Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Tejinder Singh Doabia, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The deceased, Ashok Kumar Malik, a 33‑year‑old science graduate with a Diploma in Textile Chemistry, died instantaneously in a motor‑vehicle accident on 4.6.1985 when his motorcycle (No. JKR 259) was struck by an army truck (No. 75‑D 19212 W). He left behind his widow, an infant son (Abhishekh Malik), and his parents (both over 50). A claim petition alleged that the offending vehicle was driven rashly and negligently and sought compensation. The Tribunal assessed the deceased's income and fixed dependency and awarded compensation. The decision of the Tribunal on quantum of compensation (and related distribution issues) was challenged in the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the correct quantum of compensation payable to the dependants of the deceased (i.e., correct assessment of the deceased's income, deductions, dependency and application of an appropriate multiplier)?
  2. Whether a widow who has remarried is disentitled to claim compensation arising from the death of her husband.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (mother and minor son)

  • The claim petitioners produced evidence (statements of witnesses) asserting that the deceased earned Rs. 5,000 per month (two witnesses) and Rs. 6,000 per month (one witness).
  • The mother (and the son's counsel) argued that the compensation should be enhanced and that any amounts awarded should be applied for the education and upbringing of the minor son; the mother requested that the amount be given to her son.

Respondent / Union of India

The opinion records that the Union of India did not file the appeal; the opinion does not contain a detailed account of any opposing arguments by the Union of India or any other respondent on the merits of quantum.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hariram v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1994 ACJ 1094 (MP) Widow's remarriage does not deprive her of the right to get compensation; inheritance rights are fixed as of the date of death. Cited to support the proposition that remarriage of a widow cannot be a ground for depriving her of compensation; the court relied on the reasoning that rights vest at the date of death.
Regal Sports v. Mohd. Siddique, 1994 ACJ 294 (Rajasthan) Widow cannot be declined compensation on remarriage; the widow remained entitled to compensation in that case. Used as supporting authority that remarriage does not bar compensation; cited to show consistency of judicial view.
Rajasthan State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Kiran Lata, 1993 ACJ 130 (Rajasthan) Denial of compensation on ground of possible remarriage is against public policy and violative of section 23 of the Contract Act; remarriage possibility should not be considered in awarding compensation. Cited for the principle that compensation must not be reduced or denied on account of possibility of remarriage; court relied on this to reject any approach that conditions compensation on marital status change.
Vimla Devi v. Chaman, 1992 ACJ 1048 (Rajasthan) Denial of compensation on account of widow's possible remarriage is not permissible. Cited as further support for the settled view that remarriage does not disentitle a widow to compensation.
Rajinder Kumar v. Soma Devi, 2001 ACJ 307 (HP) Consistency in holding that widow's remarriage does not disentitle her to compensation. Listed among decisions showing a consistent judicial line on the remarriage issue relied upon by the court.
Chandan v. Kanwarlal, 1989 ACJ 816 (Delhi) Authority consistent with the proposition that remarriage does not bar a widow's right to compensation. Relied upon as part of the body of precedent supporting the court's conclusion on the remarriage issue.
Khairullah v. Anita, 1994 ACJ 1017 (AP) Supports the principle that a widow's remarriage does not disentitle her to compensation. Accepted as part of the consistent authorities cited for the same proposition.
Nankuram Sarajdin v. Member, M.A.C.T., Thane, 1994 (2) TAC 346 Held that remarriage of a widow would not disentitle her to claim compensation. Included among the decisions relied upon to demonstrate uniformity of judicial approach.
Halki Bai v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., 1999 ACJ 187 (MP) Authority in the same line that remarriage does not bar a widow from compensation. Cited by the court as part of the consistent line of cases supporting its conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court limited its consideration to the quantum of compensation and the legal effect of the widow's remarriage because the Union of India did not file the appeal in relation to negligence.

