Whether
Reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment
? Yes
To
be referred to the Reporter or not ? Yes
Whether
their Lordships wish to see the fair copy of the judgment ?
No
Whether
this case involves a substantial question of law as to the
interpretation of the constitution of India, 1950 or any order
made thereunder ? No
Whether
it is to be circulated to the civil judge ? No
=================================================
TAX
RECOVERY OFFICER - Petitioner(s)
Versus
INDUSTRIAL
FINANCE CORPORATIONOF INDIA & 1 - Respondent(s)
=================================================
Appearance :
MR
MANISH R BHATT, SR. ADVOCATE with MRS
MAUNA M BHATT for Petitioner in SCA No. 3786 of 2010,
MR GAURANG
H BHATT for Petitioner in SCA No.6961 of 2010
NOTICE SERVED BY DS
for Respondent(s) : 1 - 2.
MR SN SOPARKAR and MR MIHIR THAKORE,
SR. ADVOCATES with MR MAULIK G NANAVATI for Respondent(s) : 1,
MR
MANAV A MEHTA for Respondent(s) :
2,
=================================================
CORAM
:
MUKHOPADHAYA)
The
first writ petition - Special Civil Application No. 3786 of
2010 has been preferred by the Tax Recovery Officer, Income-tax
Commissioner's Office, Gandhinagar against the action taken by the
1st
respondent - M/s Industrial Finance Corporation of India
(hereinafter referred
to as "the 1st
respondent - financial institution") under Section 13(4)
of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to
as "the SARFAESI Act"). A prayer has been made to
restrain the 1st
respondent - financial institution from parting with
possession, transferring or otherwise dealing with the properties of
the 2nd
respondent - Parekh Platinum Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as
"the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company").
2. The
question involved in the first writ petition is whether, in view of
sub-section (1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the
charge created against the property in question by mortgaging the
property by the 2nd
respondent - assessee borrower in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution during pendency of any of
the proceedings under the Income-tax Act, 1961 is void as against any
claim in respect of tax and other sum payable by the 2nd
respondent - assessee in favour of the petitioner -
revenue.
3. The
second writ petition - Special Civil Application No. 6961 of
2010 has been preferred by the Assistant Commissioner of Customs,
against the same very measures taken by the 1st
respondent - financial institution under Section 13(4) of the
SARFAESI Act. The order dated 7.10.2009 passed by the Debts Recovery
Tribunal - I, Ahmedabad in Securitization Application No. 35 of
2009 has been challenged, whereby the said Tribunal, on hearing the
parties, observed that the public auction and the subsequent
proceedings made by the 1st
respondent - financial institution shall be subject to the
final outcome of the Securitization Application pending before the
Debts Recovery Tribunal.
4. The
question involved in the second writ petition is as to whether the
Excise & Customs Department of the Central Government
have priority over the secured debt of the 1st
respondent -
financial institution.
5. For
determination of the issue, it is relevant to notice certain facts as
placed by the parties and appear from the record and detailed
hereunder.
According
to the petitioner - revenue of the first petition - SCA
No. 3786 of 2010, for the Assessment Year 1996-97 (Financial
Year 1995-96) onwards, the assessments were made and a sum of Rs.242
Crores plus interest, penalty and other charges are due to be
recovered by the petitioner - revenue from the 2nd
respondent - assessee. The petitioner had no knowledge that
the 2nd
respondent - assessee took loans from the 1st
respondent - financial institution and created a charge on the
property in question by mortgaging the property. The 1st
respondent - financial institution, as a secured creditor, has
taken physical and actual possession of the secured assets on
3.9.2009 under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. The Authorized
Officer of the 1st
respondent - financial institution issued a public notice for
sale of the secured assets on 8.9.2009 published in the local daily
"Business Standard" and "Gujarat Samachar".
The petitioner - revenue had no knowledge that the measures
have been taken by the 1st
respondent - financial institution, the secured creditor, for
recovery of their dues by taking recourse under Section 13(4) of the
SARFAESI Act and, therefore, the petitioner - revenue could not
approach the Debts Recovery Tribunal at the appropriate time.
Further
case of the petitioner - revenue is that the 2nd
respondent, who is an assessee, being defaulter, has not paid huge
outstanding income-tax demand with interest and penalty till date for
the Assessment Years 1996-97, 1998-99, 1999-2000, 2000-01, 2001-02
and for the block assessment period; the secured assets have already
been attached by the petitioner - revenue on 20.12.2004.
