AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Act;(iii) Courts of Sessions; and(iv) Courts of Magistrates.3. Section 6-A
  • Section 190 of the Code (Section 190 of the Central Code)
  • Section 497, into conflict with Sec. 167 of the Code,
  • sub-section (2) thereof. Sub-section (2) of Section 167
  • Section 438 of the Central Code (497-A of the Code)
  • Section 81 of the Central Code. Section 438,
  • Section 437 of the Central Code (497
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Act;(iii) Courts of Sessions; and(iv) Courts of Magistrates.3. Section 6-A
  • Section 190 of the Code (Section 190 of the Central Code)
  • Section 497, into conflict with Sec. 167 of the Code,
  • sub-section (2) thereof. Sub-section (2) of Section 167
  • Section 438 of the Central Code (497-A of the Code)
  • Section 81 of the Central Code. Section 438,
  • Section 437 of the Central Code (497
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Section 497-A Petition)

Factual and Procedural Background

A petition under Section 497-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure (referred to in the opinion as "the Code") was filed by the petitioner seeking anticipatory bail. A criminal case under Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code had been registered against the petitioner at Nanakpora Police Station, New Delhi. The petitioner is a resident of village Bajarni, Tehsil Doda, within the State of Jammu and Kashmir, and approached the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir for anticipatory bail under Section 497-A.

The State objected to the High Court's jurisdiction, contending that the High Court has no jurisdiction to grant anticipatory bail in respect of a case registered with a police station situated outside its territorial limits. The High Court considered the objection well founded. The Court reproduced Section 497-A in the opinion, analysed its scope in conjunction with other provisions of the Code, and ultimately dismissed the petition and vacated the interim relief previously granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court and the Court of Session have the power under Section 497-A of the Code to grant anticipatory bail to a person against whom a case has been registered with a police station situated outside the territorial limits of their jurisdiction.
  2. Whether the residence of the accused (i.e., residing within the local limits of the High Court's jurisdiction) permits that High Court to grant anticipatory bail in respect of offences registered with police stations outside the State's territorial limits.
  3. How Section 497-A should be read with other provisions of the Code (in particular Sections 6, 6-A, 9, 10, 12, 28, 496, 497 and 167) for determining the territorial extent of courts' powers to grant bail or anticipatory bail.

Arguments of the Parties

State's Arguments

  • The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir has no jurisdiction to grant anticipatory bail under Section 497-A in respect of a case registered at a police station located outside the territorial limits of the State/high court's jurisdiction.
  • Because the High Court lacks appellate, revisional or supervisory powers over courts or police stations situated outside the State, any order by this High Court would have no binding force on those authorities and therefore cannot be an effective exercise of jurisdiction.

Petitioner's / Mr. Singh's Arguments

  • Reliance on the Calcutta High Court decision in B.R. Sinha v. The State (1982 Cri LJ 61), which held that a High Court has jurisdiction to entertain an anticipatory bail application by a petitioner who resides within its jurisdiction even though the case was started outside its local limits — in support of the proposition that the High Court could grant anticipatory bail in this case.
  • Implicitly, an argument that residence of the accused within the local limits of the Court should be relevant for entertaining an anticipatory bail application.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565 : AIR 1980 SC 1632 Principles governing anticipatory bail under Section 438 (Central Code) and interpretation that Section 438's powers were not circumscribed by Section 437 of the Central Code. The Court observed that the Supreme Court in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia explained the principles of anticipatory bail but did not intend to lay down that residence of the accused could determine jurisdiction to grant anticipatory bail where the offence was registered outside territorial limits. The opinion relied on the principles but distinguished their scope from the present factual situation.
B.R. Sinha v. The State, 1982 Cri LJ 61 (Calcutta High Court) Held that the High Court could entertain applications for anticipatory bail by petitioners who resided within its jurisdiction even though they apprehended arrest in connection with cases started outside its local limits (in that case the applications related to matters pending before courts outside local limits). The Court treated B.R. Sinha as distinguishable on facts: in B.R. Sinha the matters were pending before other courts outside the local limits, whereas in the present case the complaint/case was registered with a police station outside the territorial limits. The Court declined to adopt B.R. Sinha's apparent extension (to permit jurisdiction based on residence when FIRs are filed outside territorial limits) and expressly disagreed with such an extension.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by textual and structural interpretation of Section 497-A read together with other relevant provisions of the Code to determine the territorial limits of the power to grant anticipatory bail.

