.
During investigation, involvement of these appellants in the
alleged kidnapping and murder of Sumit Kumar Ojha alias Govind was
surfaced whereafter Swapan Kumar Jha and Amarendra Kumar Sharma
@Vickky were apprehended and they made their confessional statement
disclosing therein that they had hired an Indica Car No. JH 09D 6666 and
made a plan to kidnap Gautam Kumar Ojha (brother of the deceased) who
was studying at Kolkata. Thereafter, all the three appellants went Kolkata
on 24.9.2008 and stayed in a Hotel. The plan of kidnapping for ransom was
mainly hatched out by Swapan Kumar Jha and initially he made target to
Gautam who is none else, but the maternal cousin of Swapan Kumar Jha
and accordingly Gautam was taken into contact. In course of wandering with
the appellants, Gautam Kumar Ojha sent SMS to his room-mate informing
that he is in the company of the accused persons. Considering the aforesaid
aspect, the appellants dropped their plan to kidnap Gautam Kumar Ojha and
returned to Jharia (Dhanbad) and again targeted Sumit Kumar @ Govind
who was younger brother of Gautam. On some pretext, Sumit was called by
the appellants whereafter, Sumit met with them near Children Park, Jharia
and from there, he boarded in the Indica Car occupied by appellants Swapan
Kumar Jha and Vickky Sharma besides the driver of the said Car. Sumit
was taken by them to Khalsa Hotel, Govindpur and they were also followed
by the friends of the appellants who were in a Bolero Car. All of them
wanted to consume liquor in the hotel, but Sumit did not agree to consume
liquor in the hotel, as a result, they purchased a wine/whiskey bottle and
proceeded towards Giridih. On the way to Giridih, all of them consumed
liquor and Sumit too was forced to have. They went to the house of Vickky
Sharma appellant no.2, where tea mixed with sleeping drug was
administered to Sumit after which he slept and was removed by the
companion of the appellants towards Kolkata.
Thereafter the appellants had made a call demanding Rs.
20,000,00/- ( rupees twenty lakhs) from the informant against release of
Sumit, but Appellants 1 and 2 were apprehended by the Police and were
forwarded to Jail custody.
3. The appellants were taken on police remand after which again
confession of appellant no. 1 was recorded on the basis of which the dead
body of Sumit @ Govind was recovered, in the presence of an Executive
Magistrate, the witnesses and the public, from a graveyard situated at
Bhandaridih, Dist. Giridih. The process of digging out the dead body was
also videographed. At the conclusion of the investigation, charge sheet
against these appellants was submitted and they were put on trial.
4. The appellants were charged for offences punishable under
sections 364A/302/201/34 of the Indian Penal Code to which they denied.
5. The prosecution had examined altogether 14 witnesses to
substantiate the charges, whereas the appellants had examined Dr. C.K. Sahi
as DW1 in their defence.
6. Sudhansu Shekhar Ojha happens to be the father of the
deceased and also the informant and he has been examined as PW9. He has
supported the prosecution case as made out by him in the written report,
which has been proved as Ext.3. He (PW9) has deposed that on the pointing
out of appellants 1 and 2, the dead body of Sumit was dug out from a
Kabristan situated at Bhandaridih, Giridih, on 19.10.2008 in presence of the
executive magistrate and witnesses and the dead body was identified by
him as that of his son Sumit. He has also supported the fact that the
appellants had been to Kolkata and they contacted Gautam Kumar Ojha and
moved with him in a white Indica Car .
Since Gautam Kumar Ojha had informed his room-mate about
his movement with the appellants, he was dropped and the appellants
changed their plan to kidnap Gautam, and returned to Bokaro. This witness
had identified the appellants and disclosed that appellant no. 1 is the son of
his sister. Gautam Kumar Ojha PW6 has confirmed this fact that the
appellants had been to Kolkata and he was contacted by them. They moved
together on a white Indica Car, but later, he was left by the accused
appellants. When Gautam learnt about the arrest of appellant no.1 and his
companion and also about the missing of his brother Sumit, he had disclosed
that the appellants had gone to Kolkata and they met him. Appellant no.1
Swapan Kumar Jha had introduced Vicky Sharma and Rockey Dutta
(appellants 2 and 3) who were accompanying him.
