AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2012 DHC 180-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2012 DHC 180-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment (as provided)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal (LPA No. 18/2012) challenges the Single Judge's order dated 04.01.2012 in W.P.(C) No. 4860/2011, whereby the Single Judge:

  • declared Article XIII(d) of the Constitution of respondent No. 3, Wrestling Federation of India (WFI), to have stood deleted on 05.02.2011;
  • declared elections held by the WFI between 05.04.2011 and 15.04.2011 (conducted on the basis of Article XIII(d)) to be illegal;
  • set aside the appellant's election as President of WFI (conducted in April 2011); and
  • directed that fresh election(s) for the post of President be held.

Article XIII(d) (as reproduced in the opinion) prescribed that only persons who had held office in the outgoing Executive Committee of WFI for a period of four years were eligible to contest for President, Senior Vice President and Secretary General. That clause was purportedly introduced in 2007.

The respondents (No. 1 & 2) in the writ petition contended that a Special General Body meeting on 05.02.2011 approved an amendment deleting Article XIII(d), but that despite the deletion a nomination of respondent No. 2 (Mr. P.V. Rathee) for President was rejected on the basis that Article XIII(d) remained in force for the April 2011 elections.

The Single Judge made multiple findings (summarised below) in favour of the respondents and set aside the appellant's election. The appellant appealed against those findings and the resultant order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Article XIII(d) of WFI's Constitution stood deleted on 05.02.2011 as a result of the resolution passed at the General Body meeting held on that date.
  2. Whether the meeting of 05.02.2011 was validly called and authorized (i.e., whether the President had power to call that meeting).
  3. Whether Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act, 1860 applies to the deletion/amendment of Article XIII(d) (i.e., whether such amendment required further procedural formalities including a second meeting or Registrar's concurrence to be effective).
  4. Whether rejection of the nomination of respondent No. 2 for President (on the basis that Article XIII(d) was then in force) was lawful.
  5. Whether, having found the elections to be vitiated with respect to multiple posts, the Single Judge erred in setting aside only the election to the post of President and not also those to Secretary General and Senior Vice President.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments (as set out in the writ petition)

  • A Special General Body meeting was held on 05.02.2011 which approved amendment of the WFI Constitution, including deletion of Article XIII(d).
  • Despite the deletion, nominations for the April 2011 elections (specifically respondent No. 2's nomination for President) were rejected treating Article XIII(d) as still in force.
  • The respondents sought judicial relief declaring the deletion effective and challenging the elections carried out on the basis of Article XIII(d).

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced before the Single Judge and on appeal)

  • The President of WFI was not empowered to call the 05.02.2011 meeting; only the Secretary General could call it.
  • Under Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act, 1860, an amendment of the kind effected on 05.02.2011 would not be effective without a second meeting at an interval of one month (and the minutes were not confirmed until 18.06.2011).
  • The Registrar of Societies, by letter dated 23.03.2011, refused to incorporate the purported amendments carried out on 05.02.2011 for the stated reason (i.e., procedural defect under Section 12).
  • Therefore Article XIII(d) remained in force at the time of the April 2011 elections, and rejection of respondent No. 2's nomination was correct under that Article.
  • On appeal the appellant also challenged each finding of the Single Judge and later sought a stay of the fresh elections to enable him to seek independent remedies in respect of the other two posts (Secretary General & Vice President).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Supreme Court, Bar Association v. B.D. Kaushik (2011) 11 SCALE 72 Rules relating to voting and contesting elections do not amount to altering the aims and objects of a society and can be changed without consent of the Registrar; Rules of a society are contractual among members and do not acquire statutory character; authority to amend rules vests in the General Body. The court relied on this principle to hold that Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act does not apply to amendments of internal rules governing elections (i.e., deletion of Article XIII(d) was a rules change by the General Body, not an alteration of the society's objects requiring Registrar's consent under Section 12).
Allahabad High School Society v. State of U.P. (MANU/UP/1373/2011) — referred; view confirmed by Apex Court in (2011) 6 SCC 118 Distinction between amendment of objects of a society and amendment of rules; Section 12 not applicable to amendment of rules which can be effected at a meeting of the society. The court cited this decision to reinforce that amendments of rules (such as electoral rules) are within the competence of the General Body and not governed by Section 12's procedure for alteration of objects.
M/S Narinder Batra…Petitioner v. Union of India… (ILR (2009) 4 Delhi 280) Government guidelines require national federations to enforce democracy by fixing tenure of office bearers; same office-bearers should not be permitted to dominate; limited tenure prevents monopoly and potential damage to the sport. The court relied on this policy context to support the conclusion that Article XIII(d) (which perpetuates incumbency) is objectionable and inconsistent with the democratic expectations for national sports bodies.
Dental Council of India v. Dr. H.R. Prem Sachdeva (1999) 8 SCC 471 Continuance in office of elected/nominated members should not go on for perpetuity; tenures should be limited. The court cited this authority to underpin the view that unlimited continuance in office is contrary to democratic principles and that provisions allowing perpetuity are unsustainable.
Kashmir Singh v. Union of India (2008) 7 SCC 259 Article 310 and related constitutional provisions contemplate tenure; holding public office indefinitely is opposed to the constitutional scheme; permitting indefinite tenure risks abuse. The court used this precedent to reinforce the principle that an office should not be held in perpetuity and to support the broader objection to Article XIII(d)'s effect.
Bhandara District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (1993 Supp. (3) SCC 259) Cooperative bodies are not meant to be run as a close preserve of an individual or group; broad participation is desirable. The court cited this decision to further support the policy that concentration of power and indefinite control by few is undesirable in member-driven bodies.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court affirmed the Single Judge's findings after considering the facts, statutory provisions and precedent. The analysis proceeded along two distinct strands: legal/technical (validity of the meeting and statutory applicability) and substantive/policy (democratic legitimacy of Article XIII(d)).

