Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (c) of Section 63 Indian Succession Act, 1925, provides:(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (c) of Section 63 Indian Succession Act, 1925, provides:(c)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns land in village Badoh Bhadarkali, Tehsil Amb, District Una originally owned by Bansi Lal son of Inder. After certain gifts and sales by Bansi Lal, land measuring 18 Kanals 3 Marlas remained and is described in the plaint as the "land in dispute." Bansi Lal died on 13-9-1980. The defendants obtained mutation of inheritance for the land in dispute on the basis of a will alleged to have been executed in their favour by Bansi Lal dated 12-5-1980 (Ext. D.1).

The plaintiffs challenged the will as forged or not executed by a testator of sound disposing mind and claimed that, as natural legal heirs, they were entitled to 1/2 share in the land in dispute. The defendants maintained that Bansi Lal executed a valid will in their favour in lieu of services rendered to him.

At trial the court framed six issues (listed below). The trial court held that the plaintiffs were natural heirs but found the will valid and, on that basis, dismissed the plaintiffs' suit by judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986. The plaintiffs appealed to the District Judge, Una, who allowed the plaintiffs' appeal, set aside the trial court judgment and granted a decree for 1/2 share possession to the plaintiffs by judgment dated 1-7-1989. The defendants then appealed against the District Judge's decision. The present opinion arises from that appeal and concludes by allowing the defendants' appeal, setting aside the District Judge's judgment and restoring the trial court's judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs are the natural heirs of deceased Bansi Lal along with defendants? (Issue No. 1)
  2. Whether the deceased Bansi Lal executed a valid will dated 12-5-1980 in favour of defendants? (Issue No. 2)
  3. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? (Issue No. 3)
  4. Whether the suit has been properly valued for the purpose of court fee and jurisdiction? (Issue No. 4)
  5. Whether the plaintiffs have no locus standi to file this suit? (Issue No. 5)
  6. Relief. (Issue No. 6)

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The plaintiffs challenged the alleged will (Ext. D.1) contending that no will was executed by deceased Bansi Lal in a sound disposing mind in favour of the defendants.
  • They alleged that the will, if any, resulted from forgery and therefore was not binding on the plaintiffs' interest as natural legal heirs entitled to 1/2 share in the land in dispute.
  • Counsel for the plaintiffs relied on the decision Milkhi Ram v. Smt. Surmoo Devi ((1993) 1 Sim LC 118) to contend that because natural heirs (a daughter and children of a pre-deceased daughter) were disinherited, the will Ext. D.1 was surrounded by suspicious circumstances.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants asserted that the deceased Bansi Lal in a sound disposing mind had executed a valid will dated 12-5-1980 in their favour, and that the mutation sanctioned in their favour was rightly based on that will.
  • They further stated that the will was executed in their favour in consideration of services rendered to the deceased.
  • The defendants produced the will (Ext. D.1), the scribe (D.W.2 Kesav Ram), and two attesting witnesses (D.W.3 Sher Singh and D.W.4 Amar Chand) to prove execution of the will.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mrs. S. Misra v. Sm. Mangala Kumari Devi, AIR 1946 Pat 415 Held that even if the recital contained in the will is incorrect or un-true, the will nevertheless is a valid will. The court relied on this principle to support that a false recital in the will (regarding reasons for disinheriting certain heirs) does not by itself invalidate the will.
Susama Bala Devi v. Anath Nath Tarafdar, AIR 1976 Cal 377 Untrue statements in a will do not by themselves render it invalid if due execution is otherwise proved; inequity alone is insufficient to invalidate a will but may add to other unexplained suspicious circumstances. The court cited this case to emphasize that an untrue statement is not, by itself, a ground to declare the will invalid absent other unexplained suspicious circumstances.
Atma Singh v. Smt. Guro, 1983 Cur LJ (C & Cri) 75 (High Court of Punjab & Haryana) Making an intentionally wrong statement in the will cannot, by itself, cast doubt on those parts of the will that bequeath property. The court relied on this authority to reinforce that a false recital regarding family relationships or reasons for disinheritance does not necessarily undermine the bequest provisions.
Milkhi Ram v. Smt. Surmoo Devi, (1993) 1 Sim LC 118 (As relied on by plaintiffs' counsel) The decision was cited to support the contention that disinheritance of natural heirs may create suspicious circumstances surrounding a will. The court noted that plaintiffs' counsel relied on this decision, but the court did not treat this authority as overriding the Supreme Court authorities and other High Court precedents it found decisive.
Smt. Sushila Devi v. Pandit Krishna Kumar Missir, AIR 1971 SC 2236 The Supreme Court held that prima facie a will that makes no bequest to natural heirs may appear unnatural, but if execution is satisfactorily proved the absence of a bequest does not make the will invalid. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority to hold that non-bequest to natural heirs does not invalidate a duly executed will.
Rabindra Nath Mukherjee v. Panchanan Benerjee (dead) by L.Rs, (1995) 4 SCC 459 : AIR 1995 SC 1684 The Supreme Court held that deprivation of natural heirs should not, by itself, raise suspicion because the very purpose of a will is to alter normal succession; disinheritance therefore is not necessarily suspect. The court cited this decision to support the proposition that disinheritance of natural heirs is not in itself a ground to invalidate a will and applied it in concluding the will was valid.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the findings of the lower appellate court (District Judge) which had set aside the trial court's finding of a valid will. The District Judge had relied on several "suspicious circumstances" said to surround Ext. D.1:

  1. the reasons given in the will for excluding the plaintiffs from inheritance were found to be false;
  2. one attesting witness (D.W.3 Sher Singh) was said to be ignorant of the contents of the will;
  3. the date of execution of the will was doubtful;
  4. the will was produced about nine months after the testator's death (kept secret); and
  5. contradictions in depositions of the legatee, scribe and attesting witnesses.

The court examined each point in light of law and evidence actually on record:

  • False recital as to reasons for disinheriting: The court observed (citing Mulla on Hindu Law and the cited authorities) that a testator need not give reasons for disinheriting natural heirs; moreover, an untrue recital in a will does not, by itself, invalidate the will. The court applied authorities (Mrs. S. Misra; Susama Bala Devi; Atma Singh) to conclude that the false statement in the will about services rendered by defendants as opposed to plaintiffs was not, by itself, a suspicious circumstance that would invalidate the bequest clause.
  • Attesting witness' knowledge of contents: The court relied on Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, which requires attestation by two or more witnesses who have seen the testator sign or have received personal acknowledgment of the signature; it is not necessary that witnesses know the contents of the will or that multiple witnesses be present simultaneously. The court found that D.W.3 stated he was present when the will was executed and that the testator signed in his presence; therefore the witness's inability to recite the will's contents did not render his attestation suspicious.
  • Date of execution and delay in production: The will was executed on 12-5-1980 and the testator died on 13-9-1980; the defendants produced the will for mutation on 25-5-1981 (about nine months after death). The court held that this period of about nine months was not sufficiently long to cast doubt on genuineness of the will absent evidence that the defendants had an opportunity to produce it earlier and failed to do so.
  • Contradictions in witness statements: The court treated the contradictions relied upon by the District Judge as minor and explicable by the passage of time (witnesses gave evidence about six years after execution). The court emphasized that minor inconsistencies did not amount to unexplained suspicious circumstances that would invalidate the will.
  • Proof of execution and sound mind: The court observed that execution was proved by independent witnesses (D.W.2, D.W.3, D.W.4), there was no evidence of interest or enmity on their part, and plaintiffs produced no evidence to show Bansi Lal lacked testamentary capacity. Considering the totality of evidence, the court concluded the will was valid and executed by a testator of sound disposing mind on 12-5-1980.