7 PW4 Muktipado Sen, and PW5 Shankar Sharma to whom
Sumit was known had seen Sumit boarding in a white Indica Car on
28.09.2008 at about 4.30 p.m, near Children Park and the said vehicle was
occupied by two persons, besides the driver of the car. When they learnt
about the kidnapping and murder of Sumit, they had disclosed this fact to the
appellants and also to the informant and his family members.
8 Ashok Kumar Ojha PW1 and Sridhar Ojha PW3 are uncles of
the deceased and they have supported the prosecution case as disclosed to
them by the informant PW9 and his wife. Both of them have stated that on
28.9.2008 in the evening at about 4.30 p.m. Sumit alias Govind after
receiving a phone call left home, but did not return. After two days, ransom
was demanded by the miscreants and after the arrest of appellants 1 and 2,
they learnt that Govind was kidnapped by them and he was killed . The dead
body of Sumit alias Govind was recovered from the graveyard and it was
identified by the family members. Both the witnesses (PW1 and 3) are
hearsay witnesses and they had reproduced the details regarding the incident
heard by them. Sabita Ojha PW8 happens to be the mother of the deceased
Sumit and she has stated that on 28.9.2008 while she was at home, she had
received a phone call on the land line. The caller did not disclose his identity
and said that he is a friend of Govind and requested to hand over the receiver
to Sumit. Conceding the request, she called her son Sumit alias Govind, who
attended the call and then told this witness that he would be coming back
within half an hour and left home. When Sumit did not return till late
evening, the matter was brought to the notice of his father. On the next
morning, missing report of Sumit was given to the Police. Two / three days
thereafter, they received another phone call by which a sum of rupees twenty
lakhs was demanded against release of Sumit and then the written report
was lodged. The dead body of Sumit was recovered from the graveyard after
about 20 days of the occurrence, she had identified the deadbody of her son
Sumit at the post mortem house. Further story that Sumit was boarded in the
white Indica Car near Children Park is also supported by this PW8.
9. Gautam Kumar Ojha PW6 is the brother of the deceased and he
has stated that he was informed about the missing of Sumit by one of his
friends whereafter he reached home on 29.9.2008. Since the appellants had
been to Kolkata and he moved with them on the white Indica Car, he made a
call to the appellant no.1 and informed about the missing of Sumit. It was
replied by appellant no.1 that he is now at Gaya and this conversation took
place on 3.10.2008. After the arrest of appellants no.1 and 2, he disclosed to
his parent that appellants 1, 2 and 3 had been to Kolkata and appellant no.1
made a call to him and said that he had purchased a car and invited him for
roaming with them in the car and he joined the company. When this witness
wanted to inform about his movement to his room-mate, appellant no. 1
restrained him from doing so, but getting an opportunity, he had informed
his room-mate by sending SMS. When this fact came to the knowledge of
the appellants, they dropped him and returned back to Bokaro. This witness
has also shown his presumption that the appellants might have a plan to
kidnap him, but they could not succeed, because he informed his room-mate
about his movement with the appellants. According to this witness, his
presumption turned into truth when appellants 1 and 2 were arrested with
the charge of kidnapping Sumit. This witness has also supported the
recovery of the dead body of Sumit Kumar Ojha alias Govind and he has
also claimed to have identified the dead body of his brother. Further, all the
accused appellants were identified by him and he has disclosed the name of
the driver of the said Indica Car as Dulal Mahto.
Hiralal Mahto PW7 and Md. Imtiaz Khan PW14 are formal
witnesses. PW7 has proved the seizure of the vehicle and he has stated that
the Indica car No. JH 09D 6666 was seized in connection with this case and
the said vehicle belongs to Sandhya Nandkuliyar. At the time of seizure of
the vehicle, he could learn about the kidnapping of a boy. PW14 has
produced the clothes of the deceased which were collected from the dead
body and the said clothes have been marked as material Ext. 2. Sanjeev
Kumar Das, judicial Magistrate had recorded the statement of the driver,
Dulal Mahto PW2 under Section 164 Cr.P.C.
Mahboob Alam PW11 is the Secretary of Ishlahul Mominin
Anjuman, Bhandaridih. According to his deposition, on19.10.2008 in the
afternoon, the dead body of a male was dug out from Bhandaridih
graveyard. Before digging out the dead body from the graveyard, permission
from the local administration was sought for. At the time of recovery of the
dead body, besides him, Govt. officials, police and many people were
present there. The wearing apparels of the deceased were explained by him.
