Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rule 4 of the Karnataka State Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 (hereinafter referred
  • rule 4 of the Rules or violation of Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution.
  • Article 18(1) of the Constitution read with rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules,
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules
  • rule 4(2) of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • rule 4 of the Karnataka State Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 (hereinafter referred
  • rule 4 of the Rules or violation of Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution.
  • Article 18(1) of the Constitution read with rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules,
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules
  • rule 4(2) of the Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rama Jois, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition under Article 226 challenges the legality of the State Government's appointment of respondent-3 to the post of Director of Mines and Geology. The petitioner, a Deputy Director in the same department and earlier a direct recruit as Geologist (appointed 26 October 1964), contends that respondent-3's appointment (by notification dated 18 October 1978) was made contrary to law.

Relevant chronological facts in the record: respondent-3 had earlier been promoted as Geologist in 1960; both the petitioner and respondent-3 (and a third officer) were promoted to Senior Geologist in 1976 and to Deputy Director on 29 July 1977. Seniority among several officers had not been finally fixed (W.P. 3831 of 1977 had quashed a seniority list published on 19 April 1977 and directed seniority to be fixed in accordance with law). The Director’s post fell vacant on 1 October 1978 on retirement of the incumbent, and a selection process culminated in an entry by the Chief Minister on 13 October 1978 recording that "Shri Veukatakumaran may be appointed" (respondent-3).

The petitioner seeks quashing of the appointment and a writ of mandamus directing the State Government to consider his case for promotion to Director. In response, the State Government has admitted that the three Deputy Directors were eligible but asserted that the Chief Minister, as the selecting authority, examined records and found respondent-3 more suitable on grounds of merit and seniority.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appointing authority may select and appoint one among several eligible officers to a selection post without recording reasons for the choice.
  2. Whether the record in this case discloses that the comparative merit and suitability of the eligible Deputy Directors were actually considered before selecting respondent-3, in compliance with rule 4(2)(b) of the Karnataka State Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 and Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution.
  3. If multiple eligible officers are adjudged equal in merit, whether seniority must be determined and applied as the tie-breaker.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The records do not show that the petitioner's case was considered; the selection does not contain reasons explaining why respondent-3 was chosen over the petitioner and the other eligible officer.
  • Because no reasons were recorded, the selection is arbitrary and violates Articles 14 and 16(1) (equal opportunity and equality before law) and rule 4 of the Rules.
  • The petitioner asserted he is senior by virtue of being a direct recruit to the cadre of Geologist and that seniority had not been fixed; treating respondent-3 as senior without finalisation was unjustified.
  • Relied on the ratio in Union of India v. M.L. Capoor to show that recording of reasons is required as a visible safeguard against arbitrariness in selections.

State's Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The fact that the names of the three Deputy Directors were placed before the selecting authority shows that all three cases were considered.
  • The statement of objection affirmatively asserted that the Chief Minister examined service records and after evaluating merit and suitability found respondent-3 more suitable.
  • On that basis, the State argued absence of recorded reasons does not necessarily establish lack of consideration or arbitrariness.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. M.L. Capoor (referred to as Capoor's case) Requirement that selection/appointments by promotion must record reasons so that comparative assessments of candidates are visible and to guard against arbitrariness; reasons are the link between material and conclusions (rights under Articles 14 and 16). The Court relied on Capoor to hold that recording reasons (even briefly) is necessary in selection posts to show that comparative merits and suitability were considered. Capoor is treated as the foundational authority for the visible safeguard principle invoked in this case.
Associated Electrical Industries (India) Private Ltd. v. Workmen (AIR 1967 SC 284) Decision relating to the effect of non-compliance with mandatory provisions governing selection/appointment procedures. Cited in Capoor and relied upon to support the proposition that non-compliance with mandatory procedural safeguards (such as recording reasons) can vitiate a selection. The present Court referenced it as part of the lineage of authority establishing consequences of non-compliance.
Collector of Monghyr v. Keshav Prasad Goenka ((1963) 1 SCR 98; AIR 1962 SC 1694) Another decision on effect of non-compliance with mandatory selection/appointment procedures. Referenced in Capoor and noted by the Court as part of prior jurisprudence supporting the need to comply with mandatory procedural requirements in selection matters; used to buttress the requirement of recorded reasons.
B. Virupakshappa v. State of Mysore Principle that if more than one candidate is adjudged equal in merit, seniority entitles the senior among them to preference for appointment. The Court applied this principle to explain that where candidates are equal in merit, seniority rightfully governs selection; hence seniority must be ascertained when candidates are equal in merit.
N. Shankara Rao v. K.E.B. (W.P. No. 7432 of 1978, D. 10-11-1978) Decision of the High Court cited to show application of Capoor's principle in the Court's own prior practice. The Court cited this decision as an instance where the same principle (necessity of recording reasons) had been applied in a local context; used to support the conclusion that reasons are required under rule 4(2)(b) as traced to Articles 14 and 16(1).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded step-by-step by first identifying the legal framework and the obligations it imposes. The post of Director is a selection post; rule 4(2)(a)/(b) prescribes that appointment to such posts must be made "on the basis of merit and suitability in all respects ... with due regard to seniority" and, where applicable, on seniority-cum-merit. That procedure embodies the equality guarantees of Articles 14 and 16(1).