  1. The Court reproduced Section 497-A and then examined the Code's scheme: Sections 6 and 6-A classify criminal courts and magistrates; Section 9 confines a Sessions Judge's jurisdiction to the Sessions Division (district) for which he is appointed; Sections 10 and 12 deal with appointment and territorial limits of District Magistrates and other magistrates; Section 28 indicates that High Courts and Courts of Session are competent to try offences shown to be triable by them.
  2. From this statutory framework the Court concluded that while the High Court exercises powers throughout the territory of the State of Jammu and Kashmir, Sessions Judges and Magistrates exercise powers only within defined areas. More broadly, the Court reasoned that none of these courts can exercise powers, including the power to grant anticipatory bail under Section 497-A, at any place outside the territorial limits of the State of Jammu and Kashmir.
  3. The Court stressed a practical and legal consequence: the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir lacks appellate, revisional and supervisory powers (under Chapters referenced) over courts situated outside the State's territory; therefore any order by this High Court would have no binding force on those courts or police stations outside the State, and so the law would not permit an order that could be disregarded with impunity.
  4. The Court then read Sections 496 and 497 (bail provisions for bailable and non-bailable offences) together with Section 167 (which governs detention and forwarding of accused). It concluded that the phrase "a Court" in Sections 496 and 497 must mean a court competent to try or commit the accused for trial; otherwise Section 497 would conflict with Section 167(2). By parity, the High Court and Court of Session under Section 497-A must likewise mean the High Court and Court of Session competent to try the accused seeking anticipatory bail.
  5. The Court considered Mr. Singh's reliance on the Calcutta High Court decision (B.R. Sinha) which in turn relied on Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia. The Court found the Calcutta decision distinguishable: in B.R. Sinha the petitions sought anticipatory bail in relation to matters pending before courts outside the local limits, not in relation to cases registered at police stations located outside jurisdictional limits. The Supreme Court's decision in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia did not intend to extend jurisdiction based on residence of the accused in the manner now contended for.
  6. The Court emphasized that statutory provisions speak of taking cognizance and trial of the offence (Sections 190 and the jurisdictional chapters), not the offender's residence; Section 438 of the Central Code (analogous to Section 497-A) does not make residence of the applicant a relevant factor for territorial jurisdiction. On those grounds the Court upheld the State's objection and dismissed the petition.

Holding and Implications

PETITION DISMISSED.

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The petition seeking anticipatory bail under Section 497-A was dismissed and the interim relief earlier granted to the petitioner was vacated.
  • The Court upheld the State's objection that the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir could not grant anticipatory bail in respect of a case registered with a police station situated outside the territorial limits of the State/High Court's jurisdiction.
  • The Court rejected the contention that the residence of the accused within the High Court's local limits is sufficient to confer jurisdiction to grant anticipatory bail in respect of an FIR registered outside the territorial limits.

Broader implications:

The opinion reasons that orders of the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir would have no binding effect on courts or police stations outside the territorial limits of the State; consequently, Section 497-A must be read as limited to courts competent to try or commit the accused for trial. The opinion does not undertake to announce any broader precedent beyond this legal construction, and its judgment is grounded on the statutory interpretation and the territorial limits discussed in the analysis above.

Order concluded: "Petition dismissed. The order granting interim relief to the petitioner is vacated."

    Mohan Singh Parihar v. Commissioner Of Police, New Delhi And Others

    1. This petition u/s. 497-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Code’, raises an important question of the extent of to powers of the High Court and the Court of Session, to grant anticipatory bail to a person, against whom a case has been registered with a police station, which is situated outside the limits of their territorial jurisdiction. A criminal case under Secs. 406 and 420 I.P.C has been registered against the petitioner with police station Nanakpora, New Delhi. The petitioner is a resident of village Bajarni, Tehsil Doda, a place within the territorial limits of the State of Jammu and Kashmir. He has filed the present petition in this court for granting the anticipatory bail in exercise of its powers u/s. 497-A. An objection has been taken on behalf of the State that this court has no jurisdiction to grant anticipatory bail to a person, against whom a case has been registered with a police station which is situated outside the local limits of its jurisdiction under the Code. The objection is, in my opinion, well founded and must succeed. Sec. 497-A is, for the sake of convenience, reproduced as below:

    “497-A. Direction for grant of bail to person apprehending arrest.—

    (1) When any person has reason to believe that he may be arrested on an accusation of having committed a non-bailable offence, he may apply to the High Court or the Court of Session for 3 direction under this section, and that Court may, if it thinks fit, direct that in the event of such arrest, he shall be released on bail.

    (2) When the High Court or the Court of Session makes a direction under sub-section (1), it may include such conditions and such direction in the light of the facts of particular case, as it may think fit, including—

    (i) a condition that the person shall make himself available for interrogation by a police officer as and when required;

    (ii) a condition that the person shall not, directly or indirectly make an inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the Court or to any police officer;

    (iii) a condition that the person shall not leave the State without the previous permission of the Court;

    (iv) such other condition as may be imposed under sub-section (2-a) of Sec. 497 as if the bail were granted under that section.