The star witness of the prosecution is Dulal Mahto PW2 who
was the driver of the said white Indica Car No. JH 09D 6666. According to
his statement, on 23.8.2008, at the request of the appellants no. 1, the
aforesaid vehicle was given to him on rent. He was directed to come to
Dhanbad and from Bank More, Dhanbad, he took appellant no. 1, 2 and 3
to Koklata. The appellants stayed in a hotel at Kolkata and contacted
Gautam ( brother of Sumit). All the appellants moved with Guatam hither
and thither on that car. Thereafter, Gautam was left at Kolkata and they
returned back to Bokaro. Again on 27.9.2008, they went to Giridih via
Dhanbad. They went to the house of appellant no, 2 and spent that very
night at his house. On the following day, at about 2/3 P.M. they came back
to Jharia and made a call to Sumit and asked him to come near Children
Park. Sumit was picked up by appellant no. 1 and at that time, he was
accompanied by appellant no. 2. They went to a coffee house and after
having snacks, again proceeded towards Khalsa Hotel. They wanted to have
liquor, but Sumit did not agree and therefore they purchased liquor from the
shop and proceeded towards Giridih. On the way to Giridih, they consumed
liquor and Sumit was also forced to have. They went to the house of
appellant no. 2 where appellant no. 3 also reached. On the next morning,
appellants 1 to 3, who were standing out side the house, were talking that
"15/20 lakh firauti mil jayega". After seeing this witness, they became
silent. When he asked about Sumit, they said that he would be dropped by
them and thereafter Rs.4000/- ( four thousand ) against the hire of the car
was paid by appellant no. 3 to this witness (PW2) and after that, he returned
to Bokaro. After two days, he learnt about the kidnapping of Sumit and then
he had reasons to believe that Sumit was kidnapped by these appellants.
He (PW2) further says that his statement was also recorded by
the Magistrate and he has proved signature on that statement marked Exts. 1,
1/1 and 1/2. He had identified all the appellants who were present in court at
the time of his deposition. In his cross examination, he has admitted that he
had already informed the owner of the vehicle that the vehicle was hired by
the appellants for going to Kolkata. Initially, he was not knowing either
Gautam or Sumit, but in course of moving with the appellants and after
reporting of the occurrence, he learnt about them. He had not produced any
receipt with regard to filling of fuel in the vehicle. This witness has
answered all the questions put to him in his cross examination.
10. Dr. Vineet P.Tigga PW10 had conducted autopsy on the dead
body of Sumit on 19.10.2008 at PMCH, Dhanbad, at 9.00 p.m. in artificial
light, after receiving instructions from the local administration. The
following facts were noticed by PW10 during post mortem examination :-
1. Lacerated wound 2" x 1"x bone deep, just below
the right angle of mouth where lower jaw was
found fractured;
2. Closed closed fracture of lower jaw was also found
on the left side;
On dissection :
(a) Echymosis was found underneath scalp in an
area 2"x 1 ½" on the left side of frontal bone;
(b) 3"x1" on the right side occipital parietal
region;
Brain was found liquified.
Echymosis was also found in subcutaneous tissues
of both sides in front of neck. Greater cornova of
Hyoid bone was found fractured on the right side.
Heart was empty, flabby and in a softening state.
Stomach contained 50 grams of pasty food
emitting alcoholic smell. Bladder was empty,
spleen liquefied. All other organs were in
liquefying state. Appendix was found missing.
Portion of heart, lungs, liver spleen, one whole
dissected kidney along with stomach with its
contents preserved, sealed, labeled and handed
over to the constable to he sent for chemical
analysis.
Time elapsed since death 20 to 25 days.
Cause of death - death due to asphyxia as a result of throttling. Viscera has
been preserved for chemical analysis.
Other injuries were caused by hard and blunt object.
The post mortem report has been marked as Ext. 4. He further stated that the
FSL report indicates that alluminium phosfide was detected in the portion
of viscera.
Post mortem report has been proved as Ext. 4.
The report received from the Forensic Science Laboratory was
indicative of the fact that alluminium phosfide was detected .
11 Sia Saran Prasad who is the investigating officer was examined
as PW13. He has proved formal FIR, seizure list and other documents as per
the Exhibit list and deposed that station Diary Entry 749 dated 29.9.2008
was made on the basis of the information lodged by the informant PW9 in
respect of missing of his son Sumit alias Govind. On 1.10.2008, the written
report was lodged he took charge of the investigation and recorded
statements of the witnesses and subsequent statement of the informant PW9.
