Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 4.3.1983 appellant Arun Sondhi, then a 21-year-old B.A. final year student at St. Stephen's College, Delhi, was seriously injured when his cycle was hit by a DTC bus. He suffered multiple injuries leading to amputation of one leg, paralysis of the other, became paraplegic and was assessed as 100% permanently disabled; he lost control of urine and stools and required continuous attendant care and recurring medical treatment. He filed Claim Suit No. 127/83 claiming Rs. 35 lakhs.

The respondent contested, inter alia, that no DTC bus was involved. The Tribunal rejected that defence, estimated future earnings at Rs. 2,000 per month, applied a multiplier of 16 (loss of earnings Rs. 3.84 lakhs), awarded Rs. 1 lakh for pain and suffering, about Rs. 2.25 lakhs for medical treatment in Sweden, Rs. 10,000 for conveyance and Rs. 4,375 for special diet, and awarded total compensation of Rs. 7.20 lakhs with 12% interest (Award dated 1.9.1994).

Both parties appealed. The First Appellate Court (FAC) by common judgment dated 20.12.1996 dismissed respondent's appeal and allowed the appellant's appeal, enhancing compensation to Rs. 8,68,781 by increasing the pain and suffering award to Rs. 2 lakhs and applying a maximum multiplier of 18 to the Rs. 2,000 multiplicand, raising loss of earnings to Rs. 4,32,000.

The appellant filed the present further appeal seeking additional enhancement of compensation; the respondent cross‑objected. The present judgment determines that appeal and the cross objections.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation awarded by the First Appellate Court should be further enhanced.
  2. If enhancement is justified, what is the appropriate quantum for (a) loss of future earnings, and (b) non-pecuniary damages including pain and suffering, loss of amenities and recurring medical and attendant expenses?
  3. Whether interest should be payable on any enhanced amount awarded by this Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant (through counsel Mr. Dhanda) submitted that he had been captain of his college boxing team and a member of the college Football XI, came from a well-educated and well-placed family, and thus his future earning capacity could not be limited to Rs. 2,000 per month.
  • Counsel argued that, as a bright sportsman with prospects of suitable employment and upward mobility in his career, a reasonable average monthly income for assessment of future loss should be Rs. 10,000 per month.
  • The appellant contended that the FAC awarded insufficient compensation for pain and suffering and loss of amenities; he suffers incontinence and requires constant attendant assistance and continual medical treatment.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Respondent's counsel (Mr. Aggarwal) opposed further enhancement, asserting that the appellant was already receiving compensation of Rs. 21 lakhs or more inclusive of interest and thus no additional enhancement was warranted.
  • The respondent relied on Supreme Court authority "Grifan v. Sarbjeet Singh and others, JT 2000 (8) SC 55" to show that compensation of only Rs. 2 lakhs had been awarded in a case of amputation of a right leg.
  • The respondent sought to distinguish "R.D Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) Pvt. Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 551" on the basis that the accident victim in that case was a lawyer carrying a lucrative practice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ward v. James 1965 (1) APPER 56 Illustration of the difficulty in quantifying non-pecuniary damages: judges can compensate for lost years, nursing and attendance costs, and loss of earnings during expected survival, but cannot fully compensate the fact of being rendered a helpless invalid. The Court quoted this passage to acknowledge the inherent difficulty and limits of monetary compensation in cases of grave disability, and to frame the evaluative exercise the Court must undertake.
Grifan v. Sarbjeet Singh and others, JT 2000 (8) SC 55 Cited by respondent to show a precedent where compensation of Rs. 2 lakhs was awarded for amputation of a right leg. The respondent relied on it to argue against enhancement; the Court recorded the citation as part of the respondent's submissions (no further reliance on it to limit the award is recorded).
R.D Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) Pvt. Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 551 Cited by respondent but distinguished on factual basis (victim in that case was a lawyer with a lucrative practice). The Court noted the respondent's attempt to distinguish that authority; the case was not adopted as a controlling benchmark because of differing facts.
A.K Mishra v. Muniam Babu, AIR 1999 SC 2260 Citation of a Supreme Court award of Rs. 5 lakhs to a 23‑year‑old whose spinal cord was damaged in road accident; used as a comparative authority. The Court took note of this judgment as broadly similar but observed that it does not lay down a generalized principle for non-pecuniary damages; the Court used it as a reference point while emphasizing compensation depends on facts and circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded from the uncontested factual foundation that the appellant sustained catastrophic injuries leaving him paraplegic, with 100% permanent disability, loss of bladder and bowel control, continuous need for an attendant, and recurring medical expenses. The Court reiterated the conceptual difficulty in awarding non-pecuniary damages but recognized its duty to quantify compensation to the extent money can mitigate suffering (drawing on Ward v. James).

