AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 7 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
  • Order 7 Rule 10(1)
  • Order 6 Rule 17
  • Order 7 Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 7 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
  • Order 7 Rule 10(1)
  • Order 6 Rule 17
  • Order 7 Rule
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — P.N. Nag, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit seeking permanent and mandatory injunctions directing the defendants to restore possession of a Barsati Room and Bath Room. Subsequently the plaintiff sought to amend the plaint by changing the relief sought from injunctions to a suit for possession, valuing the suit at Rs. 10,000.

The Sub Judge, Fourth Class (Shri A.K. Chaturvedi), had pecuniary jurisdiction only up to Rs. 1,000. If the proposed amendment were allowed, it would oust the Sub Judge's jurisdiction. The trial court dismissed the application to amend the plaint, relying on E.R.R.M.H.S. Committee v. P. Atchayya (AIR 1957 Andhra Pradesh 10), which the trial court interpreted to mean that a court cannot permit an amendment that would oust its own jurisdiction. The present revision petition challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a civil court which is competent to entertain and dispose of the original suit can permit amendment of the plaint under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, when the amendment would oust the pecuniary jurisdiction of that court.
  2. If such an amendment is permitted, what is the proper procedural course — specifically, whether the amended plaint should be returned for presentation before the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Mr. Marwaha)

  • Various High Courts have taken the view that a court in which the amendment is applied for and which is competent to entertain the original suit may decide the amendment even if it will result in ousting its jurisdiction.
  • After allowing the amendment, the court can return the amended plaint for presentation before the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 (i.e., the amended plaint can be returned once the amendment is carried out).

Opposing Arguments (Mr. Munjal)

  • The Andhra Pradesh High Court decision relied upon by the trial court (E.R.R.M.H.S. Committee v. P. Atchayya) correctly states that amendments of pleadings which would oust the jurisdiction of the court trying the suit should not be allowed.
  • Relies on Rachhya Singh & another v. Ram Ran Bijai Prasad Singh & others (AIR 1973 Patna 179) in support of that restrictive view.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
E.R.R.M.H.S. Committee v. P. Atchayya (AIR 1957 Andhra Pradesh 10) Held that the court cannot permit a plaint to be amended so as to oust its own jurisdiction. Noted as the decision relied upon by the trial court in dismissing the amendment; treated as representing the restrictive view which the court considered but did not follow.
Rachhya Singh & another v. Ram Ran Bijai Prasad Singh & others (AIR 1973 Patna 179) Expresses the view that amendments which oust the jurisdiction of the court trying the suit should not be allowed. Relied upon by opposing counsel; acknowledged by the court as one of the authorities taking the restrictive position.
Suri Films v. S.N. Govinda Prabhu and Brother (AIR 1989 Kerala 29) Holds that the court before which a suit competent to be entertained is pending can allow an amendment that may result in ousting its jurisdiction, and after allowing the amendment should return the amended plaint for presentation to the proper court (Order 7 Rule 10). Identified as part of the "consensus" view preferred by the court; relied upon to support allowing amendment and then returning the amended plaint.
Benisham Mohanlal Khetan v. Mahadeo Tukaram Borkar (AIR 1985 Bom. 462) Held that under Order 6 Rule 17 a civil court can allow a plaint to be amended even if it results in ousting its own jurisdiction; after amendment, the plaint should be returned under Order 7 Rule 10. Adopted by the court as supporting the permissive approach to amendment and the procedural step of returning the amended plaint.
Patel Construction & Co. at Bombay and another v. Shah Raichand Amulakh and another (AIR 1973 Guj. 283) Expresses a similar permissive view regarding amendment that may oust jurisdiction (as part of decisions cited). Cited as another authority consistent with the consensus view which the court preferred.
Makireddy Ramayyamma v. Menti Kamalakararao (AIR 1983 A.P. 11) Also expresses a permissive approach contrary to E.R.R.M.H.S. Committee's restrictive view. Noted by the court as part of the body of High Court decisions adopting the permissive approach.
C. Singara Mudaliar v. M. Govindaswami Chetty and others (AIR 1928 Madras 400) Expressed the restrictive proposition that amendments ousting jurisdiction should not be allowed. Identified among authorities taking the contrary view; acknowledged but not followed by the court in this matter.
Bhavani v. Mangamma (AIR 1949 Mad. 208) Madras High Court held that the court should not refuse amendment merely because allowing it would put the suit beyond its pecuniary jurisdiction. Noted by the court as part of the Madras High Court's contrary stance to the restrictive authorities; used to show there is divergence among High Courts.
M. Allauddin v. P.S. Lakshminarayanan (AIR 1970 Mad. 247) Similar to Bhavani — Madras High Court view that amendment should not be refused solely because it would exceed pecuniary jurisdiction. Also noted as representing the Madras High Court's contrary approach; considered in the court's survey of authorities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first framed the factual and jurisdictional premise: the Sub Judge's pecuniary limit was Rs. 1,000 while the proposed amendment would value the suit at Rs. 10,000 and thereby oust that court's jurisdiction. The trial court had dismissed the application relying on an Andhra Pradesh decision (E.R.R.M.H.S. Committee v. P. Atchayya) and similar authorities supporting the restrictive approach.