The first place of occurrence from where Sumit (deceased) boarded in Indica
Car has been described in paragraph 8 of his deposition and the place is a
road near Children Park, Jharia. In course of investigation, mobile used by
the appellants were put on track and after getting their locations, house of
appellant no. 2 was raided, whereafter appellants 1 and 2 were arrested. Both
of them had given their confessional statements which have been proved as
Exts. 8 and 9.. Two mobile sets were also seized and seizure list happens to
be Ext. 10. The investigating officer PW13 had also visited Golden Deer
Guest House, Kolkata, and detected that on 24.9.2008 in the afternoon, the
appellants had taken room No. 204 and the waiter Ghanshyam Behra had
confirmed that the appellants had come on a white car No. JH 09D 6666.
The aforesaid car was seized by the investigating officer from the house of
Subodh Kumar Nandkuliyar and the seizure list (Ext 10/1) was prepared.
The apprehended accused appellants were produced before the Court and
they were taken on police remand after which the dead body of Sumit alias
Govind was recovered on 19.10.2008 from the graveyard situated at
Bhandaridih, Giridih. Confessional statement of appellant no.1 was again
recorded on 18.10.2008 which has been proved at Ext. 11. This witness
( Investigating Officer ) has described in detail about the graveyard and its
location from where the dead body of Sumit was recovered. The Call Detail
Report (CDR) of the mobile used by the appellants were obtained and after
concluding the investigation, chargesheet against all the three appellants was
submitted under sections 302/364a/201/34 ipc and in his examination, he
admits that no DNA test was done and it is incorrect to say that they had
recovered only a skeleton. He admits that he did not examine the person in
whose name those SIM Cards which were used by the appellants, were
issued.
12. The appellants had also examined Dr. D.K. Sahi as DW 1 in
their defence. DW1 has proved the report by which he referred the dead
body to be examined by the medical board of PMCH Dhanbad, because the
dead body was in an advanced stage of decomposition. The report has been
proved as Ext. 1 and signatures of the doctor (DW1) appearing on that report
has been proved as Exts. A/1, A/2 and A/3. According to him, the dead body
was not in a state of identification. Skin and muscles were liquefied and it
was not possible to find out soft tissues injuries. In his cross examination,
he admits that in the forwarding report, the name of the deceased was
mentioned as Sumit alias Govind.
13. The appellants had mainly taken the following plea :
(i) There is no direct evidence against the appellants and the
case is based on circumstantial evidence. The chain of circumstantial
evidence is incomplete and the same is not leading towards the guilt of the
appellants, excluding all hypotheses of their innocence.
(ii) The dead body was highly decomposed and major portions
of the body were liquified. It was not in a position to be identified, which is
evident from the evidence of DW1.
(iii) The ingredients of section 364 A of the Indian Penal Code
are not attracted and the prosecution has failed to adduce evidence that any
of these appellants had put forth any demand for ransom.
(iv) The prosecution has brought on record two confessional
statements of the appellant no.1 recorded at different intervals and therefore
it could not be said that the confessional statement was leading to discovery
consequent upon which the dead body of Sumit was recovered and the
confessional statement is not admissible in evidence even after application
of Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
(v) The statement appearing in the alleged confession, if relied
upon, gives a different story which stood uninvestigated. The cause of death
as appearing from the post mortem report was never confessed by any of the
appellant. No reliance can be placed on the evidence of PW2, because his
conduct does not appear to be acceptable.
(vi) The investigation is not proper; many laches are apparent
and on the basis of such poor investigation, capital punishment could not be
awarded;
(vii) The statement of material witnesses are contradictory to
each other on material points;
(viii) On behalf of the appellant no. 3, specific plea has been
taken that he was not present with the other appellants at the alleged place
and time of kidnapping of Sumit;
(ix) On behalf of appellant 1, point has been raised that on the
basis of the same evidence, remaining two appellants have been awarded
imprisonment for life, but he has been inflicted with capital punishment.
Learned Sessions Judge has not considered the aggravating and mitigating
circumstances appearing on record and the case of appellant 1 has wrongly
been framed as the rarest of the rare case.
14. On the other hand, the prosecution has relied upon several
circumstances which are as follows :
(i) the appellants had been to Kolkata and they invited Gautam
Kumar Ojha (PW6) to ride on the car on the pretext that appellant no. 1 had
purchased the car. Accordingly, Gautam Kumar Ojha accompanied the
appellants and moved with them on the said white Indica car, but the
information sent by him to his friend(s) with regard to his movement
cautioned the appellants and they dropped their plan to kidnap Gautam
Kumar and returned back to Bokaro.
