AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by M.L. Mehta, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

Source material: judgment of M.L. Mehta, J.; appeal against ITAT order dated 12.03.2010.

The assessee is a Trust constituted under the will of the settler Lala Ram Khairati Ram. The Trust obtained registration under Section 12A of the Income Tax Act in December 1974. On the strength of that registration, the Trust received income‑tax exemptions in assessments under section 143(3) for assessment years 1996‑97 to 2005‑06.

For the assessment year 2006‑07, while the Trust filed a return seeking exemption under sections 11 and 12, the Additional Director of Income Tax (Exemptions) denied the claim in the assessment proceeding under section 143(3). The Trust's appeal against that assessment order before the CIT(A) was stated to be pending.

On 23 March 2008 the Trust was served with a show‑cause notice under section 12AA(3) as to why the registration under section 12A dated 4 December 1974 should not be cancelled. The Trust replied contesting jurisdiction and other points. Despite that, the Director of Income Tax (Exemptions) cancelled the registration by order dated 30 June 2009 with effect from assessment year 2002‑03, holding that the activities of the Trust were not in accordance with its objects.

The Trust appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), which allowed the Trust's appeal and restored its registration by an order dated 12 March 2010. The Revenue challenged that ITAT order before the High Court, agitating the legal question whether registration granted under section 12A in 1974 could be cancelled or withdrawn under section 12AA(3).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the ITAT was correct in holding that the registration granted under Section 12A on 04.12.1974 to the assessee could not be cancelled/withdrawn by the authorities under Section 12AA(3) of the Income Tax Act?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (as represented in the opinion)

  • The Trust obtained registration under Section 12A(a) in December 1974 (via Form 10A) and therefore the registration could not be cancelled under Section 12AA(3).
  • Section 12A (as it stood at the time of registration) did not provide for cancellation of registration once granted; the cancellation mechanism in Section 12AA(3) was introduced later and does not retrospectively empower the Commissioner to cancel registrations granted under Section 12A(a) prior to the amendment.

Revenue's Arguments (as represented in the opinion)

  • Once registration is granted, the authority that grants it is equally entitled to withdraw it; the power to grant implies the power to withdraw.
  • Section 12AA(3), which was inserted by Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 with effect from 1 October 2004, empowers the Commissioner to cancel registration if satisfied that activities are not genuine or not in accordance with objects; therefore the Commissioner could cancel registrations previously granted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Manav Vikas Avam Sewa Sansthan, ITA No. 161/2007 (Allahabad High Court), decided 24‑02‑2010 Dealt with a similar question whether registration under Section 12A could be cancelled; considered applicability of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act and effect of Section 12AA(3) introduced w.e.f. 01.10.2004. The Court treated this decision as a directly similar authority supporting the proposition that Section 12AA(3) is not retrospective and that authorities lacked inherent power prior to the amendment to cancel registrations granted earlier; it was relied upon to support the conclusion in favour of the assessee.
Oxford Academy for Career Development v. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Lucknow, (2009) 315 ITR 382 (All.) Held that an order by the Commissioner granting registration under Section 12A is a quasi‑judicial order and that Section 21 of the General Clauses Act does not apply to permit rescission; noted that Section 12AA(3) was introduced w.e.f. 01.10.2004 and is not retrospective. Relied upon (through the Allahabad High Court decision) to support the proposition that the Commissioner had no power to rescind or withdraw registration granted before Section 12AA(3) and that cancellation under Section 12AA(3) could not be applied retrospectively.
Ghaurul Hasan v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1987 SC 107 Legal ratio on the nature of certain orders and their relation to powers under Section 21 of the General Clauses Act (as relied on by other courts). Referenced (via the Welham Boy's School Society discussion) to support the proposition that quasi‑judicial orders like registration orders do not fall within the category of orders subject to rescission under Section 21 of the General Clauses Act.
Welham Boy's School Society (Uttranchal High Court — citation not fully reproduced in the opinion) Discussed applicability of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act to orders of the Commissioner and concluded that rescission was not available; considered non‑retrospectivity of Section 12AA(3). Used to illustrate judicial treatment that Section 21 does not empower the Commissioner to rescind registration orders and that Section 12AA(3) did not have retrospective effect to permit cancellation of earlier registrations.
Bharati Vidyapeeth v. ITO (Pune), (2008) 119 TTJ (Pune) 261 Held that Section 12AA(3) empowers cancellation only where registration has been granted under sub‑section (1)(b) of Section 12AA, and that Section 12AA(3) does not empower cancellation of registrations granted under Section 12A. Relied upon to support the Court's interpretation that the cancellation power under Section 12AA(3) was confined to registrations granted under specified clauses and did not extend to registrations like that of the assessee under Section 12A(a) of 1974.
Guru Nanak Public School v. Director of Income Tax (Exemptions), Delhi — ITA Nos. 3267.Del/2008 & 3268.Del/2008 (Tribunal) Tribunal decisions holding that the Commissioner has no power under Section 12AA(3) to cancel registration earlier granted under Section 12A(a). Cited as supporting authorities of similar import; the Court noted their conclusions as part of the body of tribunal decisions aligned with the assessee's position.
Kapoor Educational Society v. Commissioner of Income Tax, (2010) 134 TTJ (Lucknow) 250 Tribunal decision, consistent with others, that the Commissioner cannot cancel registration granted under Section 12A(a) using Section 12AA(3). Included among the tribunal decisions relied upon by the assessee and acknowledged by the Court as further support for the conclusion reached.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a textual and historical analysis of Sections 12A and 12AA of the Income Tax Act as they evolved over time. Key points from the Court's step‑by‑step analysis (as stated in the opinion) are:

