Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 3 FOREIGN AWARDS RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 1961
  • clause 42.2 of Section IV of the General Conditions of Contract.13.
  • Order 1 Rule 3 and Order 2 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • provision of Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act.42.
  • Convention) Act, 1937 (6 of 1937) (the Protocol Act)
  • Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act
  • Enforcement) Act, 1961.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 3 FOREIGN AWARDS RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 1961
  • clause 42.2 of Section IV of the General Conditions of Contract.13.
  • Order 1 Rule 3 and Order 2 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • provision of Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act.42.
  • Convention) Act, 1937 (6 of 1937) (the Protocol Act)
  • Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act
  • Enforcement) Act, 1961.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff submitted a bid in response to the first defendant NTPC's invitation for supply of a cooling water system package for its SIPAT Thermal Power Project. The bid involved collaboration with the second defendant, Alstom, pursuant to clauses in the Instructions for Bidders (IFB) allowing a bidder to club experience with associates, subject to a Joint Deed of Undertaking (JDU). The plaintiff and Alstom entered into a Project Agreement on 19.08.2004, which included an arbitration clause providing for arbitration in Paris under French law.

Alstom executed the JDU, undertaking joint responsibility and furnishing a bank guarantee for 1% of the contract value. The plaintiff's bid was accepted by NTPC on 31.05.2005, and the contract was signed on 30.06.2005. Subsequently, disputes arose when Alstom refused to furnish the bank guarantee as required under the JDU. The plaintiff sought to substitute a bank guarantee but NTPC refused. The plaintiff filed suit seeking injunctions against NTPC and Alstom to prevent encashment of the bank guarantee and to compel Alstom to furnish the guarantee.

Alstom filed an application under Section 45 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (the Act) to refer the dispute to arbitration in accordance with the Project Agreement. NTPC filed an application under Section 8 of the Act, contending the disputes fall under the arbitration clause in the General Conditions of Contract (GCC) and the suit should be stayed. The third defendant sought deletion from the suit, claiming no cause of action against it.

The Court heard arguments on the maintainability of the suit and the applicability of arbitration clauses in the respective agreements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disputes between the plaintiff and defendants are arbitrable under the respective arbitration agreements contained in the Project Agreement and the General Conditions of Contract.
  2. Whether the Court should refer the parties to arbitration under Section 8 or Section 45 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  3. Whether the suit is maintainable against defendants who are not parties to the arbitration agreements or the underlying contracts.
  4. Whether the plaintiff can avoid arbitration on grounds of alleged unworkability due to multiple arbitration clauses and parties.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The arbitration agreements do not cover all claims and parties in the suit; some claims are not arbitrable.
  • The suit involves third parties not bound by the arbitration agreements, so the Act does not apply to them.
  • The pre-arbitration mechanism in clause 6.1 of the GCC must be exhausted before arbitration can be invoked, which NTPC did not follow.
  • The existence of two separate arbitration agreements (one domestic with NTPC, one foreign with Alstom) makes arbitration unworkable and may lead to conflicting awards.
  • The inclusion of defendants 3, 4, and 5 is necessary for full adjudication and they cannot be compelled to arbitrate.

Respondents' (NTPC and Alstom) Arguments

  • The disputes fall squarely within the arbitration clauses and the Court must refer the parties to arbitration under Sections 8 and 45 of the Act.
  • The suit is an attempt at mis-joinder of parties and causes of action to evade arbitration obligations.
  • Alstom relies on Clause 9 of the Project Agreement for foreign arbitration and NTPC relies on Clause 6 of the GCC for domestic arbitration.
  • The plaintiff cannot defeat the arbitration agreements by joining non-parties or filing a suit instead of arbitration.
  • Decisions such as Swenska Handels Banken & Ors. v. Indian Charge Chrome Limited and Bank of Baroda v. M/S. Prakash Warehouse & Others support the mandatory nature of arbitration referral.
  • The third defendant is not a necessary or proper party as it is not a party to any relevant contract or arbitration agreement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Haryana Telecom v. Teralite Industries, 1999 (99) CC 675 Limits on arbitrability where suit involves parties not bound by arbitration agreement. Referenced by plaintiff to argue that arbitration cannot be compelled against non-parties and non-arbitrable claims.
Sukanya Holdings v. Jayesh H. Pandya & Another, 2003 (5) SCC 531 Section 8 requires the entire subject-matter of the suit to be arbitrable; no bifurcation of claims or parties allowed. Court distinguished the case as non-applicable because non-parties were neither necessary nor proper, and no dispute existed with them.
Swenska Handels Banken & Ors. v. Indian Charge Chrome Limited, 1994 (2) SCC 155 Mandatory nature of Section 45 to refer parties to foreign arbitration; parties cannot avoid arbitration by filing suit. Relied upon by Alstom and the Court to uphold the obligation to refer disputes to arbitration under the foreign arbitration clause.
Bank of Baroda v. M/S. Prakash Warehouse & Others, ILR 1980 (2) Del 962 Mis-joinder of parties and causes of action in suits involving arbitration agreements. Supported the argument that improper parties included in suit to avoid arbitration.
Shinetsu Chemical Co. Ltd. v. Aksh Optifibre Ltd. & Anr., 2005 (7) SCC 234 Overriding nature of Section 45 obligation to refer parties to arbitration unless agreement is null, void, or incapable of performance. Cited to emphasize the mandatory duty of courts to refer parties to arbitration under foreign arbitration agreements.
AEG Aktiengesellschaft v. Insotex (India) & Anr., CA 7855/96, decided on 10.04.1996 Section 45 requires judicial authority to refer parties to arbitration unless agreement is null, void or incapable of performance. Reinforced the mandatory referral to arbitration and that inconvenience is not incapacity.
Janos Paczy v. Haendler & Natermann GmbH, 1981 (1) Lloyds LR 302 Interpretation of "incapable of being performed" in arbitration agreements; incapacity means impossibility, not inconvenience. Used to reject plaintiff’s argument that arbitration was unworkable due to multiple arbitration clauses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the factual matrix and contractual framework involving the plaintiff, NTPC, and Alstom. It noted that the plaintiff had entered into a Project Agreement with Alstom containing a foreign arbitration clause and that the contract with NTPC contained a domestic arbitration clause. The Court found that the disputes between the plaintiff and Alstom were governed by the foreign arbitration clause (Clause 9), while disputes with NTPC were governed by the domestic arbitration clause (Clause 6 of the GCC).