Findings affirmed from the Single Judge (summarised):

  1. The WFI, in its counter affidavit, admitted that a Resolution passed in the General Council meeting of 05.02.2011 deleted Article XIII(d), and this position was confirmed in the General Council meeting of 18.06.2011.
  2. Even though the minutes of the 05.02.2011 meeting were not confirmed until 18.06.2011, the deletion took effect on 05.02.2011 itself.
  3. The meeting of 05.02.2011 was validly called by the President who was authorized to convene it.
  4. There was no requirement that the amendment (deletion of Article XIII(d)) be registered with the Registrar of Societies for it to come into operation; the operative test was whether the amendment concerned the objects of the society as contemplated by Section 12.
  5. The respondents were entitled to maintain the writ petition challenging the election to the post of President alone, though Article XIII(d) also affected other offices.
  6. The Government of India had objected by communication dated 07.04.2011 to enforcing a restrictive clause such as Article XIII(d) in the April 2011 election process.

On applicability of Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act:

The court interrogated the appellant's reliance on Section 12 (which, on its text and legislative scheme, applies to alteration of the purposes for which a society is established) and rejected the contention that Section 12 governed amendments to internal rules regulating elections. The court held that:

  • Section 12 is specifically restricted by the legislature to alterations of the society's purposes; it is not drafted to encompass all amendments to the Memorandum of Association or the Rules and Regulations.
  • If the legislature intended Section 12 to apply to internal rules it could have done so explicitly; the legislative choice to limit Section 12's applicability is decisive.
  • Therefore Section 12 does not apply to an amendment like deletion of Article XIII(d), which governed eligibility to contest office; such electoral rules are internal rules amendable by the General Body.

Reliance on precedent:

The court relied on judicial authorities (including Bar Association v. B.D. Kaushik and the Allahabad High School Society decision as confirmed by the Apex Court) which distinguish between amendments to a society's objects and amendments to internal rules governing elections; these authorities establish that electoral rules can be amended by the General Body without Registrar's consent. The court invoked policy decisions in earlier cases (e.g., Narinder Batra, Dental Council of India, Kashmir Singh, Bhandara Bank case) to frame the democratic imperative against perpetuity of office.

Substantive policy analysis:

Beyond the technical non-applicability of Section 12, the court held on broader democratic and policy grounds that Article XIII(d) was undemocratic and unsustainable for a national sports federation recognized by the Government of India. The court reasoned that:

  • It is illogical and unjustifiable to restrict certain high offices (President, Secretary General, Senior Vice President) to persons who have already held those offices for four years; such a provision perpetuates control of the federation in a few hands.
  • Article XIII(d) tends to create a "fiefdom", enables indefinite retention of office, eliminates meaningful elections, and concentrates power contrary to democratic norms applicable to societies and national federations.
  • Decentralized power and periodic change in office-bearers are preferable; limited tenure minimizes nepotism, favouritism, bias and potential abuse.

