Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 403/406/408/415/420, IPC read with Sections 34/120-B, IPC,
  • Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, Cr. P.C)
  • Section 420, IPC read with Section 34, IPC
  • Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)
  • Section 482, Cr.P.C, petitions
  • Sections 469, 504 and 120-B
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 403/406/408/415/420, IPC read with Sections 34/120-B, IPC,
  • Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, Cr. P.C)
  • Section 420, IPC read with Section 34, IPC
  • Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)
  • Section 482, Cr.P.C, petitions
  • Sections 469, 504 and 120-B
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (A.K. Sikri, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

M/s. Ashoka Land and Finance Corporation (the firm) developed “Ashoka Enclave” in Gurgaon. Shri Baldev Lal Khattar booked a 200 sq. yd. plot on 9.4.1963 for Rs. 5,000, paid Rs. 1,250 on booking and later paid remaining instalments. Baldev Lal Khattar died on 29.9.1996. His son, R.K. Khattar (the complainant), after discovering papers relating to the booking, approached the firm and its partners for allotment but received no allotment. The complainant filed a complaint under Section 200, Cr.P.C. alleging cheating; the learned Magistrate took cognizance under Section 420, IPC by order dated 12.9.2000 and issued process against three persons (Kulbhushan Sharma, Gajinder Kumar Jain and Ramchander).

The three accused appeared and were discharged by the Magistrate on 22.9.2004. The complainant filed Criminal Revision No. 102/2004; on 13.7.2005 the Additional Sessions Judge set aside the Magistrate's discharge order, referring to the Supreme Court decision in Adalat Prasad v. Roop Lal Jindal that a Magistrate has no power to review after taking cognizance and that remedy lies under Section 482, Cr.P.C. Following that principle, the present petitions under Section 482 were filed by two of the accused (Ram Chander and Gajinder Kumar Jain) challenging the summoning order dated 12.9.2000.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a prima facie case of cheating punishable under Section 420, IPC (read with Section 34, IPC) is made out on the material in the complaint.
  2. Whether the summoning order dated 12.9.2000 should be quashed and the criminal complaint dismissed on grounds including absence of ingredients of cheating, inordinate delay and laches, and the civil nature of the dispute.

Arguments of the Parties

Accused persons (petitioners)

  • The allegations in the complaint do not make out an offence under Section 420, IPC; the dispute is essentially civil and remedy lay in a suit for specific performance.
  • There was no privity of contract between the complainant (or his father) and the accused, nor any payment made to some of the accused by the complainant's father.
  • The complaint is time-barred and suffers from inordinate delay and laches, given the booking in 1963 and complaint decades later.
  • Gajinder Kumar Jain and Ram Chander contended they had retired from the partnership in November 1981 and that assets & liabilities of the firm were taken over by M/s. Greater Delhi Planners (controlled by Kulbhushan Sharma); payments were made to Greater Delhi Planners and the complainant (and his father) were aware of that fact.
  • The two petitioners asserted they were sleeping partners who did not participate in the firm's business and therefore were not in charge of affairs and could not be properly impleaded as accused.