The Court distilled two primary factual/legal questions: (i) whether the cases of the three Deputy Directors were compared on merit and suitability and respondent-3 alone found suitable (or more suitable), and (ii) whether all three were equal in merit and respondent-3 was chosen on seniority.

On examination of the record, the Court found no contemporaneous or documentary indication that a comparative assessment of merits and suitability of the three officers preceded the decision. The file shows the names were put up to the Chief Minister and the Chief Minister recorded that respondent-3 be appointed, but the record does not contain an opinion or reasons stating that respondent-3 was found more meritorious or that others were unsuitable. The Court refused to accept, without documentary support, the State's assertion in pleadings that the Chief Minister had evaluated merits; that assertion was derived from the same records and therefore could not supplant the absence of any recorded consideration.

The Court identified additional procedural infirmities that reinforced its conclusion:

  • Non-uniformity in the confidential records placed for consideration: confidential records of respondent-3 covered a much longer period (1960 to 31 March 1978), whereas the petitioner’s and the third officer’s confidential reports for the latest year(s) (e.g., year ending 31 March 1978) were missing from the file. The Court held that adoption of uniform criteria for the period of confidential records is necessary to ensure fair comparison.
  • Seniority among the eligible officers had not been finally determined despite the fact seniority matters when candidates are equal in merit. The Court noted seniority needed to be fixed and indicated during consideration.

Drawing on the principle in Capoor and related authority, the Court held that recording reasons (even briefly) is essential as the visible safeguard of the right to fair consideration. Reasons link factual material (service records/confidential reports) with conclusions reached; without them, the right to consideration becomes illusory and the selection process susceptible to arbitrariness.

The Court articulated specific conclusions (as formulated in the judgment): selection posts require comparative assessment of all eligible candidates; the only reliable method to show such comparative consideration is by recording reasons indicating the basis of selection correlated to confidential reports and service records; the period of confidential records considered must be specified and uniform; seniority must be determined where relevant; and where compliance with these requirements is shown, courts will not substitute their judgment, but where such compliance is absent the selection is liable to be set aside and reconsidered by the competent authority.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court held that the appointment of respondent-3 to the post of Director of Mines and Geology was invalid because there was no record that the comparative merits and suitability of the eligible Deputy Directors were considered and no reasons were recorded for selecting respondent-3. The rule in this petition was made absolute and the State Government was directed to reconsider the cases of all eligible officers and make fresh appointment in accordance with law.

Specific orders and direct consequences (as ordered by the Court):

  • A writ of mandamus issued directing the State Government to consider the petitioner, respondent-3 and any other eligible officers for appointment to the post of Director of Mines and Geology in accordance with law and in the light of the judgment, and to make fresh appointment within three months.
  • If on reconsideration any officer other than respondent-3 is selected and appointed, respondent-3's appointment shall cease to be effective from the date of such appointment.
  • The Court refrained from immediate displacement of respondent-3, observing that allowing time for fresh selection would avoid administrative inconvenience; no costs were imposed.

