AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 433(e) and (f) of the Companies Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Court.9. Rule 67 of the Companies Court Rules, 1959,
  • SECTION 391 COMPANIES ACT
  • provision of Section 391(1),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 433(e) and (f) of the Companies Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Court.9. Rule 67 of the Companies Court Rules, 1959,
  • SECTION 391 COMPANIES ACT
  • provision of Section 391(1),
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Company Application No. 873 of 1991 (Kedambady Jagannatha Shetty, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The application was filed under Section 391 of the Companies Act by a shareholder who was also the Managing Director of the respondent company (Bellary Spinning and Weaving Company Limited). The company had previously been ordered to be wound up by this Court by an order dated 19.10.1987/6.11.1987 in Company Petition No. 34 of 1986, under Section 433(e) and (f) of the Companies Act on grounds of inability to pay debts (the Court observed liabilities in excess of Rs. 2.5 crores exclusive of interest). The company appealed that winding-up order in O.S.A. No. 12/1987, which was dismissed.

During the pendency of that appeal the present Section 391 application was filed seeking directions to convene meetings of unsecured creditors and equity shareholders to consider a proposed scheme of arrangement/compromise sponsored by the applicant-propounder. The scheme proposed (inter alia) a lump-sum payment of Rs. 1.5 crores in full and final settlement to the Syndicate Bank (the only secured creditor) and staged payments to various statutory and other creditors in accordance with schedules set out in the proposal. The Syndicate Bank objected to the application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court is bound to direct convening of meetings under Section 391(1) of the Companies Act upon an application for directions, or whether that direction lies within the Court's discretion.
  2. Whether, on the facts of this case, the Court should exercise its discretion to direct convening of meetings to consider the propounded scheme of reconstruction (i.e., whether the scheme is prima facie bona fide, genuine, feasible and in the interest of creditors).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant (propounder / Managing Director)

  • The proposed scheme of arrangement/compromise under Section 391 is highly beneficial to the interests of creditors at large and should be placed before classes of creditors and shareholders for voting.
  • Requested directions for notices, publication, convening meetings of unsecured creditors and equity shareholders, and appointment of a chairman to report results to the Court.
  • The propounder asserted attempts to obtain financial assistance: a letter dated 7.5.1990 was submitted to Indian Bank, Bellary and the revival scheme had been forwarded to the Regional Office at Hubli; another letter dated 4.4.1991 was sent to the Chairman and Managing Director of Indian Bank with an indication that Indian Bank was likely to accept the rehabilitation proposal.
  • Explained various payment schedules for Syndicate Bank, statutory dues, labour/staff, K.E.B., sundry creditors, and compensation to shareholders, referring to Schedules C–F in the scheme.
  • Noted the Official Liquidator's endorsement (dated 3.4.1990) expressing inability to produce the full financial structure required under Section 391, and therefore sought court direction to convene meetings notwithstanding that gap.

Respondent (Syndicate Bank — only secured creditor)

  • The scheme is propounded merely to delay winding-up proceedings and is neither bona fide nor reasonable or feasible.
  • As of 19.6.1986 the company owed Rs. 3,09,53,456.30, and the present liability to the Bank exceeds Rs. 5 crores; assets are insufficient and the company is commercially insolvent.
  • The scheme proposes to pay only Rs. 1.5 crores in full and final settlement to the Bank — less than one-third of dues — and the Bank is not agreeable to that figure.
  • The scheme fails to explain how funds will be mobilised, dictates terms to statutory authorities (e.g., waiver of interest/penalty) that those authorities are likely to reject, and attempts to bind labour and other creditors to concessions.
  • The management (propounder) previously failed to comply with conditions when the appellate stay was granted (e.g., non-payment of Rs. 10 lakhs), reportedly attempted removal/disposal of machinery, and ultimately the appeal was dismissed; this conduct undermines the propounder's credibility.
  • Because the secured creditor (Bank) wholly opposes the scheme, calling meetings would be futile and only delay liquidation, consuming time and imposing costs on the Bank and other creditors.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N.A.P. Alagiri Raja and Company v. N. Guruswamy, Madras High Court, 1989, 65 Company Cases 758 That the Court is not a mere post office and must exercise discretion when considering applications under Section 391(1); the Court must be satisfied prima facie that a compromise or arrangement is genuine, bona fide and in the interest of creditors and the company. The Court relied on this authority to reject the submission that it is bound to convene meetings on every Section 391 application; it affirmed the need for a prima facie examination of bona fides, feasibility and creditor interest before directing meetings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded with a structured legal analysis focused on (a) the scope of judicial discretion under the Act and the Rules, and (b) the factual and evidentiary sufficiency of the propounded scheme.

