Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Extracted from the Provided Opinion (Suresh Kait, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the Tribunal's judgment dated 22.11.2006 which awarded compensation against respondent no. 6 (the driver), respondent no. 8 (the alleged owner of the offending vehicle) and the present appellant (registered owner). The Tribunal had directed the appellant to pay the compensation and allowed the appellant liberty to pursue a civil suit against respondent nos. 6 and 8 for recovery.

Factual matrix as recorded in the opinion:

  • On 16.10.2003 at about 5:30 AM the deceased, Jia Lal, was on the footpath and was struck from behind by a Santro car (identified by registration HR-16-B-2066 / DL-4CJ-1462) driven by respondent no. 6, resulting in fatal injuries.
  • Respondent no. 6 denied being the driver and alleged mala fides in naming him. National Insurance Co. (respondent no. 9) denied insurance coverage for the offending Santro, alleging that a cover note on record related to a different vehicle (a Maruti Zen DL-4CH-4920) and was manipulated. The appellant also denied being insurer of the offending vehicle and challenged the claim amounts as exaggerated.
  • Respondent nos. 7 & 8 did not appear before the Tribunal and were proceeded against ex parte.
  • The Tribunal framed five issues (including whether the death occurred due to rash and negligent driving, whether the petitioners were the legal representatives, and whether respondents were liable to pay compensation) and conducted evidence from claimants' witnesses, eyewitnesses, representatives and officials from National Insurance, and a witness for the appellant who produced an insurance policy for the period 26.07.2000 to 25.07.2002.
  • The Tribunal found that the offending vehicle bore a fake number and that the vehicle DL-4CJ-1462 was a stolen Santro; the registration certificate was, however, shown to be in the name of the appellant. The Tribunal held respondent no. 7 (Subhash Chand), the original owner whose vehicle had been stolen earlier, and National Insurance Company not liable; it held respondent no. 6 (driver), respondent no. 8 (alleged present owner of the offending vehicle) and the appellant (registered owner) jointly and severally liable to pay compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the deceased Jia Lal died in a motor vehicular accident dated 16.10.2003 due to rash and negligent driving of the Santro car allegedly driven by respondent no. 6?
  2. Whether the petitioners are the only legal representatives (LRs) of the deceased?
  3. Whether the respondents are liable to make payment of compensation in view of the objections raised in their written statements (including claims of stolen vehicle, manipulated cover note and non-liability of insurer)?
  4. What amount of compensation the petitioners are entitled to receive and from whom?
  5. Relief (implementation and recovery rights where applicable)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that the offending vehicle was a stolen vehicle and was in the possession of respondent nos. 6 and 8 at the time of the accident; consequently, the appellant (registered owner) could not be held liable for the accident.
  • It was argued that, at minimum, the Tribunal should have provided the appellant with recovery rights against the actual possessors/owners of the vehicle who allegedly created false documents.
  • The appellant relied on the case New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Selvarajamani (1998 ASCJ 547) — submitted as authority for the proposition that an owner cannot be held liable if the offending vehicle was not in his custody and control.

Respondents / Claimants' Arguments

  • The claimants submitted that the offending vehicle was registered in the name of the appellant at the time of the accident and therefore the appellant, as registered owner, was properly fastened with vicarious liability.
  • Claimants relied on the evidence adduced before the Tribunal (including proof of fake number, evidence of the vehicle being stolen and documentary material) supporting the Tribunal's findings of joint liability against respondent no. 6, respondent no. 8 and the appellant.

Respondent No. 6 and National Insurance (positions as recorded)

  • Respondent no. 6 (driver) pleaded that he was not the driver and that his name was mentioned as driver with mala fide intention.
  • National Insurance Co. (respondent no. 9) contended that the cover note on record related to a different vehicle (Maruti Zen DL-4CH-4920) and not to the offending Santro; it produced witnesses and documents to show the cover note and policy records did not cover the Santro, and alleged manipulation of the cover note.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Selvarajamani (1998 ASCJ 547) Proposition relied upon by appellant: if the offending vehicle was not in the custody and control of the owner, the owner cannot be held liable to pay compensation. The appellant's counsel relied on this decision to argue non-liability of the registered owner when the vehicle was stolen and not under the owner's control. The court recited that the appellant relied on this case but did not disturb the Tribunal's finding.
S. Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., AIR 2001 SC 485 Establishes that a claim for compensation before the Tribunal is sustainable and that the owner can be vicariously liable on the basis of strict liability even if the driver was not negligent. The Tribunal relied upon this Supreme Court authority in holding the registered owner vicariously liable; the High Court noted the Tribunal's reliance on this precedent in upholding the Tribunal's order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the evidence and the findings of the Tribunal and proceeded as follows (reflecting the Court's summary of the Tribunal's analysis):

