Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Comprehensive Summary of the Opinion (Pradeep Nandrajog, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from an application under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC seeking review of an order dated 11.2.2005 which had disposed IA No.4016/03 filed by defendant No.3 under Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC. The order under challenge had granted defendant No.3 unconditional leave to defend.

The plaintiff contended that it did not get an opportunity to present its case because when IA No.4016/03 was listed on 4.2.2005, counsel for defendant No.3 requested an adjournment which was refused. The court directed defendant No.3 to file written submissions within three days and gave the plaintiff two days to respond. No written submissions were filed by either side and the court proceeded to decide IA No.4016/03 on the pleadings on 11.2.2005. The plaintiff states it did not file submissions because it was awaiting the defendants' written submissions.

On 18.5.2005 the court heard the parties on whether the order dated 11.2.2005 granting leave to defend should be reviewed or recalled.

Substantively, the suit is a summary judgment proceeding based on 22 dishonoured cheques (total principal Rs. 2,07,95,253/-) issued on behalf of defendant No.1. The plaint also claims pre-suit interest at 27% per annum (Rs. 28,07,247/- as calculated in the plaint) and a total claim of Rs. 2,36,02,600/-. Defendant No.1 is a company; defendant No.2 is its Managing Director and defendant No.3 is a Director.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 11.2.2005 (which granted defendant No.3 leave to defend under Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC) should be reviewed or recalled under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
  2. Whether the plaint, and particularly the averments as to defendant No.3, sufficiently plead a cause of action against defendant No.3 as a guarantor or on any other personal liability ground.
  3. Whether a claim for pre-suit and pendente-lite interest at 27% per annum is permissible within a summary suit founded on negotiable instruments (cheques) under Order 37 CPC, given the statutory interest regime under the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  4. Whether defendant No.3 has prima facie grounds (on the pleadings and available material) to be granted leave to defend — including specific contentions about resignation as Director, denial of signatures and denial of execution of any guarantee bond.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff sought review on the ground that it was not afforded an opportunity to present its case at the hearing of IA No.4016/03 on 4.2.2005 — the plaintiff did not file written submissions because it was awaiting defendants' submissions.
  • The plaint pleads that defendants 2 and 3 were guarantors (stated in paragraph 8 of the plaint) and that defendants 2 and 3 are personally liable; plaintiff relied on a typed copy of a guarantee bond dated 9.5.1996 filed in reply to the leave application.
  • The plaint contains a statement (in para 17) averring that no relief beyond the scope of Order 37 CPC is claimed (this averment was relied upon, but the court found it to be incorrect because pre-suit interest at 27% was claimed).

Defendant No.3's Arguments

  • Defendant No.3 asserted that he had resigned as Director of defendant No.1 on 2.11.1995, whereas the transactions occurred in 1997–1998; a certified copy of Form-32 from the Registrar of Companies was filed (dated 22.1.1995 per the opinion).
  • Defendant No.3 denied signing any of the cheques, denied executing any guarantee bond, denied receipt of any goods on behalf of defendant No.1, and denied having control over the management of defendant No.1 after 1995.
  • On these factual denials and the absence of the original guarantee bond in the plaint, defendant No.3 asserted a prima facie defence deserving leave to defend.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a textual and procedural analysis of the plaint and the leave application. The principal strands of the court's reasoning are as follows.