Broader implications the Court set out (as part of its holding):

  • The decision establishes procedural safeguards for selection posts: comparative consideration must be reflected in the record and reasons must be recorded so that selections are not arbitrary and the rights under Articles 14 and 16(1) are protected.
  • Uniform treatment of confidential records and determination of seniority where relevant are mandatory aspects of fair selection practice.

Note: The statements above reflect only the consequences and principles expressly articulated in the opinion. The Court directed fresh consideration rather than immediate removal, and the judgment prescribes procedural standards to be followed in future selections.

    T.K Devaraju v. The State Of Karnataka & Others

    Rama Jois, J.:— Whether in making appointment to a selection post the appointing authority can select and appoint any one among the eligible officers without recording any reason as to why one amongst the several eligible officers is selected, is the precise question of law that arises for consideration in this writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, in which the legality of the appointment made to the post of Director of Mines and Geology by the State Government, is challenged by the petitioner, who is a Deputy Director in the same department.

    2. FACTS:—(i) The petitioner was a direct recruit to the post of Geologist. He was appointed on 26th October 1964. Respondent-3 was an Assistant Geologist. He was promoted as Geologist on 26th May 1960. Both were placed in independent charge of the post of Senior Geologist for some time and were promoted as Senior Geologists on 16th July 1976. Thereafter, the petitioner, respondent-3 and another were promoted as Deputy Directors on 29th July 1977. The seniority of these three officers and others is not finalised though in W.P 3831 of 1977 decided on 16th June 1978 a direction to fix seniority in accordance with law has been issued after quashing the seniority list published on 19th April 1977. By notification dated 18th October 1978 (Exhibit-G) respondent-3 was promoted and appointed as Director. The petitioner has presented this writ petition praying for setting aside the said appointment on the ground that it is contrary to law and has also prayed for the issue of a writ of mandamus directing the State Government to consider his case for promotion to the post of Director.

    (ii) In the statement of objections filed by the State Government it is not disputed that all the three Deputy Directors viz., the petitioner, respondent-3 and another, were fully qualified and eligible for consideration of their cases for promotion. However, it is asserted that the Chief Minister, who is holding the portfolio of the Department of Mines and Geology considered respondent-3 as more suitable after considering the cases of the three Deputy Directors. The relevant portion of the statement of objection reads:

    “…As required by the Government Order No. DPAR 76 SRS 76 dated 10th December 1976, the Hon'ble Chief Minister who is also the Minister holding the portfolio of Mines and Geology considered the merits and suitability of all these 3 Dy. Directors with due regard to the seniority. The Hon'ble Chief Minister after examining the service records pertaining to the petitioner, 3rd respondent and Sri Ramachandra Raj Urs and after evaluating the merit and suit, ability and having regard to the seniority as reflected in the seniority list dated 19th April 1977 found 3rd respondent more suitable both on the grounds of merits as well as on seniority.”

    In support of the assertion made in the statement of objection, the State Government has produced the original records. The relevant portion of the proceeding which ended with the appointment of respondent-3, reads as follows:

    “Sub: Filling up the post of Director of Mines & Geology, Bangalore, No. DPAR 247 SHD 78.

    7. The post of Director of Mines and Geology falls vacant w.e.f, 1st October 1978 with the retirement of Sri G. Shivashankar. According to the C & R Rules, the post of Director of Mines and Geology has to be filled up by promotion by selection from the cadre of Deputy Directors and if no suitable person is available for promotion, by Direct recruitment.

    8. The following are the Deputy Directors of Mines and Geology in the order of seniority, who are to be considered for selection and appointment to the post to Director of Mines and Geology:

    Sl. No. Name. Date of Birth. Date of appointment as Deputy Director. Sriyuths: 1. C.N Venkatakumaran 19-8-1929 26-8-1977 2. B. Ramachandraraj Urs. 23-3-1934 1-8-1977 3. T.K Deviraju. 2-2-1933 1-8-1977

    9. All the above-mentioned 3 officers have passed the prescribed Departmental Examinations and the Kannada Language examination. The C.Rs of the officers are placed below.

