Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • clause (a) of Rule 2 of Order XXIX, CPC
  • provisions of Order 29 Rule 2.11.
  • provisions of Order 29 Rule 2
  • Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC,
  • XXIX Rule 2 CPC.6. L/C
  • Order 29 Rule 2, CPC.
  • Order 29 Rule 2.9.
  • Order 9 Rule 13
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • clause (a) of Rule 2 of Order XXIX, CPC
  • provisions of Order 29 Rule 2.11.
  • provisions of Order 29 Rule 2
  • Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC,
  • XXIX Rule 2 CPC.6. L/C
  • Order 29 Rule 2, CPC.
  • Order 29 Rule 2.9.
  • Order 9 Rule 13
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is contesting an ex-parte decree dated 1.9.2000 passed in the respondent's Suit No. 2063/98. The appellant filed two applications—one for condonation of delay and the other for setting aside the ex-parte decree—which were rejected by the impugned order dated 9.11.2001. The respondents had filed Suit No. 2603/1998, listing the appellant's address as its corporate office in Hauz Khas, Delhi, rather than its registered office in Bhiwadi, Rajasthan. Summons were issued on 5.10.1998 and served on an employee at the corporate office on 17.3.1999. Following the process server's report, ex-parte proceedings were initiated on 20.8.1999, culminating in the ex-parte judgment and decree on 1.9.2000, with execution initiated through Petition No. 23/2001. The appellant challenged the validity of summons service, contending that service should have been effected only at the registered office and by an authorized officer.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether summons were validly served on the appellant under Order 29 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).
  2. Whether service of summons on the appellant’s corporate office, rather than the registered office, was valid.
  3. Whether non-service on the authorized officer at the registered office rendered the ex-parte decree liable to be set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Summons were not validly served under Order 29 Rule 2 CPC because they were not served at the company’s registered office in Bhiwadi, Rajasthan.
  • The authorized officer to receive summons was Mr. K.C. Joshi, posted at the registered office; no other person had authority to accept service.
  • Service at the corporate office was invalid and thus the ex-parte decree should be set aside.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The summons were validly served at the corporate office in Hauz Khas, Delhi, on an employee who signed the receipt with the company seal without objection.
  • The Supreme Court judgment in Shalimar Rope Works Ltd. v. Abdul Hussain and Ors. (AIR 1980 SC 1163) was distinguishable because it concerned a period before the 1976 amendment to Order 9 Rule 13 CPC.
  • Under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, an ex-parte order cannot be set aside merely due to irregularity in service if the defendant had notice of the hearing and sufficient time to appear.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shalimar Rope Works Ltd. v. Abdul Hussain and Ors., AIR 1980 SC 1163 Non-service of summons on unauthorized officer is fatal to proceedings. The court distinguished this precedent as it arose before the 1976 amendment to Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, which now protects ex-parte orders from being set aside solely on irregularity in service if the defendant had notice and opportunity to appear.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the provisions of Order 29 Rule 2 CPC, which allow service of summons against a corporation either by serving the secretary, any director, or other principal officer, or by sending summons by post addressed to the registered office or, if no registered office exists, to the place where the corporation carries on business. The court held that these provisions do not restrict service to the registered office alone but provide multiple valid modes of service.

In this case, summons were served at the appellant’s corporate office in Hauz Khas on an employee who signed the receipt with the company seal and did not object to his authority to receive the summons. The court reasoned that the appellant’s internal designation of an authorized officer at the registered office was an internal arrangement that could not be attributed to the respondents or the public. Therefore, service on the corporate office was sufficient to discharge the respondent’s duty.

Further, even if the employee who received the summons was not authorized, such irregularity would not invalidate the ex-parte decree under the proviso to Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, which protects ex-parte orders if the defendant had notice of the hearing and sufficient time to appear.

Consequently, the court affirmed the Single Judge’s order dismissing the appeal.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The court upheld the validity of service of summons on the appellant’s corporate office and affirmed the ex-parte decree. The decision clarifies that service under Order 29 Rule 2 CPC is not limited to the registered office and that internal company arrangements about authorized officers do not invalidate service effected in accordance with the procedural rules. The ruling does not establish new precedent but confirms that irregularities in service do not warrant setting aside ex-parte decrees where the defendant had notice and opportunity to appear.

    Parasarampuria Synthetics Ltd Petitioner v. Shankar Prasad

    B.A Khan, J.:— Appellant is contesting ex-parte decree dated 1.9.2000 passed in respondent's Suit No. 2063/98. For this he had filed two applications IA Nos. 3608-09/2001- one for condonation of delay and the other for setting aside of the ex-parte decree which stand rejected by the impugned order dated 9.11.2001 Hence this appeal.