(ii) The appellants thereafter made target to the younger brother
Sumit Kumar Ojha alias Govind and enticed him to accompany them and
accordingly on 28.9.2008 at about 4.30 p.m, Sumit alias Govind (deceased)
went in their company and boarded the car near children park, Jharia. Sumit
was seen boarding in the car by Pws 4 and 5.
(iii) Parents of the deceased Sumit received a call for ransom
against release of Sumit on 1.10.2008 and the miscreants had demanded
rupees twenty lakhs.
(iv) During investigation, mobile phone no. from which calls
were received were put on track and the Police had succeeded to apprehend
the appellants 1 and 2. During investigation, the Investigating Officer had
collected the call details report (CDR) and seized the mobile phones with
SIM cards used, from possession of the appellants.
(v) On the basis of the confessional statements, dead body of
Sumit alias Govind was recovered from the graveyard situated at
Bhandaridih (Giridih).
(vi) The car used for committing the offence was seized and the
statement of the owner as well as the driver was recorded.
. (vii) The post mortem report is indicative of the fact that Sumit
was assaulted, sustained injuries on his face and died due to throttling. The
viscera report has proved the presence of smell of alcohol and poisonous
substance.
15. After having heard both sides, we have examined the evidence
on record and perused the impugned judgment. No doubt, direct evidence
against the appellants is not apparent and therefore, we have to scrutinize
the circumstantial evidence available on the record. In the entire episode, use
of a white Indica car by the appellants has come in light. It reveals from the
record and also from the evidence of PW2 that the While Indica Car No.JH-
09D 6666 which was hired by the appellants had been seized. Dulal Mahto
PW2 was the driver of the said car. According to his evidence, on 23.9.2008,
the aforesaid car was given under the control of appellants 1 to 3 at Bank
More, Dhanbad. On the next day, the appellants went to Kolkata, booked a
room in a hotel and met with Gautam (PW6). Initially, he was made target
but the precaution taken by Gautam saved him. Since he had informed his
friend about his movement with the appellants, he was left there.
16. Again, according to the evidence of PW2, appellants returned
back to Bokaro but on 28.9.2008, they came to Dhanbad on the said car and
on that occasion, appellant 1 and 2 were with him. The vehicle was parked
near Children Park, Jharia from where Sumit was picked up and then they
proceeded towards Giridih, but on the way, they consumed liquor and Sumit
was also compelled to have. After reaching Giridih, they went to the house
of Vickey Sharma ( appellant no.2) and stayed there. Dulal Mahto PW2
spent the night in the car, whereas Sumit and the appellants remained
inside the house. In the morning, the driver overheard while the appellants
had been talking for ransom of Rs. 15/20 lakhs. Thereafter, he demanded
fare against the hire of the car and Rs. 4000/- (four thousand) was paid by
the appellant Rockey Dutta after which he returned to Bokaro on his car.
When he heard about the missing of Sumit, he had reasons to believe that
Sumit was kidnapped by those three accused/appellants. Statement of this
witness was also recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C.
17. The evidence that Sumit had boarded in the car near the
Children Park, Jharia, on 28.9.2008 finds support from the evidence of Pws
4 and 5 to whom Sumit was known from before. Presence of these two
witnesses at the relevant place and time finds support from the evidence of
the investigating officer. PW4 Mukti Pada Sen was present at a cycle
repairing shop, whereas Shankar Sharma PW5 was having a Saloon situated
near the place. Furthermore, the evidence of Pws 8 Sabita Ojha is very clear
that she received phone call on the land-line and the caller had expressed his
desire to talk with Sumit. Accordingly, the receiver was given to Sumit,
who, after attending the call, informed his mother that he would be coming
within half an hour, left home. Since 28.9.2008, Sumit was found missing;
information was given to Police and Station Diary Entry on the following
morning was made. On 1.10.2008, PW9 received a call by which ransom
was demanded against release of Sumit. Thereafter, FIR was lodged and the
police came in action. The mobile used by the miscreants were put on track
after which the appellants 1 and 2 were apprehended. From their possession,
mobile phones and SIM cards used by them were seized. Later, dead body of
Sumit was recovered on the basis of the confession made by those
appellants. The dead body was recovered in presence of a Magistrate and
Sadar of Kabristan and videography was done. The dead body was highly
decomposed, but identified by Pws. 1,6,8 and 9.