The Court held that defendants 3, 4, and 5 were neither necessary nor proper parties to the suit, as there were no substantive disputes involving them, and their inclusion appeared to be an attempt to circumvent arbitration obligations.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Sukanya Holdings, the Court distinguished the present case by emphasizing that non-parties to arbitration agreements cannot be compelled to arbitrate and that the presence of non-parties does not invalidate the arbitration agreements between the actual parties.

The Court underscored the mandatory nature of Sections 8 and 45 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which require courts to refer parties to arbitration where an arbitration agreement exists, unless such agreement is null, void, or incapable of performance. It rejected the plaintiff’s argument that arbitration was unworkable due to multiple arbitration clauses and the involvement of different jurisdictions, citing authoritative precedents that inconvenience or complexity do not render arbitration agreements incapable of performance.

The Court further found that the plaintiff could not avoid arbitration by rushing to court and that failure to follow pre-arbitration mechanisms by the plaintiff did not preclude reference to arbitration. The Court concluded that the applications filed by NTPC, Alstom, and the third defendant were entitled to succeed.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the applications filed by NTPC (I.A 2803/2006), the third defendant (I.A 14366/06), and Alstom (I.A 14367/06) and rejected the plaint as not maintainable.

The parties were directed to proceed in accordance with the arbitration clauses: Clause 6 of the GCC for disputes between the plaintiff and NTPC, and Clause 9 of the Project Agreement for disputes between the plaintiff and Alstom.

The Court held that defendants 3, 4, and 5 were not necessary parties and their inclusion was improper. The plaintiff was ordered to bear the costs and pay Rs. 50,000 each to the first and second defendants within two weeks.

No new precedent was set; the decision reinforced the mandatory referral to arbitration under Sections 8 and 45 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and clarified that inconvenience or multiplicity of arbitration agreements does not invalidate the obligation to arbitrate.

    W.P.I.L. v. Ntpc Ltd.

    S. Ravindra Bhat, J.— The present common order will disposed off several applications by the parties, viz I.A 2803/2006, under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act (hereafter ‘the Act’); I.A 14366/06 under Order I, Rule 10 and I.A 14367/06, under Section 45 of the Act.

    2. The brief facts necessary to dispose of the applications are summarized as follows. Pursuant to the first defendant's (hereafter “the NTPC”) invitation for bids for supply of a cooling water system package, for its SIPAT Thermal Power Project, Stage 1, Bilaspur at Chhatisgarh, the plaintiff submitted its bid. In terms of Clauses 7.1 and 7.3, of the instruction for Bidders (“IFB”, which, together with the terms of the bid, general terms and conditions, etc, formed the tender documents) a bidder could club the experience of associates, to enable fulfillment of eligibility conditions as regards previous experience in constructing similar works (and specified works, under the tender documents). One condition was that in such cases, if another concern was involved as an associate, it had to submit a Joint Deed of Undertaking (JDU) to the NTPC.

    3. The second defendant (hereafter ‘Alstom’) entered into an agreement with the plaintiff on 19.08.2004 (hereafter “the Project Agreement”). Clause 2.1 of that agreement spelt out the purpose, i.e preparation and submission of tender to the NTPC: Clause 7.3 of the IFB, to enable the plaintiff to qualify for the bid, was spelt out in this agreement with Alstom. Clause 4.7 recorded Alstom's obligation to sign a joint deed of undertaking, with the plaintiff, to be furnished to the NTPC. A bank guarantee to the extent of 1% of the total value of the contract was to be furnished to NTPC. Clauses 9 and 10 read as follows:

    “9.0 Disputes:

    9.1 Any dispute arising in connection with the interpretation or performance of the Agreement shall be settled through Arbitration.

    9.2 The arbitration shall take place at Paris (France) under the Rules of Conciliation and Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce,

    Paris by one or more Arbitrators appointed in accordance with the said rules.

    10.0 Applicable Law:

    10.1 The Agreement shall be governed by construed in accordance with the substantive law of France.”

    4. A JDU, in terms of the IFB, had been executed by the plaintiff and Alstom. In terms of the JDU, Alstom declared and undertook its joint and several responsibility to the NTPC (described as “the owner”) for the successful performance of the Pumps, under the plaintiff's contract with NTPC and also technically guaranteed the equipment. By clause 6 of the JDU, Alstom undertook to furnish a bank guarantee equal to 1% of the total value of the contract between NTPC and the plaintiff. Clause 8 of JDU stated that the undertaking was “irrevocable” and formed “an integral part of the contract”. “Contract” was defined as the bid, furnished by the Plaintiff, being accepted by NTPC.

    5. The plaintiff furnished its bid to the NTPC on 25.09.2004, along with a bank guarantee for Rs. 2,35,05000/- favoring it, valid till 03.09.2005 It further alleges that NTPC's officers visited Alstom's offices in France in April 2005, to satisfy themselves about feasibility of its equipment after which the plaintiff's bid was accepted on 31.05.2005 Clause 6 of the General Condition of Contract, (hereafter “GCC”) awarded by the NTPC to the plaintiff, reads as follows:

    “6. (A). Adjudicator:

    (i) If any dispute of any kind whatsoever shall arise between the Employer and the Contractor in connection with or arising out of the Contract, including without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, any question regarding its existence, validity or termination, or the execution of the Facilities or after their completion and whether progress of the Facilities or after their completion and whether before or after the termination, abandonment or breach of the Contract- the parties shall seek to resolve any such dispute or difference by mutual consultation. It the parties fail to resolve such a dispute or difference by mutual consultation, then the dispute shall be referred in writing by either party to the Adjudicator, with a copy to the other party.

