AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion contains two connected proceedings. First, I.A. No. 3585 of 2011 was an interlocutory application in which the petitioner sought to implead 8,598 employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti as additional petitioners in an existing writ petition. The Court found that this request was made at a very late stage and that the moving party had no authority to represent or implead all such employees; the application was dismissed as misconceived and without basis.

The principal matter is W.P.(S.) No. 4946 of 2008, filed by Sri P.N. Mishra (the sole petitioner). The petitioner, representing through an association, seeks a writ or directions commanding the respondents to implement and adopt a uniform and consistent pension rule for all teaching and non‑teaching staff of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya (Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti) on par with other educational institutions under the Human Resource Department, Government of India.

The petitioner specifically challenged a pension scheme (published by gazette notification dated 31.7.2008) as ultravires of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution and contended it was not framed under Article 309. The factual background in the petition included the Samiti's origin, prior adoption of Central Government rules mutatis mutandis, multiple parliamentary standing committee recommendations for pensionary benefits for Navodaya employees, and government action in 2008 to permit existing employees the option to join the New Pension Scheme (NPS) 2004 or continue with the existing Contributory Provident Fund (C.P.F.) scheme.

The respondents filed counter‑affidavits asserting there had been no pension scheme for Navodaya employees before 2008, that the Samiti (registered as a society in 1986) had governed employees under C.P.F. rules, and that the Government ultimately allowed existing employees an option to join NPS (and made NPS mandatory for recruits after 1.4.2009). The petitioner himself had been on deputation and later absorbed in 1995 under the Samiti's terms and was therefore governed by the Samiti's rules.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the pension scheme/notification (notified in 2008 and treated as effective w.e.f. 1.1.2004) is ultravires of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India and/or invalid for not being framed under Article 309.
  2. Whether employees of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti appointed prior to 1.1.2004 are arbitrarily or unreasonably discriminated against by the choice of the cut‑off date for application of the New Pension Scheme (i.e., whether the cut‑off date offends Article 14).
  3. Whether the petitioner (and by extension those similarly situated) is entitled to directions mandating parity of pensionary benefits with other educational institutions governed by the Human Resource Department.
  4. Procedural: Whether 8,598 employees of the Samiti could be impleaded as petitioners at a late stage through the interlocutory application.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner sought uniform and consistent pension rules for all teaching and non‑teaching staff of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti, comparable with other institutions under the Human Resource Department.
  • He challenged the pension scheme notified in 2008 (effective w.e.f. 1.1.2004) as ultravires of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution, and asserted it was not framed under Article 309.
  • He relied on the history of government and parliamentary committee recommendations (reports of 2005, 2006, 2007) and a review committee report of 29.1.2004 urging parity of pensionary treatment with Kendriya Vidyalaya staff.
  • In the interlocutory application, the petitioner (or movant) attempted to implead some 8,598 employees of the Samiti as co‑petitioners, asserting representative status on their behalf.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that there was no pension scheme applicable to Navodaya employees prior to the 2008 notification and that, historically, employees were governed by a Contributory Provident Fund (C.P.F.) scheme.
  • They stated that the Samiti was constituted and registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 (February 1986) and was later added to the Schedule of the Provident Fund Act, 1925 (1991), but the specific Fourth Pay Commission decisions were not applicable to the Samiti's employees because of its status as a society.
  • In light of employee demands and committee recommendations, the Government decided to allow existing employees the option to join the New Pension Scheme (2004) or continue with C.P.F.; for recruits after 1.4.2009, NPS was made mandatory.
  • Respondents argued that a number of autonomous bodies had similarly not been given old pension benefits and that parity with other institutions could not be insisted upon merely because other institutions had different schemes.
  • Regarding the interlocutory application, respondents implicitly opposed the late, unauthorized attempt to implead thousands of employees represented by one petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sudhir Kumar Consul v. Allahabad Bank, (2011) 3 SCC 486 The fixing of a cut‑off date for granting retirement benefits (creating two classes of employees) can fall within Article 14; differential treatment based on cut‑off date does not necessarily offend Article 14. Cut‑off may be justified by financial implications or terms of appointment. The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that choice of a cut‑off date for pension benefits is ordinarily within the employer's domain and does not, by itself, establish arbitrariness violating Article 14.
All India Reserve Bank Retired Officers' Assn. v. Union of India When an employer introduces a completely new scheme (unconnected with the existing scheme), considerations such as financial implications and capacity to bear burden justify different applicability; a cut‑off need not be arbitrary if rational grounds exist. The Court invoked this case to underline that introducing a new pension scheme may justify a cut‑off date on rational/financial grounds and is not automatically violative of Article 14.
UGC v. Sadhana Chaudhary The choice of a date as a basis for classification is not automatically arbitrary merely because no particular reason is given for the choice; it will stand unless shown to be capricious or widely off the reasonable mark. The Court cited this principle to emphasize that a selected cut‑off date need not be struck down absent a showing that it is capricious or unreasonable.
State of Bihar v. Bihar Pensioners Samaj Fixing of a cut‑off date for granting revised benefits is within governmental powers so long as reasons are not arbitrary and are based on rational considerations. The Court relied on this authority to reinforce that the petitioner must demonstrate that the cut‑off date was arbitrary; absent such a showing, the government's decision stands.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two distinct but related strands: first, it considered the interlocutory application for impleadment; second, it analyzed the merits of the writ petition challenging the pension scheme.