Complainant

  • The complainant alleged deceit from the beginning: respondents intended to extract money by deceitful means and had not allotted the plot despite full payment.
  • Learned counsel for the complainant submitted that payment of full consideration but failure to give the plot indicated misappropriation and that offences including cheating and allied offences were made out (originally complaint was framed under Sections 403/406/408/415/420 IPC read with Sections 34/120-B).
  • The complainant's counsel relied on authorities (Lalmuni Devi; Kamaladevi Agarwal) to submit that presence of a civil remedy does not preclude criminal proceedings where appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Adalat Prasad v. Roop Lal Jindal, (2004) 7 SCC 338 Magistrate has no power to review its order after taking cognizance and issuing process; remedy for challenging such orders lies under Section 482, Cr.P.C. The ASJ relied on this authority to set aside the Magistrate's discharge order; the opinion notes that because Adalat Prasad indicates the remedy is under Section 482, the present petitions under Section 482 were filed by accused persons challenging the summoning orders.
Suresh v. Mahadevappa Shivappa Danannava, (2005) 3 SCC 670 Complaint filed after inordinate delay may be dismissed; allegations were of civil nature and did not prima facie disclose offence under Section 420, IPC. Used as direct precedent to hold that the present complaint, filed many years after the transaction (34 years), suffers from inordinate delay and laches and does not prima facie disclose offence under Section 420, IPC.
Nageshwar Prasad Singh @ Sinha v. Narayan Singh, (1998) 5 SCC 694 Liability in cases arising out of agreements to sell and payment of earnest money is generally civil in nature and not criminal. Applied to support the conclusion that the dispute over allotment of a plot and payment is civil in character and not a case of cheating warranting criminal prosecution.
Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma v. State of Bihar, (2000) 4 SCC 168 Distinguishes mere breach of contract from cheating; to constitute cheating, fraudulent or dishonest intention must be shown right at the beginning of the transaction. The court quoted and relied on this authority to emphasize that the complaint did not allege dishonest intention at the inception and hence the ingredients of cheating under Section 415/420 were not made out.
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal Enumerates categories of cases where High Court may quash criminal proceedings; used as framework for interference where allegations do not disclose offences. The opinion referenced Bhajan Lal (via the Hridaya Ranjan discussion) to conclude the case falls within the category warranting interference because the necessary ingredients of the alleged offences were not present.
Lalmuni Devi v. State of Bihar, 2001 (1) RCR (Crl.) 228 Authority cited by complainant to show that availability of civil remedy does not preclude maintenance of criminal complaint in appropriate cases. The court acknowledged the proposition but held that even accepting that, here the ingredients of cheating were lacking and delay and laches barred the criminal complaint.
Kamaladevi Agarwal v. State of West Bengal, 2001 (4) RCR (Crl.) 522 Proposition that civil proceedings and criminal actions are to be adjudicated by separate yardsticks; presence of civil remedy does not automatically preclude criminal remedy. The court accepted the general proposition but found it inapplicable to sustain the complaint in this case because the required ingredients of cheating were absent and there was inordinate delay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by analysing chronology, material facts pleaded and legal principles governing the offence of cheating under Sections 415 and 420, IPC.

  1. Timeline and factual admissions: The plot was booked in 1963; instalments were paid over time; by 3.12.1991 Baldev Lal Khattar had written to M/s. Greater Delhi Planners stating he had paid the amount and wanted to construct; he died on 29.9.1996. The complaint was filed in 1997 and cognizance and summoning occurred on 12.9.2000.
  2. Burden to show fraudulent intention at inception: The court reiterated the established principle that to make out cheating under Section 420, the complainant must show fraudulent or dishonest inducement at the time of entering into the transaction — i.e., an intention from the very beginning not to perform the promise. Mere subsequent breach alone does not establish such intention.
  3. Inconsistency in complainant's own pleadings: The complainant himself alleged that transfer was delayed because of a Supreme Court order (PIL) prohibiting building activities within a certain radius, which undercuts the contention that respondents had a dishonest intention from the outset.
  4. Delay and laches: The court relied on Suresh (2005) to conclude that the complaint was filed after an inordinate delay (34 years from booking) and that the complainant did not take action while his father was alive despite having knowledge and correspondence (letter of 1991). This inordinate delay is a factor militating against sustaining a criminal prosecution.
  5. Civil nature of dispute: Citing Nageshwar Prasad and Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma, the court treated the allegations as essentially civil — dispute about allotment, payments and specific performance — and held that such disputes do not, prima facie, disclose cheating unless dishonest intention at inception is pleaded and shown.
  6. Specific contentions of two accused: The court noted contentions that Gajinder Kumar Jain and Ram Chander had retired as partners in 1981 and that Greater Delhi Planners (controlled by Kulbhushan Sharma) had taken over assets/liabilities; also that these petitioners were sleeping partners not involved in management. The court observed that it need not decide these further submissions because the primary ground (absence of ingredients of cheating and delay) sufficed.
  7. Conclusion of analysis: On the cumulative application of the above principles and precedents, the court found that the complaint did not disclose the ingredients of cheating under Section 420, IPC read with Section 34, IPC, and was vitiated by inordinate delay and laches.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court QUASHED the summoning order dated 12.9.2000 and DISMISSED the complaint.

