AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, Sri Badan Chandra Borkotoki, an employee of the petitioner/appellant's Tea Estate, suffered an accident on 15.3.86 at the petitioner/appellant’s factory, resulting in a fractured left patella which was subsequently removed. The respondent filed a claim before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner registered as Case No. 12/89-90. The Additional Deputy Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation Commission, Golaghat, ordered compensation to be paid to the claimant from the date of his forced retirement until he attained the age of 58 years, and also directed medical leave for the period of treatment as per rules. The petitioner/appellant challenged this order through Civil Rule No. 3832 of 1991, which was dismissed by the learned single Judge on 28.1.94. The present appeal challenges that dismissal and the underlying order of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Civil Rule could be dismissed solely on the ground of availability of an alternative statutory remedy under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  2. Whether the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation had jurisdiction to adjudicate on matters relating to the workman's retirement and entitlement to medical leave beyond the scope of compensation for injury under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  3. Whether the impugned order dated 25.3.91 by the Additional Deputy Commissioner was passed without jurisdiction and thus liable to be set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Additional Deputy Commissioner exceeded jurisdiction under the Workmen's Compensation Act by adjudicating on retirement and medical leave, which were beyond the scope of compensation determination.
  • The Civil Rule should not have been dismissed on the basis of an alternative statutory remedy, as the claim involved no factual disputes and required adjudication on jurisdictional grounds.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioner/appellant had an alternative remedy of appeal under the Workmen's Compensation Act, which was available and should have been pursued.
  • The order passed by the Additional Deputy Commissioner was justified on merit and correctly upheld by the learned single Judge.
  • The workman-respondent had retired and received compensation amounting to Rs. 96,670.00 as per the order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram and Shyam Company v. State of Haryana ((1985) 3 SCC 267 : AIR 1985 SC 1147) When there is an absolute lack of jurisdiction in passing an order, the existence of an alternative remedy does not bar the court from exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the Civil Rule could not be dismissed merely because an alternative statutory remedy was available, especially where there was a question of jurisdictional excess by the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the procedural issue of whether the Civil Rule could be dismissed due to the availability of an alternative remedy under the Workmen's Compensation Act. It concluded that since the Civil Rule was admitted and no factual disputes were involved, dismissal on that ground was improper. The Court cited the Supreme Court precedent in Ram and Shyam Company v. State of Haryana to emphasize that lack of jurisdiction overrides the availability of alternative remedies.

On the substantive question, the Court examined the scope of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner's jurisdiction under the Act, which is limited to determining compensation for personal injury caused by an accident arising out of and in the course of employment. The Court found that adjudication on the workman’s retirement and entitlement to medical leave exceeded this jurisdiction. Consequently, the impugned order dated 25.3.91 was held to be without jurisdiction and liable to be set aside.

The Court directed that the compensation claim be re-adjudicated strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, and relevant rules, focusing solely on the quantification of compensation related to the workman’s injury and loss of working capacity arising out of employment.

Given the claim was filed in 1989, the Court emphasized the need for expeditious adjudication within three months from the production of the certified copy of the present order.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The orders of the learned single Judge dated 28.1.94 and the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation dated 25.3.91 are set aside.

The case is remanded to the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner for fresh adjudication limited to the determination of compensation under the statutory scheme. The parties are directed to bear their own costs.

No new precedent is established; the decision primarily clarifies the limits of jurisdiction of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner and the proper procedural approach when jurisdictional excess is alleged.

    Manager, Borsapori Tea Estate v. Addl. Deputy Commissioner Golaghat And Anr.

    V.K Khanna, C.J:— The present appeal has been filed against the judgment of the learned single Judge dated 28.1.94 dismissing the Civil Rule No. 3832 of 1991 filed by the petitioner/appellant challenging the order of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner in Case No. 12/89-90.

    2. We have heard Mr. PG Baruah, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/appellant and Mr. DP Chaliha, learned counsel appearing for the contesting respondent. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, the present appeal is being finally disposed of.