The court then considered opposing authorities and counsels' submissions. The appellant's counsel urged that multiple High Courts had adopted a permissive approach: a court competent to entertain an original suit may decide an amendment application even if doing so would ultimately oust its own jurisdiction; once the amendment is allowed and carried out, the proper procedure is to return the amended plaint for presentation to the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10.

The court surveyed relevant case law. It identified a divergence of authority: some decisions (including E.R.R.M.H.S. Committee and certain older Madras and Patna decisions) took the view that amendments ousting jurisdiction should be refused, while a number of High Court decisions (Kerala, Bombay, Gujarat, Andhra Pradesh in some decisions) supported allowing such amendments under Order 6 Rule 17 and then returning the amended plaint under Order 7 Rule 10.

On balance, the court preferred the "consensus view" adopted by various High Courts (as exemplified by Suri Films, Benisham Mohanlal Khetan, Patel Construction, Makireddy Ramayyamma and others). The court reasoned that:

  • When a court having jurisdiction is seized of a matter, it is the proper forum to consider whether an amendment of the plaint should be allowed;
  • The question of the court's incompetency only becomes live once the amendment is actually carried out and thereby changes the character/valuation of the suit;
  • Once an amendment that ousts jurisdiction is allowed and carried out, the orderly procedural step is to return the amended plaint for presentation to the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 (Order 7 Rule 10(1) mentioned in the cited authority).

Applying this analysis to the present facts, the court concluded that the trial court had exercised its jurisdiction with material irregularity by refusing the amendment on the basis that it would oust its jurisdiction. Accordingly, the impugned order was set aside and the amendment permitted; the court noted the amended plaint had already been filed before the trial court and directed that the trial court proceed in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed. The impugned order of the trial court is set aside and the amendment to the plaint is allowed. The trial court is directed to proceed in accordance with law. The revision petition was allowed with no costs.

Implications:

  • The direct effect for the parties in this case: the amendment sought by the plaintiff is allowed; the trial court's dismissal of the amendment is set aside; the trial court is to proceed (and, where appropriate, follow the procedural step of returning the amended plaint to the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 if and when the amendment is carried out).
  • The court expressly preferred the body of High Court authorities that permit amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 even when the amendment would oust the court's pecuniary jurisdiction, followed by return of the amended plaint under Order 7 Rule 10. The opinion therefore aligns with that "consensus view" rather than the contrary restrictive authorities, but it does so by following existing precedents rather than by laying down a novel rule of law in the sense of creating a new departure from prior authorities.

This summary is strictly confined to the facts, arguments, authorities, reasoning and orders as presented in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

    Shri Harish Kumar Chaudhary. v. Mrs. Vimal Wadhawan And Another.

    P.N Nag, J.— The facts leading to the revision petition are: That the plaintiff has filed a suit for permanent as well as mandatory injunction directing the defendants to restore the possession of Barsati Room and Bath Room. The plaintiff later on wanted to amend the plaint by amending the relief clause regarding permanent as well as mandatory injunction into a suit for possession, the valuation of which was fixed at Rs. 10,000/-. p73 There is no dispute between the parties that the jurisdiction of Shri A.K Chaturvedi, Sub Judge Fourth Class, was only upto Rs. 1,000/-. Therefore, in case the amendment is allowed, it will result in ousting the jurisdiction of the learned Sub Judge. The learned Sub Judge has, therefore, dismissed the application for amendment relying upon a decision in E.R.R.M.H.S Committee v. P. Atchayya (AIR 1957 Andhra Pradesh 10) which lays down that the court cannot permit a plaint sought to be amended as to ousts its own jurisdiction. The present revision has been filed against this order.