  1. The record showed that the offending Santro car bore a fake registration number (HR-16-B-2066) and that the actual registration of the Santro was DL-4CJ-1462, a vehicle that had been reported stolen (FIR under Section 379 IPC at PS-Patel Nagar, Delhi).
  2. Evidence from witnesses called by National Insurance showed that a cover note and policy documents in their records related to a different vehicle (Maruti Zen DL-4CH-4920), not the Santro that caused the accident; National Insurance thus established that the cover note found in the offending vehicle did not pertain to that vehicle.
  3. Evidence (including certified copies and testimony) established that the registration certificate for the offending vehicle was, at the relevant time, in the name of the appellant (the Tribunal noted the RC remained in the appellant's name and that the vehicle was transferred in the name of the appellant under subrogation rights after theft).
  4. The Tribunal found that respondent no. 6 (driver) in consultation and connivance with respondent no. 8 (alleged owner in possession) had created false and fabricated documents in respect of the offending vehicle; as a result the insurer (National Insurance) was not held liable on the basis that the cover note on record related to another vehicle and had been manipulated.
  5. Given the findings of falsification and the fact that the appellant was shown as the registered owner (with the RC in its name), the Tribunal held respondent no. 6 (driver), respondent no. 8 (possessor/owner in connivance) and the appellant (registered owner) jointly and severally liable to pay compensation to the claimants.
  6. The Tribunal exonerated respondent no. 7 (Subhash Chand), the original owner whose vehicle had been stolen prior to the accident, because his vehicle had been stolen before the accident and had been transferred under subrogation to the appellant; accordingly respondent no. 7 was not held liable.
  7. The High Court reviewed these findings and the authorities relied upon (including S. Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.) and found no discrepancy in the Tribunal's reasoning or conclusion; the Court therefore declined to interfere with the Tribunal's judgment.
  8. Finally, the Court noted that the statutory amount and awarded amount were lying with the Tribunal and directed the Tribunal to release the statutory amount in favour of the appellant and the compensation amount in favour of the claimants as per the Tribunal's order dated 22.11.2006.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Direct consequences and implications as recorded in the opinion:

  • The High Court upheld the Tribunal's finding that respondent no. 6 (driver), respondent no. 8 (alleged owner/possessor in connivance) and the appellant (registered owner) are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation to the claimants.
  • The Tribunal's exoneration of respondent no. 7 (the original owner whose vehicle was stolen earlier) and National Insurance Company (respondent no. 9) was affirmed insofar as the Tribunal found that the cover note related to another vehicle and that false documents had been created by those in possession of the stolen vehicle.
  • The Court directed the Tribunal to release the statutory amount in favour of the appellant and the compensation amount in favour of the claimants in terms of the Tribunal's order dated 22.11.2006.
  • No new precedent was announced by the High Court in this opinion; the Court applied existing principles (including the strict/vicarious liability principle cited from S. Kaushnuma Begum) to affirm the Tribunal's order. The decision's primary effect is the dismissal of the appeal and maintenance of the Tribunal's compensation order and subsidiary directions regarding release of amounts.

    United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Amaratta & Ors. S

    SURESH KAIT, J.

    1. Instant appeal has been preferred against the impugned judgment dated 22.11.2006 whereby ld. Tribunal has awarded compensation against the respondent no. 6 driver, respondent no. 8 (current owner of the offending vehicle) and the present appellant.

    2. The present appellant was directed to pay the compensation amount by the ld. Tribunal and if any civil suit accrued in favour of the appellant being owner of the vehicle and against respondent nos. 6&8, in that eventuality, the appellant is at liberty to take action against the above mentioned respondents.

    3. The facts of the case in hand are very peculiar in nature. On 16.10.2003, at about 5.30 AM deceased Jia Lal was going on footpath, coming for performing the call of nature from the side of Des Bandhu Gupta Road. Meanwhile, one Car bearing no. HR-16-B-2066 driven by respondent no. 6 in rash and negligent manner broke the rallying of footpath and turned towards the side of Jhandewalan and hit deceased Jia Lal from back side, due to which he received fatal injuries.

