Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 148 Indian Penal Code. Section 324 I.P.C
  • Section 397 I.P.C read with Section 392 I.P.C
  • provisions of Section 397 I.P.C
  • fails.10. Section 397 I.P.C
  • Sections 392 and 397 I.P.C
  • Sections 392/34 I.P.C
  • Section 397 I.P.C
  • Section 411 I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 148 Indian Penal Code. Section 324 I.P.C
  • Section 397 I.P.C read with Section 392 I.P.C
  • provisions of Section 397 I.P.C
  • fails.10. Section 397 I.P.C
  • Sections 392 and 397 I.P.C
  • Sections 392/34 I.P.C
  • Section 397 I.P.C
  • Section 411 I.P.C
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary (D.P. Wadhwa, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal from the judgment dated 22-11-1985 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi (Mr. V.S. Aggarwal), which convicted the appellant Salim under Sections 392 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced him to concurrent sentences of rigorous imprisonment (3 years for Section 392 with fine of Rs.200 and 7 years for Section 397 with fine of Rs.200), with default terms for non-payment of fines. Two co-accused were Satish Kumar and Avadh Kumar. The charges arose from an incident on 22-8-1984 at about 7:30 p.m. near Adarsh Nagar (Pushta behind Adarsh Nagar near Nullah) in which four persons allegedly surrounded and robbed Singh Ram (watch, diary, Rs.200) and Tejbir Singh (Rs.20). Three of the four assailants were said to be armed with knives; Singh Ram sustained an incised wound on his left forearm.

Investigation: Avadh Kumar and Satish Kumar were apprehended on 30-8-1984; Salim (the appellant) was arrested on 30-12-1984 under the Arms Act. An identification parade was held, and Singh Ram identified Salim on 4-1-1985. The prosecution examined nine witnesses at trial. At trial the Additional Sessions Judge convicted Salim and Avadh Kumar (the latter for an offence under Section 411 IPC) and acquitted Satish Kumar. Avadh Kumar received a sentence equated to the period already undergone in custody. Salim appealed the conviction and sentence, and this opinion disposes of that appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of the appellant can be sustained on the sole testimony of the injured witness (Singh Ram), given alleged contradictions and identification issues.
  2. Whether the facts of the case attract the offence under Section 397 IPC (robbery while being armed with a deadly weapon), specifically whether a knife, not recovered and of unspecified size, qualifies as a "deadly weapon" for the purposes of Section 397.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Mrs. Ahlawat)

  • Singh Ram's testimony is internally contradictory on a material point: the prosecution case and recovery memo showed the watch (Ex. P-1) was recovered at the instance of Avadh Kumar, but Singh Ram stated it was recovered at the instance of Salim; this contradiction undermines the witness's reliability.
  • The incident occurred at night and the first information report contained no description of the assailants; thus identification by Singh Ram was unreliable. It was also contended Singh Ram had been shown the accused at the police station before the identification parade.
  • If Singh Ram's testimony is excluded, there is no other evidence to sustain conviction of Salim, as Tejbir Singh did not identify any accused.
  • As to Section 397, a knife—particularly when not recovered and of unknown size—cannot be treated as a "deadly weapon" per se; two decisions of the High Court were cited (Balik Ram and Murari Lal) to support this proposition.

Prosecution's Case (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The prosecution relied primarily on the testimony of Singh Ram (the injured witness) who identified Salim as the person who took his watch and money and inflicted the knife injury.
  • Medical evidence (examination by Dr. K.K. Gupta) established an incised wound on Singh Ram's left forearm consistent with a sharp weapon.
  • There was a recovery of the wrist watch ultimately from Avadh Kumar (which the trial court used to support parts of the prosecution case), and disclosure statements and other investigative steps connected the accused to the crime.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balik Ram v. State (1983 RLR 395) Observed that knives are not per se deadly weapons; whether a knife is deadly depends on its design or manner of use and is therefore a question of fact for the prosecution to prove. The court noted this authority but observed it did not consider a later Supreme Court decision and thus was not binding; the principle that deadly character depends on facts was acknowledged but not followed as conclusive here.
Murari Lal v. State (23 (1983) DLT 410) Reflected the submission that a knife not recovered and of unknown size ordinarily would not be classified as a deadly weapon; the High Court concluded the case did not fall within Section 397 IPC. The court recorded this decision but treated it as not resolving the issue against the prosecution in light of higher authority; it did not accept this reasoning as binding for the present facts.
Shri Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration (AIR 1975 SC 905) Supreme Court held that a knife can be a deadly weapon and that it is not necessary for the accused to brandish the knife or cause grievous hurt; carrying a knife in open view can suffice to attract Section 397. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority as binding, holding that a knife may be treated as a deadly weapon and that overt acts such as brandishing are not necessary to attract Section 397.
Lakshmiammal v. Samiappa (AIR 1968 Madras 310) Held that weapons like knives, hammer, crowbar and spades are undoubtedly deadly weapons. The court cited this case as further support for the proposition that knives can be deadly weapons and used it, along with dictionary definitions, to reject the submission that size must be specified to classify a knife as deadly.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two main strands of analysis: (A) the reliability of the identification and the sufficiency of a single witness's testimony; and (B) whether the facts attract Section 397 IPC (use of a deadly weapon).