Therefore, such property of the 2nd
respondent - assessee
could not have been attached nor possession of the same could have
been taken by the 1st
respondent - financial institution claiming it to be the
secured creditor, the charge created by mortgage on the same property
by the 2nd
respondent - borrower assessee in favour of the 1st
respondent being void in view of sub-section (1) of Section 281 of
the Income-tax Act, 1961. It is stated that an equitable mortgage
has been created by the 2nd
respondent on 4.1.1999 in respect of the immovable property as
described in the case without obtaining any previous permission from
the Assessing Officer at the time of creating the equitable mortgage.
Therefore, such charge on mortgage created by the 2nd
respondent - assessee as borrower in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution has to be declared as void
as against all the claims in respect of outstanding tax demand with
interest, penalty, charges, etc. totalling to Rs.242 crores due and
payable by the 2nd
respondent to the petitioner - revenue and to that extent, the
mortgage created by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent requires to be declared as void and not binding on the
petitioner - revenue, the Income-tax department. The same is
not legal, valid and enforceable by the 1st
respondent against the petitioner - revenue in the eye of law.
Consequently, it be held and declared that the 1st
respondent - financial institution is not entitled to exercise
power under the SARFAESI Act in the capacity of a secured creditor on
the basis of the so called mortgage which is void.
The
aforesaid submission was highlighted by the learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the petitioner - revenue of the first petition.
Further
case of the petitioner - revenue is that the action of the 1st
respondent - financial institution of issuance of public notice
for sale is ex-facie illegal, arbitrary, null and void and
unenforceable in the
eye of law. The Authorized Officer of the 1st
respondent -
financial institution has failed to indicate and mention the
encumbrances in the nature of prior attachment over the property of
the 2nd
respondent - assessee made by the Income-tax Department on
20.12.2004. To that extent, the 1st
respondent - financial institution has committed breach of the
provisions of Rule 8(6) and Rule 9(7) to (9) of the Security Interest
(Enforcement) Rules, 2002. To that extent, the impugned action of
the 1st
respondent - financial institution under the SARFAESI Act
requires to be quashed and set aside.
It
appears that an appeal under section 17 of the sarfaesi act alongwith
a petition for condonation of delay has been filed by the petitioner
- revenue, the Tax Recovery Officer, Income-tax Commissioner's
Officer, Gandhinagar before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Ahmedabad on
12.3.2010. Therein, as the action of 2002 and 2009 is challenged, the
petition for condonation of delay has been filed and the matter is
pending.
The
2nd
respondent, the assessee of the petitioner - revenue as also
borrower of the 1st
respondent - financial institution, has also challenged the
measures taken by the 1st
respondent under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act by filing another
appeal under section 17 of the sarfaesi act, being Securitization
Appeal No. 35 of 2009 pending in the Court of the Debts Recovery
Tribunal, Ahmedabad. Therein also, similar plea has been taken by the
2nd
respondent against the measures taken by the 1st
respondent apart from the other pleas relating to pendency of the
appeal before the Appellate Authority constituted under the Sick
Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985; the steps taken
for One Time Settlement between the 2nd
respondent - borrower and the 1st
respondent - financial institution and also alleged violation
of certain provisions of the sarfaesi act and the rules framed
thereunder. Before this Court also, similar plea has been taken by
the 2nd
respondent, as taken by the petitioner - revenue.
6. In
the second writ petition, the Assistant Commissioner of Customs while
raising the question of charge over the property created in favour of
the 1st
respondent - financial institution, has made out a claim on the
following facts.
7. The
Director General of Foreign Trade, New Delhi had granted EPCG License
No. 01500634 on 16.7.1997 to the 2nd
respondent. At that time, the 2nd
respondent had executed the requisite bond in favour of the Customs
Department regarding duly payment of the Customs duty alongwith
interest at the rate of 15% per annum on the said Customs duty amount
in case the export obligation is met with.
8. The
2nd
respondent has failed to discharge export obligation, as per the
notification No. 29/1997 dated 1.4.1997, and the condition of the
EPCG license during 1997-98 itself. The petitioner of the second
writ petition - Customs Department, therefore, issued a duty
demand notice on 30.12.2004 directing the 2nd
respondent to pay a sum of Rs.65,30,96,269/- alongwith interest at
the rate of 15% per annum from 16.7.1998, failing which recovery
proceedings under Section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962 shall be
initiated against the 2nd
respondent.
9. The
2nd
respondent by its letter dated 1.7.2009 informed the Central Board of
Excise & Customs (CBEC) admitting its liability regarding EPCG
license issued for Rs.92,21,76,150/- on 16.7.1997 and having export
obligation of Rs.553 crores approx. It has actually made the import
of Rs.64.19 crores and as such the export commitment was for Rs.385
crores approx. The 2nd
respondent has also admitted therein that it could not fulfill its
export obligation under the EPCG due to various reasons. Similarly,
the export obligation under certain advance licenses were also not
fulfilled due to
various natural calamities. It further intimated that as per Section
22 of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985,
as the matter is pending with the BIFR/AAIFR not to take any action
and ultimately requested to grant extension of time of 5 years to
discharge those monetary obligations.