    Mr. Marwaha, counsel for the appellant submits that the consenses of various High Courts in the matter is that the Court in which the amendment is applied for and which is competent to entertain the original suit can decide the amendment application of the plaint even if it may involve ouster of jurisdiction of that Court. After the amendment is allowed, the plaint can be returned for presentation before the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10. If the amendment results in the ouster of jurisdiction of that court, after the amendment is carried out, the plaint can be returned.

    Mr. Munjal, however, on the other hand, argues that the view taken by the Andhra Pradesh High Court which has been relied upon by the trial court is correct that the court cannot permit a suit to be amended so as to oust its own jurisdiction. He relies upon Rachhya Singh and another v. Ram Ran Bijai Prasad Singh and others (AIR 1973 Patna 179).

    In order to appreciate the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner, I would like to refer to Suri Films v. S.N Govinda Prabhu and Brother (AIR 1989 Kerala 29). In that case various authorities for and against the proposition have been noted and discussed by the learned single Judge and has come to the conclusion that the Court before which a suit which it is competent to entertain and dispose of is pending can allow amendment of the plaint involving ouster of its jurisdiction. After allowing the amendment the Court should return the plaint as amended for presentation to the proper Court. When a Court having jurisdiction is seized of a matter, the question whether the amendment of the plaint has to be allowed or not could be considered only by that Court. The question of ouster of jurisdiction and incompetency to decide anything in the suit will come into play only when that effect is achieved by amendment. Even though the amendment notionally relates back to the date of presentation of the plaint, the amended plaint will be deemed to have been wrongly presented before the Court not having jurisdiction to entertain the same only when the amendment is carried out as per orders of the Court and then alone the question of passing an order for return of plaint for presentation before the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10(1) could arise.

    Similar view has been expressed in Benisham Mohanlal Khetan v. Mahadeo Tukaram Borkar (AIR 1985 Bom. 462). In that case it has been held that a civil court under Order 6 Rule 17 can allow the plaint to be so amended as to result in ousting its own jurisdiction in the matter, and in case the amendment is allowed and carried out, the proper course to be followed is to reutrn the amended plaint to the plaintiff for presentation to the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    In Patel Construction & Co. at Bombay and another v. Shah Raichand Amulakh and another (AIR 1973 Guj.283), Makireddy Ramayyamma v. Menti Kamalakararao (AIR 1983 A.P 11) etc. similar view has also been expressed.

    In E.R.R.M.H.S Committee v. P. Atchayya (AIR 1957 Andhra Pradesh 10) and Rachhya Singh and another v. Ram Ran Bijai Prasad Singh and others (AIR 1973 Patna 179) it has been held that the amendment of pleadings which oust the jurisdiction of the Court trying the suit should not be allowed. Similar view has also been expressed in C. Singara Mudaliar v. M. Govindaswami Chetty and others (AIR 1928 Madras 400).

    Therefore, in the light of what is discussed above, it is apparent that the consenses view which has been taken by various High Court appears to be is that a civil court under Order 6 Rule 17 can allow the plaint to be so amended as to result in ousting its own jurisdiction in the matter and in case the amendment is allowed and carried out the proper course to be followed is to return the amended plaint to the plaintiff for presentation to the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    It may be noted here that the Madras High Court itself has taken a contrary view in its judgments in Bhavani v. Mangamma (AIR 1949 Mad. 208) and in M. Allauddin v. P.S Lakshminarayanan (AIR 1970 Mad.247) wherein they have held that the court should not refuse the amendment merely on the basis that if the amendment is allowed, the suit would be beyond its pecuniary jurisdiction.

    As already stated, in Makireddy Ramayyamma's case (supra), the Andhra Pradesh High Court has also taken a similar view, contrary to the view expressed in E.R.R.M.H.S Committee v. P. Atchayya's case (supra).

    I have carefully considered the judgment and prefer the consenses view expressed by the various High Court that the amendment of plaint under Order 6 Rule 17 can be allowed even if it ousts its own jurisdiction in the matter and after the amendment is allowed and carried out the proper course to be followed is to return the amended plaint to the plaintiff for presentation to the proper court under Order 7 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    In these circumstances, I am of the opinion that the trial court has exercised its jurisdiction with material irregularity. The impugned order is, therefore, set aside. The amendment sought for is allowed. The amended plaint is stated to have already been filed before the trial court. The trial court will proceed in accordance with law.

    Revision petition is allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Harish Kumar Chaudhary. v. Mrs. Vimal Wadhawan And Another.
    (Apr 21, 1992)