AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment (General) Rules, 1967
  • provision of the aforesaid sub-rule (5).
  • sub-rule (5) of rule 8 of the rules
  • sub-rule (5) of rule 8
  • sub-rule (2) of rule 8,
  • rule 8, sub-rule (5),
  • rule 4, sub-rule (1),
  • sub-rule (2)
  • rule 8(5)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment (General) Rules, 1967
  • provision of the aforesaid sub-rule (5).
  • sub-rule (5) of rule 8 of the rules
  • sub-rule (5) of rule 8
  • sub-rule (2) of rule 8,
  • rule 8, sub-rule (5),
  • rule 4, sub-rule (1),
  • sub-rule (2)
  • rule 8(5)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Three petitioners were employed as aayas at Ram Rajendrasinhji Hospital and Baluba Maternity Home, Limbdi, Surendranagar District. Each petitioner was repeatedly engaged on short-term assignments of 29 days at a time over a period exceeding two years. Petitioner 1 (date of birth 23 November 1951) was first employed on 2 April 1980 and worked on 18 further occasions up to 22 June 1983, totaling 19 engagements and 551 days. Petitioner 2 was first employed on 10 June 1981 and subsequently 12 times up to 22 June 1983. Petitioner 3 was first employed on 22 July 1981 and subsequently on 12 occasions up to 24 May 1983. Because the three petitioners had in aggregate worked for more than two years (albeit with gaps), the Civil Surgeon, Limbdi, sent them before the selection board and recommended their permanent appointment. The Director of Health and Medical Services, by letter dated 22 May 1984, turned down that recommendation on the ground that the petitioners had passed the age limit of 30 years on the date of their permanent appointment. Against that decision the present petition was filed in the court whose opinion is summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners' multiple short-term employments of 29 days each, spread over more than two years with short intervals, should be regarded as continuous service for the purposes of rule 8(5) of the Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment (General) Rules, 1967, thereby making the upper age-limit inapplicable because they were within the age limit when first employed.
  2. Whether the State's practice of repeatedly employing persons for 29 days with short breaks amounts to a circumvention of the protection in rule 8(5) and whether that technical interruption defeats the petitioners' claim.
  3. Whether age relaxation under rule 8(2) (for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes) is available to class IV employees.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented by Sri A.D. Padival)

  • The petitioners were employed repeatedly for 29-day terms but, when aggregated, their service exceeds two years and well exceeds six months; this aggregated service should be treated as qualifying service for rule 8(5).
  • It is undisputed that the petitioners were within the age limit of 30 years when they were first appointed on a temporary basis; therefore rule 8(5) should protect them from the upper age limit at the time of permanent appointment.
  • The State is resorting to a tactic of short 29-day engagements with short intervals to circumvent sub-rule (5) and deny the benefit to those who in substance have been in government service.
  • The petitioners are entitled to permanent appointment under the Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment (General) Rules, 1967 — specifically rule 8(5).

Respondent's Arguments (as presented by Sri B.D. Desai)

  • Because each employment stint lasted only 29 days and there were breaks between stints, the petitioners did not serve continuously for six months and therefore do not fall within sub-rule (5) of rule 8.
  • Under rule 8(2) age relaxation for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes is limited to certain categories of service (class I, II and III); class IV services (to which the petitioners belong) are not included, so age relaxation is not available to them.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the text of rule 8(5) of the Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment (General) Rules, 1967, which provides that the upper age limit shall not apply to a candidate already in Gujarat Government service who was within the age limit at the time of first appointment, provided the candidate has been in government service "officiating continuously for six months" in certain types of vacancies (subject to the proviso relating to competitive recruitment).

The court analysed the State's contention that the petitioners did not serve "continuously" for six months because each appointment was for only 29 days with short intervals between appointments. Although acknowledging that, strictly speaking, the petitioners were not in uninterrupted continuous employment for six months, the court rejected a purely technical interpretation that would permit the State to defeat the protective object of rule 8(5) by repeatedly engaging persons for short intervals.

The court treated repeated re-employments of 29 days each as amounting to continuous service for the purpose of giving "rational and just meaning" to rule 8(5). The court characterised the State's practice of segmenting service into repeated 29-day engagements as a subterfuge to circumvent rule 8(5) and condemned that practice as unfair, particularly because the petitioners were vulnerable class IV employees performing menial duties.

On the point of age relaxation under rule 8(2), the court acknowledged the respondent's submission that rule 8(2) permits relaxation for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes only in respect of class I, II and III services and that class IV servants are excluded. The court observed that exclusion of class IV servants from that relaxation is anomalous and discriminates against the disadvantaged, but it found that this question did not need resolution in the present case because the petitioners were within the age limit when first employed and thus squarely within rule 8(5).