10. According
to the petitioner of the second writ petition, the Customs
department, by letters dated 30.9.2009 and 8.10.2009, has informed
the 2nd
respondent about the outstanding Customs duty amount to be recovered
from the 2nd
respondent - Company. The Customs department has also issued
certificate under Section 142(1)(ii)(C) of the Customs Act, 1962 and
under the Customs (Attachment of Property of Defaulters for Recovery
of Government Dues) Rules, 1995 and forwarded the same to its
Ahmedabad office and Gandhinagar office. The Customs department has
also submitted an application dated 8.10.2009 before the Debts
Recovery Tribunal - I, Ahmedabad in the pending Securitization
Application No. 35 of 2009 filed by the 2nd
respondent under section 17 of the sarfaesi act and lodged its claim
of recovery of the amount from the 2nd
respondent.
11. The
Customs department had appeared and attended the hearing of the said
Securitization Application No. 35 of 2009 before the Debts Recovery
Tribunal -I, Ahmedabad and on 1.4.2010 the Tribunal recorded the
statement of the 1st
respondent - financial institution regarding disclosure of the
events of the sale process in respect of the properties of the 2nd
respondent. The Customs department has submitted its application
dated 5.4.2010 for intervening as a party respondent in the
Securitization Application No. 35 of 2009. The matter was adjourned
and having realized that earlier the Tribunal passed an order on
7.10.2009 (impugned order) allowing the 1st
respondent - financial institution to sell the properties
subject to the decision of the appeal, has preferred the writ
petition, particularly when it also came to know that other writ
petition being SCA
No. 3786 of 2010 has been filed by the Income-tax Department before
this Court.
12. The
1st
respondent - financial institution while opposed the prayer,
has supported the action taken under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI
Act. According to the learned counsel appearing on behalf the 1st
respondent - financial institution, the charge created by the
2nd
respondent - borrower in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution by mortgaging the property
cannot be held to be void in view of clause (i) of the proviso to
sub-section (1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
According to him, the charge having created for adequate
consideration and no notice of pendency of the income-tax proceedings
having issued or served on the 1st
respondent - financial institution by the petitioner -
revenue, the charge so created by mortgage cannot be held to be
illegal or void. It is stated that the 1st
respondent is a "financial institution" as defined under
Section 4A of the Companies Act, 1956. The 2nd
respondent is the borrower in respect of different financial
facilities which at the request of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company were granted by the 1st
respondent in its favour. Apart from availing the financial
facilities from the 1st
respondent - financial institution, the 2nd
respondent has also taken loans from different banks and financial
institutions, such as State Bank of India, Dena Bank, State Bank of
Saurashtra, Corporation Bank, Bank of India, IDBI, GSFC besides
others. The 2nd
respondent - borrower Company has intentionally not made the
other secured creditors, who have also charge over the assets of the
borrower Company, parties in the present proceeding. Therefore, the
present petition is not maintainable.
13. The
1st
respondent claims to have granted financial assistance by way of
foreign currency loan to the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company on the terms and conditions
contained in the loan agreement and other security documents. As a
security for the due repayment
of the dues, the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company created security interests in
favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution by way of hypothecation of
movable properties and by mortgage of immovable properties by
executing the loan agreement/security documents in the year 1997 as
per the details given hereunder :-
(i) Joint
Mortgage created on 21.1.1999, by deposit of title deeds with IFCI on
pari pasu basis with SBI, on the Company's immovable properties
situated at GIDC Gem & Jewellery Park, Village Bhat, District
Gandhinagar in the State of Gujarat.
(ii) Deed
of Hypothecation dated 15.1.1997, executed by the Company in favour
of IFCI Limited creating a first charge on the Company's movables at
Bhat including movable machinery, machinery spares, tools and
accessories, present and future.
(iii) Personal
Guarantee furnished by Shri Jaisukhlal J. Parekh, Shri Rajesh J.
Parekh and Shri Rajnikant J. Parekh on 16.1.1997.
(iv) Corporate
Guarantee of Arraycom (India) Ltd. (Formerly Parekh Micro Electronics
(India) Ltd. furnished on 15.1.1997.
(v) Pledge
Agreement, executed on 27.1.1999 for pledge of 1,00,00,000 equity
shares of face value of Rs10/- each in favour of IFCI Ltd.
