Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order VIII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order VIII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition, filed by the petitioner (NEPC India Limited), seeks the winding up of the respondent, Indian Airlines Limited, on the assertion that Rs. 54,24,625.96 remained outstanding for carriage of passengers and luggage under an Interline Airlines Agreement dated 13 May 1995. The petitioner drew bills on the respondent from February 1996 until May 1997 and, after receiving no payment, issued a legal notice on 21 July 1997. The respondent replied, asserting its own claims against the petitioner—originally Rs. 103.53 lakhs, reduced to Rs. 77.65 lakhs and ultimately offering to settle at Rs. 55 lakhs—which the petitioner did not accept, proposing instead Rs. 20 lakhs.

The respondent filed its formal Reply to the winding-up petition on 10 September 1999, characterising the petition as a misuse of the Companies Act and asserting that there was a bona fide dispute between the parties. In its Reply the respondent admitted the petitioner’s claim to the extent of Rs. 54.18 lakhs (together with interest at 24% per annum) while asserting additional counterclaims (including Rs. 21,15,398.50 for engineering repair services). The court considered allegations of suppression of material facts, the existence and quality of the dispute, limitation and set-off issues, and the appropriate relief, before admitting the petition with directions for a tentative deposit by the respondent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a bona fide and substantial dispute exists between the parties so as to preclude the winding up of Indian Airlines under Sections 433/434 of the Companies Act.
  2. Whether there was suppression of material facts by the petitioner warranting dismissal of the petition as an abuse of process.
  3. Whether, given admissions in the Reply and the conduct of the parties (including delay in pursuing counterclaims), the winding-up petition should be admitted.
  4. What interim measure (deposit of disputed amounts) should be ordered pending further proceedings, and what rate of interest should apply to the admitted debt.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments (Indian Airlines / Mr. Sawhney)

  • The petition is a misuse of the Companies Act and should be dismissed because a bona fide dispute exists between the parties regarding mutual dues.
  • There were significant rival claims by Indian Airlines (initially Rs. 103.53 lakhs, reduced to Rs. 77.65 lakhs, with a settlement offer of Rs. 55 lakhs) which the petitioner failed to disclose in full, amounting to material suppression.
  • Withholding payment does not equate to inability to pay as contemplated under Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act; the respondent is solvent and can produce its balance sheet.
  • Reliance was placed on J.N. Roy Chowdhary (Traders) P. Ltd. v. Jainti Enterprises to the effect that cross-claims can render a debt bona fide disputed and thus preclude winding up.

Petitioner's Arguments (NEPC / Mr. Vijay Kishan)

  • The petitioner contended that the fact of a Reply to the statutory notice and the respondent's rival claim of Rs. 103.53 lakhs were specifically mentioned in the petition, refuting the allegation of suppression of material facts.
  • The petitioner pointed out that although the respondent asserted having filed a suit, the plaint (if any) was not produced and, on the petitioner’s reading, does not disclose the respondent’s admitted claim of Rs. 54.18 lakhs—so any such suit would not adequately address the admitted claim.
  • The petitioner argued (implicitly through submissions) that delay by the respondent in initiating its own recovery proceedings and potential limitation bar weakened the respondent’s defence and counterclaims.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pradeshiya Industrial and Investment Corporation of Uttar Pradesh v. North India Petro-Chemical Ltd. and Another, (1994) 2 Comp LJ 50 (SC) Restatement of principles governing winding-up petitions where disputes exist: that the court should not wind up a company if there is a bona fide substantial dispute; other related considerations. The court relied on the principles extracted from this decision to frame the conditions (paragraph 3 in the opinion) relevant to winding-up petitions and treated it as the primary statement of law for the matter.
Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Ltd. v. Krishnaswami, [1965] 35 Comp. Cas 456 (SC) Earlier authority on the approach to disputes in winding-up proceedings (as part of the doctrinal lineage). Referenced as one of the antecedent authorities paraphrased in the PIICUP decision; cited in support of the principles adopted by the court.
Madhusudan Gordhandas and Co. v. Madhu Woollen Industries (P) Ltd., [1972] 42 Comp. Cas. 125 (SC) Earlier authority on disputes in winding-up proceedings (as part of the doctrinal lineage). Referenced as one of the antecedent authorities paraphrased in the PIICUP decision; cited in support of the principles adopted by the court.
Nishal Enterprises v. Apte Amalgamations Ltd., Civil Appeal No. 720 of 1999 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 14096 of 1998), decided 5 Feb 1999 Authority for the proposition that a Company Court may order the respondent company to deposit the disputed amount which can be held by the court pending adjudication. The court applied this principle (as noted in paragraph 11 of the opinion) when imposing a tentative deposit direction upon the respondent (Indian Airlines) given the rival claims and the state of the dispute.
J.N. Roy Chowdhary (Traders) P. Ltd. v. Jainti Enterprises, (Vol. 61 1987) Company Cases 504 That where there are claims and cross-claims between the creditor and the company sought to be wound up, the debt can be bona fide disputed and winding up should not be ordered. Relied upon by the respondent’s counsel to argue that the petition should be dismissed; the court acknowledged this authority but treated the PIICUP case as the primary restatement of law to be applied in the circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a structured analysis:

  • It first set out the established conditions relevant to winding-up petitions where disputes exist, drawing principally on the Supreme Court's decision in the PIICUP case and earlier authorities (Amalgamated Commercial Traders and Madhusudan Gordhandas).
  • It addressed the respondent's contention of material suppression by the petitioner. The court found that the petition had explicitly mentioned the fact of a Reply to the statutory notice and the rival claim of Rs. 103.53 lakhs (paragraph 8 of the petition), and therefore rejected the allegation of suppression.
  • The court examined the respondent's Reply and noted that the respondent effectively admitted the petitioner’s claim to the extent of Rs. 54.18 lakhs together with interest at 24% p.a. Simultaneously, the respondent asserted additional claims (ground handling and engineering repairs) but had not, as of the date of the Reply, initiated timely legal proceedings to quantify or adjudicate those claims.
  • On the procedural posture, the court observed that although counsel for the respondent mentioned a suit on the Original Side, no copy of the plaint was placed before the court; the petitioner contended that the plaint (if any) did not name NEPC and did not refer to the admitted claim—matters left unresolved because the plaint was not produced.
  • The court considered limitation and procedural constraints: the Interline Agreement had been terminated by the respondent on 4 August 1997, meaning any cause of action would have arisen by that date and the respondent's purported suit appeared to have been filed much later, potentially raising a limitation bar (though the court did not finally decide the limitation issue and left it for the Original Side).
  • The court relied on Order VIII Rule 6 CPC to stress that set-off is permissible only in respect of an ascertained sum; since the respondent’s counterclaims were unascertained and had not been timely prosecuted, the court was unwilling to treat them as defeating the petition.
  • Given the admission of the debt to the extent of Rs. 54.18 lakhs and the respondent’s failure to promptly pursue adjudication of its counterclaims (and the attendant limitation/set-off difficulties), the court concluded that there was only a slender chance of the respondent’s defence succeeding in law. The court therefore found the petition to fall outside the category of petitions filed merely to coerce payment.
  • Balancing competing considerations and relying on Nishal Enterprises for the deposit mechanism, the court admitted the petition but moderated the relief by fixing a lower rate of interest (9% p.a.) than the 24% claimed by the respondent, allowed a Rs. 20 lakh deduction in view of the petitioner’s earlier settlement proposal, and directed a tentative deposit to secure the admitted debt portion.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court ADMITTED the winding-up petition.

Immediate consequences and directions given in the order (direct effects on the parties):

  • The debt to the extent of Rs. 54.18 lakhs (previously admitted in the respondent's Reply) is recognised by the court, but the interest rate claimed by the respondent (24% p.a.) is not fully granted. Instead, the court fixed interest at 9% per annum for the purposes of this winding-up petition.
  • Accounting for the petitioner’s earlier indication of willingness to settle the respondent’s claims at Rs. 20 lakhs, the court allowed a deduction of Rs. 20 lakhs from the admitted sum and directed the respondent, Indian Airlines, to tentatively deposit Rs. 40,00,000 (forty lakhs) with the Registrar of the Court within four weeks.
  • Failure by the respondent to make the directed deposit within the time allowed will result in publication of citation in specified newspapers, with the matter renotified and returnable on 7 November 2002. The petition is accordingly renotified for that date.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established authorities and doctrines concerning bona fide disputes, set-off and the court's discretion in winding-up matters. The judgment does not purport to establish a new legal precedent; it applies and reconciles existing principles to the facts at hand. The court left unresolved issues (such as limitation and the merits of any suit filed by the respondent) to be decided on the Original Side where appropriate documents and pleadings may be examined.

