AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962,
  • Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act
  • SECTION 108 A CUSTOMS ACT
  • Section 135(1)(ii)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962,
  • Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act
  • SECTION 108 A CUSTOMS ACT
  • Section 135(1)(ii)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner sought anticipatory bail under Section 438 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.P.C.) anticipating arrest for involvement in fraudulent evasion of customs duty amounting to Rs. 4.64 crores. The evasion was allegedly carried out through mis-declaration and under-valuation of imported MPEG cards by four firms controlled by the petitioner. On June 3, 2004, the petitioner’s office was raided by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), and he voluntarily appeared before the officials, making a statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act admitting control over the firms involved. He undertook partial payment of the evaded customs duty. The investigation revealed his active role as the mastermind behind the import and local sale of MPEG cards, with evidence including witness statements and financial transaction scrutiny. The petitioner later retracted his statement, claiming it was made under duress, and argued that payments made were coerced and not acknowledgments of guilt. Additionally, the petitioner cited serious health issues as grounds against arrest. The respondent opposed bail, asserting ongoing investigation, lack of full cooperation by the petitioner, and alleged absconding. The court considered relevant precedents and conflicting contentions on the nature of the offence and bail eligibility.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to anticipatory bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C. in a case involving alleged fraudulent evasion of customs duty.
  2. Whether the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962 is bailable or non-bailable.
  3. The legal effect and admissibility of the petitioner’s statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act and subsequent retraction.
  4. The relevance of the petitioner’s health condition in considering the grant of anticipatory bail.
  5. The extent to which ongoing investigation and alleged non-cooperation influence the grant of anticipatory bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act was made under compulsion and later retracted.
  • Payments made towards evaded customs duty were coerced and should not be construed as an admission of guilt.
  • He suffers from serious health conditions, including a history of cardiac bypass surgery and spinal tuberculosis, making arrest and detention life-threatening.
  • The offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act is bailable, entitling him to anticipatory bail.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The investigation is ongoing, and the petitioner has not cooperated fully, sometimes evading participation citing medical reasons.
  • The petitioner has been virtually absconding, not residing at his declared office-cum-residence.
  • The petitioner acted as the mastermind behind the customs duty evasion scheme, with evidence showing his active involvement in procurement, transportation, and sale of the goods.
  • The offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act is non-bailable, as held in relevant case law.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Enforcement Officer, TED, Bombay v. Bher Chand Tikaji Bora, 2000 (121) ELT 7 (SC) Opposition to grant of bail in economic offence cases. Relied upon to support refusal of bail due to serious allegations and ongoing investigation.
Dukhishyam Benepani, Assistant Director, Enforcement Directorate (FERA) v. Arun Kumar Bajoria, 1998 JCC (SC) 18 Blanket orders insulating accused from arrest undermine interrogation. Applied to emphasize that anticipatory bail should not prevent effective investigation.
Directorate Of Enforcement v. Ashok Kumar Jain, 1998 (1) JCC (SC) 1 Health conditions do not exempt accused from arrest but require custodial care. Used to reject petitioner’s ill-health plea as a ground for bail.
State Through Deputy Commissioner Of Police, Special Branch, Delhi v. Jaspal Singh Gill, 1984 CRI.L.J 1211 Rejection of bail on health grounds in economic offence cases. Supported denial of bail despite petitioner’s health issues.
Ram Narain Popli v. CBI, 2003 1 AD (CRI) SC 253 General principles on bail and investigation in economic offences. Referred to in context of bail denial.
Del Agha v. Directorate Of Revenue Intelligence, 2002 (1) CC Cases (HC) 152 Opposition to grant of bail in customs evasion cases. Invoked to support respondent’s stance against bail.
Sanjiv Kumar Gupta v. Commissioner of Customs, 2001 (1) JCC Delhi 146 Authority regarding bail in customs offence cases. Used to argue non-bailability of the offence.
Subhash Chanana v. State, 1994 CRI.L.J 2370 (Delhi High Court) Considerations on bail in economic offences. Referred to in opposition to bail.
Rama Swaroop v. The State (Delhi Admn.) & Others, 1986 CRI.L.J 526 Precedent on bail and investigation cooperation. Supported denial of bail due to incomplete cooperation.
Wajinder Singh etc. v. State, 1979 Rajdhani Law Reporter 381 Principles on bail in criminal cases. Referred to in the context of bail refusal.
Mohan Lal Thapar v. Y.P Dabara, Inspector, Customs, New Customs house, New Delhi, 2002 (1) JCC 460 Determination that offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of Customs Act is non-bailable. Applied to reject petitioner’s claim that the offence is bailable.
Subhash Chaudhary v. Deepak Jyala & Others, CRL. W.P 1384/2004 (Bombay High Court) Contended by petitioner to support bailability of offence under Section 135(1)(ii). Court found the decision contradictory and declined to follow it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, noting it carries punishment extending to three years or fine or both. The Court rejected the petitioner’s contention that the offence is bailable, referencing the classification in Table II of the First Schedule to the Cr.P.C. and prior authoritative decisions including Mohan Lal Thapar v. Y.P Dabara. The Court found the Bombay High Court decision cited by the petitioner to be internally inconsistent and declined to follow it.

