Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for possession, perpetual injunction and mandatory injunction in respect of house No. B-1, Khasra No. 234, Bhaskar Compound, Abul Fazal Enclave, Part-I, Jamia Nagar, New Delhi-110025, alleging that the defendants had unauthorizedly and illegally occupied the property during her absence while she went to the USA to reside with her daughter. The plaintiff claimed ownership based on documents dated 2.6.2004 (General Power of Attorney, Agreement to Sell and Purchase, Will, Possession Letter, receipt etc.), and asserted that she had obtained possession under an Agreement to Sell executed in her favour, invoking the provisions of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

By IA No. 7516/2010 (purporting to be filed under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure), the plaintiff sought a direction to pay the deficient stamp duty on the Agreement to Sell and Purchase dated 2.6.2004 which had been filed in original. Defendant No. 1 opposed the application, objecting to admission of an insufficiently stamped document and raising a preliminary objection that Section 151 (a procedural provision) was being invoked when the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (a substantive code) governed the matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court should permit the plaintiff to pay the deficient stamp duty and prescribed penalty so that the insufficiently stamped Agreement to Sell dated 2.6.2004 may be admitted in evidence, in accordance with the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (notably Sections 33, 35, 38 and 39).
  2. Whether the application filed by the plaintiff under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure is maintainable, or whether the application should be treated as one under Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899.
  3. Whether Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (part performance) is attracted given the plaintiff's claim of possession under the Agreement to Sell.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Position

  • The plaintiff claims ownership and possession of the suit property on the basis of documents dated 2.6.2004, including an Agreement to Sell and Purchase and other related instruments, and relies on Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act as applicable.
  • By IA No. 7516/2010 (filed purportedly under Section 151 CPC), the plaintiff sought directions to pay the deficient stamp duty on the Agreement dated 2.6.2004 so the document could be admitted in evidence.

Defendant No. 1's Arguments

  • There is no justification for admitting an insufficiently stamped document in evidence.
  • Preliminary objection that the plaintiff invoked Section 151 CPC (a procedural provision), whereas the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 contains the substantive provisions governing stamp duty and admissibility of instruments; thus, invocation of Section 151 CPC is improper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chilakuri Gangulappa v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Madanpalle, (2001) 4 SCC 197 Established that when an instrument produced in Court is found to be insufficiently stamped, Section 33 of the Indian Stamp Act applies; the Court may admit such a document if the party pays the deficient stamp duty together with a penalty (ten times the deficient duty where applicable), and in that event the Court should forward only a copy of the document with a certificate to the Collector. If the party refuses to pay, the original must be forwarded to the Collector. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's exposition in this case to determine that it should offer the plaintiff the choice to pay the deficient duty and prescribed penalty and, on payment, to forward a copy with the required certificate to the Collector. The Court followed the approach that payment allows admission in evidence and the original need not be sent to the Collector.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the procedure mandated by the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as set out in Sections 33, 35, 38 and 39, and summarized their operation:

  • Section 33 requires a person authorised to receive evidence (such as a Court) to impound an instrument that appears not to be duly stamped.
  • Section 35 provides that an instrument chargeable with duty shall not be admitted in evidence unless duly stamped; however, such an instrument may be admitted on payment of the requisite duty together with a penalty—either Rs.5 where applicable, or where ten times the amount of the deficient duty exceeds Rs.5, a sum equal to ten times the deficient duty.
  • Section 38 authorises that when a person impounding an instrument (who has authority to receive evidence) admits it on payment of the penalty, he shall send an authenticated copy together with a certificate stating duty and penalty to the Collector; in other cases the original is to be sent to the Collector.
  • Section 39 permits the Collector, where a copy is sent under Section 38(1), to refund any portion of the penalty in excess of Rs.5 if he thinks fit.

The Court treated the Supreme Court's decision in Chilakuri Gangulappa as clarifying that the trial Court must first ask the party producing an insufficiently stamped document whether they will pay the deficient duty and the prescribed penalty; upon agreement and payment the Court should admit the document in evidence and forward only a copy with a certificate to the Collector for adjudication under Section 40(1)(b). Only if the producing party refuses payment should the original be forwarded to the Collector.

Applying these statutory provisions and the precedent to the Agreement dated 2.6.2004, the Court held that the document was a contract for transfer of immovable property in the nature of part performance and that, under Article 23A of Schedule 1A (applicable to Delhi), 90% of the duty payable on a conveyance was required to be paid on that document. Consequently the Court directed the plaintiff to pay the balance of 90% of the duty which would have been payable on a conveyance at the relevant time, together with ten times the amount of the deficient stamp duty as penalty, within four weeks from the date of the order.

