Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from an award dated 4-5-1994 by an arbitrator (the District Judge, Udhampur) under the J. & K. Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immovable Property Act. The appellants include the Union of India, the Estates Officer, Udhampur and the Assistant Defence Officer, Udhampur. Respondents Nos. 1 to 38 are the recorded owners of land measuring 408 Kanals 7 Marlas in villages Sansoo and Dhanoori, Tehsil Udhampur.

Chronology and key procedural facts stated in the opinion:

  • Initially (1948) the Army took the land on rent; it was requisitioned on 24-4-1950.
  • Proceedings for acquisition were initiated on 26-12-1988 under the Act; the Deputy Commissioner, Udhampur, was appointed to assess fair compensation and categorized the land into three classes with rates of Rs. 12,000, Rs. 10,000 and Rs. 9,000 per kanal respectively.
  • Respondents 1–38 sought appointment of an arbitrator; S.R.O. No. 40 dated 25-2-1993 appointed the District Judge, Udhampur, as arbitrator.
  • Respondents claimed Rs. 1,00,000 per kanal and Rs. 15,00,000 as lump-sum for trees. Appellants relied on the Deputy Commissioner’s rates as fair compensation.
  • The arbitrator framed issues, recorded evidence (witnesses for both sides), and issued an award on 4-5-1994 fixing market value at Rs. 70,000 per kanal, awarding Rs. 14,00,000 for trees and assessing an arbitration fee of Rs. 41,000 (suo motu) which he charged to respondents and directed that the Union reimburse half.
  • Both the Union of India and respondents appealed the award (appeals clubbed). The court heard arguments and delivered the decision summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the amount of compensation was determined and paid as per prevailing market rate at the time of requisition (Issue No. 1 framed by the arbitrator).
  2. If Issue No. 1 is not proved, what was the prevailing market rate at the time of acquisition (Issue No. 2)?
  3. Whether compensation for standing trees had been paid to the landlords and, if not, what compensation the landowners were entitled to (Issue No. 3)?
  4. Whether the petitioners (respondents-claimants) are entitled to solatium (jabrana) at the rate of 15% and interest on the compensation and, if so, to what extent (Issue 3-A)?
  5. To what relief are the landowners entitled (Issue No. 4)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Union of India and others)

  • The arbitrator wrongly treated the rural/village land as urban, thereby fixing an inflated price.
  • The land is located in a rural area with only a corner touching the National Highway; ingress and egress are surrounded by Army lands — it is not reasonably characterized as near Udhampur town.
  • The sale deeds relied on by the arbitrator were for small residential-site plots and are not comparable to the large rural holdings in dispute.
  • The arbitrator awarded Rs. 14 lakhs for trees without documentary basis; the Army planted many of the trees after taking possession and earlier agreements did not mention trees. The arbitrator used an arbitrary uniform formula and an unsupported per-tree value (Rs. 350 net) and multiplier.
  • The arbitrator (appointed statutorily) had no authority to claim/charge arbitration fees under the Arbitration Act; he incorrectly fixed and charged Rs. 41,000 for fee (assertion that actual sittings were fewer than charged).

Respondents' Arguments (Owners / Claimants Nos. 1–38)

