Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Sudeep Jain, filed petitions under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking quashing of the summoning order dated 29.09.2012 passed by the Metropolitan Magistrate, Patiala House, New Delhi, in two complaint cases titled ECE Industries Ltd. v. GEI Industrial Systems Ltd. The petitioner is a Company Secretary in the accused company and contends that his role is limited to ensuring statutory compliances under the Companies Act, without involvement in the day-to-day functioning or issuance of cheques. The petitioner argues that no specific averments were made against him regarding responsibility for the alleged offence. The petitions challenge the summoning order issued against him and others in relation to offences under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person holding a position such as Company Secretary can be held vicariously liable under Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 without specific averments demonstrating their role in the conduct of the company's business at the relevant time.
  2. What are the necessary averments required in a complaint under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act to hold an individual liable for offences committed by a company.
  3. What procedural safeguards should Metropolitan Magistrates observe before issuing summons to directors or employees of accused companies in complaints filed under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner, as Company Secretary, is not involved in day-to-day operations or issuance of cheques by the company.
  • No specific averments were made in the complaint to show the petitioner’s responsibility for the alleged offence.
  • Liability under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act cannot be imposed merely by stating a person’s designation or mechanically reproducing statutory language.
  • Summoning orders against persons without specific involvement in the offence cause undue harassment and increase the burden on courts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.M.S Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Neeta Bhalla, 2005 (7) SCALE 397 Necessity of specific averments in complaint under Section 138 r/w 141 of Negotiable Instruments Act to hold a person vicariously liable. Reaffirmed that mere designation is insufficient; the accused must be shown to be in charge and responsible for conduct of business at the relevant time.
National Small Industries Corp. Ltd. v. Harmeet Singh Paintal, 2010 (2) SCALE 372 Clarification on the requirement of averments for vicarious liability under Section 141(1) and (2) of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Emphasized that mechanical repetition of statutory language is inadequate; specific facts showing consent, connivance, or negligence are required.
Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal, (2004) 7 SCC 338 Finality of summoning orders and limitation on Magistrates' power to review such orders once issued. Noted that once summons are issued, Magistrates cannot review the order, thus highlighting the importance of careful scrutiny before summoning.
Anita Malhotra v. Apparel Export Promotion Council, (2012) 1 SCC 520 Reiteration of principles governing vicarious liability under Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Supported the view that liability depends on the specific role and responsibility of the accused in the company’s business conduct.
Laxmi Dyechem v. State of Gujarat, 2012 (11) SCALE 365 Further affirmation of the settled legal position on vicarious liability under the Negotiable Instruments Act. Reinforced the necessity of clear averments showing the accused’s responsibility for the offence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the legal framework under Chapter XVII of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, particularly Sections 138 and 141, which deal with offences relating to dishonour of cheques and liability of company officials. It emphasized that liability under Section 141 is not automatic upon holding a position such as Director or Company Secretary. Instead, the complaint must contain specific averments showing that the accused was in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business at the time the offence was committed.

The Court referred to authoritative Supreme Court judgments that clarified these principles and underscored that indiscriminate summoning of all company officials without due scrutiny causes harassment and judicial inefficiency. It noted the need for Magistrates to scrutinize complaints carefully at the pre-summoning stage and to require complainants to provide detailed information, including Form-32, to identify directors at the relevant time and their specific roles.

The Court thus directed procedural safeguards for Metropolitan Magistrates to ensure summons are issued only to those persons who prima facie satisfy the criteria for vicarious liability, thereby preventing undue harassment of innocent persons and reducing unnecessary burden on courts.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the exemption applications and disposed of the petitions seeking quashing of the summoning orders subject to just exceptions.

The Court mandated that from 1st July 2013, all Metropolitan Magistrates in Delhi must require complainants in Section 138 r/w 141 cases to annex detailed information identifying accused persons' roles and direct summons only to those with prima facie responsibility for the offence. This decision aims to prevent mechanical issuance of summons, reduce harassment of innocent company officials, and alleviate the burden on the judiciary. No new legal precedent altering substantive law was established; rather, the Court emphasized procedural diligence and adherence to settled legal principles.

    Sudeep Jain Petitioner v. M/S. Ece Industries Ltd.

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KAILASH GAMBHIR

    ORDER

    Crl.M.A No. 5630/2013 (Exemption)

    Crl.M.A No. 5632/2013 (Exemption)

    Exemption allowed subject to all just exceptions. The applications stand disposed of.

    Crl. M.C No. 1821/2013 & Crl.M.A No. 5629/2013(Stay)

    Crl. M.C No. 1822/2013 & Crl.M.A No. 5631/2013(Stay)

    1. By these petitions filed under Section 482 of Cr. P.C, the petitioner - Sudeep Jain is seeking quashing of summoning order dated 29.09.2012 passed by Shri Arul Verma, Metropolitan Magistrate, Patiala House, New Delhi against him in two complaint cases being CC Nos. 422/1/12 and CC Nos. 423/1/12 titled as ECE Industries Ltd. v. GEI Industrial Systems Ltd.