    (ii) The Adjudicator shall give its decision in writing to both parties within twenty-eight (28) days of a dispute being referred to it. If the Adjudicator has done so, and no notice of intention to commence arbitration has been given by either the Employer or the Contractor within fifty-six (56) days of such reference, the decision shall become final and binding upon the Employer and the Contractor. Any decision that has become final and binding shall be implemented by the parties forthwith.

    (iii) Should the Adjudicator resign or die, or should the Employer and the Contractor agree that the Adjudicator is not fulfilling its functions in accordance with the provisions of the Contract, a new Adjudicator shall be jointly appointed by the Employer and the Contractor. Failing agreement between the two, within twenty eight (28) days, the new Adjudicator shall be appointed at the request of either party by the Appointing Authority specified in the SCC.

    (B). Arbitration:

    (i) It either the Employer of the Contractor is dissatisfied with the Adjudicator's decision, or if the Adjudicator fails to give a decision within twenty-eight (28) days of a dispute being referred to it, then either the Employer or the Contractor may, within fifty-six (56) days of such reference, give notice to the other party, with a copy for information to the Adjudicator, of its intention to commence arbitration, as hereinafter provided, as to the matter in dispute, and no arbitration in respect of this matter may be commenced unless such notice is given.

    (ii) Any dispute in respect of which a notice of intention to commence arbitration has been given, in accordance with GCC Sub-Clause 6.2.1, shall be finally settled by arbitration. Arbitration may be commenced prior to or after completion of the Facilities.

    (iii) Any dispute submitted by a party to arbitration shall be heard by an arbitration panel composed of three arbitrators, in accordance with the provisions set forth below.

    (iv) The Employer and the Contractor shall each appoint one arbitrator, and these two arbitrators shall jointly appoint a third arbitrator, who shall chair the arbitration panel. F the two arbitrators do not succeed in appointing a third arbitrator within twenty-eight (28) days after the latter of the two arbitrators has been appointed, the third arbitrator shall, at the request of either party, be appointed by the Appointing Authority for arbitrator designated in the SCC.

    (v) If one party fails to appoint its arbitrator within forty-two (42) days after the other party has named its arbitrator, the party which has named an arbitrator may request the Appointing Authority to appoint the second arbitrator.

    (vi) If for any reason an arbitrator is unable to perform its function, the mandate of the Arbitrator shall terminate in accordance with the provisions of applicable laws as mentioned in GCC Clause 5 (Governing Law) and a substitute shall be appointed in the same manner as the original arbitrator.

    (vii) Arbitration proceedings shall be conducted (i) in accordance with the rules of procedure designated in the SCC, (ii) in the place designated in the SCC, and (iii) in the language in which this Contract has been executed.

    (viii) The decision of a majority of the arbitrators (or of the third arbitrator chairing the arbitration panel, if there is no such majority) shall be final and binding and shall be enforceable in any court of competent jurisdiction as decree of the court. The parties thereby waive any objections to or claims of immunity from such enforcement.

    (ix) The Arbitrator(s) shall give reasoned award.

    (C) Notwithstanding any reference to the Adjudicator or arbitration herein.

    (i) The parties shall continue to perform their respective obligations under the Contract unless they otherwise agree

    (ii) The Employer shall pay the Contractor any monies due to the Contractor.”

    6. The plaintiff alleges having signed the contract with NTPC on 30.06.2005 in anticipation of Alstom fulfilling its obligations. It further alleges that at after that, Alstom started entertaining doubts about its terms. After a series of letters and correspondence were exchanged, on 22.07.2005 and 09.08.2005, the plaintiff was informed that Alstom would not be furnishing the bank guarantee for an amount equivalent to one percent of the contract value (with NTPC), in terms of the JDU. It is claimed that the plaintiff has performed and is ready to and willing to perform all obligations, including those mentioned under clauses 31 and 32.1 of ITB and is ready to furnish 10% of the performance security to NTPC.

    7. The plaintiff avers having sought to submit a bank guarantee in lieu of the one to be submitted by Alstom, since it had fulfilled all other obligations. However, on 23.08.2005, the NTPC refused that request. The plaintiff adverts to a letter dated 07.09.2005 and a meeting held between itself and the first three defendants on 08.09.2005 and 09.09.2005 whereby Alstom refused to submit the bank guarantee in terms of IFB. According to the plaintiff, Alstom and the third defendant also presented the plaintiff with a new draft sub-contract, in terms drastically different from the agreed conditions. One instance cited is the term containing the plaintiff's liability to furnish bank guarantee for 6 million Euros, not contracted or agreed upon earlier. The plaintiff avers to further correspondence with NTPC on 15.09.2005 and 19.09.2005 whereby the latter were asked to accept its (i.e the plaintiffs') substituted bank guarantee instead of Alstom; the pleadings also refer to meetings held between 21.09.2005 to 23.09.2005

    8. It is alleged that the plaintiffs were threatened by NTPC that the bank guarantee furnished to it would be en-cashed. The plaintiff alleges without prejudice to its other contentions that the refusal by Alstom to furnish a bank guarantee, equivalent to one percent of the contract value is a circumstance beyond its control and is “Force Majeure” within the meaning of clause 37 of the General Conditions agreed upon with NTPC.