  • Section 12A was originally enacted (Finance Act, 1972) effective 1 April 1973 and, at various times, contained provisions regarding conditions for registration of trusts. The title of Section 12A was changed on 1 June 2007 from "Conditions as to registration of the Trusts etc." to "Conditions for applicability of Sections 11 and 12", and as a result it no longer itself provided for registration procedures.
  • Section 12AA — a specific procedure for registration — was introduced with effect from 1 April 1997 to prescribe the process for registration (including sub‑section (1) dealing with the Commissioner calling for documents and satisfying himself before registering under clause (b) of sub‑section (1)).
  • There was no provision for cancellation of registration under Section 12AA until sub‑section (3) was inserted with effect from 1 October 2004 by Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004. That sub‑section (3) authorised cancellation where registration had been granted under clause (b) of sub‑section (1) of Section 12AA, and, after a further amendment by Finance Act, 2010 (effective 1 June 2010), the power was extended to registrations obtained under Section 12A.
  • From a conjoint reading of Section 12AA(1)(b) and Section 12AA(3), the Court concluded that, prior to the 1 June 2010 amendment, the cancellation power under Section 12AA(3) applied only to registrations granted under clause (b) of Section 12AA(1) (i.e., registrations granted under the procedure in Section 12AA), and not to registrations granted earlier under Section 12A(a) (such as the assessee's 1974 registration).
  • Consequently, when the Director cancelled the Trust's 1974 registration by invoking Section 12AA(3) in an order dated 30 June 2009, that action was beyond the Commissioner's power as it sought to cancel a registration that was granted under Section 12A(a) before the 1 October 2004/1 June 2010 changes that would have enabled such cancellation.
  • The Court also considered and relied upon prior judicial pronouncements (High Court and Tribunal decisions) which held that Section 12AA(3) was not retrospective and that the Commissioner lacked an inherent power to rescind registrations granted earlier; these authorities reinforced the textual interpretation described above.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Appeal dismissed.

The Court answered the substantial question of law in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue, holding that the Commissioner did not have the power to cancel or withdraw the registration granted under Section 12A(a) on 4 December 1974 by invoking Section 12AA(3) as it then stood.

Direct implications for the parties:

  • The High Court dismissed the Revenue's appeal against the ITAT order which had restored the Trust's registration; the ITAT decision in favour of the assessee stands.
  • As applied to this case, the Director's order dated 30 June 2009 cancelling the registration w.e.f. AY 2002‑03 was not sustained.

Broader implications:

The Court's decision rests on the statutory reading that, until the amendment effective 1 June 2010, Section 12AA(3) did not empower the Commissioner to cancel registrations granted under Section 12A(a) prior to the insertion of Section 12AA(3). The opinion relied upon a line of tribunal and High Court authorities that reached similar conclusions regarding non‑retrospectivity of Section 12AA(3) and the absence of inherent power to rescind earlier registration orders. The opinion did not purport to create a novel legal principle beyond this interpretative application of the statutory amendments and the cited authorities.

