Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • case.13. Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • case.13. Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction against the defendant restraining him from interfering with the suit land (Khewat/Khatauni Nos. 61 min/67 min, Khasra No. 151/1, measuring 1-3 Bighas, village Matyal, Tehsil Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur). The plaint alleged that the plaintiff (together with a pro forma defendant) was owner in possession of the land with a residential house, cow-shed and courtyards since time immemorial. The defendant allegedly obtained an illegal allotment of adjacent land and then began interfering with the plaintiff's possession by putting raw material on the suit land, felling trees, and threatening construction.

The defendant contested the suit by filing a written statement raising preliminary objections (including maintainability, valuation, jurisdiction, non-joinder/mis-joinder, locus standi, estoppel and res judicata) and denying the plaintiff's possession and the existence of the claimed structures. The plaintiff filed a replication reiterating his claim.

The trial Court framed ten issues (including whether the plaintiff was owner in possession, whether the defendant interfered, entitlement to possession if dispossessed, and several objections raised by the defendant). After evidence and hearing, the trial Court: partly decided issue No.1 in favour of and against the plaintiff (found plaintiff in possession of part of the suit land), held issue No.3 redundant, decided issue No.2 against the plaintiff (i.e., found defendant not interfering), and decided remaining preliminary issues against the defendant. The suit was dismissed by the trial Court by judgment and decree dated 2-6-1992.

The plaintiff appealed; the District Judge, Bilaspur affirmed the trial Court's judgment and decree by a judgment dated 24-6-1999. The plaintiff thereafter filed this appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenging the appellate decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is owner in possession over the suit land as alleged? (Issue No.1)
  2. Whether the defendants are interfering with the possession of plaintiff over the suit land as alleged? (Issue No.2)
  3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for possession of the suit land if found to be dispossessed during the pendency of the suit as alleged? (Issue No.3)
  4. Whether the suit is not maintainable as alleged? (Issue No.4)
  5. Whether this Court has no jurisdiction to entertain and try the suit as alleged? (Issue No.5)
  6. Whether the suit is not properly valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction as alleged? (Issue No.6)
  7. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of necessary parties as alleged? (Issue No.7)
  8. Whether the suit is barred by principle of res judicata as alleged? (Issue No.8)
  9. Whether the plaintiff is estopped to file the suit as alleged? (Issue No.9)
  10. Relief sought. (Issue No.10)

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff alleged ownership and possession of the suit land (including residential house, cow-shed and courtyard) since time immemorial.
  • The plaintiff alleged that the defendant illegally obtained allotment of adjoining land and thereafter started interfering with the plaintiff's possession by placing raw material, felling trees and threatening construction on the suit land.
  • By replication, the plaintiff controverted the defendant's defence and reaffirmed his possession and entitlement to relief.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant raised preliminary objections in the written statement: maintainability, improper valuation, lack of jurisdiction, non-joinder/mis-joinder of necessary parties, lack of locus standi, estoppel and res judicata.
  • On merits the defendant denied the plaintiff's possession and the existence of the alleged structures, claiming that part of Khasra No. 151/1 was used as a path by villagers and the remaining portion was used by the defendant as 'Bartan'.
  • The defendant stated that the defendant had constructed a cow-shed and house on a different Khasra (151/2), and thereby denied the plaintiff's claimed physical occupation of the disputed portions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Braham Datt v. Prem Chand, 2000 (1) SLJ 431 The appellate Court, if it entertains doubt about correctness of revenue demarcation, ought to appoint a Local Commissioner for demarcation rather than dismiss the suit; courts must ensure substantial justice is delivered and parties should not be deprived of merits due to lapses by revenue agencies. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that, given the confusion in Tatimas/demarcations and the appellate court's doubts, a Local Commissioner should be appointed to ascertain the correct spot position of the suit land (Khasra No. 151/1) and report, and the appeal was remitted with directions to appoint such Commissioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the findings of the two lower courts and the record. It noted that both courts had concurrently found that the plaintiff was in possession of a part of the suit land (excluding the defendant's house) but had also found that the defendant was not interfering with the plaintiff's possession. The appellate Court concluded these concurrent findings—that the defendant is not interfering—were unreasonable and unsupported by the record.

