Appeal
is admitted.
Considering the facts and
circumstances of the case, and with consent of learned counsel for
both the parties, the appeal is heard on merits today and is being
disposed of by this judgment.
The instant appeal is filed
challenging the order dated 15.3.2010 passed by learned Member of
Railway Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench ('RCT, Ahmedabad Bench',
for short), whereby the application filed by the appellants herein
for restoration of main claim petition came to be dismissed on the
ground that the delay could not be condoned for restoration.
I have perused the impugned order
rendered by the learned RCT, Ahmedabad Bench and the relevant
provisions, namely, Section 17(2) and Section 18 of the Railway
Claims Tribunal Act as well as Rule 18(2) and Rule 38 of Railway
Claims Tribunal (Procedure) Rules 1989. In the case, there was delay
of about one year and 7 months in moving restoration application to
restore the main claim petition, which came to be dismissed for
non-prosecution. The Tribunal observed that Section 17(2) of the RCT
Act does not apply for restoration of application which is subject
of Rule 18(2) of the RCT (Procedure) Rules. The Tribunal
alternatively observed that even there was no sufficient ground for
condonation of delay. Accordingly, the delay was not condoned and
the restoration application came to be dismissed.
Mr.Mehta, ld.advocate for the
appellants, relied upon a case of Pushpakaran Vs.Union of India
reported in 2008 ACJ
2469, wherein the main petition
was dismissed for default and the restoration application which came
to be filed was delayed by 30 days. The concerned Tribunal held that
since the same was not a civil Court, it had no power to condone the
delay beyond the time fixed in the Rules. The matter came up before
Kerala High Court and the issue which was required to be decided was
whether the Railway Claims Tribunal can condone the delay on
sufficient reasons on application u/s.5 of the Limitation Act or
not, and the said issue was replied in the affirmative and the delay
was condoned and the main claim petition was remanded to the
Tribunal for adjudication on merits. Considering the facts and
circumstances of the case, this Court is of the opinion that the
ratio laid down in the case relied upon shall squarely apply to the
facts and circumstances of the instant case.
In
the memo of appeal as well as during the course of submissions,
Mr.Mehta, ld.advocate for the appellant submitted that since the
appellants were residing at the relevant time in Dehradun, and due
to non-presence of the appellants and the advocate on 9.5.2006
before the Tribunal, the matter came to be dismissed. It is further
averred in the memo of
appeal as well as submitted by ld.counsel Mr.Mehta, the appellants
are of old age and are poor, and only on 9.5.2006, he could not
reach to Ahmedabad from Dehradun and the main matter came to be
dismissed. However, Mr.Ravi Karnavat, ld.counsel for the respondent
submitted that no sufficient ground is available for condonation of
long delay of one year and 7 months. Considering the facts and
circumstances of the case and especially the nature of main
litigation, so also considering the averments made in the memo of
appeal as well as considering the submission advanced on behalf of
the appellants, this Court is of the opinion that sufficient ground
is available for condonation of delay and the delay is sufficiently
explained. However, Mr.Ravi Karnavat, ld.advocate for the respondent
- Railway submitted that the Claims Tribunal at the relevant
time in main claim petition directed the appellant herein to pay
costs of Rs.1000/- to the railway administration, but even the said
order of the Tribunal was not complied with. Mr.Mehta, ld.advocate
for the appellants states that the appellants have no objection to
deposit the amount of costs.
For
the foregoing reasons, the appeal deserves to be allowed and main
order passed by the learned RCT, Ahmedabad Bench on 15.3.2010 in
MX0700078 is set-aside and the main claim petition being OA
No.0100005 is ordered to be restored to the file
of learned RCT, Ahmedabad Bench and the aforesaid main claim
petition shall be heard and disposed of by the Tribunal in
accordance with law.
The appellants are
directed to deposit Rs.1000/- as costs before the learned Railway
Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench.
(J.C.UPADHYAYA,
J.)
(binoy)
Top