AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Proceedings) Act, 1997,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Proceedings) Act, 1997,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These two civil revisions, heard together, arise from eviction suits in which the respondents (plaintiffs in the trial court) seek eviction of the petitioners (defendants in the trial court) from the suit premises. The petitioners filed applications in the trial court seeking a stay of proceedings under the Jammu and Kashmir Migrants (Stay of Proceedings) Act, 1997 ("the Act"); the trial court rejected those applications and the rejection is challenged by the present civil revisions.

It is common ground that eviction suits between landlord and tenant fall within the scope of "immovable property" as defined by the Act. Section 3 of the Act (quoted in the opinion) provides for a stay of proceedings pending or subsequently filed against a "migrant" in respect of recovery or immovable property situated in the Kashmir Division, subject to a proviso excluding disputes inter se migrants.

The petitioners assert that they migrated from the Kashmir Valley after 1 November 1989 and were registered as migrants with the Relief Commissioner; accordingly, they contend proceedings must be stayed under Section 3. The respondents countered that (a) they themselves also migrated and, therefore, the proviso (excluding inter-se migrant disputes) applies, or (b) the petitioners returned to the Valley and so have lost any migrant status and cannot claim a stay. The parties' pleadings and evidence, as well as the petitioners' participation in the trial, factored centrally in the dispute.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether proceedings in the eviction suits against the petitioners must be stayed under Section 3 of the Jammu and Kashmir Migrants (Stay of Proceedings) Act, 1997.
  2. Whether a person once classified or registered as a "migrant" under Section 2(c) of the Act retains that status indefinitely, or whether migrant status can cease (for example, upon return to the Valley) and be the subject of judicial determination.
  3. Whether active participation by a defendant in the trial (including examining witnesses and otherwise contesting the suit) can operate as waiver or estoppel, preventing the defendant later from invoking Section 3 to obtain a stay of proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners migrated from the Kashmir Valley after 1 November 1989 and were registered as migrants with the Relief Commissioner at Jammu; respondents admitted this migrant status in their objections to an application for additional evidence.
  • Because they fall within the definition of "migrant" in Section 2(c), Section 3 mandates that all proceedings pending or thereafter filed against a migrant relating to immovable property situated in the Kashmir Division shall remain stayed.
  • The Act does not provide for cessation of migrant status, and therefore a person who falls within Section 2(c) must be treated as a migrant for the purposes of obtaining a stay of proceedings.
  • Counsel relied on certain precedents (cited in the opinion) to support the proposition that participation in proceedings does not automatically cure a statutory bar to proceedings or confer jurisdiction where it otherwise does not exist.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that they too had migrated, thus invoking the proviso to Section 3: disputes between migrants inter se are excluded from the stay, so Section 3 would not protect the petitioners in any event.
  • Alternatively (and centrally), the respondents asserted the petitioners returned to the Valley and resumed living and doing business there; evidence was pointed to showing active business use of the suit premises and conduct inconsistent with migrant status (including the cancellation of migration certificates), which, according to respondents, showed the petitioners had lost migrant status.
  • Respondents also argued that the petitioners' prolonged and active participation in the trial process — including examining numerous witnesses and filing procedural applications at a late stage — amounted to waiver or acquiescence and estopped them from invoking Section 3 to stay proceedings at that late stage.
  • Counsel for respondents relied on precedents (cited in the opinion) for the proposition that participation can amount to waiver of a right to challenge proceedings later on the stated ground.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
His Holiness Digya Darshan Rajendra Ram Doss v. Devendra Doss, AIR 1973 SC 268 Cited by petitioners' counsel (Mr. G.A. Lone). The opinion notes the decision was relied upon but indicates these decisions were on a different point. The court recorded that these decisions were relied upon by petitioners' counsel but observed they were decisions on a different point; they were not treated as determinative of the present issue.
Phula Singh v. Gram Panchayat, Sharon, AIR 1982 Punjab 204 Cited by petitioners' counsel; noted in the opinion as a decision on a different point. The court noted the reliance but stated these decisions were on a different point and did not directly resolve the issues before it.
Basheshar Nath v. Commissioner of Income Tax, AIR 1959 SC 149 Cited by respondents' counsel in support of the proposition that participation in proceedings can amount to waiver of rights to later challenge proceedings. The court treated the case as authority supporting the principle that active participation may constitute waiver/acquiescence; the court applied the waiver principle in its reasoning.
Bibi Amna Khatoon v. Zahir Hussain, AIR 1981 Patna I Cited by respondents' counsel in support of the submission that participation can waive a right later relied upon. The court noted the reliance and treated the case as supporting the general proposition that participation may bar later invocation of a statutory protection; it was considered in the course of assessing waiver/acquiescence.
Bisheshwar Nath v. Commissioner of Income Tax (referred to as "Vide Bisheshwar Nath v. Commissioner of Income Tax (supra)") Used by the court to explicate the accepted connotation of 'waiver'—that waiver requires intentional relinquishment of a known right or conduct warranting an inference of relinquishment. The court cited this authority as the doctrinal foundation for concluding that active and conscious participation may estop a party from seeking a stay under Section 3 on grounds of waiver/acquiescence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused on a limited set of legal propositions derived from the Act and the parties' conduct in the litigation:

  1. Nature and effect of Section 3: The court observed that Section 3 of the Act provides for the stay of proceedings against migrants, but it does not divest or denude the court of jurisdiction to try the suit. In other words, Section 3 operates to stay proceedings when invoked; it is not a statutory curtailment of inherent jurisdiction.
  2. Mechanism for staying proceedings: The court emphasized that Section 3 does not contemplate an automatic cessation of proceedings; the stay operates "only on application of the party i.e. the defendant." If the defendant does not apply and allows the suit to proceed, they may be precluded from later asserting that a final decree is illegal for want of jurisdiction.
  3. Cessation of migrant status: Although the Act is silent on whether migrant status can cease, the court refused to accept a construction that migrant status, once declared or registered, must endure ad infinitum. The court held that the Act's object is to protect those who are absent and unable to contest suits; those who return to the Valley and resume their affairs would no longer be entitled to such protection. The question of migrant status is factual and for determination by the court; the court itself can declare that a person has lost migrant status.
  4. Waiver, acquiescence and estoppel by participation: The court placed considerable emphasis on the petitioners' active participation in the litigation — including extensive evidence led by the defendants (petitioners) after the Act came into force, and procedural conduct such as filing applications late in the trial — and concluded that such active and conscious participation can give rise to waiver or estoppel. The court explained the accepted meaning of "waiver" (intentional relinquishment of a known right or conduct warranting an inference of relinquishment), citing Bisheshwar/Basheshar Nath as doctrinal support.
  5. Chronology and conduct: The court noted relevant dates: the Act came into force on 2-6-1997; the defendants began examining witnesses on 30-5-1998 and examined as many as 14 witnesses before the present dispute over Section 3 was invoked. The application invoking Section 3 was filed for the first time in an application for additional evidence dated 5-8-2002. The court treated this late invocation, after active participation, as significant to the question whether the petitioners' plea for a stay was bona fide or was an attempt to stall the eviction proceedings.
  6. Policy consideration: The court observed that Section 3 is intended to be used as a "shield" to protect those genuinely unable to defend suits because of forced absence, and not as a "weapon" to be deployed to obstruct proper adjudication. This policy consideration informed the court's conclusion that the trial court did not err in rejecting the stay application where petitioners had actively litigated the case.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITION: The revisions were dismissed. The court held that the rejection of the prayer for a stay of proceedings by the trial court "cannot be said to be illegal or unjustified" and therefore did not warrant interference by the revisional court. The revision petitions were dismissed "without any order as to costs."

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the petitioners remain subject to the ordinary progress of the eviction suits; their application for a stay under Section 3 of the Act was properly rejected in the facts of this case.
  • The court endorsed the proposition that migrant status can cease and is a question of fact for the court to determine; similarly, the court emphasized that active participation in proceedings may operate as waiver or estoppel and thereby preclude later invocation of statutory protection intended for absent migrants.
  • The opinion does not purport to establish a broader or novel precedent beyond these legal conclusions applied to the facts; the decision resolves the dispute between the parties by dismissal of the revisions and does not, in terms of the text, announce any sweeping new rule beyond the reasoning set out above.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion contains.

