Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) filed a complaint under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 read with Sections 24(1) and 27 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992. The complaint alleged that certain plantation companies, including the petitioners, had raised funds from investors without complying with regulatory mechanisms, promising questionable high returns. The petitioners, who were directors of the accused company, were charged for their alleged involvement in the commission of offences related to non-compliance with SEBI regulations framed in 1997. The petitioners were summoned to answer the charges, and they challenged the summons on the ground that the averments regarding their role as directors responsible for the company’s affairs were insufficient to proceed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the averments in the complaint that the petitioners were directors and responsible for the day-to-day affairs of the company were sufficient to attract criminal liability and justify summoning them to answer the charges.
  2. Whether the petitioners’ claim of having ceased to be directors before the alleged offence could be considered at the stage of taking cognizance or was a matter for trial.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The averment that the petitioners were directors and responsible for day-to-day affairs was insufficient to proceed against them.
  • Some petitioners contended they were merely investors, had only signed proposal forms for directorship, never attended board meetings, and were removed from directorship before the alleged offence.
  • They urged that the order summoning them be quashed on these grounds.

Respondent's Arguments

  • SEBI relied on the complaint averments that the petitioners were directors responsible for the company’s affairs at the material time.
  • SEBI placed on record a letter dated 13.1.1998 and balance sheet signed by petitioners as directors as of 31.12.1997, indicating their directorship during the relevant period.
  • SEBI argued that the question of whether petitioners ceased to be directors was a matter for trial and not for consideration at the stage of cognizance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
SMS Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Neeta Bhalla, (2005) 8 SCC 89 A clear, unambiguous, and specific allegation that a person was in charge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of its business at the material time is sufficient to hold that person liable. The Court held that the complaint contained such sufficient averments against the petitioners as directors responsible for the company’s affairs, warranting summons.
N. Rangachari v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., (2007) 5 SCC 108 Directors of a company are presumed to be in charge of its affairs, and restrictions on their powers are matters for the trial to establish. The complaint’s allegation that accused were directors implies their control and responsibility. The Court relied on this to affirm that mere allegation of directorship imports the element of responsibility, thus supporting the summons against petitioners.
Sections 291 to 293 of the Companies Act, 1956 Defines the roles, powers, and functions of directors as per the memorandum and articles of association of a company. The Court noted that the role of a director is a question of fact and depends on the company’s constitutional documents.
Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act When an offence is committed by a company, every person in charge and responsible for the conduct of business at the time is deemed guilty along with the company. The Court cited this to explain the presumption of directors’ responsibility for company acts, reinforcing the sufficiency of averments in the complaint.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the sufficiency of the complaint’s averments regarding the petitioners’ roles as directors responsible for the company’s affairs. It emphasized that criminal liability attaches not merely due to directorship but due to conduct, act, or omission, and such conduct must be averred in the complaint. The Court referred to authoritative Supreme Court precedents, particularly SMS Pharmaceuticals Ltd. and N. Rangachari, which establish that a clear allegation of being in charge and responsible for the company’s business at the relevant time suffices to proceed.

The Court rejected the petitioners’ contention that the averments were insufficient, holding that the complaint met the required threshold. It further held that the petitioners’ defense that they had ceased to be directors before the alleged offence was a matter to be proved at trial and could not be considered at the cognizance stage.

The Court also noted documentary evidence submitted by SEBI indicating that petitioners were directors at the relevant time, including a letter and balance sheet signed by petitioners as directors after the alleged offence period.

Finally, the Court observed that the position of managing director carries a presumption of managing and controlling the company’s affairs, reinforcing the sufficiency of allegations against petitioner No. 1.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The Court dismissed the petition challenging the summons. The direct effect is that the petitioners are required to answer the charges based on the complaint’s averments. No new precedent was established; the decision applies existing principles confirming that clear allegations of directorship and responsibility suffice at the stage of taking cognizance, while defenses concerning actual control and tenure are matters for trial.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sushila Devi v. Securities And Exchange Board Of India .

    Pradeep Nandrajog, J.— Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) filed a complaint against the petitioners under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 read with Section 24(1) and 27 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India, 1992. Inter alia, it was stated that Section 11 of the Act casts upon SEBI the duty to protect the interest of investors in securities and that SEBI was enjoined upon to promote the development of and to regulate the securities market through appropriate measures.

    2. It was stated that the last decade had witnessed initiative by private entrepreneurs to undergo plantation activities on a commercial scale. It was noted that promoters would invest minimal amounts in such ventures. They would raise funds from ordinary investors in the absence of regulatory mechanisms. It was stated that the high returns promised under the schemes were questionable. It was stated that in the year 1997 certain guidelines were framed pertaining to plantation companies.

    3. Listing out various regulations which require to be complied with in the year 1997 and alleging that the same were not complied with, complaint was filed alleging violation of Section 27 of the Act as also the regulations framed.

    4. Pertaining to petitioners 1 to 7 who were impleaded as respondents 2 to 9 following averments were made in para 7 of the complaint:

    “7. The accused No. 1 is a company registered under the provisions of the companies act and the accused Nos. 2 to 9 are the directors of the accused No. 1 company. The accused Nos. 2 to 9 are the persons incharge and responsible for the day-to-day affairs of the company and all of them were actively connived with each other for the commission of the offences.”

    5. At the hearing, learned Counsel for the petitioners urged a limited submission being that the averment that petitioners were the directors and person in charge and responsible for the day-to-day affairs of the company was insufficient to proceed against the petitioners. Thus, Counsel urged that the order dated 15.12.2003 summoning the petitioners to answer the charges was liable to be quashed.

    6. I need not discuss a plethora of authorities on the issue as to what constitutes sufficient averments in a complaint to make it actionable vis-a-vis the directors of a company.

