VIBHU BAKHRU, J
1. This is an application filed by the applicant seeking recall of the
order dated 07.11.2012 passed by this Court whereby the Ex-Directors of
the respondent company, (in liquidation), Mr Deepak Kumar Jain and the
applicant, were directed to deposit a sum of `9.23 lacs in two equal
proportions in the office of the Official Liquidator. This direction was
passed pursuant to a report (report no.650/2012) submitted by the Official
Liquidator. This Court concluded that the Official Liquidator had been
unable to recover a sum of `9.23 lacs shown as receivable in the books of
the company because the Ex-Directors had failed and neglected to provide
the requisite information.
2. The applicant being aggrieved by the order dated 07.11.2012 had
preferred an appeal being Company Appeal No.4/2013 before a Division
Bench of this court. The said appeal was disposed of by the Division Bench
by an order dated 23.01.2013 whereby the Division Bench had permitted
the applicant to file an application to take all contentions and raise all issues
with respect to the liability of the applicant to compensate the company for
its receivables which could not be recovered. The Division Bench further
clarified that the order dated 07.11.2012 would not come in the way of this
Court deciding all the issues and contentions on merits. The learned counsel
for the parties have submitted that in view of the order dated 23.01.2013
passed by the Division Bench, the question whether the applicant could be
held liable for paying the amount as directed, has to be decided afresh.
3. The principal controversy in the present application relates to the
question whether the ex-directors of a company in liquidation can be held
accountable for the receivables of the company that can't be recovered by
the Official Liquidator for want of requisite information and the complete
records of the company. The other controversy that needs to be considered
is whether the applicant was a director of the company at the relevant date
as defined in Section 454(8) of the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter
referred to as the „Act‟).
4. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that Millennium
Heath Institute and Diagnostics Pvt. Ltd. (i.e. the company in liquidation)
had four Directors out of which two Directors were in charge of the day-to-
day affairs of the company. He contended that the action of the Official
Liquidator in fixing the liability for making good the receivable only upon
two Ex-Directors of the company is wholly arbitrary and amounts to the
Official Liquidator picking and choosing the Directors against whom the
Official Liquidator wishes to proceed. It was further contended that the
pleadings in the winding up petition indicated that Mr Sugani was in charge
of the affairs of the company and also received remuneration from the
company. However, no liability had been fixed on Mr Sugani and the
applicant who is stated to be non executive director has been mulcted with
the liability to compensate the company.
5. Secondly, it was contended that no allegation of malfeasance and
misfeasance had been made by the Official Liquidator against the applicant.
And, in absence of any allegation that the applicant had siphoned of funds
of the company or was guilty of misconducting the affairs of the company
no liability for any amount due to the company or any loss caused to the
company could be fastened on the ex Directors. In support of his
contention the learned counsel placed reliance on the decision of this Court
in Ashoka Auto and General Industries Private Limited v. Inder Mohan
Puri & Ors.: (2005) 124 Comp Cas 422 (Delhi).
6. It was further contended by the applicant that he was never involved
in managing the day-to-day affairs of the company. It was submitted that
the applicant was a non executive director and had resigned from the
company on 31.03.2008. He stated that a distinction is required to be made
between Directors who are incharge of the day to day affairs of the
Company and Directors who hold non executive positions for the purposes
of determining whether any liability for misconducting the affairs of the
company is to be imposed on them. In support of his contention the learned
counsel for the appellant relied upon the decision of the Division Bench of
Kerala High Court in K. Subramony v. Official Liquidator, Malabar Phyto
Chemicals Ltd. (in liquidation): 2010 (157) Comp. Cas. 61 (Ker.) and the
decision of the Allahabad High Court in Vijai Laxmi Sugar Mills Ltd. (in
liquidation), Official Liquidator v. Mathura Prasad and Ors.: AIR 1963
Allahabad 55. The learned counsel further submitted that as the applicant
was not incharge of the day-to-day affairs of the company, the applicant
could not be held to be liable to compensate the company for the loss
caused to the company on account of lack of documents/records. It was
further submitted that since the applicant had resigned on 31.03.2008, the
applicant did not have any control over the assets or the books of accounts
of the company. He submitted that in order to fasten a liability on an ex-
director it must be shown that the director was in possession or in control of
any assets of the company and had failed to surrender the same to the
Official Liquidator.