Regarding the petitioner’s health condition, the Court held that ill-health does not grant immunity from prosecution or arrest in economic offences, referencing the Supreme Court’s observations in Directorate Of Enforcement v. Ashok Kumar Jain and other precedents. The Court emphasized that authorities must take adequate care of detainees’ health but should not be restricted in their statutory functions.

The Court also considered the evidence indicating the petitioner’s complicity and the ongoing investigation, noting allegations of incomplete cooperation and absconding. It referred to the principle that blanket protection from arrest would render interrogation ineffective, as highlighted in Dukhishyam Benepani v. Arun Kumar Bajoria.

Balancing these factors, the Court concluded that the petition for anticipatory bail should be declined.

Holding and Implications

The petition for anticipatory bail is dismissed.

The interim protection granted earlier is vacated. The decision directly affects the petitioner by denying anticipatory bail, thereby permitting his arrest and continued investigation. No new legal precedent is established; the ruling affirms existing principles regarding the non-bailability of offences punishable with imprisonment up to three years under the Customs Act and the limited role of health considerations in bail decisions involving economic offences.

    Inderjeet Nagpal v. Directorate Of Revenue Intelligence (Dri) .

    B.N Chaturvedi, J.:— In anticipation of his arrest on account of being invovled in fraudulent evasion of customs duty to the tune of Rs. 4.64 crores by way of mis-declaration and under valuation in respect of import of MPEG cards in the names of four firms, namely, M/s. Shri Krishna Impex, M/s. Damodar Enterprises, M/s. Marco Enterprises and M/s. Nav Durga Enterprises, the petitioner seeks grant of pre-arrest bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C

    2. The petitioner is running an office by the name of M/s. Everything International at his residential premises bearing No. C-163, Greater Kailash, Part-I, New Delhi, which was raided by the officials of the respondent, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence(DRI), on 3rd of June, 2004 in connection with investigation in regard to import of MPEG cards by aforesaid firms by mis-declaring and under valuing the same as PCB. ON being so required, the petitioner appeared before the concerned DRI officials at 1300 hrs on the same very day to join investigation when he allegedly made a voluntary statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act admitting that the aforesaid firms importing the MPEG cards by mis-declaring and under valuing the same as PCB were being controlled by him during the relevant period. He undertook to deposit the entire customs duty amounting to Rs. 4,64,42,823/-, which had been evaded, and submitted a demand draft for Rs. 24 lacs and postdated cheques for Rs. 1.29 crores towards part payment of the aforesaid evaded amount. He also deposited a demand draft for Rs. 8 lacs in the DRI Office at Delhi and Rs. 5 lacs in DRI Office at Bombay as part payment. It is added that on being shown the details of bills of entry and other evidence indicating his involvement in the evasion of customs duty, the petitioner acknowledged the details by giving a certificate on its each page as seen and agreed/Scrutiny of the statement of accounts obtained from bank in regard to the account maintained by the petitioner in the name of his firm M/s. Everything International revealed huge financial transactions between his firm and M/s. Shri Krishana Impex, Goa, over and above the value of PU leather imported.