    9. The plaintiff, therefore, seeks permanent injunction against NTPC from encashing the bank guarantee issued by the fourth defendant bank (hereafter “the bank”) as also a consequential injunction restraining the bank from paying money under bank guarantee dated 22.09.2004; similarly a mandatory injunction directing the first defendant to return the bank guarantee, is also sought. The relief sought against Atstom is mandatory injunction to submit bank guarantee to the extent of one percent of the contractual amount in terms of the tender and JDU, or, in the alternative, a direction to it and the Defendant No. 3 to secure NTPC and the plaintiff for the bid security, being the bank guarantee issued by the fourth defendant. A. declaration that clause 32.4 is invalid, has been sought; finally, the plaintiff seeks mandatory injunction against NTPC to permit it to substitute another bank guarantee to the extent of one percent to perform of the value of its contract, along with its obligations under the tender along with the fifth defendant.

    10. Alstom has applied under Section 45 of the Act for an appropriate order, being I.A No. 14367/2006. It relies upon clauses 9 and 10 of the Project Agreement entered into with the plaintiff on 19.08.2004 and alleges that the plaintiff has disregarded it, contrary to the agreed terms. It also contends that this Court is a judicial authority within the meaning of Section 45 and is seized of actions brought by the plaintiff and, therefore, has an obligation to refer the dispute in respect of Alstom, contained in the suit, in terms of clauses 9 and 10.

    11. The NTPC, by its application, I.A No. 2803/2006 relies on Section 8 (which appears in Part-I of the Act), and submits that the disputes, that are subject matter of the suit cannot be proceeded with by the Court in view of the clause-6 of the GCC. This Court had issued an interim order against NTPC from encashing the bank guarantee, on 28.09.2005 However, even before the said order could be served upon NTPC, the bank had released payment under the bank guarantee. It is contended that the plaintiffs averments with regard to existence of Force Majeure conditions on account of alleged violation of the JDU by Alstom and alleged loss occasioned to the NTPC due to the plaintiff's actions and omissions squarely fall within clause 6. Therefore, the plaintiff, if aggrieved, has to seek recourse to the arbitration clause and cannot maintain the present suit.

    12. The applicant NTPC further avers in its rejoinder filed on 31.08.2006 that the plaintiff's inability and failure to comply with the terms of the contract and the demand made to it, to furnish the bank guarantee of its associates resulted in termination of the contract. It refers to a letter, dated 21.12.2005 granting 14 days' time to enable it to furnish the bank guarantee and the subsequent termination letter, dated 10.01.2006 in line with clause 42.2 of Section IV of the General Conditions of Contract.

    13. The third defendant has preferred I.A No. 14366/2006 for deleting it from the arena of parties. It alleges not being a necessary nor a proper party to the dispute between the plaintiff on the one hand and the NTPC and Alstom on the other. According to this applicant, the plaintiff has merely adverted to it as belonging to the same group as Alstom and having participated in dealings with it. It is not a party to JDU or Project Agreement or even the agreement with NTPC, out of which the alleged causes of action have arisen. It, therefore, claims that the suit is not maintainable as far as it is concerned.

    14. Mr. T.S Ganju, learned senior counsel for the plaintiff contended that Alstom's application as well as that of NTPC, are not maintainable because the averments in the suit and the reliefs claimed, are not arbitrable in terms of clause 9 of the Project Agreement. He submitted that notwithstanding the arbitration agreement, if the suit contains averments which cannot be the subject matter of arbitration, has involved third parties to the arbitration agreement, the Act has no application. Learned counsel referred to the decisions reported as Haryana Telecom v. Teralite Industries, 1999 (99) CC 675 and Sukanya Holdings v. Jayesh H. Pandya & Another, 2003 (5) SCC 531. It is further contended that the suit has been filed against the parties such as third, fourth and fifth defendants who were not parties to the arbitration agreement contained in the tender dated 20.06.2004, or the Project Agreement. Therefore, such non-parties cannot be referred to arbitration under clause 6.2 of the general terms and conditions. According to the plaintiff, the fifth defendant is a necessary party for the full adjudication of this case as it is its associate. Yet, it is not a party to the arbitration agreement and cannot be compelled to participate in such proceedings.

    15. The plaintiff contends, that though there are two separate agreements between it and NTPC and between it and Alstom, yet they are part of the same transaction and are intertwined. It was emphasized that the bid leading to the contract between NTPC and plaintiff was finalized in consultation with Alstom whose offices were visited by NTPC; the latter had full knowledge that Alstom was involved in the contract and even accepted the JDU. Reference is made to clause 4.7 of the Project Agreement and clause 6 of the JDU, furnished by Alstom.

    16. It was contended that the NTPC cannot insist upon arbitration of the dispute forming subject matter of the suit because the clause 6.1 of the General Conditions of the Contract consists of a pre-arbitration mechanism without recourse to which there can be no reference to arbitration. It was submitted that if NTPC wanted reference to arbitration in terms of the agreement, it had to compulsorily follow the procedure outlined in clause 6.1 It did not do so; therefore, the application under Section 8 of the Act is not maintainable. It was lastly contended that in any event, since the suit concerns one transaction and outlines the grievance against different parties arising out of a series of transactions intertwined with each other, though it comprehends two different arbitration clauses, referring parties to such arbitration proceedings would be unworkable. Counsel emphasized that the arbitration proceedings arising out of such agreements would be entirely different; the arbitration with Alstom would have to be in Paris (France) in terms of foreign law whereas arbitration with NTPC would be under domestic law. Though common questions of fact and law would arise, there would be a real possibility of conflicting awards prejudicing the plaintiff. In the circumstances, the Court should decline the request and dismiss the applications.

    17. Mr. Rajiv Nayyar and Mr. Valmiki Mehta appearing on behalf of NTPC and Alstom submitted that the decision in Sukanya Holdings (supra) has no application to the facts of this case. According to the counsel, the plaintiff has clubbed two unrelated causes of action and the suit is bad for mis-joinder of causes of action. It is submitted that the allegations in the suit indicate that when it was presented, the plaintiff's main grievance was against encashment of bank guarantee by NTPC. This is evident from the first three reliefs sought. Such disputes with the NTPC are squarely covered by clause 6 of the general conditions of contract and the Court necessarily has to relegate the plaintiff to arbitration. In this context, Mr. Nayyar contended that the mandate of Section 8 cannot be ignored by the Court merely because the plaintiff artificially roped in other parties in order to confuse the real dispute.