The court thus systematically applied statutory requirements (Section 63, Indian Succession Act, 1925), legal principles from cited case law, and an evaluation of factual evidence to reject the alleged suspicious circumstances relied upon by the District Judge.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: APPEAL ALLOWED. The court allowed the defendants' appeal, set aside the judgment and decree dated 1-7-1989 of the District Judge, Una, and restored the judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986 of the trial Court.

Consequences and immediate implications:

  • The trial court's finding that a valid will (Ext. D.1) dated 12-5-1980 was executed by deceased Bansi Lal in favour of the defendants is restored.
  • Accordingly, the decree previously granted by the District Judge in favour of the plaintiffs (granting 1/2 share possession) is set aside.
  • The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles that (a) a false recital in a will does not, by itself, invalidate the will; (b) attesting witnesses need not know the contents of the will so long as Section 63 requirements are met; and (c) minor contradictions and a moderate delay in producing a will are not necessarily suspicious. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities.

Disposition: Appeal allowed; impugned appellate judgment set aside; trial court judgment restored; parties to bear their own costs.

    Shakuntala Devi v. Savitri Devi And Others

    1. This appeal has been directed by the defendants against the judgment dated 1-7-1989 of the District Judge, Una, allowing the appeal of the plaintiffs against the judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986 of the Sub Judge 1st Class, Amb, District Una and granting a decree for joint possession to the extent of ½ share in the land in dispute.

    2. The admitted pedigree table of the parties is as under:—

    Bansi Lal son of Inder owned and possessed the following lands in village Badoh Bhadarkali, Tehsil Amb, District Una:—

    (a) ½ share in the land measuring 95 Kanals 18 Marlas comprising of Khewat No. 532, Khatauni Nos. 1291 to 1296;

    (b) ¼ share in the land measuring 36 Kanals 13 Marlas comprising of Khewat No. 534 Khatauni Nos. 1302 to 1308;

    (c) ⅛ share in the land measuring 5 Kanals 18 Marlas comprising of Khewat No. 537 Khatauni Nos. 1338 to 1343.

    The total land thus falling to the share of said Shri Bansi Lal was 57 Kanals 17 Marlas. Bansi Lal, above named, during his lifetime made certain gifts and sale of a part of the land owned by him. Such gifts and sale are not being disputed by the plaintiffs. After deducting the land gifted away and sold by said Sh. Bansi Lal, land measuring 18 Kanals 3 Marlas, as detailed in the headnote of the plaint and hereinafter referred to as the ‘land in dispute’, was left with him. Bansi Lal died on 13-9-1980. The defendants got a mutation of inheritance qua the land in dispute sanctioned in their favour on the basis of a will alleged to have been executed in their favour by deceased Bansi Lal.

    3. The plaintiffs have challenged the said will alleged to have been executed by deceased Bansi Lal in favour of the defendants. It was averred that no will was executed by the deceased Bansi Lal in a sound disposing mind in favour of the defendants. The will, if any, is a result of forgery and not binding on the interest of the plaintiffs, who are entitled to succeed to the extent of ½ share in the land in dispute being the natural legal heirs of the deceased Bansi Lal along with the defendants.

    4. The defendants resisted and contested the suit by averring that the deceased Bansi Lal in a sound disposing mind had executed a valid will in their favour of 12-5-1980 and that the mutation of inheritance was rightly sanctioned in their favour on the basis of the said will. It was further stated that the will was executed by the deceased in their favour in lieu of the services rendered by them to the deceased.