The Court analyzed the defendant's written statement and concluded that by denying the plaintiff's possession over the suit land as a whole and asserting that part was a village path and the remainder used as the defendant's 'Bartan', the defendant implicitly claimed rights over portions that both lower courts had found to be in the plaintiff's possession. This pleading, taken together with oral evidence from the plaintiff (PW-1) and witnesses Ram Chand (PW-2) and Sunder Ram (PW-3), demonstrated that the defendant had the intention and was interfering with the plaintiff's possession of the portion claimed by the plaintiff. On that basis, the Court found the lower courts' conclusion (that there was no interference) contrary to both pleadings and evidence and therefore unsustainable.

The Court further examined the documentary evidence regarding demarcation (Tatimas). It found irreconcilable differences between the Tatima prepared by the plaintiff's patwari (Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A) and that prepared by the defendant's revenue official (Tatimas Ex. DW-3.A). Specifically, the suit Khasra No. 151/1 was shown in differing locations in the respective Tatimas, creating confusion as to the identity and exact spot location of the suit land.

The Court criticized the lower appellate Court's preference for the Tatima prepared by DW-3 on the ground that DW-3 was a kanungo; the record showed that when DW-3 prepared Tatimas Ex. DW-3.A he was, in fact, a patwari. The Court held that the confusion arose from how the Tatimas were prepared (including the manner adopted by the revenue official Partap Singh, Kanungo (DW-3)) and not from any deliberate fault of the parties, and that they should not suffer for errors in official demarcation.

The Court considered Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which empowers the Court to issue a commission for local investigation to elucidate any matter in dispute. The Court emphasized that a commission under this Rule may be issued suo motu and that where a local investigation is requisite and proper in the facts and circumstances, the Court ought to exercise its discretion to issue a commission so that a final and just decision can be rendered.

Applying the principle in Braham Datt v. Prem Chand, the Court held that because accurate demarcation could not be achieved from the existing Tatimas and oral evidence alone, and because the lower courts' conclusions on interference were untenable in light of pleadings and evidence, it was necessary for the fair and just decision of the case to appoint a Local Commissioner to determine the actual position on the spot (with reference to Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A) and to report on path, construction and possession-related facts.

The Court concluded that the findings on issue Nos.1 and 2 recorded by the Courts below were unsustainable and must be set aside. However, findings on issue Nos.3 to 9 were sustained and left undisturbed. Consequently, the appropriate remedy was to remit the matter to the lower appellate Court with directions to appoint a Local Commissioner to investigate and report, and thereafter to decide the appeal afresh on issues 1 and 2 in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; IMPUGNED JUDGMENT AND DECREE SET ASIDE; MATTER REMITTED TO THE LOWER APPELLATE COURT WITH DIRECTIONS.

Holding:

  • The Court allowed the appeal under Section 100 CPC.
  • The Court affirmed the findings on issue Nos. 3 to 9 as recorded by the Courts below.
  • The Court set aside the concurrent findings on issue Nos. 1 and 2 (relating to ownership/possession of part of the suit land and whether the defendant was interfering with plaintiff's possession) and thereby set aside the impugned judgment and decree.
  • The Court remitted the appeal to the lower appellate Court with a direction to appoint a Local Commissioner to investigate and report the actual factual position regarding the path, construction, etc., on the suit land (Khasra No. 151/1) as specified in Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A, and to proceed thereafter according to prescribed procedure and law.
  • There was no order as to costs.
  • Parties were directed to appear before the lower appellate Court on 23-9-2002.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the earlier dismissal of the suit (and the appellate affirmance) is vacated insofar as it rests on findings in issue Nos. 1 and 2; those issues must be re-examined by the lower appellate Court after a local investigation.
  • The appointment of a Local Commissioner is required to resolve the factual confusion created by conflicting Tatimas; this is expected to enable a final decision on possession and interference so as to prevent perpetuation of the dispute.
  • No broader precedent beyond the specific application of Rule 9, Order 26 and the cited authority was newly created by this decision; the Court applied established discretionary power to order local investigation in order to secure a just resolution of factual disputes.