  • Claimants contended that the land had acquired urban character by the time of acquisition and had building potentiality, being near the Town Area Committee limits, touched by roads and surrounded by commercial activity and army installations; therefore much higher market values applied (they pleaded up to Rs. 1.50 lakh per kanal but formally claimed Rs. 75,000 per kanal).
  • Respondents asserted entitlement to solatium (15%) and interest (18% p.a.), invoking Article 31 of the Constitution of India as applicable to Jammu & Kashmir and contending the award is inadequate. They also contended the Union’s appeal lacked locus and was time-barred.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chaman Lal Hargovind Lal v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, AIR 1988 SC 1652 Factors to be considered while determining market value (plus and minus factors such as smallness of size vs largeness of area; proximity to road; frontage; nearness to developed area; regular shape; remoteness; level and special disadvantage factors). The court applied these plus/minus factors to assess "building potentiality" and market comparability; it used the factors to evaluate whether comparable small-plot sales could be used and to justify adjusting the comparable-sales-based valuation downward given the land's largeness and limited frontage.
Periyar and Paree-Kani Rubbers v. State of Kerala, (1991) 4 SCC 195 Explains "market value" as the price in an open market between a hypothetical willing vendor and a prudent purchaser; cautions against anxious buyers, fictitious sales, and mechanical assessment—requires close scrutiny of evidence and consideration of neighbourhood lands with similar potentialities. The court invoked this passage as a guiding principle for objective scrutiny of the sales evidence and to justify rejecting mechanical or inflated assessments; it stressed objective assessment and consideration of neighbourhood potentialities when fixing the market value at Rs. 70,000 per kanal.
Koya Pathodi v. State of Kerala, (1991) 4 SCC 8 : AIR 1991 SC 2027 Method for assessing value of fruit-bearing/standing trees: adopt either (a) market value of land including value of trees treating them as timber, or (b) annual net income of the fruit trees capitalised over 15 years, whichever is higher. The court cited this rule to require proper valuation methodology for trees. It found the arbitrator's Rs. 14 lakhs assessment was unsupported; applying the standard of cogent proof and probabilities, the court modified the award for trees to Rs. 4 lakhs based on the evidence deficiencies described in the opinion.
Rao Narain Singh (Dead) By Lrs. v. Union Of India, AIR 1993 SC 1557 Concerned solatium awarded under Section 23(2) of the Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act and compared availability of solatium under State Act versus Central Act or Requisitioning Act. The court observed that the decision did not hold that solatium and interest are payable under the Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immovable Property Act; the precedent therefore was not helpful to respondents' claim for solatium. It was used to deny solatium/interest in the present case.
Prabhu Dayal v. Union of India, AIR 1991 SC 1451 (as cited) In the reported facts there was a delay of five years in appointment of arbitrator and under those circumstances claimants were held entitled to solatium at 15% on market value. The court noted the factual distinction (no similar delay here) and held the precedent inapplicable; it relied on the arbitrator's reasons to reject the claim for solatium and interest.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded in discrete analytical steps, applied to the issues framed by the arbitrator and grounded in the evidence adduced at the arbitration hearings:

  1. Statutory principle: The court cited the amended Sub-clause (3) of Section 8 of the Act (as substituted by Act No. VI of 1977) which provides that compensation, in absence of agreement, shall be "the price which the requisitioned property would have fetched in open market, if it had remained in the same condition as it was at the time of requisitioning and been sold on the date of acquisition." The court emphasized that valuation method depends on the nature of evidence and the building potentiality of the land.
  2. Market-value assessment: Applying the Chaman Lal factors and the guidance in Periyar and Paree-Kani Rubbers, the court carefully scrutinised the comparable sale deeds relied upon by respondents (small residential-site sales in the neighbourhood) and considered both plus and minus factors: the land's large size and relatively limited frontage (minus points) and its proximity to roads, presence of nearby commercial activity, army buildings and nearness (at certain points 1–2 km) to the Town Area Committee limits (plus points).
  3. Weight of evidence: The court reviewed evidence from both sides, including admissions by appellant witnesses (Patwaris) about contemporary high land prices and respondent witnesses' testimonies. The arbitrator's adoption of comparable-sales method, with downward margin for the land's size and other negative factors, was held to be a reasoned exercise. The court found no misappreciation of evidence or law in fixing Rs. 70,000 per kanal and therefore confirmed findings on Issues Nos. 1 and 2.
  4. Valuation of trees: The court applied the Koya Pathodi approach (methodology for tree valuation) and examined the evidence on number, kinds and ages of trees. It found respondents' oral evidence on trees to be inconsistent and largely not within personal knowledge for the relevant period; the Assistant Defence Estates Officer had testified that the Army had planted trees after taking possession. The arbitrator had assessed 4,000 trees at net Rs. 350 per tree (giving Rs. 14 lakhs) without adequate evidentiary basis. The court held that this finding was unsupported and set aside that portion of the award, but on probabilistic assessment ordered Rs. 4 lakhs as tree compensation payable to respondents in proportion to holdings.
  5. Solatium and interest: The court considered precedents cited by respondents (Rao Narain Singh and Prabhu Dayal) and found them factually distinguishable. Rao Narain Singh did not support payment of solatium under the Requisitioning Act; Prabhu Dayal was a special case involving a five-year delay in arbitrator appointment. The court accepted the arbitrator's reasons that respondents were not entitled to solatium or interest and confirmed the finding on Issue No. 3-A.
  6. Arbitrator's fee and applicability of Arbitration Act: The appellants challenged the arbitrator's unilateral fixation and charging of Rs. 41,000 as fee under Section 14 of the Arbitration Act. The court noted that clause (g) of Section 8 of the Requisitioning Act makes clear that provisions of the Arbitration Act do not apply to proceedings under the Requisitioning Act; therefore any direction by the arbitrator under the Arbitration Act had no legal sanction and required no obedience.
  7. Relief and disposition: After modulating the award (confirming land value, reducing tree award, denying solatium and interest, nullifying arbitrator's fee direction), the court partially allowed the Union’s appeal and rejected the respondents’ cross-appeal. Parties were directed to bear their own costs. Amounts deposited in court were to be paid in accordance with the modified findings after the period of appeal expires.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core rulings):

