Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff sought to purchase a flat and approached the defendant, a real estate dealer, who offered a flat for Rs. 7,00,000/-. Due to financial constraints, the plaintiff issued bearer cheques without dates as security, with an understanding that the defendant would consult him before encashment. Later, the plaintiff decided to call off the deal and requested the return of the cheques, which the defendant refused. The plaintiff stopped payment on the cheques, which were subsequently dishonoured upon presentation. The defendant then initiated a criminal case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act against the plaintiff. In response, the plaintiff filed a suit seeking declaration and permanent injunction to prevent the defendant from benefiting from or using the cheques.

The defendant filed an application under Order 7, Rule 11, CPC, seeking rejection of the plaint on the ground of non-maintainability under the Specific Relief Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit for declaration and injunction against the holder of dishonoured cheques is maintainable under the provisions of the Specific Relief Act and the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a declaration that the defendant has no title or benefit in respect of the bearer cheques issued.
  3. Whether the plaintiff can obtain an injunction restraining the defendant from using or prosecuting proceedings based on the dishonoured cheques.
  4. Whether the suit constitutes an abuse of the process of the Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff issued bearer cheques without dates based on an agreement that the defendant would seek consent before encashment.
  • The plaintiff called off the deal and requested return of the cheques, which was refused by the defendant.
  • The plaintiff sought declaration that the defendant is not entitled to any benefit from the cheques and an injunction restraining the defendant from using them.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contended that the suit is not maintainable under the Specific Relief Act.
  • The defendant asserted entitlement to the benefits of the cheques as holder in due course under the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  • The defendant instituted a criminal case under Section 138 of the Act following dishonour of the cheques.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.K Modi v. K.N Modi, 1998 (3) S.C.C 573 Proceedings filed for collateral purposes or spurious claims may amount to abuse of process of Court. The Court found the suit to be a gross abuse of the process of the Court as it was instituted after the criminal case and appeared to be a collateral attempt to set up a defence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed that the plaintiff had issued bearer cheques, which are negotiable instruments, and the defendant, as holder in due course, is entitled to their benefits under the Negotiable Instruments Act. The Court noted the statutory presumptions in favor of the payee under Sections 118(g) and 139 of the Act, which the plaintiff failed to rebut. The cheques were dishonoured, and the defendant duly initiated criminal proceedings under Section 138 of the Act.

The Court held that since the cheques had already been used by the defendant prior to the suit, any declaration that the defendant is not entitled to benefit from them would be ineffective and of no real consequence. Granting such declaration or injunction would deprive the defendant of his legal remedies.

Regarding the injunction sought by the plaintiff to restrain the defendant from using the cheques or prosecuting the criminal case, the Court referred to Section 41(b) of the Specific Relief Act, which prohibits injunctions restraining prosecution of court proceedings. Hence, the injunction could not be granted.

Further, the Court emphasized that the plaintiff’s suit appeared to be a collateral attempt to pre-empt the criminal trial and amounted to abuse of the Court’s process, supported by the precedent in K.K Modi v. K.N Modi. The Court concluded that the suit was groundless and liable to be rejected under Order 7, Rule 11, CPC.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the defendant's application and rejected the plaint under Order 7, Rule 11, CPC.

The plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant’s costs, quantified at Rs. 5,000/-, while bearing his own counsel fees.

The decision effectively upholds the defendant’s right to enforce the dishonoured cheques and prevents the plaintiff from circumventing the criminal proceedings by civil litigation. No new precedent was established beyond applying existing legal principles to the facts.

    Capt. Atul Kumar Singh v. Ms. Jalveen Rosha.

    M.S.A Siridiqui, J.— By this order, I propose to dispose of the application filed by the defendant under Order 7, Rule 11, CPC.

    2. The plaintiff filed this suit for declaration and permanent injunction on the allegations that the plaintiff was interested in purchasing a flat for his residence. He, therefore, approached the defendant, who was dealing in real estate business. Some time in the month of December, 1994 the defendant informed the plaintiff about a flat offered for sale for Rs. 7,00,000/-. Due to financial constraints, the plaintiff expressed his inability to pay the entire consideration in a lumpsum. However, on the defendant's suggestion to furnish some security in the form of bearer cheques for finalising the deal, the plaintiff issued the following bearer cheques in favour of the defendant.

    Cheque No Date Bank Amount 969772 Nil Hong Kong Bank 2,00,000/- 969773 Nil Hong Kong Bank 2,00,000/- 969774 Nil Hong Kong Bank 2,00,000/- 969775 Nil Hong Kong Bank 1,00,000/-

    3. According to the plaintiff, he deliberately omitted to mention the date of issue on the said cheques and it was agreed between the parties that the defendant would take the plaintiff into confidence before their presentation for encasement. Some time in the second week of April, 1996, the plaintiff desired to call off the deal and requested the defendant to return the said cheques. The defendant refused to return these cheques as a result whereof the plaintiff advised his Bank to stop the payment. Pursuant to the plaintiff's advice, the aforesaid cheques were dishonoured on presentation. The defendant, after due service of a notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act(for short ‘the Act’) instituted a criminal case against the plaintiff in the Court of the Metropolitan Magistrate, New Delhi. On these allegations, the plaintiff has asked for the following reliefs by his plaint:

    “(a) Declare that the defendant is not entitled to any benefit on account of holding the cheques, more aptly mentioned in the plaint.