Regarding past decisions: the Tribunal had used Rs. 2,000 per month as the multiplicand and multiplier 16; the FAC retained the Rs. 2,000 multiplicand but applied the maximum multiplier of 18, increasing the compensation for loss of earning to Rs. 4,32,000 and raising pain and suffering to Rs. 2,00,000, producing a total Rs. 8,68,781 award.

The Court found scope to enhance the multiplicand. Considering the appellant's family background, education and sporting achievements (captain of college boxing team; member of college Football XI), the Court concluded a conservative but higher prospective earning should be assumed: Rs. 5,000 per month. Applying the maximum multiplier of 18 to Rs. 5,000 produced a loss-of-earnings figure of Rs. 10,80,000.

On non-pecuniary damages (pain, suffering, loss of amenities, recurring medical and attendant expenses), the Court considered an assumption of 25 years of survival post-accident and an estimated monthly expenditure of Rs. 2,000 for these recurring needs, yielding Rs. 6,00,000 for this head. The Court noted the Supreme Court's decision in A.K Mishra but observed that it does not establish a generalized rule and that compensation must be assessed on the particular facts.

Combining the revised loss of earnings (Rs. 10,80,000) with the enhanced amount for pain/suffering/recurring needs (Rs. 6,00,000) and considering earlier components of the award, the Court arrived at a revised total of Rs. 19,16,781 as the appropriate compensation. The Court expressly directed that no interest shall be payable on the enhanced portion.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed and the award of the First Appellate Court is modified. The appellant is awarded a total compensation of Rs. 19,16,781. No interest shall be payable on the enhanced amount. The respondent is directed to satisfy the remaining award within four months of receipt of the order. The respondent's cross objections are dismissed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is an increase in the appellant's compensation to Rs. 19,16,781 and an obligation on the respondent to pay the balance within four months; no interest is payable on the enhancement.
  • The Court emphasized that awards in such catastrophic injury cases turn on the facts and circumstances of each case and noted that cited authorities (including A.K Mishra) do not lay down generalized rules for non-pecuniary damages. The judgment therefore does not purport to establish a new general precedent on quantification beyond the factual assessment in this case.

    Arun Sondhi v. Delhi Transport Corporation.

    B.A Khan, J.— Appellant, Arun Sondhi, 21, a B.A Final year student in St. Stephens College, Delhi was seriously injured in road accident on 4.3.1983 when his cycle was hit by a DTC bus. His one leg was amputated and the other paralysed. He became paraplegic because of multiple injuries received by him and his permanent disability was assessed at 100%. He filed Claim suit No. 127/83 and claimed a compensation of Rs. 35 lacs. Respondent contested this amongst others on the ground that no DTC bus was involved in the accident. Tribunal rejected respondent's stand on this and estimated his future earning at Rs. 2000/- a month and applied a multiplier of 16 to it to assess the loss of his earning at Rs. 3.84 lacs. It also awarded Rs. 1 lac for pain and suffering and loss of amenities and enjoyment of life, Rs. 2.25 lacs or so for medical treatment at Sweden and here, Rs. 10,000/- for conveyance and Rs. 4,375/- for special diet and awarded total compensation of Rs. 7.20 lacs with 12% interest vide Award dated 1.9.1994

    2. Both sides filed appeals against this Award which were disposed off by common judgment dated 20.12.1996 by First Appellate Court. Appellant's appeal was allowed and compensation enhanced to Rs. 8,68,781/- and that of respondent was dismissed. While doing so First Appellate Court increased compensation to Rs. 2 lacs for pain suffering and assistance and applied maximum multiplier of 18 to the multiplicand of Rs. 2000/- to raise the loss of earning to Rs. 4,32,000/-.

    3. Appellant feels dis-satified and has filed this appeal for further enhancement. His counsel Mr. Dhanda submitted that appellant was the captain of his college boxing team and member of its Football Xl and had bright future as he came from a well educated and well placed family. Therefore, his future income could not be restricted to Rs. 2000/- a month. He contended that being a bright Sportsman, he had a reasonable prospect of being suitably employed and the reasonable potential to go up the ladder in his career and to earn an average monthly income of Rs. 10,000/- a month. He also complained that FAC had awarded less for the pain and suffering undergone by him and the loss of amenities of life. He claimed that Appellant had lost control even on his urine and stool and always needed assistance of an attendant and for his movement and living. Learned counsel for respondent Mr. Aggarwal on the other hand, opposed any further enhancement in the compensation. He claimed that appellant was already getting compensation of Rs. 21 lacs or more inclusive of interest and there was no further warrant for any enhancement in the compensation. He cited Supreme Court judgment in Grifan v. Sarbjeet Singh and others, JT 2000 (8) SC 55 to show that compensation of only Rs. 2 lacs was awarded for amputation of right leg in that case. He also distinguished the other judgment rendered by Apex Court in R.D Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) Pvt. Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 551 on the ground that accident victim in that case was a lawyer carrying a lucrative practice.

