However, since the decision is to be taken by the Board of Directors and the appellant had questioned the validity of the constitution of the Board, it was directed that whatever decision is taken, would be subject to final orders that the C.L.B would pass in the main case. It is against this order that the present appeal has been filed.

    5. An urgent application was made to this Court by Mr. Ganesh that it is virtually a matter of life and death, as far as his client is concerned, which sentiment unfortunately I do not share and very grave urgency was pleaded that the court must take up this matter on a top priority basis and hear it. Accordingly, the meeting of the Board of Directors which was to be held on 6-2-1995 was directed to be postponed and the petition was listed for urgent hearing.

    6. It is necessary to confine this decision to limited aspect of the case namely the short question as to whether the C.L.B was justified in having refused to exercise jurisdiction in respect of the distributorship agreement and more importantly, if the refusal was unjustified, whether this Court should stop the Board of Directors from taking a decision in this regard. As far as this last aspect of the matter is concerned, I need to observe that the appellant's charges are still in the realm of allegations and have yet to be established. The appellant goes to the extent of alleging bias on the part of the directors and he contends that having regard to the charges made by him that it is a foregone conclusion that they will decide in favour of terminating the agreement. The appellant is not only the minority director but a party interested and he therefore submits that there is virtually nothing he can do with regard to the distributorship matter in these circumstances except approaching a legal forum for reliefs. Mr. Ganesh also submitted that quite apart from the excellent track record of Sterling, that it would be a loss running into virtually crores of Rupees because the entire infrastructure and the jobs of 300 employees of his client's company are at stake. He also advanced a strong plea that this Court should direct that the decision should be deferred until the C.L.B hears the petition next month on 27-3-1995. In this regard he submitted that in any event, the six months notice period has yet to run but if the decision were to be taken, the moment it comes to be known in the market, that it would have ruinous consequences to the appellants. Mr. Ganesh places reliance on an Division Bench decision of the court in the case of M/S Synchron Machine Tools Private Ltd. v. U.M Suresh Rao* . 1994 79 Company Cases 868.. The principle enunciated in that case were to the effect that in the face of allegations of oppression and mismanagement and a petition filed for reliefs, that the court had sufficiently wide powers to grant just and equitable reliefs, which require to be moulded to suit the circumstances of the case. On an analogy, Mr. Ganesh submitted that this was a most deserving case in which a director who has complained about gross mismanagement should be protected from oppressive consequences that are sought to be visited on him. He contended that it was wrong on the part of the C.L.B to have refused an interim order and that this Court therefore ought to intervene. He also relied on certain passages from Ramaiya's commentary on the Companies Act at pages 2229 and 2230 in support of his contention that excluding a joint venture from participating in all major decisions affecting the company's affairs has been recorded as unfairly prejudicial. In this regard, he relied on the well known decision in Westbourne Galleries Case2, where the court amplified the aspect of equitable considerations. Basically, what the learned counsel has submitted is that in a situation of a joint venture business, a total and unfair exclusion of one of the parties is a sufficient cause of action calling for corrective steps. In totality therefore he submitted that judicial intervention at this point of time is fully justified.

    7. Opposing the grant of any reliefs, Mr. Ashok Desai on behalf of the respondents, submitted that the principles laid down in the Synchron case referred to supra will have no application whatsoever as far as the present proceeding is concerned because the present dispute relates to only one aspect of the proceeding pending before the C.L.B namely the termination of the distributorship agreement which is an issue completely extraneous to the main dispute. Mr. Desai submitted that the allegations of oppression and exclusions which have been levelled against the respondents have been denied, that even as of today the appellant is very much a director of the company and that no vindictive actions have been taken against him. That issue however is within the ambit of the proceedings before the C.L.B and, the principles enunciated by the courts in the decisions referred to above are totally extraneous to the issue that falls for determination before me. Mr. Desai has also submitted, and with considerable justification that a Civil Court would be precluded from adjudicating upon the wisdom or otherwise to terminate a distributorship agreement and in this regard, he placed reliance on a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Amritsar Gas Service . 1991 1 SCC 533., wherein, the Supreme Court disapproved of a Civil Court having interfered with an arbitration award in the matter of a distributorship agreement. Mr. Desai submitted that it is for the Board of Directors to decide as to who should distribute the products of the company and the terms and conditions thereof and he drew my attention to the reply filed by the company wherein it is pointed out that the company was contemplating the termination of the agreement principally because it would be far more beneficial to the financial interest of the company and would affect a saving of as much as Rs. 1.5 Crores. This position has been disputed by Mr. Ganesh but I need to record that the Board of Directors of a limited company in particular are required to act in the best interests of a company and it is presumed that they are doing so until the contrary is established. This Court is not even required to adjudicate on that question because the step has so far not been taken and also because the entire dispute is yet to be heard by the C.L.B This Court is however required to decide as to whether it is required to exercise jurisdiction in a matter of the present type and whether it would be right in doing so. The principles laid down in the Indian Oil Case very clearly mandate that it would not be appropriate for a court to sit in judgment over a decision of this type because there are several aspects of the matter that are involved and which are relevant including the fact as rightly pointed out by Mr. Desai that where parties are at logger head, the inadvisability of one of them distributing the products is an issue of consequence. I am in agreement with the submissions canvassed by learned counsel therefore that this Court ought not and should not come in the way of the Board of Directors exercising their discretion in this matter. Even if the decision is erroneous, since the composite dispute is pending before the C.L.B, it is open to that forum if it so desires, to direct corrective action.