The Court further specified procedural consequences: on payment of the deficient duty and penalty the Registry shall send the requisite certificate under Section 38(1) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 to the Collector, detailing the amounts deposited; the original document need not be forwarded to the Collector in that event. If the plaintiff fails to deposit the sums as directed, the Registry shall send the original Agreement dated 2.6.2004 to the Collector pursuant to Section 38(2).

Regarding the objection to invocation of Section 151 CPC, the Court found no merit: the application can be treated as an application under Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act and is so treated.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The application (IA No. 7516/2010) is disposed of in the terms directed by the Court: the plaintiff is directed to pay the balance of 90% of the duty (as applicable to a conveyance at the time of the agreement) together with ten times the amount of the deficient stamp duty as penalty, within four weeks; on payment the Registry will forward the requisite certificate under Section 38(1) to the Collector and need not send the original document; if payment is not made, the Registry shall forward the original document to the Collector under Section 38(2).

Implications: The direct effect is procedural — the plaintiff must either pay the specified deficient duty and penalty within the prescribed time or have the original Agreement forwarded to the Collector for adjudication. The Court treated the application as properly falling under the Stamp Act provisions (Section 35) despite its caption under Section 151 CPC. The opinion does not announce or discuss any new legal principle beyond applying the statutory regime and the Supreme Court authority in Chilakuri Gangulappa; no broader precedent was set by this order.

Orders and Further Listing

The application stands disposed of in terms of the order. The main suit (CS(OS) No. 667/2008) was directed to be placed before the Joint Registrar on 24th October, 2011 for admission/denial of documents and before the Court on 12th March, 2012 for framing of issues.

    Rasheeda Siddiqui v. Mustafa Aleem Siddiqui

    V.K Jain, J.

    IA No. 7516/2010

    1. This is a suit for possession, perpetual injunction and mandatory injunction. The case of the plaintiff is that she is the owner of house No. B-1, Khasra No. 234, Bhaskar Compound, Abul Fazal Enclave, Part-I, Jamia Nagar, New Delhi-110025 and that the aforesaid property was unauthorizedly and illegally occupied by the defendants during her absence when she had gone to USA to reside with her daughter. The plaintiff has accordingly sought possession of the suit property from the defendants. She has also sought an injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with her possession. She has also claimed mesne profits from the defendants @ Rs. 30,000/- p.m

    2. The case of the plaintiff in respect of ownership of the suit property is based on documents such as General Power of Attorney, Agreement to Sell and Purchase, Will, Possession Letter, receipt etc. all dated 2.6.2004 The Agreement to Sell and Purchase purports to have been executed by Shri Shahzad Mirza in favour of the plaintiff, for a total sale consideration of Rs. 5 lakh. It is stated in the agreement that possession of property No. B-1 comprised in Khasra No. 234, Bhaskar Compound, Abul Fazal Enclave, Part-I, Jamia Nagar, New Delhi-110025 has been given to the purchaser Smt. Rasheeda Afaq Siddiqi. Since, the plaintiff claims to have obtained possession from the erstwhile owner of the suit property under an Agreement to Sell executed in her favour, the provisions of Section 53A of The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 come into application.

    3. Vide IA No. 7516/2010, purporting to have been filed under Section 151 Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiff has sought direction to pay the deficient stamp duty on the Agreement to Sell and Purchase dated 2.6.2004, which has been filed in original.

    4. The application has been opposed by defendant No. 1, who has stated that there is no justification for admitting the insufficiently stamped document in evidence. He has also taken a preliminary objection that the plaintiff has invoked Section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure, which is a procedural provision whereas the provisions of The Indian Stamp Act, 1899 are substantive provisions of law.

    5. Section 33 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, to the extent it is relevant, provides that every person having by law or by consent of parties, authority to receive evidence, and every person in charge of a public office, except an officer of police, before whom any instrument, chargeable, in his opinion, with duty, is produced or comes in the performance of his functions, shall, if it appears to him that such instrument is not duly stamped, impound the same. Section 35 of the Act, to the extent it is relevant, provides that an instrument which is chargeable with duty shall not be admitted in evidence unless it is duly stamped, but, such an instrument shall be admitted in evidence, on payment of the requisite duty together with a penalty of five rupees, or, when ten times the amount of the proper duty or deficient portion thereof exceeds five rupees, of a sum equal to ten times the proper duty/deficient duty. Section 38 of the Act provides that where the person impounding an instrument under Section 33 has the authority to receive evidence and he admits such instrument in evidence on payment of penalty specified in Section 35, he shall send to the Collector an authenticated copy of such instrument, together with a certificate in writing, stating the amount of duty and penalty levied in respect thereof, and shall send such amount to the Collector, or to such person which the Collector may appoint in his behalf. In other cases, the person impounding the instrument is required to send it in original to the Collector. Section 39 of the Act provides that when a copy of the instrument is sent to the Collector under Section 38, sub-section (1), he may, if thinks fit, refund any portion of the penalty in excess of rupees five which has been paid in respect of such instrument.

