Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 17 and S. 21 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • S. 112 of the Indian Evidence Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 17 and S. 21 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • S. 112 of the Indian Evidence Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Miss Alpana, a minor, filed a petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr. P.C.) read with Article 227 of the Constitution of India through her mother and natural guardian, Smt. Sarla Devi. The petition challenged the judgment dated 27 November 1991 of the Sessions Judge (Forests), Shimla, which had affirmed the judgment dated 24 December 1988 of the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate (SDJM), Rampur Bushahar. The SDJM had dismissed a petition under Section 125, Cr. P.C. filed on behalf of Miss Alpana for maintenance, holding that she was not the daughter of the respondent, Mohan Lal.

Background chronology and relevant prior proceedings (as stated in the opinion):

  • Smt. Sarla Devi and respondent Mohan Lal were married in 1983 and the marriage subsisted.
  • On 22 March 1986, Smt. Sarla Devi filed a petition under Section 125, Cr. P.C. for maintenance for herself and her first daughter, Miss Kalpana. That petition was resisted by Mohan Lal but ultimately allowed by the SDJM by a judgment dated 16 November 1987, awarding Smt. Sarla Devi Rs. 150 per month. No maintenance was allowed to Miss Kalpana because her custody had been taken over by Mohan Lal. This judgment became final as no appeal was filed.
  • Miss Alpana (the present petitioner) was born on 15 July 1986. A fresh petition under Section 125, Cr. P.C. for her maintenance was filed on 16 February 1988. In reply, Mohan Lal denied that Miss Alpana was his daughter. After trial, the SDJM dismissed that petition, accepting Mohan Lal's contention that Miss Alpana was not begotten by him; the court held the presumption under Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act had been rebutted, mainly by Smt. Sarla Devi's statement. The Sessions Judge affirmed those findings, leading to the present petition under S. 482 Cr. P.C. and Article 227.
  • The High Court obtained and considered the earlier judgment dated 16 November 1987 and a statement dated 22 July 1987 of Mohan Lal from the earlier proceedings, which were brought on record in the present petition to show inconsistency between his earlier admission and his later denial.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court in exercise of inherent powers under Section 482, Cr. P.C. and powers of superintendence under Article 227 of the Constitution can interfere with and set aside concurrent factual findings of the two lower courts that Miss Alpana is not the daughter of Mohan Lal.
  2. Whether an earlier statement and earlier final judgment and findings (including admissions made by a party in earlier proceedings) can be read in subsequent proceedings and used as substantive evidence without the earlier statement having been confronted with the party when he later appeared as witness in the subsequent proceedings.
  3. Whether, applying the evidence on record (including earlier admissions, panchayat birth records, witness statements and the chronology of events), Miss Alpana is the daughter of Mohan Lal and entitled to maintenance under Section 125, Cr. P.C., and, if so, what amount should be fixed as maintenance.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments (as articulated by his counsel)

  • The Court cannot look into the earlier statement of Mohan Lal made in the previous petition when deciding the present petition because that earlier statement was not put to him when he appeared in the witness-box in the later proceedings; therefore he was not given an opportunity to explain it.
  • The factual findings recorded by the two courts below — that Miss Alpana is not the daughter of Mohan Lal — are findings of fact and cannot be interfered with by this Court in exercise of inherent powers under Section 482, Cr. P.C. or powers of superintendence under Article 227.

