The
present petition is for seeking winding up of the respondent
Company, i.e. GHCL Ltd.
Heard
Mr.Patel for the petitioner and Mr.Sanjanwala for the respondent
Company.
It
prima facie appears that the contention of the petitioner is that
there is Deed of Guarantee executed by the respondent Company for
guaranteeing the liability of the goods supplied to its wholly owned
subsidiary Company, viz. Rosebys Operations Limited. It is an
admitted position that the Deed of Guarantee was not executed.
However, the contention of the respondent Company is that the Deed
of Guarantee was executed at UK and therefore, when the goods were
supplied by the petitioner to Rosebys Operations
Limited(hereinafter referred to as principal debtor/subsidiary
Company of the respondent Company), at U.K. the cause of action
wholly or in part is outside the Indian territory and at UK and
therefore, such claim based on Deed of Guarantee is not enforceable.
As
per the petitioner, the goods/material were supplied to the
subsidiary Company of the respondent and the payment has not been
made and therefore, the guarantee is invoked. The same is coupled
with the circumstance that the subsidiary Company is declared
insolvent and is under the administration of the concerned Court
under insolvency proceeding. The petitioner has lodged the claim
before the concerned authority for recovery of the amount from the
subsidiary Company. However, no money is realised therefrom and the
matter is at the stage of adjudication of the claim. At that stage,
the guarantee was invoked. Further, the petitioner filed the Suit
based on the guarantee before the Court at UK and as stated in the
Judgement, the respondent did not appear and therefore, there is a
default Judgement (ex parte) for the sum of £1,11,498.21 on
the basis of which statutory notice was served to the respondent
Company under the Indian Companies Act. In the very statutory
notice, the subsequent claim which remained unpaid by the subsidiary
Company of £48,344.13 was also referred to and the demand was
made based on the Guarantee from the respondent Company to pay the
same. There is no denial by the respondent to such statutory notice
in toto, but the communication is that the claim is not verified and
therefore, the same is denied.
Mr.Sanjanwala,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent Company mainly raised
three contentions; one is that no part of cause of action has arisen
within the territory in India and have arisen in UK and therefore,
the Deed of Guarantee is not enforceable nor any claim based on such
Deed of Guarantee is non-enforceable in Indian Courts. Clause
14.1(a)(i) of the Deed of Guarantee reads as under -
(i) For
the benefit of the Supplier, the Guarantor submits to the exclusive
jurisdiction of the courts of England and Wales in relation to all
claims, disputes, differences or other matters arising out of or in
connection with this Deed provided that nothing in this clause
shall prevent the supplier in its sole and unfettered discretion,
from commencing proceedings against the Guarantor in any court of
competent jurisdiction. (Emphasis supplied)
Therefore,
prima facie it appears that the action by the supplier for
commencing the proceedings against the Guarantor in any Court of the
competent jurisdiction is not barred. If the respondent Company is
registered in Gujarat, this Court can be said as that of the
competent jurisdiction for entertaining of the proceedings of the
winding up. Therefore, prima facie, the contention raised on behalf
of the respondent cannot be said as acceptable for ousting the
jurisdiction of this Court on a mere ground that the cause of action
pertaining to the supply or the delivery or the guarantee had not
arisen in India.
The
next contention raised by Mr.Sanjanwala was that the Deed of
Guarantee is without prior approval of RBI as per the provisions of
the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (hereinafter referred to
as 'FEMA'). Therefore, the Deed of Guarantee is non-enforceable in
India. It was submitted that if the Deed of Guarantee is
non-enforceable in India in absence of the permission of the RBI,
the same cannot be invoked nor any liability based on the same can
be enforced in Indian Courts by the petitioner.
Prima
facie the submission appears to be attractive, but upon a close
scrutiny, it appears to be unjust, inequitable, and not bonafide.
It deserves to be recorded that as per the Deed of Guarantee, even
if the permission of RBI was to be obtained under FEMA, the same was
an obligation upon the respondent Company when it executed a Deed of
Guarantee. The respondent Company who has made the petitioner to
believe as per the Agreement that the necessary permission of the
competent authority will be obtained and if has not been obtained
and based on such Deed of Guarantee, if the petitioner has acted
upon the same, the respondent cannot be permitted to take benefit
therefrom. Further, the amount of statutory notice even if
considered in toto, is less than $ 100 Million, which is the minimum
requirement for seeking sanction of RBI. If the contention of the
respondent Company is that on account of any transaction by wholly
owned subsidiary Company abroad, the Guarantee as was to be given by
the respondent Company being Indian party, the permission of RBI was
required to be obtained, then also, such obligation would be upon
the respondent Company to obtain the permission. Even if the
contention is considered for the sake of examination that the
permission was not obtained, the respondent Company cannot get away
from its liability to discharge the obligation as per the Deed of
Guarantee in any case for the sum equivalent to Indian Rupees. If
such a contention is entertained, it would frustrate the basic
principles of maintenance of equitable jurisdiction coupled with the
statutory power to be exercised as per the provisions of the
Companies Act for winding up of the Company. Therefore, the said
contention prima facie does not deserve to be accepted. At this
stage, reference may be made to the decision of the Calcutta High
Court reported at [1983]53 Company Cases 744 (Cacutta) and more
particularly, the observations made at para 4 of the said decision.
It
was lastly contended by Mr.Sanjanwala, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent Company that the decree of Court of England is
non-enforceable in India as per the provisions of Section 13B and
13D of CPC and it was submitted that the remedy for enforcement for
execution of such decree of the Courts of UK is as per Section 44A
of CPC since the UK being a country of reciprocating territory, but
in view of the fact that such decree is non-executable as per
section 13 of cpc, and if such decree is non-enforceable, there is
no valid claim which can be made as the basis for invoking the power
of this Court for winding up of the respondent Company.