Appeal allowed.

    Bali Ram v. Mela Ram And Another

    1. This appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been preferred by the appellant/plaintiff (hereafter referred to as ‘the plaintiff’) against the judgment and decree dated 24-6-1999 passed by the learned District Judge, Bilaspur whereby the judgment and decree dated 2-6-1992 passed by the learned Sub Judge, Ghumarwin dismissing the suit of the plaintiff, have been affirmed.

    2. Brief facts leading to the presentation of this appeal are that the plaintiff instituted a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction against the respondent/defendant (hereafter referred to as ‘the defendant) restraining him from interfering in the suit land comprising Khewat/Khatauni Nos. 61 min/67 min, Khasra No. 151/1, measuring 1-3 Bighas, situate in village Matyal, Tehsil Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur. The case of the plaintiff as made out in the plaint is that he along with the pro forma respondent/defendant is owner in possession of the suit land having a residential house, cow-shed and courtyards on the suit land and their possession as such is since time immemorial. The defendant illegally got allotment of two Biswas of Nautor land out of the adjoining Khasra No. 251/246 though he was not eligible for such allotment. Thereafter the defendant started interfering With the possession of the plaintiff and the pro forma defendant over the suit land by putting raw material on the suit land and by felling the trees standing thereon and further threatened to raise construction by digging the courtyard of the cow-shed of the plaintiff. The defendant did pot desist from his acts despite requests. Hence, the suit.

    3. The defendant contested the suit. In the written statement he raised preliminary objections regarding maintainability and valuation of the suit, jurisdiction of the Court, non-joinder and misjoinder of necessary parties, want of locus standi, estoppel and res judicata. On merits, it was claimed that the suit land is not in possession of the plaintiff nor there exist any cow-shed, residential house or courtyard. It has further been claimed that the suit land is situate between the cattle shed of the defendant and the land allotted to the defendant and there exists a path on a part of the suit land and the remaining suit land was used by the defendant as ‘Bartan’ and he had constructed a cow-shed and a house on land Khasra No. 151/2. Thus, the claim of the plaintiff has been denied.

    4. The plaintiff filed replication thereby controverting the defence taken by the defendant and re-affirmed his claim.

    5. On the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial Judge framed the following issues:—

    “1. Whether the plaintiff is owner in possession over the suit land as alleged? OPP

    2. Whether the defendants are interfering with the possession of plaintiff over the suit land as alleged? OPP

    3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for possession of the suit land if found to be dispossessed during the pendency of the suit as alleged? OPP

    4. Whether the suit is not maintainable as alleged? OPD

    5. Whether this Court has no jurisdiction to entertain and try the suit as alleged? OPD

    6. Whether the suit is not properly valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction as alleged? OPD

    7. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of necessary parties as alleged? OPD

    8. Whether the suit is barred by principle of res judicata as alleged? OPD

    9. Whether the plaintiff is estopped to file the suit as alleged? OPD

    10. Relief.”

    6. After recording the evidence and hearing the parties, the learned trial Judge decided issue No. 1 partly in favour of the plaintiff and partly against him and held issue No. 3 as redundant. Issue No. 2 was held against the plaintiff and the remaining issues were decided against the defendant. In view of the findings so recorded, the suit was dismissed vide judgment and decree dated 2-6-1992. Being aggrieved, the plaintiff preferred an appeal which was dismissed by the learned District Judge, Bilaspur by the impugned judgment and decree. Hence this appeal.

