Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a company incorporated under the Companies Act engaged, inter alia, in the manufacture of carbon paper. The petitioner filed writ petitions seeking quashing of: (a) the order of the Assistant Collector (Annexure D), (b) the order of the Appellate Collector (Annexure G), and (c) the notice of demand (Annexure H). The contested demands related to alleged difference of excise duty for two periods: 16-10-1978 to 15-4-1979 (show cause notice dated 16-4-1979 proposed demand for that period) and a further period 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980.

A key factual predicate is that the petitioner had previously been charging excise under a residuary tariff entry (Item 68) on the basis of a trade notice (Central Excise Trade Notice No. 56/76 dated 2-3-1976) and a Tariff Advice (No. 5/76) from the Central Board of Central Excise, both of which treated carbon paper and stencil paper as articles of stationery outside Item 17 of the Central Excise Tariff.

The Assistant Collector held that carbon paper fell within tariff Item 17(2) as coated paper and issued an order accordingly. The petitioner appealed to the Appellate Collector of Central Excise, Madras, which, by order dated 27-12-1980, dismissed the appeal and affirmed classification under Item 17(2). The petitioner then filed these writ petitions challenging the Appellate Collector's decision and the demand (Annexure H) for the subsequent period.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the carbon paper manufactured and cleared by the petitioner during the relevant periods was correctly classified and assessable to excise duty under tariff Item 17(2) (coated paper) or was correctly classifiable as an article of stationery under the residuary Item 68 as per Trade Notice No. 56/76 and Tariff Advice No. 5/76.
  2. Whether the show cause notice, adjudication by the Assistant Collector (Annexure D), affirmation by the Appellate Collector (Annexure G) and the consequent demand (Annexure H) for the periods 16-10-1978 to 15-4-1979 and 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980 were illegal and liable to be quashed.
  3. Whether legislative amendments (including the amendment effective 27-5-1976 to Item 17 and the later specific inclusion of carbon paper with effect from 27-2-1982) and the memorandum/objects and reasons of the Finance Bill bearing on legislative intent should control classification prior to the specific 1982 addition.
  4. Whether a Collector (for example, the Collector of Central Excise, Bangalore) had jurisdiction to issue a trade notice/classification (e.g., the 22-11-1979 trade notice) altering prior classification and thereby affect liability for earlier periods.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Appellant's) Arguments

  • For the period 16-10-1978 to 15-4-1979 the goods were rightly subjected to levy under Item 68 in conformity with Trade Notice No. 56/76 (2-3-1976) and Tariff Advice No. 5/76; the show cause notice and subsequent order were therefore illegal.
  • For the subsequent period 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980 the same trade notice continued to apply and the department was not entitled to treat the goods as coated paper under Item 17(2) following the 1976 amendment.
  • Challenged the jurisdiction of the Collector of Karnataka in issuing Trade Advice/classification (the petitioner submitted that the department/other Collectors had continued to treat carbon paper as stationery under Item 68 until its explicit addition to Item 17 in 1982).
  • Relied on the legislative intent reflected in the Memorandum and Budget speech accompanying the Finance Bill of 1982 (and the explanatory memorandum) to show that the specific insertion of carbon paper into Item 17 with effect from 27-2-1982 indicates that prior to that date carbon paper should not have been taxed under Item 17(2).

Respondent's Arguments

  • Carbon paper is properly classified as coated paper within the scope of Item 17(2) following the amendment effected in 1976 (effective 27-5-1976), and the department was therefore justified in demanding the difference of duty.
  • Relying on the statement of objections, respondents argued the chemical processes and treatments applied to base paper produce a new commodity—carbon paper—which appropriately falls within the description of coated paper.
  • Submitted that carbon paper had been brought under Item 17(2) after the 1976 amendment and that coated paper necessarily includes carbon paper.

Table of Precedents Cited

No case law precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning follows a stepwise analysis grounded in the documentary history, administrative practice and principles of tax statute interpretation set out in the opinion:

  1. The court noted the prior administrative classification: Trade Notice No. 56/76 (2-3-1976) and Tariff Advice No. 5/76 of the Central Board, which treated carbon paper and stencil paper as articles of stationery outside Item 17 of the Central Excise Tariff, and observed that the petitioner's levy under residuary Item 68 was therefore consistent with that guidance.
  2. The court acknowledged the amendment to Item 17 effective 27-5-1976 which expanded sub-clause (2) to include coated paper and other treated papers. It recorded that no specific clarification or trade notice was issued by the Collector or the Central Government, at that time, expressly bringing carbon paper within the amended description of “coated paper” under Item 17(2).
  3. The court observed that a later trade notice (issued by the Collector of Central Excise, Bangalore on 22-11-1979) attempted to classify carbon paper under Item 17, but the court treated this as a subsequent administrative reinterpretation which did not negate the earlier Tariff Advice and Trade Notice that classified carbon paper as stationery.
  4. The court considered the legislative amendment of 27-2-1982 (Finance Act of 1982) which added specific entries (Items 17(3) and 17(4)) explicitly mentioning carbon and other copying papers. The court examined the memoranda and the Budget speech accompanying the Finance Bill of 1982 (referred to in the petitioner's submissions) and treated these documents as reflecting legislative intent when interpreting taxing statutes.
  5. Applying the canon that, for taxing statutes, the intention of an amendment may be gathered from the memorandum of objects and reasons (part of the amending bill and Finance Minister's speech), the court concluded that carbon paper should not have been treated as coated paper under Item 17(2) prior to its specific inclusion by the 1982 amendment.
  6. On that basis, and having regard to the Board's tariff advice and the Collector's earlier trade notice treating carbon paper as stationery, the court accepted the petitioner's contention that imposing the classification and concomitant demand under Item 17(2) for the relevant earlier periods was not justified.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The writ petitions are allowed; the order of the Assistant Collector (Annexure D), the Appellate Collector's order (Annexure G) affirming it, and the demand made as per Annexure H are set aside.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The impugned orders and the demand in respect of the periods challenged (including the subsequent period shown in the enclosure to Annexure H, i.e., 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980) are quashed.
  • The petitioner is at liberty to make a claim for refund of the sum of Rs. 4,61,218.18 (and amounts paid under protest for the period 4-3-1980 to 26-3-1981 and subsequent period) before the department; the court did not itself order the refund but left the remedy to departmental process.
  • The opinion rests on application of established interpretive principles for taxing statutes and on the documentary record (Board tariff advice and trade notices); the court did not purport to create an overarching new rule of law beyond its application to the facts before it. (The opinion contains no statement of creating a new precedent beyond the adjudication of the writ petitions.)

Disposition: Rule issued in the writ petitions is made absolute.

    Khoday Industries Limited v. Union Of India And Others

    1. The petitioner is a Company incorporated under the Companies Act and is engaged, inter alia, in the manufacture of carbon paper. In the writ petitions, the petitioner has prayed for quashing the order of the Assistant Collector Annexure ‘D’ and that of the Appellate Collector Annexure ‘G’ and the notice of demand, Annexure ‘H’. The two writ petitions relate to the demand made to pay difference of excise duty for the period 16-10-1978 to 18-4-1979 and the demand made for the further period 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980 as per Annexure ‘H’.

    2. A show cause notice was issued to the petitioner Company on 16-4-1979 proposing to demand difference of duty on the carbon paper cleared during 16-10-1978 to 15-4-1979. This item had been subjected to duty under item 68 as per the classification list approved by the proper Officer. What was proposed to be done under the show cause notice was to demand difference of duty payable under item, 17(2) of the Central Excise Tariff which was amended with effect from 27-5-1976.

    3. The petitioner replied to the show cause notice contending that the carbon paper manufactured by the petitioner Company was being rightly subjected to duty under Item 68 and that was in conformity with the Collector's trade notice 56/76 dated 2-3-1976. The trade notice is reproduced below:

    “CENTRAL EXCISE TRADE NOTICE NO. 56/76, DATED 2-3-1976 (3/76 Paper)

    Sub: Paper—carbon paper and stencil paper—Whether excisable under item No. 17 of CET.

    A doubt has been raised whether carbon paper/stencil paper, produced by conversion of duty paid base paper, should be treated as paper falling under Tariff Item 17(4) of Central Excise Tariff, or as an item of stationery, outside the scope of Item 17 of Central Excise Tariff.

    2. The matter has been examined and it is clarified for the information of the trade, that the carbon paper/stencil paper, are articles of stationery, and therefore, outside the purview of Item 17 of Central Excise Tariff.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    4. It was clarified in the said trade notice by the Collector that carbon paper/stencil paper are articles of stationery and, therefore, are outside the purview of Item 17 of the Central Excise Act. It is relevant to notice that this trade notice was issued consequent to the tariff advice 5/76 by the Central Board of Central Excise.

    ‘Tariff Advice No. 5/76.

    Subject: Paper—Carbon paper and Stencil Paper—whether Excisable under Item No. 17 of C.E Tariff.

    A doubt had been raised whether carbon paper/stencil paper produced by conversion of duty paid base paper, should be treated as paper falling under tariff item 17(4) of Central Excise Tariff or as an item of stationery, outside the scope of Item 17 of Central Excise Tariff.

