O R D E R % 24.09.2009
1. By order dated 5th March, 2008, Information Commissioner had
passed the following directions:-
“ 6.1 … The Commission also sees no harm in providing the Appellant with a copy of the Agreement arrived at between the Government of India and the kingdom of Saudi Arabia as this is a public document. In case the Respondents have any problem in providing the Appellant a copy of it, they may revert back to the Commission and also the Appellant.”
2. The respondent Ministry of External Affairs thereafter moved an
application, which was disposed of vide order dated 26th May, 2008
recording as under:-
“The Commission partly accepts the submission of the Respondents and directs them to supply a copy of the Agreement to the Appellant after
applying section 10 of the rti-act to the particular issue mentioned by him to the Commission. This may be done by 13 June 2008.”
3. The impugned order dated 26th May, 2008 has been passed without
issue of notice and without hearing to the petitioner. The impugned order
dated 26th May, 2008, therefore, cannot be sustained.
4. It may be noted that the petitioner has been repeatedly
corresponding with the Central Information Commission and the
respondents asking for copy of the agreement. The respondents have, on
the other hand, taken the stand that agreement cannot be furnished in
view of the order dated 26th May, 2008 and Section 8(1)(f) of the Right to
Information Act, 2005. The impugned order dated 26th May, 2008 does
not refer to Section 8(1)(f) or accept the contention of the respondent
Ministry of External Affairs in this regard. The contention of the
respondent Ministry of External Affairs or whether Section 8(1)(f) of the
Right to Information Act, 2005 applies, has to be decided by the
Information Commissioner and cannot be left to the Ministry to decide.
5. Accordingly, impugned order dated 26th May, 2008 is set aside and
the matter is remanded back to the Information Commissioner to pass a
fresh speaking order. The petitioner and the respondents are directed to
appear before the Registrar, Central Information Commission on 22nd
October, 2009 when date of hearing will be fixed.
The writ petition is accordingly disposed of.
SANJIV KHANNA, J.