    5. On the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed by the trial Court:—

    1. Whether the plaintiffs are the natural heirs of deceased Bansi Lal along with defendants? OPP

    2. Whether the deceased Bansi Lal executed a valid will dated 12-5-1980 in favour of defendants? OPD

    3. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? OPD

    4. Whether the suit has been properly valued for the purpose of court fee and jurisdiction? OPD

    5. Whether the plaintiffs have no locus standi to file this suit? OPD

    6. Relief.

    6. The learned trial court found Issues Nos. 2 and 5 in favour of the defendants. It was held that deceased Bansi Lal had executed a valid will dated 12-5-1980 in favour of the defendants. While, deciding Issue No. 1 in favour of the plaintiffs the trial court came to the conclusion that the plaintiffs are the natural heirs of the deceased Bansi Lal along with the defendants. Issues Nos. 3 and 4 were found against the defendants. Consequent upon such findings, the suit of the plaintiffs was dismissed by the trial Court vide judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986.

    7. Feeling aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986 of the trial Court, the plaintiffs went up in appeal before the District Judge, Una, who allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment and decree of the trial court and granted a decree for possession to the extent of ½ share of the land in dispute in favour of the plaintiffs, by holding that no valid will was executed by deceased Bansi Lal in favour of the defendants.

    8. I have heard Sh. Bhupender Gupta, Advocate, learned counsel for the defendants and Sh. K.D Sood, Advocate, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs and have also gone through the record of the case.

    9. Ext. D.1 is a ‘will’ dated 12-5-1980, alleged to have been executed by deceased Bansi Lal in favour of the defendants. This will has been scribed by D.W 2 Kesav Ram. S/Sh. Sher Singh and Amar Chand, D.W 3 and D.W 4, respectively, are the true attesting witnesses thereof. The lower appellate Court while holding the will Ext. D.1 to be in valid, has come to the conclusion that the suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the will have not been satisfactorily explained by the defendants, the propounders of Ext. D.1 The following suspicious circumstances have been relied upon by the first appellate Court:—

    (a) reasons for excluding the plaintiffs from inheritance having been found to be false;

    (b) D.W 3 Sher Singh one of the attesting witnesses being ignorant of the contents of the will;

    (c) date of the execution of the will doubtful;

    (d) the will was kept secret for about nine months after the death of the testator; and

    (e) contradictions appearing in the depositions of the legatee Smt. Satya Devi, the scribe and the attesting witnesses of the will.

    10. A perusal of the will Ext. D.1 shows that the reason for making the will in favour of the defendants is recited that both the defendants had been rendering services to the deceased testator by staying with him even after their marriage, and that no services were being rendered by the plaintiffs. This reason given for excluding the defendants from inheritance and for making the will in favour of the defendants has been found to be false from the evidence coming on the record.

    11. In para 368, at page 485 of Mulla Principles of Hindu Law, Fifteenth Edition, it has been commented in the following terms:—

    “There is nothing to prevent a Hindu from so disposing of his property by will as to defeat the rights of his sons, wife, or other, legal heirs even to the extent of completely disinheriting them. No express words are necessary to dis-inherit the heirs; it is sufficient if the property is bequeathed to some other person(s).”

    12. Therefore, under the law, no reasons are required to be given by a testator for disinheriting one or more of his natural legal heirs while making the will. The question, which next arises, is that if reasons for disinheriting a particular legal heirs are given in the will and such reasons are found to be false, whether the same would constitute a suspicious circumstances shrouding the execution of the will.

    13. The above question came up for consideration before the High Court of Patna in Mrs. S. Misra v. Sm. Mangala Kumari Devi, AIR 1946 Patna 415, and it was held that even if the recital contained in the will is incorrect or even un-true, the will nevertheless is a valid will.

    14. In Susama Bala Devi v. Anath Nath Tarafdar AIR 1976 Cal 377, the testator had disinherited his three elder sons while making the will in favour of his younger son, stated in the will that he was dis-inheriting his three elder sons on account of their misbehaviour with their mother. This reason given by the testator of disinheriting his three eleder sons was found to be false. Relying upon the ratio laid down by Patna High Court in Mrs. S. Misra's case (AIR 1946 Pat 415) (supra), it was held by the High Court of Calcutta, as under (at p. 386 of AIR):—

    “………. Therefore, untrue statement contained in the Will by itself constitutes no ground to hold the Will invalid or unreal if its due execution is otherwise proved and there be no other unexplained suspicious circumstances. It is also true that inequity of disposition by itself is no ground to hold the Will invalid. If it is permissible to say so, we might say that most Wills contain some elements of inequitous disposition, if intestacy is considered to be the valid and normal disposition of a deadman's property. But all these things will have to be considered? along with other suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the Will. If other suspicious circumstances are there which are unexplained then inequitous disposition and untrue statements contained in the will would go to add further volume to the suspicious circumstances that the will is not a, genuine document.”

