Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — P.K. Bhasin, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (brother of the detenue) filed this writ petition challenging the detention order dated 23.09.2009 issued by Smt. Rasheda Hussain, Joint Secretary to the Government of India, under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA Act), by which Shri Raj Kumar Aggarwal (@ Munna) was detained and kept in Central Jail, Tihar. The detenue has been in preventive detention since 08.05.2013.

Prior litigation included a pre-execution writ (Crl. W.P. No. 1787/2009) by the detenue dismissed by a Division Bench on 18.03.2010, and a Special Leave Petition to the Supreme Court (SLP(Crl.) No. 2698/2010) which did not succeed at pre-execution stage but permitted challenge after execution; that SLP was withdrawn on 13.07.2010. The detenue also filed a petition under Article 32 (W.P. (Crl.) No. 65/2010) challenging part of Section 3(1) COFEPOSA, which was rejected on 02.07.2012. After the rejection and the cessation of stay against arrest, the detenue was arrested on 08.05.2013. During pendency of the present petition, the Advisory Board confirmed the detention order and the petitioner amended the writ to challenge that confirmation.

The factual backdrop as recited by the Division Bench in the pre-detention proceedings describes raids on 17–18 February 2009 at premises associated with persons including the detenue and his brother, seizure of Indian currency (approximately Rs. 8,00,000) and documents, recording of statements (later retracted by some), applications for release of seized currency and passport, and representations asserting that the seized amount was duly accounted for and that the detenue was engaged only in domestic mobile phone trading and not in import.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the detention order dated 23.09.2009 is liable to be quashed due to an abnormal and unexplained delay in its execution following the rejection of pre-execution litigation (in particular after 02.07.2012).
  2. Whether the detaining/executing authorities adequately explained the delay in execution (including whether they took steps such as initiating proceedings under Section 7(1)(a)/(b) of COFEPOSA or other measures to declare the detenue an absconder and effect his apprehension).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The detention order, though sustainable at pre-execution stage, was executed with a huge and unexplained delay: the detenue was arrested on 08.05.2013 despite the Supreme Court having rejected his challenge on 02.07.2012 and no stay against arrest thereafter.
  • The delay in execution renders the detention order liable to be quashed; continued detention after such delay is non-est and a sham. Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Saeed Zakir Hussain Malik v. State of Maharashtra, (2012) 8 SCC 233.
  • Pleading in the petition (para 5(K)) asserted that the detenue attended to business and that no action under Section 7(1)(a) or 7(1)(b) of COFEPOSA was taken (to the detenue's knowledge), supporting the contention that delay was unexplained and attributable to the authorities' inaction.