7. The learned counsel for the Official Liquidator, at the outset,
submitted that the prayers made in the status report (report no.650/2012)
were not directed against the applicant alone but against all Ex-Directors
including Mr Sugani. He submitted that although the company had four
Directors, this Court had found that Shri Jagjivan Kumar Jain had resigned
much earlier and, therefore, was not concerned with the present
proceedings. The remaining three Directors were thus liable to compensate
the company on account of the failure on the part of the Directors to
provide all requisite information. He submitted that it was not necessary to
allege or prove that the Ex-Directors were guilty of malfeasance and
misfeasance in order to fasten the liability for the loss suffered by the
company on account of non submission of requisite information. He
further submitted that the statement of the applicant that he had resigned
from the company could not be accepted at the threshold and the applicant
would be required to prove the same in a trial for offence under Section 454
of the Act. In support of his contention, the learned counsel for the Official
Liquidator relied on the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in
Official Liquidator, Suganti Alloys Castings Limited v. Edupuganti
Subba Rao: [2006] 72 SCL 201 (AP). The learned counsel also relied
upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Official Liquidator,
Supreme Bank Ltd. v. P.A. Tendolkar & Ors.: (1973) 1 SCC 602 and P.K.
Nedungadi v. The Malayalee Bank Ltd. (In Liquidation) and Ors.: (1971)
3 SCC 598.
8. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. At the outset, it must
be noted that there is no dispute that the Statement of Affairs filed with the
Official Liquidator is incomplete. The requisite documents and accounts
that were necessary for recovering the debts due to the company have not
been furnished to the Official Liquidator. It is also not disputed that on
account of inadequate information and the requisite documents, there is no
possibility to recover certain debts of the company. The controversy that
needs to be addressed is whether in such circumstances, the Ex-Directors
could be called upon to compensate the company even though there is no
allegation of misappropriation or mala fide on their part. There is also no
allegation that the Directors have gained in any manner by not providing
the necessary documents to the Official Liquidator.
9. The principal question to be addressed is whether it is necessary to
allege and prove misfeasance on the part of an Ex-director of a company in
order to make the concerned director liable for the loss suffered by the
company on account of its inability to recover the debts from its debtors
due to inadequate information. The other question that needs to be
considered is whether the applicant had resigned from the company prior to
the appointment of the provisional liquidator and, if so, whether he could be
held liable for not providing the requisite details to the Official Liquidator.
10. In the present case, the learned counsel for the Official Liquidator
has sought to justify the claim for compensation on the basis of Section 543
of the Act. Section 543 of the Act being relevant is quoted below:-
"543. - Power of Tribunal to assess damages against
delinquent directors, etc. - (1) If in the course of winding up
of a company, it appears that any person who has taken part in
the promotion or formation of the company, or any past or
present director, manager, liquidator or officer of the company-
(a) has misapplied, or retained, or become liable or
accountable for, any money or property of the
company; or
(b) has been guilty of any misfeasance or breach of trust in
relation to the company,
the Tribunal may, on the application of the Official Liquidator,
or the liquidator, or of any creditor or contributory, made within
the time specified in that behalf in sub-section (2), examine into
the conduct of the person, director, manager, liquidator or
officer aforesaid, and compel him to repay or restore the money
or property or any part thereof respectively, with interest at
such rate as the Tribunal thinks just, or to contribute such sum
to the assets of the company by way of compensation in respect
of the misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust,
as the Tribunal thinks just.
(2) An application under sub-section (1) shall be made within
five years from the date of the order for winding up, or of the
first appointment of the liquidator in the winding up, or of the
misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust as the
case may be, whichever is longer.
(3) This section shall apply notwithstanding that the matter is
one for which the person concerned may be criminally liable."
11. A plain reading of sub-section (1) of Section 543 of the Act indicates
that the provision has two limbs. The first limb would be applicable where
a past or present Director, Manager, Liquidator or any officer of the
company (hereinafter referred to as the „specified person‟) has misapplied
or retained or has become liable or accountable for any money or asset of
the company. The second limb would be applicable if the specified person
is guilty of misfeasance or breach of trust in relation to the company. It is
apparent that in order to invoke the first limb of Section 543(1), it would be
essential to come to a conclusion that the specified person has misapplied
or retained any asset or has become liable or accountable for any money or
property of the company. In the present case, there is no allegation that the
funds of the company in liquidation have been misapplied or retained by
the applicant. The only ground on which a claim of compensation has been
made is that the applicant is guilty of misfeasance or breach of trust in
relation to the company in liquidation.