    2. Grievance raised by Mr. Krishan Kumar, Advocate appearing for the petitioner, is that the petitioner is a Company Secretary in the accused company M/s. GEI Industrial Systems Ltd., Bhopal and his duty is restricted to ensure the proper observance and compliances made by the said company in terms of various statutory requirements laid down under the Companies Act. He further submits that the petitioner is neither obliged nor is actually instrumental in the day to day functioning of the said company and in fact has no knowledge or any role in the issuance of any cheque on behalf of the said company in favour of the complainant company. It is further the case of the petitioner that no specific averments, as to how and in what manner the petitioner was responsible for the day to day conduct of the business of M/s. GEI Industrial Systems Ltd., have been made by the complainant company in the complaint against the petitioner. Counsel for the petitioner also apprises this court that 12 other persons have been issued summons in the said case and some of them have already approached this court for quashing of the said summoning order.

    3. In support of the above, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the legal position is now well settled that the liability for an offence punishable under Section 138 r/w Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 will not arise by merely stating that the accused person holds some designation in the accused company or by merely reproducing the language of Section 141 of the Act in the complaint. The complainant has to make a specific averment in the complaint as to how and in what manner the person accused of the offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 was responsible or had a role in the conduct of the business of the accused company at the relevant time. A mere fact that the accused person was a Director or was holding some other office in the company cannot make a person vicariously liable to face the prosecution as per the mandate of Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

    4. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner.

    5. Chapter XVII was incorporated in the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 by the Banking Public Financial Institutions and Negotiable Instruments Laws (Amendment) Act, 1998 with effect from 1.4.1989 for the purpose of imposing penalties in case of dishonor of cheque due to insufficiency of funds in the account of drawer of the cheque, in addition to the remedy of filing a recovery suit already available to the aggrieved under the civil law. Finding the punishment contained in this chapter inadequate and the procedure to deal with such matters cumbersome, this chapter was further amended by the Negotiable Instruments (Amendment and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2002 for the purpose of early disposal of the cases related to dishonor of cheques as well as for enhancing punishment for the offenders. It would not be inappropriate to say that while this chapter's introduction has, on the one hand, reduced the civil litigation to a great extent, but, on the other hand, has led to the filing of countless complaints before the criminal courts which are mostly against companies, whether Private or Public Ltd., registered under the Companies Act.

    6. Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 deals with the offences by the companies and says that if an offence has been committed by a company under section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 then every person, who at the time the offence was committed was in charge of, and was responsible to the company in the conduct of the business of the company, as well as to the company is liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly. What necessary averments are required to be made in the complaint to hold any Director or other post holder in the company as vicariously liable for an offence committed under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 by the company has been a subject matter of discussion in a number of cases. Despite the legal position now being well settled with the catena of pronouncements of the Apex Court on this subject, the trend set up by the complainants to implead all the Directors, company secretaries, etc., of the accused company, irrespective of whether they were actually involved in the commission of alleged offence or not, has not yet ended. One of the earliest case, S.M.S Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Neeta Bhalla, 2005 (7) SCALE 397, which threw light on the averments required to be made in the complaint under Section 138 r/w 141 of Negotiable Instruments Act, observed as follows in paragraph 16:-

    (a) It is necessary to specifically aver in a complaint under Section 141 that at the time the offence was committed, the person accused was in charge of, and responsible for the conduct of business of the company. This averment is an essential requirement of Section 141 and has to be made in a complaint. Without this averment being made in a complaint, the requirements of Section 141 cannot be said to be satisfied.

    (b)…Merely being a director of a company is not sufficient to make the person liable under Section 141 of the Act. A director in a company cannot be deemed to be in charge of and responsible to the company for conduct of its business. The requirement of Section 141 is that the person sought to be made liable should be in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the company at the relevant time. This has to be averred as a fact as there is no deemed liability of a director in such cases.

    (c)…the Managing Director or Joint Managing Director would be admittedly in charge of the company and responsible to the company for conduct of its business. When that is so, holders of such positions in a company become liable under Section 141 of the Act. By virtue of the office they hold as Managing Director or Joint Managing Director, these persons are in charge of and responsible for the conduct of business of the company. Therefore, they get covered under Section 141. So far as signatory of a cheque which is dishonoured is concerned, he is clearly responsible for the incriminating act and will be covered under Sub-section (2) of Section 141.

    7. Reiterating the same view, the Apex Court in National Small Industries Corp. Ltd. v. Harmeet Singh Paintal, 2010 (2) SCALE 372, further observed that:-

    24. …if the accused is not one of the persons who falls under the category of “persons who are responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company” then merely by stating that “he was in-charge of the business of the company” or by stating that “he was in-charge of the day-to-day management of the company” or by stating that “he was in-charge of, and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company”, he cannot be made vicariously liable under Section 141(1) of the Act. To put it clear that for making a person liable under Section 141(2), the mechanical repetition of the requirements under Section 141(1) will be of no assistance, but there should be necessary averments in the complaint as to how and in what manner the accused was guilty of consent and connivance or negligence and therefore, responsible under Sub-section (2) of Section 141 of the Act.