    2. The matter was considered in the Central Excise Tariff Conference held at Cochin on the 13th to 15th November, 1975. It was reported that carbon paper/stencil paper is sold in the market mostly cut to size by retail stationers. The Indian Customs Tariff Guide has also treated Carbon paper as an item of stationery and not as paper. The Conference was therefore, of the view that carbon paper/stencil paper, were commercially recognised only as articles of stationery.

    3. The Board is accordingly advised that carbon paper and stencil paper should be treated as articles of stationery, and therefore outside the purview of item 17 of Central Excise Tariff.’

    5. The Assistant Collector, in his original order, did not agree with the contention of the petitioner and treated the carbon paper as falling under tariff item 17(2), which read thus, during the relevant period:

    Item No. Description of goods Rate of duty (1) (2) (3) 17. Paper and paper boards, all sorts (including pasteboard, millboard, strawboard, card-board and corrugated board), in or in relation to the manufacture of which any process is ordinarily carried on with the aid of power
    (1) Uncoated and coated printing and writing paper (other than poster paper) Twenty-five per cent ad valorem (2) Paper board and all other kinds of paper (including paper or paper boards, which have been subjected to various treatments, such as coating, impregnating, corrugation, creping and design printing) not elsewhere specified 1 (Forty per cent ad valorem)

    6. The Assistant Collector was of the view that carbon paper should be treated as coated paper falling under tariff item 17(2). Against the order of the Assistant Collector, the petitioner filed an appeal before the Appellate Collector of Central Excise, Madras. The adjudication made by the Assistant Collector, was followed by a demand as per Annexure ‘H’ under which the difference of duty for the period from 16-10-1978 to 15-4-1979 was demanded and in addition, the duty payable thereafter for 16-4-1978 to 22-2-1980 was also demanded. Before the appellate Collector, only the original order of the Assistant Collector was challenged and the demand for the subsequent period is challenged in these writ petitions.

    7. The Appellate Collector of Central Excise, Madras, by his order dated 27-12-1980 dismissed the appeal agreeing with the order of the Assistant Collector and held that the carbon paper was rightly brought to tax under tariff item 17(2) as coated paper. Being aggrieved by this order of the Appellate Collector and the demand made as per Annexure ‘H’ for the subsequent period, these writ petitions are filed challenging them.

    8. It is urged by Sri Naganand, the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the show cause notice issued proposing to levy difference of duty for the period 16-10-1978 to 15-4-1979 is illegal. His first contention is, that for this period as per the trade notice 56/76 issued by the Collector, the carbon paper was subjected to levy as article of stationery in conformity with the said trade notice and was subjected to levy under item 68, the residuary item in the Act. It is, therefore, his contention that there was no reason to take a different view by the Assistant Collector and the order made pursuant to the show cause notice should be quashed.

    9. There is force in the contention of the learned Counsel. The carbon paper cleared by the petitioner company during this period was rightly subjected to levy under item 68 as per Trade Advice issued by the Board, and there was no reason to take a different view and review the levy made earlier.

    10. The demand made for the subsequent period 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980 is also questioned on the same ground. It is the contention of the learned Counsel that even for this period the trade notice 56/76 applies to the petitioner's case and the department was not right in treating it was coated paper falling under item 17(2) after its amendment with effect from 27-5-1976. In this connection, the learned Counsel also challenges the jurisdiction of the Collector of Karnataka in issuing Trade advice. It is only from that date the Collector of Karnataka understood and issued the trade notice that carbon paper will be liable for classification under 17(2).

    Item No. Description of goods Rate of duty 17. Paper and paper boards, all sorts (including pasteboard, millboard, strawboard, card-board and corrugated board), in or in relation to the manufacture of which any process is ordinarily carried on with the aid of power— (1) Uncoated and coated printing and writing paper (other than poster paper). Twenty-five per cent ad valorem (2) Paper board and all other kinds of paper (including paper or paper boards, which have been subjected to various treatments, such as coating, impregnating, corrugation, creping and design printing), not elsewhere specified. 1 (Forty per cent ad valorem)

    11. There was further amendment to item No. 17 by the Finance Act of 1982. Item 17 was amended with effect from 27-2-1982, and two specific entries were added. They are (3) and (4) which are re-produced below:

    Item No. Description of goods Rate of duty 17. XX XX (3) Carbon and other copying papers (including duplicator stencils) and transfer papers, whether or not cut to size and whether or not put to in boxes. 321/2% ad valorem (4) Boxes, cartons, bags and other packing containers (including flattened or folded boxes and flattened or folded cartons), whether or not printed and whether in assembled or unassembled condition., 321/2% ad valorem

    12. Relying upon this amendment which was brought into force with effect from 27-2-1982, the learned Counsel for the petitioner contends that till the carbon paper was specifically added in item 17 with effect from 27-2-1982, the goods in question should be subjected to levy only under tariff item 68 and not under 17(2). He has referred to the statement of object of reasons and the Budget speech of the Finance Minister while introducing the Finance Bill of 1982 which according to him, throws light on the object of adding a specific description of carbon paper as an independent item in item 17 and the purpose of the amendment. Relevant portion of Paragraph 123 of the Budget speech of the Finance Minister is extracted and reads thus:—

    “……However, certain converted papers of high value-added categories are proposed to be subject to basic excise duty at 324% ad valorem.