Therefore, the prosecution evidence remain quite consistent
from beginning to end i.e.from the stage the appellants had hired the car
for committing the offence and till recovery of the dead body from the
graveyard situated at Bhandaridih. We do not find any missing link giving
rise to any hypothesis of the innocence of the appellants. In view of the
above, we do not agree with the submissions that the chain of circumstantial
evidence are not complete.
18. The learned counsel for the appellants also drew our attention
to the evidence of DW1 and contended that the dead body was not of Sumit,
because it was not in a position to be identified. But after discussion of the
evidence of Pws1,6,8 and 9, learned counsels have conceded and they have
dropped that point. Even though, we think it necessary to mention that the
marks of old surgery appearing on the person of Sumit was noticed by the
witnesses and the surgery was done for the purpose of removal of his
appendix.
19. The next point raised on behalf of the appellants was that no
ransum was paid to any appellant and no direct evidence with regard to the
conversation held between the appellants and the witnesses has come on the
record. In this regard, learned Sessions Judge has discussed the point in
detail in the impugned judgment. The informant has clearly stated that
on1.10.2008, he received a phone call by which a sum of rupees twenty
lakhs was demanded against release of Sumit; only thereafter, the FIR was
lodged. The call details report which are admissible under section 65(B) of
the Evidence Act are available on the record.
20. Learned counsel vehemently argued with regard to the
application of Section 27 of the Evidence Act and the investigation done.
We have already discussed that after the arrest of appellants 1 and 2, they
had been forwarded to Jail custody and again, they were taken on police
remand and on the basis of their confessional statements, the police party
proceeded to Giridih and the executive Magistrate was appointed,
permission was sought from the Administration and Sadar of the concerned
graveyard and in presence of the aforesaid authorities and a large number of
people, the dead body of Sumit was dug out and accordingly inquest report
and other formalities were done. The identification of the particular place
where the dead body was buried, could become possible only on the
pointing out of the appellants . The digging out of the dead body was
videographed. Therefore, the available confession made by the appellants
was leading to recovery of the dead body and this part of their confession is
quite admissible under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. We do agree that
remaining part of the confession shall not be considered as the ground for
their conviction .
21. It appears that the appellants had, some how or the other, tried
to mislead the investigation and they did not disclose as to how Sumit was
actually murdered. They did not confess the manner of occurrence, but it
would not make any difference in view of the theory of last seen applicable
in the case of circumstantial evidence. Again, it would not be out of place to
mention that PW2 had left Sumit in the company of these appellants where-
after Sumit was not seen alive. Furthermore, on the basis of the confession,
the dead body was recovered and part of confession finds support from the
evidence of Pws 2, 4,5,11 and 14, the post mortem report, the viscera report
and the material Exhibits.
22. After analysing the evidence in detail and with objectivity it
becomes clear that the accused persons in a pre-planned manner identified a
target for kidnapping with a motive to realise ransom. Accordingly, they
executed their plan meticulously. From their acts, it is apparent that the
accused persons were led by Swapan Jha as he had identified and fixed the
target. He was the best person who knew the background of the informant
and his prosperity. He is the own Bhagina of the informant. After
identifying the target a plan was hatched out and the target was son of the
informant. Initially they had planned to entice Gautam Kumar Ojha (PW6)
from Calcutta, but it failed. The factum of going to Calcutta in white Indica
Car is proved as per the evidence of Pw1,2 and 6 and the investigating
officer. A police team had gone to Calcutta and verifications were made.
After the failure of such plan the accused developed an alternate plan i.e.
kidnapping of the younger son of the informant. Accused Swapan Jha along
with others succeeded in kidnapping Sumit Kumar Ojha. The plan succeeded
and was executed.
The idea prevailing in the mind of the accused is apparent and
they knew what was to be done. They were aware of the consequence. It is
well known that whenever kidnapping is done by a known person, there is
hardly any chance of survival of the victim. Thus, from the very beginning
the accused persons knew that the victim if kidnapped he shall be done away
with. The chances of return of a known victim alive is remote. In this case,
the victim is the own cousin of the accused/appellant Swapan Kumar Jha.
The question of allowing the victim return alive was remote even if ransom
was paid. The presence of criminal intent ( mens rea) is present from the
very beginning and the accused persons had made all preparations and had
plans for committing murder of the victim. In this case, even after the
murder, the accused persons had the guts to call the informant and make a
demand for ransom. From the evidence adduced, it has already been proved
that they had secretly buried the body in a graveyard in a professional
manner. Their criminal intent is proved beyond shadows of reasonable
doubt".