Petitioner's Contentions (as reflected in the record and relied upon by the Court)

  • Copies of the earlier judgment (dated 16 November 1987) and the statement of Mohan Lal dated 22 July 1987 from earlier proceedings were placed on record to show that the stand subsequently taken by Mohan Lal — that Miss Alpana is not his daughter — contradicted his earlier admission and the earlier judgment.
  • No reply was filed by Mohan Lal to explain or deny the earlier judgment or the earlier statement in the present petition; the petitioner relied on these earlier materials as probative of paternity and of the respondent's previous admission.
  • The petitioner pointed to other evidence on record (statements of Smt. Sarla Devi, Plast Ram, the panchayat record produced by Mela Ram, and chronology of birth and visits) to show that the lower courts erred in disbelieving that Miss Alpana was the respondent's daughter.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bharat Singh v. Mst. Bhagirathi, AIR 1966 SC 405 Supports the principle that an earlier statement of a party can be used as substantive evidence and it is not necessary to put that earlier statement to the party when he later appears as a witness in order to use it as evidence; confrontation serves a different purpose (testing veracity of inconsistent later statements). The Court relied on this authority to hold that Mohan Lal's earlier statement admitting paternity could be used in the subsequent proceedings and in the present petition; the Court rejected the objection that the earlier statement could not be read because it was not put to Mohan Lal when he later testified.
Union of India v. Moksh Builders and Financiers Ltd. etc., (1977) 1 SCC 60 : AIR 1977 SC 409 Similar support for the use of prior statements of a party as substantive evidence without the need for formal confrontation in subsequent proceedings; addresses the legal position as to admission and its evidentiary effect (as applied with S.17 and S.21 of the Indian Evidence Act in the opinion). The Court cited this precedent along with Bharat Singh to reinforce that Mohan Lal's earlier admission stands as substantive evidence; the Court therefore used that earlier admission in its assessment of the total evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a multi-step analysis based strictly on the pleadings, evidence on record and earlier proceedings. The reasoning, in the sequence used by the Court, is summarized below:

  1. Admissibility and Use of Earlier Statement and Earlier Judgment:
    • The Court held that once a party accepts his earlier statement, it becomes a substantive piece of evidence of the facts admitted under Sections 17 and 21 of the Indian Evidence Act (as cited in the opinion). The fact that the earlier statement was not put to Mohan Lal while he gave evidence in the later proceedings did not preclude its use; confrontation is primarily for testing veracity of inconsistent later statements. The Court relied on precedents (Bharat Singh and Union of India v. Moksh Builders) to support this legal position.
    • The earlier judgment dated 16 November 1987 (in the earlier Section 125 petition by Smt. Sarla) could be read as part of the evidence in the later proceedings and could be used in deciding the present petition.
  2. Assessment of Evidence on Paternity:
    • The Court reviewed the record of the Section 125 petition filed on behalf of Miss Alpana, the earlier judgment and the statement of Mohan Lal dated 22 July 1987. It noted that in the earlier proceedings Mohan Lal had made admissions accepting that the second daughter born to Smt. Sarla Devi (born 15 July 1986) was his daughter, and that he had visited Smt. Sarla's parents' house many times before the birth.
    • The Court highlighted that no explanation or denial of the earlier judgment or earlier statement had been filed in the present proceedings to account for the apparent contradiction in Mohan Lal's stand.
    • The Court analyzed testimony from witnesses called for the petitioner: Smt. Sarla Devi (P.W.1) stated Miss Alpana was Mohan Lal's daughter and that Mohan Lal had not maintained her; Plast Ram (P.W.2), Smt. Sarla's father, stated Smt. Sarla had been residing in his house and that Miss Alpana was about two years old when he gave his statement, implying Smt. Sarla was pregnant when she came to her father's house. The Court observed that cross-examination did not put to these witnesses the contention that Miss Alpana was not begotten by Mohan Lal.
    • The Court noted that the Gram Panchayat record produced by Mela Ram (P.W.3) recorded the father of the second daughter (named Guddi) as Mohan Lal, and that in cross-examination it was admitted that the father whose name was recorded had come to inform about the birth.
  3. Errors in Findings by the Courts Below:
    • The Court found both lower courts erred by giving cursory treatment to the statements of Smt. Sarla Devi and Plast Ram and by placing undue reliance on Mohan Lal's later testimony that he had no access to Smt. Sarla after 6 October 1984 (and had last met her on 6 December 1984 or 6 December 1985 as variously recorded). The Court concluded the lower courts did not properly test the veracity of Mohan Lal's statements in the context of other material evidence.
    • The Court specifically observed that Mohan Lal, while denying paternity, could not name any other man as father of Miss Alpana; he also admitted in panchayat records that he was shown as father of the second daughter. Taken together with the chronology (marriage in 1983, petition filed March 1986 stating Smt. Sarla was pregnant, and birth in July 1986), the Court found the lower courts' conclusion that Miss Alpana was not Mohan Lal's daughter to be unsustainable.
  4. Exercise of Inherent and Superintendence Powers:
    • The Court held that this was a fit case to exercise inherent powers under Section 482, Cr. P.C. and powers of superintendence under Article 227 because the findings of fact by both lower courts were not sustainable on the pleadings and evidence on record, and, if not set aside, would defeat the ends of justice.
    • The Court concluded that the earlier statement and the earlier judgment established on record that Mohan Lal had knowingly and intentionally denied paternity in the later proceedings in order to harass the petitioner and her mother; the later denial therefore deserved to be rejected.
  5. Determination of Maintenance and Financial Capacity:
    • Having found neglect and refusal to maintain proven by Mohan Lal's denial, the Court noted Mohan Lal was employed as a casual constable in Home Guards and was physically fit to work. The Court made a reasoned presumption (stated in the opinion) that even if Mohan Lal worked as a daily wage labourer, his monthly income would be about Rs. 660 at Rs. 22 per day. The Court also noted that he was the only son of a father who possessed sufficient land and other property.
    • Taking into account that Mohan Lal had the existing obligation of maintaining his first daughter Miss Kalpana and paying Rs. 150 per month to Smt. Sarla Devi pursuant to the earlier judgment, the Court determined that his only additional liability would be maintenance for Miss Alpana.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is ALLOWED. The findings of both the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate and the Sessions Judge (Forests), Shimla, that Miss Alpana was not the daughter of Mohan Lal are set aside. The Court held that Miss Alpana is the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal and that he is bound to maintain her.