  1. Initial mistake and correction: The judge acknowledged an earlier error in observing that the plaint contained no averment that defendant No.3 stood as a guarantor. On re-examination the judge found that paragraph 8 of the plaint did in fact state that defendants 2 and 3 were guarantors. The failure to note this earlier was attributed to the plaint's focus on the cheques and otherwise unsatisfactory drafting.
  2. Close reading of the plaint: A detailed reading of paragraphs 3 to 9 showed that while various allegations of personal liability appear in paragraphs 3, 6 and 7, the specific averment of a guarantor relationship is only in paragraph 8. The pleaded cause of action (paragraph 9) is tied to the dates when the cheques were presented and dishonoured.
  3. Deficiencies in pleading guarantee particulars: Importantly, the court stressed that no particulars of any guarantee signed by defendant No.3 were set out in the plaint; nor was there an averment that defendant No.3 was called upon to pay as guarantor on default by defendant No.1. The court set out the minimal pleadings necessary to make out a cause of action against a guarantor, namely:
    • (a) A pleading that the defendant stood as guarantor in respect of the principal debtor and facts showing how that status arose;
    • (b) That the principal debtor defaulted;
    • (c) That under the guarantee the guarantor was called upon to make payment and he did not pay;
    • (d) That the guarantor's liability is co-extensive with the principal debtor's liability.
    The court found that the plaint lacked these requisite assertions.
  4. Absence of original guarantee bond and the defendant's denials: The original guarantee bond was not filed with the plaint; defendant No.3 denied execution of any guarantee bond and filed a certified Form-32 indicating resignation as director. On the available materials, the court concluded defendant No.3 would be entitled to put forward a defence that he had resigned before the transactions and had no involvement in management or signing the cheques.
  5. Claim for interest beyond Order 37: The court analysed the interest claim. Order 37 Rule 2(1)(b) requires that a plaint for summary judgment aver that no relief outside the ambit of Order 37 is claimed. Although the plaint contained such an averment in paragraph 17, the court found it incorrect because the plaint claimed pre-suit interest at 27% per annum. The court observed that in a suit founded on negotiable instruments (cheques), the statutory interest regime under the Negotiable Instruments Act prescribes the maximum interest that can be claimed; there was no pleaded or demonstrated written acknowledgement by the defendants agreeing to 27% interest. Thus, the claim for 27% interest took the relief beyond the scope of a pure Order 37 summary recovery.
  6. Conclusion on leave to defend: For these reasons — (i) inadequacy of pleadings on guarantee particulars and notice to guarantor, (ii) non-production of original guarantee bond and defendant's denial, and (iii) the claim for excessive interest beyond the scope of a negotiable-instrument-based summary suit — the court concluded that defendant No.3 would be entitled to leave to defend. The court emphasised that, though the earlier reasoning was in part mistaken about the absence of a guarantor averment, on different grounds (including the pleading deficiencies and the interest claim), defendant No.3 nonetheless merits leave to defend.

The court therefore refused the plaintiff's application for review/revocation of the order granting leave to defend, and proceeded to make directions for further pleadings and listing.

Holding and Implications

Holding: IA No.2157/05 is dismissed and defendant No.3 is entitled to leave to defend the suit. The order granting leave under Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC (the disposal of IA No.4016/03 on 11.2.2005) is not disturbed in substance because, even after correcting an earlier oversight, the court found independent and sufficient reasons to allow defendant No.3 to defend.

Direct consequences and procedural directions:

  • Defendant No.3 has filed a written statement; the plaintiff is to file replication within six weeks.
  • The suit (CS(OS) 2191/98) is listed for further proceedings on 22.8.2005.

Broader implications: The opinion does not articulate any novel or binding precedent. It confines itself to applying established pleading requirements for claims against guarantors and the limits of summary proceedings under Order 37 CPC where non-statutory interest is claimed. No wider ratio decidendi or new precedent is set out in the opinion; the decision's immediate effect is to permit defendant No.3 to contest the claim on the merits and to require more definite pleading or production of original documents by the plaintiff.

    Steel Authority Of India Ltd v. Century Tubes Ltd. & Ors .

    Pradeep Nandrajog, J.:— By the present application under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC, plaintiff seeks review of the order dated 11.2.2005 by which order IA.No 4016/03 filed defendant No. 3 under Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC was disposed of. Defendant No. 3 was granted unconditional leave to defend.

    2. Review is principally sought on the ground that the plaintiff did not get an opportunity to present its case for the reason when IA.No 4016/03 came up for hearing on 4.2.2005, counsel for defendant No. 3 made a request for an adjournment. Suit being of the year 1998, adjournment was declined. Defendant No. 3 was directed to file written submissions within three days. Counsel for the plaintiff was given two days time to respond thereto. IA.No 4016/03 was reserved for orders. No written submissions being received from either party, this court went through the pleadings of the parties on its own and vide order dated 11.2.2005 disposed of IA.No 4016/03. It is stated in the present application that the plaintiff was awaiting written submissions from the defendants and for said reason, plaintiff did not file its written submissions.

    3. On 18.5.2005, I heard the parties on the issue of leave to defend in the context whether order dated 1.2.2005 needs to be reviewed/recalled.

    4. Suit seeks a summary judgment against the defendants. As per the averments made in the plaint, defendant No. 1 is a company registered under the Companies Act. Defendant No. 2 is its Managing Director and defendant No. 3 is its Director. As per the plaint, defendants 2 and 3 secured credit facilities from the plaintiff on behalf of defendant No. 1. Material used to be lifted from the stockyard of the plaintiff. 22 cheques were issues totalling Rs. 2,07,95,253/-. Cheques were issued, on behalf of defendant No. 1 under the signatures of defendants 2 and 3. Cheques were dishonoured. Principle amount payable is stated to be the sum covered by said 22 cheques i.e Rs. 2,07,95,253/-. Interest @ 27% per annum calculated from 22.7.1998 till date of suit is stated to be Rs. 28,07,347/-. Suit, therefore, claims a decree in the sum of Rs. 2,36,02,600/- together with interest @ 27% per annum.