Respondent / Detaining Authority's Arguments

  • The detaining authority contended that the detenue concealed himself after the Supreme Court's dismissal on 02.07.2012 and absconded; periodic discreet enquiries were made to trace him on multiple dates (enumerated in the counter-affidavit).
  • The respondents produced a police report dated 15.03.2013 stating that the detenue was not available at two given addresses on that date; they asserted due publication was made in December 2009 directing appeal to the Commissioner of Police.
  • On this basis, the respondents argued the delay in execution was attributable to the detenu's concealment and that he should not be allowed to benefit from his own wrongdoing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Saeed Zakir Hussain Malik v. State of Maharashtra, (2012) 8 SCC 233 Quashing of detention orders where there is an inordinate and unexplained delay in execution; authorities must satisfactorily explain delay. The court relied on this decision to hold that unexplained delay in execution vitiates the detention; it treated Saeed Zakir as controlling authority illustrating that long delays have been held sufficient to quash detention orders.
P.M. Hari Kumar v. Union of India, (1995) 5 SCC 691 Authorities must take sincere and earnest efforts (including approaching courts to cancel bail) to effect execution; unexplained delay by authorities leads to quashing. Cited to show that where authorities failed to take available urgent steps to secure detention (e.g., cancel bail), delay was held unexplained and detention quashed; used to compare and criticize respondents' lack of earnest steps here.
Sultan Abdul Kader v. Govt. of India, (1998) 8 SCC 343 Order of detention can be quashed where no serious efforts were made by police/authorities to apprehend the detenu and delay is unjustified. Relied upon for the proposition that lack of serious efforts by authorities to apprehend a person leads to quashing of detention; the court found the present case worse because no Section 7 steps were even claimed.
A. Mohammed Farook v. Govt. of India, (2000) 2 SCC 360 Even a delay of about 40 days in executing a detention order, if unexplained, can vitiate the Detaining Authority's subjective satisfaction and lead to quashing. Invoked to demonstrate that relatively short unexplained delays have been held sufficient to vitiate detention; used to support the court's conclusion that the long delay here (about ten months after 02.07.2012 to 08.05.2013) was fatal to the order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed its decision primarily on the ground of delay in execution of the detention order. The analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. The court observed that after the Supreme Court dismissed the detenue's Article 32 petition on 02.07.2012 and there was no stay of arrest thereafter, the detenue was arrested only on 08.05.2013 — a long delay for which no satisfactory explanation was offered by respondents.
  2. The respondents' principal explanation was that the detenue had concealed himself and that periodic "discreet enquiries" were made on numerous dates. The respondents produced only one police report (dated 15.03.2013) accompanying the counter-affidavit; the court treated the claim of multiple discreet enquiries as ipse dixit without substantiation.
  3. The court noted an inconsistency: an earlier affidavit had not claimed that discreet enquiries were made, whereas a later affidavit did. The court regarded this as undermining the credibility of the respondents' explanation.
  4. The court emphasized that if the executing authority truly believed the detenue to be absconding, they could and should have invoked steps under Section 7(1)(a) and (b) of COFEPOSA to declare him an absconder (with attendant consequences like attachment of property under Sections 82 and 83 CrPC) or pursued other available processes to enforce appearance; the respondents did not claim to have initiated such proceedings.
  5. The court relied on the precedent law (notably Saeed Zakir and the cases of P.M. Hari Kumar, Sultan Abdul Kader and A. Mohammed Farook) establishing that unreasonable or unexplained delay in executing a detention order vitiates the Detaining Authority's subjective satisfaction and therefore the detention itself.
  6. Given the lack of documentary proof of sustained efforts, absence of invocation of Section 7 measures, and the long unexplained gap between 02.07.2012 and 08.05.2013, the court concluded that the delay was abnormal and unexplained and that the detention order was therefore vitiated.
  7. The court expressly stated that, having reached this conclusion on the delay point, it need not examine the other grounds of challenge raised by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: QUASHED — The writ petition is allowed and the detention order dated 23 September, 2009 passed by Smt. Rasheda Hussain, Joint Secretary to the Government of India, is quashed.

Direct consequences:

  • The detenue, Raj Kumar Aggarwal @ Munna, is directed to be released from jail unless he is required to be detained in connection with some other case.
  • The court's decision is specifically grounded in the abnormal and unexplained delay in execution of the detention order; the court did not reach or decide other challenges raised in the petition.

Broader implications:
The opinion rests on established precedent that unexplained delay in execution of detention orders vitiates the detaining authority's subjective satisfaction. The judgment does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying those precedents; its immediate practical effect is the quashing of the impugned detention order and the release direction stated above.

    Anil Kumar Aggarwal Petitioner v. Uoi & Anr. S

    JUDGMENT

    P.K BHASIN, J:

    The petitioner, by means of this writ petition, challenges the detention order dated 23.09.2009 issued by Ms. Rasheda Hussain, Joint Secretary to the Government of India in exercise of the powers under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (hereinafter referred to as ‘COFEPOSA Act’) pursuant to which his brother Sh. Raj Kumar Aggarwal has been detained and kept in custody I Central Jail, Tihar, New Delhi. The petitioner's brother Sh. Raj Kumar Aggarwal (hereinafter referred to as ‘the detenu’) has been in preventive detention since 08.05.2013

