AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 147/148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.The
  • section 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 147/148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.The
  • section 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an income tax assessee engaged in the tourism and travel business, challenged a notice dated 4.7.2011 issued by the revenue under sections 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act seeking to reopen the assessment for the assessment year 2006-07. The Assessing Officer (AO) issued the reassessment notice on the basis that certain expenses incurred abroad were not disclosed by the assessee, and thus the reassessment was initiated to verify these expenses. Earlier, the petitioner had filed a writ petition against a previous reassessment notice dated 17.2.2010 for the same assessment year. That earlier notice was quashed by the Court on the ground that the reasons for reopening must stand on their own and not be substantiated by new or different grounds. The Court allowed the AO liberty to record fresh reasons for reopening in accordance with law. The current reassessment notice was issued on similar grounds as the previous one, prompting the petitioner to challenge it again.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reassessment notice dated 4.7.2011 issued under sections 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act is legally justified and based on tangible material to justify reopening the assessment for AY 2006-07.
  2. Whether the reasons recorded by the AO for reopening the assessment amount to a mere change of opinion, which is impermissible under the law as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Commissioner Of Income Tax, Delhi v. Kelvinator Of India Limited.
  3. Whether the reassessment can be legitimately initiated merely to verify the genuineness of expenses incurred abroad without concrete evidence of escapement of income.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The impugned reassessment notice is on the same lines as the previously quashed notice and lacks fresh or tangible material to justify reopening.
  • The AO's opinion that expenses booked outside India were excluded from gross receipts is not supported by new evidence.
  • Reopening the assessment merely to verify the genuineness of expenses amounts to an impermissible fishing enquiry.

Respondent/Revenue's Arguments

  • The reassessment notice is justified as liberty was granted by the Court in the previous order to reopen the assessment on fresh reasons recorded in accordance with law.
  • The reassessment is necessary to verify the expenses incurred abroad which were not disclosed in detail by the assessee.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner Of Income Tax, Delhi v. Kelvinator Of India Limited (2010) 2 SCC 723 Interpretation of "reasons to believe" under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act; prohibition against reopening assessments based on mere change of opinion; distinction between power to review and power to reassess. The Court applied this precedent to hold that the AO's reasons for reopening must be based on tangible material and not on a mere change of opinion. The impugned reassessment notice was quashed as it relied on similar grounds as the previously invalidated notice without new material.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the reasons recorded by the AO for reopening the assessment and found that they did not disclose any new tangible material justifying reassessment. The grounds cited were essentially a reiteration of previous reasons already considered and rejected by the Court in earlier proceedings. The Court emphasized the principle from Kelvinator Of India Ltd. that the expression "reasons to believe" cannot be satisfied by a mere change of opinion, as that would convert reassessment into an impermissible review. The Court noted that the AO's assumption that expenses incurred abroad were excluded from gross receipts was known at the time of the original assessment and had been accounted for. The Court held that reopening the assessment merely to verify the genuineness of these expenses without evidence of income escapement constitutes an impermissible fishing enquiry. Consequently, the reassessment notice was found to be beyond the AO's authority and without legal justification.

Holding and Implications

The Court quashed the impugned reassessment notice dated 4.7.2011 and allowed the writ petition.

The direct effect of this decision is that the reassessment proceedings based on the impugned notice are invalid and cannot proceed. The Court did not establish any new precedent but reaffirmed the legal principle that reopening of assessments must be grounded in tangible material and not mere change of opinion or fishing enquiries. The ruling limits the scope of reassessment notices under sections 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act to cases where concrete evidence of escapement of income exists.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Le Passage To India Tours & Travels Pvt. Ltd. Petitioner v. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax

    S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.: (OPEN COURT)

    CM 19191/2012

    Exemption is allowed subject to all just exceptions.

    The application is disposed of.

    W.P(C) 7550/2012 & CM 19190/2012

    1. The petitioner, an income tax assessee challenges a notice dated 4.7.2011 issued by the respondent/revenue (hereinafter referred to as “revenue”) in exercise of its powers under section 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act seeking to reopen the assessment for the assessment year 2006-07.

    2. The assessee is in the tourism and travel business. By the impugned reassessment notice, the AO was of the opinion that based upon the materials on the record, certain expenses incurred abroad were not disclosed. He therefore sought to use the reassessment proceedings to verify the expenses and thereafter frame a re-assessment. The material portion of the reassessment notice dated 4.7.2011 to the extent it is relevant is extracted below.