Implications

  • Direct effect: The criminal proceedings founded on the summoning order (12.9.2000) are terminated by quashing the summoning order and dismissal of the complaint; the petitions and applications are disposed of.
  • Reasoning basis: The dismissal was based on (a) absence of prima facie ingredients of cheating under Section 420, IPC read with Section 34, (b) the civil character of the dispute, and (c) inordinate delay and laches in prosecuting the complaint.
  • Precedential effect: The opinion applies existing Supreme Court authorities to the facts but does not purport to lay down a new legal principle; it disposes of the matter on the application of settled principles to the record before the court.
Petitions and Applications disposed of.

    Ram Chander v. R.K Khattar & Anr.

    A.K Sikri, J.— The issues sought to be raised in all these petitions are same and, therefore, the same are heard and decided by this common order.

    2. M/s. Ashoka Land and Finance Corporation, a partnership firm, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the firm’), developed a colony with the name ‘Ashoka Enclave’ in Gurgaon (now vested in Faridabad). It carved out certain plots and offered it to general public for sale. One Shri Baldev Lal Khattar booked a plot with the said firm on 9.4.1963 and the total consideration was fixed at Rs. 5,000/-. He deposited Rs. 1,250/- at the time of booking and later on paid the remaining instalments as well. Shri Baldev Lal Khattar died on 29.9.1996 After his death, his son Mr. R.K Khattar (hereinafter referred to as ‘the complainant’) approached the firm and its partners for allotment of plot but no heed was paid. The complainant, therefore, filed a complaint before the learned Magistrate under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, ‘Cr. P.C’) alleging therein that he was duped by the accused persons. On examination of the complainant, the learned Magistrate took cognizance of the offence under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) vide order dated 12.9.2000 and issued process against the three accused persons, namely Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma, Mr. Gajinder Kumar Jain and Mr. Ramchander. The aforesaid three accused persons appeared before the learned Magistrate and made separate applications for their discharge. These applications were allowed vide order dated 22.9.2004 and the learned MM discharged all the three persons. The complainant filed Criminal Revision No. 102/2004 against the aforesaid three accused persons and vide judgment and order dated 13.7.2005, the learned ASJ has set aside the order of the Magistrate. While allowing the revision petition, the learned ASJ has referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Adalat Prasad v. Roop Lal Jindal, (2004) 7 SCC 338, as per which the Magistrate has no power to review its order after taking cognizance of the offence and issuance of the process. There cannot be any quarrel about the order passed by the learned ASJ and, therefore, the order of the learned MM discharging the three accused persons was rightly passed. However, since in Adalat Prasad (supra), the Supreme Court has held that the remedy lies in invoking Section 482, Cr.P.C, petitions are filed by Mr. Ram Chander, s/o. Raghu Nath (accused No. 3) and Mr. Gajinder Kumar Jain (accused No. 2) challenging the summoning orders dated 12.9.2000 passed by the learned MM.