Details
of Secured Assets
Movable
properties : The
whole of the movable properties of the Borrower (Respondent No. 2 /
Borrower Company) including its movable plant and machinery,
machinery spares, tools and accessories and other movables, both
present and future (save and except book debts) whether installed or
not and whether now lying loose or in cases or which are now lying or
stored in or about or shall hereafter from time to during the
continuance of the security of these presents by brought into or upon
or be stored or be in or about all the borrower's factory premises
and godowns situated at GIDC Gen & Jewellery Complex, Village
Bhat, District Gandhinagar, in the State of Gujarat and/or be in or
about all the Borrower's factories, premises and godowns anywhere or
wherever else the same may be or be held by any aprty to the order or
disposition of the borrower or in the course of transit or on high
seas or on order, delivery, howsoever and wheresoever in the
possession of the Borrower and either by way of substitution
or addition.
Immovable
properties
: All piece and parcel of non-agricultural
freehold land being lying and situated at Plot No. 66, GIDC Gem &
Jewellery Park, Post Bhat, District Gandhinagar - 380428 of
Revenue Survey Nos. 43/A, 43/2, 44/1,
44/2, 53/A, 54/!A, 54/2A, 60/1+2 and 61 within the village limits of
Bhat, District Gandhinagar containing 1,20,000 sq. mts.
The
amounts outstanding and repayable to the 1st
respondent as on 31.12.2002 were as under :-
Principal : Rs.51,26,01,210/-
Interest : Rs.15,85,31,057/-
--------------------------
Total : Rs.67,11,32,267/-
--------------------------
According
to the 1st
respondent, further as on 11.9.2009, a sum of Rs.173,31,39,698/- is
due and payable by the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company to the 1st
respondent alone.
14. A
joint meeting of the financial institutions and banks was held on
10.2.2003 wherein the financial institutions and banks representing
more than 75% of the amount of debts decided to proceed against the
2nd
respondent - borrower Company under the SARFAESI Act. The 1st
respondent received various letters from various secured creditors
requesting the 1st
respondent - financial institution to initiate action under
section 13 of the sarfaesi act, thereby given consent as per Section
13(9) of the SAFAESI Act. The 1st
respondent - financial institution has taken consent of the
secured creditors representing more than 75% of the value of the
amount outstanding as required under Section 13(9) of the SARFAESI
Act, as detailed below :-
S.No.
Date
Consent
of Secured Creditors
18.02.2003
Dena Bank
19.02.2003
Corporation
Bank
20.02.2003
State Bank
of India
20.02.2003
Gujarat
State Financial Corporation
22.02.2003
Indian Bank
26.02.2003
Allahabad
Bank
28.02.2003
Bank of
India
28.02.2003
State Bank
of Saurashtra
10.03.2003
Industrial
Investment Bank of India Ltd.
15. ARCIL,
assignee of debts of Dena Bank, appointed "Resolution
Commercial Management Company" as a facilitator for resolving
the loan account of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company. On 28.8.2008, the "Resolution
Commercial Management Company" informed the 1st
respondent that ARCIL intends to proceed under Section 13(4) of the
SARFAESI Act and gave its consent for the same. The 1st
respondent - financial institution being the lead institution
duly issued a notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act on
29.4.2003. The 2nd
respondent - borrower Company approached the BIFR with a sole
objective to avoid proceeding under the SARFAESI Act. Reference Case
No. 240 of 2004 was registered before the BIFR, but the same was
rejected by the BIFR on 19.3.2008 on the ground that the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company has approached the BIFR with
unclean hands by manipulating the Company's accounts. The 2nd
respondent - borrower Company has approached the 1st
respondent - financial institution for One Time Settlement and
offered to pay the total sum of Rs.29.96 crores towards the
settlement of dues of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company. However, the proposal being on
the lower side was not acceptable to the 1st
respondent - financial institution. On 25.7.2007, the 1st
respondent - financial institution has informed the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company that the 1st
respondent is only agreeable to consider the proposal of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company envisaging an aggregate payment
of Rs.36 crores immediately. Since the terms and conditions of the
settlement were not complied with by the 2nd
respondent - borrower
Company and the payment was not made, by letter dated 1.5.2008 the
1st
respondent revoked the One Time Settlement proposal as was given to
the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company. Since the secured creditors
decided to proceed ahead under the SARFAESI Act, the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company filed two writ petitions before
this Court in SCA No. 9945 of 2008 and SCA No. 3 of 2009. Thereafter
they filed a Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court to stay
the auction. However, the Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave
Petition as a consequence of which the secured assets of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company were sold. Subsequently, the
sale proceeds were also distributed amongst the secured creditors.