    Similarly, specified articles made of paper and paper board are proposed, to be brought within the purview of the tariff item but effectively restricting the levy to printed cartons and printed boxes.”

    13. In the memorandum explaining the bill at paragraph 5:17 it is stated thus:

    “Paper and paper boards and articles of paper and paper board:

    The tariff description is being revised to include specifically articles of paper and paper board.”

    14. Therefore, developing his argument on the basis of the legislative intendment as reflected in the Memoranda to the Finance Minister's speech, Sri Naganda's further submission is that carbon paper cannot be treated as coated paper and subjected to levy under 17(2) prior to its addition with effect from 27-2-1982.

    15. Sri Shivashankar Bhat, learned Counsel appearing for the respondents, has, on the other hand, argued that carbon paper is rightly classified and treated as coated paper as per the amendment effected in 1976. Therefore, the department was right in demanding the difference of duty and subjecting it to levy under 17(2) with effect from 27-5-1976. In support of his argument he has relied upon paragraph 3 of the statement of objections filed in the case explaining chemical process and treatment that the base paper undergoes and a new commodity comes into existence. It is, therefore, argued by Sri Bhat that carbon paper which was treated hitherto as stationery was rightly brought under 17(2) after its amendment in 1976 and that it cannot be disputed that carbon paper is coated paper and coated paper includes carbon paper. There is force in the contention of Sri Bhat that so far as the process that the ordinary paper undergoes and the treatment that is given to base paper for converting it into carbon paper, it may appropriately fall under the description of ‘coated paper’.

    16. Trade notice 56/76 was issued by the Collector on 2-3-1976. This trade notice was based on the instructions issued by the Board that carbon paper should be commercially recognised only as an article of stationery falling under entry 68. Item 17 was amended with effect from 27-5-1976 and sub-clause (2) was amended which among other things, included coated paper. Subsequent to the amendment to item 17 by adding coated paper, it is to be noticed that there was no further clarification or trade notice issued by the Collector or by the Central Government bringing carbon paper specifically within the description of ‘coated paper’ as per the amended item 17(2).

    17. It is only on 22-11-1979 that the Collector of Central Excise, Bangalore issued the trade notice clarifying the position regarding classification of carbon paper under item 17. This classification as per the trade notice is challenged by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that such a classification should not be given effect to since the department understood and treated carbon paper only as an article of stationery until it was specifically added as an independent item in 17 with effect from 27-2-1982. Any interpretation of an item in the Central Excise Tariff throughout the country should be uniform and should not be left to each Collector to interpret in a different way. It was also asserted that many other Collectors had continued to treat carbon paper as stationery under item 68 until it was added to Item 17 in the year 1982. The intention of the Legislature to tax it under Item 17(2) with effect from 27-2-1982 should be accepted and no other interpretation is permissible or prejudiced.

    18. After carefully considering the arguments of the learned Counsal for the petitioner as well as the respondents and having regard to the legislative amendments effected to Item No. 17 and keeping in view the tariff advice issued by the Board classifying carbon paper as an article of stationery dutiable by entry 68, the contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioner should be accepted. One of the well accepted canons of interpretation so far as taxing statutes are concerned, is the intention of the amendment may be gathered from the memorandum of objects and reasons, which is a part of the Amending Bill to the Finance Minister's speech. The order of the Appellate Collector confirming the show cause notice and the provisional assessment and the demand made for the subsequent period as indicated in the enclosure to Annexure ‘H’ i.e, for the period from 16-4-1979 to 22-2-1980 are therefore liable to be quashed.

    19. In the result, the writ petitions are allowed and the order of the Assistant Collector Annexure ‘D’ which was affirmed by the Appellate Collector as per Annexure ‘G’ and the demand made as per Annexure ‘H’ are set aside. One of the prayers made in the Writ Petitions is for a direction to the respondents to refund to the petitioner a sum of Rs. 4,61,218.18 paid by the petitioner under protest for the period from 4-3-1980 to 26-3-1981 and for the subsequent period. The petitioner is at liberty to make such claim before the department.

    20. Rule issued is made absolute.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Khoday Industries Limited v. Union Of India And Others
    (Oct 30, 1985)