Specific orders made by the Court (direct effects on the parties):

  • Mohan Lal is declared to be the father of Miss Alpana and is held liable to pay maintenance for her.
  • An amount of Rs. 100 per month is fixed as maintenance for Miss Alpana, to be calculated from the date of the application (6 February 1988).
  • The Court recognized Mohan Lal's continuing liabilities: maintaining his first daughter Miss Kalpana and paying Rs. 150 per month to Smt. Sarla Devi as previously ordered; beyond these obligations the Court fixed only Rs. 100 per month as Miss Alpana's maintenance.
  • The petition under Section 482, Cr. P.C. and Article 227 was allowed and the orders of the courts below on this point were set aside.

Implications: The opinion states the direct consequences for the parties as above. The text does not articulate any broader legal rule or announce that a new binding precedent is being laid down beyond the Court's exercise of Section 482 and Article 227 in the specific circumstances of this case. No broader implications beyond the direct effect on the parties are discussed in the provided opinion.

Concluding Disposition

The petition was allowed and maintenance for Miss Alpana fixed at Rs. 100 per month from 6 February 1988.

    Alpana v. Mohanlal .

    1. Miss Alpana is a minor. She has filed this petition under S. 482, Cr. P.C read with Art. 227 of the Constitution of India through her mother and natural guardian, Smt. Sarla Devi wife of respondent Mohan Lal. Miss Alpana is aggrieved by the judgment dated 27th November, 1991 passed by the Sessions Judge (Forests), Shimla, whereby the judgment dated 24th December, 1988 of Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Rampur Bushahar, was affirmed. The Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate had dismissed the petition under S. 125, Cr. P.C filed by Miss Alpana for granting her maintenance, holding that she is not the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal.