    5. While allowing IA.4016/03, on reading of the plaint I had noted that there was no averment in the plaint that defendant No. 3 stood as a guarantor. I had read the plaint and held that a meaningful reading of the plaint shows that liability was being fastened on defendant No. 3 because he was a Director of defendant No. 1. That defendant No. 3 had signed some cheques from the account of defendant No. 1 would not make him personally liable in a civil action for recovery of the amount from defendant No. 1.

    6. I was wrong in my observation pertaining to there being no averment against defendant No. 3 as a guarantor for the reason, as point out at the hearing, in para 8 of the plaint it is stated that defendant No. 3 as well as defendant No. 2 were guarantors.

    7. Reason why said averment of the plaintiff was overlooked is that the plaintiff has pleaded cause of action only on the cheques and had otherwise made averments in the plaint which are far from satisfactory. Averments made in paras 3 to 9 of the plaint are relevant and may be noted:

    “3. The defendant No. 2 is the Managing Director and defendant No. 3 is the Director of defendant No. 1 company respectively and had sought and secured credit facilities on behalf of defendant No. 1 and in their personal capacities from the plaintiff in respect of the dues or amounts payable to the plaintiff for the supply of various types of steel materials from time to time. The plaintiff supply different types of steel materials from time to time either by issuing offer letters and delivery orders or through railway receipts. The defendant Nos. 2 and 3 are looking after the business of defendant No. 1.

    4. The defendant No. 2 and 3 on behalf of defendant No. 1 used to lift materials from the stockyard of the plaintiff in Ballavgarh as well as by district dispatch from the steel plants on credit by issuing blank undated cheques along with the letter of authorities issued by the defendant Nos. 2 and 3 on behalf of defendant No. 1 in favour of the plaintiff to enable the plaintiff to present the cheque after putting the dates and the invoice value in respect of the goods/materials delivered to defendant No. 1 by the plaintiff. These cheques were to be presented after the expiry of the credit period granted by the plaintiff in favour of defendant No. 1. The defendants No. 2 and 3 on behalf of defendant No. 1 had issued 22 cheques and the particulars are given herein below:—

    x x x x x

    (particulars of cheques have been given)

    x x x x x

    The above mentioned cheques were of Punjab National Bank, Nehru Place, Branch, New Delhi-19 issued by defendant No. 2 and 3 on behalf of defendant No. 1. The plaintiff deposited these 22 cheques issued on behalf of the defendant No. 1 on different dates after an expiry of the credit facility extended to defendant No. 1 by the plaintiff to their banker State Bank of India. All the cheques presented by the plaintiff were dishonoured with the remarks “exceeds in arrangements.

    5. The plaintiff thereafter issued 22 notices under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (As amended) to all the defendants demanding payments of total amount of Rs. 2,07,95,253/- within 15 days from the date of receipt of the said notices. The defendants have received this notice but did not make any payment to the plaintiff till date.

    6. The defendants are liable to pay of the price of the steel materials sold and delivered by the plaintiff for which no payment was received due to dishonouring all the cheques issued by defendant No. 2 & 3 on behalf of defendant No. 1 and as such the plaintiff is entitled to claim interest @ 27% along with the principal amount due to the plaintiff from the defendants in the present suit. The particulars of the claim of the plaintiff are as under:

    DESCRIPTION AMOUNT (i) Principal amount Rs. 2,07,95,253 (ii) Interest on amount @ 27% calculated up to 22-7-1998. Rs. 28,07,247 Total: Rs. 2,36,02,600

    7. The defendants No. 2 & 3 are also personally liable for the aforesaid amount payable to the plaintiff for the goods received on behalf of defendant No. 1. All these defendants are liable to pay Rs. 2,236,02,600/-(Rupees two crores thirty six lakhs two thousand six hundred only) including interest due to payable by the defendant No. 1 since they have failed to pay the amount despite demand for such payment made by the plaintiff.

    8. The plaintiff is entitled to recover the aforesaid amount of Rs. 2,36,02,600/- (Rupees two crores thirty six lakhs two thousand six hundred only) with interest @ 27% from the defendant No. 2 & 3 being the guarantors of the principal debtor that is defendant No. 1. The defendants No. 2 & 3 had misappropriated the said amount for their personal benefit and use and as such they are liable to pay the aforesaid amount with 27% interest. The plaintiff is also entitled to future interest @ 27% till the date of payment.

    9. The cause of action for the present suit arose when the materials were lifted by the defendants on the date of presentation of these 22 cheques on 21.3.98, 23.3.98, 24.3.98, 30.3.98, 3.4.98, 6.4.98, 11.4.98 The cause of action again arose when the plaintiff issued legal notices to the defendants under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (as amended) after the said cheques were dishonoured on their presentation and again when the defendants failed to pay the entire amount with interest even after services of notices under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (as amended).”