    (3) If such person is thereafter arrested without warrant by an officer-in-charge of a police station on such accusation and is prepared either at the time of arrest or at any time while in the custody of such officer to give bail, he shall be released on bail, and if Magistrate taking cognizance of such offence decides that a warrant should issue in the first instance against that person he shall issue a bailable warrant in conformity with the direction of the Court under sub-section (1).”

    2. In order to determine its true intent and scope, Sec. 497-A has to be read with a few other sections of the Code. Sec. 6 enumerates the classes of criminal courts. These are:

    (i) High Court;

    (ii) Courts constituted under a Special Act;

    (iii) Courts of Sessions; and

    (iv) Courts of Magistrates.

    3. Section 6-A further classifies the courts of Magistrates into courts of Judicial Magistrates, namely, Chief Judicial Magistrate, Judicial Magistrates of the First Class, Judicial Magistrates of the Second Class, and Special Judicial Magistrates and Executive Magistrates namely, District Magistrates, Addl. District Magistrates, Sub-Divisional Magistrates, Executive Magistrates of the First Class, Executive Magistrates of the Second Class, and Special Executive Magistrates. A Sessions Judge, in terms of Sec. 9, exercises his jurisdiction under the Code within the limits of the Sessions Division, to be known as the district, for which he is appointed as a Sessions Judge. Consequently, a Sessions Judge who has ceased to be a Sessions Judge of one district, and has not become the Sessions Judge of another district, cannot exercise the powers of Sessions Judge. These powers are always relatable to a territory, and cannot be exercised in isolation thereof. Section 10 says that the Government shall appoint District Magistrates, and the High Court the Chief Judicial Magistrate for such districts, who shall exercise their powers as such Magistrates within the territorial limits of their respective districts. The other Executive and Judicial Magistrates, in terms of Section 12 shall be appointed for such districts, but the local areas in the district within which they shall exercise their powers under the Code, shall have to be defined by the Government, in so far as the Executive Magistrates are concerned, and by the High Court, in so far as the Judicial Magistrates are Governed. Section 28 provides that subject to the other provisions of the Code, any offence under the Ranbir Penal Code may be tried by the High Court, or by the Court of Session, or by any other Court by which such offence is shown to be triable in the 8th Column of the Second Schedule. From a careful reading of this section it clearly transpires that whereas the jurisdiction of every other criminal Court to try an offence is restricted by the 8th Column of the Second Schedule, the jurisdiction of the High Court and the Court of Session is not so limited and these Courts are competent to try all offences, provided the cases are properly brought to these Courts for their trial. High Court has been defined by Cl. (f) of Section 4 to mean “the highest Court of criminal appeal and revision in the Jammu and Kashmir State”.

    4. A combined’ reading of these sections would thus indicate that whereas the High Court will exercise its powers under the Code throughout the territory of the State of Jammu and Kashmir, the Sessions Judge and other Magistrates will exercise their powers within their defined areas in the territory of the State. It further follows that none of these Courts shall exercise any power conferred on it, including the power to grant anticipatory bail under Section 497-A, at any place outside the territorial limits of the State of Jammu and Kashmir.

    5. That apart, the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir not having the appellate powers under Chap. XXXI nor the revisional powers under Chap. XXXI of the Code, and nor even the powers of superintendence and control u/s. 104 of the Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir in relation to Courts situated outside the territory of the State, its order will have no binding force on those Courts. The same will be true of the Police Stations which are situated outside the territory of the State. Law will not, therefore, countenance a situation where an order of the High Court may be flouted by a Court lower than the High Court or for that matter by an officer-in-charge of a police station with impunity. If the interpretation sought to be placed on Section 497-A by Mr. Singh, that the High Court and the Court of Session have powers to grant anticipatory bail to a person, against whom a case has been registered with a police station, situated outside the territory of the State is to be accepted, then a situation is likely to arise where the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir may have to watch as a helpless spectator its order granting anticipatory bail to the accused in that case being disregarded by the Officer-in-charge of the police station. Such cannot be the true intent and scope of Section 497-A.

    6. The same conclusion is bound to follow, if the problem is approached from another angle. Section 496 of the Code provides that a person accused of a bailable offence shall be released on bail when he is arrested by the police, or appears or is brought before a Court, provided he is prepared to give bail. Section 497 which deals with non-bail-able offences, provides that a person accused of a non-bailable offence, other than the one punishable with death or imprisonment for life, if he is arrested by the police, or appears or is brought before a Court, may also be released on bail by such Court. The expression “a Court” occurring in both these sections cannot mean and include any other, whether within or outside the State of Jammu and Kashmir, but must mean a Court competent to try or commit the accused for trial, for the contrary interpretation to be placed upon it is bound to bring Section 497, into conflict with Sec. 167 of the Code, in particular, to sub-section (2) thereof. Sub-section (2) of Section 167 reads as under:

    “(2) The Magistrate to whom an accused person is forwarded under this section may, whether he has or has not jurisdiction to try the case, from time to time authorise the detention of the accused in such custody as such Magistrate thinks fit for a term not exceeding fifteen days in the whole. If he has not jurisdiction to try the case or commit it for trial and considers further detention unnecessary, he may order the accused to be forwarded to a Magistrate having such jurisdiction.