    2. Prior to the filing of the present habeas corpus petition the detenue himself had also filed a writ petition (being Crl. W.P No. 1787/2009) challenging the detention order dated 23.09.2009 at pre-execution stage but the same was dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court vide judgment dated 18.03.2010 That judgment was then challenged by the detenue before the Hon'ble Supreme Court by filing a Special Leave Petition (being SLP(Crl.) No. 2698/2010) but there also he could not succeed in getting the detention order quashed at pre-execution stage. He was, however, permitted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court to challenge the detention order on all the grounds after the execution of the detention order and so that Special Leave Petition came to withdrawn by the detenue on 13.07.2010 During the pendency of that SLP the detenue had also filed a writ petition(being W.P (CRL.) NO. 65/2010) under Article 32 of the Constitution of India in the Supreme Court challenging the constitutional validity of some part of Section 3(1) of the COFEPOSA Act but finally that petition was also rejected on 02.07.2012

    3. The detenue, whose arrest had been stayed by the Division Bench of this Court during the pendency of his pre-execution stage writ and which stay was continued by the Supreme Court in the SLP as well as in the writ petition under Art. 32, was then arrested on 08.05.2013 after the rejection of his writ petition on 02.07.2012 Then the present habeas corpus writ petition was filed by the brother of the detenue for his release. During the pendency of this writ petition the Advisory Board had confirmed the detention order and then challenge to that decision was also added in the writ petition by way of amendment.

    4. The facts leading to the issuance of the impugned detention order as noticed by the Division Bench of this Court in the pre-detention writ petition of the detenue are as under:-

    “One Ambika Electronics, engaged in the business of mobile phones, belongs to Anil Kumar Aggarwal, who is detenu's brother. On 17.02.2009, premises of the said firm at 136, M.C.D Market, Karol Bagh, New Delhi and other premises, viz., residence of Anil Kumar Aggarwal, that of detenu at Pitam Pura,’ New Delhi, shop premises of M/s. Bhagwati Electronics situated at 135, Municipal Market, Karol Bagh, New Delhi belonging to Kapil Jindal were raided by the office of the Directorate of Enforcement, New Delhi. Indian currency amounting to Rs. 8,00,000/- approximately was recovered and some documents were also seized by the Enforcement Authorities, who took into custody the detenu's passport as well. The detenu was also taken away by the official to their office at Jamnagar House, Akbar Road, New Delhi in the intervening night between 17.02.2009 and 18.02.2009 where he was interrogated. His statements were obtained, though it is claimed that it was done by exercising threat, pressure and coercion and that on the very next day, i.e, 19.02.2009, the detenu made retraction of the said statement. Thereafter, he was summoned on various occasions. However, because of his illness, he was unable to travel much. The detenu ultimately appeared on 15.05.2009 when his signatures were purportedly taken on certain blank papers. On 18.05.2009, he moved an application for release of the Indian currency seized on 17.02.2009 By this application, he categorically averred that the amount in question was duly accounted for in the books of accounts and he is not involved in any contravention or violation under the FEMA. On 25.05.2009, he also moved the application for release of passport seized by the officials of the Directorate of Enforcement. Reply dated 08.09.2009 was received by him stating that the matter regarding seized currency/documents would be decided after completion of investigation against the detenu.

    3. It so happened that on 17.02.2009, residential premises of Sh. Anil Kumar Aggarwal at Pitam Pura, New Delhi were also searched and Indian currency amounting to Rs. 8,00,000/- along with certain documents were taken into possession by the Enforcement Directorate. He was also issued summons under section 37 of fema pursuant to which he attended the office on 20.04.2009 On 18.05.2009, Anil Kumar Aggarwal moved the application for release of his Indian currency with the averments that the said amount is duly accounted for in his books of accounts and there is no violation or, contravention under FEMA. He was also given reply dated 08.09.2009 that the matter regarding seized currency would be decided after completion of investigation into the matter. The petitioner maintains that the detenu has nothing to do with the affairs of Anil Kumar Aggarwal. In the premises of M/s. Bhagwati Electronics, searched by the Directorate, Indian Currency, this letter was recovered. Kapil Jindal was also taken to the office around 1.00 a.m in the intervening night of 17.02.2009 and 18.02.2009 and his statement was recorded. However, he also retracted his statement on 19.02.2009 alleging that it was involuntarily statement and was obtained under threat and coercion. He also asked for return of his currency and was given the same reply, viz., the matter regarding seized currency would be decided after the completion of investigation.