    3. The brief facts for adjudicating the present appeal are that the respondent-2 Sri Badan chandra Borkotoki who was admittedly an employee of the petitioner/appellant's Tea Estate met with an accident while working in the factory of the petitioner/appellant on 15.3.86 and fractured his left patella which was removed subsequently. A claim was raised by the aforesaid respondent before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner which was registered as Workmen's Compensation Case No. 12/89-90. The Addl. Deputy Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation Commission, Golaghat gave the following relief on the claim made by the respondent-workman.

    “It is, therefore, ordered that the claimant be paid by the opposite party, the full average pay from the date of his forced retirement i.e 1.12.86 till he attains the age of 58 years as compensation forthwith. The period of his treatment should be regularised by granting medical leave for prolong treatment of his injury arising out of the accident under sick benefit scheme and medical leave be paid for the period as per rules.”

    4. The learned single Judge has negatived the claim of the petitioner/appellant on the ground that it has an alternative remedy for filing statutory appeal under the Workmen's Compensation Act, and that there is no illegality and/or infirmity in the order/award given by the Addl. Deputy Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation Commission, Golaghat dated 25.3.91 and therefore no interference is called for from this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    5. Mr. Barua, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/appellant urged before us that the Addl. Deputy Commissioner under the impugned order dated 25.3.91 had exceeded the jurisdiction conferred under the Workmen's Compensation Act inasmuch as he could only adjudicate the question as to what amount the claimant workman was entitled to because of the accident in accordance with the prescribed Schedule and could not have adjudicated on the questions of retirement and whether the workman was entitled to medical leave or not.

    6. Mr. DP Chaliha, Counsel appearing for the workman-respondent has however urged that the petitioner/appellant could file appeal under the Workmen's Compensation Act and the learned single Judge has rightly dismissed the Civil Rule. It has also been urged that the order passed by the Addl. Deputy Commissioner on 25.3.91 was passed on merit and is justified. In this connection, it maybe noted that Mr. Barua, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/appellant has stated before us that the workman-respondent has retired from the Company's service and has received an amount of Rs. 96,670.00.

    7. The first question which arises for consideration before us is as to whether the Civil Rule, after the order having been passed by the learned single Judge, could be dismissed on the ground of availability of an alternative statutory remedy.

    8. After careful consideration of the point raised by the learned counsel for the parties, we are of the opinion that the Civil Rule could not be dismissed for that reason. Firstly, the Civil Rule having been admitted, the same has to be adjudicated on merits and could not be dismissed on the ground of availability of an alternative remedy, specially as no questions of facts are involved for deciding the question raised in the Civil Rule. Secondly, as held by the Apex Court in case of Ram and Shyam Company v. Stale of Haryana ((1985) 3 SCC 267 : AIR 1985 SC 1147), when there is absolute lake of jurisdiction in passing the order, the existence of alternative remedy will not debar the court in exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.

    9. It has now to be seen whether there was absolute lack of jurisdiction when the impugned order was passed. A claim under the Workmen's Compensation Act can be made for recovery from the employer, the liability of compensation which has been set out in section 3 of the aforesaid Act, i.e, if personal injury is caused to a workman by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, his employer shall be liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Act. The jurisdiction of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner, therefore, is limited only to that extent. The adjudication by the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner on the questions as to whether the workman had been properly retired or not and whether medical leave should have been granted to him, are outside the jurisdiction of the Commissioner under the Workmen's Compensation Act. We are of the opinion that the impugned award given by the Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation Act dated 25.3.91 is liable to be set aside on the ground of lack of jurisdiction to pass such an order.

    10. We are, however, of the opinion that the claim of the petitioner/appellant be adjudicated again by the concerned Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 and the rules framed thereunder. He would determine the amount of compensation for the loss of his working capacity caused by the accident and whether it arose in the course of employment of workman-respondent.

    9. As the claim by the workman was filed in the year 1989, the interest of justice requires that the concerned Workmen's Compensation Commissioner shall now adjudicate the claim as laid down by the Court within three months from the date of production of the certified copy of this order by the workman-respondent.

    10. Subject to the aforesaid observations, the present appeal is allowed and the order of the learned single Judge dated 28.1.94 and the order of the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation, Golaghat dated 25.3.91 are set aside.

    However, looking to the entire facts and circumstances of the case, the parties shall bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Manager, Borsapori Tea Estate v. Addl. Deputy Commissioner Golaghat And Anr.
    (Jan 5, 1995)