    7. Officers responsible for the conduct of the affairs of a company are generally referred to as directors, managers, secretaries etc. With reference to Sections 291 to 293 of the Companies Act, 1956 it would be evident that what a Board of Directors of a company is empowered to do depends upon the roles and functions assigned to the directors as per the memorandum and articles of association of a company.

    8. It would be sufficient for me to state that the question as to what is the role of a director in a company is a question of fact.

    9. Since criminal liability is foisted upon a director not merely on account of his or her being a director but on account of a conduct, act or omission, there must be a averment in a complaint relatable to the said act or omission.

    10. What would be said sufficient averment?

    11. The answer is found in a 3-Member Bench decision of the Supreme Court SMS Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Neeta Bhalla, (2005) 8 SCC 89, wherein it was observed that a clear, unambiguous and specific allegation against a person impleaded as an accused that he was incharge of and responsible to the company in the conduct of its business at the material time when the offence was committed is sufficient.

    12. Decision in SMS Pharmaceuticals Ltd.'s case has been a subject matter of consideration by the Supreme Court in the latest pronouncement N. Rangachari v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., (2007) 5 SCC 108 in paras 19, 21 and 23 following was observed by the Supreme Court:

    “19. Therefore, a person in the commercial world having a transaction with a company is entitled to presume that the Directors of the company are incharge of the affairs of the company. If any restrictions on their powers are placed by the memorandum or articles of the company, it is for the Directors to establish it at the trial. It is in that context that Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act provides that when the offender is a company, every person, who at the time when the offence was committed was incharge of and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company, shall also be deemed to be guilty of the offence along with the company. It appears to us that an allegation in the complaint that the named accused are Directors of the company itself would usher in the element of their acting for and on behalf of the company and of their being incharge of the company. In Gower and Davies Principles of Modern Company Law (17th Edn.), the theory behind the idea of identification is traced as follows:

    “It is possible to find in the cases varying formulations of the underlying principle, and the most recent definitions suggest that the Courts are prepared today to give the rule of attribution based on identification a somewhat broader scope. In the original formulation in Lennard's Carrying Company case Lord Haldane based identification on a person ‘who is really the directing mind and will of the corporation, the very ego and centre of the personality of the corporation’. Recently, however, such an approach has been castigated by the Privy Council through Lord Hoffmann in Maridian Global case as a misleading ‘general metaphysic of companies’. The true question in each case was who as a matter of construction of the statute in question, or presumably other rule of law, is to be regarded as the Controller of the Company for the purpose of the identification rule.”

    xxxxxxxxx

    21. A person normally having business or commercial dealings with a company, would satisfy himself about its creditworthiness and reliability by looking at its promoters and Board of Directors and the nature and extent of its business and its memorandum or articles of association. Other than that, he may not be aware of the arrangements within the company in regard to its management, daily routine, etc. Therefore, when a cheque issued to him by the company is dishonoured, he is expected only to be aware generally of who are incharge of the affairs of the company. It is not reasonable to expect him to know whether the person who signed the cheque was instructed to do so or whether he has been deprived of his authority to do so when he actually signed the cheque. Those are matters peculiarly within the knowledge of the company and those incharge of it. So, all that a payee of a cheque that is dishonoured can be expected to allege is that the persons named in the complaint are incharge of its affairs. The Directors are prima facie in that position.

    xxxxxxxxx

    23. In the light of the ratio in S.M.S Pharmaceuticals Ltd. what is to be looked into is whether in the complaint, in addition to asserting that the appellant and another are the Directors of the company, it is further alleged that they are incharge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company. We find that such an allegation is clearly made in the complaint which we have quoted above. Learned Senior Counsel for he appellant argued that in Saroj Kumar Poddar case this Court had found the complaint unsustainable only for the reason that there was no specific averment that at the time of issuance of the cheque that was dishonoured, the persons named in the complaint were incharge of the affairs of the company. With great respect, we see no warrant for assuming such a position in the context of the binding ratio in S.M.S Pharmaceuticals Ltd. and in view of the position of the Directors in a company as explained above.”

    13. Thus, I hold that the complaint makes material averments sufficient to attract cognizance of the complaint and issuance of the summons to answer the charge.

    14. The second submission made by learned Counsel for the petitioners and for which Board resolutions were relied was to urge that petitioners 1, 2, 4 and 6 were mere investors. That they merely signed the proposal form of directorship. That they never attended any Board meeting. That in September, 1997 they were removed from the directorship of the company.

    15. Relevance of said submission is that as per the complaint accused No. 1 company had acted contrary to directions issued on 18.11.1997

    16. It was thus urged that by November 1997, petitioners 1, 2, 4 and 6 had ceased to be the directors of accused No. 1.

    17. I am afraid, said plea cannot be taken into account as it relates to a defence which has to be proved after leading evidence.

    18. However, I would be failing if I do not note that the respondent has placed on record a letter dated 13.1.1998 written by accused No. 1, i.e the company enclosing therewith certain information. Balance sheet of the company as of 31.12.1997 has been submitted under cover of said letter. Petitioner Nos. 1 and 2 have signed the balance sheet of the company as on 31.12.1997 Further, letter dated 13.1.1998 informs SEBI that all 8 persons impleaded as accused were the directors of the company.

    19. Qua petitioner No. 1, Sushila Devi, I note it was informed that she was the Managing Director.

    20. As clarified in SMS Pharmaceuticals Ltd. case, by its very nomenclature, a person who holds the post of managing director would be presumed to be managing and controlling the affairs of a company.

    21. I find no merits in the petition.

    22. Dismissed.

    Petition dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sushila Devi v. Securities And Exchange Board Of India .
    (Aug 13, 2007)