    10. According to G.O No. DPAR 76 SRS 76 dated 10th December 1976, the merit and suitability of candidates for appointment as Heads of Departments will have to be assessed by the Chief Minister in consultation with the Minister concerned.

    11. The file is submitted for selection of an officer for appointment as Director of Mines and Geology, Bangalore w.e.f 1st October 1978 vice Sri G. Shivashankar, retiring from service.

    12. In this case since Mines and Geology comes under the portfolio of the C.M the selection for the post of Director of Mines and Geology will have to be made by him (C.M)

    13. Since, the Chief Minister also-happens to be incharge of the portfolio of the Mines and Geology, it is only the Chief Minister who has to decide as to which Deputy Director of Mines and Geology should be appointed as Director of Mines and Geology. The C.Rs of the 3 Deputy Directors of Mines and Geology, who have passed the prescribed departmental examinations and who are otherwise eligible for being considered for appointment as Director of Mines and Geology are placed below. The present Director of Mines and Geology is retiring at the end of this month and hence, the C.M may kindly take a decision, on his successor, before that time.

    ………………

    Deputy Director to Government,

    DCA & DPAR (Services & Cabinet)

    14. Since the process of selection takes some time the C.M may order the re-employment of Sri Shivashankar till the end of October 1978, pending approval of the Cabinet.

    15. In the meantime, the papers will be submitted to the C.M for the selection of the successor.

    Sd/—XX

    26th September 1978

    Sd/—D. Devaraj Urs

    Chief Minister.

    18. Orders of re-employment of Sri G. Shivashankar for one month from 1st October 1978 to 31st October 1978 have been issued File is re-submitted for selection of the successor by the Chief Minister Reference para 15 xxx facts of the case are given at paras 7 to 10 xxx. Exposto facto approval of the Cabinet may be obtained after issue of orders on selection of successor.

    21. Shri Veukatakumaran may be appointed.

    Sd/—D. Devaraj Urs,

    Chief Minister,

    13-10-78.

    3. Sri S.K Kulkarni, learned counsel for the petitioner, contended that the records do not disclose that the case of the petitioner was considered. He also argued that reasons should have been given for selecting respondent-3 in preference to the petitioner and another. In the absence of any reason given, he submitted that the selection has to be annulled on the ground that it is arbitrary. In support of his submission he relied on the observations of the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. M.L Capoor(1). The relevant portion reads as follows:

    “28. In the context of the effect upon the rights of aggrieved persons, as members of a public service who are entitled to just and reasonable treatment, by reason of protections conferred upon them by Articles 14 and 16 of the constitution, which are available to them throughout their service, it was incumbent on the Selection Committee to have stated reasons in a manner which would disclose how the record of each officer superseded stood in relation to records of others, who were to be preferred, particularly as this is practically the only Remaining visible safeguard against possible injustice and arbitrariness in making selections. If that had been done, facts on service records of officers considered by the Selection Committee would have been correlated to the conclusions reached. Reasons are the links between the materials on which certain conclusions are based and the actual conclusions. They disclose how the mind is applied to the subject matter for a decision whether it is purely administrative or quasi-judicial. They should reveal a rational nexus between the facts considered and the conclusions reached. Only in this way can opinions or decisions recorded be shown to be manifestly just and reasonable. We think that it is not enough to say that preference should be given because a certain kind of process was gone through by the Selection Committee. This is all that the supposed statement of reasons amounts to. We, therefore, think that the mandatory provisions of Regulation 5(5) were not complied with. We think that reliance was rightly placed by respondents on two decisions of this Court relating to the effect of non-compliance with such mandatory provisions. These were: Associated Electrical Industries (India) Private Limited, Calcutta v. Workmen, AIR 1967 SC 284 and Collector of Monghyr v. Keshav Prasad Goenka, (1963) 1 SCR 98 : (AIR 1962 SC 1694).”

    Relying on the above observations, he submitted that as no reasons are given for the selection of respondent-3, the right for equal opportunity guaranteed to the petitioner under Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution is violated and the selection is also violative of rule 4 of the Karnataka State Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’). He also submitted that the petitioner being a direct recruit to the cadre of Geologist is senior to respondent-3 and that without fixing seniority pursuant to the writ issued by this Court in W.P 3831 of 1977, respondent-3 was treated as senior and there was no justification to supersede his claim.

