AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 72 and 73 of the Bihar Reorganization Act.72. Provisions
  • Section 73 of the Bihar Re-organization Act, 2000,
  • Section 73 of the Bihar Reorganization Act
  • clause 16 of the Jharkhand Reservation Act
  • provisions of sub-section (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 72 and 73 of the Bihar Reorganization Act.72. Provisions
  • Section 73 of the Bihar Re-organization Act, 2000,
  • Section 73 of the Bihar Reorganization Act
  • clause 16 of the Jharkhand Reservation Act
  • provisions of sub-section (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as a Junior Engineer in the State of Bihar on 30.4.1983. Having not been promoted despite what he alleges was satisfactory service, he filed W.P.(C) No. 3538 of 2002 seeking a direction to the respondents to consider his promotion. The Court disposed of that writ petition by directing the Secretary, P.H.E.D., Government of Jharkhand to take a decision on a promotion request dated 13.2.2002 from the Secretary, P.H.E.D., Government of Bihar.

Following concurrence from the State of Jharkhand and upon obtaining vigilance clearance from the Bihar Public Service Commission, the petitioner was promoted by the State of Bihar to the post of Executive Engineer by Notification No. 9205 dated 11.12.2002. The petitioner then discharged duties on the promoted post in the territory of the State of Jharkhand.

Subsequently, the respondents issued an order dated 4.9.2010 (Annexure-6) cancelling the promotion on the ground that, as on the appointed day (15.11.2000), the quota for Scheduled Castes (10%) was full and no vacancy existed in that category. The petitioner challenged the validity of that reversion order in the present application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned reversion order contained in Annexure-6 (dated 4.9.2010) reverting the petitioner from Assistant/Executive Engineer back to Junior Engineer is justified.
  2. Whether the Jharkhand Reservation Act (and specifically clause 16 relating to reservation quotas) could be applied to vary the petitioner’s service conditions to his disadvantage after the appointed day (15.11.2000) without the previous approval of the Central Government, in light of the proviso to Section 73 of the Bihar Re-organisation Act, 2000.
  3. Whether, in the context of provisional posting and non-finalised cadre bifurcation, the State of Bihar was competent to promote the petitioner (after obtaining Jharkhand's consent) and whether the State of Jharkhand could subsequently withdraw that promotion.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner was promoted by the State of Bihar (Notification No. 9205 dated 11.12.2002) after vigilance clearance from the Bihar Public Service Commission and with the consent of the State of Jharkhand pursuant to the Court's earlier direction in W.P.(C) No. 3538 of 2002.
  • The cadre-controlling position and a clarificatory order (Annexure-A to the respondents' counter affidavit) indicate that Bihar was the competent authority to decide promotions for the share of vacancies falling to Bihar (60%), after seeking Jharkhand's consent, which had been given; therefore Jharkhand lacked competence to withdraw the promotion.
  • Section 73 (proviso) of the Bihar Re-organisation Act, 2000 prohibits varying service conditions applicable immediately before the appointed day to the disadvantage of a person except with prior approval of the Central Government; the impugned reversion varies the petitioner’s service to his disadvantage without such approval and is therefore invalid.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The promotion by the State of Bihar was provisional and subject to certain conditions (referenced as contained in letter No. 1079 dated 28.2.2004 issued by the Personnel and Administrative Reforms), although a copy of that letter was not placed on record.
  • After the decision by Bihar, the Jharkhand Reservation Act was promulgated (Notification No. 3465 dated 3.12.2001) providing 10% posts for promotion to the Scheduled Caste category. As applied to 132 Assistant Engineer posts earmarked for Jharkhand, 28% (37 posts) are to be filled from Junior Engineers and 10% of those (4 posts) from Junior Engineers of Scheduled Caste; however 9 Scheduled Caste Junior Engineers were posted, creating an excess of 5 posts beyond the admissible quota under clause 16 of the Jharkhand Reservation Act.
  • On that account, the reversion order reverting the petitioner to Junior Engineer was justified to conform with the reservation quota under the Jharkhand Reservation Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first recorded the undisputed factual background: the petitioner was provisionally promoted by the State of Bihar in compliance with the earlier Patna High Court order, based on BPSC recommendation, vigilance clearance and the consent of the State of Jharkhand (letter no. 9205 / letter dated 13.2.2002 / Annexure 13). The Court observed that eight years later the State of Jharkhand issued Annexure-6 (memo no. 3650 dated 4.9.2010) reverting the petitioner on the ground that reservation quotas under the Jharkhand Reservation Act resulted in an excess number of Scheduled Caste incumbents.