(A) On the testimony and identification:

  • The court emphasized there is no legal rule precluding conviction on the basis of the testimony of a single witness.
  • The court evaluated the credibility of Singh Ram (the injured witness) and found him to be reliable: he clearly identified Salim as the person who inflicted the knife blow and robbed him; there was no allegation of enmity or motive for fabrication against Singh Ram.
  • The court rejected the contention that identification could not have been reliable because of darkness: the incident occurred at about 7:30 p.m. on 22-8-1984 and the court held it could not be said there was darkness at that time sufficient to preclude identification from a close quarter.
  • Although a discrepancy existed in the witness's account about at whose instance the watch was recovered (Singh Ram said at Salim's instance whereas recovery was from Avadh Kumar), the court did not find this contradiction to be of such weight as to discredit the witness's core identification of Salim.
  • The alleged procedural flaw that the accused may have been shown to the witness before the identification parade was noted, but the court observed that regardless of any such flaw, Singh Ram was able to identify Salim; and the absence of other supporting reasons to doubt his testimony justified the trial court's acceptance of it.
  • Consequently, the court held there was sufficient evidence to convict Salim on the substantive offences charged.

(B) On whether Section 397 IPC is attracted (the "deadly weapon" issue):

  • The court reviewed the authorities cited by counsel. It observed that two High Court decisions (Balik Ram and Murari Lal) supported the view that a knife is not necessarily a deadly weapon per se and that its deadly character may depend on size, design or manner of use.
  • However, the court gave primacy to the Supreme Court decision in Shri Phool Kumar, which held that a knife can be a deadly weapon and that an overt act such as brandishing

    Court Opinion Summary (D.P. Wadhwa, J.)

    Factual and Procedural Background

    This is an appeal from the judgment dated 22-11-1985 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi (Mr. V.S. Aggarwal), which convicted the appellant Salim under Sections 392 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced him to concurrent sentences of rigorous imprisonment (3 years for Section 392 with fine of Rs.200 and 7 years for Section 397 with fine of Rs.200), with default terms for non-payment of fines. Two co-accused were Satish Kumar and Avadh Kumar. The charges arose from an incident on 22-8-1984 at about 7:30 p.m. near Adarsh Nagar (Pushta behind Adarsh Nagar near Nullah) in which four persons allegedly surrounded and robbed Singh Ram (watch, diary, Rs.200) and Tejbir Singh (Rs.20). Three of the four assailants were said to be armed with knives; Singh Ram sustained an incised wound on his left forearm.

    Investigation: Avadh Kumar and Satish Kumar were apprehended on 30-8-1984; Salim (the appellant) was arrested on 30-12-1984 under the Arms Act. An identification parade was held, and Singh Ram identified Salim on 4-1-1985. The prosecution examined nine witnesses at trial. At trial the Additional Sessions Judge convicted Salim and Avadh Kumar (the latter for an offence under Section 411 IPC) and acquitted Satish Kumar. Avadh Kumar received a sentence equated to the period already undergone in custody. Salim appealed the conviction and sentence, and this opinion disposes of that appeal.

    Legal Issues Presented

    1. Whether the conviction of the appellant can be sustained on the sole testimony of the injured witness (Singh Ram), given alleged contradictions and identification issues.
    2. Whether the facts of the case attract the offence under Section 397 IPC (robbery while being armed with a deadly weapon), specifically whether a knife, not recovered and of unspecified size, qualifies as a "deadly weapon" for the purposes of Section 397.

    Arguments of the Parties

    Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Mrs. Ahlawat)

    • Singh Ram's testimony is internally contradictory on a material point: the prosecution case and recovery memo showed the watch (Ex. P-1) was recovered at the instance of Avadh Kumar, but Singh Ram stated it was recovered at the instance of Salim; this contradiction undermines the witness's reliability.
    • The incident occurred at night and the first information report contained no description of the assailants; thus identification by Singh Ram was unreliable. It was also contended Singh Ram had been shown the accused at the police station before the identification parade.
    • If Singh Ram's testimony is excluded, there is no other evidence to sustain conviction of Salim, as Tejbir Singh did not identify any accused.
    • As to Section 397, a knife—particularly when not recovered and of unknown size—cannot be treated as a "deadly weapon" per se; two decisions of the High Court were cited (Balik Ram and Murari Lal) to support this proposition.

    Prosecution's Case (as reflected in the opinion)

    • The prosecution relied primarily on the testimony of Singh Ram (the injured witness) who identified Salim as the person who took his watch and money and inflicted the knife injury.
    • Medical evidence (examination by Dr. K.K. Gupta) established an incised wound on Singh Ram's left forearm consistent with a sharp weapon.
    • There was a recovery of the wrist watch ultimately from Avadh Kumar (which the trial court used to support parts of the prosecution case), and disclosure statements and other investigative steps connected the accused to the crime.

