Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges

    Gujarat v. Natha

    1. The applicants seek condonation of delay of 1923 days and also seek to set aside abatement of the Second Appeal. It is stated in the application that the sole respondent in the Appeal, Shri Nathabhai Jinabhai passed away on 25th January 2007. The applicants had no knowledge about the death of the respondent. It is further stated that even learned advocate appearing for the respondent in the appeal did not inform the applicants about the death of the respondent. It is stated that the applicants came to know about the death of the respondent only recently. It is stated that the applicants had received copy of the power of attorney in favour of one of the heirs of the respondent at the Circle office. On such grounds the applicants prayed to condone delay of 1923 days in setting aside the abatement of the Second Appeal and thereafter to bring on record the heirs of deceased respondents. This application is opposed by the heirs of the deceased respondents by filing affidavit in reply and it is stated therein that the applicants were informed about the death of deceased respondent by written letter in the year 2008 and therefore, the applicants could not be said to have given sufficient explanation for the condonation of delay, at least for the period after 2008.

    2. The applicants therefore, took time to file rejoinder to the said reply and in the rejoinder dated 10th December 2012 the applicants have stated that not only the advocate appearing for the respondent has not intimated the applicants about the death of the deceased respondent but the heirs of the deceased respondent have not intimated the fact about the death of the respondent to the concerned office.

    On receipt of such rejoinder, one of the heirs of the deceased respondent named Natubhai filed further affidavit dated 16th January 2013 placing on record a letter dated 1st March 2007 addressed by him to Superintending Engineer, Western Gujarat Vij Company Limited, Junagadh division intimating the fact of death of his father taken place on 25th January 2007 and this letter appears to have been received by the dispatch clerk on 5th March 2007 at Circle Office, Junagadh. Today when application is taken up for hearing, further affidavit is tendered on behalf of the applicants wherein it is stated that the above letter sent by one of the heirs of the deceased respondent was received by the Circle Office situated at Girnar Darwaja, Junagadh on 5th March 2007. It is further stated that this matter is being looked after by the Corporate Office as it is relating to service conditions of the employees of the company. It is further stated that neither the Circle office is concerned with the matter nor even in any way connected with the main office as regards matters of the employees to be dealt with. It is also stated that Sub Division Office is party before this Court which is also situated at M. G Road, Junagadh and since, the matter is looked after by the Corporate Office and as there was communication gap between Circle Office and Sub Division office and/or by the Corporate office, the Corporate office was not in knowledge of the death of the respondent. It is further stated that only on 9th May 2012, the death of the respondent was communicated to Additional General Manager and consequently the matter was taken up for bringing the heirs of deceased respondent on record of the Appeal.

    Having considered the explanation given in the application with further affidavit filed by the applicants and having considered the reply affidavits filed by the opponents and having heard learned advocate for the parties, it appears that the deceased respondent was though represented by advocate before this Court in the appeal, did not inform about the death of the respondent to learned advocate for the appellants. It also appears that the appeal is originally filed by the main office of the Board along with the office of the Board at Porbandar as also with the Executive Engineer of the board having office at M.G Road Junagadh. The board has been then known as Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited and accordingly substituted in place of the board. This application is preferred by the main Corporate Office with Superintending Engineer having his office at M.G Road Junagadh and with Executive Engineer having his office at M.G Road Junagadh. It further appears that the heirs of the deceased respondent sent letter informing about the death of respondent only at Circle office which is at different place.

    4.1 In view of the above fact situation when the applicants have come out with the case that the applicants had no knowledge about the death of the respondent on account of communication gap between Circle office and the applicants and when learned advocate appearing for the respondent has also failed to intimate about the death of the respondent to learned advocate for the appellant, I am of the view that the applicants can be said to have made out sufficient cause for condonation of delay of 1923 days and also to set aside abatement of the Appeal for bringing heirs of the deceased respondent on record of the Second Appeal.

    In the case of Ram Nath Sao alias Ram Nath Sahu and Others Vs. Gobardhan Sao and Others reported in 2002(3) SCC 195, Hon ble Supreme Court has observed that the expression sufficient cause should be given liberal interpretation to ensure that substantial justice is done.

    It is required to be noted that it is not a case where the applicants are praying for condonation of delay for the purpose of filing any fresh appeal but the applicants want to pursue their appeal and during the pendency of such appeal, the sole respondent has passed away and if there is no intimation on the part of learned advocate appearing for such respondent and when the applicants have explained the circumstances under which the applicants had no knowledge about the death of the deceased respondent, I am of the view that the applicants cannot be said to be in any way at fault or responsible for not making application within time limit.

    For the reasons stated above the application deserves to be allowed. Accordingly the application is allowed and the delay caused in preferring the application is condoned. Consequently the abatement of the Second Appeal is set aside. Application stands allowed accordingly. Rule is made absolute.

    (C.L.SONI, J.) mary Page of 7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gujarat v. Natha
    (Feb 5, 2013)