The Court identified the pivotal statutory provisions relevant to decision-making — Sections 72 and 73 of the Bihar Re-organisation Act, 2000 — and reproduced the operative content of those provisions (including the proviso to Section 73). The proviso to Section 73 provides that conditions of service applicable immediately before the appointed day in the case of any person deemed to have been allocated to Bihar or Jharkhand shall not be varied to his disadvantage except with the previous approval of the Central Government.

Applying that statutory principle to the present facts, the Court noted that before the appointed day (15.11.2000) the petitioner’s service conditions were not governed by the Jharkhand Reservation Act. The Court reasoned that applying the reservation-based limitation (under clause 16 of the Jharkhand Reservation Act) so as to reduce or cancel a promotion granted by Bihar would amount to varying the petitioner’s service conditions to his disadvantage.

Crucially, the Court found that no prior approval of the Central Government was obtained before the order in Annexure-6 was passed. Because Section 73’s proviso bars such disadvantageous variation of service conditions without Central Government approval, the Court concluded that the authority committing the reversion order did so in breach of the statutory restriction.

The Court also considered the respondents’ contention that the promotion was provisional and subject to conditions (including the impact of final cadre division and determination of seniority), noting the existence of such qualifying conditions in the record; however, the Court’s reasoning focused on the statutory embargo under Section 73 and the absence of Central Government approval as decisive.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court set aside the order contained in Annexure-6 (memo no. 3650 dated 4.9.2010) and allowed the application. The Court concluded that passing the reversion order without prior approval of the Central Government was illegal.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The impugned reversion order (Annexure-6) has been quashed; the application is allowed. (The opinion expressly sets aside Annexure-6.)
  • The Court's decision rests on the statutory requirement in the proviso to Section 73 of the Bihar Re-organisation Act, 2000 — namely, that post-appointed-day service conditions applicable immediately before the appointed day cannot be varied to an incumbent's disadvantage without prior Central Government approval. Because no such approval was obtained, the reversion was held illegal.
  • The opinion does not state or claim the setting of any broader binding precedent beyond the adjudication of these facts; it expressly grounds relief on statutory interpretation and the absence of Central Government approval in this specific factual and statutory context.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion. No facts, arguments, or authorities beyond those appearing in the opinion have been added or inferred.

    Tapeshwar Choudhary Petitioner v. State Of Jharkhand And Others S

    Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was appointed as Junior Engineer in the State of Bihar on 30.4.1983 In spite of rendering services to the satisfaction of the authorities, when the petitioner was not promoted to the higher post, he moved an application before this Court, vide W.P(C) No. 3538 of 2002 for a direction to the respondents-authority to consider the case of promotion of the petitioner. In that case, it was placed before this Court that a decision is to be taken by the State of Bihar with the consent of the State of Jharkhand, as the cadre has not been bifurcated. The case was disposed of directing the Secretary, P.H.E.D, Government of Jharkhand to take a decision on the request letter dated 13.2.2002 received from the Secretary, P.H.E.D, Government of Bihar relating to promotion of the petitioner and others.

    Pursuant to that, concurrence was given by the State of Jharkhand for taking decision in the matter of promotion of the petitioner. Upon which Vigilance clearance was taken from the Bihar Public Service Commission and only on that basis, the petitioner was promoted to the post of Executive Engineer vide Notification No. 9205 dated 11.12.2002 by the State of Bihar. Thereupon, the petitioner started discharging his duty on the promoted post in the territory of State of Jharkhand but all on a sudden, the respondents came with an order dated 4.9.2010, as contained in Annexure-6, whereby the promotion given to the petitioner earlier by the State of Bihar was cancelled on the ground that on the appointed day i.e 15.11.2000, quota, meant for Scheduled Castes to the extent of 10%, was full and as such, no vacancy has been existing against the Scheduled Caste category. The said order has been challenged to be bad.