    8. The real issue as indicated by me earlier centres around the narrow question as to whether the C.L.B was justified in having refused to exercise discretion. In this regard, Mr. Desai relied on a decision of the Chancery Division in Re JE Cade & Son Ltd. wherein under somewhat similar circumstances, the court was concerned with the company or the majority share holder refusing to purchase the minority share holders free hold in a firm and the court laid down the principles that it was not permissible to consider the petition because the interests that were being sought to be protected were entirely different from the petitioner's interests as a member of the company. Mr. Desai also relied on another decision of the Chancery Division reported in Butterwoths Company Law4 cases, wherein the interesting question had arisen in relation to a member of the company seeking to protect other interests and the court in that case declined to grant the reliefs prayed for. Basically, what is submitted by learned counsel is that the termination of the agreement between the company and Sterling has nothing to do with the rights of the appellants in his capacity as a share holder and director of the company and that therefore, the C.L.B was fully justified in having refused to grant the reliefs.

    9. This is a case in which admittedly, the appellant who is a share holder and director of the company also has other business interests. This is perfectly legitimate and is also permissible. The real issue is as to whether in the event of the distributorship agreement being terminated, it may be said that any rights of the appellant in his capacity as share holder and director are being infringed upon. Conversely, it is necessary to examine as to whether the appellant, undoubtedly has a dual status. One as a share holder of Krone and on the other hand as a director of Sterling and, as far as the present appeal is concerned, is desperately interested in protecting the interest of Sterling as he contends, can invoke the special of the C.L.B under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act for this purpose. Since the matter has been fully argued before me, it is incumbent that this Court records a finding on the issue that has been canvassed and I need to observe that even if one were to accept that the appellant has the interest of Krone equallv at heart, the fact remains that the relief asked for by him relates exclusively to the anticipated loss, prejudice or damage that may occur to Sterling. On the pleadings before me, on behalf of the Krone it is contended that the termination of the agreement would benefit the company and its share holders both businesswise and financially. It may be that the appellant does not agree with this appraisal. But it is also clear as was more than evident in the course of Mr. Ganesh's submissions that the appellant is desperately concerned about his business interests in Sterling. That cannot be the subject-matter of an application under Sections 397 or 398 because these sections are circumscribed to situations where the interest in relation to that very company are concerned. To my mind therefore, the C.L.B was more than fully justified in having refused to exercise jurisdiction in respect of the distributorship agreement because it is totally and completely extraneous to the main dispute. I do concede that this aspect of the case has been very cleverly interwoven into the main dispute in order to give it the complexion of being an integral part thereof. It is however distinctly separable and to my mind has been rightly excluded. Having regard to this position, no interference is called for through the present appeal which accordingly fails and stands dismissed. In the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    MFSJ 17-2-1995

    10. After the judgment was pronounced, appellants' learned advocate requested the court to ensure that the status quo is maintained for a period of two weeks in order to enable the appellants' to consider taking further steps in the matter. The position that emerges is that this Court has confirmed the view of the C.L.B that the C.L.B itself had no jurisdiction to pass any orders with regard to this particular part of the dispute namely the distributorship agreement. However, the respondents learned advocate on instructions from his client states that they are agreeable to defer whatever steps the company contemplates for a period of two weeks from today only.

    11. This statement is recorded.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.L Thukral And Others v. Krone Communication Limited, Bangalore And Others
    (Feb 17, 1995)