    2. There is no dispute that Smt. Sarla Devi, the mother of Miss Alpana, is the wife of respondent Mohan Lal and their such relationship is subsisting. They were married in the year 1983. On 22nd March, 1986, Smt. Sarla Devi filed a petition under S. 125, Cr. P.C for maintenance for herself and for her first daughter, Miss Kalpana. The petition was resisted by respondent Mohan Lal but it was ultimately allowed by the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Rampur Bushahar, vide his judgment dated 16th November, 1987. An amount of Rs. 150/- per month was awarded as maintenance to Smt. Sarla Devi. No maintenance was allowed to her duaghter Miss Kalpana as during the pendency of the petition, her custody was taken over by the respondent Mohan Lal. This judgment became final between the parties as no appeal was filed against it. In the meantime, another daughter, the present petitioner, Miss Alpana, was born to Smt. Sarla Devi and another petition under S. 125, Cr. P.C was filed on 16th February, 1988 for granting her maintenance. In reply to this petition, respondent Mohan Lal took the stand that Miss Alpana is not his daughter and he was not bound to maintain her. After trial, this petition was dismissed by the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Rampur Bushahar, accepting the contention of respondent Mohan Lal that Miss Alpana was not begotten from him. It was further held that the presumption arising under S. 112 of the Indian Evidence Act that every child born during the subsistence of valid marriage is legitimate stood rebutted on the basis of rccord, mainly, the statement of Smt. Sarla Devi herself. These findings were affirmed by the Sessions Judge (Forests), Shimla. Hence the present petition.

    3. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone through the record of this case as well as of the earlier application under S. 125, Cr. P.C (No. 33-IV of 1986 titled Sarla Devi v. Mohan Lal) which had ended in the judgment dated 16th November, 1987. The copies of the judgment dated 16th November, 1987 and the statement dated 22nd July, 1987 of respondent Mohan Lal made in the earlier proceedings have been brought on record of the present petition to show that the stand taken by respondent Mohan Lal that Miss Alpana is not his daughter is contradictory to his admission made in the earlier proceedings and also the findings in the judgment made therein. No reply has been filed to the present petition denying or explaining the earlier judgment and/or alleging that findings in the judgment dated 16th November, 1987 may not be taken into account while deciding the present petition for any reason. This Court called the parties and made efforts for their reconciliation but without any results. Ultimately, the case was heard.

    4. Sh. Ajay Sharma, appearing on behalf of the learned counsel for the respondent, has made submissions that this Court cannot look into the statement of respondent Mohan Lal made in the earlier petition for deciding the present petition as it was not put to him while he appeared in the witness-box to enable him to explain the same. Another submission made by Mr. Sharma is that the findings of fact arrived at by both the Courts below that Miss Alpana is not the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal cannot be interfered with in the present petition in exercise of the inherent powers under S. 482, Cr. P.C and powers of superintendence under Art. 227 of the Constitution of India.

    5. So far the first submission is concerned, respondent Mohan Lal has not denied his earlier statement and his only objection is that it cannot be read in the later proceedings as it was not put to him when he appeared as a witness to enable him to explain it. Once a party accepts his earlier statement, it becomes a substantive piece of evidence of the fact(s) admitted therein in view of S. 17 and S. 21 of the Indian Evidence Act. It is a different matter what weightage is to be attached to such a statement. Before using such a statement, it is not required to be put to its maker to provide him an opportunity to explain it when he appears as a witness or by calling him as a witness. The purpose of confronting a witness with his earlier statement is altogether different, that is, to test the veracity of his later statement, if it differs from the earlier statement. (See Bharat Singh v. Mst. Bhagirathi, AIR 1966 SC 405 and Union of India v. Moksh Builders and Financiers Ltd. etc., (1977) 1 SCC 60 : AIR 1977 SC 409).