16. In
present case, we have noticed that an appeal under Section 17 of the
SARFAESI Act with a petition for condonation of delay has already
been preferred by the petitioner - revenue before the Debts
Recovery Tribunal, Ahmedabad against the measures taken by the 1st
respondent - financial institution under Section 13(4) of the
SARFAESI Act. The auction of the immovable property is under
challenge. The 2nd
respondent has also filed Securitization Appeal No. 35 of 2009
against such measures taken by the 1st
respondent under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act and the said
matter is also pending before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Ahmedabad.
In this background, it is not desirable to decide the question
whether the measures taken by the 1st
respondent under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act are against any of
the provisions of the sarfaesi act or the rules framed thereunder and
thereby illegal or not. The secured assets having already been sold,
the auction purchaser having not been impleaded as a party respondent
to the present writ petition, the other financial institutions and
banks with whom the auction amount has already been distributed being
not parties to the present petition, it is not desirable to decide
the question of validity of the measures taken by the 1st
respondent under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.
17. The
only question which is required to be determined, for which the case
was heard, as already noticed, is whether in view of sub-section (1)
of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the charge created
against the property in question by mortgaging the property by the
2nd
respondent - assessee borrower in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution during pendency of any of
the proceedings under the Income-tax Act, 1961 is void as against any
claim in respect of income-tax and other sum payable by the 2nd
respondent - assessee in favour of the petitioner -
revenue.
18. It
is not in dispute that a proceeding under the Income-tax Act, 1961 is
pending since Assessment Year 1996-97 (Financial Year 1995-96)
as also the proceeding under the Income-tax Act, 1961 for the
subsequent Assessment Years 1998-99 onwards against the 2nd
respondent - assessee, which is a borrower of the 1st
respondent
- financial institution. The charge has been created by the
2nd
respondent as borrower in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution by way of equitable mortgage
on 21.1.1999 in respect of the immovable property in dispute, during
pendency of the proceeding under the Income-tax Act. Therefore, the
rigor of sub-section (1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961
is attracted in respect of the mortgaged property in question.
19. The
stand of the 1st
respondent is that the mortgage created by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent is saved by the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 281
of the Income-tax Act and, therefore, not void.
20. It
is not in dispute that the 1st
respondent has advanced loan to the 2nd
respondent for which the loan agreement was executed between the
parties. The 2nd
respondent having received such loan created an equitable mortgage by
depositing the title documents in favour of the 1st
respondent. Thus, it is evident that the mortgage has been made by
the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent, having
received the consideration of amount by way of loan.
21. The
parties have not disputed that at the time of creation of the
mortgage in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial Company, Mr ND Shah, Director of the
2nd
respondent - borrower Company executed a declaration and
undertaking on 21.1.1999 stating that the properties of the Company
mortgaged to the 1st
respondent - financial institution are free from all
encumbrances (statutory or otherwise), claims and demands, and that
no
proceedings are pending or initiated against the borrower under the
Income Tax Act, 1961, Public Demands Recovery Act or under other law
in force in India for the time being and that no notice has been
received or served on the Company under Rules 2, 16, 21 and 51 of
the Second Schedule of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and/or any other law
that there is no pending attachments whatsoever issued or initiated
against the said immovable properties or any of them or any part
thereof
.
It was further declared that
the
Company has paid all rents, royalties and all public demands
including provided fund dues, gratuity dues, Employees' State
Insurance Dues, Income Tax, Sales Tax, Corporation Tax and all other
taxes and revenues payable to the Government of India or to the
Government of any State or to any Local Authority and that at present
there are no arrears of such dues, rents, royalties, taxes and
revenues due and outstanding and that no attachments or warrants have
been served on the Company in respect of Sales Tax, Income Tax,
Government Revenues and other Taxes.
The aforesaid
facts have not been disputed by the petitioner - revenue.
22. The
learned counsel for the 1st
respondent while referred to Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961
submitted that the said provision does not prescribe any adjudicatory
machinery for deciding any question which may arise under it. In
order to declare a
transfer fraudulent under Section 281, appropriate proceeding will
have to be taken out by the department before the competent Civil
Court. In absence of such declaration, the creation of mortgage in
favour of the 1st
respondent cannot be declared to be bad.
23. It
is specifically pleaded by the 1st
respondent that no notice of pendency of the income-tax proceeding
was served on the 1st
respondent on or before the execution of the equitable mortgage deed
by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent. Therefore, according to the counsel for the 1st
respondent, the mortgage created by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent is saved under clause (i) of the proviso to sub-section
(1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
24. Section 281
of the Income-tax Act, 1961 reads as follows :-
"281. Certain
transfers to be void,-
(1) Where, during the pendency of any proceeding under this Act or
after the completion thereof, but before the service of notice under
rule 2 of the Second Schedule, any assessee creates a charge on, or
parts with the possession (by way of sale, mortgage, gift, exchange
or any other mode of transfer whatsoever) of , any of his assets in
favour of any other person, such charge or transfer shall be void as
against any claim in respect of any tax or any other sum payable by
the assessee as a result of the completion of the said proceedings or
otherwise :
Provided
that such charge or transfer shall not be void if it is made -
(i) for
adequate consideration and without notice of the pendency of such
proceeding or, as the case may be, without notice of such tax or
other sum payable by the assessee; or
(ii) with
the previous permission of the Assessing Officer.