    3. As mentioned above, plot was booked by the father of the complainant in the year 1963 and he made payments towards the said plot. It was booked with the firm. According to the averments made in the plaint, total consideration was Rs. 5,000/- for 200 sq. yds. A sum of Rs. 1,250/-, i.e 25% of the amount, was paid at the time of booking the plot on 9.4.1963; balance amount was sent to M/s. Greater Delhi Planners, in view of the fact that vide letter dated 29.6.1963, father of the complainant was intimated that the balance payment is to be made to M/s. Greater Delhi Planners. Till his death on 29.9.1996, father of the complainant had not taken any legal steps against the accused persons. In the complaint, the complainant has mentioned that before his death, his father had written letter dated 3.12.1991 to M/s. Greater Delhi Planners to know the exact position of the site, since he wanted to carry out construction over his plot as he had already paid the entire amount. It is explained that the complainant found the papers relating to the booking of the said plot after the death of his father and then he immediately tried to contact Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma (accused No. 1), who is described as the partner/proprietor/managing director of M/s. Greater Delhi Planners. It is alleged that Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma initially refused to talk further and later even threatened the complainant with dire consequences. According to the complainant, it shows that from the very beginning it was the intention of the respondents to extract money from the complainant's father by deceitful means. It is also mentioned that during the lifetime of complainant's father, since there was legal hindrance for transfer of the plot due to a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) pending in the Supreme Court as the Supreme Court had barred the building activities within the radius of 5 kms, from Suraj Kund and Badkhal Lake, which covered the area in question as well, the plot could not have been given at that time. After this restriction was relaxed, the accused persons were liable to make the allotment and their actions in not doing so clearly show that they had intention to cheat the father of the complainant.

    4. All the three accused persons have filed three petitions challenging the summoning orders, though on different grounds. Insofar as Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma is concerned, his plea is that no case under Section 420, IPC is made out on the basis of the averments made in the complaint and the evidence on record. He also submitted that complainant had admitted that there was no privity of contract between him and the accused persons nor had he made payment to the accused persons. It was further submitted that the dispute, if any, is of civil nature and if the father of the complainant was not given the plot, remedy was to file a suit for specific performance. During his life-time, he never filed any such suit for specific performance and such a remedy had become time barred long ago while the complainant's father was still alive. It was also submitted that even the criminal complaint, alleging the offence of cheating, filed more than 30 years after the alleged booking of the plot, was time barred.

    5. The other two accused persons, namely Gajinder Kumar Jain and Ram Chander, in addition made the following submissions:

    (a) Gajinder Kumar Jain and Ram Chander had retired as partners from the firm way back in November 1981 and the complainant as well as his father were well aware of this fact;

    (b) all the assets and liabilities of the firm were taken over by M/s. Greater Delhi Planners, a firm fully owned and controlled by Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma (accused No. 1). It is for this reason that the remaining instalments were paid by the father of the complainant to M/s. Greater Delhi Planners and this fact was within the knowledge of the father of the complainant. Further, even letter dated 3.12.1991, allegedly written by the father of the complainant, was addressed to Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma of M/s. Greater Delhi Planners, as he knew that the petitioners had nothing to do with the firm.

    (c) Since 1963, the petitioners were not in picture and the father of the complainant also never contacted the petitioners during his lifetime and never lodged any complaint against the petitioners. It is also mentioned that the petitioners were only sleeping partners and never participated in the business of the firm, of which the active partner was Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma only and they were, therefore, not in charge of the affairs of the said firm and, thus, could not be impleaded as accused persons.

    6. The first and the foremost question which arises for consideration is as to whether prima facie case of cheating is made out by the complainant. As would be clear from the averments made in the complaint itself and the admitted position appearing on record, the plot in question was booked in the year 1963. Thereafter, payments were made in instalments from time-to-time. Though it is not stated as to when the last instalment was paid, fact remains that this must have been given much before 1991 as on 3.12.1991 the father of the complainant had written letter to M/s. Greater Delhi Planners mentioning that the payment had been made and wanted to know the exact position of the site as he wanted to construct over his plot. It is not stated as to what happened after he wrote this letter. Fact remains that he was not given the plot. Thus, even if we take his demand made in letter dated 3.12.1991 as the starting point of cause of action, admittedly father of the complainant did not take any steps till 29.9.1996 when he died. If the accused persons were not giving him the plot, he did not allege that he was cheated and file criminal complaint. He did not even file a suit for specific performance.