    Learned counsel further submits that from a Circular, issued by the Central Government, it is evident that the cadre Controlling Authority in respect of officers provisionally posted in the State of Jharkhand would be the State of Bihar until final allocation is made and further the clarificatory order, as contained in Annexure-A to the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent no. 2, stipulates that the State of Bihar is competent to take decision in the matter of promotion to the extent of 60% of the total vacancy, which falls to the share of the State of Bihar and thus, this clarificatory order fully establishes that the State of Bihar was the Competent Authority to take decision in the matter of promotion after seeking consent from the State of Jharkhand which had already been given by the State of Jharkhand and under that situation, it was not within the competence of the State of Jharkhand to withdraw that order under which promotion was given to the petitioner.

    Learned counsel further submits that on other ground also, the order, under which promotion was given to the petitioner, cannot be cancelled or withdrawn in view of the provision, as contained in proviso to Section 73 of the Bihar Re-organization Act, 2000, stipulating therein that the service conditions of the persons applicable immediately before the appointed day shall not be varied to their disadvantage except with the previous approval with the Central Government and, therefore, the order, as has been passed under Annexure-6, is certainly disadvantageous to the interest of the petitioner and hence, the same cannot be passed by the State of Jharkhand without having approval of the Central Government and on this count also, the impugned order is fit to be set aside.

    As against this, Mr. D.K Dubey, G.P.I submits that it is true that while the petitioner was serving in the State of Jharkhand, the State of Bihar on account of non-division of the cadre took a decision to promote the petitioner to the post of Assistant Engineer but that promotion was provisional and it was subject to certain conditions stipulated in a letter bearing No. 1079 dated 28.2.2004 issued by the Personnel and Administrative Reforms. However, copy of the same was never filed.

    He would further submit that by the time decision was taken by the state of Bihar relating to the promotion of the petitioner, the Jharkhand Reservation Act was promulgated, vide Notification No. 3465 dated 3.12.2001 whereby only 10% post has been earmarked for promotion to the category of Scheduled Caste. In this respect, it was further pointed out that altogether 132 posts of Assistant Engineers were earmarked for the State of Jharkhand. Out of which, as per the rule, 28% of the post, i.e 37 posts are to be filled up from the quota of Junior Engineer and of it 10% posts, i.e 4 posts are to be filled up from Junior Engineers belonging to Scheduled Caste category.

    It was further pointed out that as against 4 posts meant for Scheduled Caste candidates, 9 persons of the same category were posted in the State of Jharkhand, meaning thereby that 5 posts are in excess than the admissible quota fixed under clause 16 of the Jharkhand Reservation Act and under this situation, the order was passed whereby the petitioner was reverted to the post of Junior Engineer and as such, no illegality has been committed.

    Having heard learned counsel appearing for the parties, it does appear that it has not been in dispute that this petitioner was provisionally promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer by the State of Bihar in compliance of the order passed by the Patna High Court and on getting recommendation by the Bihar Public Service Commission and also after having clearance from the State of Jharkhand, vide order as contained in letter no. 9205 dated 12.11.2002 After 8 years, the State of Jharkhand, vide its order as contained in memo no. 3650 dated 4.9.2010 (Annexure 6) has passed order of reversion to the post of Junior Engineer on the ground which has been taken in the counter affidavit and has been highlighted by the learned counsel appearing for the State in his submission. It is also the stand of the State that the order of promotion was qualified with certain conditions and was issued with a stipulation that such order of promotion may get adversely affected due to final cadre division and in that event, the petitioner cannot put forth any claim. It would be better to point it out those conditions which are being given herein below.