    Nepc India Ltd. v. Indian Airlines Limited.

    Vikramajit Sen, J.— This petition has been filed for the winding up of Indian Airlines Limited on the complaint that a sum of Rs. 54,24,625.96 remains outstanding towards transportation of passengers and luggage of persons holding tickets/airway bills of the Respondent. The Claims are predicated on an Interline Airlines Agreement dated 13th May, 1995. The Petitioner had drawn Bills on the Respondent commencing from February 1996 till May 1997. On the Petitioner's request for the clearance of outstandings bearing no fruition, the Petitioner caused a legal notice dated July 21, 1997 to issue to the Respondent. In reply thereto it was stated on behalf of the Respondent, inter alia, that in respect of the Respondent's claims against the Petitioner a sum of Rs. 103.53 lacs was due from the former to the latter. This sum was reduced by the Respondent to Rs. 77.65 lacs, and since the Petitioner was still raising disputes', the Respondent finally offered to settle their claims at Rs. 55 lacs. However, even this offer was not accepted by the Petitioner as per their letter dated February 16, 1997, in which they instead reiterated their proposal to settle the claims of Indian Airlines at Rs. 20 lakhs. These claims could not be settled amicably, and a consensus was not arrived at. Thereafter in Reply to the said Legal notice, it has been stated in the letter dated August 26, 1997 on behalf of Indian Airlines that-“Even otherwise the claim of your client for an amount of Rs. 54,24,625.95 towards sale of tickets is not factually correct. It is with a view to pre-empt any action by our clients to seek recovery of money legitimate due to our clients that your clients have chosen to send a legal notice for winding up of our clients. You are requested to advise your clients not only to desist from resorting to any ill-advised and misconceived legal proceedings against our clients but also to make the payment of Rs. 103.53 lacs with interest @ 24% on the said amount from the date of same became due till date of payment.”

    2. The Respondent's reply to the petition has been filed on 10th September, 1999. It has been averred that the petition is a misuse of the provisions of the Act. The claims of Indian Airlines have been reiterated in detail. It has been pleaded that on 31.3.1997 the Respondent sent an Invoice for Rs. 77,64,720/- to the Petitioner. The defence is found crystalised in paragraph (ix) of the Reply and is reproduced verbatim.

    “It is thus clear from the a foregoing that there was a dispute between Indian Airlines and NEPC in respect of their respective dues and to pre-emptany action on the part of Indian Airlines, NEPC caused a legal notice to be issued on 21.7.1997 which was suitably replied to by Indian Airlines on 26.08.1997 There is thus a bona fide dispute between the parties and there is therefore no question of any winding up order being passed. Moreover withholding of payment cannot mean inability of pay debt as contemplated under Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act. The respondent company is solvent and if necessary the balance sheet for the year ended 31.03.1998 can also be produced. Indian Airlines further reserves the right to initiate appropriate legal action against NEPC for the recovery of its dues towards Ground Handling services which are still due after adjusting the amount of Rs. 54.18 lacs plus interest @ 24% p.a Infact, besides this an amount of Rs. 21,15,398.50 is also recoverable on account of engineering repair services, rendered to NEPC upto February 1998. Indian Airlines reserves the right to take appropriate action for recovery of the dues as well.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    3. In winding-up proceedings it is necessary to keep the following conditions in perspective—

    (i) If there is a bona fide dispute and the defence is a substantial one, the Court will not wind-up the company.

    (ii) Where the debt is undisputed the Court will not act upon a defence, that the company has the ability to pay the debt but the company chooses not to pay it.

    (iii) Where the defence of the company is in good faith and one of substance, and the defence is likely to succeed in point of law, and the company adduces prima facie proof of the facts on which the defence depends, the petition should be rejected.

    (iv) The Court may consider the wishes of creditors so long as these appear to be justified.

    (v) The machinery of winding-up should not be allowed to be utilised merely as a means of realising its debts.

    [For the above propositions see Pradeshiya Industrial and Investment Corporation of Uttar Pradesh v. North India Petro-Chemical Ltd. and Another, (1994) 2 Comp LJ 50 (SC) in which the observation in Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Ltd. v. Krishnaswami, [1965] 35 Comp. Cas 456 (SC) and Madhusudan Gordhandas and Co. v. Madhu Woollen Industries (P) Ltd., [1972] 42 Comp. Cas. 125 (SC) have been paraphrased].