    Madan Lal Sahani And Ors. v. Satpal Sahani And Ors.

    1. These two civil revisions involve common question and, as such, they have been heard together and are disposed of by this common order.

    2. The question which arises for decision is whether proceedings in the suits instituted by the respondents are to be stayed in terms of the Jammu and Kashmir Migrants (Stay of Proceedings) Act, 1997, The petitioners who are defendants in the court below filed application for stay of proceedings which was rejected by the impugned order. The suits were filed seeking eviction of the petitioners from the suit premises. It is not in dispute, having regard to the definition of 'immovable property' in Section 2(b) of the Act that eviction suits between landlord and tenant are otherwise covered by the Act.

    3. The relevant provision which is contained in Section 3 of the Act runs as under:

    "Stay of proceedings against Migrants.-Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any law for the time being in force, all proceedings pending or hereinafter filed against a migrant for recovery of loan raised in the Kashmir Division or relating to immovable property situated in the Kashmir Division shall remain stayed from the commencement of this Act till the Government notifies otherwise.

    Provided that nothing in this section shall apply to a dispute relating to recovery of money or immovable property inter-se migrants."

    The definition of 'migrant' in Section 2(c) of the Act may also be noticed as under :

    "Migrant" means any person who has migrated from the Kashmir Valley after Ist. November, 1989 and is registered as such with the Relief Commissioner and includes a person who has not been so registered on the ground of his being in service of the Government in any moving office, or having left the Valley in pursuit of his occupation or vocation and is possessed of immovable property in the Valley but is unable to ordinarily reside there due to the disturbed conditions."

    4. The case of the petitioners is that they migrated from the Kashmir valley in the wake of turmoil after 1st. November 1989, were registered as such with the Relief Commissioner at Jammu, as admitted by the plaintiffs-respondents in their objections field in reply to the petitioners' application for additional evidence. Being migrants, the proceedings cannot be continued against them in view of the mandatory provisions of Section 3 of the Act. According to the respondents the petitioners had migrated in the wake of turmoil and so had the respondents. In terms to proviso to Section 3, where dispute is between migrants inter se, the provision relating to stay of proceedings is not applicable. In any view, the petitioners having returned to the village, their migrant status, if any, came to an end and they are not entitled to seek stay of proceedings.

    5. On behalf of the petitioners, it was submitted that the respondents having admitted the migrant status of the petitioners in their objections to the petitioners' application for additional evidence, they can not turn around and take any plea to the contrary. It was submitted that the Act does not provide for cessation of migrant status of the person and thus if he falls within the ambit of Section 2(c) of the Act, he must be treated as migrant and no proceeding by way of suit, appeal etc. can be initiated or continued against him.

    6. Mr. G.A. Lone appearing for the petitioners placed heavy reliance on the said statements in para 5 of the respondents' objections to the petitioners' application for additional evidence, which according to him, contains a clear admission of the petitioners' migrant status. The statement in para 5 of the objections were made in response to the petitioner' averments in para 5 of the application (for additional evidence) and, therefore, it would be appropriate to first notice petitioners' statements in para 5 of the application (for additional evidence):

    "That during the course of enquiry, it has come in evidence that plaintiffs, namely Inder Paul and Ved Paul have migrated from Srinagar alongwith their families, lock, stock and barrel. These plaintiffs have been initially receiving benefits from Relief Commissioner in the capacity of migrants, but with the passage of time they have permanently settled at Jammu. The plaintiffs have their two residential houses in Jammu, one house situate at Kathi Talab and other at Trikuta Nagar."