    15. The High Court of Punjab and Haryana in Atma Singh v. Smt. Guro 1983 Cur LJ (C & Cri) 75, where the recital in the Will that the testator had no sister was found to be false, held that making of an intentionally Wrong statement in the will cannot cast any doubt on the contents of those parts thereof by which the property is bequeathed in the Will.

    16. In the present case as well, simply due to the fact that the recital made in the will that services were being rendered to the deceased testator Bansi Lal by the defendants and that no services were being rendered by the plaintiffs, having been found false, will not be a suspicious circumstance on the contents of that part of the Will by which the land in dispute was bequeathed in favour of the defendants.

    17. The next suspicious circumstances relied upon by the District Judge is that D.W 3 Sher Singh one of the attesting witnesses, was not even aware of the contents of the will. Admittedly, the Will Ext. D.1 was executed in favour of the two defendants. D.W 3 Sher Singh has stated in his cross-examination that the Will was executed only in favour of one daughter who was residing with the testator to render services to him. The District Judge has drawn the inference that since D.W 3 was not aware of the contents of the Will, this witness cannot be said to be present at the time of the alleged execution of the will, and that he had signed the same subsequently without having been approached by the testator in this regard.

    18. Under the law, it is not necessary that the attesting witnesses should know the contents of the Will. The testator need not disclose the nature and contents of the instrument. Attestation does not mean that the attesting witnesses should have the knowledge of the contents of the will. It is also well settled that the attesting witnesses need not be present at the time of the execution of the Will by the testator. Clause (c) of Section 63 Indian Succession Act, 1925, provides:—

    “(c) The will shall be attested by two or more witnesses, each of whom has seen the testator sign or affix his mark to the will or has seen some other person sign the will, in the presence and by the direction of the testator, or has received from the testator a personal acknowledgment of his signature or mark, or of the signature of such other person; and each of the witnesses shall sign the will in the presence of the testator, but it shall not be necessary that more than one witness be present at the same time, and no particular form of attestation shall be necessary.”

    19. A bare reading of the abovesaid provision shows that attestation is valid when the same is attested by the witnesses after having received from the testator a personal acknowledgment of his signature or mark on the Will.

    20. In the present case, it is in the statement of DW 3 that he was present when the Will was executed. The testator had signed the same in his presence and he has attested the Will as a witness in the presence of the testator. Therefore, the mere fact that D.W 3 Sher Singh could not correctly give the contents of the Will Ext. D.1, will not be a suspicious circumstance.

    21. The Will Ext. D.1 is shown to have been executed by deceased Bansi Lal on 12-5-1980. Admittedly, Bansi Lal had died on 13-9-1980, that is after about four months of the execution of the Will Ext. D.1 The defendant Smt. Satya Devi as D.W 1 has stated that her father Bansi Lal remained ill for about 15-16 days before his death. She has further stated that when the Will Ext. D.1 was executed, even then her father used to remain ill. In her examination-in-chief, she has stated that the Will was executed about six months before the death of Bansi Lal. Though D.W 2 Kesav Ram has stated that the deceased Bansi Lal had died 15/20 days after the execution of the Will Ext. D.1, will not mean that the Will was not executed on the day, it is shown to have been executed. Similarly, it has come in the evidence of D.W 4 Amar Chand that deceased Bansi Lal might have died about eight months to one year after the execution of the Will Ext. D.1 It is significant to note that neither D.W 2 Kesav Ram, the scribe of the Will Ext. D.1, nor D.W 4 Amar Chand one of the attesting witnesses, is related to the deceased Bansi Lal. They are rustic villagers. They appeared in the court for making a statement about six years after the execution of the Will Ext. D.1 Therefore, it cannot be expected that they would remember the minute details of the facts of a particular case. The contradiction coming with regard to the death of deceased Bansi Lal in the statements of D.W 2 and D.W 4 will not be a suspicious circumstance against the validity of Will Ext. D.1