    4. Sri B.B Mandappa, learned High Court Government Pleader on the contrary, argued that the fact that the names of the petitioner, respondent-3 and another were put up for consideration shows that the cases of all the three officers were considered and by the mere fact that no reasons are given, it cannot be concluded that there was no consideration of comparative merits of the three eligible officers before selecting respondent-3. He referred to the statement of objection in which it is specifically asserted that merit and suitability of all the three Deputy Directors were considered by the Chief Minister and after evaluating the merit and suitability found respondent-3 was more suitable.

    5. Having set out all the relevant facts as stated in the pleadings and also the rival contentions, I shall now proceed to consider the validity of the contentions urged for the parties. The post of Director is a selection post. The procedure for making appointment to a selection post is laid down in rule 4(2) of the Rules which reads;

    “4. PEOCEDURE FOR APPOINTMENT.—

    Subject to the provisions of these rules, appointments to any service or post shall be made……

    (1) ****

    (2) In the case recruitment by promotion,……

    (a) if it is to a post to be filled by promotion by selection, by selection of a person, on the basis of merit and suitability in all respects to discharge the duties of the post with dub regard to seniority, from among persons eligible for promotion:

    (b) if it is to a post other than that referred to in sub-clause (a), by selection of a person on the basis of seniority-cum-merit, that is, seniority subject to fitness of the candidate to discharge the duties of the post, from among persons eligible for promotion.”

    The above rule which prescribes the procedure for appointment also serves the purpose of ensuring compliance to Article 16(1) of the Constitution which guarantees equality of opportunity in matters relating to employment under the State and the right, to equality, guaranteed under Article 14 of the Constitution. The extent of right to which a civil servant is entitled to in the matter of promotion to a selection post is well settled. The right is for a fair and proper consideration. If appointment of an officer to a selection post is made without considering the comparative merit of officers, who under the rules of recruitment are eligible for consideration, an eligible officer whose case has not been considered can legitimately complain, before the Court that his right for consideration is violated. If, on the other hand, on proper consideration of the cases of all the eligible candidates, one of them is found suitable for promotion and others unsuitable, or any one of them is found more suitable in cases where more than one are found suitable for appointment to a selection post, such selection made cannot be a subject matter for judicial review. In such, cases the candidates not selected, whether seniors or juniors, cannot complain of violation of rule 4 of the Rules or violation of Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution. However, if more than one candidate, are adjudged equal in merit, then the claim of senior amongst them, for appointment, cannot be denied. (See: B. Virupakshappa v. State of Mysore.(2)

    6. Therefore the two questions which arise for consideration in this case are:

    (i) Whether the case of the three Deputy Directors were considered by comparing their merit and suitability, and upon such consideration, respondent-3 alone was found suitable or he was found more suitable and the petitioner and another were found unsuitable or less-suitable?

    (ii) All the three Deputy Directors were found equal in merit and suitability and respondent-3 was selected on the ground that he was senior to two others?

    The records do not disclose that consideration of the comparative merit and suitability of the three officers as to their fitness to discharge the duties of the post of Director which is the requirement of rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules preceded the decision to appoint Respondent-3. All that the record shows is that the names of three persons were put up and the Chief Minister recorded that respondent-3 be appointed. No opinion is recorded to the effect that on comparing the merit and suitability of the three officers, respondent-3 was found more merited and suitable for appointment or that respondent-3 alone was found suitable and petitioner and another were found unsuitable for appointment or that respondent-3 was preferred on the ground of seniority, merit and suitability of the three being equal. In fact, as stated earlier, seniority inter se is still to be fined and finalised. In this situation no importance could be attached to the averment made in para-3 of the statement of objection extracted earlier, in which it is stated that the Chief Minister selected respondent-3 after considering the comparative merit and suitability of all the three officers, as the knowledge of the deponent who is an Under Secretary to Government is only derived, from the records as stated by him and the records do not disclose any such information. The deponent speaks to facts which are not borne out by the records. I find it extremely difficult to agree with the learned High Court Government Pleader that as the names of the three officers were put up in the file and one of them was appointed, it shows that the case of the petitioner had been considered. It cannot be presumed that the consideration of comparative merit, which is invisible in the record is nevertheless in existence. It is unsafe to proceed on any such consideration having regard to the valuable rights of officers for consideration of their cases for selection and appointment as any such assumption would render the right illusory.