    7. It is the case of the complainant that he found papers relating to this plot after the death of his father, though he has not stated as to when he found these papers. However, what is stated is that when he tried to contact Mr. Kulbhushan Sharma, he refused to talk further. How on the basis of the aforesaid averments the complainant could say that from very beginning it was the intention of the accused persons to extract money from his father by deceitful means. This notion of the complainant would further be falsified as he has himself stated that there was legal hindrance for the transfer of plot due to the orders passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in some Public Interest Litigation. Thus, on the one hand, the complainant admits that the accused persons did not give the plot to his father during his lifetime because of the orders of the Supreme Court, and on the other hand, he alleges that there was intention to cheat his father from inception.

    8. It is necessary that to constitute the offence of cheating, it is shown that there was fraudulent or dishonest inducement to the person so deceived, to deliver any property to the persons deceiving him. Thus, this fraudulent or dishonest inducement has to be at the time of entering into the deal. Therefore, the necessary ingredient which had to be established by the complainant in the instant case was that from the very beginning, i.e when the plot in question was booked by the father of the complainant, there was deceitful intention on the part of the accused persons not to give him plot and extract money. However, the complainant has himself stated that the plot could not be given earlier not because of bad intentions but because of the Supreme Court's orders.

    9. In Suresh v. Mahadevappa Shivappa Danannava, (2005) 3 SCC 670, the complainant had alleged that agreement to sell dated 25.12.1988 in respect of a house was executed in favour of his wife by the accused person. The accused person (A-1) sold the said house to the wife of another accused (A-4). Legal notice dated 11.7.1996 was issued by the complainant calling upon the accused No. 1 to execute the sale deed. Accused No. 1 replied to the said notice on 18.7.1996 denying the very existence of the said agreement and the receipt of the amount. Complainant filed the complaint on 17.5.1999, i.e nearly three years from the date of reply by the accused No. 1, and 10-½ years from the date of the alleged agreement. The Apex Court, in these circumstances, held that complaint was not at all maintainable at this distance of time and was liable to be dismissed on the ground of inordinate laches on the part of the complainant itself. It was also held that the allegations in the complaint were of civil nature and did not prima facie disclose commission of alleged offence under Section 420, IPC. The instant case of the complainant is even one worse. The alleged agreement is of the year 1963. For almost 33 years, till the father of the complainant was alive, he did not take any legal steps. Even if there was some embargo because of the Supreme Court orders, as per the complainant's own showing, letter dated 3.12.1991 was written by the complainant's father, but even thereafter no steps were taken. Present complaint was filed in the year 1997, i.e after a lapse of 34 years from the date of alleged booking of the plot. The allegations contained in the complaint do not make out a case under Section 420, IPC and there is inordinate delay and laches.

    10. Likewise, Nageshwar Prasad Singh @ Sinha v. Narayan Singh, (1998) 5 SCC 694, was also a case arising out of agreement to sell and earnest money was paid as part consideration. The Supreme Court held that liability, if any, was of civil nature and not criminal. Similarly, in Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma v. State of Bihar, (2000) 4 SCC 168, the Court found that when the allegations in the complaint, read as a whole, did not indicate, expressly or impliedly, any intentional deception on the part of the appellants right from the beginning of the transaction, ingredients of cheating, as mentioned in Section 415, IPC were not made out. In that case, the Court distinguished cheating from mere breach of contract. After quoting the provisions of section 415, ipc which defines cheating, the Apex Court observed as under:

    “14. On a reading of the section it is manifest that in the definition there are set forth two separate classes of acts which the person deceived may be induced to do. In the first place he may be induced fraudulently or dishonestly to deliver any property to any person. The second class of acts set forth in the section is the doing or omitting to do anything which the person deceived would not do or omit to do if he were not so deceived. In the first class of cases the inducing must be fraudulent or dishonest. In the second class of acts, the inducing must be intentional but not fraudulent or dishonest.