  • Market value upheld at Rs. 70,000 per kanal.
  • Compensation for standing trees reduced from Rs. 14,00,000 (arbitrator’s award) to Rs. 4,00,000 (to be paid to respondents Nos. 1–38 according to their shares).
  • No solatium or interest was allowed to respondents (the claim for jabrana/solatium and interest was rejected).
  • The arbitrator's direction to charge Rs. 41,000 fee and to have the Union reimburse half was held to be without legal sanction (provisions of the Arbitration Act do not apply to proceedings under this Requisitioning Act), and therefore requires no obedience.
  • Result on appeals: Civil Appeal No. 31/1994 (Union and others) was partially accepted; the respondents' appeal (Civil-38/1994) was rejected; parties to bear their own costs.

Implications and practical effects:

The immediate, direct effects on the parties are:

  • The respondents will receive compensation for the land at Rs. 70,000 per kanal.
  • Respondents will receive Rs. 4,00,000 total as compensation for standing trees (to be apportioned among respondents Nos. 1–38 by share of holdings).
  • No additional solatium or interest award was allowed, and the arbitrator's fee direction was declared legally unsanctioned.
  • Amounts already deposited will remain deposited until the appeal period expires and thereafter be paid in accordance with the court’s modified findings.

The opinion does not announce or rely on any new legal precedent; it applies existing statutory provisions and established precedents to the facts and evidence before the court. No broader doctrinal change was stated in the opinion.

Source: Summary derived exclusively from the provided opinion text. No outside materials or inferences beyond the text were used.

    Union Of India And Others v. Chain Singh And Others

    1. The appellants namely, Union of India, Estates Officer, Udhampur and Assistant Defence Officer, Udhampur, through the medium of this appeal have challenged the Award dated 4-5-1994 given by the learned Arbitrator, (District Judge, Udhampur) under the provisions of the J. & K. Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immoveable Property Act (hereinafter to be are the owners of the land measuring 408 Kanals 7 marlas situated in village "Sansoo"

    and village "Dhanoori" Tehsil Udhampur.

    Initially in the year 1948, the Army auth orities had taken over the said land on rent but subsequently on 24-4-1950 the same was requisitioned. On 26-12-1988 the proceedings for the acquisition of the land were initiated under the said Act and the Deputy Commis sioner, Udhampur, was appointed as a com petent authority for assessing the fair com pensation, who categorised the land into three classes and fixed the rates on the following terms:-

    1. Brehal Changi @ Rs. 12,000/- per kanal.

    2. Brehal Mandi @ Rs. 10,000/-per kanal.

    3. Banjer Kadeem or Banjer Jadeed @ Rs.9,000/-per kanal.

    2. Respondents Nos. 1 to 38 felt aggrieved and approached the Government for appointment of arbitrator. This request was accepted. Under Sub-clause (b) of Section 8 of the Act, S.R.O. No. 40 dated 25-2-1993 was issued whereby the learned District Judge, Udhampur, was appointed as arbitrator. On a notice issued by the arbitrator to respondents Nos, 1 to 38 inviting their claims for compensation, they filed a claim statement claiming Rupees one lakh per kanal as compensation for acquired land. They also claimed lump sum amount of Rupees fifteen lakhs as the cost of the trees standing over the land. Appellants Nos. 2 and 3 countered these claims by stating that the rates fixed by the Deputy Commissioner, Udhampur, were fair and they may be construed as fair amount of compensation.