12. In order to sustain the present claim against the applicant, it would be
essential to show that the applicant was guilty of misfeasance or breach of
trust. The examination of the conduct of the applicant must indicate that the
applicant has committed a breach of his duty and as a result thereof, a loss
has been caused to the company.
13. It is well settled that a charge of misfeasance or a breach of fiduciary
duty is a serious charge and may result in a personal liability. The nature of
the said liability has been explained by the Supreme Court in Official
Liquidator v. Parthasarathi Sinha: (1983) 1 SCC 538 as under:-
"18. The liability arising under the misfeasance proceedings is
founded on the principle that a person who has caused loss to the
company by an act amounting to breach of trust should make
good of the loss. Section 543 of the Act does not really create
any new liability. It only provides for a summary remedy for
determining the amount payable by such person on proof of the
necessary ingredients. The section authorises the court to direct
such persons chargeable under it to pay a sum of money to the
company by way of compensation. ...."
14. It necessarily follows that the charge/allegation would have to be
specifically pleaded in order that the person accused of the same has due
opportunity to meet the accusation. The Supreme Court in its decision in
Official Liquidator v. Raghawa Desikachar: (1974) 2 SCC 741, expressed
this view as under:
"7. ..... It may be mentioned that misfeasance action against the
Directors is a serious charge. It is a charge of misconduct or
misappropriation or breach of trust. For this reason the
application should contain a detailed narration of the specific
acts of commission and omission on the part of each Director
quantifying the loss to the Company arising out of such acts or
omissions. ....."
15. This Court has in the case of Security and Finance Pvt. Ltd. v. B.K.
Bedi: (1991) 71 Comp Cas 101 (Del.) articulated the settled position in
law as under :-
"Under Section 543 of the Act, the court is vested with
jurisdiction to examine the conduct of the past or present
director, manager, liquidator or any other officer of the
company to find out whether he has misapplied or retained or
become liable or accountable for any money or property of the
company; or he has been guilty of any misfeasance or breach of
trust in relation to the company and, where any such conduct is
found attributed to any such person, then, to compel him to
repay and restore the money or property, or any part thereof to
the company. In other words, under this section, the court is to
examine the conduct of an individual director or officer and to
pass an order against him, if such a person is personally found
to be liable for misapplication, etc., of the money or property of
the company or, otherwise, is guilty of any misfeasance or
breach of trust in relation to the company. It is thus clear that, to
enable the court to examine the conduct of an individual
director or officer and to pass an effective order to make him
personally liable for misapplication, etc., of the money or the
property of the company, there has to be positive and specific
evidence and pleadings in respect of the individual director of
an act of the nature contemplated by the section. In the absence
of such specific allegations and positive evidence, it is not
possible or proper for the court to indulge in a fishing or roving
enquiry so as to compel the individual director to reimburse
and/or compensate the company. The principles with regard to
the pleadings and proof are well-settled. There cannot be a
general and roving enquiry into the conduct of a person sought
to be made liable."
The above quoted passage from the decision in Security and Finance Pvt.
Ltd. (supra) has also been followed in the later decision of this Court in
Ashoka Auto & General (supra) and has also been reaffirmed by the
Andhra Pradesh High Court in Official Liquidator v. T.J. Swamy and Ors.:
(1996) 86 Comp Cas 696 (AP).
16. In the present case, the claim for compensation is premised on a
breach of the obligation to furnish a complete and accurate Statement of
Affairs and providing the necessary documents, required for recovering the
money due to the company in liquidation, to the Official Liquidator. The
learned counsel for the Official Liquidator has rightly submitted that in
such circumstances the application for claiming compensation could be
sustained by establishing that: (a) The documents/information provided to
the Official Liquidator were insufficient to effect recovery of the amounts
due to the company; (b) That the company had suffered a loss on account of
its inability to pursue its claims for recovery; and (c) the person from whom
compensation is claimed was under a duty to provide the
documents/information to the Official Liquidator.
17. It has been pointed out in the report (no. 650/2012) that the Official
Liquidator has been unable to recover the amount due to the company for
want of sufficient documents and information. It is alleged that the ex-
directors of the company have failed in their obligation to furnish a
complete Statement of Affairs and provide the necessary documents. The
applicant is also named one of the ex-directors.