    It would thus be seen that whenever an instrument which is not stamped or is inadequately stamped is filed in a Court (which by law as authority to receive evidence), it is required to be impounded, but the Court has to admit such a document in evidence if the person relying upon the document pays the deficient stamp duty along with a penalty which is ten times the amount of deficient stamp duty. The Court after payment of the deficient stamp duty along with the prescribed penalty is required to forward a copy of the instrument along with the requisite certificate indicating the amount of duty as well as the penalty, to the Collector who may, in his discretion, remit such portion of the penalty as he may deem appropriate. In such a case, the original document need not be sent to the Collector. If however, the deficient stamp duty along with requisite penalty is not paid, the Court is required to send the document, in original, to the Collector.

    6. In Chilakuri Gangulappa v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Madanpalle, (2001) 4 SCC 197 the appellant filed a Civil Suit basing his claim on an agreement dated 26.6.1986 When the agreement was produced in the Court, it was found to be insufficiently stamped and accordingly it was impounded and forwarded to the delegatee of the Collector for taking further action in the matter. The delegatee of the Collector was of the view that these agreement required additional stamp duty of Rs. 3895/- and imposed penalty of Rs. 38950/- being ten times the deficient stamp duty. The order of the delegatee of the Collector was challenged before the Senior Civil Judge, who held that the appeal was not maintainable. A Revision filed before the High Court was also dismissed. When the matter reached the Supreme Court by way of Special Appeal, Supreme Court was of the view that it was Section 33 of the Indian Stamp Act, which was attracted to such an instrument. Noticing that the Court has the power to admit the document in evidence, if the party producing the same would pay the stamp duty together with a penalty amounting to ten times the deficient stamp duty, Supreme Court observed that when the Court chooses to admit the document on compliance with the condition of payment of deficient stamp duty along with prescribed penalty, then the Court needs to forward only a copy of the document to the Collector, together with the amount collected from the party for taking adjudicatory steps and in case the party refuses to pay the amount of the stamp duty and penalty, the Court has no other option except to impound the document and forward the same to the Collector. Supreme Court was of the view that the trial Court should have asked the appellant as to whether he would remit the deficient portion of the stamp duty together with a penalty amounting to ten times of the deficient stamp duty and if the appellant agreed to do so it had to proceed with the trial after admitting the documents in evidence and it had in the meanwhile to forward a copy of the document to the Collector for the purpose of adjudicating on the question of deficiency of stamp duty as provided in Section 40(1)(b) of the Act. It was further observed that only if the appellant was unwilling to remit the amount, the Court was to forward the original of the document itself to the Collector for the purpose of adjudicating on the question of deficiency of the stamp duty.

    7. The agreement dated 2.6.2004 being a contract for transfer of immovable property in the nature of part performance, article 23a of schedule 1a, applicable to Delhi, is attracted and 90% of the duty payable on a conveyance is required to be paid on this document. The plaintiff therefore, is directed to pay balance of 90% of the duty which was payable on a conveyance, at the time this agreement purports to have been executed, along with ten times the amount of deficient stamp duty as penalty, within four weeks from the date of this order. On payment of the deficient stamp duty along with penalty in terms of this order, the Registry shall send the requisite certificate under Section 38(1) of The Indian Stamp Act, 1899 to the Collector, detailing the amount of deficient stamp duty as well as the amount of penalty along with the amount deposited by the plaintiff. The original document in that case need not be sent to the Collector. If however, the plaintiff fails to deposit the deficient stamp duty and penalty in terms of this order, the Registry shall send the original agreement to sell and purchase dated 2.6.2004 to the Collector in terms of Section 38(2) of The Indian Stamp Act, 1899.

    8. As regards the objection that the plaintiff has invoked Section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure, I find no merit in the objection since the application of the plaintiff can always be treated as an application under Section 35 of The Indian Stamp Act and it is treated as such.

    The application stands disposed of in terms of this order.

    CS(OS) No. 667/2008

    The matter be listed before the Joint Registrar on 24th October, 2011 for admission/denial of documents and before the Court on 12th March, 2012 for framing of issues.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rasheeda Siddiqui v. Mustafa Aleem Siddiqui
    (Sep 5, 2011)