23. The facts and circumstances appearing from the case in hand
entirely tally with the facts and circumstances of the case of Vikram Singh
Vs. State of Punjab ( 2010(3) SCC 56). In that case, a school going boy,
aged 16-17 years was kidnapped for ransom and known persons were
involved in the kidnapping. The boy was kidnapped in a car, which was
borrowed by one of the accused. To overpower the boy, Chloroform was
administered. The accused persons had demanded rupees fifty lakhs from the
father of the deceased, but during investigation, they were apprehended and
the vehicles used for committing the offence were seized. On the basis of
confession, incriminating articles were recovered and finally the accused
were held guilty and awarded capital punishment.
24. In view of the discussions made above and the materials
available on the record, we find that the prosecution has succeeded to form a
complete chain of evidence leading towards the guilt of the appellants and
the learned Additional Sessions Judge has rightly held the appellants guilty
for offences punishable under sections 364a/302/201/34 ipc.
The sentence passed against the appellants Amarendra Kumar
Sharma @ Vickey and Rockey Dutta needs no discussion, but considering
the death reference, capital punishment passed against the appellant no. 1
Swapan Kumar Jha is required to be discussed.
25. It was contended that on similar set of evidence, other two
appellants have been awarded rigorous imprisonment for life, but the
appellant no.1 has been awarded death sentence and the grounds on which
the sentence has been distinguished, do not appear to be proper and tenable.
The case does not come under the purview of the rarest of rare case.
Admittedly, the case is based on circumstantial evidence and the learned
Sessions Judge has failed to prepare proper balance sheet with regard to the
aggravating and mitigating circumstances relating to appellant no. 1 Swapan
Kumar Jha. No previous criminal antecedents or conviction against the
appellant no. 1 has been brought on record. He is also a young boy and there
is every chance of his reformation and rehabilitation, because larger part of
his life is remained to be spent. There might be an evil design in his mind to
become rich by adopting short cut methods, but the family background does
not indicate that he is habitual of committing such offences. Learned
Additional Sessions Judge has mis-appreciated the guidelines given by the
apex court in the case of Bachan Singh Vs. State of Punjab ( 1980 [2]SCC
684). The learned court below should have considered the view of the Apex
Court reported in 2009 (6) SCC 498 ( Santosh Kumar Satish Bhushan
Bariar Vs. State of Maharashtra ) in which mitigating circumstances lying
in favour of the convicts have been categorized and explained in para 170 to
178, although considering the facts and evidence of that case. Most of the
mitigating circumstances considered in the said judgment appears to be
fully applicable in the case at hand with regard to the appellant no. 1
Swapan Kumar Jha and he should not have been awarded death sentence.
26. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the State has
relied upon the following judgments :
(i) 1980(2)SCC 684 (Bachan Singh Vs. State of Punjab)
(ii) 2010(3) SCC 56( Vikram Singh Vs. State of Punjab)
(iii) 2004 (SCC) (Cri) 529 ( Sushil Murmu vs. State of
Jharkhand;
27. We would like to re-produce hereinbelow paragraphs
32,33,34 and 37 of the judgment in the case of Machchi Singh Vs. State of
Punjab reported in 1983 (3) SCC 470, which guide us to bring a
particular case within the category of the rarest of the rare case.
"32. The reasons why the community as a whole
does not endorse the humanistic approach
reflected in "death sentence-in-no-case" doctrine
are not far to seek. In the first place, the very
humanistic edifice is constructed on the
foundation of "reverence for life" principle. When
a member of the community violates this very
principle by killing another member, the society
may not feel itself bound by the shackles of this
doctrine. Secondly, it has to be realized that every
member of the community is able to live with
safety without his or her own life being
endangered because of the protective arm of the
community and on account of the rule of law
enforced by it. The very existence of the rule of
law and the fear of being brought to book operates
as a deterrent of those who have no scruples in
killing others if it suits their ends. Every member
of the community owes a debt to the community for
this protection. When ingratitude is shown instead
of gratitude by "killing" a member of the
community which protects the murderer himself
from being killed, or when the community feels
that for the sake of self-preservation the killer has
to be killed, the community may well withdraw the
protection by sanctioning the death penalty. But
the community will not do so in every case. It may
do so "in rarest of rare cases" when its collective
conscience is so shocked that it will expect the
holders of the judicial power centre to inflict death
penalty irrespective of their personal opinion as
regards desirability or otherwise of retaining
death penalty. The community may entertain such
a sentiment when the crime is viewed from the
platform of the motive for, or the manner of
commission of the crime, or the anti-social or
abhorrent nature of the crime, such as for
instance:
I. Manner of commission of murder
33. When the murder is committed in an extremely
brutal, grotesque, diabolical, revolting or dastardly
manner so as to arouse intense and extreme
indignation of the community. For instance,
(i) when the house of the victim is set aflame with
the end in view to roast him alive in the house.