Concluding its analysis, the court found the Director's refusal to allow permanent appointment on the basis that the petitioners had passed the age limit to be a misconceived, hyper-technical position and thus unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed. A writ of certiorari is issued quashing and setting aside the impugned order of the Director of Health and Medical Services (dated in the opinion as 22 February 1984), which had turned down the appointments on the ground that the petitioners had passed the age limit. A writ of mandamus is issued directing the respondents to appoint the petitioners as aayas with effect from 22 February 1984 and to pay their salary from that deemed date of appointment until the date of payment.

The court directed that the respondents pay the petitioners their salary from the date of their deemed appointment (22 February 1984) until the date of payment within four weeks of receipt of the writ, and that the petitioners be employed on their respective posts within one week from receipt of the writs. The writs were ordered to issue immediately; the rule was made absolute and there was no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the petitioners must be appointed permanently and paid arrears as directed. The opinion does not articulate a broader rule of general application beyond this remedy, and it does not set out any separate precedent beyond applying rule 8(5) to the facts; it principally resolves the dispute before the court by treating aggregated short-term service as qualifying for protection under rule 8(5) in these circumstances.

    Mariamban Amirbhai And Others v. State Of Gujarat And Others

    1. The petitioners herein were employed as aayas at Ram Rajendrasinhji Hospital and Baluba Maternity Home, Limbdi, in Surendranagar District. They were employed over a period of two years and more on several, occasions each time for a period of 29 days at a stretch. Petitioner 1 whose date of birth is stated to be 23 November 1951, was employed for the first time as aaya on 2 April 1980, for a period of 29 days. Thereafter, she has been employed on 18 occasions with short intervals, each time the employment being for 29 days. Thus, from 2 April 1980, upto 22 June 1983, she had worked on 19 occasions, each time 29 days making a total of 551 days. Similarly, petitioner 2 was employed as aaya for the first time on 10 June 1981, for a period of 29 days. Thereafter she was employed 12 times for a period of 29 days at a time till 22 June 1983. Similarly, petitioner 3 also was first appointed as aaya on 22 July 1981, for 29 days and was subsequently appointed from time to time on 12 different occasions, each time for 29 days till 24 May 1983. The three petitioners having worked as aayas for more than two years although there were gaps in between and each time the employment was for a period of 29 days, they were sent before the selection board for permanent appointment. The appointing authority in the case of the petitioners is the Civil Surgeon, Limbdi. He selected the petitioners and recommended their permanent appointment as aayas in the said hospital. The Director of Health and Medical Services by his letter, dated 22 May 1984, turned down the recommendation of the Civil Surgeon, Limbdi, on the ground that the petitioners had passed the age limit of 30 years on the date of their permanent appointment. Against the said order of the Director, the present petition is filed.

    2. Sri A.D Padival for Sri P.M Thakker, the learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that although the petitioners were employed for a period of 29 days on each occasion, in fact, they had served for about 2 years with short intervals. Therefore, according to him, the petitioners are entitled to be appointed permanently on the basis of their service for nearly two years. Sri Padival has further argued that it is not in dispute that the petitioners were within the age limit of 30 years when they were first employed on temporary basis for a period of 29 days. He has submitted that as per the Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment (General) Rules, 1967 (hereafter rules), the petitioners are entitled to be employed, on a permanent basis. He relies on rule 8, sub-rule (5), which provides as under:

    “(5) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any rules for the time being in force relating to the recruitment to any service or post, the upper age limit for the purposes of recruitment prescribed in such rules shall not apply to a candidate who is already in Gujarat Government service either as a permanent Government servant or as a temporary Government servant officiating continuously for six months in a substantive or leave vacancy or in a vacancy caused as a result of deputation of other servants and was within the age limit prescribed for the post at the time of his first appointment in Government service. Provided that such upper age limit shall apply to such candidate in a case where recruitment to a post or service is done through competitive examination or by direct selection for which experience has not been prescribed as one of the qualifications for such post.”

    Sri Padival submits that although the petitioners have not continuously worked for a period of six months at a stretch at any time, but considering that they had been employed for 29 days on many occasions when taken together comes to much more than six months. According to him, the State has been resorting to this tactics of employing for a period of 29 days at a time and re-employing for a similar period after a short break, is only with a view to circumvent the provision of the aforesaid sub-rule (5). He, therefore, submits that the petitioners who were within the age limit of 30 years when they were first employed on a temporary basis, now it is not open to the State to say that the petitioners have passed the age limit at the time of their permanent employment. According to Sri Padival, the petitioners were also in the Government service before they had reached the age limit of 30 years and that they have been kept for more than two years on a temporary basis employing for a period of 29 days at a time over a period of more than two years, the question of age limit does not arise for their appointment in permanent service.