    (vi) If the stance of the adversaries hangs in balance it is always open to the Company Court to order the Respondent Company to deposit the disputed amount. This amount may be retained by the Court and be held to the credit of the suit, if any. [see Civil Appeal No. 720 of 1999 arising out of SLP (C) No. 14096 of 1998 - Nishal Enterprises v. Apte Amalgamations Ltd., decided on February 5, 1999].

    3. It appears to me that the following point may be added to the foregoing considerations.

    (vii) Generally speaking, an admission of debt should be available and/or the defence that has been adopted should appear to the Court not to be dishonest and/or a moonshine, for proceedings to continue. If there is insufficient material in favour of the petitioners, such disputes can be properly adjudicated in a regular civil suit. It is extremely helpful to draw upon the analogy of a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the Company Court reaches the conclusion that, had it been exercising ordinary original civil jurisdiction it would have granted unconditional leave to defend, it must dismiss the winding-up petition.

    4. Mr. Sawhney, Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent has contended that the petition ought to be dismissed since there has been material suppression of facts. It is his argument that the Petitioner was duty bound to disclose in detail the Respondent's claims against the Petitioner as is easily evident on a reading of the correspondence exchanged between them. He has meticulously mentioned that the Respondent had originally claimed over Rs. One crore and owing to protracted parleys, had brought its claims down by over Rs. 25 lakhs; yet the Petitioner did not settle the claims. Reliance was specially made on the Petitioner's letter dated 12.5.1997 in which it has been stated, inter alia, that - “We accept your handling charge of Rs. 9565/- per flight and request for a meeting with the concerned official to rework out the amount payable by us on the basis of Rs. 9565/- per flight handling to enable us to come to a final amount payable by us with further discount of 20% on the total bill.” Mr. Sawhney has submitted that on a rough calculation on this formula, the amount payable by the Petitioner to the Respondent would be about Rs. 55 lakhs, without the discount, and that this offer was reduced to writing in terms of the Respondent's letter dated 11.6.1997 On these predications it is his contention that the petition should be dismissed since a bona-fide dispute has undeniably been disclosed which cannot be conceived as an after thought; that the existence of the Respondent's counter claim is palpably prevailing; and that the Respondent would have to make recoveries even after granting an adjustment for the Petitioner's admitted claims. He has placed reliance on a decision of the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in J.N Roy Chowdhary (Traders) P. Ltd. v. Jainti Enterprises, (Vol. 61 1987) Company Cases 504, in which it has been observed that “where there are claims and cross-claims between the creditor seeking the winding up and the company sought to be wound up, the debt can be said to be bona fide disputed and the court will not order the winding up of the company. Winding up proceedings are not intended to be exploited as a normal alternative to the ordinary mode of debt realisation.” There can be no scope for any discussion on the proposition enunciated in this case, especially since the Division Bench had analysed and applied the decisions of the Apex Court in Amalgamated Traders Case (supra) and Madhusudan case (supra). However, as the factors culled out in paragraph 3 above have been substantially extracted from the views of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the PIICUP case (supra) it is this decision rather than that the Division Bench which is in the nature of the Restatement of the law on the subject.

    5. The exercise of jurisdiction under Sections 433/434 of the Act is discretionary and in instances where there has been material suppression of facts, which may have resulted in the Court issuing notice or admitting the winding-up petition, that may be sufficient cause to reject it. However, as pointed out by Mr. Vijay Kishan, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, the factum of a Reply having been sent to the statutory notice has been duly mentioned in paragraph 8 of the petition; as also the rival claim of Rs. 103.53 lakhs. Therefore, I find no merit in the Respondent's accusation that material facts have been suppressed.