    18. Mr. Valmiki Mehta appearing on behalf of Alstom contended that clause 9 of the Project Agreement casts an absolute duty on the parties, which has to be given effect to by the Court under Section 45. He relied upon the decision reported as Swenska Handels Banken & Ors. v. Indian Charge Chrome Limited, 1994 (2) SCC 155 and submitted that merely by entering into other contracts, the plaintiff cannot defeat the parties' intention under clause 9 and 10 to have a foreign arbitration for resolution of their disputes. It was also argued that having regard to Order 1 Rule 3 and Order 2 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiff has indulged in mis-joinder of parties as well as causes of action. The counsel urged that the dispute with Alstom had no bearing with NTPC or the bank; any claim raised by the plaintiff in this regard could not legitimately involve a response by any other party. Alstom submitted that it was constrained to withdraw from the understanding because the plaintiff had changed material particulars in the documents furnished after the Project Agreement was entered into with it. The basis of the understanding whereby Alstom agreed to collaborate and become the plaintiff's associate had been changed; consequently it did not want to commit itself. These facts and disputes were exclusive to the plaintiff and Alstom. Similarly, so far as the third defendant was concerned, it was unnecessarily roped without any rhyme or reason. Learned counsel relied upon the decision of this Court Bank of Bank Of Baroda…Plaintiff v. M/S. Prakash Warehouse & Others…Defendants, ILR 1980 (2) Del 962. It was, therefore, contended that the suit cannot be proceeded with and if the plaintiff wishes to adjudication of any disputes he should seek recourse to the arbitration clause in question.

    19. Before discussing the merits of the parties' contentions, it would be necessary to notice the relevant conditions. The invitation for bids by clause 7 states as follows:

    “7.0 QUALIFYING REQUIREMENTS FOR BIDDERS

    In addition to qualifying requirements stipulated under Instruction to Bidders (ITB), the following shall also apply:

    (7.1A) The Bidder should have executed in the preceding seven (7) years reckoned as on date of bid opening, civil & structural works of cooling water pump house/intake pump house, fore-bay, pump sumps involving deep excavation, de-watering, back-filling, concreting etc. and should have achieved at least the following:

    (a) Concreting of 30,000 cubic meters in any one (1) one year in one (1) or cumulative of two (2) concurrently running contracts and,

    (b) (i) Fabrication of 3000 MT mild steel pipes/ducts carrying fluids in any one (1) year in one (1) or cumulative of two (2) concurrently running contracts and,

    (ii) Erection of 3000 MT mild steel pipes/ducts carrying fluids in any one (1) year in one (1) or cumulative of two (2) currently running contracts.

    (iii) The average annual turnover of the bidder, in the preceding three (3) financial years as on the date of bid opening, shall not be less than INR 600 million or equivalent in foreign currency.

    (7.1B) Bidder should have designed, manufactured, supplied, erected/supervised erection, tested and commissioned/supervised commissioning of at least two (2) nos. of vertical wet pit pumps or two (2) nos. of concrete volute pumps or metallic volute pumps with concrete encasement for condenser cooling water application/comparable duty, of capacity 40,000 cu. m/hr or more having specific speed in the range of 4000-7000 (US units) which are in successful operation for at least two (2) years as on date of bid opening.

    The reference pumps should be of the same type i.e vertical wet pit type pumps or concrete volute type pumps or metallic volute pumps with concrete encasement as is being offered by the Bidder.

    (7.2) Bidder who meets the requirements specified in 7.1(A) above, can also participate provided he associates with a firm who meets the requirement of 7.1(B) above which the bidder himself is unable to meet.

    In such a case bidder shall furnish undertaking jointly executed by him and his associate for the satisfactory performance of the equipment under the contract, as per the format enclosed in the bid document. This joint deed of undertaking shall be submitted alongwith the bid, failing which the bidder shall be disqualified and his bid shall be rejected. Further, in case of award, the Bidder's associate will be required to furnish an on demand bank guarantee for 1.0% (one percent) of the contract price in addition to the contract performance security by the Bidder.

    (7.2B) Bidder who meets the requirements specified in 7.1(B) above, can also participate provided he associates with a firm who meets requirement of 7.1(A) above which the bidder himself is unable to meet.

    In such a case bidder shall furnish undertaking jointly executed by him and his associate for the satisfactory performance of the civil works under the contract, as per the format enclosed in the bid document. This joint deed of undertaking shall be submitted alongwith the bid, failing which the bidder shall be disqualified and his bid shall be rejected. Further, in case of award, the Bidder's associate will be required to furnish an on demand bank guarantee for 4% (four percent) of the contract price in addition to the contract performance security by the Bidder.

    (7.3) Bidder who has designed, manufactured, supplied, erected/supervised erection, tested and commissioned/supervised commissioning of at least two (2) nos. of vertical wet pit or concrete volute condenser cooling water pumps, each of capacity 15,000 cum./hr. or more having a specific speed in the range of 4000-7000 (US Units) which are in successful operation for at least two (2) years as on date of bid opening, can also participate, provided he associates/collaborates with a firm or two firms separately, meeting the requirements of 7.1(A) and 7.1(B) above respectively. The bidder shall offer only the type of pump for which the associate/collaborator gets qualified as above.

    In such a case bidder shall furnish undertaking jointly executed by him and his associate(s)/collaborator(s) for the satisfactory performance of the civil works/respective equipment (as applicable) under the contract, as per the format(s) enclosed in the bid document. These joint deed (s) of undertaking shall be submitted along with the bid, failing which the bidder shall be disqualified and his bid shall be rejected. Further, in case of award, the Bidder's Civil works associate and Equipment associate/collaborator will be required to furnish an on demand bank guarantee for 4.0% (four percent) and 1.0% (one percent) respectively of the contract price in addition to the contract performance security by the Bidder.”