On the question of discretion, the Court observed that Rule 67 of the Companies Court Rules, 1959 allows an application under Section 391 to be made ex parte but an ex parte hearing does not dispense with the Court's duty to apply its mind to the merits. Section 391(1) vests discretion in the Court, and Rule 69 contemplates that directions for convening meetings may be refused ("unless he (the Judge) thinks fit for any reason to dismiss the summons"). Thus convening a meeting under Section 391(1) is not mandatory; the Court must be satisfied that it is a fit case to issue directions.

The Court treated the cited Madras High Court decision (N.A.P. Alagiri Raja) as authoritative support for the proposition that the Court must be satisfied prima facie that any proposed compromise or arrangement is genuine, bona fide and in the interest of creditors and the company before directing meetings.

Turning to the facts, the Court evaluated the propounded scheme on its merits:

  • The scheme proposed a lump-sum Rs. 1.5 crore payment to the Syndicate Bank and staggered payments to other creditors, with total claims in the scheme aggregating roughly Rs. 2.5 crores as set out in the proposal; however, the company's recorded liabilities exceeded Rs. 3.09 crores (as of 19.6.1986) and, per the Bank, now exceed Rs. 5 crores.
  • The scheme did not adequately explain how funds would be mobilised; the applicant admitted inability to obtain firm financial assistance (despite correspondence with Indian Bank and representations of hopeful acceptance) and had not secured committed funding at the time of hearing.
  • The applicant had a history of failing to comply with conditions imposed during the appellate stay (failure to pay Rs. 10 lakhs and failure to run the mill as required), and the appellate court had characterized the appellant's conduct as indicating no intention to make payments; the appeal was dismissed on 1.3.1991 with a remark that no scheme had been presented despite lengthy pendency.
  • Statutory requirement: under Section 391(2) the Court cannot sanction a scheme unless it is approved by the statutory majority (¾ of creditors or class). Here, the Court noted that 100% of the secured creditor (the Syndicate Bank) opposed the scheme, making it effectively impossible to secure the necessary approval of the secured creditors and rendering convening meetings for unsecured creditors an idle formality.

Having considered these factors, the Court concluded that it was not satisfied that the scheme was bona fide, genuine, feasible or in the interest of creditors; rather, the proposal appeared designed to prolong winding-up proceedings and was too vague and unsupported by finances to warrant convening meetings under Section 391.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Company Application No. 873 of 1991 is DISMISSED with costs.

Costs were quantified at Rs. 3,000/-. The direct effect of the decision is that the Court refused to direct convening of meetings under Section 391(1) and rejected the propounded scheme on discretionary and substantive grounds.

Implications: The opinion confines itself to the case at hand and does not state any broader rule altering precedent. The decision rests on (a) the Court's discretion under Section 391 and the Companies Court Rules to refuse directions where the scheme is not prima facie bona fide or feasible, and (b) practical consequence that opposition by the secured creditor (constituting the relevant class) can make calling meetings an idle formality because statutory majority approval would be unattainable. No new binding precedent beyond the application of existing principles was announced in the text of the opinion.

    K.R Balasubhramanyan v. M/S Bellary Spinning & Weaving Co. Ltd. (In Liquidation)

    Kedambady Jagannatha Shetty, J.:—

    This Company Application is filed by one of the share-holders of the respondent-Company, under Section 391 of the Companies Act, which was directed to be liquidated by the order of this Court, dated 19.10.1987/6.11.1987 in Company Petition No. 34 of 1986.

    2. Brief facts are:—

    The respondent-Company was wound up under the provisions of Section 433(e) and (f) of the Companies Act (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’) since the Company was unable to pay the debts to the creditors. This Court has observed that the respondent-Company has failed to discharge the liability which exceeds Rs. 2.5 Crores, exclusive of interest and is unable to pay the debts within the meaning of Section 433(e) of the Act. The respondent-Company had preferred an appeal against the said order in O.S.A No. 12/1987, which came to be dismissed.