    Director Of Income Tax (Exemptions) v. M/S. Mool Chand Khairati Ram Trust

    M.L MEHTA, J. (ORAL)

    1. This is an appeal directed against the order dated 12.03.2010 of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as the “Tribunal”) whereby the order dated 30th June, 2009 of the Director of Income Tax (Exemptions) passed under Section 12AA(1)(b) read with Section 12A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short “the Act”) was set aside and the appeal of the assessee was allowed. By the impugned order, the Tribunal also restored the registration granted to the assessee under Section 12A of the Act.

    2. The facts in brief are like this. The assessee Trust was created on the basis of the will left behind by the Settler late Lala Ram Khairati Ram. It got registration under Section 12A of the Act in December 1974. Based on this, the assessee got exemption of the income tax in the assessments under Section 143(3) for the assessment years 1996-97 to 2005-2006. It was in the assessment year 2006-2007, when the assessee filed return seeking exemption under Sections 11 and 12 of the Act, that the Additional Director of Income Tax (Exemptions), while proceeding to make assessment under Section 143(3), denied the claim of exemption. The assessee preferred appeal against the said order before the Commissioner, Income Tax (Appeal) [for short CIT(A)], which is stated to be pending. On 23rd March, 2008, assessee was served with a show-cause notice under Section 12AA(3) of the Act as to why the registration granted under Section 12A of the Act vide order dated 4 December, 1974 should not be cancelled. The assessee filed detailed reply contending therein inter alia the action of cancellation to be without jurisdiction. However, the Director of Income Tax (Exemptions) (for short “DIT”) cancelled the registration under Section 12AA(3) with effect from December 2002-2003 vide his order dated 30 June, 2009. The Director while passing such an order, reasoned as under:-

    “10. In view of the facts mentioned above, I hold that the activities of the trust are not in accordance with the object of the trust and therefore, the registration granted vide Regn. No. DLI(IT68)/74-75 dated 4.12.1974 is cancelled. It has been observed that the activities of the assessee have definitely been in violation of the objects of the trust for the past several years (chart for assessment year 2002-03 to 2006-07 is mentioned in the order earlier). Accordingly, registration u/s 12A is cancelled w.e.f AY 2002-03.”

    3. Against this order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Tribunal, which came to be allowed vide the impugned order dated 12 March, 2010. It is against this order that the Revenue has preferred this appeal. The order was also passed restoring the registration. Since the question of law was raised by the Revenue, the appeal is admitted on the following substantial question of law:

    “Whether the ITAT was right in holding that the registration granted under Section 12A on 04.12.1974 to the assessee could not be cancelled/withdrawn by the Authorities under Section 12AA(3) of the Act?”

    4. With the consent of the counsel of both the parties, we have heard the matter finally. It is admitted case that the assessee was granted registration under Section 12A (a) of the Act in December 1974. Learned counsel for the assessee has drawn our attention to the application for registration of the assessee as charitable trust/institution under Section 12A(a) of the Act, as made in Form 10A, and also registration granted under the said provision, namely, Section 12A(a) of the Act. That being so, the only question that calls for consideration is, as to whether registration so granted under Section 12A(a) could not be cancelled/withdrawn by the Revenue under Section 12AA(3) of the Act as submitted by the learned counsel for the assessee? On the other hand, it was submitted by the learned counsel for the Revenue that if after the grant of registration under Section 12A(a), the Authority is satisfied that the conditions prescribed under the said Section are not satisfied, registration could be withdrawn under Section 12AA(3) which came to be inserted by Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 with effect from 1st October, 2004. He submitted that under the law, the Authority, which is entitled to grant registration, is equally entitled to withdraw such a registration, just as power of granting registration is available so is the power of withdrawing.