On quantum, the court evaluated the evidence on the deceased's income:

  1. Witness evidence: two witnesses stated monthly income as Rs. 5,000, and one witness stated Rs. 6,000. The court regarded it reasonable to take the average of Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 6,000, i.e., Rs. 5,500 per month.
  2. From Rs. 5,500, monthly rent of Rs. 800 for residential accommodation was deducted, leaving Rs. 4,700 per month.
  3. The court found that one‑third of this balance (approximately Rs. 1,700) would reasonably be spent by the deceased on himself (including petrol and small expenses), leaving Rs. 3,000 per month as the contribution to the family.
  4. Annual dependency was calculated as Rs. 36,000 (Rs. 3,000 x 12).
  5. Given the deceased's age of 33 years, the court applied a multiplier of 16 to the annual dependency to compute the total compensation: Rs. 36,000 x 16 = Rs. 5,76,000.
  6. The court enhanced the Tribunal's award by Rs. 4,41,000 to reach the figure of Rs. 5,76,000 and directed interest at 9% per annum on the enhanced amount, with effect from the date of institution of the application.

On the legal effect of the widow's remarriage, the court reviewed an array of authorities and concluded that remarriage of a widow does not disentitle her to compensation. The court endorsed the reasoning in cited decisions that rights vest on the date of the husband's death and that denying compensation on the ground of remarriage would be contrary to public policy. The court also observed social realities: remarriage may not erase the social stigma and may create additional difficulties (especially when there is an infant), reinforcing the conclusion that remarriage should not deprive the widow or her children's entitlement to compensation.

Regarding distribution and protective measures for the minor, the court noted that the amount earlier found payable by the Claims Tribunal had been invested in Kisan Vikas Patras and renewed periodically by the grandparents. The court directed that the enhanced total amount and accumulated investments be made available to the minor (Abhishekh Malik) on attaining majority (treated here as 21 years) and ordered that the Union of India deposit the enhanced amount within three months. The court directed deposit in a fixed deposit receipt (FDR) with a scheduled bank and allowed for the possibility of earlier release upon application by the minor. Interest on the enhanced amount was fixed at 9% per annum. If the Union of India failed to deposit within three months, the rate of interest would be the same as that allowed by the Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is ALLOWED. The Tribunal's award was enhanced and the court directed payment and protective measures as set out below.

Direct consequences and orders made by the court:

  • The deceased's monthly contribution to the family was fixed at Rs. 3,000, yielding annual dependency of Rs. 36,000.
  • The multiplier of 16 was applied for a deceased aged 33, producing total compensation of Rs. 5,76,000.
  • The enhancement of Rs. 4,41,000 over the Tribunal's award was made, and interest on the enhanced amount was directed at 9% per annum from the date of institution of the claim.
  • The enhanced/awarded amount and the investments (Kisan Vikas Patras) were directed to be made available to the minor Abhishekh Malik on attaining majority (treated as 21 years), with provision for an earlier release upon application to the court.
  • The Union of India was directed to deposit the entire amount within three months; failure would result in interest as allowed by the Tribunal.

Implications: The court applied and relied upon an established line of authorities to hold that remarriage of a widow does not disentitle her (or her children) to compensation. The decision alters the monetary quantum awarded to the claimants in this case and prescribes protective custody of the funds for the minor, but it does not announce a novel legal principle beyond the precedent cited; the ruling principally applies existing law to the facts to increase the compensation and to protect the minor's entitlement.

    Seema Malik And Others v. Union Of India .

    Tejinder Singh Doabia, J.:— Ashok Kumar Malik, a science graduate from D.A.V College, Amritsar, Guru Nanak Dev University and who had also obtained a Diploma in Textile Chemistry from Punjab State Board of Technical Education in First Division, met with an accident on 4.6.1985 and died. He left behind his widow and an infant child and parents, who had crossed the age of 50. The deceased was going on a motor cycle bearing registration No. JKR 259, when he was near Tawi Bridge he was hit by an army truck No. 75-D 19212 W. The death appeared to be instant. When the claim petition was preferred the plea taken was that the offending vehicle was being driven rashly and negligently. Compensation was accordingly claimed. With a view to sustain the claim regarding the compensation, it was pleaded that the aforementioned science graduate with a Diploma in Textile Chemistry was carrying on his business of cloth merchant. This was from a shop located in Jammu. His income was put across at Rs. 5,000 by two of the witnesses and Rs. 6,000 per month by another witness. He was found to be paying a sum of Rs. 800 as rent for residential accommodation and in this manner the Tribunal observed that his income could not have been less than Rs. 3,000. This figure was taken note of. The personal expenses of the deceased and his widow were taken to be around ⅔rd and the dependency of the infant was put around Rs. 500. So far as parents are concerned, it was concluded that he must be contributing about Rs. 250 for meeting the expenses which could have been incurred by the mother. As such, the dependency of the mother and the infant was fixed at Rs. 750. Annual dependency was calculated at Rs. 9,000. The multiplier of ‘15’ was applied and the amount of compensation was accordingly awarded. The fact that the widow had remarried was taken note of and, therefore, no benefit OP this was given to the minor. It was precisely for this reason an observation was made that the amount which the deceased must be spending on himself and the widow is required to be taken note of. Now this decision given by the Tribunal is subject-matter of challenge in this appeal.