    3. According to the respondent, the petitioner acted as mastermind behind the import of MPEG cards and the owners of the importing firms were simply getting commission of Rs. 10,000/- to Rs. 15,000/- per container, as admitted by Sanjay Chauhan, paper proprietor of the firms. It is claimed that the investigation reveals that the petitioner was concerned in procurement, transportation, receipt and sale of impugned goods in local market. One Shri Jawahar Roop Chand is stated to have confirmed in his statement dated 10.6.2004 that the petitioner had imported MPEG cards and sold the same in the local market through one Shahji and that it was the petitioner himself who had arranged the money to be given to foreign suppliers.

    4. In regard to his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act, the plea on behalf of the petitioner is that he was actually forced to make that statement and that the same, subsequently, stands retracted by him. In regard to various payments alleged to have been made in part payment of the customs duty evaded, it is contended that the petitioner was compelled to make the same in order to save himself from being arrested and such payments, thus, could not be taken to amount to an acknowledgment on his part of his involvement in the commission of offence complained of.

    5. This apart, it is submitted that the petitioner is a serious Cardiac patient having undergone a bye-pass surgery in 1997. He had also been a patient of Spinal Tuberculosis and in view of his precarious health condition, his arrest and detention would put his life in jeopardy without any useful purpose being served, particularly when he has been regularly joining investigation as and when so required.

    6. The counter plea of the respondent, on the other hand, is that the investigation into the matter is still underway and investigating agency should be allowed a freehand in the matter to collect all available evidence showing involvement of the petitioner in the commission of crime. It is complained that the petitioner has not been fully co-operative in investigation and has often evaded full participation citing medical ground. It is added that he has virtually been absconding as he is found to be not staying at his office-cum-residence and, in the circumstances, does not deserve any protection.

    7. Reliance was placed on decisions in Enforcement Officer, TED, Bombay v. Bher Chand Tikaji Bora, 2000 (121) ELT 7 (SC),Dukhishyam Benepani, Assistant Director, Enforcement Directorate (FERA) v. Arun Kumar Bajoria, 1998 JCC (SC) 18; Directorate Of Enforcement v. Ashok Kumar Jain, 1998 (1) JCC (SC) 1, State Through Deputy Commissioner Of Police, Special Branch, Delhi v. Jaspal Singh Gill, 1984 CRI.L.J 1211; Ram Narain Popli v. CBI, 2003 1 AD (CRI) SC 253; and many more, to oppose the petition. In addition, decision of this Court in Del Agha v. Directorate Of Revenue Intelligence., 2002 (1) CC Cases (HC) 152; Sanjiv Kumar Gupta v. Commissioiner of Customs, 2001 (1) JCC Delhi 146; Subhash Chanana v. State 1994 CRI.L.J 2370 (Delhi High Court); Rama Swaroop v. The State (Delhi Admn.) & Others, 1986 CRI.L.J 526; Wajinder Singh etc. v. State, 1979 Rajdhani Law Reporter 381; and some other High Courts were also referred to in support of plea opposing the grant of petition.

    8. Learned senior counsel, appearing for the petitioner, laid utmost emphasis on his contention that the offence punishable under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962, is a bailable one and therefore the petitioner even otherwise deserves to be released. A Single Bench decision of Bombay High Court in Subhash Chaudhary v. Deepak Jyala & Others in CRL. W.P 1384/2004, was referred to in this connection.