    7. Another infirmity disclosed from the records, is that no uniform criteria is adopted in the matter of taking into account the confidential records of the eligible officers. In the note prepared on 16th September 1978 by the Deputy Secretary of the Commerce and Industries Department, it is stated that the confidential records for the last three years of the three officers were placed in the file for consideration by the Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms in making the selection. But the original records produced disclose that confidential records of respondent-3 from the year 1960 upto 31st March 1978 were put up whereas the confidential records of the petitioner and another for the period commencing from 1st January 1976 to 31st March 1977 and for the year ending 31st December 1975 alone were put up. The latest confidential reports for the year ending 31st March 1978, pertaining to the petitioner and another are not found in the file. It should be pointed out that even in the matter of taking confidential records for consideration, adoption of uniform rule is necessary to ensure fair and proper consideration. If three years' confidential records of the eligible officers preceding the date of consideration is treated as relevant, it must be so in respect of all the officers. Because exclusion of good or bad record even for any one year out of three years' record which is considered relevant or taking into account, confidential records earlier to three years in the case of one and not taking into account the confidential records for similar period in the case of another, is sure to place one or other office under an advantage or disadvantage as the case may be and open to the criticism that there has been no fair and proper consideration by applying uniform criteria and consequently the right to equality is denied. In the present case though such a criteria was indicated in the earlier note put up by the Industries and Commerce Department, the same was not complied with as the confidential reports of the petitioner and another for the period ending 31st March 1978 were not placed in the file for consideration and there is no explanation as to why it was not placed in the records for consideration, though the confidential record of respondent-3 for the year ending 31st March 1978 was placed in the records.

    8. Further, the seniority was not finalised before considering the case. It is also not clear whether respondent-3 was selected on the ground that three officers were found suitable for appointment and respondent-3 was senior, as he was shown as senior in the note put up or that he was selected on the ground of his merit and suitability. As stated earlier, all the three eligible officers were promoted as Deputy Directors by selection on 29th July 1977. It is no doubt true that confidential reports of respondent-3 are good. But the two confidential reports of the petitioner and another placed in the file also disclose that their record of service is also good and they have no adverse remarks.

    9. In the circumstances and in the absence of any material in the records to indicate that the comparative merit of all the three Deputy Directors was considered while making the selection of respondent-3 indicating the basis of selection, the contention of the petitioner that his case was not considered has to be upheld.

    10. The next point for consideration is, as to whether the recording of reasons for selecting one amongst several eligible officers is or is not necessary? The very existence of the right in the civil servants for a fair and proper consideration of their cases for promotion to higher posts, to which they are eligible to be Considered for promotion, makes it impossible to hold that recording of reasons is not necessary. It is no doubt true that it is the power of the appointing authority to make thees lection but that power has to be exercised in a reasonable manner, because, arbitrary exercise of power is antithesis of Rule of Law, which is one of the basic features of our constitutional system. Compliance to Rule of Law is necessary not only to safeguard the rights of individuals but also to safeguard public interest. In the present case, the public interest involved is the appointment of the most suitable officer to hold the important and responsible post of the Head of the Department under the State Government. In order to ensure that the selection is fair and proper and is in accordance with law, formation of opinion, after applying the mind to the comparative merits and suitability of all the officers eligible for consideration, is essential. The fair and proper consideration could be shown to exist only by recording reasons in making the selection and appointment, because that could only be the visible safeguard for the right for consideration available to a civil servant in the matter of appointments by promotion by selection as observed by the Supreme Court in Capoor's case. If the contention urged for the State Government that recording of reasons is not necessary were to be accepted, then even that only visible safeguard available to the civil servants would cease to exist and would also be detrimental to public interest. Therefore, recording of reasons however brief it may be for selecting one in preference to the other eligible candidates which can be correlated to their confidential reports and the record of their performance in the lower post or posts, is of utmost importance to avoid arbitrariness in making appointments to selection posts and to ensure all the eligible candidates that the State has considered their cases fairly in obedience to the mandate addressed to it to accord equality before law and equal opportunity in matters relating to employment, under the State by Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution. This is the principle laid down by the Supreme Court in Capoor's case. Though the said decision was rendered while interpreting regulation 5(5) of the Indian Administrative Service/Indian Police Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955, which required the recording of reason for supersession, the right was traced to Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution. (See decision of this Court in W.P No. 7432 of 1978, D. dated 10-11-1978, N. Shankara Rao v. K.E.B). Therefore selection of one to the exclusion of other eligible candidates under rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules which is also incorporated to ensure the right of equal opportunity must also disclose a proper consideration and reason for selecting one in preference to the other eligible candidates. Upholding of the decision to appoint respondent-3, which was made without consideration of the comparative merits of the three eligible officers would render the recognised right for consideration meaningless.