(2) This
section applied to cases where the amount of tax or other sum payable
or likely to be payable exceeds five thousand rupees and the assets
charged or transferred exceed ten
thousand rupees in value.
Explanation
-
In this section, "assets" means land, building,
machinery, plant, shares, securities and fixed deposits in banks,
to the extent to which any of the assets aforesaid does not form part
of the stock-in-trade of the business of the assessee."
25.
The petitioner - revenue, the Tax Recovery Officer, has not
disputed the fact that no notice of pendency of any income-tax
proceeding was served on the 1st
respondent - financial institution on or before the equitable
mortgage made by the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution. It is not the case of the
petitioner - revenue that no adequate consideration was made
before creating the charge by equitable mortgage by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution.
26. The
learned counsel for the petitioner referred to the Annual Reports of
1993-94 onwards of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company to show that in the report dated
30.9.1997 i.e. much prior to the creation of the equitable mortgage,
the 2nd
respondent has shown under the heading "Contingent Liabilities
Not Provided For", including "the taxation matter under
appeal" Rs.815.98 lacs (Previous Year Rs.54.01 lacs). It was
contended on behalf of the petitioner - revenue that the 1st
respondent - financial institution before allowing the loan in
favour of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company must have noticed the Annual
Reports of the Company to find out the liability of repayment and
thereby it is to be accepted that they have knowledge of liability of
payment of tax dues by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the petitioner - revenue. However,
such submission cannot be accepted as a fact cannot be presumed that
the 1st
respondent had the knowledge of income-tax liability of the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company and/or pendency of any income-tax
proceeding against the 2nd
respondent - borrower Company, particularly while executing the
agreement, the Director on behalf of the 2nd
respondent had specifically mentioned in the agreement that there was
no income-tax dues and no such proceeding was pending. As the fact
cannot be presumed, the aforesaid
submission made on behalf of the petitioner - revenue cannot be
accepted.
27. Under
the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 281, the charge or transfer
shall not be void if made - (i) for adequate consideration and
without notice of the pendency of such proceedings, or (ii) without
notice of tax or other sum payable by the assessee. There is nothing
on record to suggest that any notice was given by the revenue to the
1st
respondent relating to pendency of such income-tax proceeding or
liability of any tax payable by the 2nd
respondent - assessee in favour of the petitioner -
revenue. As the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 281 stipulates
a notice relating to such pendency of the income-tax proceeding or
payment of tax payable by the assessee, the revenue cannot take the
plea that the 1st
respondent had knowledge of the pendency of the proceeding and
thereby it is open to the 1st
respondent to derive advantage of clause (i) of the proviso to
sub-section (1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, so far as
it relates to charge created by the 2nd
respondent in favour of the 1st
respondent - financial institution by equitable mortgage of the
immovable property in question, as against any claim in respect of
any tax or any other sum payable by the assessee as a result of
completion of any proceeding or otherwise by the petitioner -
revenue.
28. Similar
matter fell for consideration before the Madhya Pradesh High Court in
the case of State
of Madhya Pradesh vs. Abhaykumar,
reported in (1992) 86 Sales Tax Cases 88. Therein the State revenue
referring to the provisions of Section 33-A of the Madhya Pradesh
General Sales Tax Act, 1958 contended that the transfer as against
the revenue was void. The Indore Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High
Court having noticed the provision of Section 33-A of the Madhya
Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1958, which was almost similar to the
present sub-section (1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act, 1961,
held that the transfer was for a valuable consideration
and it was without notice of the pendency of the proceeding under the
Sales-tax Act and, therefore, the transfer falls under the exception
created by the proviso to Section 33-A of the said Act. The finding
of the lower Court was upheld and the second appeal preferred by the
State of Maharashtra was dismissed.
Similar
finding was also given by a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High
Court (Gwalior Bench) in the case of Pooranchand
Ved Prakash vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh,
reported in (1973) XXXI Sales Tax Cases 170. Therein, the Division
Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, taking into consideration the
object of the proviso to Section 33-A of the Madhya Pradesh General
Sales Tax, 1958, held that such proviso was to give protection to a
bona fide transferee for consideration. Where, therefore, a
transferee acquires property from a dealer bona fide for valuable
consideration without notice of the proceedings for recovery of
arrears of sales tax against that dealer, the transfer will be saved
under the proviso even though it is hit by the main part of the
Section. The view that the expression "without notice of the
proceedings" in the proviso refers to the dealer and not to be
transferee is not correct.