    7. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have also gone through the records.

    8. It may be pointed out at the very outset that while deciding issue No. 1, the trial Court held that the plaintiff is in possession of a part of the suit land, excluding the house of the defendant. Thus, the issue regarding ownership and possession has been partly decided in favour of the plaintiff. Similarly, the lower appellate Court, vide impugned judgment, held that a part of the suit land is in possession of the plaintiff. Both the Courts have further recorded the concurrent findings that the defendant is not interfering with the possession of the plaintiff over the suit land. That is why, the suit of the plaintiff for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with his possession over the suit land has been dismissed.

    9. The concurrent findings of fact recorded by both the Courts below to the effect that the defendant is not interfering with the possession of the plaintiff over the suit land are evidently unreasonable and not supported by the material on record. It is unambiguously clear from the pleadings of the defendant read with other evidence on record that he has all the intentions to interfere and is interfering with the possession of the plaintiff over that part of the suit land which is in his possession. It is so because the defendant, in his written statement, has denied the possession of the plaintiff over the suit land as a whole and has claimed that part of land khasra No. 151/1 is used as a path by the villagers and the remaining land is used by him as Bartan. It is, thus, implicit in the defence taken by the defendant that he is claiming a path on a part of the suit land and remaining portion of it as his Bartan. This challenge to the Claim of the plaintiff constitutes a challenge even to his claim regarding that part of the suit land which, according to both the Courts below, is in possession of the plaintiff. When this pleading of the defendant is read with the statements of the plaintiff (PW-1), Ram Chand (PW-2) and Sunder Ram (PW-3), it is crystal clear that the defendant is interfering with the possession of the plaintiff over the portion of the suit land which is in possession of the plaintiff. Therefore, the findings recorded by the Courts below that the defendant is not interfering with the possession of the plaintiff are contrary to the pleadings and evidence on record and cannot be sustained being unreasonable.

    10. The other aspect of the case is that the plaintiff has been found in possession of a part of the suit land, which he is using as his cow-shed and as his Bartan. In view of the above findings, the relief claimed by him could not have been denied to him in its entirety. Therefore, the dismissal of his suit simply means just to dispose of the case and not to decide it and thereby perpetuate a dispute which deserved to be finally decided so that no cause for future disputes and litigation remained alive.

    11. A perusal of the Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A produced by the plaintiff and the Tatimas Ex. DW-3.A produced by the defendant are incapable of being reconciled. The suit land comprising khasra No. 151/1 has been shown in Ex. PW-4.A on the extreme pastern side of the entire Abadi land, whereas the location of this Khasra number has been shown almost in the center of the entire Abadi land in Tatimas Ex. DW-3.A. Thus, Tatimas Ex. DW-3.A does not appear to have been prepared with reference to the suit land but as per the specifications given by the defendant, whereas to clearly show the spot position, the Tatimas ought to have been prepared on the basis of the specified suit land i.e khasra No. 151/1 as shown in Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A. Thus, the confusion about the identity of the suit land has been created not because of the fault of either of the parties, but because of the manner adopted by Partap Singh, Kanungo (DW-3) in preparing the Tatima Ex. PW-3.A. The parties could not get prepared Tatimas in the desired manner but have to be satisfied with the Tatimas as prepared by the revenue officials. Thus, for the confusion which has cropped in because of the Tatimas, parties cannot be held responsible and should not suffer for it.

    12. It may also be pointed out that the lower appellate Court appears to have given preference to the Tatimas prepared by DW-3 for the reason that he is a Kanungo whereas PW-4 Amar Singh, who has prepared Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A is a Patwari. This reasoning of the lower appellate Court cannot be accepted for the reason that when Tatimas Ex. DW-3.A was prepared by DW-3, he himself was a Patwari and not a kanungo. In view of the confusion created, it was necessary for the just and final decision of the dispute between the parties that the proper picture regarding possession over the land khasra No. 151/1 as depicted in Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A was brought on record. It is not always possible to bring the exact position of the spot on record by way of oral evidence or evidence other than the documents prepared after investigation on the spot. That, however, has not been done in this case.