On the interlocutory application (I.A. No. 3585 of 2011), the Court observed that the attempt to implead about 8,598 employees at a late stage and without any authorization was misconceived. The mover had no basis to act as representative for all employees who had not themselves come forward. For these reasons the application was dismissed as without basis.

On the main petition (W.P.(S.) No. 4946 of 2008), the Court reviewed the factual record set out in the petition and counter‑affidavits: the Samiti's registration as a society (February 1986), historical governance of employees under C.P.F. rules, repeated employee demands and parliamentary recommendations for pensionary benefits, and the Government's eventual notification in 2008 allowing existing employees the option to switch to the New Pension Scheme (2004) or remain in C.P.F., with mandatory NPS for recruits after 1.4.2009.

The Court noted that the petitioner himself had come on deputation and was later permanently absorbed w.e.f. 1.7.1995 under the Samiti's terms and conditions; therefore he is governed by the Samiti's absorption rules.

Legally, the Court applied settled principles concerning the validity of cut‑off dates for pension or retirement benefits. Citing the precedents reproduced in the record, the Court observed that the selection of a cut‑off date for applying a new pension scheme is ordinarily within the domain of the employer and the State and will not be set aside unless shown to be arbitrary, capricious, or irrational so as to violate Article 14. The Court quoted and relied on authorities which explain that when a new, distinct scheme is introduced, legitimate considerations (notably financial implications and the employer's capacity to bear burden) may justify differential treatment based on a cut‑off date.

Applying those principles to the facts, the Court found that the petitioner had not demonstrated that the chosen cut‑off date (the New Pension Scheme effective w.e.f. 1.1.2004 as notified in 2008) was arbitrary, unreasonable, or a gross violation of Article 14. The facts in the petition itself and the respondents' affidavits established that the Government had acted after consideration of employee demands and parliamentary recommendations, and that existing employees were given the option to join the new scheme. The Samiti's status as an autonomous society was also material to the Court's analysis of why the Samiti's employees had historically been governed differently from other government educational institutions.

Because the petitioner could not show the requisite arbitrariness or irrationality in fixing the cut‑off date, the Court concluded that no mandamus or directional relief was warranted.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The interlocutory application (I.A. No. 3585 of 2011) seeking impleadment of 8,598 employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti was dismissed as without basis.
  • The writ petition (W.P.(S.) No. 4946 of 2008) filed by Sri P.N. Mishra was dismissed as being without merit.

Implications: The direct effect of the decision is that the petitioner’s request for a declaration that the 2008 notification (with effect from 1.1.2004) was ultravires of Articles 14, 16 and 21, and for directions to impose uniform pension rules on the Samiti, was refused. The Court accepted the respondents' position that existing employees had been offered an option to join the New Pension Scheme or continue with C.P.F., and that the Samiti's prior governance under C.P.F. and its status as a society were relevant factual and legal considerations.

The opinion does not announce any new legal principle; it applies established precedents about the acceptability of cut‑off dates for pension benefits and emphasizes that absent a showing of arbitrariness or irrationality, a cut‑off fixed by an employer or the State will not be interfered with. No broader or novel precedent was set by this order beyond the application of those established authorities to the facts before the Court.


End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion text.

    Shri P.N Mishra Petitioner v. The Union Of India & Others S

    I.A NO. 3585 OF 2011

    Aparesh Kumar Singh, J. The instant Interlocutory application has been filed on behalf of the petitioner praying therein to implead 8598 employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti as petitioners in the present writ petition.

    The petitioner has unnecessarily, at the fag end and at a very late stage sought to implead about 8598 employees/staffs of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti situated in different parts of the country as petitioners in the present writ petition. Moreover, petitioner has unnecessarily without any such authorization taken upon himself as representative and implead all the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti as co-petitioners, although non of them has come forward on their own before this court.