29. The
case of the petitioner of the first writ petition - SCA No.
3786 of 2010 being also covered by the aforesaid decision, we hold
that the 1st
respondent - financial institution is entitled to the
protection to the bona fide transfer of the property having made for
valuable consideration from the 2nd
respondent - assessee and the same having made without notice
of the proceedings for recovery of arrears of income-tax against the
1st
respondent - transferee is saved under clause (i) of the
proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 281 of the Income-tax Act,
1961, though the transfer is hit by the main part of the Section. In
absence of any merit, the first writ petition - SCA No. 3786 of
2010 is dismissed, but there shall be no order as to costs.
30. In
the second writ petition - SCA No. 6961 of 2010, the Customs
department has claimed priority over the secured creditor, the 1st
respondent, in view of Section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962.
According to it, the claim of the Customs department has priority
over the claim of the secured creditor, the 1st
respondent.
31. Section 142
of the Customs Act, 1962 relates to "Recovery of sums due to
Government", as quoted hereunder :-
"142.
Recovery of sums due to Government,
- (1) Where any sum payable by any person under this Act including
the amount required to be paid to the credit of the Central
Government under Section 28B is not paid,-
(a) the
proper officer may deduct or may require any other officer of customs
to deduct the amount so payable from any money owing to such person
which may be under the control of the proper officer or such other
officer or customs; or
(b) the
Assistant Commissioner of Customs or Deputy Commissioner of Customs
may recover the amount so payable by detaining and selling any goods
belonging to such person which are under the control of the Assistant
Commissioner of Customs of Deputy Commissioner of Customs or such
other officer of customs; or
(c) if
the amount cannot be recovered from such person in the manner
provided in clause (a) or clause (b) -
(i) the
Assistant Commissioner of Customs or Deputy Commissioner of Customs
may prepare a certificate signed by him specifying the amount due
from such person and send it to the Collector of the district in
which such person owns any property or resides or carries on his
business and the
said Collector on receipt of such certificate shall proceed to
recover from such person the amount specified thereunder as if it
were an arrears of land revenue; or
(ii) the
proper officer may, on an authorization by a Commissioner of Customs
and in accordance with the rules made in this behalf, distrain any
movable or immovable property belonging to or under the control of
such person, and detain the same until the amount payable is paid;
and in case, any party of the said amount payable or of the cost of
the distress or keeping of the property, remains unpaid for a period
of thirty days next after any such distress, may cause the said
property to be sold and with the proceeds of such sale, may satisfy
the amount payable and the costs including cost of sale remaining
unpaid and shall render the surplus, if any, to such person :
Provided
that where the person (hereinafter referred to as predecessor), by
whom any sum payable under this Act including the amount required to
be paid to the credit of the Central Government under Section 28B is
not paid, transfers or otherwise disposes of his business or trade in
whole or in part, or effects any change in the ownership thereof, in
consequence of which he is succeeded in such business or trade by any
other person, all goods, materials, preparations, plants,
machineries, vessels, utensils, implements and articles in the
custody or possession of the person so succeeding may also be
attached and sold by the proper officer, after obtaining written
approval from the Commissioner of Customs, for the purposes of
recovering the amount so payable by such predecessor at the time of
such transfer or otherwise disposal or change.
(2) Where
the terms of any bond or other instrument executed under this Act or
any rules or regulations made thereunder provide that any amount due
under such instrument may be recovered in the manner laid down in
sub-section (1) the amount may, without prejudice to any other mode
of recovery, be recovered in accordance with the provisions of that
sub-section."
From the
aforesaid provision, it will be evident that under Section 142, no
charge is created in favour of the Customs department, much less the
first charge or priority of claim over a secured creditor. It only
relates to manner in which the amount payable by the assessee is to
be recovered.
32. The
question relating to priority of dues of the Government fell for
consideration before the Supreme Court and other High Courts from
time to time. Taking into consideration the different decisions of
the Supreme Court, a Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Baroda
City Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. State of Gujarat,
reported in 2010 (3) GLR 2132 : 2010 (2) GLH 525, held as follows :-
"16. From
the judgments referred to above, it will be evident that -
(a) The
arrears of tax due to the State can claim priority over the unsecured
debt.
(b) If
first charge by way of priority is not claimed under the statute, the
said doctrine is not applicable.
(c) Normally,
the doctrine of first charge/priority of State will prevail over the
private debt which is an unsecured debt.