    11. In the light of discussion as above, having due regard to the fundamental right for equality before law guaranteed under Article 14 and the right for equal opportunity in matters relating to employment under the State under Article 18(1) of the Constitution read with rule 4(2)(b) of the Rules, my conclusions are as follows:

    (1) In making appointments to a post by promotion by selection, the merit and suitability of all the candidates eligible for consideration must be compared by the appointing authority or the selecting authority, as the case may be, and upon such consideration the official adjudged as suitable or the seniormost officer, if more than one officer are found suitable and adjudged as equal in merit, should be selected and appointed by the appointing authority.

    (2) The only method of ensuring that the requirement to consider the comparative merits of the eligible officers has been complied with, is by recording reasons however brief it may be-indicating that selection has been made on comparing the merit and suitability of the eligible officers as disposed from their confidential reports and other service records.

    (3) The period of confidential records taken into consideration to adjudge the suitability of the eligible offioers should be specific and uniform for all the officers whose cases are considered.

    (4) As seniority assumes importance when more than one officer are found suitable and equal in merit, seniority of all eligible officers should be determined and indicated at the time of consideration of their cases for selection.

    (5) If a decision is taken by the competent authority as to the suitability of an officer for appointment to a higher post having considered the confidential report and service records of all the eligible officers and recording the reasons, such a selection cannot be interfered with by the Court and the Court cannot substitute its judgment in the matter of selection, to that of the competent authority. But, if it is established that before making the appointment there has been no consideration of cases of eligible officers in the required manner and no reason is given for selecting one among the several eligible officers, the selection and appointment, when called in question before the Court by an aggrieved person, is liable to be set aside and the competent authority would have to be directed to make selection and appointment after considering the cases of officers eligible for consideration in accordance with law.

    (6) In the present case, there has been no consideration of the cases of the eligible candidates which includes the petitioner in accordance with law and therefore, the appointment of respondent-3 to the post of Director of Mines and Geology has to be held invalid and the Government should be directed to reconsider the case of all eligible officers and to make fresh appointment of the officer selected after consideration in accordance with law and in the light of this judgment.

    12. However, I am of the opinion that immediate displacement of respondent-3 is not necessary as it takes sometime to make fresh appointment after considering the comparative merits of the eligible officers and as such immediate displacement is likely to cause inconvenience in the administration of the department and, therefore, it would be sufficient to direct the Government to make appropriate orders in accordance with the result of the fresh selection.

    13. For the reasons aforesaid, I make the following order:

    (i) Rule made absolute.

    (ii) A writ of mandamus shall issue to the State Government to consider the case of the petitioner, respondent-3 and any other eligible officers for appointment to the post of Director of Miner and Geology in accordance with law and in the light of this judgment and to make fresh appointment within a period of three months from today.

    (iii) It is further directed that if on such reconsideration, any officer other than respondent-3 is selected and appointed, the appointment of respondent-3 shall cease to be effective from the date of such appointment.

    (iv) No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T.K Devaraju v. The State Of Karnataka & Others
    (Jun 13, 1979)