    2. So far as the issue regarding negligence is concerned, this need not to be gone into as Union of India has not filed the appeal. Thus the only material issue is issue No. 2, which is with regard to quantum of compensation. This would also require determination of the question as to whether a widow on remarriage disentitles herself to claim compensation on account of death of her husband.

    3. As indicated above, it has come on record that the deceased was a science graduate. He was having proficiency in Textile Chemistry. Instead of opting for a job, he opted to carry on his own business.

    4. PW Janak Kumar Khorana has stated that the income of the deceased was around Rs. 5,000 per month. Nasib Singh is another witness, who gave the same figure. Krishan Chand, PW, stated that the deceased was earning Rs. 6,000 p.m He stated that the deceased was contributing Rs. 4,000 to his family. Dr. J.N Raina, PW stated that the deceased was paying rent for the residential accommodation. This was to the tune of Rs. 800 p.m If the figure as given by these witnesses is taken note of then the reasonable way of looking at would be to take into consideration the average of the two figures, i.e, Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 6,000. The average of this would come to Rs. 5,500. The Tribunal took note of the fact that the deceased paying Rs. 800 p.m as rent and, therefore, his income could not be less than Rs. 3,000. It was this figure which was taken note of. The evidence led by claimants in the shape of statements of two witnesses is that the deceased was having an income of Rs. 5,000 and one witness has stated that he was having an income of Rs. 6,000 per month. Thus if the totality of the evidence is taken note of then a finding can be recorded that the deceased must be earning Rs. 5,500. He was paying Rs. 800 as rent for residential accommodation and was also maintaining a motor cycle. Therefore, to repeat it would be apt to hold that the deceased was having income of Rs. 5,500 p.m If out of this amount of Rs. 5,500 a sum of Rs. 800 is deducted as rent for residential accommodation then the figure would come to Rs. 4,700.

    5. Out of this amount the deceased would be incurring one-third amount on himself. If amount spent on petrol and other small expenses is taken note of then Rs. 1,700 can be said to be the amount which deceased must have been spending upon himself. Thus the deceased must be contributing a sum of Rs. 3,000 to the family. Therefore, this is the figure which is required as contribution to the family to be taken note of. As a matter of fact this is the figure indicated by the Tribunal also, but the Tribunal has come to the conclusion that out of this the deceased must be spending ⅔rd of the income on himself and on his wife. This conclusion in my opinion is not apt. The deceased was a science graduate and had attained proficiency in Textile Chemistry. The modern trend to take care of the children is a factor which cannot be ignored. Therefore, it would be apt to hold that the deceased was having income of Rs. 5,500. After paying rent of Rs. 800 for hiring residential accommodation, he was having the balance of Rs. 4,700. Rs. 1,700 excluded out of this amount. Deceased was thus contributing a sum of Rs. 3,000 for the family. The annual dependency of the family would come to Rs. 36,000 The deceased was of the age of 33 years. It is thought apt to apply the multiplier of ‘16’. In this way the total amount of compensation payable would come to be Rs. 5,76,000. Thus the enhancement to the extent of Rs. 4,41,000 is made. On this enhanced amount the rate of interest would be 9 per cent with effect from the date of institution of the application.