    3. The arbitrator framed the following issues:-

    1. Whether amount of compensation was determined and paid as per prevailing market rate at the time of requisition? OPD

    2. In case Issue No. 1 is not proved, what was the prevailing market rate at the time of acquisition of land in dispute? OPP

    3. Whether the compensation of standing trees has not been paid to the landlords, if so, to what compensation the land owners are entitled in this count? OPP 3-A. Whether the petitioners are entitled to solatium (Jabrana) at the rate of 15 per cent and interest on the amount of compensation. If so, to what extent? OPP

    4. To what relief, the land owners are entitled to? OPP

    4. The owners-claimants examined Dwarka Nath, Puran Chand, Dewan Chand and Ram Sarup as witnesses. Besides that, owners-claimants namely, Gian Singh, Sal-dev Singh, Sansar Chand, Chain Singh, Rattan Singh, Lal Singh and Karan Singh also appeared as witnesses. On behalf of the appellant Union Government, Janak Singh, Parshotam Singh, Jagdish Lal and Manjit Singh (Assistant Defence Estates Officer) appeared as witnesses.

    5. The arbitrator purporting to act on evidence produced by the parties made an award on 4-5-1994. By that award the market value of the acquired land was fixed at Rs. seventy thousands per kanal and the cost of the standing trees was assessed in the sum of Rs. 14 lakhs. In addition to this, the arbitrator suo motu fixed his arbitration fee at the rate of Rs. 1,000/- per hearing and quantified it at rupees forty one thousand. He charged this amount from respondents-claimants Nos. 1 to 38 before the award was given and made a direction, in the award, that the appellant, Union of India, should reimburse them to the extent of half of it at the time of making the payment of award amount.

    6. The Union of India felt the award as excessive. Respondents-claimants Nos. 1 to 38 have treated the award as inadequate. Both have challenged the same by filing the appeals which are clubbed together. The appellant Union of India along with other appellants i.e. Nos. 2 and 3 have challenged the award on the following grounds :-

    1. The learned arbitrator after admitting the land in question as rural and village land has wrongly treated the same as urban land and fixed inflated price.

    2. The land in question is located in the rural area and only a corner of it touches the National Highway, the ingress and egress thereof is surrounded by the lands belonging to Army authorities. The conclusions arrived at by the arbitrator that it is situated near the town of Udhampur is thus not based on sound reasoning.

    3. The arbitrator has made three sale deeds namely, dated 23-8-1987, 11-8-1987 and 19-12-1984 as the basis for fixing the market price of the land in question. The subject-matter of these sale deeds were small pieces of land meant to be used as residential sites and such a land could not be compared as of the same kind as the land in question which undoubtedly is rural land.

    4. In the agreement of the land in question no mention has been made of any tree standing on the land in question and respondent No. 39 (Deputy Commissioner, Competent Authority, Udhampur) had rightly not taken into consideration any tree but the arbitrator on the oral assertions of respondents Nos. 1 to 38 and their witnesses have given compensation to the tune of Rupees 14 lakhs. The factual position is that after taking the possession of the land in question (which was taken in August, 1948), the army authorities started planting trees in abundance for the purposes of camouflaging vital installations and for environmental development. But this fact was wrongly ignored. The arbitrator, without any basis and at random fixed the cost of a tree at the rate of Rs. 350/-. In the J & K Forest Manual the price of a tree is fixed at Rupees 350/- which has a dia. of 140 cm. to 150 cm. and girth of 10 feet and also is in the age group of 80 to 90 years. On spot there is no girth of any tree which is more than five feet. The uniform formula adopted in giving compensation at the rate of Rs. 3430.93 NP per kanal as the cost of standing trees on every piece of land is arbitrary and unjustifiable.