    13. Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereafter referred to as ‘the Code’), empowers the Court to issue commission to make local investigation which may be required for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute. Though the object of the local investigation is not to collect evidence which can be taken in the Court, but the purpose is to obtain such evidence, which from its peculiar nature, can only be had on the spot with a view to elucidate any point which is left doubtful on the evidence produced before the Court. To issue a commission under Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code, it is not necessary that either or both the parties must apply for issue of commission. The Court can issue local commission suo motu, if, in the facts and circumstances of the case, it is deemed necessary that a local investigation is required and is proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute. Though exercise of these powers is discretionary with the Court, but in case the local investigation is requisite and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case, it should be exercised so that a final and just decision is rendered in the case.

    14. In Braham Datt v. Prem Chand, (2000 (1) SLJ 431), this Court held as under:—

    “14. Be it stated that whatever was within the power of the plaintiff to show that a piece of land owned by him has been encroached upon by the defendants, has been done by him. If the revenue agency has prepared a report which may not be according to rules, the case of the plaintiff could not have been thrown out simply for the lapses committed by the revenue agency/Tehsildar in carrying out the demarcation. No amount of oral evidence which could be led by the plaintiff, would have established the identity of the encroached land. To identify it the only way was to get it demarcated. The plaintiff adopted that course and nothing more could have been done by him. In case the appellate Court entertained any doubt about the correctness of the demarcation and the report, the prayer of the plaintiff for appointment of Local Commissioner for demarcation of the suit land to find out the extent of the encroachment, if any, ought to have been acceded. It is the duty of the Courts to ensure that substantial justice is delivered to the parties and that for the mistake of any Government agency in demarcating the land, a party should not be deprived of the justice on merits by taking recourse to technicalities.

    15. Once the learned District Judge had entertained doubt about the correctness of the demarcation given by the Tehsildar, he ought to have appointed a Local Commissioner to demarcate the disputed area to find out whether there was any encroachment and if so, to what extent, instead of proceeding to dismiss the suit. The impugned judgment and decree, therefore, cannot be sustained.”

    15. In the case in hand, as already stated, the preparation of the Tatima correctly was not within the powers of the parties and they did whatever was possible on their part. Therefore, after coming to the conclusion that a part of the suit land is in possession of the plaintiff and the defendant is interfering with his possession, it is necessary for fair and just decision of the case to ascertain the actual position of the spot which can be best ascertained by issue of a commission at the cost of the parties.

    16. In view of the above discussion, the findings recorded by the Court below on issue Nos. 1 and 2 are rendered unsustainable. However, a perusal of the record reveals that the findings on issue Nos. 3 to 9 as already recorded, are sustainable and do not call for any interference.

    17. In the given circumstances, the only course left open to this Court is to remand the case to the lower appellate Court with a direction to appoint a Local Commissioner to carry out a local investigation and thereafter dispose of the appeal in accordance with law.

    18. As a result, this appeal is allowed and while affirming the findings on issue Nos. 3 to 9, as already recorded, the findings on issue Nos. 1 and 2 as recorded by the Courts below, are set aside and as a consequence, the impugned judgment and decree are set aside. The appeal is remitted to the lower appellate Court, with the direction to appoint a Local Commissioner to investigate and report about the actual and factual position about the path, construction etc., if any, on the suit land, i.e khasra No. 151/1, as specified in Tatimas Ex. PW-4.A and after receipt of the report of the, Local Commissioner to deal with it as per the prescribed procedure and record findings on issue Nos. 1 and 2 and dispose of the appeal in accordance with law.

    19. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there is no order as to costs.

    20. The parties, through their learned counsel, are directed to appear before the lower appellate Court on 23-9-2002.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bali Ram v. Mela Ram And Another
    (Aug 28, 2002)