    7. In reply, the respondents stated vide para 5 of the objections as under:-

    In reply to para 5, it is submitted that defendants have deliberately suppressed the facts and tried to mislead this Hon'ble Court. The defendants in both the suits have migrated like plaintiffs Ved Pal and Inder Pal have been registered as migrants with Relief Commissioner where from the defendants have been regularly receiving the relief. One fails to understand how defendants have been on the one hand claiming that they are running their business in the suit shops and on the other hand they have been claiming relief before Relief Commissioner at Jammu on the plea that they are not safe at Srinagar to conduct their business. Copies of the documents wherein the defendants in both the suits have been registered as migrants are enclosed herewith. It is submitted that Shri Ved Pal and Sh. Inder Pal after having left the Valley in turmoil have for lack of resources been registered as migrants. But it is denied that either of them have permanently settled at Jammu. Plaintiffs have failed to understand on what basis and from which sources the defendants have stated that Sh. Inder Paul and Ved Paul have residential house at Trikuta Nagar and Khati Talab, Jammu. Ancestral house at Khati Talab is in possession of eldest brother of the plaintiff namely Ram Pal who is not a party of the proceedings and moreover having ancestral house at Jammu have no relevance as far as the present eviction suits are concerned and none of the plaintiffs either have or had any house at Trikuta Nagar Jammu which is only figment of imagination of the defendants having been put up only to delay the proceedings.

    8. It would appear that the thrust of the petitioners' statements in para 5 of the application was that the respondents had migrated from Srignagar along with their families and had settled at Jammu. It is relevant to mention here that the respondents seek eviction of the petitioners on the ground of personal necessity and these statements in para 5 of the application were apparently made to negative the respondents' case of personal necessity. Clearly, if the respondents had left Srinagar and settled at Jammu, they do not need the premises for their own occupation, but if that is so, they too acquired the status of migrants attracting the proviso to Section 3 which makes the provision regarding stay of proceedings inapplicable as between the migrants inter-se. Thus if respondents admitted the migrants status of the petitioners, as contended on their behalf, the petitioners too admitted the respondents' migrant status. It was in the context of the petitioners' case as set out in paragraph 5 of the application for additional evidence that the averments were made in para 5 of the objections. In the said paragraph, nodoubt, the respondents stated about the petitioners' registration as migrants. However, this statement too appears to have been made in the particular context, so that they could seek petitioners' eviction from the suit premises. If the plaintiffs can not seek defendant's eviction on the ground of personal necessity because they have settled elsewhere, as contended by the defendant, surely, by the same logic, the defendant also can not resist the decree of eviction, if they have settled elsewhere. As a matter of fact, if I may say so, if the petitioners in the instant case had really migrated, and not returned to the valley thereafter, it is not understandable as to why else they are contesting the respondent's claim for eviction.

    9. I am not inclined to accept the case of the petitioners that the status of a person as migrant would remain as such notwithstanding the subsequent events. The Act is no doubt silent on the point. But granting an ad-infinitum status as migrant to a person would not be in consonance with the object of the Act. The object clearly is to protect the interest of migrants' who are in no position to contest the suit etc. brought against them on account of their forced absence from the valley. Those who return to the valley would not be entitled to such protection any longer. Any other interpretation may cause injustice to the suitor as he may be deprived of the enforcement of his rights for all times to come. It is to be kept in mind that the declaration of one's migrant status is not by the statute but under the statute. It is a question of fact which is to be determined by the court on the basis of evidence as and when such status is claimed or question arises. The court can also declare that the person has lost his migrant status.

    10. Mr. Bashir A. Bashir appearing on behalf of the respondents referred to the evidence of the witnesses and submitted that the evidence of defendants' witnesses, in fact, no less than the defendants themselves in their respective suits on 30-5-1988, suggests that they are doing business in the suit premises; they daily go to temple which is 6 minutes walk from the shop premises. Defendant Pran Nath in fact stated that he had taken another shop near the temple on rental of Rs. 1000/- per month. According to the counsel, the evidence clearly shows that the defendants after migrating from the valley when turmoil broke out in November 1989, later returned and started living there, doing business. That is why the migration certificate of some of them was cancelled. If that is so, they lost their migrant status and can no longer claim stay of proceedings.

