AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 37(2) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 37(2) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed a claim petition before the learned Arbitrator against M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd., also naming Mr. Anil Sarin and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. as respondents. Mr. Anil Sarin and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. objected to their impleadment as unnecessary parties. The learned Arbitrator passed an order dated 27.3.2008 deleting the names of respondents no. 2 and 3 from the array of parties, holding that they had been unnecessarily impleaded by the appellant. The appellant subsequently filed this appeal under section 37(2) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996, challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Mr. Anil Sarin, in his individual capacity, could be impleaded as a party to the arbitration claim despite being a director of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd.?
  2. Whether M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. was a proper party to the arbitration claim given that it was not a signatory to the agreement and not an owner of the property involved?
  3. Whether the learned Arbitrator was justified in deleting the names of Mr. Anil Sarin and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. from the array of parties?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the contractual and factual matrix to determine the propriety of impleading the respondents. It noted that Mr. Anil Sarin signed the agreement only in his capacity as Director of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and there was no arbitration agreement between the appellant and Mr. Sarin individually. Therefore, he could not be held liable or made a party to the claim in his personal capacity.

Regarding M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd., the court observed that although this entity was mentioned in the agreement and received Rs. 10 lac as part consideration, it was not a party to the agreement and did not sign it. The agreement to sell was exclusively between the appellant and M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd., which was the owner of the land in question. Since specific performance or compensation claims relate to ownership, only the owner could be impleaded. The payment to M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. was considered to have been made on behalf of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and not in an independent capacity.

The court further clarified that mere mention of a third party in a contract who has not signed it does not render that party liable under the contract or subject to the arbitration agreement. The appellant retained the option to recover the Rs. 10 lac independently if it so chose, but this did not justify impleading M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. as a party to the arbitration claim based on the contract.

Accordingly, the court found no infirmity in the learned Arbitrator’s order deleting the names of Mr. Anil Sarin and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. from the array of parties.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The decision confirms that only parties who are signatories to the arbitration agreement and contract can be impleaded in arbitration claims. Individuals acting solely as directors without personal arbitration agreements cannot be held liable individually. Similarly, entities mentioned but not parties to the contract, and not owners of the subject matter, cannot be impleaded for specific performance or compensation claims arising from that contract. The ruling directly affects the parties by removing unnecessary respondents but does not establish any new precedent beyond these principles.

    Karamshi Jethabhai Somaiya (Delhi) Trust v. Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. S

    By this appeal under section 37(2) of the arbitration & conciliation act, 1996, the appellant has assailed an order dated 27.3.2008 passed by the learned Arbitrator whereby the learned Arbitrator held that names of respondents no. 2 & 3 be deleted from the array of parties as they had been unnecessarily impleaded by the appellant in its claim.

    2. The brief facts relevant for the purpose of deciding this appeal are that the appellant filed a claim petition before the learned Arbitrator against M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and in this claim petition he also made Mr. Anil Sarin and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd as respondents. Both, Mr. Anil Sarin and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd filed objections objectionsthat they were not necessary parties resulting into passing of the above order by the learned Arbitrator. The learned Arbitrator observed that Mr. Anil Sarin was merely a Director of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd, the party to the contract, Mr. Anil Sarin could not be impleaded in his individual capacity as a party to the claim as there was no arbitration agreement between the appellant and Mr. Anil Sarin. Similarly, the learned Arbitrator observed that from reading of agreement to sell it was apparent that M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. was not a party to the agreement neither it was M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd, who had signed the agreement therefore M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. was not a party to the Arbitration Agreement and even otherwise no relief had been claimed against M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. therefore the name of M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. was also deleted.

    3. The factual situation is not in dispute. Mr. Anil Sarin had signed the agreement to sell in the capacity of a Director of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. Mr. Anil Sarin in his individual capacity cannot be made a party to the dispute raised by the appellant. Neither, Mr. Anil Sarin in his individual capacity can be held liable to pay awarded amount, if any, to the appellant. I, therefore consider that the order of the learned Arbitrator deleting the name of Mr. Anil Sarin does not suffer from any infirmity.

    4. As far as M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. is concerned, a perusal of agreement dated 16.12.2003 would show that this agreement to sell was made between M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and the appellant. In the very first paragraph of the agreement M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. has been referred to as ‘seller’ and appellant has been referred to as ‘purchaser’ and in the very next paragraph M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. has been shown as owner of 6.44 acre of land and other parts of land and the details of different khasra nos. and kila nos. of which M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. was the owner have been mentioned. In the body of agreement to sell, the mode of payment of consideration by the purchaser has been mentioned. Clause 2(a) states that a cheque of Rs. 10 lac was paid as part consideration and clause 2(c) states that this amount of Rs. 10 lac was paid to M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. and M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. would be known as second seller. At the bottom of the agreement a space was provided for signatures on behalf of three parties, one M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. through its authorized signatory M/s Anil Sarin; second M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. through its authorized signatory Mr. Anil Sarin and third being the appellant through its authorized signatory Mr. G.H Keswani. While signatures of Mr. Anil Sarin appeared against M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and signatures of Mr. G.H Keswani appeared against appellant but no signatures appear against M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. There is no dispute about the fact that this amount of Rs. 10 lac was received by M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. on behalf of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and not in an independent capacity, M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. is not the owner of the land and could not have entered into an agreement to sell with the appellant in view of the fact that it was not owner of the land. In the claim petition filed by the appellant, the appellant has asked for a specific performance of agreement to sell in respect of 6.44 acres of land which is owned by M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. Specific performance of agreement to sell cannot be ordered against a person, who is not the owner of the property. In the alternative, the appellant has asked for directing respondent to pay market value of the land. Obviously, only the owner of the land can be impleaded as a party for such a claim.

    5. In a claim petition made on the basis of a contract between the parties only those persons can be impleaded who are parties to the arbitration agreement and to the contract. Merely by mentioning a third party in the contract, who has not signed the contract, the third party cannot be made liable for the contract. In the present case, in the agreement to sell the name of M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. is mentioned but M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Limited is not a party to the contract either in the title of the contract or at the place of signing of the contract. The contract has been signed only on behalf of M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and not on behalf of M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd.. No doubt, the appellant has paid Rs. 10 lac to M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. The appellant is at liberty to recover this amount from M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd. independent of this contract, if it is the case of the appellant that this amount was not for purchase of the land from M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. Since, the amount was part of consideration for purchase of land from M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. and the receipt of this amount has not been disputed by M/s Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. I consider that in the claim petition M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Limited could not have been made as a party and the learned Arbitrator rightly struck off the name of M/s Anant Raj Exports Pvt. Ltd.

    I find no force in the appeal. The appeal is hereby dismissed.

    SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA, J.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Karamshi Jethabhai Somaiya (Delhi) Trust v. Anant Raj Agencies Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. S
    (Apr 16, 2009)