It
deserves to be recorded that as per the Decree of the Court of UK,
the process is served, but the respondent Company has not defended.
It may be that the decree is not on merit after dealing with each
and every contention of the plaintiff, but thereby, it cannot be
said that there is no foreign judgement against the respondent
Company. After having being served the statutory notice by the
petitioner, nothing prevented the respondent Company for filing the
suit for a declaration that the decree is not binding, but such
option available has not been exercised. Further, when there is a
decree/judgment of a foreign Court for fastening the liability, it
cannot be prima facie said that their would not be any liability at
all of the respondent. In any case, the aspects of
non-enforceability may be required to be considered in execution
proceeding, if resorted to, but such cannot be a sole ground to deny
the entertainment of the petition for winding up of the Company on
the basis of such liability. The reference may be made to the
decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in the case of Enernorth
Industries Inc. Vs. VBC Ferro Alloys Ltd. reported at [2006]133 Comp
Case 130 (AP), more particularly the observations made at para 34
and 35 that merely because the other modes are available, it cannot
be said that the petition for winding up is not maintainable.
In
the above view of the matter, it prima facie appears that the
defence as sought to be canvassed on behalf of the respondent
Company is not bonafide and is just to create a situation of no
liability whatsoever of the respondent Company though it had
executed a Deed of Guarantee for supply to be made by the petitioner
to its wholly owned subsidiary Company. Therefore, such an attempt
on the part of the respondent Company to disown the liability
whatsoever can be said as malafide defence. The grounds of breach
of certain procedural aspects not followed or certain jurisdictional
aspects, prima facie are without substance.
It
was submitted on behalf of the respondent Company by Mr.Sanjanwala
that the respondent Company is a Limited Company and it is
financially very sound Company and therefore, if it has ability to
pay the amount, this Court may decline the entertainment of the
petition for winding up by dismissing the same at this stage.
Had
it been a case where the amount claimed is deposited with this
Court, it might stand on different footing. Further, had it been a
case where this Court finds that the defence is genuine or non
dishonest or substantial, it may stand on different footing. But in
a case where neither of the situation arise and the matter is at the
stage of admission of the petition, it would profitable to extract
certain observations of this Court in the case of Ficom Organics
Ltd. Vs. Laffans Petrochemicals Ltd. reported in (1998) 5 Comp LJ 24
(Guj). This Court in the said decision made the observations as
under:
IV COURT'S FINDINGS ON BONA FIDES OF COMPANY'S
DEFENCE AND ORDERS WHICH MAY BE PASSED UPON SUCH
FINDINGS
(1) After considering the material on record, if the
Court comes to the conclusion that the defence
raised by the Company is not only not bona fide,
but the defence is reeking with mala fides or the
company's conduct leading to the dispute (in
respect of which the Company's defence is found
to be not bona fide) was dishonest, the Court
would admit the petition and pass an order for
advertisement.
(2) Where the Court comes to the conclusion that the
defence is not bona fide (as distinguished from
the conclusion that the defence is mala fide),
the Court may give the Company an opportunity to
pay the debt to the petitioner within the
stipulated time limit. If the debt is not paid,
the Court would ordinarily admit the petition,
unless a strong case is made out for not
admitting the petition. The Court may, in its
discretion, even pass a conditional order of
admission without an order for advertisement
while giving the finding that the Company's
defence is not bona fide.
(3) Where the Court gives only a prima facie or
tentative finding that the Company's defence is
not bona fide, before admitting and advertising
the petition the Court must also give a prima
facie or tentative finding that the Company is
commercially insolvent, that is, the Company is
unable to pay its debts as a going concern.
(4) Where the Court gives a finding that the defence
raised by the Company is a bona fide one, i.e.
substantial, non payment of such debt cannot
amount to neglect to pay debt as contemplated by
Sec. 434(1)(a) and the petition would have to be
dismissed. In such a case, the Company Court may
give only a prima facie i.e. tentative finding
because the controversy can be finally decided in
the civil suit. Of course, such a finding is
bound to result into the Company (defendant in
the suit) getting unconditional leave to defend
(which would be perfectly just and proper) in
case the petitioner files a summary suit for
recovering the debt in question.
(5) If the case falls in the grey area, that is, the
Company's defence is neither found to be
substantial nor a moonshine and, therefore, the
Court is not in a position even tentatively to
give a finding one way or the other whether the
defence is bona fide or not, the Court may
require the Company to deposit the claim amount
or a part thereof in the Court and require the
petitioner to prove its claim before the Civil
Court to which the amount deposited will be
transferred or the Court may require the Company
to give
security for the amount claimed.
Therefore,
keeping in view the aforesaid, if the facts of the present case are
considered, prima facie, at the admission stage, the following
deserves to be passed :
Admit.
As
the defence of the respondent Company is found to be not bonafide,
before this Court passes the further order for issuing advertisement
in accordance with law, by way of an opportunity to be given to the
respondent Company for showing its ability to pay the debt and also
to show the complications which may arise on account of the
advertisement upon its commercial solvency or insolvency as the case
may be, the respondent is directed to deposit the amount of
Rs.89,19,840/- being equivalent Indian rupees at the rate of Rs.80/-
per pound of £ 1,11,498.21. So far as amount equivalent to £
48,343.13 is concerned, no order for directing to deposit is made at
this stage. Such amount be deposited with this Court without two
weeks on or before 15th September, 2009.
S.O.
to 17th September, 2009 for passing further orders.
(JAYANT PATEL, J.)
*bjoy
Top