Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff-Bank filed a suit in 1985 seeking recovery of money from five defendants. Defendants 1, 2, and 5 did not appear after summons and were proceeded ex-parte. Defendants 3 and 4 initially appeared and contested but ceased to appear subsequently and were also proceeded ex-parte. An ex-parte decree was passed on 3rd October 1997 against defendants 3 and 4. Despite the decree, the plaintiff was unable to enforce it as defendants 3 and 4 kept the matter alive by filing an application under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure to set aside the ex-parte decree. This application was filed on 26th September 1998.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicants (defendants 3 and 4) have shown sufficient cause for their non-appearance in the suit proceedings to justify setting aside the ex-parte decree under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether fault on the part of the applicants' Advocate constitutes sufficient cause for non-appearance in the facts and circumstances of this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The applicants engaged an Advocate who ceased appearing from 2nd April 1991 without informing them.
  • The applicants were assured by their Advocate that they would be informed when their presence was required.
  • The non-appearance was due to the Advocate's fault, and the applicants should not suffer for this fault.
  • The applicants claimed bona fide non-appearance and only came to know of the ex-parte decree when they received a letter from the plaintiff-Bank in August 1998.
  • Reliance was placed on several precedents supporting the proposition that fault of an Advocate may amount to sufficient cause.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sagaayam Engineering Works v. Srivatsa Tube Corporation, AIR 1989 Madras 237 Supporting the proposition that fault of Advocate may constitute sufficient cause. Considered but held that fault of Advocate alone is not sufficient without bona fide conduct of the party.
Shyam Lal Dhar v. Ply Board Industries, AIR 1981 J&K 95 Similar principle regarding sufficient cause due to Advocate's fault. Referenced to examine bona fides and diligence of party.
Nivrutti Nana Waghmare v. Narayan Mahadeo Mokal, AIR 1980 Bombay 250 On sufficient cause for setting aside ex-parte decree. Used to analyze applicants' conduct.
Ranipet Chemicals and Engineering Company Pvt. Ltd. v. Swastik Stainless Steel Stores, AIR 1986 Calcutta 76 On sufficient cause and non-appearance. Considered in context of diligence and bona fide.
Lajpat Rai v. State of Punjab, (1981) 3 SCC 94 : AIR 1981 SC 1401 Principles relating to sufficient cause and setting aside ex-parte decrees. Applied to assess bona fide and diligence of applicants.
Savithri Amma Seethamma v. Aratha Karthy, (1983) 1 SCC 401 : AIR 1983 SC 318 On sufficient cause under Order IX Rule 13 CPC. Used to reinforce the need for bona fide and diligence.
Guljan Bibi v. Nazir-ud-din Mia, AIR 1975 Goa 30 Failure of lawyer not necessarily sufficient cause without party's diligence. Specifically cited to emphasize that party must show due diligence and bona fide.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether the applicants demonstrated sufficient cause for their non-appearance under Order IX Rule 13 CPC. The applicants attributed their absence to the fault of their Advocate, who stopped appearing from 2nd April 1991 without notice. Despite the Advocate receiving default notices and inspecting the case file, he did not appear in court. The applicants failed to provide any satisfactory explanation for the Advocate's non-appearance or show that they pursued their case with due diligence. The Court noted the applicants did not inquire with their Advocate after learning of the ex-parte decree and relied on an assurance from the Advocate that they would be informed when required, which the Court found to be an after-thought and unconvincing.

The Court emphasized that there is no absolute rule that mistakes of an Advocate constitute sufficient cause; the bona fide nature of absence and diligence of the party must be established. The applicants' conduct was found to be negligent and lacking bona fide, as they did not act diligently to ensure representation or follow up on their case for over six years. The cumulative facts showed that the applicants were partly responsible for the delay and non-appearance. Therefore, the Court held that the applicants failed to demonstrate sufficient cause to set aside the ex-parte decree.

Holding and Implications

The Court's final decision was to dismiss the application to set aside the ex-parte decree with costs of Rs. 2,000/-.