    4. Upon coming to know of the proposal to detain the detenu, a number of representations were made categorically highlighting that he is not engaged in any transaction which may attract contravention under the provisions of FEMA and the Indian currency/amount seized is duly accounted for in the books of accounts. The detenu also categorically averred that he is merely engaged in the business of sale and purchase of mobile phones in India and is not engaged in import of any products. The competent authority still went ahead and passed the impugned detention order on 23.09.2009……………………..

    5. The detention order dated 23rd September, 2009 reads as under:-

    “No. 673/02/2009-Cus. VIII

    Government of India

    Ministry of Finance Department of Revenue

    Central Economic Intelligence Bureau

    COFEPOSA Unit

    Dated 23 September, 2009

    Whereas, I, Smt. Rasheda Hussain, Joint Secretary to the Government of India, specially empowered under section 3(1) of the conservation of foreign exchange & prevention of smuggling activities act, 1974 (as amended), am satisfied with respect to the person known as Shri Raj Kumar Aggarwal @ Munna, R/o SU-184, G.F Near Park Citi Hotel Pitampura, New Delhi that with a view to preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the conservation and augmentation of foreign exchange in future, it is necessary to make the following order:-

    Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by section 3(1) of the conservation of foreign exchange & prevention of smuggling activities act, 1974 (as amended), I direct that the said Shri Raj Kumar Aggarwal @ Munna, be detained and kept in custody in the Central Jail, Tihar, New Delhi.

    Sd/-

    (Rasheda Hussain)

    Joint Secretary to the Government of India”

    6. The detention order was sought to be quashed by the petitioner on many grounds but in our view this writ petition deserves to be allowed on one ground alone and that ground is the delay in its execution. Mr. Vikram Chaudhary, learned counsel for the petitioner had submitted that though all the litigation at the pre-execution stage was over with the dismissal of the writ petition filed by the detenue in the Supreme Court challenging the vires of some part of section 3 of cofeposa act on 02.07.2012 and there was no stay of arrest of the detenue in operation thereafter but the detenue was arrested only on 08.05.2013 and there is no explanation for that huge delay. Consequently, the detention order becomes liable to be quashed on this ground alone. In support of this submission reliance was placed on a recent decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Saeed Zakir Hussain Malik v. State of Maharashtra”, (2012) 8 SCC 233.

    7. Regarding the delay in the execution of the detention order the petitioner had pleaded in para no. 5(K) of the writ petition as under:

    “5(K) Because it is an admitted fact on record that the Detenue has been attending to his routine business activities but none had ever come to serve the order of detention even after the rejection of the Writ Petition at pre-detention stage, wherein, stay was operating till 2.7.2012 During the course of his business activities, the Detenue even had a quarrel with one Sachin Mittal a neighbour which led the Detenue to file a complaint before the Station House Officer, Police Station Karol Bagh, New Delhi on 26.3.2013 It is a matter of record that with the intervention of the police, the matter was patched up between the Detenue and his neighbour and a compromise was duly drawn and endorsed by the police authorities. Furthermore, no action whatsoever has been initiated by the respondents either under Section 7(1)(b) or 7(1)(a) of COFEPOSA as per the knowledge of the Detenue. In these circumstances, the delay in execution of the impugned order of detention is fatal and further continued detention is wholly non-est, reducing the necessity to detain to be a mere pretence and sham exercise.”

    8. The reply of the detaining authority to this ground of challenge in the detailed counter-affidavit dated 11th July, 2013 was as under:

    “5(K) In reply to ground K, it is submitted that the Detenue concealed himself after rejection of his writ petition (WP(Crl.) No. 65/2010) by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on 2.7.2012 Detenue did not show streak of being law abiding citizen by way of surrendering in wake of pending detention order against him, especially in wake of the orders passed in the WP (Crl.) 65/2010 and the SLP (Crl.) No. 2698/2010. No comments can be offered as to the narrated quarrel of Detenue with one Sachin Mittal, his filing of complaint before the SHO, PS Karol Bagh, and the compromise thereof endorsed by the Police authorities are nothing to do with the execution of detention order. As brought out, periodic discreet enquries were conducted by the officials of department to trace the Detenue on 10.07.2012, 22.07.2012, 09.08.2012, 16.08.2012, 24.08.2012, 28.09.2012, 18.10.2012, 27.10.2012, periodically thereafter, 06.02.2013, 20.03.2013 & 15.04.2012 Enquiry reports dated 22.07.2012, 17.08.2012, 30.10.2012, 23.01.2013, 06.02.2013, 20.03.2013 & 15.04.2013 in this regard are on records of department. Besides, Police Report of P.S Maurya Enclave, dated 15.03.2013, also clearly brings out that all along the Detenue was concealing himself to avoid execution of Detention Order until he was apprehended on 08.05.2013 Therefore, the Detenue was avoiding service of Detention Order until he was apprehended. Due publication had also been taken out in this matter in December 2009 directing him to appeal before the Commissioner of Police.

    Therefore, it was clear that the delay in execution of detention order is attributable to the Detenue himself and he cannot be allowed to take advantage of his own wrong.”

    9. The detaining authority had also pleaded in the counter-affidavit as under:

    “3(ii)……………After dismissal of the W.P (Crl.) 65/2010, as above, the detenue did not choose to surrender and rather absconded, until he was apprehended on 08.05.2013 In view of the aforesaid submission, the ground raised under this para is devoid of any merit as live and proximate link was very much existing on the date of passing of detention order.

    4.27 In reply to this Para 4.27 it is submitted that it is falsely put forth on behalf of Detenue that after rejection of his W.P (Crl.) 65/2010 by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and stay having ceased to operate after 02.07.2012, Detenue was attending to his routine business activities but none had ever come to serve detention order. The correct fact is that the Detenue concealed himself to avoid execution of Detention Order upon him………………………………………………….”

    10. From the aforesaid paras extracted from the counter affidavit of the detaining authority it is clear that no serious steps were taken by them to ensure the arrest of the detenue. Merely claiming that periodic discreet enquiries were made by the officials to trace out the detenue is the ipse dixit of the respondents and is no explanation worth the name for the delay in the execution of the detention order. Even though many dates were given in the counter affidavit when enquiries were allegedly made to trace out the detenue but alongwith the counter-affidavit dated 11.07.2013 the respondents had placed on record copy of only one report dated 15.03.2013 of the police official from Maurya Enclave police station to the effect that the detenue was not available at his two given addresses when he had gone there that day to execute the detention order. It is also significant to note that prior to the filing of counter-affidavit dated 11.07.2013 another affidavit of another Joint Secretary to the Government of India was also filed but in that affidavit it was not claimed that discreet enquiries were made about the whereabouts of the detenue and in fact it was pleaded at that time that the detenue should have himself surrendered after the dismissal of his writ petition by the Supreme Court. In the subsequent affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents it was claimed that discreet enquiries were made on many dates. If that was also correct then these facts should have been pleaded in the first affidavit. There is in any case no reason or justification forthcoming as to why proceedings under Section 7(1)(a) and (b) of the COFEPOSA Act for getting the detenue declared an absconder and getting his properties attached, as provided under Sections 82 and 83 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and also why proceedings for the prosecution of the detenue under Section 7(1)(b) were not got initiated if actually the executing authority was finding it difficult to ensure that the detenue surfaces. Learned counsel for the respondents drew our attention to the observations made by the Supreme Court while dismissing the detenue's writ petition filed for getting a declaration that some part of section 3 of the cofeposa act was ultra vires the Constitution to the effect that at the pre-execution stage the detenue was evading his arrest. However, we are not aware as to what material had been placed before the Supreme Court to show that the detenue during that period was evading his arrest. There was in any case stay against his arrest in operation during the pendency of the writ petition in this Court and then when the matter was pending in the Supreme Court. As noticed already, after pre-execution stage there was no hindrance against his arrest, the long delay in arresting the detenue has remained totally unexplained. In one of the judgments referred to by the Supreme Court in Saeed Zakir's case (supra) even 40 days unexplained delay in the execution of the detention order was considered sufficient to quash the detention order. Here the detention order was executed after almost a year of the dismissal.