    3. During the pendency of the Appeal, this Company Application was filed by the share holder and also the Managing Director of the said Company. The prayer in the application is that the scheme of arrangement/compromise under Section 391 of the Act, which is sponsored by the applicant is highly beneficial to the interest of creditors at large and that scheme be put to vote to all class of creditors and necessary summons for direction to be given as to issue and publication of notices and convening of meetings of both class of creditors viz., secured and unsecured. The prayer in the Application reads as follows:—

    “(1) Direct meetings to be called of the unsecured creditors, equity share-holders of the Company Bellary Spinning and Weaving Company Limited, for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving, with or without modification a scheme of arrangement proposed to be made between the Company and the said creditors and members of the said Company;

    (2) Pass an order giving directions as to the method of convening, holding and conducting the said meetings and as to the notices and advertisements to be issued;

    (3) Pass an order appointing Chairman of the said meetings who shall report the result thereof to the Court;

    (4) Pass such other orders as the Hon'ble Court deems fit in the circumstances of the case.”

    4. The only secured creditor is the Syndicate Bank, which has filed the objection opposing the prayer made in the Application referred above.

    5. In the affidavit filed by the applicant in support of the direction to call for the meeting of share-holders, of the secured and unsecured creditors, it was stated that the propounder approached the financial institution viz., Indian Bank, Bellary and submitted a letter dated 7.5.1990 to the said Bank. The Indian Bank has stated that the revival scheme has been forwarded to the Regional Office at Hubli, for their comments. Further he has averred that one more letter dated 4.4.1991 was sent to the Chairman and Managing Director and the Indian Bank is likely to accept the proposal for rehabilitation. The only objection raised by the Bank is the pendency of the Appeal and that the Indian Bank wants an order at the hands of the Court for revival. It is further averred that as per the Scheme, the Syndicate Bank would be paid Rs. 1.50 crores in full and final settlement of its dues within three months from the date of approval of the scheme. Further, it was stated that all other statutory dues would be cleared in terms of the norms as applicable to units under BIFR. So far as the Labour and Staff are concerned, it is mentioned in detail the proposals as per Schedule-C. The outstanding to the K.E.B would also be settled in terms of Schedule-D, and the sundry creditors dues would be paid in terms of Schedule-E. That apart, the compensation payable to the share-holders is also mentioned as per Schedule-F. Further, it has been stated, that since the Official Liquidator has expressed his inability in terms of the endorsement, dated 3.4.1990, as such, they are not able to produce the financial structure as required under Section 391 of the Act along with the Application. Therefore, the applicant has sought a direction from the Court.

    6. The respondent-2, the Syndicate Bank, has, in its objection statement, inter alia contended that the Scheme has been propounded merely to delay the winding up proceedings. A sum of Rs. 3,09,53,456-30 was due from the Company in liquidation as on 19.6.1986 and the present liability of the Company to the respondent-Bank is more than Rs. 5 crores. The respondent-Company is required to pay substantial amounts to private creditors towards certain statutory dues like K.S.T, C.S.T, Provident Fund, Employees' State Insurance, Income-tax etc. The dues of labour and staff also comes to a substantial amount. It is also due to the K.E.B and other persons in huge amounts. The assets of the Company in liquidation is not sufficient to meet its liabilities, and the Company is commercially insolvent. It is further averred that by order, dated 19.10.1987/6.11.1987 the Company Judge passed an order directing compulsory winding up of the Company in liquidation against which, an appeal in O.S.A No. 12/87 was preferred by the company represented by its Managing Director, the propounder of the present Scheme. In the said appeal, this Court afforded several opportunities to the Management to run the industry with a further direction to deposit certain amounts. However, the Management, represented by the present propounder, miserably failed to keep up its promise and also failed to deposit the amount inspite of several extensions granted by this Court. It is further stated, that during the period, when the Management of the Company in liquidation was in possession of the mill, it attempted to remove the machinery and dispose of them. The Appeal ultimately came to be dismissed on 1.3.1991 It is stated further that the proposed scheme is neither bona fide nor reasonable and is liable to be rejected without any further consideration. The present scheme is nothing but a continuation of the earlier attempt by the propounder, who has no regard for the promises he makes. The respondent-Bank is the biggest creditor of the Company in liquidation. The dues of the Company to this respondent far exceeds Rs. 5 crores. Under the present scheme, a payment of Rs. 1.5 crores in full and final settlement is proposed by the propounder. This figure works out to less than one-third of the dues and the respondent-Bank is not agreeable for the said scheme. In addition to this, the scheme dictates terms to the statutory authorities and to the labour and staff as also to K.E.B etc., to forego interest, penalty etc., and requires the authorities to grant instalments, which, on the face of it, will be rejected by the said authorities. Virtually, the propounder intends to make the one man show. The Company became sick and could not be revived inspite of sufficient opportunities by the propounder of the scheme and his team. It is further averred that the respondent has already spent huge amounts towards liquidation expenses, litigation and security charges, to preserve the assets. The very purpose of the scheme appears to be to drag on the proceedings without any result and ultimately saddle this respondent with further liability to pay security charges. This intention is very clear from the application filed under Section 391 of the Act. While requesting for meetings of unsecured creditors and equity share holders, the propounder of the scheme has not requested this Court for a meeting of the secured creditors. The respondent-Bank is a secured creditor and also a major creditor, and the respondent-Bank is not agreeable to the present scheme which is highly unreasonable. As such, the scheme is liable to be rejected without calling for any meeting of the unsecured creditors or the members. Calling for meeting will be nothing but a waste and will unnecessarily consume time and drag on the liquidation proceedings. If a meeting is called pursuant to the request of the propounder, the same will further delay the proceedings and this respondent and other creditors will suffer. The respondent-Bank has stated that the scheme is liable to be rejected even without calling for the meetings.