On relief as to other posts:

Although the Single Judge's findings indicated that Article XIII(d) affected elections to Secretary General and Senior Vice President as well, the court declined to set aside those elections on appeal because the electees to those posts were not before the court and notice in the writ petition had been limited to the challenge to the President's election. The respondents before the appellate court stated they had no objection to setting aside those other elections; however, in the absence of the elected persons' presence before the court, the appellate court would not set aside those elections sua sponte. The appellant was advised to pursue independent proceedings if he wished to challenge those elections.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed and the order of the Single Judge dated 04.01.2012 is affirmed. In particular, the deletion of Article XIII(d) was effective from 05.02.2011, the rejection of respondent No. 2's nomination on the basis of Article XIII(d) was illegal, the appellant's election as President was set aside and a fresh election for President was directed. The court refused to stay the fresh election process. No order as to costs was made.

Implications (direct consequences on the parties)

  • The Single Judge's decision is affirmed and the specific relief granted by that court (setting aside the appellant's election as President and directing a fresh election) remains effective.
  • Article XIII(d) is treated as having stood deleted with effect from 05.02.2011, thereby invalidating the April 2011 elections conducted on its basis to the extent judicially challenged.
  • The court declined to set aside elections to Secretary General and Senior Vice President on appeal because the electees to those posts were not before the court; those elections may be challenged independently by the appellant or other interested parties.
  • The appellant's request for a stay of the fresh elections was denied and the appellate court noted that the election process was already in motion; the appellant may prosecute separate proceedings if he wishes to challenge other elections.
  • No order as to costs was made.

Broader legal effect: The court's reasoning reinforces existing authorities distinguishing amendments to a society's objects (caught by Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act) from amendments to a society's internal rules governing elections (which are within the competence of the General Body). The judgment emphasises democratic and policy considerations applicable to national federations, but the court did not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying and following cited authorities.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sh. Dushyant Sharma v. Haryana Wrestling Association & Ors. S

    JUDGMENT

    RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.

    Caveat No. 37/2012

    The counsel for the caveator/respondent No. 3 has appeared. The caveat stands discharged.

    LPA No. 18/2012

    1. The challenge in the appeal is to the order dated 04.01.2012 of the learned Single Judge allowing W.P(C) No. 4860/2011 filed by the respondents No. 1&2 and declaring Article XIII(d) of the Constitution of the respondent No. 3 Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) to have stood deleted on 05.02.2011 and declaring the elections held by respondent No. 3 WFI between 05.04.2011 and 15.04.2011 (on the basis of said Article XIII(d)) to be illegal and yet further setting aside the election of the appellant (during the said elections) to the post of President of the respondent No. 3 WFI and consequently directing fresh election for the said post.

    2. Article XIII (d) supra is as under:-

    “It shall be a mandatory requirement for elections to the post of President, Senior Vice President and Secretary General that only those members, who had held the office in the outgoing Executive Committee of WFI for a period of 4 years shall be eligible to contest the election.”

    The said Article was purportedly introduced in the Constitution of respondent No. 3 WFI in the year 2007.

    3. It was the case of the respondents No. 1&2.writ petitioners that a Special Meeting of the General Body of the respondent No. 3 WFI was held on 05.02.2011 wherein amendment of the Constitution of the respondent No. 3 WFI was approved and one of the amendments approved was of deletion of aforesaid Article XIII(d). It was further the case in the writ petition that notwithstanding the said deletion, nomination of the respondent No. 2 Mr. P.V Rathee, being the representative of the respondent No. 1 Haryana Wrestling Association for the post of President of the respondent No. 3 WFI in the elections to be held on 15.04.2011 was rejected treating the aforesaid Article XIII(d) to be then in force.