    11. Now, we would like to refer to some of the paras from the decision of the Supreme Court in Saeed Zakir's case (supra) cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner in which the detention order was quashed because the authorities had failed to justify the delay of fourteen and a half months delay in the execution of the detention order. This is how the Supreme Court had dealt with the aspect of delay in execution of the detention order while quashing the detention order:

    “Contentions of the appellant:

    5.(a) Though the detention order was passed on 14.11.2006 and the detenu was available on the address known to the authorities, the authorities have chosen to execute the order only on 01.02.2008 Pursuant to the same, there was an inordinate and unreasonable delay of 14½ months in executing the detention order which vitiates the detention itself;

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    Contentions of the respondent-State:

    6.(a) Since the detenu was absconding, in spite of repeated attempts by the Executing Authority for executing the detention order, all the efforts were in vain as the detenu had rendered himself non-traceable.

    (b) The delay has been properly explained by filing an affidavit not only by the Detaining Authority but also by the Executing Authority.

    (c) After realizing that the detenu has absconded an action was also taken under Section 7(1)(b) and additionally under Section 7(1)(a) of COFEPOSA that the detenu did not comply with the same. It is pointed out that once appropriate action has been taken under Section 7(1)(a)(b) of COFEPOSA, the burden shifts on the detenu.

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    10. In P.M Hari Kumar v. Union of India, (1995) 5 SCC 691, which is almost similar to the case on hand, the only reason for delay in execution of the detention order was that the detenu was absconding and they could not serve the detention order on him because of his own fault. Rejecting the said contention, this Court held:

    “13. If the respondents were really sincere and anxious to serve the order of detention without any delay it was expected of them, in the fitness of things, to approach the High Court or, at least, the Court which initially granted the bail for its cancellation as, according to their own showing, the petitioner had violated the conditions imposed, and thereby enforce his appearance or production as the case might be. Surprisingly, however, no such steps were taken and instead thereof it is now claimed that a communication was sent to his residence which was returned undelivered. Apart from the fact that no such communication has been produced before us in support of such claim, it has not been stated that any follow-up action was taken till 3-8-1990, when Section 7 of the Act was invoked. Similarly inexplicable is the respondents' failure to insist upon the personal presence of the petitioner in the criminal case (CC No. 2 of 1993) filed at the instance of the Customs Authorities, more so when the carriage of its proceeding was with them and the order of detention was passed at their instance. On the contrary, he was allowed to remain absent, which necessarily raises the inference that the Customs Authorities did not oppose his prayer, much less bring to the notice of the Court about the order of detention passed against the detenu.”

    After finding that the respondent-authorities did not make sincere and earnest efforts and take urgent and effective steps which were available to them to serve the order of detention on the petitioner therein, this Court quashed the order of detention holding that the unusual delay in serving the order of detention has not been properly and satisfactorily explained.

    11. In Sultan Abdul Kader v. Govt. of India (1998) 8 SCC 343 the order of detention was passed on 14.03.1996 but the detenu was detained only on 07.08.1997 After finding that no serious efforts were made by the police authorities to apprehend the detenu and the Joint Secretary himself had not made any efforts to find out from the police authorities as to why they were not able to apprehend the detenu, quashed the order of detention.

    12. In A. Mohammed Farook v. Govt. of India (2000) 2 SCC 360, the only contention before the Court was that of delay in executing the order of detention. In that case, the detention order was passed on 25.02.1999 but the authorities have chosen to execute the detention order only on 06.04.1999 after an inordinate and unreasonable delay of nearly 40 days. In the absence of proper and acceptable reasons for the delay of 40 days in executing the detention order, this Court concluded that the subjective satisfaction of the Detaining Authority in issuing the detention order dated 25.02.1999 gets vitiated and on this ground quashed the same.

    13. It is clear that in the light of sub-section (5) of Article 22, it is incumbent on the Detaining Authority as well as the Executing Authority to serve the detention order at the earliest point of time. If there is any delay, it is the duty of the said authorities to afford proper explanation.