    The said prayer is totally misconceived and cannot be allowed. Accordingly, the said I.A No. 3585 of 2011 seeking impleadment of 8598 employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti is, therefore dismissed as without any basis.

    W.P(S.). No. 4946 of 2008

    1. This writ petition has been preferred by the sole petitioner Sri P.N Mishra seeking issuance of writ, direction, directions commanding upon the respondents to implement and adopt uniform and consistent pension Rule for entire teaching and non-teaching staffs of the Navodaya Vidyalaya as has been adopted in respect of other educational institutions of the Human Resource Department, Government of India.

    2. Petitioner has further assailed the pension scheme approved w.e.f 1.1.2004 and prayed to declare it as ultravires to article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India and not framed under article 309 of the Constitution of India. It is stated that the aforesaid scheme has been published by a gazette notification dated 31.7.2008, so far as staffs of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti is concerned.

    3. Facts of the case are that petitioner claims to be an executive member of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya, B.I.T Mesra, Ranchi Branch represented through All India Navodaya Vidyalaya Staff Association. It is stated that Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya schools have been established all over India by Human Resource Department, Government of India in the year 1985. It is further stated that by office memorandum no. 4/1/87-PIC-1 dated 1.5.1987, the Human Resource Department, Government of India decided to implement the Rules including all the service benefits and pensionary benefits for teaching and non teaching staffs of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti. As per the petitioner the executive committee of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti in its meeting held on 17.1.1992 decided to adopt the Rules and Regulations, circular and procedures applicable to the central government Mutatis & Mutandis till such time the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti formulates its own Rules, which is annexed as annexure-2 to the writ application. However, in the subsequent paragraphs of the writ petition itself it has been stated on behalf of the petitioner that a parliamentary standing committee of Human Resource Department in its 154th report presented before the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha on 2.3.2005 and 3.3.2005 respectively strongly recommended the pensionary benefits to be given to the teaching and non-teaching staffs of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools and Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools and that the said benefits to be extended at par with other schools governed by the Human Resource Department, Government of India. He has further referred to strong recommendation made by the Parliamentary standing committee on 30.11.2006, 17.8.2007 in its 184 and 198 reports. It is further submitted that the report has been submitted by a review committee of the Human Resource Department, Government of India on 29.1.2004 suggesting similar treatment to the employees of the Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools with those of the teaching and non-teaching staffs of Kendriya Vidyalaya Schools for extending and admitting such pensionary benefits.

    4. It also appears from the averments made in the writ petition that the commissioner of Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools, who is controlling authority of Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools, New Delhi had made recommendations on 29.12.2006 for enforcement of pensionary benefits to the teaching and non-teaching staffs of Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools/Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools at par with the employees of the other educational institutions governed by the Human Resource Department, Union of India. The said recommendation is annexed as annexure-3 series.

    5. Based on the aforesaid submissions of facts it is submitted on behalf of the petitioner that teaching and non-teaching staffs of Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools/Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Schools are being discriminated arbitrarily denying their pensionary benefits and other benefits as given to similarly situated educational institutions of Human Resource Department, Government of India. In the circumstances, it is submitted that the notification contained in annexure-1 is highly prejudicial to the teaching and non-teaching staffs of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti, who has been appointed before 1.1.2004 and as such may be declared ultravires violating article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India. The government has come out with a condition that on account of notification contained in annexure-1 there remain uncertainty with respect to pensionary benefits for those employed in Jawahar Navodaya Schools prior to 1.1.2004 Based upon the aforesaid facts the writ petitioner has prayed for the reliefs as made in para 1 of the writ petition.

    6. A number of affidavits have been filed and exchanged on behalf of the parties. Respondents No. 1 to 4 have appeared and filed number of affidavits contesting the stands of the respondents. In sum and substance it has been stated on behalf of the respondents that there was no pension scheme in existence for the employees of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti. The Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti Schools in fact had adopted Contributory Pension Fund Schemes. On the repeated demand of the employees, the Government of India has approved the introduction of new pension scheme for all the regular employees joining the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti after the date of notification, with an option for the regular employees of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti, as on date of notification of New Pension Scheme, to continue with the existing C.P.F Scheme or to join the New Pension Scheme. In case the employee opted for New Pension Scheme in that case the amount accumulated in the C.P.F account will be transferred to the pension fund under the new pension scheme. As per instruction of Government of India the New Pension Scheme is applicable for all the employees, who joined government service after 1.1.2004 and by allowing employees who had joined Navodaya Vidayalaya Samiti working prior to 1.1.2004 to opt for New Pension Scheme.