    4. The learned Single Judge in a detailed well considered judgment has found/held:

    (i) that the respondent No. 3 WFI in its counter affidavit filed before the learned Single Judge admitted and acknowledged the position that vide Resolution passed in the General Council meeting held on 05.02.2011, Article XIII(d) was deleted and the said position was confirmed in the next meeting of the General Council held on 18.06.2011;

    (ii) that notwithstanding the Minutes of the Meeting held on 05.02.2011 being not confirmed till 18.06.2011 i.e till after the holding of the elections, the said deletion had come into force on 05.02.2011 itself;

    (iii) that the meeting held on 05.02.2011 was validly called by the President of respondent No. 3 WFI who was authorized to call the said meeting;

    (iv) that there was no requirement for the amendment to be registered with the Registrar of Societies and the amendment by way of deletion of Article XIII(d) supra, to come into operation was not dependent upon registration thereof with the Registrar of Societies;

    (v) that the respondents No. 1&2 writ petitioners were entitled to maintain the writ petition challenging the election to the post of President alone without challenging the election to the other posts of Senior Vice President & Secretary General also affected by Article XIII(d) supra;

    (vi) that the Government of India vide its communication dated 07.04.2011 had objected to the restrictive Article XIII(d) supra being enforced in the election scheduled on 15.04.2011 and to the schedule of elections which did not give due time at each stage of the election process.

    Accordingly, it was held that Article XIII(d) stood deleted on 05.02.2011 and rejection of nomination of respondent No. 2 for the post of President on the basis thereof was illegal and the election of appellant to the said post set aside and re-election ordered.

    5. The senior counsel for the appellant has challenged each of the findings aforesaid of the learned Single Judge. It is contended that the President of respondent No. 3 WFI was not empowered to call the meeting of 05.02.2011, which could be called by the Secretary General only; that the Resolution in the said meeting deleting Article XIII(d) could not under Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act, 1860 be effective without a second such meeting being convened at an interval of one month after the former meeting and which was admittedly not held and the confirmation of the Minutes of the Meeting of 05.02.2011 according to the respondents also took place only on 18.06.2011; that Article XIII(d) thus was in force at the time of election on 15.04.2011; that the Registrar of Societies also vide letter dated 23.03.2011 had refused to incorporate the amendments purportedly carried out in the meeting of 05.02.2011 for the said reason; that thus the nomination of the respondent No. 2 for the post of President being contrary to Article XIII(d) was rightly rejected.

    6. We are unable to find merit in any of the contentions aforesaid and concur with and affirm the findings on each of the aforesaid aspects arrived at by the learned Single Judge. We have enquired from the counsel for the appellant as to how Section 12 of the Societies Act, which applies to alteration of the purpose or purposes for which the Society has been established, is attracted to the amendment aforesaid. The senior counsel for the appellant with reference to Sections 1 and 2 of the Societies Act has contended that since the Rules and Regulations of the Society are to be filed along with the Memorandum of Association, the provisions of section 12, would apply to an amendment of the said Rules and Regulations also. We are again, unable to agree. Section 12, if was intended to apply to amendment of Memorandum of Association, nothing prevented the legislature from providing so. The legislature however chose to restrict the applicability of Section 12 to alteration of the purpose for which the Society has been established. Thus the same cannot have any applicability to any other alterations in the Memorandum of Association, even if the Rules and Regulations are to be said to be a part thereof.

    7. We may notice that the Apex Court in Supreme Court Bar Association v. B.D Kaushik (2011) 11 SCALE 72 observed that Rules relating to exercise of right to vote and contest the elections do not amount to altering, amending or changing the aims and objects of the Society and can be done without the consent of the Registrar as provided in the Societies Registration Act. It was also held that a Society is entitled to have its own Rules and Regulations which are in the nature of a contract amongst the members of the Society and which though required to be registered under the Societies Registration Act do not acquire any statutory character and the authority to amend, vary and rescind such Rules vests in the General Body of the members of the Society. A Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court recently in Allahabad High School Society v. State of UP MANU/UP/1373/2011 noticed the distinction between amendment of objects of the Society and amendment of Rules of the Society and held the provisions of Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act to be not applicable to amendment of Rules and which amendment was held to be possible at a meeting of the Society. The said view was confirmed by the Apex Court in judgment reported as (2011) 6 SCC 118.

    8. Besides the aforesaid, we on a larger plane are of the opinion that a Clause as Article XIII(d) supra in the Constitution of respondent No. 3 WFI which is a National Sports Body recognized by the Government of India in the sport of Wrestling, is undemocratic and unsustainable. Once elections of the respondent No. 3 WFI are required to be held periodically, we find it absolutely illogical to restrict the elections to the post of President, Secretary General and Vice President to only those who have held the said office earlier. There is no basis whatsoever for perpetuating control and management of the respondent Federation in a few persons and it ought to be left to the electorate of the Federation to elect whosoever they find most suitable for discharging the obligations thereunder. A clause as Article XIII(d) smacks of creation of fiefdom which cannot be permitted. The elected officials cannot in this manner be given carte blanche which will have the effect of eliminating elections and allowing them to retain their offices indefinitely. Decentralized power is preferable to power centralized and concentrated. Article XIII(d) supra tantamounts to one-man rule which is in negation of democracy and jeopardizes the democratic mechanism intended for the Societies.