18. A Director is placed in a fiduciary position to that of a company and,
therefore, it is the duty of a Director to ensure that the assets of the
company are preserved and protected. It is the duty of a Director to ensure
that the affairs of the company are conducted in a manner so as to comply
with all laws and for the benefit of the company. Indisputably, the
Directors of the company would be liable if the records of the company are
not maintained as required by law or that the relevant books and papers of
the company are not preserved. Thus, in certain circumstances, where loss
is caused to the company on account of not maintaining proper records or
where the Directors have failed to take appropriate steps for preserving and
recovering the assets of the company, the Directors of that company would
be liable. This is so because the Directors have the power to manage the
affairs of the company and coupled with this power is a duty to ensure that
the affairs of the company are properly managed. In such circumstances, it
would not be necessary to impute any malintent or make any specific
allegation against a particular Director and it would be sufficient if it was
established that proper records of the company were not maintained or that
the Directors of the company, who were incharge of its affairs, did not take
the necessary steps to preserve and recover the assets of the company. In
the case of Official Liquidator, Supreme Bank Ltd. (supra), the Supreme
Court held that even if no specific act of dishonesty was proved against a
Director personally, the Court could nonetheless hold a Director to be liable
for misfeasance if he was found to be closely associated with the
management of the company. In these circumstances, the Director would be
deemed to be cognizant of the entire affairs of the company and would thus
also be liable to compensate the company for any fraud that may have been
committed in the conduct of the affairs of the company even though their
specific knowledge of the fraud could not be proved. The Supreme Court
further held that it was not necessary for a Director to have participated in
commission of a fraud, it was enough if it could be shown that the Director
was negligent which enabled the fraud to be committed. The Directors of a
company are placed in a position of trust thus, it is not necessary to show
that the Directors themselves have participated in pilfering or secreting the
assets of a company, it would be sufficient to point out that the affairs of
the company have been carried on negligently which made it possible for
the assets to be pilfered or misappropriated. The Directors, by virtue of
their position, would have to accept the liability for the conduct of affairs of
the company. In the case of Official Liquidator, Suganti Alloys Castings
Limited (supra), the Andhra Pradesh High Court held the Directors were
liable to compensate a company on account of certain receivables of the
company that had become time barred. The rationale being that it was the
duty of the Directors to ensure that steps are taken for recovery of the debts
due to the company. The failure to initiate appropriate steps for recovery of
debts was found to be sufficient to hold the Directors liable to compensate
the company.
19. Given the allegations in the present case, it is not necessary that any
separate and specific allegation be made against the applicant since the
liability is sought to be imposed on the applicant on account of his being a
Director of the company at the relevant time.
20. If the report of the Official Liquidator is viewed in the above
perspective, it is apparent that it does contain the necessary allegations on
the basis of which a claim of compensation can be based. Thus, the
requirement that an application under section 543 of the Act must contain
specific allegations on which the claim is based, is duly met.
21. The next step is to examine whether the allegations made in the
report are established. It is not in dispute that full particulars have not been
provided to the Official Liquidator and, consequently, it has not been
possible for the Official Liquidator to recover the amounts due to the
company. The only other aspect that needs to be considered is whether the
applicant was under a duty to ensure that all records of the company are
handed over to the Official Liquidator and the Statement of Affairs
containing all the necessary particulars are handed over to the Official
Liquidator.
22. The applicant has disputed the contention that he had any obligation
to ensure that the records of the company are handed over to the Official
Liquidation, on the ground that he had ceased to be a Director much prior
to the Official Liquidator being appointed as a Provisional Liquidator. The
applicant has also submitted that, he did not have the necessary details or
records in his possession to submit a Statement of Affairs which was
complete in all respects.
23. It is contended by the applicant that, by a letter dated 01.04.2008, the
applicant had tendered his resignation as a Director of the respondent
company and also sent a copy to the Registrar of Companies. The present
Company Petition was filed on 13.08.2007. This court, by an order dated
02.04.08, directed the company to file a reply stating the names of its
directors. In terms of the directions the company filed a reply on
26.07.2008, wherein the applicant was indicated as a director of the
company. However, the reply also specified that the applicant had tendered
his resignation as a Director of the company which had not been accepted.
The present petition was admitted and Official Liquidator was appointed as
a Provisional Liquidator by an order dated 15.01.2010.