(d) In
normal course, the doctrine of first charge/priority cannot prevail
over secured debts, but if first charge of the State is over the
secured debts, both debts being equal, the State can claim priority
even over the secured debts, and
(e) The
secured debts under the Securitization Act or debt under the RDDB Act
has no first charge and thereby cannot compete with first
charge/priority claim of the State if made under the statute."
33. A
specific question whether the Central Excise Department can claim
priority over the secured debt of a secured creditor under the
Central Excise Act, 1944 also fell for consideration before different
High Courts and the Supreme Court. A Full Bench of the Madras High
Court in the case of UTI
Bank Ltd. vs. The Dy. Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai II
Division,
reported
in 2007 (1) Law Weekly, 50 while dealing with the Central Excise Act,
1944, the Customs Act, 1962 and the SARFAESI Act, 2002, considered
whether the Crown's debts, for which there is no priority or charge
is created under the statute, should have precedence over the secured
creditors or not. Considering the facts of the said case that the
UTI Bank had taken possession of the property under Section 13(4) of
the SARFAESI Act and having noticed that there are no specific
provisions under the Central Excise Act or the Customs Act to claim
first charge, as provided under other enactments, the Full Bench held
that generally the dues to the Government i.e. tax, duties, etc.
(Crown's debts) get priority over ordinary debts; only when there is
a specific provision in
the statute claiming first charge over the property, the Crown's debt
is entitled to have priority over the claim of others. In absence of
any such provision to claim first charge, the Government cannot claim
precedence under the Central Excise Act over the claim of the secured
creditor under the SARFAESI Act, 2002.
34. Similar
question fell for consideration before the Supreme Court in the case
of Union
of India vs. Sicom Ltd.,
reported in (2009) 2 SCC 121. Having noticed the provisions of the
Central Excise Act, 1944, the Supreme Court has rejected the claim of
the Government to have first charge over the secured debt.
35. The
same very issue also fell for consideration before a Division Bench
of this Court in the case of Kotak
Mahindra Bank vs. District Magistrate,
reported in 2011 (1) GLR 18. In the said case, the proceeding under
the Central Excise Act, 1944 was initiated on 24.2.1987 and 26.2.1991
when Rule 173Q(2) and Rule 211 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 were
in vogue. At the time the first order of confiscation was passed, the
authority had jurisdiction under Rule 173Q(2) to confiscate the land,
building, plant, machinery, etc.. The said order was set aside and
remitted for de nova decision. The final order was passed on
25.2.2006, by this time both Rule 173Q(2) and Rule 211 stood omitted.
Having noticed the different provisions of the Central Excise Act,
1944, Central Excise Rules, 1944 and the Central Excise Rules, 2001
including Rule 28 of the Central Excise Rules, 2001 which related to
the property to be vested in the Central Government on confiscation,
and different decisions of the High Courts and Supreme Court, this
Court held that Excise and Customs department of the Central
Government cannot claim any priority over the secured debt of a
secured creditor as created under the SARFAESI Act.
36. The
case of the petitioner of the second writ petition, the Assistant
Commissioner of Customs in SCA No. 6961 of 2010 being covered by the
decision of the Madras High Court in the
case of UTI
Bank Ltd. vs. The Dy. Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai II
Division,
reported
in 2007 (1) Law Weekly, 50, the decision of the Supreme Court in
the case of Union
of India vs. Sicom Ltd.,
reported in (2009) 2 SCC 121 and the decision of a Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Kotak
Mahindra Bank vs. District Magistrate,
reported in 2011 (1) GLR 18, we hold that the Customs Department
cannot claim any priority of claim over the claim of the secured
creditor, the 1st
respondent - financial institution. No relief can be granted
in the second writ petition - SCA No. 6961 of 2010, which is
accordingly rejected.
37. So
far as the question of taking over possession of the property under
Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act or auction of sale of the said
property under said Section 13(4) or distribution of the assets
between the different secured creditors are concerned, they being the
matters pending consideration before the Debts Recovery Tribunal,
Ahmedabad in Securitization Appeal No. 35 of 2009 filed by the 2nd
respondent and the proposed appeal filed by the petitioner -
revenue alongwith a petition for condonation of delay, we have not
expressed any opinion. Therefore, the present judgment will not
affect on the question to be determined by the Debts Recovery
Tribunal, Ahmedabad i.e. whether the measures taken by the 1st
respondent - financial institution in respect of the property
in question under Section 13(4) are against the SARFAESI Act or the
Rules framed thereunder, which is to be determined on the basis of
the facts and pleadings independently.
[S.
J. MUKHOPADHAYA, CJ.]
[K.
M. THAKER, J.]
sundar/PPS
Top