    Clause 12.6 of the Instructions to Bidders (ITB) states as follows:

    “The bid security may be forfeited

    (a) if the Bidder withdraws its bid during the period of bid validity specified by the bidder in the bid form.

    (b) if the Bidder does not accept the correction of its Bid Price pursuant to ITB Sub-Clause 21.2;

    (c) if the Bidder does not withdraw any deviation listed in Attachment-6 at the cost of withdrawal indicated by him;

    (d) if the Bidder refuses to withdraw, without any cost to the Employer, any deviation not listed in Attachment-6 but found elsewhere in the bid; or

    (e) in the case of a successful Bidder, if the Bidder fails within the specified time limit

    (i) to sign the Contract Agreement, in accordance with ITB Clause 31, or

    (ii) to furnish the required Performance Securities, in accordance with ITB Clause 32.”

    Clause 32 states as follows:

    “32. Performance Security

    32.1 Within twenty-eight (28) days after receipt of the Notification of Award, the successful Bidder shall furnish performance securities for ten percent (10%) of Contract Price for all the contracts and in the form provided in the section “Forms and Procedures” of the bidding documents.

    32.2 In case Deed(s) of Joint Undertaking by the Contractor alongwith his associate(s)/collaborator(s) form part of the Contract, then, unconditional Bank Guarantee(s) from such associate(s)/collaborator(s) towards faithful performance of the Deed(s) of Joint Undertaking for amount(s) specified in item No. 3.0 of Bid Data Sheets shall be furnished within twenty eight (28) days after Notification of Award. These Bank Guarantees shall be furnished in the form provided in the section “Forms and Procedures” of the bidding documents and shall be valid till such period as specified in the corresponding format for Deed of Joint Undertaking.

    32.3 In case of a successful foreign bidder, if the Employer accepts to enter into the Second Contract and/or Third Contract with Assignee, pursuant to ITB Sub-Clause 28.4 above, then, within twenty eight (28) days of Notification of Award, the Assignee shall furnish additional performance security(ies) for ten percent (10%) of the value of the Contract(s) entered into with the Assignee and in the form provided in the Section “Forms and Procedures” of the bidding documents.”

    32.4 Failure of the successful Bidder to comply with the requirements of ITB Clause 31 or 32 shall constitute sufficient grounds for the annulment of the award and forfeiture of his bid security, in which event the Employer may make the award to the next lowest evaluated Bidder or call for new bids.”

    20. It would now be necessary to extract the relevant provisions of the Act; they are as follows:

    “5. Extent of judicial intervention—Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, in matters governed by this Part, no judicial authority shall intervene except where so provided in this Part.

    ******************

    8. Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is an arbitration agreement—

    (1) A judicial authority before which an action is brought in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party so applies not later than when submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute, refer the parties to arbitration.

    (2) The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall not be entertained unless it is accompanied by the original arbitration agreement or a duly certified copy thereof.

    (3) Notwithstanding that an application has been made under subsection (1) and that the issue is pending before the judicial authority, an arbitration may be commenced or continued and an arbitral award made.

    ******************

    44. Definition

    In this, Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires, “foreign award” means an arbitral award on differences between persons arising out of legal relationships, whether contractual or not, considered as commercial under the law in force in India, made on or after the 11th day of October, 1960—

    (a) in pursuance of an agreement in writing for arbitration to which the Convention set forth in the First Schedule applies, and

    (b) in one of such territories as the Central Government, being satisfied that reciprocal provisions have been made may, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare to be territories to which said Convention applies.

    45. Power of judicial authority to refer parties to arbitration—Notwithstanding anything contained in Part I or in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), a judicial authority, when seized of an action in a matter in respect of which the parties have made an agreement referred to in section 44, shall, at the request of one of the parties or any person claiming through or under him, refer the parties to arbitration, unless it finds that the said agreement is null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed.”

    21. It is apparent from the above discussion that the plaintiff, in order to submit its tender for the award of contract by NTPC, was anxious to have Alstom, as its associate. This perhaps was essential, in view of Clause 7 of IFB, to bolster its chances of being awarded the contract. Alstom agreed to the proposal; the plaintiff entered into an agreement, called the Project Agreement, on 19.08.2004, (with Asltom); it contained an arbitration agreement, viz. Clause 9. Alstom also furnished the JDU, (as part of its agreement with the plaintiff) to NTPC. The latter finally awarded the contract in favour of the plaintiff, on 31.05.2005 Differences apparently arose soon after the award of contract (to the plaintiff) with Alstom. The plaintiff alleges that those disputes were baseless; Alstom alleges that the plaintiff had altered the basis of the project agreement. Regardless of these differences, two things followed—one, Alstom refused to furnish the 1% guarantee to NTPC and two, this became its bone of contention or a “dispute” with the plaintiff; Alstom started insisting on the execution of a sub-contract agreement. That this dispute is squarely governed by 9 of the Project Agreement has not been disputed. The plaintiff's inability to furnish the requisite guarantee led to NTPC insisting that it comply with the terms of the contract. Fearing that NTPC would encash the bank guarantee for Rs. 2.35 crores the plaintiff filed the present suit for injunction.