    9. On the contrary, a decision of this Court in Mohan Lal Thapar v. Y.P Dabara, Inspector, Customs, New Customs house, New Delhi, 2002 (1) JCC 460, is cited on behalf of the respondent to contend that an offence punishable under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962 is a non-bailable one. It was contended that the present petition for anticipatory bail could not be used as a basis for obtaining a declaration to the effect that the offence in question is a bailable one and if the petitioner really felt that way, the very maintainability of the present petition would be rendered questionable.”

    10. Table II of the First Schedule to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 incorporates Classification of Offences Against - other laws. It reads thus:

    II - CLASSIFICATION OF OFFENCES AGANST - OTHER LAWS

    Offence Cognizable or non-cognizable Bailable or non-bailable By what court triable 1 2 3 4 If punishable with death, imprionment for life, or imprisonment for more than 7 years. Cognizable Non-bailable Court of Session If punishable with imprisonment for 3 years, and upwards but not more than 7 years. Ditto Ditto Magistrate of the first class. If punishable with imprisonment for less than 3 years or with fine only. Non-cognizable Bailable Any Magistrate

    11. The offence under Section 135(1)(ii) of the Customs Act is punishable with imprisonment extending to three years or with fine or with both. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner sought to maintain that the offence punishable under Section 135(1)(ii) would fall under Entry 3 of Table II and borrows support to his contention in this regard from the aforesaid decision of the Bombay High Court in Subhash Chaudhary (supra). Having gone through the decision in Subhash Chaudhary (supra), it is difficult to subscribe to the view taken therein as the same would appear to suffer from inherent contradictions. The offence punishable under Section 135(1)(ii) providing for punishment extending to three years clearly indicates that the same is punishable with imprisonment for a period upto 3 years. In that view of the matter, the same cannot be pleaded to fall under Third Entry of Table II. In Mohan Lal Thapar (supra), the plea if an offence under Section 135(1)(ii) is a bailable one was examined by this Court and answered in negative. I find no reason to take a different view.

    12. Adverting to the other ground, I am afraid, ill-health offers no licence for indulging in criminal activities of the nature complained of, with impunity. The efficacy of such a plea was taken note of by the Supreme Court in Directorate Of Enforcement v. Ashok Kumar Jain (supra), and dealt with in the following terms:

    “It is not unusual that persons involving themselves in economic offences, particularly those living in affluent circumstances, are afflicted by conditions of cardiac instability. So the authorities dealing with such persons must adopt adequate measures to prevent deterioration of their health during the period of custodial internment. Court would interfere when such authorities fail to adopt necessary measures. But we are not in favour of stipulating in advance modalities to be. followed by the authorities for that purpose. According to us such anticipatory stipulations are interference with the efficient exercise of statutory functions when dealing with economic offences. Hence, learned single judge ought not have imposed such conditions on the Directorate.”

    13. In yet another case, The State (through Deputy Commr. of Police, Special Branch), Delhi v. Jaspal Singh Gill (supra), a similar view was taken. Clearly, the petitioner would deserve no concession on the ground of ill-health. The incriminating evidence brought out in the course of hearing, prima facie, reflects the complicity of the petitioner in the commission of crime complained of. The investigation is still underway and the allegations against the petitioner of not fully cooperating in investigation cannot be lost sight of. In Dukhishyam Benepani, Assistant Director, Enforcement Directorate (FERA) v. Arun Kumar Bajoria (supra), the Supreme Court observed that a blanket order fully insulating a person from arrest would make his interrogation a mere ritual.

    14. In the totality of facts and circumstances, the prayer for anticipatory bail is liable to be declined. The petition is, accordingly, dismissed. Interim order stands vacated.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Inderjeet Nagpal v. Directorate Of Revenue Intelligence (Dri) .
    (Mar 1, 2005)