Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Mohammed v. Mohammed Asif Abdul Kayub Shaikh

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    1. This Appeal is preferred by claimant for Rs. 5.00 lacs challenging award passed by Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad in M.A.C.P No. 507 of 2001 decided on 23rd August, 2006, Exh.19 where Claims Tribunal has awarded Rs. 1,45,800/- with 8% interest in favour of appellant - claimant.

    2. Learned advocate Mr. A.V Prajapati submitted that Claims Tribunal has committed gross error in not awarding reasonable and just amount of compensation in favour of claimant, therefore, present appeal is filed. He submitted that 25% negligence which has been decided by Claims Tribunal without any evidence on record and therefore accident is occurred not due to contributory negligence of appellant but it was sole negligence of respondent No. 1. He also submitted that future prospective income which has been decided Rs. 1,05,400/- being calculation error because Claims Tribunal has not applied mind. He submitted that for pain, shock and sufferings only Rs. 12,000/- has been awarded but claimant is entitled some more amount for pain, shock and sufferings. Therefore he submitted that some reasonable amount of compensation in respect to each head may be enhanced in favour of appellant.

    3. Learned advocate Mr. Sandip Shah appearing on behalf of Insurance Company submitted that Claims Tribunal has properly examined matter and decided it on basis of evidence and rightly awarded a reasonable amount of compensation in favour of claimant for that Claims Tribunal has not committed any error which requires interference by this Court.

    4. I have considered submissions made by both learned advocates and I have also perused award passed by Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad. Accident occurred on 1.7.2000 at about 17.45 hours. Claimant was going for calculation of his business from his house on his motorcycle bearing Registration No. GJ-1-EE-6918 and when he reached opposite to Gujarat Samachar Circle and he was taking the turn towards BJP Office, at that time, one motorcycle which was driven by opponent No. 2 came from Dinbai Tower and opponent No. 2 has driven his motorcycle in rash and negligent manner and in full speed and dashed with motorcycle of claimant. The claimant was fallen on the road and he sustained injuries on right leg. The opponent No. 2 had raced his motorcycle and claimant has seen the Registration No. of his motorcycle which is GJ-1-CA-2355. The incident took place due to negligence on part of respondent No. 2 who has driven his vehicle in rash and negligent manner. The claimant sustained serious injuries on right leg and one Mr. Amitbhai who is residing in the same flat in which claimant is staying had taken claimant to V.S Hospital in auto-rickshaw, where x-ray of right leg was taken in which fracture is being seen and operation was fixed on Tuesday. Thereafter claimant was admitted in hospital of Dr. Manoj Joshi, where he was operated and given treatment as an indoor patient for 20 days. Thereafter he was advised to take rest for period of six months. During that period he had occasionally visited hospital of Dr. Manoj Joshi for the purpose of dressing and he has spend Rs. 40,000/- for medicines and medical treatment. Claimant was having business of building material and construction earning Rs. 15,000/- per month and he got 28% disability and due to that he suffered in business of contract and he was using right leg and due to injury and permanent disability he was not able to do work. The reply is filed by respondent No. 2 at Exh.22 and Insurance Company has filed reply Exh.17 Thereafter issues have been framed by Claims Tribunal Exh.14 Issue of negligence has been considered by Claims Tribunal in paragraph 10 as under:

    After hearing the learned Advocate of both the sides, if we peruse Exh.26, the deposition of the petitioner, he has narrated the incident in detail. Moreover, the complaint at Exh.47 also supports the case of the petitioner and if we peruse the cross-examination of the petitioner, he has stated that in the incident both the vehicles were coming from opposite direction and he has seen the opposite vehicle from 10 ft. to 15 ft. away. He has also admitted that after the incident, he and the opponent No. 2 fallen on the road. Thus, it can be said that the petitioner has seen the opposite vehicle from 10 ft. to 15 ft. away. Moreover, if we peruse the panchnama of place of offence at Exh.48, but it is not showing the real picture of the incident. In these circumstances, considering the fact that the incident took place at 17.45 hours, both the vehicles are of the same cadre i.e motorcycle and both the vehicles were coming from the opposite direction and they dashed with each other. Moreover, the petitioner has seen the opposite vehicle from 10 ft. to 15 ft. In these circumstances, it can be said that the petitioner has not taken step to prevent the incident. In these circumstances, there is some negligence of the petitioner and considering the fact, I am of the opinion that 75% negligence is required to be held on the part of the opponent No. 2 and 25% negligence on the part of the petitioner. Hence, I find the issue No. 1 and 2 accordingly.

    5. The Claims Tribunal has committed gross error in coming to conclusion that there is 25% contributory negligence of claimant in absence of any evidence which found on record. Panchnama Exh.48 not giving real picture of accident. Merely submission was made by claimant before Claims Tribunal that he has seen the opposite vehicle from 10 ft. to 15 ft., but in absence of evidence of respondent No. 2 who was not examined before Claims Tribunal, the conclusion of Claims Tribunal that claimant has not taken steps to prevent the accident and therefore there is some negligence of claimant is contrary to evidence which are on record. Therefore finding in respect to negligence decided by Claims Tribunal, 25% contributory negligence is required to be set aside because it was a case of sole negligence of respondent No. 2 who was a driver of opposite motorcycle. Therefore, according to my opinion, there is no contributory negligence of claimant is proved before Claims Tribunal. Therefore claimant is entitled amount of compensation without deducting 25% contributory negligence as decided by Claims Tribunal.

    6. The Claims Tribunal has committed a calculation error in paragraph 14. The Claims Tribunal from evidence on record produced by claimant, Rs. 4,000/- income has been assessed and 14.4% disability as body as whole has been accepted. The monthly loss of income comes to Rs. 576 and yearly it comes to Rs. 6,912/-, and considering 17 multiplier looking to age group of claimant 30 to 35 years then the net amount comes to Rs. 1,17,504/-, instead of that Claims Tribunal has awarded amount Rs. 1,05,400/-. Therefore claimant is entitled difference of Rs. 12,104/- from respondent. The Claims Tribunal has also committed gross error in awarding amount Rs. 12,000/- for head of pain, shock and sufferings. Looking to evidence on record and operation was carried out by claimant in hospital of Dr. Manoj Joshi and plate was inserted and was discharged from hospital on 12.7.2000 and also considering injury of fracture of right leg and initially he was admitted in V.S Hospital and thereafter he was transferred to Dr. Manoj Joshi hospital, therefore, Rs. 12,000/- which has been awarded on pain, shock and suffering is on lower side. According to my opinion, claimant is entitled Rs. 30,000/- being amount of compensation for pain, shock and sufferings. Accordingly enhanced amount comes to Rs. 18,000/-.

    7. In view of aforesaid discussions and observations made by this Court after considering submissions made by both learned advocates, the enhanced amount comes to Rs. 12,104/- for future loss of income, Rs. 18,000/- for enhanced amount for pain, shock and sufferings and Rs. 48,600/- which was deducted for 25% negligence on part of claimant is now the claimant is entitled Rs. 48,600/-, which total amount comes to Rs. 78,704/- which recovered from respondent Insurance Company with 8% interest from date of filing claim petition till realisation of this petition with proportionate cost from opponents jointly and severally. Accordingly, award passed by Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad, challenged in present appeal is required to be modified as referred above and appeal is partly allowed with a direction to respondents to pay Rs. 78,704/- with 8% interest from date of claim petition to deposit before Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad, within a period of two months from the date of receipt of copy of present order. After realising said amount from the respondents, it is directed to Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad to pay entire amount by Account Payee Cheque in name of Mohammed @ Nurmohammed Kureshi after proper verification.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohammed v. Mohammed Asif Abdul Kayub Shaikh
    (Feb 16, 2010)