The direct effect of this ruling is that the ex-parte decree passed on 3rd October 1997 remains in force against defendants 3 and 4. The Court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed the principle that fault of an Advocate alone does not constitute sufficient cause unless accompanied by bona fide conduct and due diligence by the party.

    New Bank Of India v. Marvels (India)

    A.K Sikri, J.— This suit was filed by the plaintiff-Bank for recovery of money against the defendants, who are five in numbers, in the year 1985. The defendants 1, 2 and 5 after service of summons, did not appear and were proceeded ex-parte. The defendants 3 and 4 although appeared initially and contested the suit, stopped appearing after a particular period. They were also proceeded ex-parte and ex-parte decree was passed on 3rd October, 1997. However, the plaintiff has not been able to enjoy the fruits of this decree and even after 16 years of the filing of the suit the matter is kept alive by the defendants 3 and 4 (hereinafter referred to as the applicants, for short) as the present application has been filed under the provisions of Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure for setting aside the ex-parte decree dated 3rd October, 1997.

    2. Obviously, the question to be determined in this application is as to whether there is sufficient cause for non-appearance of the applicants in the suit proceedings. The plea in support of sufficient cause raised by the applicants is the one which is often taken, namely, fault on the part of their Advocate and it is contended that the applicants should not be made to suffer due to the fault of their Advocate. Whether such a plea is available to the applicants in the facts and circumstances of this case needs to be examined.

    3. Before embarking on this enquiry it would be appropriate to note certain material dates:

    15.4.85 Suit filed by the plaintiff—Bank. 11.2.86 Written statement filed by defendants 3 and 4. 27.5.86 Defendants 1, 2 and 5 proceeded ex-parte. 17.11.88 Issues were framed. 10.4.92 As nobody appeared default notice was sent to Counsel for both the parties which was duly received by the Counsel for the parties. Counsel for the applicant received that notice on 22.5.92 However, Counsel for the applicants still did not appear. 24.4.93 Counsel for the applicants inspects the file, so he is aware of the proceedings. However he does not appear on the dates fixed. 6.11.96 Defendants 3 and 4 are also proceeded ex-parte on 6.11.96 vide the following order: “Defendants 1, 2 and 5 are ex-parte. No one is appearing on behalf of defendants 3 and 4 since 28.8.1991 They are proceeded ex-parte. …………. 3.10.97 Ex-parte decree is passed for the sum of Rs. 6,94,768.60p. along with pendente lite and future interest @ 15% per annum as well as cost. Suit against defendant No. 5 is dismissed. 26.9.98 Present application is filed.

    4. It is stated in the application that the applicants had engaged an Advocate who without notice to the applicants suddenly stopped appearing from 2nd April, 1991 and did not appear inspite of default notice sent to him. In the meanwhile, whenever the applicants enquired about their case they were informed that the matter is listed for evidence and as and when the applicants were required to be there, an intimation from the office of the lawyer would be sent. Inspite of those assurances the lawyer did not appear and the applicants suffered ex-parte decree and that such non-appearance of the applicants constitutes sufficient cause as it was bona-fide. The applicants came to know about the ex-parte decree only when the applicants received letter dated 27th August, 1998 from the plaintiff-Bank on 29th September, 1998 calling upon the applicants to pay the amount under decree.

    5. Learned Counsel for the applicants in support of his submission stated that the applicants should not suffer because of the fault of the lawyer and relied upon the following judgments:

    1. Sagaayam Engineering Works v. Srivatsa Tube Corporation, AIR 1989 Madras 237.

    2. Shyam Lal Dhar v. Ply Board Industries, AIR 1981 J&K 95.

    3. Nivrutti Nana Waghmare v. Narayan Mahadeo Mokal, AIR 1980 Bombay 250.

    4. Ranipet Chemicals and Engineering Company Pvt. Ltd. v. Swastik Stainless Steel Stores, AIR 1986 Calcutta 76.

    5. Lajpat Rai v. State of Punjab, (1981) 3 SCC 94 : AIR 1981 SC 1401.

    6. Savithri Amma Seethamma v. Aratha Karthy, (1983) 1 SCC 401 : AIR 1983 SC 318.

    6. There is no absolute proposition of law that all cases of mistakes on the part of the Advocate or Pleader would constitute sufficient cause. What is to be seen is as to whether absence of the Advocate was bona-fide. This is to be examined in conjunction with the conduct of the party who had engaged Advocate viz. whether he was pursuing his case diligently or the conduct and approach was so callous that it amounted to negligence. If this is so then nonappearance would not be bona-fide and it would not constitute sufficient cause within the meaning of Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Failure of lawyer to appear for no fault of the party is not necessarily sufficient cause for non-appearance of the party (Refer: Guljan Bibi v. Nazir-ud-din Mia, AIR 1975 Goa 30. It is necessary for the applicant to establish that the applicants did all that was required under the law to retain the Advocate and that the applicants were pursuing the case with due diligence.

    7. In the instant case both the applicants and their Advocate have not acted with due diligence and the case depicts lack of bond-fides. In so far as applicants' Lawyer is concerned he stopped appearing from 2nd April, 1991. Admittedly even default notice was served upon the applicants' Counsel which was duly received by him on 22nd May, 1992. However, still he did not appear. Not only this he inspected the file on 24th April, 1993 which shows that he had the knowledge of the proceedings and the next date of hearing. Still he chose not to appear. What was the reason for non-appearance of the Counsel? No satisfactory explanation for this is forthcoming. It is not stated in the application that the applicants contacted their Lawyer after coming to know of the ex-parte decree and tried to find the reasons for applicants' Lawyer not appearing. In para 9 of the application, the applicants have simply stated that after coming to know of the ex-parte decree they engaged another Lawyer to inspect the file and filed the present application on their behalf. It is strange that the applicants after coming to know of the ex-parte decree would not even enquire from their earlier Advocate as to why and under what circumstances he stopped appearing and why such ex-parte decree was passed. This shows that everything was not alright on applicants front as well. There is something amiss about which there is no explanation by the applicants.

    8. Not only this the conduct of the applicants shows sheer negligence in defending the present case. Their Counsel stopped appearing in 2nd April, 1991 and the ex-parte decree was passed only in October, 1997. The intervening period was more than six and a half years. In fact, according to them, they came to know of the ex-parte decree only on 29th August, 1998 and therefore for a period of almost 7 years they did not bother to get in touch with the Advocate or find the progress of the case.

    9. Why the applicants would be satisfied with the alleged representation on the part of their Advocate, as stated in the application, that the applicants were not required and they would receive a communication from their Advocate as and when they are required to be present in the Court. No proceedings for such a long period would have made them suspicious. From this one can reasonably infer that the story put forth by the applicants that they were in touch with their Lawyer and the Lawyer had assured them that he would inform that when they are required in the case is an after-thought plea. This explanation does not inspire confidence. The application is not even supported by affidavit of the Counsel who was representing them.

    10. Therefore, I am of the considered view that the applicants have not been able to make out sufficient ground for setting aside the ex-parte decree. No doubt the words “sufficient cause” should receive liberal construction so as to advance substantial justice. However when it is found that the applicants were most negligent in defending the case and their non-action and want of bona-fide are clearly imputable, the Court would not help such a party. After all “sufficient cause” is an elastic expression for which no hard and fast guide-lines can be given and Court has to decide on the facts of each case as to whether the defendant who has suffered ex-parte decree has been able to satisfactorily show sufficient cause for non-appearance and in examining this aspect cumulative effect of all the relevant factors is to be seen. In the instant case, no doubt applicants, had engaged Lawyer who did not appear. However, the reason for non-appearance is not discernible and it cannot be said that he neglected or failed to appear in the case or there was no justification on the part of the Lawyer not to appear. It also cannot be said that the applicants had done all what was required of them to ensure that their Counsel would represent them on all the necessary hearings. The applicants have also failed to show that they were diligent in their pursuit or acted bona-fide.

    11. This application is accordingly dismissed with costs quantified at Rs. 2,000/-.

    Application dismissed with costs.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    New Bank Of India v. Marvels (India)
    (May 14, 2001)