    6. In view of this legal position, this Court finds no substance in the submission made on behalf of respondent Mohan Lal and holds that his earlier statement containing, inter alia, the admission that the second daughter born to Smt. Sarla Devi is his daughter, can be used in the proceedings under S. 125, Cr. P.C filed on behalf of Miss Alpana and also the present petition. What weightage is to be attached to this statement will be examined while dealing with the other submission. So far the judgment dated 16th November, 1987 is concerned, there is no dispute that it could be read as part of evidence in the later proceedings as well as for deciding the present petition.

    7. So far the second submission is concerned, this Court is of the opinion that it is a fit case to exercise the inherent powers under S. 482, Cr. P.C as well as the powers of superintendence under Art. 227 of the Constitution of India as the findings of fact arrived at by both the Courts below are not sustainable on the pleadings and evidence on record and if the judgments of the Courts below are not set aside, the ends of justice will be defeated.

    8. It is correct that in his reply to the petition of Miss Alpana, respondent Mohan Lal has denied that she is his daughter but from the tenor of his reply it appears that his real objection was that he was not the father of any girl by the name of Miss Alpana Sharma as he is not Sharma and Brahman by caste. His reply to para 2 of the petition is relevant. It is:—

    “2) Para II of the application is partly denied as the respondent does not belong to Sharma of Brahmin caste of Hindu Religion and the respondent is not bound to maintain any Alpana Sharma. The rest of the para is correct.”

    Even from the cross-examination of witnesses who appeared on behalf of Miss Alpana, it is clear that it was not the case of the respondent Mohan Lal that second daughter of Smt. Sarla bevi was not his but his objection was that he had no daughter by the name of Alpana Sharma. Smt. Sarla Devi (P.W 1) appeared as a witness and stated that Miss Alpana is the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal who was not maintaining her from the very beginning. It has not been asked from her in the cross-exlamination that Miss Alpana was not begotten from respondent Mohan Lal. It was also not put to Sh. Plast Ram, the father of Smt. Sarla Devi, who appeared as P.W 2, that Miss Alpana, the second daughter of Smt. Sarla Devi, was not of respondent Mohan Lal. He had categorically stated that Miss Alpana was about 2 years old and. Smt. Sarla Devi was residing in his house for the last 2½ years. His statement and statement of Smt. Sarla Devi were recorded on 15th July, 1988. According to Smt. Sarla Devi, at the time she gave the statement, third year had started since when she was residing with her parents and her daughter Miss Alpana was about two years old. If both these statements are read together, the only conclusion possible is that when Smt. Sarla came to the house of her parents, she was pregnant as admittedly Miss Alpana was born on 15th July, 1986.

    9. Both the Courts below have not referred to the statement of Plast Ram, father of Smt. Sarla Devi, which is very much relevant for deciding the controversy. They have arrived at their findings by wrongly interpreting the statement of Smt. Sarla Devi and believing the statement of respondent Mohan Lal that Smt. Sarla Devi had left his house on 6th October, 1984 and thereafter he had visisted her only once on 6th December, 1984 but did not stay in her house. Both the Courts below have not tested the veracity of his statement in the context of other evidence on record. Though respondent Mohan Lal has stated in his examination-in-chief that Miss Alpana was not his daughter and in cross-examination that Smt. Sarla Devi gave birth to a girl after about 1 ½ years of their separation, yet, he could not state who was the father of Miss Alpana. Admittedly, the distance between his house and the house of the parents of Smt. Sarla Devi is of ten minutes walk and Smt. Sarla Devi did not have illicit relations with any one. He has also admitted that in the Panchayat record his name has been recorded as father of second daughter of Smt. Sarla Devi named Guddi. But according to him, he had not got it recorded. He has further stated in his cross-examination that twice he had gone to the house of parents of Smt. Sarla Devi to call her. back. Both the Courts below have dealt with the statement of Smt. Sarla Devi and respondent Mohan Lal in a very cursory manner, They have also not considered the statement of Mela Ram (P.W 3), Secretary Gram Panchayat Nirmand who had produced the record blithe birth of Miss Guddi, the second daughter of Smt. Sarla Devi. According to him, the name of the father of both the daughters of Smt. Sarla Devi is Mohan Lal as per the record of the Panchayat. In cross-examination, he has stated that it was the father of the girl, whose name is recorded as Mohan Lal, who had come to inform about the birth of second daughter of Smt. Sarla Devi named Guddi.