    8. A perusal of paras 3 to 9 of the plaint would reveal that in para 3 of the plaint, plaintiff states that defendants 2 and 3 in their personal capacity obtained credit facilities for defendant No. 1. In para 4, plaintiff states that defendants 2 and 3 used to lift material and had issued 22 cheques. In para 5 of the plaint it is stated that the said cheques bounced. In para 6 it is averred that defendants are liable to pay the price of the material received. In para 7, it is averred that defendants 2 and 3 are personally liable for the aforesaid amount. It is only in para 8 it is stated that defendants 2 and 3 being the guarantors of defendant No. 1 are liable. The cause of action pleaded in para 9 is the date when cheques were dishonoured.

    9. No particulars of guarantee signed by defendant No. 3 has been set out in the plaint. There is no averment that defendant No. 3 was called upon to pay the amount as a guarantor on default of payment by defendant No. 1.

    10. It is trite that if action is founded against a defendant on a cause which emanates from a written document, particulars of the documents have to be stated in the plaint. To constitute a complete cause of action against a guarantor, in the least, following pleadings have to be made in the plaint:

    (a) That in respect of a transaction with the principle debtor, defendant stood as a guarantor. Facts showing as to how defendants stood as a guarantor have to be pleaded.

    (b) That the principle debtor defaulted in making payment.

    (c) That under the deed of guarantee/guarantee bond, guarantor was called upon to make the payment and he did not pay.

    (d) That liability of guarantor is co-extensive as that of the principle debtor.

    11. Plaint lacks assertions as afore-noted.

    12. Be that as it may, even the guarantee bond was not filed along with the plaint. Further, while pleading cause of action, qua defendant No. 1 cause of action pleaded had to be that cheques issued by the said defendant bounced. This cause of action has been pleaded. Qua defendant No. 3, while pleading cause of action, it was required to be pleaded that defendant No. 3 is liable to pay under the guarantee bond. It was required to be pleaded that plaintiff called upon defendant No. 3 to honour the obligation under the guarantee bond and that in spite of service of notice, defendant No. 3 failed to discharge his legal obligation. None has been pleaded.

    13. While seeking leave to defend, defendant No. 3 has averred that he resigned from the Directorship of defendant No. 1 on 2.11.1995 while the transaction took place in the year 1997-1998. Certified copy of Form-32 from the record of the Registrar of Companies dated 22.1.1995 has been filed. Defendant No. 3 has denied his signatures on any cheque. Defendant No. 3 has further denied having executed any guarantee bond. Defendant No. 3 has denied receipt of any goods on behalf of defendant No. 1. Defendant No. 3 has denied any control over the management of defendant No. 1 post 1995.

    14. In reply to application of defendant No. 3 seeking leave to defend, plaintiff has averred that defendant No. 3 had executed a personal guarantee bond dated 9.5.1996 A true typed copy of the guarantee bond has been filed.

    15. While granting leave to defend to defendant No. 3, I had held the said defendant to be entitled to leave to defend on two grounds. First being that the plaint does not bring out personal liability of defendant No. 3. The second was that interest has been claimed @ 27% per annum for the pre-suit period as also pendente-lite. Suit being based on a negotiable instrument i.e cheques, I had held that statutory interest prescribed under the Negotiable Instrument Act is the maximum which could be claimed.

    16. Under Clause (b) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 2 of Order 37 CPC, a plaint seeking summary judgment must contain an averment that no relief which does not fall within the ambit of the rule has been claimed in the plaint. In para 17 of the plaint, plaintiff has made said averment. However, said claim is incorrect for the reason, pre-suit interest @ 27% per annum has been claimed.

    17. Suit is based on 22 dishonoured cheques. No document has been relied by the plaintiff, much less shown during arguments, which contains a written acknowledgment of the defendants that defendants would be liable to pay interest @ 27% per annum. It is obvious that the suit claims a relief which falls beyond the scope of Order 37 CPC in so far it relates to recovery of interest.

    18. Original guarantee bond has not been filed. Defendant has denied having executed any guarantee bond. Defendant has filed certified copy of Form 32. Defendant would, therefore, be entitled to a defence entitling the defendant to show that he had resigned as a Director of defendant No. 1 in the year 1995 and had no concern with the management of said defendant in the year 1997-1998. Defendant No. 3 would be entitled to a defence to establish that he had not signed the cheques in question.

    19. Though for different reasons, defendant No. 3 would still be entitled to leave to defend.

    20. IA.No 2157/05 is accordingly dismissed.

    CS(OS) 2191/98

    Defendant No. 3 has filed written statement. Replication be filed within six weeks.

    Suit be listed for further proceedings on 22.8.2005

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Steel Authority Of India Ltd v. Century Tubes Ltd. & Ors .
    (May 23, 2005)