    5. That the arbitrator without the authority of any law has taken Rs. 41,000/- as his fee from respondents Nos. 1 to 38 and wrongly ordered the appellant Union of India to reimburse the respondents to the tune of half of the amount. The arbitrator was not appointed as an arbitrator by the act of the parties but his appointment was statutory. He could not claim any fee for acting as arbitrator. On facts it was denied that the arbitrator had held 41 sittings in the proceedings. Rather, it is pleaded that he had held 26 hearings (both effective and non-effective).

    7. Respondents-claimants 1 to 38 in their appeal (No. 38 of 1994) have claimed compensation at the rate of Rs. 75,000/- per kanal Solatium is claimed at the rate of 15 per cent and interest at the rate of 18% per annum. They have pleaded that on the basis of evidence, they have proved the price of land at Rs. 1.50 lakh per kanal but as they could not pay the Court-fee on this amount so they have claimed the rate of compensation at Rs. 75,000/- per kanal. That the land in question has all the potentialities of urban land surrounded by roads and is situated within the vicinity of the town of Udhampur. Article 31 of the Constitution of Indie is applicable to the State of Jammu and Kashmir, which commands that no property can be compulsorily acquired or requisitioned save for public purpose and by authority of law which provides for compensation for the property so acquired or requisitioned. The appeal filed by the Union of India is not maintainable as it has no locus standi to file the present appeal. The owner claimants have been left with no other land except the land which has been occupied by them for residential purposes and the awarded amount is meagre. It is also pleaded that the appeal filed by the Union of India is time-barred.

    Heard the arguments of the learned counsel for the parties.

    8. Mr. B. S. Slathia, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants has contended that the learned arbitrator had fallen into error by basing the assessment of the claim of compensation on the sale prices of such lands which comprised of small pieces and were meant to be used as sites of the buildings. That the land in question comprises of a big chunk which at the material time was of arable and waste nature and at the time of its acquisition it could fetch less price in the market. Mr. Bhagotra, the learned counsel for respondents Nos. I to 38 has asserted that the land in question had at the time of its acquisition acquired the nature of "Urban (and "because of abnormal extension of the town of Udhampur. That the extended limits of the Town Area Committee, Udhampur were only at stones throw from the land in dispute. That the ingression and egression into the land stood well established vehicular roads which touched it from three sides. That the nearly area had started hubing with commercial activities as there were some shops and a "stone crusher". That the army authorities have used the land for setting up buildings and installations. That taking into account all these factors it cannot be said that the land was still "Agricultural land". Rather, it could fetch more price in the market if sold as plots and the learned Arbitrator has erred in fixing the price at lower side. Lastly, he has contended that respondents Nos. 1 to 38 have been left with meagre holdings which are situated in the "Abadi Deh" of these villages.

    9. I have considered the respective contentions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties. Sub clause (3) of Section 8 of the Act was amended vide Act No. VI of 1977 and the following sub clause was substituted :-

    "The compensation payable for the acquisition of property under Section 7 shall in the absence of an agreement be the price which the requisitioned property would have fetched in open market, if it had remained in the same condition as it was at the time of requisitioning and been sold on the date of acquisition."

    The amended Section lays down a principle aimed at giving to the owner of the acquired land an amount of compensation which approximates to such lands' just equivalent value on the date of its acquisition. Method of valuation to be resorted to by an arbitrator in determining acquired lands' just equivalent price, has to necessarily depend on the nature of evidence adduced by the panics in that regard. Building Potentiality of the acquired land assumed significance on the basis of sale deeds as well as other evidence.

    In the case of Chaman Lal Hargovind Lal v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (AIR 1988 SC 1652), the Appex Court laid down that while disposing of a reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, the following factors must be skectched on the mental screen:-

    Plus factors Minus points

    1. Smallness of size Largeness of area.

    2. Proximity to a road

    2. Situation in the interior at a distance from the road.

    3. Frontage on aroad

    3. Narrow strip of land with very small frontage compared to depth.

    4. Nearness to developed area.

    4. Lower level re-quiring the de-pressed portion to be filled up.

    5. Regular shape

    5. Remoteness fromthe developed locality.

    6. Level vis-a-vis land underacquisition.

    6. Some special disadvantage factor which would deter apurchaser.

    Again in the case of Periyar and Paree-Kani Rubbers v. State of Kerala, (1991) 4 SCC 195 while dealing with the provisions of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act the Appex Court explaind the meaning of "market value" in the following manner: -

    "The guiding star would be the conduct of a hypothetical wilting vendor who would offer the lands and a willing purchaser in normal human conduct would be willing to buy as a prudent man in normal market conditions as on the date of notification under Section 4(1) -but not an anxious buyer dealing at arms' length nor facade of sale or fictitious sales brought about in quick succession or otherwise to inflate the market value.