(ii) When the victim is subjected to inhuman acts
of torture or cruelty in order to bring about his or
her death.
(iii) When the body of the victim is cut into pieces
or his body is dismembered in a fiendish manner.
II. Motive for commission of murder
34. When the murder is committed for a motive
which evinces total depravity and meanness. For
instance when (a) a hired assassin commits murder
for the sake of money or reward (b) a cold-blooded
murder is committed with a deliberate design in
order to inherit property or to gain control over
property of a ward or a person under the control of
the murderer or vis-a-vis whom the murderer is in
a dominating position or in a position of trust, or
(c) a murder is committed in the course for betrayal
of the motherland.
Personality of victim of murder
37. When the victim of murder is (a) an innocent
child who could not have or has not provided even
an excuse, much less a provocation, for murder (b)
a helpless woman or a person rendered helpless by
old age or infirmity (c) when the victim is a person
vis-a-vis whom the murderer is in a position of
domination or trust (d) when the victim is a public
figure generally loved and respected by the
community for the services rendered by him and
the murder is committed for political or similar
reasons other than personal reasons."
28. In view of the guidelines given above, we have
considered the following reasons to frame the case of the appellant no. 1
within the ambit of the rarest of the rare case.
29. In this case, a boy aged about 19 years, who was a student, was
kidnapped for ransom, demanded in terms of rupees twenty lakhs.
(ii) Appellant No.1 Swapan Kumar Jha is none else, but the
cousin of the deceased Sumit alias Govind. He was the master-mind behind
the plan and he had identified and fixed the target for kidnapping one of his
relatives to realize hefty amount. The informant is the maternal uncle of the
convict Swapan Kumar Jha.
(iii) since the target was known to the convict and, therefore, it
was all along within the mind of the appellant no. 1 that the prey shall not be
spared even after realization of the ransom. It is not a case of murder
simpliciter, rather, the appellants have been held guilty for the offences
under section 364a of the ipc and this section has been introduced in order
to curb the menace of kidnapping for ransom.
(iv) It appears that the deceased was administered spurious
drugs and thereafter he was murdered and even after killing the deceased,
ransom was demanded;
(v) It is a case of betrayal of trust and no society will survive if
the trust is betrayed by a close relation;
(vi) The convicts, in order to screen themselves from the legal
punishment, had disposed of the dead body like habitual offenders. They
had carefully and cautiously executed their plan and buried the dead body in
the graveyard, about 6 ft deep, beneath the earth.
(vii) Mental agony of the parents who lost their son and that too
at the instance of their close relative, put them under a great shock and such
incident is sufficient to put the society at large under threat and no one will
have trust or faith in others;
(viii) It was a pre-planned cold blooded murder and the plan
was designed by the convict no. 1 who is a close relative of the deceased. He
has committed the offences for ransom and he was pre-determined from the
very beginning to kill the deceased irrespective of payment of ransom and
therefore we find that the principles laid down by the apex court in the case
of Vikram Singh Vs. State of Punjab (2010(3) SCC 56) shall be applicable
to the case in hand and we do agree with the view of the learned Addl.
Sessions Judge that the case of the convict Swapan Kumar Jha, appellant
No.1, comes within the purview of the rarest of the rare case and he deserves
the death sentence.
Accordingly, the death sentence awarded to the appellant no.1
stands confirmed.
30. In view of the discussion made above, we do not find any merit
in any of the appeal preferred by the appellants, referred to above and the
same stand dismissed. The impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge in Sessions Trial No.
88 of 2009 stands upheld.
( D.N. Upadhyay,J.)
I agree.
(R.K.Merathia,J.)
(R.K.Merathia,J.)
Jharkhand High Court,
Ranchi, Dated 29th July,2011.
Ambastha/AFR