24. Section 454 of the Companies Act, 1956 enjoins all persons who are
Directors on the relevant date to file a statement of affairs. The relevant
provisions of Section 454 of the Act are quoted below:-
"454. Statement of affairs to be made to Official
Liquidator- (1) Where the Tribunal has made a winding up
order or appointed the Official Liquidator as provisional
liquidator, unless the Tribunal in its discretion otherwise orders,
there shall be made out and submitted to the Official Liquidator
a statement as to the affairs of the company in the prescribed
form, verified by an affidavit, and containing the following
particulars, namely : -
(a) the assets of the company, stating separately the cash
balance in hand and at the bank, if any, and negotiable
securities, if any, held by the company;
(b) its debts and liabilities;
(c) the names, residences and occupations of its creditors,
stating separately the amount of secured and
unsecured debts; and in the case of secured debts,
particulars of the securities given, whether by the
company or an officer thereof, their value and the dates
on which they were given ;
(d) the debts due to the company and the names, residences
and occupations of the persons from whom they are due
and the amount likely to be realised on account thereof ;
(e) such further or other information as may be prescribed,
or as the Official Liquidator may require.
(2) The statement shall be submitted and verified by one or
more of the persons who are at the relevant date the directors
and by the person who is at that date the manager, secretary or
other chief officer of the company, or by such of the persons
hereinafter in this sub-section mentioned, as the Official
Liquidator, subject to the direction of the Tribunal, may require
to submit and verify the statement, that is to say, persons-
(a) who are or have been officers of the company;
(b) who have taken part in the formation of the company at
any time within one year before the relevant date;
(c) who are in the employment of the company, or have
been in the employment of the company within the said
year, and are, in the opinion of the Official Liquidator,
capable of giving the information required;
(d) who are or have been within the said year officers of, or
in the employment of, a company which is, or within
the said year was, an officer of the company to which
the statement relates.
(3) The statement shall be submitted within twenty-one days
from the relevant date, or within such extended time not
exceeding three months from that date as the Official
Liquidator or the Tribunal may, for special reasons, appoint.
(4) Any person making, or concurring in making, the statement
and affidavit required by this section shall be allowed, and shall
be paid by the Official Liquidator or provisional liquidator, as
the case may be, out of the assets of the company, such costs
and expenses incurred in and about the preparation and making
of the statement and affidavit as the Official Liquidator may
consider reasonable, subject to an appeal to the Tribunal.
(5) If any person, without reasonable excuse, makes default in
complying with any of the requirements of this section, he shall
be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend
to two years, or with fine which may extend to one thousand
rupees for every day during which the default continues, or with
both.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
(8) In this section, the expression „the relevant date‟ means, in a
case where a provisional liquidator is appointed, the date of his
appointment, and in a case where no such appointment is made,
the date of the winding up order."
25. A plain reading of Section 454(2) of the Act indicates that a
Statement of Affairs has to be filed by persons who are Directors on the
relevant date. Sub-section 8 of Section 454 defines the relevant date to be
the date on which a Provisional Liquidator is appointed. And, in case where
no such appointment is made, the relevant date is defined to be the date on
which the winding up order is passed. In the present case, the relevant date
would be 15.01.2010 when the order appointing the Official Liquidator as a
Provisional Liquidator was passed by this Court. Thus, all persons who
were Directors on 15.01.2010 were obliged to file a Statement of Affairs.
26. The Official Liquidator could also require other persons as specified
in Section 454(2) of the Act to file a statement of affairs, however, such a
direction could only be passed in cases where the Official Liquidator
believed that such persons had control over certain records of the company
or had particular knowledge regarding the affairs of the company. In the
present case, the liability was sought to be imposed on the applicant on the
assumption that the applicant was a Director of the company at the relevant
date (15.01.2010) and was thus, obliged to file a Statement of Affairs. The
Official Liquidator has proceeded on the basis that the applicant was a
Director solely on basis that the records of the Registrar of Companies
indicated the respondent to be a Director of the company on the relevant
date.
27. As stated earlier, the applicant is stoutly disputing the assumption
that he was a Director of the company on 15.01.2010. It is apparent, from
the reply filed on behalf of the company, that the company represented the
applicant to be a Director of the company in spite of the applicant having
submitted his resignation only on the basis that his resignation had not been
accepted by the Board of Directors of the company. In conformity with this
stand taken by the company, the company also did not file Form No. 32
with the Registrar of Companies.