    5. There is also no dispute that the registration, which is sought to be withdrawn by the Authority, is by virtue of power vested in the Commissioner under Section 12AA(3) of the Act. The order which was passed by the DIT was under Section 12AA(1)(b) read with Section 12A of the Act. For proper appreciation of the rival submissions based on the interpretation of sections 12a and 12aa(1)(b) and 12aa(3), it would be useful to reproduce relevant parts of these Sections, which are as under:

    “12A. [Conditions for applicability of sections 11 and 12.] - The provisions of section 11 and section 12 shall not apply in relation to the income of any trust or institution unless the following conditions are fulfilled, namely:

    (a) the person in receipt of the income has made an application for registration of the trust or institution in the prescribed form and in the prescribed manner to the 8[***] Commissioner before the 1st day of July, 1973, or before the expiry of a period of one year from the date of the creation of the trust or the establishment of the institution, 9[whichever is later and such trust or institution is registered under section 12AA] :

    “12AA. Procedure for registration. - (1) The 2[***] Commissioner, on receipt of an application for registration of a trust or institution made under clause (a) [or clause (aa) of subsection (1)] of section 12A, shall—

    (a) call for such documents or information from the trust or institution as he thinks necessary in order to satisfy himself about the genuineness of activities of the trust or institution and may also make such inquiries as he may deem necessary in this behalf; and

    (b) after satisfying himself about the objects of the trust or institution and the genuineness of its activities, he—

    (i) shall pass an order in writing registering the trust or institution;

    (ii) shall, if he is not so satisfied, pass an order in writing refusing to register the trust or institution,

    and a copy of such order shall be sent to the applicant :

    Provided that no order under sub-clause (ii) shall be passed unless the applicant has been given a reasonable opportunity of being heard.

    (2) …..

    (3) Where a trust or an institution has been granted registration under clause (b) of sub-section (1) [or has obtained registration at any time under Section 12A [as it stood before its amendment by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1996 (33 of 1996)] and subsequently the Commissioner is satisfied that the activities of such trust or institution are not genuine or are not being carried out in accordance with the objects of the trust or institution, as the case may be, he shall pass an order in writing cancelling the registration of such trust or institution:”

    6. At the outset, it may be pertinent to note that the title of Section 12A “Conditions for applicability of Sections 11 and 12” was substituted with effect from 1 June, 2007 in place of previous title “Conditions as to registration of the Trusts etc.”. It means that prior to 1 June, 2007, this Section itself provided conditions regarding registration of trust etc. It is noted here because with the substitution of the present title, this Section no longer provides for registration of trust etc. A special provision has been enacted in Section 12AA providing for procedure for registration of trust etc. with effect from 1 April, 1997. It is also noted that Section 12A was inserted in the statute book by the Finance Act, 1972 with effect from 1 April, 1973. It was omitted and was again restored with effect from 1 April, 1989. Section 12A, as it stood at the time when it provided for registration of trust, nowhere provided for cancellation of the registration once granted. It is also pertinent to note that the words “such trust or institution is registered under Section 12AA” were also substituted in this Section with effect from 1 April, 1997. In fact, this Section even now nowhere stipulates about the cancellation or withdrawal of the registration, once granted under the said Section. It is only under Section 12AA, which came in the statute book with effect from 1 April, 1997 that a fresh procedure for registration of the trust or institution is prescribed. Even under this Section 12AA, there was no provision for cancellation of registration once granted till the enactment of sub-Section (3) with effect from 1 October, 2004. There is no dispute with regard to this fact that the provision regarding cancellation of registration came to be introduced for the first time by virtue of sub-Section (3) in Section 12AA with effect from 1 October, 2004. This sub-Section (3) provides that when a trust or an institution has been granted registration under clause (b) of sub-Section 1 and subsequently the Commissioner is satisfied that the activities of such trust or institution are not genuine or are not being carried out in accordance with the objects of the trust or institution, as the case may be, he shall pass an order in writing cancelling the registration of such trust or institution. A plain reading of this provision would show that Section 12AA empowered the CIT to grant the registration in those cases where the assessee applied for such registration under sub-Section (1) thereof. Sub-Section (1) provides that the CIT on receipt of an application for registration of a trust or institution made in clause (a) or clause (aa) of sub-Section (1) of Section 12A, shall -

    (a) ….

    (b) after satisfying himself about the objects of the trust or institution and the genuineness of its activities, -

    (i) shall pass an order in writing registering the trust or institution,

    (ii) shall, if he is not so satisfied, pass an order in writing refusing to register the trust or institution.