    1. The promotion might be adversely affected due to final cadre division and thereafter on determination of seniority.

    2. In case of adverse effect on promotion concerned engineers would not be entitled to any claim.

    Thus, the question is as to whether the impugned order as contained in Annexure 6 under which the petitioner was reverted from the post of Assistant Engineer to Junior Engineer is justified?

    For deciding this issue, it would be relevant to refer the provision as contained in Sections 72 and 73 of the Bihar Reorganization Act.

    “72. Provisions relating to services in Bihar and Jharkhand- (I) Every person, who immediately before the appointed day is serving in connection with the affairs of the existing State of Bihar shall, on and from that day provisionally continue to serve in connection with the affairs of the State of Bihar unless he is required, by general or special order of the Central Government to serve provisionally in connection with the affairs of the State of Jharkhand:

    Provided that no direction shall be issued under this section after the expiry of a period of one year from the appointed day.

    1. As soon as may be after the appointed day, the Central Government shall, by general or special order, determine the successor State to which every person referred to in sub-section (1) shall be finally allotted for service and the date with effect from which such allotment shall take effect or be deemed to have taken effect.

    2. Every person, who is finally allotted under the provisions of sub-section (2) to a successor State shall, if he is not already serving therein be made available for serving in the successor State from such date as may be agreed upon between the Governments concerned or in default of such agreement, as may be determined by the Central Government.

    73. Other provisions relating to services :- (I) Nothing in Section 72 shall be deemed to affect on or after the appointed day the operation of the provisions of Chapter I of Part XIV of the Constitution in relation to determination of the conditions of service of persons serving in connection with the affairs of the Union or any State:

    Provided that the conditions of service applicable immediately before the appointed day in the case of any person deemed to have been allocated to the State of Bihar or to the State of Jharkhand under Section 72 shall not be varied to his disadvantage except with the previous approval of the Central Government.

    (2) All services prior to the appointed day rendered by a person-

    (a) If he is deemed to have been allocated to any State under Section 72, shall be deemed to have been rendered in connection with the affairs of that State;

    (b) if he is deemed to have been allocated to the Union in connection with the administration of the Jharkhand shall be deemed to have been rendered in connection with the affairs of the Union, for the purposes of the rules regulating his conditions of service.

    (3) The provisions of Section 72, shall not apply in relation to members of any All India Service”.

    Thus, the provisions as contained in Section 73 of the Act does stipulates that the condition of service applicable immediately before the appointed day in the case of any person deemed to have been allocated to the State of Bihar or to the State of Jharkhand shall not be varied to his disadvantage except with the previous approval of the Central Government.

    It may be reiterated that the petitioner has been promoted by the State of Bihar after getting recommendation of the Bihar Public Service Commission, Vigilance clearance and also with the consent of the State of Jharkhand and also keeping in view the vacancies against the sanctioned strength which would be evident from the letter dated 13.2.2002 issued by the Commissioner and Secretary, P.H.E.D, Government of Bihar to the Secretary, P.H.E.D, Government of Jharkhand (Annexure 13) but now the impugned order of reversion has been passed by taking the stand that the sanctioned strength of the Assistant Engineer for the category of Scheduled Tribes is only 4 and as against that, 9 persons have been posted and as such, continuation of the petitioner on the post of Assistant Engineer is not permissible under clause 16 of the Jharkhand Reservation Act.

    It would be worthwhile to note here that before the appointed day, i.e 15.11.2000 the service condition of the petitioner was never governed by such Act and as such, the provision of the said Act cannot be enforced in case of the petitioner in view of the embargo put under Section 73 of the Bihar Reorganization Act which does stipulate that service condition cannot be varied to the disadvantage except with the previous approval of the Central government. Admittedly, no such approval has been taken by the Central Government before the order as contained in Annexure 6 was passed.

    Under that situation, the authority by passing the order as contained in Annexure 6 without the approval of the Central Government has certainly committed gross illegality and hence, the order as contained in Annexure 6 is hereby set aside.

    In the result, this application is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tapeshwar Choudhary Petitioner v. State Of Jharkhand And Others S
    (Feb 25, 2011)