    22.Interestingly, the plaint averments do not contain any allegations against defendants nos. 3, 4 and 5 Now, third defendant's position is—and justifiably so—that begning an independently incorporated company, its mere association with Alstom, in the absence of privity of contract with the plaintiff of NTPC—or even the Bank does not clothe the plaintiff with any “cause” to join the it as a party, As far as defendant No. 4 is concerned, Mr. Ganju during the hearing had fairly stated that no cause survives because the guarantee had been encashed. Besides this concession, the plaintiff has not shown how it had—or can have any cause of action against the Bank. The plaint is bereft of any averments concerning the bank's breach of any legal duty or contractual obligations, or that the encashment of the bank guarantee, by NTPC, was tainted by fraud. No averments also regarding special equities, or the guarantee not being invoked in terms of the contract, which are the only other grounds available in law, to interdict a bank's independent obligations under commercial credits, like bank guarantees, have been made. Thus, the suit against the fourth defendant is plainly not maintainable. As far as the fifth defendant is concerned, there is no allegation by the plaintiff; indeed one of the reliefs sought is that mandatory injunction should be granted to the plaintiff and “its associate” the said fifth defendant. One cannot, therefore, comprehend how this defendant's presence is as a “proper” much less necessary party. It is, therefore, held that so far as adjudication of the two sets of disputes, i.e between the plaintiff and Alstom on the one hand, and the plaintiff and NTPC on the other, are concerned, none of the other defendants, i.e Defendants 3, 4, and 5 are necessary parties.

    23. In Sukanya Holdings (supra), the Supreme Court held that:

    “15. The relevant language used in Section 8 is: “in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement”. The court is required to refer the parties to arbitration. Therefore, the suit should be in respect of “a matter” which the parties have agreed to refer and which comes within the ambit of arbitration agreement. Where, however, a suit is commenced—“as to a matter” which lies outside the arbitration agreement and is also between some of the parties who are not parties to the arbitration agreement, there is no question of application of Section 8. The words “a matter” indicate that the entire subject-matter of the suit should be subject to arbitration agreement.

    16. It would be difficult to give an interpretation to Section 8 under which bifurcation of the cause of action, that is to say, the subject-matter of the suit or in some cases bifurcation of the suit between parties who are parties to the arbitration agreement and others is possible. This would be laying down a totally new procedure not contemplated under the Act.”

    24. The Supreme Court in Sukanya Holdings (supra) was concerned with the correct interpretation of Section 8 of the Act, which occurs in Part-I of the enactment. No doubt, the observations do suggest that suit claims cannot be bifurcated or “split up” into arbitrable and non-arbitrable disputes. This conclusion is not only logical, but also in tune with the law that a plaint cannot be partly rejected. However, the question which confronts this Court is a bit different—the non-parties to the two sets of arbitration agreements are neither necessary, nor proper for the adjudication of disputes. No attempt is made by the plaintiff to show how Defendant Nos. 3, 4 and 5 have any concern or are connected with the dispute relating to termination of contract, or the dispute with Alstom for its alleged breach of terms of the Project Agreement. In these circumstances, the inescapable inference is that they were included in the suit, as defendant, to circumvent and possibly defeat the arbitration clause. There are no “disputes” between the plaintiff and them; in any event if any statement of any such party is required in arbitral proceedings, their officials or employees can be cited as witnesses.

    25. It would now be necessary to analyze the provisions of Section 45 of the Act, and the decision in Svenska (supra). India became a signatory to the Geneva Protocol on Arbitration Clauses, 1923 and the Convention on the Execution of Foreign Arbitral Awards, 1927. To give effect to her obligations, India resultantly, enacted the Arbitration (Protocol and Convention) Act, 1937 (6 of 1937) (“the Protocol Act”) to enforce the terms of the Protocol and the Convention. This enactment was restricted to enforcement of foreign awards, in matters considered as “commercial”, in terms of the first schedule to that enactment. Later, The New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, 1958 (hereafter “the New York Convention”) was ratified on the 13th July, 1960 by the Government of India. To give effect to the New York Convention, Parliament enacted the Foreign Awards (Recognition and Enforcement) Act, 1961. The object of the New York Convention is to enable enforcement of private party agreements determining the forum to decide the parties' disputes. It records rules for recognition and enforcement of awards. The Convention provides for reciprocal enforcement of foreign arbitral awards, and strives to eliminate the need to resort to municipal or domestic courts, to resolve international disputes. While acceding to the Convention, India restricted her obligations

    “only to differences arising out of legal relationships, whether contractual or not, which are considered as commercial under the Law of India.”

    26. The position, under the 1996 is to be gathered from Section 44, which enacts certain preconditions, viz. that the “foreign award” would be, for the purpose of enforcement, in India, one:

    (i) Pursuant to difference arising out of legal relationships considered as commercial under the law in force in India.

    (ii) It must have been made on or after 11th October, 1960.

    (iii) It must be in pursuance to an agreement, in writing, for arbitration to which the convention set-forth in the First Schedule (New York Convention) applies, and;

    (iv) It must have been made in one of the reciprocating contracting States notified by the Central Government.

    Now, Section 45 obligates every judicial authority in India (which, concededly this court is) to refer the parties to arbitration, if they have agreed to be governed by arbitration agreements, which would be covered by Section 44. The obligation is an overriding one, apparent from the non-obstante clause, and the mandatory “shall” occurring in the provision. The only qualifications, relieving the court from its duty to refer the parties to arbitration, is if it is convinced that the agreement is “null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed (Section 45). Shinetsu Chemical Co. Ltd. v. Aksh Optifibre Ltd. & Anr., 2005 (7) SCC 234 is a three judge decision on the overriding nature of the court's obligation; though there is a plurality of views in the Bench decision on other issues, on this question, the judges were unanimous.

    27. Svenska (supra) was concerned with the applicability of Section 3 of the Foreign Awards (Recognition and Enforcement) Act, 1961. That provision was cast in identical terms as Section 45 of the Act. Dealing with a fact situation identical as those in this case—where two or more contracts, containing different arbitration clauses existed, the Supreme Court held as follows:

    “40. The only ground given by the High Court for refusing the stay of the suit against defendants 1 to 3 is as mentioned earlier. The High Court has also pointed out that since the plaint does not make severable allegations against different defendants who are parties to different contracts, with different arbitration agreements and the allegations made by the plaintiff against different defendants are such that they cannot be separated from each other and since the arbitrations between the plaintiff and different defendants may have to go to different arbitrators, all the arbitration clauses must be treated as having become inoperative. It has further been observed by the High Court that if all the agreements containing arbitration clauses with different defendants had envisaged only one arbitrator for adjudicating all the disputes, the fact that there were several agreements with the different defendants would not have affected the matter and the award given by the common arbitrators could have bound all the parties in the suit.