    10. From such type of evidence, both the Courts below were not justified in holding that Miss Alpana was not the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal as he had no access to her mother Smt. Sarla Devi. Besides the evidence adduced in the petition under S. 125, Cr. P.C filed on behalf of Miss Alpana, there is the statement dated 22nd July, 1987 of respondent Mohan Lal given in the earlier petition in which he has categorically admitted that the second daughter of Smt. Sarla Devi, Miss Alpana, who was born after the filing of that petition, was his daughter. He has also admitted that he had visited the house of the parents of Smt. Sarla Devi many a times before the birth of his second daughter but he did not stay there. According to him, he had lastly met his wife Smt. Sarla on 6th December, 1985. In para 2 of that petition, Smt. Sarla had stated that at the time of filing the petition she was pregnant and expected to deliver a baby within two months thereafter. In his reply, respondent Mohan Lal had admitted para 2 as correct. The petition was filed on 22nd March, 1986 and Miss Alpana was born on 15th July, 1986. In the said petition when Smt. Sarla Devi had appeared as her witness on 20th November, 1986, she had stated that two daughters were born to her out of her wedlock with respondent Mohan Lal and this statement was accepted as no question was asked in cross-examination that her second daughter was not of respondent Mohan Lal. While giving his judgment dated 16th November, 1987, the Judicial Magistrate, on the assessment of evidence adduced before him, held as under:—

    “…..In the present case, neglect of the respondent in maintaining the petitioner No. 1 before filing of this application is apparent from the fact that he has never visited the petitioner No. 1 at her father's house. He did not also visit her when she gave birth to the second child parentage of which was not disputed when the respondent appeared in the witness-box. He even has not seen the face of his second daughter before she was brought to the Court what to talk of providing any money or necessities to her or to her mother……”

    11. Had the judgment dated 16th November, 1987 and the earlier statement of respondent Mohan Lal been taken into account by the Courts below, they would not have held that Miss Alpana is not the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal. From the earlier statement of respondent Mohan Lal and the findings in the judgment dated 16th November, 1987, it is proved on record that respondent Mohan lal knowingly, intentionally and in order to harass Miss Alpana and her mothr Smt. Sarla Devi denied that Miss Alpana was not begotten from him. His later statement denying that he had any access to Smt. Sarla Devi and Miss Alpana was begotten from him deserves to be rejected outrightly. In the face of this material, if the judgments of both the Courts below are not set aside there will be grave miscarriage of justice and not only the petitioner Miss Alpana will be denied maintenance but also be dubbed as illegitimate child which findings may stare at her throughout her life besides causing aspersions on the character of her mother Smt. Sarla Devi.

    12. The result of the above discussion is that the findings of both the Courts below are set aside. This Court holds that Miss Alpana is the daughter of respondent Mohan Lal and he is bound to maintain her. Since he has denied that Miss Alpana is his daughter, his neglect and refusal to maintain her stands proved. Admittedly, he is working as casual constable in Home Guards and is physically fit to work. Therefore, this Court can safely presume that even if he works as a daily wage labourer, his monthly income will be about Rs. 660/- at the rate of Rs. 22/- per day. Admittedly, he is the only son of his father who possesses sufficient land and other property.

    13. Therefore, besides maintaining his first daughter Miss Kalpana and paying Rs. 150/- to Smt. Sarla Devi as maintenance allowance, he has no other liability. In view of these circumstances, an amount of Rs. 100/- per month is fixed as maintenance for Miss Alpana from the date of the application, that is, 6th February, 1988. The petition is allowed accordingly.

    14. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Alpana v. Mohanlal .
    (Oct 27, 1993)