28. In the aforesaid circumstances, the substratal controversy that needs
to be addressed is whether filing of Form No. 32 or acceptance of
resignation submitted by a Director is necessary for the same to be
effective. It is well settled that unless otherwise specified in the Articles of
Association of a company, a resignation by a Director would become
effective from the date on which it is communicated. A resigning Director
is not obliged to file Form No. 32 with the Registrar of Companies. A
resignation by a director implies a relinquishment of his office. This is a
unilateral Act which unless the Articles of Association otherwise provide,
is not contingent on the acceptance by the company. Directors act as agents
of the company and are, thus, also entitled to terminate their agency. The
act of resignation or relinquishment of the office would not require the
consent of the company and, therefore, would become effective from the
time when the intention to relinquish the office as a Director is
communicated.
29. The law on the question as to when does a resignation by a director
become effective, is stated in Palmer's Company Precedents, seventeenth
edition, part 1, at page 565 as under:-
"Where there is no provision in the Articles as to the
procedure for resignation it would seems that resignation will
take effect until it has been tendered to the company as a
whole, but the company cannot refuse it.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
Even in the absence of any express power to resign, it is
submitted that, unless the articles are specially framed, a
director may by notice to the company resign his directorship.
Directors‟ are merely agents of the company‟ and an agent
may determine his agency.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
Where a director has resigned he is not liable for a report
made after his resignation, even though his resignation was
not communicated to the company and his name appeared in
the report."
30. The statement of law on the subject in Gore-Browne's Handbook on
Joint Stock Companies, 41st edition, page 358, reads as under:-
"Articles usually permit a director to resign. Even in the
absence of such a power, unless the articles contain
conditions, he may resign, and his resignation is complete
where notice is given to the secretary, and cannot
subsequently be withdrawn and even though no acceptance
has taken place. Notwithstanding that the articles contemplate
a written resignation a verbal notice of resignation given and
accepted at a general meeting of the company is binding."
31. In the present case, the Articles of Association also provides that the
resignation would take effect from such date as may be specified. Article
35 of the Articles of Association of the respondent company is relevant and
is quoted below:-
"Section 283 of the Companies Act, 1956 shall be applicable
with regard to vacation of office by a Director. A Director
shall also be entitled to resign from the office of Director from
such date as he may specify while so resigning."
32. By virtue of Section 303(2) of the Act a company is obliged to file a
return in the prescribed form indicating inter alia any change among its
directors. Section 303(2) of the Act is quoted below:
"(2) The company shall, within the periods respectively
mentioned in this sub- section, send to the Registrar a return
in the prescribed form containing the particulars specified in
the said register and a notification in the prescribed form of
any change among its directors, managing directors, managers
or secretaries specifying the date of the change. The period
within which the said return is to be sent shall be a period of
thirty days from the appointment of the first directors of the
company and the period within which the said notification of
a change is to be sent shall be thirty days from the happening
thereof."
e-Form No. 32 of the Companies (Central Government‟s) General
Rules and Forms, 1956 is the prescribed form in which the relevant return
in accordance with section 303(2) of the Act is to be filed. It is thus
apparent that filing of Form 32 is an obligation of the company and not of
the Director who is demitting office. The filing of Form 32 with the
Registrar of Companies is an action which is required to be taken by a
company and not by a Director who has tendered his resignation. And, the
same is required to be initiated after the resignation by a Director has
become effective. It is obvious that once a Director has demitted his office,
he would have no authority to file any form on behalf of the company.
33. In the present case, the company itself has accepted that the applicant
had tendered his resignation and an affidavit to this effect was placed on
record much prior to the Official Liquidator being appointed as a
Provisional Liquidator. Thus, there can be no doubt that the applicant had
communicated his unequivocal intention to relinquish his office as a
Director of the company. In view of the settled law that, unless articles
provide otherwise, the acceptance of resignation submitted by a Director is
not necessary for the same to take effect, it is clear that the applicant had
demitted office as a Director much prior to the Official Liquidator being
appointed as a Provisional Liquidator. In this view, no liability for non
performance of any obligation as a Director on the relevant date
(15.01.2010) can be imposed on the applicant. As stated earlier, in the
present case, the sole basis for imposing the liability on the applicant to
compensate the company for insufficient particulars/records was the
assumption that the applicant was a Director of the Company (in
liquidation) on the relevant date (i.e. 15.01.2010). In view of the decision
that this assumption is erroneous, no liability can be imposed on the
applicant.
34. Accordingly, the present application is allowed and it is clarified that
the applicant is not required to deposit 50% of the sum of `9.23 lacs as
directed by the order dated 07.11.2012.
35. The Provisional Liquidator is directed to file a fresh status report
within a period of 8 weeks.
36. List on 30.04.2014.
VIBHU BAKHRU, J
FEBRUARY 11, 2014
RK