    It is the paramount duty of the Courts of facts to subject the evidence to close scrutiny, objectively assess the evidence tendered by the parties on proper considerations thereof in correct perspective to arrive at reasonable market value. The neighbourhood lands possessed of similar potentialities or same advantageous features or any advantageous special circumstances available in each case also are to be taken into account. The mechanical assessment has to be eschewed. Misplaced sympathies or undue emphasis solely on the claimants' right to compensation would place heavy burden on the public exchequer to which everyone contributes by direct or indirect taxes. The claimant has to be re-compensated for re-habilitation or to purchase similar lands elsewhere."

    10. Now, adverting to the evidence tendered by the parties in this case it is established that a corner of the land was touching the "National Highway" even in the year 1950. At the time of its acquisition (in the year 1988) "Karemchi-Mansar road" was also touching it from the southern and western sides. The learned Arbitrator has held that on the eastern side of the land "National Highway" touches it upto a length of one hundred meters. That on the western side "Kerimchi-Mansar" metalled road touches it upto 725 metres and on the southern side it passes upto a length of 460 metres. The limits of the Town Area Committee. Udhampur are from some points at a distance of one kilometre and other points at two kilometres. It is the admitted case of the appellants that Army authorities have set up stores and buildings over this land. The evidence led by respondents Nos. 1 to 38 goes un-rebutted to the fact that there are commercial activities nearby the land in question. Respondents-claimants and their witnesses have deposed that major portion of the land from these two villages have been acquired by the Army authorities and the inhabitants have been left only with small holdings nearby their residential sites. All this establishes the "building potentiality" of the acquired land. The argument pales into insignificance that still it is agricultural land of arable and waste kinds. The neighbourhood lands possess the potentialities of commercial activities and these advantageous features cannot be denied to the land in question. The learned Arbitrator has adopted the "comparable sales method" in evaluating the price of the land in question. Respondents-claimants have produced the evidence of those sale deeds where the subject matter for sale was of small portions of land and the same was to be used as sites for the residential buildings. The sales had taken place in the neighbourhood of the land acquired. The minus points which lean in favour of the land in question are its large size and a small portion as frontage on. roads. The learned Arbitrator has taken note of these factors and marginalized the price on the lower side. The lands which are the subject matter of the sales reflected in the sale deeds duly tendered in evidence have fetched the price which varies between rupees on Lakh and Rupees one and half Lakh per kanal. Even the witnesses of the appellants namely, Parshotam Singh, and Janak Singh (who are Patwaris) have admitted tremendous hike in price of the lands. Parshotam Singh has stated that the price of the land at the material time was at Rupee 11/2 Lakhs per kanal whereas Janak Singh has stated it was Rupees two Lakhs per kanal. The learned Arbitrator has objectively taken into consideration the vastness of the land in question as well as its location which mostly is on the interior side of the roads. He after eschewing the machanical process of assessment rightly fixed the price at Rupees seventy thousand per kanal. There is thus found no illegality either of mis-appreciation of evidence or of law. The result is that the findings on issues Nos. 1 and 2 are confirmed.

    11. The next question which falls for consideration and determination is whether the compensation of Rupees fourteen Lakhs as the cost of the trees is just or not. Respondents-claimants Nos. I to 38 in their case before the learned Arbitrator had set up this claim by stating as under:-

    Moreover, the cost of standing trees in the land and fruit trees has not been assessed and the cost of trees is more than Rs. 15 Lakhs and the petitioners claim near Rs. 15 Lakhs as cost of trees.