    14. Now, let us consider the delay in the case on hand in serving the order of detention. Though the detention order was passed on 14.11.2006, the same was served only on 01.02.2008 Ms. Asha Gopalan Nair, learned counsel appearing for the State contended that since the detenu himself was absconding, in spite of repeated attempts made by the Executing Authority, the same were not materialized. She also brought to our notice the affidavits filed by the concerned authorities explaining the efforts made in serving the order of detention. By giving details about their efforts, she pointed out that the detenu absconded after release from the prison on 11.11.2005 and actions were also taken under Sections 7(1)(b) and 7(1)(a) of COFEPOSA and that the detenu did not comply with the same. It is pointed out from the other side that during this period, the bail order dated 11.11.2005 was not cancelled nor an attempt was made to forfeit the amount which was deposited by the detenu. When this Court posed a specific question to the learned counsel for the State about the delay, particularly, when the detenu was released on bail on 11.11.2005 and no proper steps have been taken for cancellation of the bail and forfeiture of the amount which was deposited by the detenu, it is not disputed that such recourse has not been taken. In such circumstances, the reasons stated in the affidavit filed by the Detaining and Executing Authorities that, on several occasions, their officers visited the residential address of the detenu and he could not be traced, are all unacceptable. We hold that the respondent-authorities did not make any sincere and earnest efforts in taking urgent effective steps which were available to them, particularly, when the detenu was on bail by orders of the court. We are satisfied that the unusual delay in serving the order of detention has not been properly and satisfactorily explained. In view of the same, we hold that the authorities have not executed the detention order promptly as required under Article 22(5) of the Constitution.

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    23. It is clear that if there is unreasonable delay in execution of the detention order, the same vitiates the order of detention. In the case on hand, though the detenu was released on bail on 11.11.2005, the detention order was passed only on 14.11.2006, actually, if the detenu was absconding and was not available for the service of the detention order, the authorities could have taken steps for cancellation of the bail and for forfeiture of the amount deposited. Admittedly, no such recourse has been taken. If the respondents were really sincere and anxious to serve the order of detention without any delay, it was expected of them to approach the court concerned which granted bail for its cancellation, by pointing out that the detenu had violated the conditions imposed and thereby enforce his appearance or production as the case may be. Admittedly, no such steps were taken instead it was explained that several attempts were made to serve copy by visiting his house on many occasions.

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    25. In this regard, we reiterate that the Detaining Authority must explain satisfactorily the inordinate delay in executing the detention order, otherwise the subjective satisfaction gets vitiated. In the case on hand, in the absence of any satisfactory explanation explaining the delay of 14½ months, we are of the opinion that the detention order must stand vitiated by reason of non-execution thereof within a reasonable time.

    26. We are also satisfied that no serious efforts were made by the Police Authorities to apprehend the detenu. Hence the unreasonable delay in executing the order creates a serious doubt regarding the genuineness of the Detention Authority as regards the immediate necessity of detaining the detenu in order to prevent him from carrying on the prejudicial activity referred to in the grounds of detention. We hold that the order of detention passed by the Detaining Authority was not in lawful exercise of power vested in it.”

    12. The situation in the case in hand is worse inasmuch as in the said case before the Supreme Court the authorities had initiated proceedings under Section 7(1)(a) and (b) of the COFEPOSA Act against the person sought to be detained but still the Court came to the conclusion that no serious efforts had been made to execute the detention order while in the present case before us the respondents do not even claim to have taken any steps under section 7 of the cofeposa act to have the detenue declared an absconder which declaration in turn would have made the properties of the detenue liable to be attached. So, the impugned detention order gets vitiated because of the failure of the respondents to explain the delay in its execution after the rejection of the detenue's writ petition by the Supreme Court on 02.07.2012 and the vacation of the order of stay of his arrest.

    13. In view of our decision that the impugned detention order gets vitiated because of the abnormal and unexplained delay in its execution we need not examine other grounds of challenge raised by the petitioner.

    14. In the result, this writ petition is allowed and consequently the detention order dated 23 September, 2009 passed by Ms. Rasheda Hussain, Joint Secretary to the Government of India is quashed. The detenue Raj Kumar Aggarwal @ Munna is directed to be released from jail unless he is required to be detained there in connection with some other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anil Kumar Aggarwal Petitioner v. Uoi & Anr. S
    (Oct 30, 2013)