    4. Respondent no. 6 (respondent no. 1 before Tribunal) had filed written statement wherein he stated that the suit was not maintainable as he was not the driver of the vehicle in question. No accident was caused by him and his name was mentioned as driver with mala fide intention.

    5. Respondent no. 9, National Insurance Co. Ltd. (respondent no. 4 before Tribunal) also filed written statement wherein it is stated that on checking of its record, it was not found that the cover note no. 295257 was issued on 21.02.2000 insuring a Zen Car No. DL-4CH-4920 for the period 21.02.2000 to 28.02.2001 in favour of Modex International Securities Limited, thus, it is clear that Santro Car No. HR-16-B-2066 was not insured with respondent no. 9. Therefore, the cover note was manipulated. In this manner, respondent no. 9 was not the necessary party to the suit.

    6. The appellant (respondent no. 5 before Tribunal) also filed the written statement in which it is stated that they were not the insurer of the offending vehicle nor the alleged offending vehicle was being used or plied at its instructions. The amount claimed by the claimants was highly exaggerated and exorbitant.

    7. Respondent nos. 7&8 were not present before the ld. Tribunal and they were proceeded ex-parte by the tribunal vide order dated 04.01.2005

    8. Ld. Tribunal has framed issues as under: -

    “1. Whether the deceased Jia Lal died in a motor vehicular accident dated 16.10.2003 due to rash and negligent driving of Santro Car (having two registration nos. HR-16-B-2066.DL-4CJ-1462 driven rashly and negligently by respondent no. 1 Rafiq?

    2. Whether the petitioners are the only LRs of the deceased?

    3. Whether the respondents are not liable to make payment of compensation in view of the objection raised in the written statement?

    4. To what amount of compensation, the petitioners are entitled to receive and form whom?

    5. Relief.”

    9. During trial, respondent no. 1.claimant had appeared herself as PW1 and proved the allegations in the petition and also proved the negligence by filing the certified copy of the record as Ex.P1 to Ex.P25

    10. PW2 Paras Nath, nephew of the deceased examined as eye witness of the accident.

    11. Respondent no. 9 National Insurance Company Limited has also examined four witnesses to rebut the claim of the petitioners. R4W1 A.N Chauhan, Assistant Divisional Manager proved the copy of cash collection receipt dated 21.02.2000 Ex.R4W1/1. The carbon copy of the policy is Ex.R4W1/12. The attested copy of the Collection Register is Ex.R4W1/3. R4W2 Sh. M.M Narang, Development Officer of respondent no. 9 has proved the cover note as Ex.R4W2/1. R4W3 Naresh Chand, LDC from Janak Puri Transport Authority has stated that the vehicle was transferred in the name of the appellant i.e United India Insurance Co. Ltd. w.e.f 16.10.2001 Copy of RC is Ex.R4W3/1. R4W4 Sh. Mukund Kumar, Sr. Assistant with respondent no. 9 has proved the certified copy of challan as Ex.R4W4/1.

    12. Appellant (respondent no. 5 before Tribunal) has examined Ms. Veni Lata, its Assistant Manager, who proved the insurance policy of the vehicle for the period from 26.07.2000 to 25.07.2002

    13. Instant appeal has been filed mainly on the ground that the offending vehicle was a stolen vehicle and it was with respondent nos. 6&8 (respondent nos. 1&3 before Tribunal). Therefore, the appellant company cannot be the owner of the said vehicle and therefore, the ld. Tribunal has wrongly fasten the liability on the appellant.

    14. Ld. Counsel for the appellant argued that in such circumstances, ld. Tribunal should have at least given the recovery rights against the owner of the offending vehicle, who is also responsible to create false documents.

    15. Counsel for the appellant has relied upon a case of New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Selvarajamani1998 ASCJ 547 decided by Double Bench of the High Court of Madras whereby it is held that if the offending vehicle was not in custody and control of the owner, then the said owner cannot be held liable to pay the compensation.

    16. On the other hand, ld. Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents/claimants has submitted that since the offending vehicle was registered in the name of the appellant at the time of accident, therefore, being the owner of the offending vehicle, ld. Tribunal has rightly fasten the liability on the appellant.

