Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by Deepak Gupta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the constitution of the State Information Commission in Himachal Pradesh. The petition alleged that the State had appointed only a State Chief Information Commissioner and had not appointed any State Information Commissioner(s), and that this made the constitution of the State Information Commission illegal and not in accordance with Section 15(2) of the Right to Information Act, 2005. The central statutory provision at issue was Section 15(2), which provides that the State Information Commission shall consist of the State Chief Information Commissioner and "such number of State Information Commissioners, not exceeding ten, as may be deemed necessary."

The State disputed the claim and defended its decision to appoint only a Chief Information Commissioner. The petitioner also sought an order preventing the Chief State Information Commissioner from acting as the entire Commission and sought that he not be entitled to salary and allowances until a properly constituted Commission was in place. The Court heard arguments and delivered a judgment directing the State to appoint at least one State Information Commissioner within eight weeks and addressed the petitioner's prayer regarding the Chief Commissioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Information Commission under Section 15(2) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 can be constituted as a single-member body (only a State Chief Information Commissioner) or must be a multi-member body (a Chief Information Commissioner plus at least one State Information Commissioner).
  2. Whether the Chief State Information Commissioner should be restrained from acting as the entire Commission and/or deprived of salary and allowances until the State appoints the required State Information Commissioner(s).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The State Information Commission must consist of a State Chief Information Commissioner and at least one State Information Commissioner; appointment of only the Chief renders the constitution of the Commission illegal and contrary to Section 15(2) of the Act.
  • The petitioner sought, in addition, that the Chief State Information Commissioner should not act as the Commission and should not receive salary and allowances until the Commission is properly constituted.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The State contended through counsel that it is not incumbent upon the State to appoint any State Information Commissioner beyond the Chief; the phrase "as may be deemed necessary" in Section 15(2)(b) confers discretion on the State to appoint any number up to ten and includes the option of appointing none.
  • The State argued that appointing additional Commissioners is not justified because pending work in the State is low, and appointing additional members would cause unnecessary expense and wastage of public money.
  • Counsel for the State also referred to Section 23 of the Act and argued that, absent a clear demarcation of powers between the Chief and other Commissioners, no additional Information Commissioners could be appointed; the implication being that procedural or power-allocation gaps should prevent appointments.
  • To support the construction of discretion, counsel relied on Article 324 and case law concerning the Election Commission, arguing by analogy that discretion can include not appointing additional members.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Article 324, Constitution of India (provision cited) Shows the constitutional wording for the Election Commission: "The Election Commission shall consist of the Chief Election Commissioner and such number of other Election Commissioners, if any, as the President may from time to time fix." Used to demonstrate that the phrase "if any" permits either a single-member or multi-member Election Commission. The Court compared the language of Article 324(2) with Section 15(2) of the RTI Act and concluded the drafting differs: Article 324 expressly contemplates a possibly single-member body, whereas Section 15(2) of the Act uses different language (including the conjunction "and") indicating the legislature intended a Chief plus at least one other member for the State Information Commission.
S.S. Dhanoa v. Union of India, (1991) 3 SCC 567 : AIR 1991 SC 1745 Addresses controversy over whether the Election Commission should be multi-member and discusses circumstances in which multiple Election Commissioners were appointed despite not being warranted by workload. The Court referred to the case as illustrative of disputes over multi-member bodies and the reasons given for appointments; the opinion extracts the case's criticism of appointments made when additional members were not necessary, but treats it as part of the broader discussion on composition (not as directly determinative of RTI Act construction).
T.N. Seshan, Chief Election Commissioner of India v. Union of India, (1995) 4 SCC 611 Constitution Bench consideration of Article 324; it corrected certain observations in S.S. Dhanoa and made pertinent observations about multi-member bodies and expectation of dignified resolution of differences among high functionaries. The Court relied on the Constitution Bench's observations to support the proposition that independent statutory bodies can be multi-member and that the scheme allowing multiple members presumes they will work together with professionalism; the opinion treats these observations as relevant to interpreting the composition of an independent body like the State Information Commission.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis followed established rules of statutory interpretation and applied them to Section 15(2) of the Right to Information Act, 2005:

  • Textual and grammatical construction: The Court observed that sub-section (2) of Section 15 is divided into two clauses joined by the conjunction "and" — one clause referring to the State Chief Information Commissioner and the other to "such number of State Information Commissioners, not exceeding ten, as may be deemed necessary." Reading the provision plainly suggests the Commission "shall consist of" both the Chief and some State Information Commissioners.
  • Ordinary meaning and the golden rule: The Court reiterated the cardinal principle that words of a statute must be given their ordinary, grammatical meaning unless such a construction leads to absurdity. When statutory language is clear and unambiguous, courts must give effect to it.
  • Rejecting the State's workload/cost argument: The Court rejected the State's contention that low pending work or potential expense justified not appointing any State Information Commissioners. If Parliament intended a single-member Commission, it could have said so expressly; the Court held the State cannot rely on considerations of inconvenience or expense to override a mandatory statutory composition, if that is what the language indicates.
  • On Section 23 and demarcation of powers: The Court rejected the submission that appointments cannot be made because powers between the Chief and other Commissioners were not demarcated. Instead, the Court held it is open to the State to prescribe procedures and regulations under the Act (for example, under Section 23 or other enabling provisions) to lay down how powers will be exercised when additional Commissioners are appointed.
  • Comparative drafting analysis with Article 324: The Court compared Section 15(2) with Article 324(2). Article 324 expressly uses "if any" after "such number of other Election Commissioners," indicating that the Election Commission may be single-member. By contrast, the Court found Section 15(2) is drafted so as to require a Chief plus at least one other member — the legislature could have used language like Article 324(2) had it intended to permit zero additional members.
  • Use of case law on multi-member bodies: The Court considered earlier judgments concerning the Election Commission (S.S. Dhanoa and T.N. Seshan). It observed that while there has been controversy over the constitution of multi-member bodies, the Constitution Bench in T.N. Seshan corrected certain observations in S.S. Dhanoa and emphasized expectations that high functionaries resolve differences properly. The Court found these observations relevant to independent bodies like State Information Commissions but not determinative of the statutory meaning of Section 15(2).
  • Conclusion from the foregoing: The Court concluded the plain language and legislative design indicate that the State Information Commission must be a multi-member body, consisting of a State Chief Information Commissioner and at least one State Information Commissioner; the State's discretion to appoint Commissioners extends to any number up to ten but not to appointing none.
  • On the petitioner's request to restrain the Chief and withhold salary: The Court declined to grant relief that would invalidate actions already taken by the Chief or penalize the Chief for the State's failure to perform its mandatory functions. The Court expressed concern that such relief would create chaos and that the Chief should not be punished for an omission by the State.
  • Remedial direction and safeguard: To secure compliance, the Court directed the State to appoint at least one State Information Commissioner within eight weeks. The Court further declared that if the State failed to comply, the State Information Commission — being then improperly constituted — would cease to exist or function, and all consequences would follow.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed. The Court held that the State Information Commission under Section 15(2) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 must be a multi-member body comprising the State Chief Information Commissioner and at least one State Information Commissioner (and up to ten as may be deemed necessary by the State). The State of Himachal Pradesh was directed to appoint at least one State Information Commissioner within eight weeks.

Implications and direct effects:

  • Direct effect on parties: The State must appoint at least one State Information Commissioner within eight weeks of the order. If it fails to do so, the Court declared the State Information Commission — being then improperly constituted — shall cease to exist or function and all consequences will follow.
  • Relief not granted against the Chief: The Court refused to restrain the Chief State Information Commissioner from acting or to withhold his salary and allowances; the Court would not penalize the Chief for the State's omission and declined to nullify actions already undertaken by the Chief.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion rests on statutory construction principles applied to Section 15(2) and on analogies with Article 324 and decisions about the Election Commission, but the judgment does not expressly claim to set a novel beyond-the-record precedent; it focuses on the immediate interpretive conclusion and remedial direction as applied to the facts before the Court.

No order as to costs. The writ petition was disposed of in the terms set out above (Petition allowed).

    Virender Kumar v. P.S Rana & Anr.

    Deepak Gupta, J.:— The short question which arises for decision in the present case is whether the State Information Commission to be constituted under the Right to Information Act, 2005, (hereinafter referred to as the Act) can be a single member body or must be a multi member body.

    2. The petitioner has filed this writ petition alleging that the State of Himachal Pradesh has only appointed the Chief Information Commissioner and has not appointed any State Information Commissioner(s) and, therefore, the constitution of the Station Information Commission is illegal and not in accordance with Section 15(2) of the Act, which reads as follows.—

    “15(1) xxxxxxx

    (2) The State Information Commission shall consist of—

    (a) the State Chief Information Commissioner; and

    (b) such number of State Information Commissioners, not exceeding ten, as may be deemed necessary.”