    “1. Assessment in this case was completed under section 143(3) on 26.12.2008 at an income of Rs. 8,55,51,563/- as against the returned income of Rs. 8,55,11,040/-. Further, the case was reopened u/s 147 and assessment u/s 147/143(3) was completed at Rs. 1,22,84,55,005/-. Scrutiny of income tax assessment records revealed that as per the submissions of the assessee during the course of reassessment proceedings the assessee had earnings of Rs. 1,31,10,67,825/- and the assessee offered income from services in P&L A/c at Rs. 21,03,01,532/-. Accordingly, being not satisfied with the submissions of the assessee the Assessing officer made a disallowance of Rs. 114,29,03,442/- the assessee filed writ petition against the said order before the Hon'ble High Court and the Hon'ble High Court quest the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer and also has held that the reasons for reopening have to stand on their legs and cannot be substantiate for reasons and grounds which are not mentioned therein. The Hon'ble Court further commented that we will only state that this order does not and will not operate as a bar or prohibition. It is opened to the Assessing Officer to record reasons and re-open assessment for the A.Y.2006-07 in accordance with law. In view of the above, the following reasons recorded to re-open the assessment for A.Y.2006-07. The assessee at the time of re-assessment proceedings only submitted that the income has been offered on the basis of netting. All the expenses booked outside India were excluded from the gross receipts. The assessee never offered details of the expenses where and to whom payments were made outside India. In the absence of any evidence on records, it is necessary to reopen the assessment for verification of expenses incurred outside India amounting to Rs. 114,29,03,442/-. For the verification of genuineness of the expenses, it is extremely necessary to initiate proceedings u/s 148 in the instant case.

    2. In view of the above, I have reasons to believe that the income of Rs. 114,29,03,442/- chargeable to tax has escaped assessment within the meaning of section 147/148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.”

    The petitioner had approached this Court earlier by filing writ petition 8685/2010 in respect of the earlier reassessment notice for the same assessment year, dated 17.2.2010 In that instance, the AO after considering the notes to accounts filed during the original assessment proceedings, prima facie felt that the assessee had earned Rs. 129 crores in foreign currency on approval basis from sale and service but disclosed only Rs. 21.03 lakhs in the profit and loss account under the head “services”. The Court in those writ proceedings was of the opinion that since all the materials were on the record, on an appropriate application of the Supreme Court's ruling in Commissioner Of Income Tax, Delhi v. Kelvinator Of India Limited(2010) 2 SCC 723, the earlier reassessment notice was not justified. The court accordingly quashed the reassessment notice. At the same time the Court observed that the order would not operate as a bar or prohibition and fresh reasons for the reopening assessment for 2006-07 may be recorded in accordance with law.

    3. It is submitted that the present impugned reassessment notice dated 4.7.2011 is on the same lines which led the Court to quash the previous one. It is urged that there is no fresh or tangible material to trigger a legally justified reassessment proceedings in the circumstances of this case. In the previous instance the AO was of the opinion that income to the tune of Rs. 121 crore had not been offered though what was shown in P & L account was Rs. 129 crores. In the present case similarly the AO has expressed the opinion that reassessment proceedings are called for on the assumption that all expenses booked outside India were excluded from the gross receipts. The revenue has filed its counter affidavit urging that the impugned notice in this case does not call for interference and that since liberty was given in the previous order, the reopening of assessment was justified.

    4. In Kelvinator of India Ltd. (supra) the Supreme Court stated that the expression “reasons to believe” cannot comprehend a mere change of opinion which would only amount to an impermissible review. The Court held that-

    “…..Therefore, post-1-4-1989, power to re-open is much wider. However, one needs to give a schematic interpretation to the words “reason to believe” failing which, we are afraid, Section 147 would give arbitrary powers to the Assessing Officer to re-open assessments on the basis of “mere change of opinion” which cannot be per se reason to re-open.

    6. We must also keep in mind the conceptual difference between power to review and power to re-assess. The Assessing Officer has no power to review; he has the power to re-assess. But re-assessment has to be based on fulfillment of certain pre-condition and if the concept of “change of opinion” is removed, as contended on behalf of the Department, then, in the garb of re-opening the assessment, review would take place.”

    5. In the present case the “reasons to believe” - extracted above - nowhere reveal as to what tangible material which the AO came to obtain to justify the reassessment notice. In the previous instance, the reassessment notice was based on the assumption that a much larger income had accrued to the assessee whereas only a fraction of its was offered in the P & L account. In the present case, a somewhat similar, if not identical, ground has been made out i.e that of expenses incurred abroad have not been revealed. This was an aspect which was known to the AO at the time of the original assessment; the explanations by the assessee appear to have been taken into account. At the time when the first reassessment notice was issued a facet of this was taken into consideration and in fact cited in the “reasons to believe”. A virtual assertion of the same reasons in different words does not clothe the reassessment notice, in the opinion of the Court, with any more sanctity, nor does it take away the vice of lack of jurisdiction noticed in the order in WP 8685/2010. Moreover, an assessment cannot be reopened merely to verify the genuineness of the expenses as that would amount to an impermissible fishing or rowing enquiry without any tangible material to show escapement of income.

    For the above reasons it is held that the impugned notice is not justified and beyond the authority of law. It is accordingly quashed and the writ petition is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Le Passage To India Tours & Travels Pvt. Ltd. Petitioner v. Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax
    (Apr 16, 2014)