    22. As stated above, the testator Bansi Lal had died on 13-9-1980. The Will Ext. D.1 was produced by the defendants before the Patwari for getting the mutation entered on its basis on 25-5-1981 after a period of about nine months of the death of the testator. This period of about nine months is not long enough, so as to cast a shadow of doubt on the genuineness of Will Ext. D.1, in the absence of evidence to show that the defendants failed to produce the Will Ext. D.1 prior to 25-5-1981 in spite of having an opportunity to do so.

    23. The District Judge has relied heavily on the contradictions appearing in the depositions of D.W 1 Satya Devi, D.W 2 Keshav Ram, DW 3 Sher Singh and D.W 4 Amar Singh with regard to the execution of the Will. Such contradictions, which are of minor nature, will not be a suspicious circumstance. The memory fades away with the passage of time and when evidence is being given after a lapse of six years, the witnesses cannot be expected to make a parrot like statement on each and every minor aspect of the case. Therefore, the District Judge has erred in relying upon such minor contradictions coming in the statements of various witnesses.

    24. The learned counsel for the plaintiffs by placing reliance on the decision of this Court in Milkhi Ram v. Smt. Surmoo Devi, (1993) 1 Sim LC 118, has contended that since the natural heirs namely, a daughter and the children of a pre-deceased daughter were disinherited, the Will Ext. D.1 is surrounded with suspicious circumstance.

    25. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Smt. Sushila Devi v. Pandit Krishna Kumar Missir, AIR 1971 SC 2236, has held that prima facie, the circumstance that no bequest was made to the natural heir (s) by the testator would make the will appear unnatural, but if the execution of the Will is satisfactorily proved, the fact that the testator had not bequeathed any property to one of his children cannot make the Will invalid.

    26. Again, in Rabindra Nath Mukherjee v. Panchanan Benerjee (dead) by L.Rs, (1995) 4 SCC 459 : (AIR 1995 SC 1684), it has been held by the Hon'ble Apex Court that deprivation of natural heirs should not raise any suspicion because the whole idea behind execution of will is to interfere with the normal line of succession. So natural heirs would be debarred in every case of will; of course, it may be that in some cases they are fully debarred and in others only partially. The Hon'ble apex Court in the said case, where the will was executed by the testator in favour of the sons of a half-blood brother by excluding the descendants of a full blood sister, held the Will to be valid and that disinheritance of the descendants of a full blood sister could not have been taken as a suspicious circumstances.

    27. The execution of the Will stands duly proved by D.W 2 Kesav Ram, D.W 3 Sher Singh and D.W 4, Amar Chand. All these witnesses are independent witnesses. There is nothing on record to show that they are having any interest in the legatees. Nor there is any evidence to show that they are in any way inimical towards the plaintiffs. No evidence has been led on behalf of the plaintiffs to show that deceased Bansi Lal was not having a sound disposing mind at the relevant time.

    28. Therefore, considering the entire evidence coming on the record in its totality, I hold that a valid Will Ext. D.1 was executed by deceased Bansi Lal in favour of the defendants, while in a sound disposing mind on 12-5-1980.

    29. As a result, the present appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and decree dated 1-7-1989 of the District Judge, Una is set-aside and the judgment and decree dated 22-10-1986 of the trial Court is restored. The parties are left to bear their own costs.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shakuntala Devi v. Savitri Devi And Others
    (Jan 11, 1996)