    3. The contention of the petitioner is that the State Information Commission must consist of a Chief Information Commissioner and at least one State Information Commissioner. On the other hand, the contention of the respondents as put forth by Mr. R.S Cheema, learned Senior Advocate, appearing for the State of Himachal Pradesh is that it is not incumbent upon the State to appoint a State Information Commissioner. According to him the words “as may be deemed necessary” in Clause (b) of sub-section (2) of Section 15 vest discretion in the Government to appoint any number of State Information Commissioner up to a maximum of 10. It is contended that the State can, therefore, decide not to appoint any State Information Commissioner also.

    4. On behalf of the respondents it is also contended that there is no justification for the appointment of any State Information Commissioner since the pending work in the State is very low and the appointment of another person would lead to unnecessary expense and wastage of public money.

    5. As far as this contention is concerned, we cannot accept the stand of the respondents. Mr. Cheema has taken us through the provisions of the Act and the rules according to which the State has to provide certain facilities and staff to the State Information Commissioners. We are of the considered view that if under the provisions of the Act it is the mandate of Parliament that the State Information Commission should be a multi member body then the State cannot be allowed to plead that it be permitted to have a single member Commission on the ground that the work is less or that it would lead to unnecessary expenses.

    6. Mr. R.S Cheema, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the respondents, has also drawn our attention to Section 23 and has submitted that in the absence of clear demarcation of the powers of the State Chief Information Commissioner and the State Information Commissioners, no Information Commissioners can be appointed. We are not in agreement with this submission. It is for the State to lay down the procedure which can be in the form of regulations and, therefore, when the State appoints another State Information Commissioner, it can also lay down the manner in which power shall be exercised by this officer.

    7. The only question which remains to be answered is the construction and meaning to be given to Section 15(2) of the Act. It would be pertinent to note that the legislature in its wisdom has divided sub-section (2) into two clauses. Between the two clauses the conjunction “and” has been used. On a bare reading of the Act, it appears that the State Information Commission shall consist of the State Chief Information Commissioner and some State Information Commissioners. The maximum number of State Information Commissioners to be appointed is 10.

    8. It is a cardinal principle of law of interpretation of statute that the words of a statute must be understood in their natural, ordinary or popular sense and construed according to their grammatical meaning, unless such construction leads to some absurdity or unless there is something in the context or in the object of the statute to suggest to the contrary. The golden rule is that the words of a statute must be given their ordinary meaning. It is yet another rule of construction that when the words of the statute are clear, plain and unambiguous, then the Courts are bound to give effect to that meaning irrespective of the consequences. It is said that the words themselves best declare the intention of the law giver. The Courts have adhered to the principle that efforts should be made to give meaning to each and every word used by the legislature and it is not a sound principle of construction to brush aside words in a statute as being inapposite surpluses if they can have a proper application in circumstances conceivable within the contemplation of the statute.

    9. The present case is to be decided keeping in mind the aforesaid principles.

    10. Learned Senior Counsel for respondent No. 2 has referred to Article 324 of the Constitution of India and has also cited certain judgments with a view to support his view that the discretion given in Clause (b) of Section 50(2) (sic 15(2)) to the State means that it is for the State to decide whether to appoint any State Information Commissioner or not.

    11. It would be relevant to refer to Article 324 of the Constitution of India under which the Election Commission of India is constituted, relevant portion of which reads as follows:—

    “324. Superintendence, direction and control of elections to be vested in an Election Commission.— (1) The superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of the electoral rolls for, and the conduct of, all elections to Parliament and to the Legislature of every State and of elections to the offices of President and Vice-President held under this Constitution shall be vested in a Commission (referred to in this Constitution as the Election Commission).

    (2) The Election Commission shall consist of the Chief Election Commissioner and such number of other Election Commissioners, if any, as the President may from time to time fix and the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners shall, subject to the provisions of any law made in that behalf by Parliament, be made by the President.

    (3)-(6) xxxxxx”

    12. The use of words “if any” used in Article 324(2) after the phrase “such number of other Election Commissioners” clearly shows that the intention of the Parliament was that the Election Commission may be a single member body or a multi-member body. If the language of Article 324(2) of the Constitution of India is compared with the language of Section 15(2) of the Act, it is apparent from the reading of the Act that as far as the State Information Commission is concerned, it has to consist of the Chief Election Commissioner and at least one other member.