    7. During the course of hearing, the Counsel Mr. Radhesh Prabhu for respondent-Bank informed the Court that Appeal O.S.A No. 12 of 1987 preferred by the respondent-Company was dismissed on 1.3.1991

    8. The question is whether the request for convening a meeting to consider a scheme for reconstruction of Company should be allowed or is the Court bound to convene the meeting contemplated under Section 391, and objection if any, can and should be considered at a meeting and later at the time of sanctioning of the scheme by the Court.

    9. Rule 67 of the Companies Court Rules, 1959, no doubt, says that an application under Section 391 for direction is to be made ex-parte. But hearing of motion ex-parte does not mean that the Court has not only applied its mind or be prima facie satisfied about the merits of the application. On proper analysis of the provision of Section 391(1), it is absolutely clear about the discretion resting with the Court in granting application. It is well laid principle of law that the Court will not and shall not pass an order unless it is satisfied that it is a fit case to do so. Equally Rule 69 further makes it clear and points out that directions are to be given “unless he (the Judge) thinks fit for any reason to dismiss the summons (for direction)”. Therefore, on the basis of the Act and Rules made thereunder, it is not compulsory for the Court to give direction to convene a meeting contemplated under Section 391(1) of the Act.

    10. In the Decision of Madras High Court N.A.P Alagiri Raja and Company v. N. Guruswamy . 1989 65 Company Cases 758., it is opined as follows:—

    “The Court is not intended to act as a post office with no discretion or power to refuse to call for a meeting. In our opinion, even when considering an application under Section 391(1), the Court will have to be satisfied as to the prima facie case that compromise or arrangement is genuine, bona fide and would be in the interest of the creditors and the company.”

    11. The contention of Mr. Ashwatha Reddy, Counsel for the applicant, that the Court is bound to issue direction to convene the meeting when an application is made under Section 391(1), and the objection, if any, either by the creditor or any other person interested will have to be considered in convening the meeting or later at the time of sanctioning the scheme by Court is plainly unsustainable and is devoid of merit, as such, it is rejected.

    12. Let me consider the rival contention of the parties.

    13. Before issuing direction to convene a meeting as requested by the applicant propounder, the Court will have to examine and see whether the scheme is bona fide, genuine or feasible and in the interest of the creditors of the Company.

    14. The respondent-Bank says that the proposed scheme is neither bona fide nor reasonable as well as not feasible and is liable to be rejected. It further says, that it is filed with a view to prolong and stall liquidation proceedings. With regard to the scheme, the respondent-Bank has pleaded that though more than Rs. 3.5 crores was due as on 19.6.1986 and the present liability of the Company is more than Rs. 5 crores, the scheme has taken into only Rs. 1.5 crores as full and final settlement of all dues. Further it is pleaded, that the scheme does not give any detail about the manner in which the funds are sought to be mobilised; merely mention the schedule of payment. The respondent further reiterates and states, that it has considered the scheme of arrangement and is of the view that the scheme is not beneficial to the Bank. The respondent-Bank, is the major secured creditor and the scheme is not agreeable to them. If the meeting is called, the respondent-Bank being the major secured creditor and when the scheme is not accepted by them, then, calling of any meeting either of unsecured or secured creditors will be nothing but a waste and unnecessarily consume time and drag on the liquidation proceedings. Thus, it is submitted by the respondent-Bank that it would be an exercise in futility to direct the convening of the meeting.