    7. It is further stated that there are several autonomous bodies in the country where old pension scheme benefit has not been extended to its employees. The employees of the Samiti cannot be allowed to take plea since other institutions have the benefit of pension, the same should be extended as well.

    8. Earlier by order dated 7.12.2011 the respondents were directed to give their positive stand whether there was any G.P.F/Pension Scheme in the year 1986-87 when these appointment were given to the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya. This was in context of the reference of a document shown during the course of argument wherein it was stated that G.P.F/Pension Scheme referred to in the document indicating that if the option is not received within the stipulated period it will be presumed that he or she will be opting G.P.F/Pension. In response to that a counter affidavit was filed by the respondents no. 1 to 4 specifically in respect of the observations made by this court in its order dated 7.12.2011

    9. In para 8 of their affidavit it has been stated that Navodaya Vidalaya Samiti was constituted and registered under Society Registration Act, 1860 in the month of February, 1986 (annexure-A to the counter affidavit) and by ministry of Finance notification dated 11.11.1991 the name of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti was added in the Scheduled of Provident Fund Act, 1925 (annexure-B). This was followed by Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti circular dated 17.12.1991 It is stated that Rules for absorption of deputationists in Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti are enclosed as annexure-D.

    10. It is the categorical stand of the respondents that the petitioner, Sri P.N Mishra came on deputation from Bihar State Leather Industry Development Corporation, Ranchi to the post of Office Superintendent initially for a period of three years w.e.f 3.3.1990 (annexure-E). Subsequently, on acceptance of resignation from his post in the parent organization, he was absorbed in Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti w.e.f 1.7.1995 vide order dated 4.4.1997 (annexure-F). The terms and conditions of his appointment were as given in the permanent absorption Rules of the Samiti (Annexure-D). The respondent have submitted that the petitioner is guided by the terms and conditions of his absorption made as per the Rules of the Samiti. It is categorically been stated on behalf of the respondents that ever since the inception of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti and after being registered in February, 1986 the employees of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti have never been given the option of G.P.F/Pension under the Pension Rule, 1972. All through till 2008 the employees were governed by the C.P.F Rules, although, there was persistent demand from the employees for introduction of the Pension. The demands of the employees for introduction of pension were considered by the government from time to time but could not be agreed to since as per the decision taken by the Government of India on the recommendations of Fourth Pay Commission, all the C.P.F beneficiaries in service as on 1st January, 1986 had been given an option to switch over to Pension/G.P.F/Scheme. As the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti was established as a Society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, the said recommendations were not applicable to the employees of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti.

    11. In the circumstances, it is submitted that ultimately it was decided by the Government to give option to the existing employees either to join the New Pension Scheme, 2004 or to continue with the existing C.P.F scheme. For the new recruits joining after 1.4.2009, the New Pension Scheme is mandatory.

    12. From the submission made on behalf of the petitioner read with averments made in the writ petition and the contention made on behalf of the respondents together with the averments made in the counter affidavits including the last affidavit dated 6.2.2012, one thing is clear that even the petitioner admits that the benefits of pensionary scheme were not available to the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti till the notification of the said scheme in the year 2008 giving option to the existing employees to join the new pension scheme, 2004 or to continue with the existing C.P.F Scheme. Moreover, from the averments made in the writ petition itself it is absolutely clear that taking note of the repeated demand of the employees of the Navodaya Vidalaya Samiti even the Parliamentary committee had made strong recommendations for inclusion of the employees of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti under the pensionary scheme and for treating them at par with other employees of the educational institutions under the Human Resource Department, Government of India. It appears that based upon the said recommendations itself the Government of India finally decided to come out with a notification in the year 2008 whereby the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti were allowed to join the New Pension Scheme, 2004 or to continue with the existing C.P.F Scheme. This fact is also clear from the affidavits filed by the respondents as well as the last affidavit dated 6.2.2012

    13. On the other hand petitioner had initially joined as a deputationist under the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti, whose services were later on absorbed w.e.f 1.7.1995 vide Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti order dated 4.4.1997 (annexure-F to the affidavit dated 6.2.2012). The said order clearly speaks that the petitioner is being absorbed permanently as Office Superintendent in the Samiti w.e.f 1.7.1995 under the terms and conditions as laid down by the Samiti. Petitioner, thereafter is guided by the Rules framed by the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti and are governed by the same.