    6. Another issue which is required to be taken note of is with regard to the rights of a widow to claim maintenance even if she remarries. The judicial opinion is to the effect that simply because a widow has remarried, is not to be made a ground for declining her compensation. In Hariram v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1994 ACJ 1094 (MP), the view expressed was that the widow on remarriage cannot be deprived of her right of getting compensation. In the above case, the argument put across was that as the widow had remarried, therefore, the entire amount be given to the father of the deceased. It was held that this legal proposition cannot be sustained. The reasoning given was that the inheritance never remains in abeyance and, therefore, rights of a widow are to be taken and recognised on the date when her husband dies. Therefore, she cannot be deprived of her right of getting compensation.

    7. Rajasthan High Court in the case reported as Regal Sports v. Mohd. Siddique, 1994 ACJ 294 (Rajasthan), held that the widow cannot be declined compensation on her remarriage. Amount awarded was Rs. 66,420. This was reduced in appeal to Rs. 50,000. What is sought to be pointed out is that the widow was held entitled to claim amount of compensation. In Rajasthan State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Kir an Lata, 1993 ACJ 130 (Rajasthan), the view expressed was that to deny compensation on the ground of possibility of remarriage of the widow would be enforcing a view which is against the public policy and would be violative of section 23 of the Contract Act. It was accordingly observed that question of possibility of remarriage would not come in the way at all and compensation is not to be based by taking into consideration the question of marriage or possibility of remarriage. In another decision of Rajasthan High Court, reported as Vimla Devi v. Chaman, 1992 ACJ 1048 (Rajasthan), it was held that the denial of compensation is not to be on account of possibility of remarriage of the widow of the deceased. Some other decisions dealing with this aspect of the matter are Rajinder Kumar v. Soma Devi, 2001 ACJ 307 (HP); Chandan v. Kanwarlal, 1989 ACJ 816 (Delhi); Khairullah v. Anita, 1994 ACJ 1017 (AP); Nankuram Sarajdin v. Member, M.A.C.T, Thane, 1994 (2) TAC 346 and Halki Bai v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., 1999 ACJ 187 (MP). Learned Judges in these cases have consistently held that remarriage of a widow would not disentitle her to claim compensation.

    8. Another reason which reinforces the above conclusion that on remarriage of a widow the social stigma which stood imposed earlier is not completely washed of. Some negative factors continue to exist and are taken note of in the case of remarriage of a widow. She may on remarriage may not enjoy the same status and frame of mind. Readjustment when widow has an infant, creates other social problems and she has to provide some security to the child or children from the first husband. This factor has to be taken note of. As such a widow on remarriage cannot be deprived of the compensation.

    9. The mother of the minor had stated that the amount of compensation was required to be spent on educating and bringing up her minor son. According to her, that much amount which she would have got would have been spent on the upkeep of the minor. Her counsel has stated that whatever amount she becomes entitled to now be given to her son; so that this monetary relief be of some solace for the fatherly love which he was unable to enjoy. As the appeal has been preferred by the son and mother of the deceased, the awarded enhanced amount shall go to the son.

    10. The amount which was found payable by the Claims Tribunal was invested in Kisan Vikas Patras. These were renewed from time to time. These accounts were being maintained by the grandparents. The grandparents, however, made a statement on 25.7.2000 that these Kisan Vikas Patras be got renewed. In pursuance of the directions given by this court, the amounts were reinvested and amount thus invested and the enhanced amount would be available to Abhishekh Malik, minor. It is directed that he would be given this amount on his attaining the age of majority. As this court was taking care of the interest of the minor, the age of majority in this case would be taken as 21 years. However, if the minor makes an application in this regard for the release of any amount at the earlier date, then that prayer can be considered by this court. As the enhancement of the compensation has been claimed by only two persons, i.e, son and mother and as the mother has stated that the entire awarded amount of compensation be given to the minor, it is directed that the entire amount would be payable to the minor. On the enhanced amount the rate of interest would be 9 per cent per annum. The Union of India would deposit the entire amount within three months, failing which amount of interest would be the same as allowed by the Tribunal. The entire amount would be deposited in a FDR with a scheduled bank and be made available to Abhishekh Malik in terms of the directions given in this order.

    11. appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Seema Malik And Others v. Union Of India .
    (Nov 27, 2002)