    6. I shall now consider the Respondent's Claim as mentioned in its Reply. It needs to be underscored that in the Reply itself the Petitioner's Claim to the extent of Rs. 54.18 lakhs together with interest at the rate of 24% per annum stands admitted. The Respondent's case is that it intended to initiate appropriate legal action against the Petitioner for the recovery of its outstandings towards Ground Handling Services which are still due after adjusting the afore-mentioned sum of Rs. 54.18 lakhs. In paragraph (ix) of the Reply the Respondents have mentioned that a further sum of Rs. 21, 15,398.50 is also recoverable on account of Engineering Repair Services rendered to NEPC (the Respondent) upto February 1998. The Reply was filed on 10th September, 1999. Till date nothing has been placed on record to show that the Respondent has initiated any legal proceedings against the Petitioner. Mr. Sawhney has mentioned in the course of hearings that a suit has been filed on the Original Side of this Court to which Mr. Vijay Kishan's reply is that on a bare reading of the Plaint the Defendant is not present Petitioner, namely NEPC India Limited. For reasons which remain inexplicable, a copy of the Plaint has not been submitted for the Court's perusal. Mr. Vijay Kishan has further submitted that on a reading of the Plaint it at once evident that the Petitioner's admitted claim of Rs. 54.18 lakhs does not find any mention in the Plaint. If this is so, even if a Plaint has been filed against the Petitioner herein, the Claim raised in this winding-up petition is beyond the contemplation of the suit.

    7. It would have been permissible for the Respondent, as the Plaintiff in the said suit, to set up its claim and thereafter plead a counter claim of the afore-mentioned sum of Rs. 54.18 lakhs. In the absence of such a position it is difficult to accept the contention that a bona fide dispute exists in respect of the sum of Rs. 54.18 lakhs. Furthermore, according to the Respondent's own showing, it terminated the Interline Agreement with the Petitioner in terms of the letter dated 4th August, 1997. The cause of action, therefore, would have arisen at least on this date, necessitating the filing of the suit for recovery on or before 3rd August, 2000 although since the Ground Handling arrangements stood discontinued with effect from January 1996, it could be much earlier. From the submissions made in the course of arguments I gather that the suit has been filed much after that date, thus making it prima facie barred by the prohibitive principles of Limitation. This observation should not be treated as definitive, since this issue will appropriately be decided on the Original Side of this Court in the afore-mentioned suit.

    8. There is yet another obstacle to be crossed by the Respondent, inasmuch as a set-off is available only in respect of an ascertained sum of money. The Respondent's claim is in essence in the nature of a counter claim, for which the period of limitation does not have the same elasticity as in the case of a set-off. Reference need only be made to Order VIII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. When bona fides are to be determined, it may be unreasonable for the Court to attribute them against the party who has not struck the first litigative blow. Persons do not rush to initiate legal actions; it is usually the last resort as it well should However, once the Petitioner had filed the present petition there seems to me to be scant reason for the Respondent to have neglected to take timely action thereafter, especially since it is the Respondent's claim that it has to make recoveries against the Petitioner. Instead, it may have allowed time to run out. In such a situation, a defence which may have appeared to have legitimacy, would transform into sterility. The position is exacerbated when it is recalled that the Respondent's claim is yet to be ascertained through adjudication.

    9. The present case, therefore, fulfils all the conditions mentioned in paragraph 3 above. The debt to the extent of Rs. 54.18 lakhs together with interest at the rate of 24 per cent per annum stands admitted. It will, therefore, make no difference that the Respondent has the ability to pay its debts. Although the defence may have been bona fide in nature and a substantial one, there is now only a very slender chance of its succeeding in law. There is no explanation forthcoming as to why the Respondent did not initiate its own legal claim for the amount mentioned by it in its Reply immediately in its filing. At this belated stage it would not be correct in law to keep them in contemplation even though the constraints of the law of Limitation have intervened. Since the debt stands admitted, the Petition would not fall in the genre of actions which have been preferred merely as a means of coercing payment and/or realising debts.

    10. The winding-up petition is hence admitted.

    11. As already mentioned, the Claim for Rs. 54.18 lakhs together with interest at the rate of 24% per annum stands admitted. However, keeping in view the rival claims, I do not think it appropriate to grant interest at the admitted rate. In my opinion, interest at the rate of 9 per cent per annum would meet the ends of justice so far as this winding-up petition is concerned. However, since the Petitioners had indicated their willingness to settle the claims of the Respondent at Rs. 20 lakhs, it would be equitable to permit this deduction from the afore-mentioned sum of Rs. 54.18 lakhs. Accordingly, the Respondent Company, Indian Airlines, is directed to tentatively deposit with the Registrar of this Court the sum of Rupees forty lakhs within four weeks from today. If there is a failure on its part to make this deposit within the time allowed, citation to be published in the Indian Express (English) Delhi Edition, Nav Bharat Times (Hindi) and Delhi Gazette, returnable on 7th November, 2002.

    12. The Petition be renotified on 7th November, 2002.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nepc India Ltd. v. Indian Airlines Limited.
    (Aug 21, 2002)