    Neither appellant No. 2 nor appellant No. 3 in his objections filed before the said Arbitrator denied this allegation by taking a specific plea that there was no tree on the land at the time of its requisition. Equally respondents-claimants Nos. I to 38 have not specified the the number of trees, their kinds and ages etc. The method how assessment in respect of the standing fruit trees on an acquired land is made was spelled out by the Honourable Supreme Court in the case of Koya Pathodi v. State of Kerala. (1991) 4 SCC 8 : (AIR 1991 SC 2027) wherein it was said that

    "where land with fruit bearing trees standing thereon is acquired, held, either market value of the land including value of the trees treating them as timber or annual net income of the fruit bearing trees multiplied by capitalisation of 15 years, whichever is higher should be adopted."

    12, In the instant case, respondents-claimants Nos. 1 to 38 had tried to establish their claim by leading oral evidence which is not of cogent and consistent nature. Dewan Chand PW is the only witness who could state from his personal knowledge that there were trees standing on the land when it was requisitioned in the year 1950 because his present age is 79 years. According to him, when the land was requisitioned, there were many trees standing thereon. Petitioner Gian Singh who is 38 years old has stated that there were many trees of the variety of "Shesham". "Tun", "Jaman", "Mangoes", "Simbal" and "Khe-dak" and they are still there. Baldev Singh respondent-claimant who is 50 years old has stated that at that time there were about one thousand or one and a half thousand such trees on the land. Sansar Chand, respondent-claimant who is of 57 years age has stated that there were more than one thousand such trees on the land. Respondent-claimant, Chain Singh, who is also of the same age has stated that there were many such trees and if sold at that time they would have fetched a price of Rupees 30 Lakhs. Rattan Singh, Respondent-claimp.nt who is 55 years old has valued the trees at a rate of about rupees 30 Lakhs and further stated that Army personnel are cutting and selling them. Lal Singh, respondent-claimant who is 36 years old has valued these trees at rupees 15 lakhs. Karan Singh, respondent-claimant whose age is 40 years has valued the trees at Rupees 22 Lakhs. From the deposition of these witnesses it becomes clear that hardly anyone of them can claim on the basis of his personal knowledge as to what was the age and number of trees in the year 1948 or 1950. Those claimants who show their present age as 57 years were hardly children of about eight years and not competent to register such facts on their mental screens. Parshotam Singh, Patwari who has been examined as a witness by the appellants herein has supported the case of the respondents-claimants by deposing that there are about four to five thousand trees standing on the land. His evidence is also of no help as he is deposing of the present number of the trees. Mr. Manjit Singh, Assistant Defence Estates Officer, who has appeared as a witness of the appellants has stated that agreement which was executed between the parties at the time of requisitioning the land does not recite anything which can show that there was any tree standing on the land. According to him, the Army authorities have planted many trees for the purpose of camouflaging and beauti-fication. In his cross-examination, he has admitted that there is no such column in this agreement which required any mention of the trees.

    13. At the time when the land was requisitioned it is mentioned in the revenue record that it was of arable nature and only a

    -part of it was waste i.e. "Banjer Qadeem" and "Jadeed". When such was the condition of the land, it cannot be admitted that old trees of the varieties shown above were in abundance i.e. numbering four to five thousands. No cultivator allows its land to become shady because that hampers the growth of the crops. Respondents-claimants Baldev Singh and fSansar Chand have admitted that there" were about one thousand or more trees standing on the land. In the presence of such evidence which was of puerile nature, the learned Arbitrator has assessed the number of standing trees at four thousand and of the age of more than 50 years. He has evaluated the fire-wood cost at rupees 500/ - each tree. After deducting Rs. 150/- as for cutting and removing a tree, the net value of a tree has been asses sed Rupees 350/-. By adopting a multiplier of 4000 he has awarded Rs. 14 Lakhs as the cost of the trees. This finding is based on no evidence and runs contrary to the admission made by some of the respondents-claimants as stated above. This is a stark reality that after taking over the possession of the land in question the Army authorities had put it to the use of their choice. The statement of Mr. Manjit Singh, Assistant Estates Officer, cannot be ignored who has stated that Army Authorities have planted the trees for camouflaging their installation as well as for environmental beautification. The respondents-claimants have here blown their claims out of proportions in order to derive the maximum benefit but that, without any basis cannot be allowed to become a windfall for them. In the absence of any cogent evidence, this claim has to be settled on probabilities. At the same time it cannot be said authoritatively that there was no tree standing on the land at the time of its requisition. Respondents-claimants Nos. 1 to 38 have to rehabilitate themselves in the present scenario when there is universal trend in price rise of lands. Law does not allow that such an expropriation which is for a public purpose should prove baneful for them. Taking stock of all these attending circumstances it is, therefore, held that the findings of the learned Arbitrator is set aside to the extent where he has mechanically assessed the value of the standing trees to the extent of Rupees fourteen Lakhs. But it will be relevant to state here that the probabilised price of the standing trees at the material time is Rupees four lakhs which the appellant Union of India is bound to pay to the respondent-claimants Nos. I to 38, , according to the share of the holding. The finding on issue No. 3 is modified to this extent.