    (b) Cancel the instrument more aptly described in the plaint and hold that the holder in due course has no title to the same.

    (c) Permanently injunct the defendant or her agent, servant, authority from using, claiming any benefit by virtue of possessing the instruments.”

    4. By this application, the defendant seeks rejection of the plaint on the ground that the present suit is not maintainable under the provisions of the Specific Reliefs Act.

    5. Admittedly, the plaintiff had issued the aforesaid cheques in favour of the defendant. A cheque is a negotiable instrument and under section 9 of the Act the payee is the holder in due course. The defendant, as a holder of the said cheques, is entitled to their benefits. Sections 72, 73, 75A and Section 84 of the Act are specific provisions which protect the interest of the payee under the cheque and also retain the liability of the drawer. Under Section 118(g) of the Act, the presumption is that the payee had given valuable consideration for the cheque issued in his favour. Under Section 139 of the Act, it is incumbent upon the Court to presume that the cheque issued was in discharge of debt or other liability. In the instant case, the rebuttable presumptions under Section 118(g) and 139 of the Act operate in favour of the defendant. It is also beyond the pale of controversy that these cheques were dishonoured on presentation, that the defendant had served a notice on the plaintiff under Section 138 of the Act, that the plaintiff had failed to respond to the said notice and that the plaintiff has instituted the present suit after institution of a criminal case against him under Section 138 of the Act. It is worth mentioning that under Section 64 of the Act, on default in presentation, the holder of a Negotiable Instrument is bound to loose his remedy against the drawer tinder the Act. Therefore, it was incumbent upon the defendant to present the said cheques for encasement.

    6. These dishonoured cheques are also the foundation of the criminal case instituted by the defendant against the plaintiff. Generally, in a suit for declaration, the Court may determine the position as it stood on the date of the plaint. In the instant case the position was that the cheques were already used by the defendant much prior to the institution of the suit. Therefore, the declaration that the defendant is not entitled to the benefit under the cheques in question would now be worth nothing. That being so, this Court should not, in my view, exercise its discretion and grant the declaration which would be of no real effect. That apart, if the declaration sought for or the injunction is granted to the plaintiff, the defendant would perhaps be completely deprived of his legal remedies against the plaintiff, Judged from any angle, the plaintiff is not entitled to grant of declaration sought in the present suit. The declaratory relief Nos. (a) and (b) sought by the plaintiff cannot granted as these cheques have already been used by the defendant and further the defendant as a holder of these cheques is entitled to their benefit.

    7. The plaintiff has also claimed the relief of injunction restraining the defendant from using the said cheques. It has to be borne in mind that the present suit has been instituted after institution of a criminal case against the plaintiff under Section 138 of the Act. The reliefs claimed in this suit are n substance for an injunction restraining the defendant from prosecuting the criminal case instituted against the plaintiff. Section 41 (b) of the Specific Relief Act denies to the Court the jurisdiction to grant an injunction restraining any person from prosecuting any proceedings in a Court. Consequently, the injunction sought by the plaintiff cannot be granted since it would have the effect of preventing the defendant form prosecuting the criminal case against the plaintiff.

    8. As noticed earlier, the plaintiff has filed the present suit after institution of a criminal case against him under Section 138 of the Act. The reliefs which the plaintiff has asked for appear to have been framed with a view to set up a defence during the trial of the said criminal case. What the accused under Section 138 of the Act would put as a defence during the trial cannot be gone into in a civil suit of instant nature. I am constrained to observe that the present suit is a gross abuse of the process of the Court. In K.K Modi v. K.N Modi, 1998 (3) S.C.C 573 = 11 (1998) SLT 295 (NC) = 1 (1998) CLT 72 (SC), it was held that a proceeding being filed for a collateral purpose, or a spurious claim being made in litigation may also in a given set of facts amount to an abuse of 11% process of the Court especially where the proceedings are absolutely groundless. It was also observed that the Court has power to stop such proceedings summarily and prevent the time of public and the Court from being wasted.

    9. For the foregoing reasons the application is allowed and the plaint is rejected under Order 7, Rule 11, C.P.C The plaintiff shall pay the cost of the defendant and bear his own. Counsel's fee is quantified at Rs. 5.000/-.

    Application allowed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Capt. Atul Kumar Singh v. Ms. Jalveen Rosha.
    (Feb 26, 1999)