    17. Issue no. 1&2, as noted above, need not be discussed as there is no dispute qua both the issues.

    18. So far as issue no. 3 is concerned, respondent no. 6 was the driver of the offending vehicle, i.e, HR-16-B-2066, which was allegedly owned by respondent no. 8.

    19. It is not in dispute that the offending vehicle which caused the accident was stolen one in the hands of respondent no. 6 having insurance policy from respondent no. 9, i.e, National Insurance Co. Ltd. vide Cover note no. 27749. The said Company in its written statement as well as in evidence examined Sh. A.N Chauhan as R4W1, Sh. M.M Narang as R4W2, Sh. Naresh Chand as R4W3 and Sh. Mukund Kumar as R4W4, who have proved on record that Cover Note was issued by their agent in favour of vehicle No. DL-4C-H-4920, which was Maruti Zen Car and not for offending vehicle, i.e, HR-16-B-2066 or Vehicle No. DL-4CJ-1462, which was Hyundai Santro Car.

    20. From the certified copies of the criminal case on record and from the testimony of R5W1 Ms. Vani Lata, it is established that vehicle bearing no. HR-16B-2066 was having fake number as the vehicle was not registered in the Transport Authority, Bhiwani, Haryana. From the enquiry of the Investigating Officer of the present case, it is established that, in fact, number of the aforesaid Santro Car was DL-4CJ-1462, which was a stolen vehicle against which FIR under Section 379 IPC was registered in PS-Patel Nagar, Delhi.

    21. Testimony of R4W3 Naresh Chand, LDC has proved that the vehicle no. DL-4CJ-1462 was transferred in the name of the appellant and the registration certificate of the offending vehicle is still in the name of appellant.

    22. On considering the evidence on record, ld. Tribunal has opined that there is no liability of respondent no. 7 Sh. Subhash Chand, who was the owner of the vehicle bearing no. DL-4CJ-1462 as his vehicle was stolen in 2001, much before the accident and the said vehicle had already been transferred under subrogation right in favour of the appellant. Therefore, issue no. 3 has been decided in favour of respondent no. 7, i.e, Subhash Chand, who was not liable to make the payment of the compensation to the claimants.

    23. Ld. Tribunal has also opined that respondent no. 9 National Insurance Company is also not liable for making the payment of compensation in respect of the accident in question because it has been proved by respondent no. 9 that cover note dated 22.02.2000 was found in offending vehicle which was belonging to vehicle no. DL-4CH-4920, i.e, Zen Car and not for Santro Car HR-16-B-2066 or for vehicle bearing no. DL-4CJ-1462.

    24. On considering the evidence on record, ld. Tribunal has also opined that respondent no. 6 in consultation and connivance with respondent no. 8 has created false and fabricated documents in respect of the offending vehicle and therefore respondent no. 9, i.e, National Insurance Co. Ltd. being the insurer of the vehicle in question was also not held liable to make the payment of compensation in favour of the claimants. Accordingly, respondent no. 6 being the driver of the offending vehicle, respondent no. 8 being the alleged owner of the offending vehicle and appellant being the registered owner of the offending owner of the offending vehicle are held liable to make the payment of the compensation in favour of the claimants.

    25. Since the false documents in respect of the offending vehicle and false insurance certificate were created by the aforesaid driver and owner, therefore, both of them held jointly and severally liable to make the payment of compensation to the claimants.

    26. Simultaneously, since the appellant has become the owner of the vehicle, after making the payment of the compensation amount to respondent no. 7 in case of theft of vehicle, the appellant being the owner of the offending vehicle is also held liable to make compensation to the claimants.

    27. While doing so, ld. Tribunal has relied upon a case of S. Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.AIR 2001 SC 485 wherein it is held that even if driver not negligent in causing the accident, claim for compensation before the Tribunal is sustainable and owner is vicariously liable for the damages on the basis of strict liability.

    28. In view of the above discussion and legal position, I do not find any discrepancy in the judgment dated 22.11.2006 passed by the ld. Tribunal, therefore, I am not inclined to interfere therewith.

    29. Consequently, finding no merit in the instant appeal, same is dismissed with no order as to costs.

    30. It is informed by the ld. Counsels for the parties that statutory amount and awarded amount is lying with the ld. Tribunal. Therefore, ld. Tribunal is directed to release statutory amount in favour of the appellant and compensation amount in favour of the claimants in terms of the order dated 22.11.2006 passed by it.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Amaratta & Ors. S
    (Apr 4, 2013)