    Summarizing the legal position, The Apex court further laid down the following principles:-

    (i) The primary responsibility is on the complainant to make specific averments as are required under the law in the complaint so as to make the accused vicariously liable. For fastening the criminal liability, there is no presumption that every Director knows about the transaction.

    (ii) Section 141 does not make all the Directors liable for the offence. The criminal liability can be fastened only on those who, at the time of the commission of the offence, were in charge of and were responsible for the conduct of the business of the company.

    (iii) Vicarious liability can be inferred against a company registered or incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 only if the requisite statements, which are required to be averred in the complaint/petition, are made so as to make accused therein vicariously liable for offence committed by company along with averments in the petition containing that accused were in-charge of and responsible for the business of the company and by virtue of their position they are liable to be proceeded with.

    (iv) Vicarious liability on the part of a person must be pleaded and proved and not inferred.

    (v) If accused is Managing Director or Joint Managing Director then it is not necessary to make specific averment in the complaint and by virtue of their position they are liable to be proceeded with.

    (vi) If accused is a Director or an Officer of a company who signed the cheques on behalf of the company then also it is not necessary to make specific averment in complaint.

    (vii) The person sought to be made liable should be in-charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the company at the relevant time. This has to be averred as a fact as there is no deemed liability of a Director in such cases.

    8. The recent judgments of the Apex Court namely, Anita Malhotra v. Apparel export Promotion Council, (2012) 1 SCC 520 and Laxmi Dyechem v. State of Gujrat, 2012 (11) SCALE 365, have again reiterated the said legal position.

    9. The prime objective of this Court is to remind all the Metropolitan Magistrates in Delhi to carefully scrutinize all the complaint cases being filed under Section 138 r/w 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 against the accused companies at the pre-summoning stage and make sure that notice be directed only to those directors or employees of the company who satisfy the principles laid down in the aforesaid judgments. Summons must be issued only after giving due consideration to the allegations and the materials placed on record by the complainant. Undeniably, as per the aforesaid legal pronouncements, Managing Director and the Joint Managing Director are deemed to be vicariously liable for the offence committed by the company because of the position they hold in the company. Problem arises in cases where all the persons holding office in the company are sought to be prosecuted by the complainant, irrespective of whether they played any specific role in the incriminating act. It is surprising to see that in plethora of cases, the complaint contains allegations even against those persons who might have been Directors at any point in time in the accused company, but had resigned from such company much prior to the period when the alleged offence was committed. Issuing summons to all persons named in the complaint mechanically, without ascertaining whether they played any actual role in the transaction, not only pesters the innocent directors/employees named in the complaint, but also upsurges the load on the High Courts as the Magistrates once issuing the summoning orders against the accused, are precluded from reviewing their summoning orders in view of the decision of the Apex Court in Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal, (2004) 7 SCC 338. One can also not lose sight of the fact that once such innocent persons are summoned, they have no choice but to seek bail and face the ordeal of trial. Many of such persons also approach the High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C to seek quashing of the summoning order and the complaint filed against them and this further increases the burden on the already overburdened Courts.

    10. With a view to ensure that the Metropolitan Magistrates dealing with the complaint cases filed under Section 138 r/w Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act have a clear and complete picture of the persons arrayed by the complainant so as to hold them vicariously liable for the commission of the offence by the accused company, I am inclined to direct that the Magistrates must seek copies of Form-32 from the complainant to prima facie satisfy the Court as to who were the directors of the accused company at the time of commission of the alleged offence and on the date of filing of the complaint case. In addition to the above, the Magistrates must also seek information as given in the following table which is to be annexed by the Complainant on a separate sheet accompanying the complaint:-

    a. Name of the accused Company;

    b. Particulars of the dishonoured cheque/cheques;

    •Person/Company in whose favour the cheque/cheques were issued

    •Drawer of the cheque/cheques

    •Date of issuance of cheque/cheques

    •Name of the drawer bank, its location

    •Name of the drawee bank, its location

    •Cheque No./Nos.

    •Signatory of the cheque/cheques

    c. Reasons due to which the cheque/cheques were dishonoured;

    d. Name and Designation of the persons sought to be vicariously liable for the commission of the offence by the accused Company and their exact role as to how and in what manner they were responsible for the commission of the alleged offence;

    e. Particulars of the legal notice and status of its service;

    f. Particulars of reply to the legal notice, if any.

    11. The Registry is directed to send a copy of this order to all the Metropolitan Magistrates posted in various district courts of Delhi for necessary compliance. Registry is further directed to send a copy of this order to all the Bar Associations of various district courts of Delhi, so that they can apprise the members of the Bar about the aforesaid directions.

    12. The aforesaid directions in terms of Para 10 shall come into effect from 1st July 2013.

    13. Issue notice to the respondent, returnable on 21 August, 2013.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sudeep Jain Petitioner v. M/S. Ece Industries Ltd.
    (May 6, 2013)