    11. What stares more prominently at the petitioners' case is their active participation in the suits. It was stated by Mr. Bashir that after the plaintiffs' examined their witnesses between 17-5-1993 and 18-9-1997, the respondents started examining their witnesses from 30-5-1998 and as up to 22-7-2000 they examined as many as 14 witnesses. When the suit was in the final stage, they filed application for additional evidence and upon its rejection by the court below, came to this court in civil revision No. 54/2003. In the said application for additional evidence filed on 5-8-2002, for the first time they sought to invoke the provisions of Section 3 of the Act. This Court while upholding the order by which request for leading additional evidence was turned down, gave liberty to invoke Section 3 of the Act; that is how they filed the application giving rise to these revisions.

    12. The submissions of Mr. Lone was that petitioner's participation in the suit can not constitute estoppel, more so, in view of the respondents' admission in para 5 of their objections (supra). Reliance was placed on His Holiness Digya Darshan Rajendra Ram Doss v. Devendra Doss., AIR 1973 SC 268 and Phula Singh v. Gram Panchayat, Sharon. AIR 1982 Punjab 204. (These decisions are on different point) It was submitted that even if petitioners participated, it would not confer jurisdiction on the Court. In reply, Mr. Bashir placed reliance on Basheshar Nath V. Commissioner of Income Tax, AIR 1959 SC. 149, and Bibi Amna Khatoon v. Zahir Hussain, AIR 1981 Patna I, and submitted that by participating in the proceedings, petitioners waived their right to seek stay of proceedings.

    13. In my opinion, the issue lies in a narrow compass. Section 3 of the Act provides for dis-continuance of the proceedings. It does not effect or denude the jurisdiction of the court to try the suit etc. The court otherwise has jurisdiction to try the case. In other words, it is not case of inherent lack of jurisdiction. If it were a case of inherent lack of jurisdiction, certainly, no amount of participation by a party would confer jurisdiction on the court, But the position would not be the same where the party knowingly, in derogation of his rights subjects itself the jurisdiction and participates in the proceeding. It is to be kept in mind that Section 3 of the Act does not contemplate automatic cessation of proceedings. The proceedings are to be stayed only on application of the party i.e. the defendant. If such application is not made and the suit is allowed to proceed, it may continue upto the final stage and decree is passed, can the defendant take the plea that the decree is illegal for want of jurisdiction ? The answer must be in the negative. That being the position, the fact that the petitioners participated in the proceedings all these years raises a question as to whether they waived their right or the application for stay was bona fide at all. Section 3 does not make distinction between application made bona fide or otherwise, but certainly, an active and conscious participation may estop the party from seeking stay of the proceedings on the principle of waiver and acquiescence. The accepted connotation of 'waiver' is that to constitute waiver, there must be an intentional relinquishment of a known right or privilege or the voluntary relinquishment or abandonment an existing legal right and a conduct which warrants an inference of the relinquishment of a known right or privilege. Vide Bisheshwar Nath v. Commissioner of Income Tax (supra).

    14. It is to be kept in mind that the Act came into force and effect from 2-6-1997 and defendants started examining their witnesses from 13-5-1998 and examined as many as 14 of them before the present dispute arose . In a sense, it is no wonder that such application came to be filed at a late stage. Tenants in occupation of suit premises are known for making attempts to somehow stall the proceedings in eviction suits on one ground or the other. It was stated by Mr. Bashir that seeds have been sown for another round of dispute by seeking addition of the State as a party-defendant on the ground that the suit property is a Nazool property -another attempt to get the suits stalled. The suits were laid 18 years ago in 1986. No-doubt, the conditions prevailing in the valley also attributed to delay in disposal of the suits. The proceedings, however, appear to have gained momentum in 1993 or thereafter when respondents started examining their witnesses. As rightly observed by the court below, Section 3 of the Act is designed to be used as a 'shield' and should not be allowed to be used as a 'weapon' to stall the suits, appeals etc.

    15. In the above premises, the rejection of the prayer for stay of proceedings can not be said to be illegal or unjustified to warrant interference in civil revision.

    16 The revision petitions are accordingly dismissed, but without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Madan Lal Sahani And Ors. v. Satpal Sahani And Ors.
    (Jul 30, 2004)