    15. On merits, I am unable to accept that the applicant-propounder has made out a case for calling a meeting as required under Section 391(1) of the Act. In the scheme, it is stated, that the respondent-Bank is the only highest secured creditor and they proposed to pay in one lumpsum payment of Rs. 1.5 crores as full and final settlement. The statutory dues would be about Rs. 25 lakhs and that would be paid within four years including one year holiday for repayment. The labour and staff dues is about Rs. 10 lakhs and that would be paid over the periods of four years from 31.3.1992 to 31.3.1996 The K.E.B dues is about Rs. 5 lakhs after foregoing penal interest and that would be paid over the period of two years. The other sundry creditors whose dues about Rs. 10 lakhs would be paid in full by 31st March 1993. The compensation to share-holders about Rs. 64.5 lakhs which the propounder proposes to offer Rs. 10/- to each of the preference and equity shares of Rs. 100/- at Rs. 50/- as compensation. Finally, it is stated in the scheme that the propounder proposed to discharge all the liabilities stated in the scheme. According to the statement made in the scheme, the total amount due to various creditors and other claimants roughly comes to Rs. 2.5 crores.

    16. It may be seen from the Clauses ABCD in the scheme proposed, that all the creditors will be paid their amounts in full. However, it is not stated that, how the amount could be paid to all the creditors. In the affidavit filed in support of the application, he has stated that he had submitted a letter, dated 7.5.1990 to the Indian Bank, Bellary for providing financial assistance for revival of the Company and he at the request of the Indian Bank forwarded the scheme and he is hopeful that Indian Bank is likely to accept the proposal, but the only objection of the Indian Bank that it wants an order at the hands of the Court. It is relevant to refer here that the application for revival of the Company was filed on 27.2.1991 The matter came up for hearing of the application for several times. The Court asked the applicant whether he was able to mobilise the fund, or able to get any financial assistance from the Indian Bank or any other Bank for the payment of the amount due to the various creditors. The applicant has expressed that so far he could not get financial assistance either from the Indian Bank or from any other financial institutions.

    17. I may mention here that after the winding up order was passed by this Court, the respondent-Company represented by the applicant propounder preferred an appeal in O.S.A No. 12 of 1987 and obtained an order of stay. The respondent-Bank filed an application for vacating the order of stay, but it was allowed to continue up to 9.1.1989 subject to the appellant therein to run the Mill for three months initially and the appellant shall pay the amount of Rs. 10 lakhs to the respondent-Bank before 6.1.1989 Since the said amount was not paid and the appellant (applicant-propounder) did not run the Mill, the appellate Court vacated the order of stay. The appellate Court has observed while rejecting I.A III for extension of stay that “the conduct of the appellant has left an impression in our mind that it has no intention to make any payment. We have granted sufficient indulgence to the appellant to make some payment to the Bank, but the appellant has failed to do so”. I may also mention here that the Appeal also came to be dismissed by the Appellate Court on 1.3.1991 In the said order it is observed that “we have pointed out earlier that no scheme has been presented even though the petition was pending for long time, nor any such scheme is prescribed before us though the Appeal is pending for more than four years.”

    18. It is relevant to refer to the provisions of Section 391(2) of the Act. The Company Court has no jurisdiction to sanction a scheme if it is not approved by ¾th majority of the creditors or class creditors. Considering the question of sanctioning the scheme by the Court would arise only if the scheme has been approved by the statutory majority provided for under Section 391(2) of the Act. It is apparent in the present case 100% of the secured creditor (respondent-Bank) is opposing the scheme. It would, therefore, be an idle formality to direct the convening of the meeting of the unsecured members to consider the scheme. In view of the above stated legal position, the application filed by the propounder of the scheme is liable to be rejected and the direction as sought by the applicant for convening the meeting cannot be issued.

    19. I am also of the view, even on merit, the application of the propounder is liable to be rejected. From the foregoing discussions it is clear that the scheme is put forth with a view to delay the winding up proceedings. Though the hearing of the application is adjourned for several times, the applicant propounder was not able to say how he would make available funds for running the Mill, and make payments to the various creditors. That apart, the applicant has not refuted the allegations made by the respondent-Bank in its objection statement, by filing any reply. The scheme even otherwise does not appear to be feasible and viable.

    20. I am also of the opinion that the scheme is not genuine, bona fide and it would not be in the interest of the creditors and the Company. The scheme put forward by the applicant propounder is mainly for the purpose of prolonging the winding up proceedings. That apart, the scheme is extremely vague.

    21. In view of the above discussions, the Company Application No. 873 of 1991 is dismissed with costs. The cost is quantified at Rs. 3,000/-.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.R Balasubhramanyan v. M/S Bellary Spinning & Weaving Co. Ltd. (In Liquidation)
    (Dec 15, 1992)