    7. From the conjoint reading of sub-Section (1) clause (b) and sub-Section (3) of Section 12AA, it would be seen that the cancellation of the registration was provided where the registration was granted under clause (b) of sub-section (1). Further cancellation under sub-Section (3) was also provided where the registration was obtained at any time under Section 12A (may be under clause (a) or clause (aa) of sub-Section (1) of Section 12A). But this power of cancellation of registration obtained under Section 12A came to be incorporated by way of amendment introduced by the Finance Act, 2010 with effect from 1 June, 2010. That being the interpretation of sub-Section (3), it is amply clear that the power to cancel the registration once granted was only confined to the registration granted under clause (b) of sub-Section 1 of Section 12AA till before 1 June, 2010. Of course, now with effect from 1 June, 2010, the power vests with the Commissioner even to cancel the registration granted under any of the clauses of sub-section (1) of Section 12A. In that view of interpretation, we are of the considered view that there was no power vested with the Commissioner to cancel or withdraw the registration granted to the assessee under Section 12A(a) in the year 1974.

    8. Similar question also arose before the Allahabad High Court in CIT v. Manav Vikas Avam Sewa Sansthan, ITA No. 161/2007 decided on 24 February, 2010, wherein the reliance was placed in the case of Lucknow Bench in Oxford Academy for Career Development v. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Lucknow, (2009) 315 ITR 382 (All), wherein it was held as under:-

    “Regarding cancellation of registration which was granted on 01.04.1999 under Section 12A of the Act, it is true that there was no express provision in Section 12A of the Act for cancellation of the Registration. The applicability of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 was discussed by the Uttranchal High Court in the case of Welham Boy's School Society (supra), where it was observed that any order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax under Section 12A is a quasi-judicial order, which does not fall in the category of “orders” mentioned in Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 by relying the ratio laid down in the case of Ghaurul Hasan v. State of Rajasthan reported in AIR 1987 SC 107. The High Court observed that by virtue of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, the Commissioner of Income Tax had no power to rescind the order passed earlier by the Commissioner granting registration to the petitioner's society. It may be mentioned that section 12AA(3) was incorporated w.e.f 01.10.2004 to empower the Commissioner to cancel the registration granted to a trust or institution. The same is not applicable retrospectively and in the assessee's case for the assessment years under consideration. The object of this provision is not clarification or explanatory, so prior to that date, the authorities granting registration had no inherent power to withdraw or revoke the registration already granted. The order cancelling the registration granted to a trust or institution under Section 12AA of the Act being a quasi-judicial order does not fall within the category of orders mentioned under Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, which provides that the power conferred on an authority empower to issue orders including the power to rescind such orders and the Commissioner would not have power to rescind the order passed by the Commissioner earlier granting the registration to a trust or institution.”

    9. Learned counsel appearing for the assessee also relied upon the case of Bharati Vidyapeeth v. ITO (Pune), (2008) 119 TTJ (Pune) 261, where in was held as under:

    “Sec.12AA(3) empowers the CIT to cancel such registration if he is satisfied that activities of trust or institution are not genuine or are not being carried out in accordance with the objects of the trust or institution as the case may be. The combined reading of both the sections makes it clear that registration can be cancelled only in those cases where the registration has been granted under sub-s. (1b) of s. 12AA. This section nowhere empowers the CIT to cancel or withdraw the registration granted under s.12A In the absence of such power, in our opinion, the registration granted under s. 12A cannot be withdrawn or cancelled.”

    10. In addition to this, learned counsel also relied upon the decision of the Tribunal in the cases of Guru Nanak Public School v. Director of Income Tax (Exemptions), Delhi, in ITA Nos. 3267.Del/2008 & 3268.Del/2008 and the case of Kapoor Educational Society v. Commissioner of Income Tax, (2010) 134 TTJ (Lucknow) 250. There is no need to reproduce what has been held in these cases as the sum and substance of these cases is also that the Commissioner has no power under Section 12AA(3) to cancel the registration granted earlier under Section 12A(a).

    11. In view of our above discussion, we answer the question in affirmative in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Director Of Income Tax (Exemptions) v. M/S. Mool Chand Khairati Ram Trust
    (Apr 4, 2011)