    Provided that:—

    (a) the Magistrate may authorise detention of the accused person, otherwise than in custody of the police, beyond the period of fifteen days if he is satisfied that adequate grounds exist for doing so but no magistrate shall authorise the detention of the accused person in custody under this section for a total period exceeding sixty days and on the expiry of the said period of sixty days the accused person shall be released on bail if he is prepared to and does furnish bail, and every person released on bail under this section shall be deemed to be so released under the provisions of Chapter XXXIX for the purpose of that Chapter;

    (b) No Magistrate shall authorise detention in any custody under this section unless the accused is produced before him:

    (c) No Magistrate of the second class not specially empowered in this behalf by the Government or the High Court, as the case may be, shall authorise detention in the custody of the police.”

    7. On its plain language, where further detention of the accused in police custody is not considered necessary by the Magistrate before whom the accused, is produced for remand, he shall not release him on bail, unless he has the power to try or commit him for trial. Such a Magistrate may, however, release him on bail in exercise of his powers under Section 497, if “a Court” of which this section speaks, were to mean and include any Court. Section 497 has, therefore, to be read along with Section 167 to find out the amplitude of the expression “a Court” occurring in it. On the parity of the reasoning, the High Court and a Court of Session of which Section 497-A speak, must also mean the High Court and the Court of Session competent to try the accused seeking enlargement on bail.

    8. In support of his contention, Mr. Singh, however, relied upon a Bench decision of the Calcutta High Court viz.: B.R Sinha v. The State, 1982 Cri LJ 61 in particular, to the following passage occurring therein (at p. 63):

    “Considering the provisions laid down in S. 438 of the Code and the principles of law with regard to the anticipatory bail explained by their Lordships in Gurbaksh Singh's case (1980 Cri LJ 1125) (SC): ((1980) 2 SCC 565 : AIR 1980 SC 1632) and also considering the view taken by at least three Division Benches in the cases referred to above, we are of the opinion that this Court has jurisdiction to entertain application for anticipatory bail of a petitioner who resides within the jurisdiction of the Court, though he apprehends arrest in connection with a case, which has been started outside the jurisdiction of this court.”

    9. This decision is clearly distinguishable on facts. In all the three applications before the Calcutta High Court, the petitioners had sought anticipatory bail not in cases registered with police stations outside the local limits of the jurisdiction of the High Court, but in cases pending before different Courts situated outside the local limits, of its jurisdiction. Deriving support from the principle laid down by their Lordships in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565 : AIR 1980 SC 1632 : (1980 Cri LJ 1125), that powers of the High Court or the Court of Session to grant anticipatory bail under Section 438 were not circumscribed by the limitations contained in Section 437 of the Central Code (497 of the Code), the Bench held that anticipatory bail could be granted to a person under Section 438, even if the offence for which the person sought bail was not bailable as provided by Section 81 of the Central Code. Section 438, there can be no manner of doubt, applies not not only to those cases which are registered with police stations, but also to those cases which are pending in Courts. On the view taken by their Lordships in Gurbaksh Singh's case (supra), no fault can be found with the view taken by the learned Judges in B.R Sinha's case (1982 Cri LJ 61) (Cal) (supra). But, if tiie learned Judges by making the above quoted observations meant to convey further that the High Court or the Court of Session in whose local limits of jurisdiction the person seeking anticipatory bail resides at the relevant time, are competent to grant it even in those cases where the case against such person has been registered with a police station situated outside the territorial limits of the jurisdiction of that Court, then with utmost respects to the learned Judges, if I may say so, I cannot agree with them in taking this view. Neither their Lordships of the Supreme Court meant to lay down any such law in Gurbaksh Singh's case (supra) and nor could residence of the accused in such cases play any role in the matter. Section 190 of the Code (Section 190 of the Central Code) speaks of taking cognizance of the offence, but not of the offender. Like wise Chapter XV of the Code (Chapter XIII of the Central Code) which deals with the jurisdiction of the criminal Courts in inquiries, and trials, including the ordinary place of inquiry and trial, also speaks of the trial of the offence but not of the offender. That apart, even Section 438 of the Central Code (497-A of the Code) does not in terms makes relevant the residence of the person seeking enlargement on anticipatory bail. For all that has been stated heretofore, the objection taken by the State survives and the petition is dismissed accordingly. The order granting interim relief to the petitioner is also vacated.

    10. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohan Singh Parihar v. Commissioner Of Police, New Delhi And Others
    (Nov 12, 1982)