    4. It goes without saying that Appellant had become crippled and permanently disabled for ever. His permanent disability was 100% and he was living his life, whatever its worth, in a wheel chair. It is also the admitted position that he had become paraplegic and had lost control even over his urine and stool. He required assistance of an attendant and medical treatment all the time which involved a recurring expenditure. His plight could not be described in words, nor could his pain and suffering, frustration and disappointments be gathered or gauged. An athlete of yester-year must be ruing his survival which had plunged him in a veritable hell.

    5. No money could obviously compensate him for all this and consequently no reasonable compensation could be determined for what he had and must be going through. But all the same the Courts had to undertake the exercise in the discharge of their duty if only to compensate him to the extent payment of money could. As was aptly observed in Ward v. James 1965 (1) APPER 56:—

    “Although you cannot give a man so gravely injured much for his lost years, you can, however, compensate him for his loss during his shortened span, that is, during his expected “years of survival”. You can compensate him for loss of earnings during that time and for the cost of nursing treatment and attendance. But how can you compensate him for being rendered a helpless invalid. He has lost everything that makes life worthwhile. Money is no good to him. Yet Judges and Juris have to do the best they can and give him what they think is fair. No wonder they find it well neigh insoluble. They are being asked to calculate the incalculable. The figure is bound to be for the most part a converted sum.”

    6. Given regard to all this, it becomes difficult to assess the non-pecuniary damages in the present case because whatever amount was awarded to the incapacitated and crippled Appellant, it would not restore his broken body and shattered life. But all the same an effort was required to be made to grant him a reasonable compensation that could at least mitigate his suffering and hardship and reduce the intensity of his pain, if not provide him bare minimum amenities and enjoyments of life.

    7. Frankly speaking we do not find much of a scope for awarding what Appellant deserved in the present day scenario where human life and limb had ceased to be valuable. But still proceeding within the laid down framework, we find some leeway to increase compensation in the loss of earning which is assessed by Tribunal and FAC at Rs. 2000/- P.M It is a conservative estimate in our view. Because looking to family background and educational and sports career of Appellant, it could be reasonably expected that he would have been suitably employed to earn at least on an average of Rs. 5000/- a month. Applying a maximum multiplier of 18 to this, his loss of earning would come to Rs. 10,80,000/-.

    8. We also find that the award of Rs. 2 lacs for pain and suffering and loss of amenities and enjoyment of life was on the lower side. It is common ground that Appellant was living a painful life and stood deprived of all good things and enjoyments of life including marriage etc. He also needed a continuous medical treatment and assistance of an attendant etc. If it was assumed that he would live for 25 years only after the accident and would spend only Rs. 2,000/- P.M on both counts, the compensation amount for this would come to Rs. 6 lacs.

    9. At this stage, we noticed Supreme Court judgment in A.K Mishra v. Muniam Babu, AIR 1999 SC 2260 awarding Rs. 5 lakhs to a 23 year old youngman whose special cord was damaged in the road accident, by and large in similar circumstances. But this judgment, in over view, does not lay down any generalised principle or guideline for award of non-pecuniary damages in serious accident injury case. The determination of compensation in such cases would depend on the facts and circumstances of each case and notwithstanding the element of sympathy involved with the accident victim. We are also conscious of the fact that assessment of compensation in such cases had to be on objective standards and not based on any fanciful or whimsical calculations. But since a bit of conjecture was permissible, it presented no difficulty to make provision for the recurring medical expenditure and attendance for the Appellant and we feel that estimated compensation for this was based on a conservative estimate.

    10. Therefore, proceeding on this premises, Appellant is awarded Rs. 10,80,000/- for loss of his earning and Rs. 6 lacs for recurring medical expenditure and attendance in the pain and suffering head injury which would take the total compensation amount to Rs. 19,16,781/-. No interest shall, however, be payable on the enhanced amount. The impugned award of FAC shall stand modified accordingly and respondent shall satisfy the remaining award within 4 months from receipt of this order. This appeal is accordingly allowed and the cross objections filed by respondent dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Arun Sondhi v. Delhi Transport Corporation.
    (Apr 9, 2001)