    15. In determining the question it has to be kept in mind that the distinction between mere breach of contract and the offence of cheating is a fine one. It depends upon the intention of the accused at the time of inducement which may be judged by his subsequent conduct but for this subsequent conduct is not the sole test, Mere breach of contract cannot give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right at the beginning of the transaction, that is the time when the offence is said to have been committed. Therefore it is the intention which is the gist of the offence. To hold a person guilty of cheating it is necessary to show that he had fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making the promise. From his mere failure to keep up promise subsequently such a culpable intention right at the beginning, that is, when he made the promise cannot be presumed.

    16. Judged on the touchstone of the principles noted above, the present case in our considered view warrants interference inasmuch as the ingredients of the offence of cheating punishable under Section 420, IPC and its allied offences under Sections 418 and 423 has not been made out. So far as the offences under Sections 469, 504 and 120-B are concerned even the basic allegations making out a case thereunder are not contained in the complaint. That being the position the case comes within the first category of cases enumerated in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal and as such warrants interference by the Court. Reading the averments in the complaint in entirety and accepting the allegations to be true, the ingredients of intentional deception on the part of the accused right at the beginning of the negotiations for the transaction has neither been expressly stated nor indirectly suggested in the complaint. All that respondent 2 has alleged against the appellants is that they did not disclose to him that one of their brothers had filed a partition suit which was pending. The requirement that the information was not disclosed by the appellants intentionally in order to make respondent 2 part with the property is not alleged expressly or even impliedly in the complaint. Therefore the core postulate of dishonest intention in order to deceive the complainant-respondent 2 is not made out even accepting all the averments in the complaint on their face value. In such a situation continuing the criminal proceeding against the accused will be, in our considered view, an abuse of the process of the Court. The High Court was not right in declining to quash the complaint and the proceeding initiated on the basis of the same.”

    11. Learned Counsel for the complainant submitted that since father of the complainant had paid full consideration but still the plot was not given, it would be clear that the accused had misappropriated the plot and case of cheating and fraud was made out. It has to be noted in the first instance that though the complainant had filed the complaint under Sections 403/406/408/415/420, IPC read with Sections 34/120-B, IPC, summoning order was passed only under Section 420, IPC read with Section 34, IPC and, therefore, we are concerned only with the allegations of cheating. As pointed out above, this case had the trappings of civil claim and ingredients of cheating are not made out. Counsel for the complainant relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Lalmuni Devi v. State of Bihar, 2001 (1) RCR (Crl.) 228, to buttress his submission that merely when a civil claim is also maintainable does not mean that criminal complaint cannot be maintained. He also referred to the judgment of the Apex Court in Kamaladevi Agarwal v. State of West Bengal, 2001 (4) RCR (Crl.) 522, wherein the Supreme Court held that civil proceedings, as distinguished from criminal action, have to be adjudicated and concluded by adopting separate yardsticks. There is no quarrel about this proposition. There may be instances where both civil and criminal remedies are open to an aggrieved person and he is at liberty to take any or both these remedies. However, in the instant case, as mentioned above, not only ingredients of cheating are lacking, but the complaint filed suffers from delay and laches as well.

    12. In view of the aforesaid, I need not go into the other submissions advanced by the petitioners—Ram Chander and Gajender Kumar Jain, stating that they had retired from the partnership firm and further that since the said firm was taken over by M/s. Greater Delhi Planners, they have no liability. Accordingly, summoning order dated 12.9.2000 is quashed and the complaint is dismissed.

    13. Petitions and the applications stand disposed of.

    Petitions and Applications disposed of.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Chander v. R.K Khattar & Anr.
    (Nov 18, 2006)