    13. The question whether a body like the Election Commission of India should be a multi-member body or there should only be one Chief Election Commissioner has been a subject-matter of controversy. In S.S Dhanoa v. Union of India, (1991) 3 SCC 567 : AIR 1991 SC 1745, the Apex Court in Para 21 held as follows:—

    “21. In the first instance, the petitioner and the other Election Commissioners were appointed when the work of the Commission did not warrant their appointment. The reason given by Respondent 1 (Union of India), that on account of the Constitution (61st Amendment) Act reducing the voting age and the Constitution (64th Amendment) and (65th Amendment) Bills relating to election to the Panchayats and Nagar Palikas, the work of the Commission was expected to increase and, therefore, there was need for more Election Commissioners, cuts no ice. As has been pointed out by Respondent 2, the work relating to revision of electoral rolls on account of the reduction of voting age was completed in all the States except Assam by the end of July, 1989 itself, and at the Conference of the Chief Electoral Officers at Tirupati, Respondent 2 had declared that the entire preparatory work relating to the conduct of the then ensuing general elections to the Lok Sabha would be completed by August in the whole of the country except Assam. Further, the Constitution (64th and 65th Amendment) Bills had already fallen in Parliament, before the appointments. In fact, what was needed was more secretarial staff for which the Commission was pressing, and not more Election Commissioners. What instead was done was to appoint the petitioner and the other Election Commissioner on October 16, 1989. Admittedly, further the views of the Chief Election Commissioner were not ascertained before making the said appointments. In fact, he was presented with them for the first time in the afternoon of the same day, i.e October 16, 1989.”

    14. In T.N Seshan, Chief Election Commissioner of India v. Union of India, (1995) 4 SCC 611 : 1995 AIR SCW 3341, a Constitution Bench of Apex Court was dealing with the scheme of Article 324 of the Constitution of India. Certain observations made in S.S Dhanoa's case supra were held to be incorrect. The Apex Court in Para 13 made certain pertinent observations in relation to the Election Commission of India, which, in our opinion, are also relevant to an independent body like the State Information Commission.

    “14. xxxxx. We cannot overlook the fact that when the Constitution-makers provided for a multi-member Election Commission they were not oblivious of the fact that there may not be agreement on all points, but they must have expected such high-ranking functionaries to resolve their differences in a dignified manner. It is the constitutional duty of all those who are required to carry out certain constitutional functions to ensure the smooth functioning of the machinery without the clash of egos.”

    15. The way Section 15(2) of the Act has been worded leaves us in no manner of doubt that the legislature intended and the Act provides that the State information Commission should be a multi-Member Body consisting of one State Chief Information Commissioner and at least one State Information Commissioner. In case the intention of the State was otherwise, the section could have been worded in a different manner altogether. No doubt, the State has been given the discretion to appoint as many State Information Commissioners as it deem necessary, but this number cannot be less than one and cannot exceed ten. We are unable to accept the contention of the respondents that the State has the discretion not to appoint any State Information Commissioners. Such an interpretation would militate against the language of Section 15(2) which, in our opinion, clearly shows that the State Information Commission is to be a multi-Member Body.

    16. The petitioner has also prayed that respondent No. 1, i.e the Chief State Information Commissioner should not act as State Information Commission and should not be held entitled to his salary and allowances until the State Information Commission is constituted by respondent No. 2 in accordance with law. In our opinion this prayer cannot be granted. We cannot set at nought the actions which have already been taken by the Chief State Information Commissioner. This may lead to a State of chaos. We are also of the view that the Chief State Information Commissioner cannot be penalized because the State has not performed its mandatory functions. We can, however, make adequate safeguards to ensure that a properly constituted Commission is constituted in the near future.

    17. We, therefore, allow this writ petition and direct the respondent No. 2 State of Himachal Pradesh to appoint at least one State Information Commissioner in accordance with Section 15(2)(b) of the Right to Information Act, 2005. This he positively done within 8 weeks from today. In case the State fails to appoint a State Information Commissioner in terms of this order in the time so stipulated, the State Information Commission being an improperly constituted body shall cease to exist or function and all consequences shall follow.

    18. The writ petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. No order as to costs.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Virender Kumar v. P.S Rana & Anr.
    (May 17, 2007)