    41. It appears to us that the aforesaid reasoning of the High Court is strained and totally erroneous. It also amounts to disregarding the mandatory provision of Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act.

    42. For purposes of the present case we are, for the present, considering merely the applications for stay of the suit filed on behalf of the lenders. It is clear from their applications that all the conditions envisaged for the applicability of Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act are fully complied with.

    43. The plaintiff by merely entering into other contracts with different parties cannot prejudice or defeat the rights of the different party under the different contract, particularly when the right of the foreign arbitration has been provided by Parliament as an indefeasible right in which the court, does not have any kind of discretion.

    44. The arbitration is contemplated as per Section 3 of the Foreign Awards Act. The plaintiff by filing a plaint, cannot make the arbitration clause invalid or inoperative. Therefore, the finding of the High Court that the arbitration agreements have become inoperative and incapable of being performed or invalid is erroneous in law and, therefore, must be set aside.”

    28. The overbearing nature of Section 45 and the non-obstante clause, obliging the Court to relegate the parties to the agreed remedies in terms of the arbitration agreement was again emphasized in AEG Aktiengesellschaft v. Insotex (India) & Anr. (CA 7855/96, decided on 10.04.1996) by the Supreme Court thus:

    “Section 45 thereof enjoins a judicial authority (the Company Law Board being one such judicial authority) when requested by any one of the parties or any person claiming through or under him, where the parties have made an agreement referred to in Section 44, to refer the parties to arbitration, unless it finds that the said agreement is null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed. Undisputably, there exists an arbitration agreement between the parties whereby their disputes arising out of the contract would be referable to an arbitrator having his legal seat at Zurich, Switzerland, and to which disputes the substantive law of contract as prevalent in India would apply. The Company Law Board would thus be obliged to proceed in accordance with Section 45 and refer the parties to arbitration, because the agreement is neither null and void, nor inoperative or incapable of being performed. Incapability, of course, has not to be understood as being inconvenienced. When the parties enter into such agreement with open eyes they are presumed to have incurred on themselves the inconveniences inherent in the deal. Thus, only an application by any of the parties is required to be made, which would set the judicial authority to act in the manner provided.”

    29. The plaintiff's contentions are not that the arbitration agreement is “null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed” it raises what can be termed as a bogey of “unworkability” due to separate arbitration clauses embedded in two different agreements. True, there could be a certain element of overlapping in the disputes, which it may raise, and the allegations in one arbitration may constitute evidence in the other; yet, that does not result in the agreement being “null and void” or rendering the agreement incapable of performance. Unworkability is not a ground afforded by law makers to thwart obligations characterized by the Supreme Court as “indefeasible” rights to arbitral proceedings. Nor can the court, through an interpretive mechanism create exceptions (from the obligation to relegate parties to arbitration) when no explicit ground exists. Doing so would not only distort the statute, but eventually undermine obligations accepted by parties to international agreements, with open eyes. As explained by the Supreme Court, “incapacity” is not inconvenience. In a similar vein, while interpreting the expression “incapacity”, urged by a party seeking to be excused from arbitration, while insisting on maintaining civil action, it was held, in Janos Paczy v. Haendler & Natermann GmbH, 1981 (1) Lloyds LR 302, by the Court of Appeal, that:

    “In my judgment, on the true construction of these words, “incapable of being performed” relates to the arbitration agreement under the consideration. The incapacity of one party to that agreement to implement his obligations under the agreement does not, in my judgment, render the agreement one which is incapable of performance within the section any more than the inability of a purchaser under a contract for purchase of land to find the purchase price when the time comes to complete the sale could be said to render the contract for sale incapable of performance. The agreement only becomes incapable of performance in my view if the circumstances are such that it could no longer be performed, even if both parties were ready, able and willing to perform it…”

    30. Russel on Arbitration (twenty first Edn, Sweet & Maxwell), in Para 7-014 states this:

    “7-014. Third parties involved. There is no longer any scope for the court refusing a stay of proceedings on the ground that third parties are involved and that it would be preferable for the dispute to be dealt with by one tribunal (i.e the court) in order to avoid the possibility of inconsistent decisions.”

    31. It is held, for the above reasons, that the reasons urged by the plaintiff to reject Alstom's application are unmerited Further, its argument that without seeking recourse to Clause 6.1, there can be no reference, is, in the facts of this case wholly untenable. It is the plaintiff who has rushed to court, ignoring the arbitration clause; had the defendant No. 1 done so, possibly this ground could have been justified. As things are, the plaintiff cannot seek dismissal of the application under Section 8- it is the party seeking to highlight disputes, and wanting their adjudication. So far as the other applications are concerned, the previous portion of the judgment dealing with mis-joinder of parties, and the reasons given why Sukanya's ratio has no application in this case, are sufficient to reject the plaintiff's arguments. Consequently, I.A 2803/2006, by NTPC; IA. 14366/06 (by the third defendant) and I.A 14367/06 by Alstom are entitled to succeed; they are allowed. In the circumstances, the parties are at liberty to take steps in accordance with Clause 6 of the GCC (so far as the plaintiff and NTPC are concerned) and Clause 9 of the Project Agreement, so far as the plaintiff and Alstom are concerned. The plaint, is accordingly rejected as not maintainable. The plaintiff shall bear the costs, and pay Rs. 50.000/- each to the first defendant and the second defendant, within two weeks.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    W.P.I.L. v. Ntpc Ltd.
    (Jan 16, 2009)