    14. It is a settled principle of law that cut of date of notification of pensionary scheme is within domain of the employer and is not subject to interference ordinarily unless it is arbitrary and unreasonable and some gross case of violation of Article 14 is made out. It would be profitable to quote the observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India on the choice of cut of date in the matter of grant of benefit of pension etc. on an employee by his employer. Reference may be made to the judgment delivered in the case of Sudhir Kumar Consul v. Allahabad Bank., reported in (2011) 3 SCC 486 which is as follows:-

    “18. Moreover, the fixing of the cut-off date for granting retirement benefits such as gratuity or pension under the different schemes incorporated in the subordinate legislation, thereby, creating two distinct and separate classes of employees is well within the ambit of Article 14 of the Constitution. The differential treatment of two sets of officers appointed prior to the notified date would not offend Article 14 of the Constitution. The cut-off date may be justified on the ground that additional outlay as involved or the fact that under the terms of appointment, the employee was not entitled to the benefit of pension or retirement.

    22. In All India Reserve Bank Retired Officers' Assn. v. Union of India, the Retired Officers' Association of Reserve Bank of India questioned the validity of introduction of pension scheme in lieu of Contributory Provident Fund Scheme. The bank employees, who retired prior to 1-1-1986, had not been given benefit of the said Pension Scheme. This Court held that the said cut-off date was neither arbitrary nor artificial or whimsical. It was further observed: (SCC pp. 677-78, para 10)

    “10. … The underlying principle is that when the State decides to revise and liberalise an existing pension scheme with a view to augmenting the social security cover granted to pensioners, it cannot ordinarily grant the benefit to a section of the pensioners and deny the same to others by drwing an artificial cut-off line which cannot be justified on rational grounds and is wholly unconnected with the object intended to be achieved. But when an employer introduces an entirely new scheme which has no connection with the existing scheme, different considerations enter the decision making process. One such consideration may be the financial implications of the scheme and the extent of capacity of the employer to bear the burden. Keeping in view its capacity to absorb the financial burden that the scheme would throw, the employer would have to decide upon the extent of applicability of the scheme.”

    23. In UGC v. Sadhana Chaudhary this Court has observed: (SCC p. 546, para 21)

    “21. … It is settled law that the choice of a date as a basis for classification cannot always be dubbed as arbitrary even if no particular reason is forthcoming for the choice unless it is shown to be capricious or whimsical in the circumstances. When it is seen that a line or a point there must be and there is no mathematical or logical way of fixing it precisely, the decision of the legislature or its delegate must be accepted unless it can be said that it is very wide off the reasonable mark.”

    30. In State of Bihar v. Bihar Pensioners Samaj this Court held: (SCC p. 71, para 17)

    “17. We think that the contention is well founded. The only ground on which Article 14 has been put forward by the learned counsel for the respondent is that the fixation of the cut-off date for payment of the revised benefits under the two notifications concerned was arbitrary and it resulted in denying arrears of payments to certain sections of the employees. This argument is no longer res integra. It has been held in a catena of judgments that fixing of a cut-off date for granting of benefits is well within the powers of the Government as long as the reasons therefor are not arbitrary and are based on some rational consideration.”

    15. From the discussion of the case of the parties made herein above it is clear that the new pension scheme has come into force w.e.f 1.1.2004 upon a conscious decision of the employers i.e Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti on approval of the Government of India in the year 2008. The petitioner has not been able to show any grounds for treating the said cut of date as arbitrary, unreasonable and irrational or in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The mere fact that other institutions had been governed by different pensionary schemes since earlier point of time will not entitle the petitioner to claim that the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti is legally obliged to follow the same as it is an autonomous body, admittedly framed under the Societies Registration Act. As such even the employees in service prior to 1.1.2004 have been granted benefits to switch over to the new scheme as per the provisions of the scheme. Sympathies have no place in a society governed by the Rule of law as been eminently observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in para 31 the judgment delivered in the case of Sudhir Kumar Consul v. Allahabad Bank. (Supra) which is as follows:-

    “31. We have sympathies for the appellant but, in a society governed by the rule of law, sympathies cannot override the Rules and Regulations. We may recall the observations made by this Court while considering the issue of compassionate appointment in public service”.

    16. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the factual position discussed above, we are of the considered view that the writ petitioner has failed to make out a case for issuance of any direction or mandamus upon the respondents in the manner prayed by him in para 1 of the writ petition.

    17. The writ petition is without any merit and accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri P.N Mishra Petitioner v. The Union Of India & Others S
    (Mar 2, 2012)