    2. The only issue involved is whether or not summons were validly served on appellant under Order 29 Rule 2, CPC. Ld. Single Judge has held that service of summons was valid but appellant disputes this.

    3. Respondents filed Suit No. 2603/1998 showing appellant's (defendant) address its corporate office in Haus Khas, Delhi instead of its registered office at Bhiwadi in Rajasthan. Summons were issued by the Joint Registrar on 5.10.1998 and were eventually served on some employee of appellant at the Hauz Khas corporate office on 17.3.1999 The Process Server submitted his report in this regard culminating in order dated 20.8.1999 taking ex-parte proceedings against appellant. This was followed by the ex-parte judgment and the decree on 1.9.2000 and the consequent execution by the execution Petition No. 23/2001.

    4. Appellant filed the two applications for condonation of delay and for setting aside the ex-parte decree on the plea that summons were not validly served on it under Order 29 Rule 2 CPC. The company contended that its authorised officer was one Mr. K.C Joshi who was posted at Bhiwadi; in Rajasthan and that none else had any authority to receive the summons. Moreover, the summons could only be served at its registered office at Bhiwadi and service of these at the corporate office was not a valid service.

    5. Ld. Single Judge over-ruled all this and held:—

    “In the present case, summons for 9.7.1999 were sent to defendant at Corporate Office Hauz Khas. It was clearly pointed out in the summons that service is to be effected through Managing Director/Director/Secretary or Principal Officer of company. Thus the mode of service as pointed out on the summons itself was as prescribed in clause (a) of Rule 2 of Order XXIX, CPC either by service to be effected on Secretary/Director or Principal Officer of the corporation. Summons were duly served in the Corporate Office of the company 26th March, 1999, which was received by the person concerned under his signature along with seal of the company without raising any objection about his authority to receive the summons. For compliance of Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC, it is sufficient to address the summons in the name of defendant and simultaneously specifying the mode of service i.e service to be effected through Managing Director//Secretary or Principal Officer. In the circumstances, I think summons were duly served on the defendant in accordance with Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC.”

    6. L/C for appellant has reiterated his stand that there was no valid service of summons on the appellant as these were not served on the company's registered office under Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC. He has also invoked the aid of Supreme Court Judgment in Shalimar Rope Works Ltd. v. Abdul Hussain and Ors., AIR 1980 SC 1163 to suggest that non-service of summons on the unauthorised officer of the company was fatal and warranted setting aside of the ex-parte decree.

    7. L/C for respondent Mr. Gagan Gupta has on the other hand distinguished the Supreme Court Judgment on the plea that it dealt with a situation prior to 1976 amendment in Order 9 Rule 13 which provided that an ex-parte order was not liable to be set aside on the ground of some irregularity in the service of summons when the court was satisfied and the Defendant had notice of the next date of hearing and had sufficient time to appear on that date.

    8. The only issue that falls for consideration is whether service of summons on appellant's corporate office was valid and whether it was mandatory to serve it on the company's registered office only under Order 29 Rule 2.

    9. The relevant provisions of Order 29 Rule 2 read thus:—

    “Service on corporation

    Subject to any statutory provision regulating service of process, where the suit is against a corporation, the summons may be served—

    (a) on the secretary or on any director, or other principal officer of the corporation, or

    (b) by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the place where the corporation carries on business.”

    10. This, in our view, does not limit the service of summons on the registered office of the company alone. It provides for different modes which include service of summon on Secretary or Managing Director or Principal Officer of the Corporation or service through registered post on the corporation's registered office or at the place where corporation carries on the business in case it has no registered office. This in no case could be said to restrict the service of summons on the registered office only. Therefore, where summons were served on the corporate office of the company also and were admittedly received by the employee of the company who had executed the receipt affixing the seal of the company, it could not be said or held that the service was bad or invalid for contravening provisions of Order 29 Rule 2.

    11. It may as well be that company had appointed some officer as the authorised officer to conduct cases or to receive communications from the outside. But that was its own internal arrangement at best of which its knowledge could not be attributed to respondents or for that matter general public. Respondent having effected service on appellant's corporate office at Hauz Khas, which is admitted had done his duty. He was not expected to do more in the circumstances.

    12. Apart from that, even if it was assumed that appellant's employee was not authorised, service of summons on him would at best constitute any irregularity under proviso to Order 9 Rule 13 which lays down that no ex-parte order could be set aside on the ground that there was some irregularity in the service of summons when the court was satisfied that defendant had notice of the date of hearing and had sufficient time to appear on the next date.

    13. We, therefore, find ourselves in accord with the view taken by the Ld. Single Judge and affirm his order to dismiss this appeal.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Parasarampuria Synthetics Ltd Petitioner v. Shankar Prasad
    (Jan 31, 2003)