    3. Sri B.D Desai, the learned Assistant Government Pleader, has urged that the petitioners having been employed for only 29 days on each occasion, it cannot be said that they have served continuously a period of six months to come within the purview of sub-rule (5) of rule 8 of the aforesaid rules. The contention of Sri Desai must be rejected. The fact that the petitioners have worked for a period of nearly two years although with short intervals and only for 29 days at a stretch, cannot be taken to mean that they have not worked for a period of six months continuously. If they had been given continuous employment it would have been much longer than six months. But by resorting to the subterfuge of employing for 29 days at a stretch, an attempt is made to circumvent the aforesaid provision of the rules. Technically, of course, it may be correct to say that the petitioners have not worked continuously for a period of six months, but this technicality cannot be allowed to perpetrate injustice. The re-employment over and over again although for 29 days at a time, must be regarded as continuous for the purpose of giving rational and just meaning to the aforesaid provision in the rules. Even if a private employer were to resort to this kind of unfair tactics, it would be regarded as bad enough. But the State resorting to these kinds of unfair tactics must be denounced in no uncertain terms. It does not behove the State as an employer to resort to the exploitation of its employees especially those belonging to the lowest stratum, the poor, the ignorant and the weak ones. The petitioners who were working as aayas, i.e, class IV servants doing menial job of leaning the dirt in the hospital. The fact that they have been subjected to this unfair treatment should disturb the conscience of any right thinking person. It is difficult to see how the Director of Health and Medical Services tried to take shelter behind the provisions of the rules when the Civil Surgeon, Limbdi, had recommended their appointment as permanent aayas. The Civil Surgeon, Limbdi, was justified in taking the view that the petitioners were within the age limit when they were first employed on temporary basis. It is surprising that the Director turned down the recommendation of the Civil Surgeon on the flimsy and untenable ground that the petitioners had passed the age limit of 30 years at the time of their permanent appointment and that they could not get the benefit of sub-rule (5) of rule 8 of the rules as they had not put in a continuous service for more than six months. The stand taken by the Director is based on a misconception. He is entirely wrong and hyper-technical in taking the view that the petitioners had not put in a continuous service of six months because they were employed for 29 days at a time and that there were short breaks in between various re-employments, It is hoped that the State as an employer, will not resort to such subterfuge in future.

    4. Sri Desai has also urged that under sub-rule (2) of rule 8, the appointing authority has power to relax the age limit in favour of candidates belonging to the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes only in cases of a service or post in subordinate service or of a State service where the age limit does not exceed 40 years, it may be relaxed up to five years. Sri Desai points out that under rule 4, sub-rule (1), the service and post of class I and II are known as State services. Under sub-rule (2) services and posts in class III are known as subordinate services, and under sub-rule (3) the services and posts in class IV are called inferior services. According to Sri Desai, there can be age relaxation under rule 8(2)(a) only in respect of class I, II and III only but not in respect of class IV service, who are not included in the said clause. He, therefore, submits that the petitioners being class IV employees, there cannot be any age relaxation although petitioner 1 belongs to the backward class and petitioners 2 and 3 belong to scheduled castes. It is really difficult to understand how and on what basis class IV servants are excluded from the benefit of the rule regarding relaxation of age limit. If the servants in class I, II and III can get benefit of age relaxation, there can be no rational why class IV should be excluded from it. The purpose of age relaxation in the case of scheduled castes and scheduled tribes is quite obvious. They being the unfortunate section of the community, they cannot compete with others on equal basis and, therefore, the age relaxation in their cases is justifiable. But to achieve that object, only class I, II and III should be given the benefit of age relaxation and class IV should be excluded from it, is patently discriminatory and violative of the petitioners' fundamental right to equality under Art. 14 of the Constitution of India. It is hoped that the Government will apply its mind to this aspect of the matter and remove this anomaly. In this case, however, the application of this particular rule of relaxation beyond 40 years' age limit does not arise because the petitioners were within the age limit when they were employed on a temporary basis. Therefore, they are entitled to the benefit of rule 8(5) as stated above.

    5. In the result, the petition is allowed. A writ of certiorari shall issue quashing and setting aside the impugned order, dated 22 February 1984, of the Director of Health and Medical Services, turning down the appointments of the present petitioners on the ground that they had passed the age limit on the date of their permanent appointment. A writ of mandamus shall also issue directing the respondents to appoint the petitioners at aayas in the aforesaid hospital with effect from 22 February 1984. The respondents are further directed to pay the petitioners their salary from the date of their deemed appointment on 22 February 1984, till today within a period of four weeks from the date on which the writ is received. The petitioners shall be employed on their respective posts within a week from the date of receipt of writs. Writs to issue immediately. Rule made absolute. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mariamban Amirbhai And Others v. State Of Gujarat And Others
    (Dec 6, 1984)