    9. This Court in M/S. Narinder Batra…Petitioner v. Union Of India…S ILR (2009) 4 Delhi 280 noticed the Guidelines of the Government mandating that in order to be entitled to financial assistance or recognition as a National Level Body by the Union Government, the same is required to be a Society or an Association or a Federation which enforces democracy by fixing the tenure of the office bearers. It was further observed that such national level federations enjoy a monopoly position and are directly concerned with selection of teams to represent the country and the same set of office bearers cannot be permitted to control selection or act in other matters relating to National Sports Federations influencing the development of sports in the country. It was yet further held that if such tenure clause was not enforced, the office bearers could be repeatedly elected allowing them to dominate the affairs of the Association/Federation resulting in creation of monopoly having the potential to damage the sport itself. A limited office tenure minimizes if not eliminates allegations, criticisms and elements of nepotism, favouritism and bias of any kind. New office bearers with fresh ideas and enthusiasm can make a valuable addition to such organizations and also ensure removal of corrupt and undesirable in the organization.

    10. Notice may also be taken of Dental Council of India v. Dr. H.R Prem Sachdeva(1999) 8 SCC 471 also laying down that continuance in office of the elected/nominated members should not go on for perpetuity. Similarly in Kashmir Singh v. UOI(2008) 7 SCC 259 also though relating to Shiromani Gurudwara Prabhandhak Committee, it was held that Article 310 of the Constitution of India provides for a tenure and it does not contemplate a life tenure or a permanent term; Article 16 which is a species of the equality clause contained in Article 14, speaks of grant of equal opportunity to all; allowing a person to hold public office indefinitely would be opposed to the Constitutional scheme; Constitution of India does not envisage holding of office in perpetuity. It was yet further held that allowing holding office in perpetuity has the potential of abuse of position. Though in relation to a Cooperative Society, it was similarly held in Bhandara District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra1993 Supp. (3) SCC 259 that it is not meant to be run as a close preserve of an individual or a group of persons and it is desirable to have active participation of as many members as possible.

    11. We, for this reason also are of the opinion that no interference is required in the discretion exercised by the learned Single Judge in quashing the election to the post of President and which discretion is found to be in consonance with the principles of equity, justice and good conscience.

    12. We are therefore not inclined to entertain this appeal.

    13. The senior counsel for the appellant at this stage has contended that once the learned Single Judge has found the elections to the other two posts of Secretary General & Vice President also to be bad, he has erred in not setting aside the same and in setting aside the election to the post of President only.

    14. We may notice that though the respondents No. 1 & 2 writ petitioners had filed the writ petition challenging the elections to the other posts also but finding that respondent No. 2 had filed nomination for the post of President only, notice of the petition was issued limited to the challenge to the election for the post of President. The counsel for the respondents No. 1&2 today also states that the respondents No. 1&2 have no objection to setting aside of the election of other two posts also and which election suffers from the same malaise as the election to the post of President which has been set aside.

    15. The senior counsel for the appellant also contends that if the elections to the other two posts are also set aside, the appellant will have the option in the fresh elections ordered by the learned Single Judge to contest for either of the posts.

    16. However, in the absence of the electees to the other two posts before this Court, we cannot set aside the election thereto. We have enquired from the senior counsel for the appellant as to why the appellant, if interested to contest the election to the other two posts, has not taken independent remedy for having the same set aside.

    17. The senior counsel for the appellant at this stage states that the fresh elections directed be stayed to enable the appellant to apply for setting aside of the elections to the post of Vice President and Secretary General also.

    18. We are however not inclined to accede to the said request also. The election to the post of President would be independent of the elections to the post of Secretary General and Vice President when set aside. Moreover, we are informed that the election process is already in motion. It is open to the appellant to take independent proceedings challenging the elections to the other two posts and on succeeding in the same seek directions for simultaneous holding of the elections.

    19. The appeal is therefore dismissed. No order as to costs.

    Dasti under signature of the Court Master.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sh. Dushyant Sharma v. Haryana Wrestling Association & Ors. S
    (Jan 10, 2012)