    14. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent-claimants has pleaded that his clients are entitled to "Jabrana" and the "Sqlatium" and in support of his contention, he has cited the case of Rao Narain Singh (Dead) By Lrs. v. Union Of India, AIR 1993 SC 1557.

    From the perusal of this decision it is found that solatium was granted at the rate admissible under Section 23(2) of the Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act and no such rate was admissible under the corresponding provisions of the Central Land Acquisition Act. The facts of that case are quite different from the facts of the present case. In the reported case, the controversy was regarding the payment of the solatium either under the central Land Acquisition Act or under the State Land Acquisition Act. The Appex Court has held that the solatium to be paid for the land acquired under the Requisitioning and Acquisition Act cannot be a benefit of solatium not available for a land acquired under the State Act i.e. under the Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act. It has not been held therein that solatium and interest are to be paid under the Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immovable Property Act. The ruling cited at the bar is thus of no help to the respondents-claimants.

    The next case cited at the bar by the learned counsel appearing for the respondents-claimants is that of Prabhu Dayal v. Union of India, AIR 1991 SC 1451 (sic). The facts of this case are also different from the case in hand as there was a delay of five years for the appointment of Arbitrator and under those special circumstances the claimants were entitled to solatium at the rate of 15% on the market value. In this case that is not the position. The Arbitrator has given sound reasons which disentitle respondents-claimants Nos. I to 38 to receive any solatium and interest on the amount awarded. The finding on issue No. 3-A is thus confirmed.

    15. The appellants in the memo of the appeal have raised an objection that the learned Arbitrator has unauthorisedly fixed his arbitration fee under Section 14 of the Arbitration Act when it had no application to these proceeding. On facts it was also pleaded that the learned Arbitrator had held only 21 sittings when he has suo motu charged rupees fourty one thousand from respondents-clai-

    mants Nos. 1 to 38 for 41 sittings and without any legal basis directed the appellant Union of India to reimburse them by one half. No argument was advanced by either side on this factual and legal plea. A bare perusal of clause

    (g) of Section 8 of the Act makes it clear, that no provision of the arbitration act has any application in the proceeding which are conducted under the Act. In this view of the matter, any direction given by the learned Arbitrator under any provision of the arbitration act has no legal sanction and requires no obedience.

    16. In the cross appeal (No. 38/94) filed by respondents-claimants Nos. 1 to 38, the claim of compensation has been set forth in the sum of Rs. 75,000/- per kanal. On the evidence which was led before the learned Arbitrator such plea could not be substantiated. The evidence has been discussed in detail in connected Civil Appeal No. 31 / 94. Similarly, the plea for getting solatium and interest has been discussed in detail.

    17. In view of the discussions made above, appeal Civil No. 31/1994, of the-appellants is partially accepted and appeal of the respondents-claimants (Civil-38/1994) is rejected. The parties are left to bear their own costs. The amount of compensation deposited in terms of the orders of the Court shall be paid to respondents-claimants Nos. 1 to 38 in terms of the findings given in these appeals but after the expiry of the period of appeal. Till that period expires, the amount shall remain deposited as it is.

    All the connected CPM's are also accord ingly disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. Chain Singh And Others
    (May 21, 1996)