    Table of Precedents Cited

    Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
    Balik Ram v. State (1983 RLR 395) Observed that knives are not per se deadly weapons; whether a knife is deadly depends on its design or manner of use and is therefore a question of fact for the prosecution to prove. The court noted this authority but observed it did not consider a later Supreme Court decision and thus was not binding; the principle that deadly character depends on facts was acknowledged but not followed as conclusive here.
    Murari Lal v. State (23 (1983) DLT 410) Reflected the submission that a knife not recovered and of unknown size ordinarily would not be classified as a deadly weapon; the High Court concluded the case did not fall within Section 397 IPC. The court recorded this decision but treated it as not resolving the issue against the prosecution in light of higher authority; it did not accept this reasoning as binding for the present facts.
    Shri Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration (AIR 1975 SC 905) Supreme Court held that a knife can be a deadly weapon and that it is not necessary for the accused to brandish the knife or cause grievous hurt; carrying a knife in open view can suffice to attract Section 397. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority as binding, holding that a knife may be treated as a deadly weapon and that overt acts such as brandishing are not necessary to attract Section 397.
    Lakshmiammal v. Samiappa (AIR 1968 Madras 310) Held that weapons like knives, hammer, crowbar and spades are undoubtedly deadly weapons. The court cited this case as further support for the proposition that knives can be deadly weapons and used it, along with dictionary definitions, to reject the submission that size must be specified to classify a knife as deadly.

    Court's Reasoning and Analysis

    The court's analysis proceeded in two principal strands: assessment of the evidentiary value of the injured witness's testimony and the legal characterization of a knife as a "deadly weapon" for Section 397 IPC.

    1. Assessment of the witness (Singh Ram) and identification evidence:

    • The court reiterated that conviction may validly rest on the testimony of a single competent and reliable witness; there is no rule of law requiring multiple witnesses.
    • On the facts, the court found Singh Ram to be a credible witness: he specifically identified Salim as the person who inflicted the knife blow and took his watch and cash. There was no suggestion of enmity or motive to falsely implicate Salim.
    • The court rejected the submission that identification was impossible because of darkness: the incident took place at about 7:30 p.m. and the court held it could not be said there was such darkness as to preclude identification from close quarters.
    • The court acknowledged inconsistencies (notably the discrepancy regarding at whose instance the watch was recovered) but treated them as not fatal to the core identification and reliability of Singh Ram.
    • Although concerns about pre-parade exposure of the accused were noted, the court concluded that even if there were procedural flaws, they did not override the witness's clear identification and the absence of other reasons to distrust his testimony.

    2. Whether Section 397 IPC is attracted (the "deadly weapon" question):

    • The court considered the High Court decisions cited for the proposition that a knife is not per se a deadly weapon (Balik Ram and Murari Lal) but distinguished them from the binding Supreme Court authority in Shri Phool Kumar.
    • The court invoked Shri Phool Kumar to the effect that a knife can amount to a deadly weapon and that an accused need not have brandished it or caused grievous hurt for Section 397 to apply; carrying a knife in a manner sufficient to frighten or terrorize victims may attract Section 397.
    • The court also relied on Lakshmiammal and dictionary definitions to show that knives are commonly understood to be instruments capable of inflicting fatal injury and thus can be "deadly weapons" depending on use and circumstances.
    • On the facts, medical evidence showed an incised wound caused by a sharp weapon; there was also evidence that Salim was carrying a knife and that the injury to Singh Ram was inflicted by such a sharp-edged weapon. The court held it was not necessary to prove the size of the knife to bring the case within Section 397.

    Combining the credibility of the injured witness and the medical and circumstantial evidence about the weapon and injury, the court concluded that both the substantive conviction under Section 392 and the enhanced offence under Section 397 were made out and were rightly recorded by the trial court.

    Holding and Implications

    Holding: THE APPEAL IS DISMISSED. The trial court's conviction of the appellant Salim under Sections 392 and 397 IPC and the sentences imposed were upheld by this court.

    Implications:

    • Direct effect on the parties: Salim's conviction under Sections 392 and 397 IPC and the concurrent sentences (including the minimum seven-year sentence prescribed by Section 397) were affirmed. Avadh Kumar had been convicted under Section 411 IPC by the trial court and sentenced to the period already undergone; Satish Kumar was acquitted at trial. These outcomes remain in effect.
    • On legal principle: the court applied binding Supreme Court authority (Shri Phool Kumar) to hold that a knife can be a deadly weapon for the purposes of Section 397 and that proof of size is not necessary; however, the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying existing authority.
    • No new, broadly framed precedent was announced by this opinion beyond the application of established case law to the facts; the court rejected the appellant's factual and identification-based challenges and found the trial court's assessment reasonable.

    Salim v. State (Delhi Admn.) .

    D.P Wadhwa, J.:— This is an appeal against the order dated 22-11-1985 of Mr. V.S Aggarwal, Addl. Sessions Judge, Delhi, convicting the appellant under Sections 392 and 397 I.P.C and sentencing him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 3 years and to pay a fine of Rs. 200/- for the offence under Section 392 I P.C and in default of payment of fine to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for 3 months, and further sentencing him under Section 397 I.P.C to rigorous imprisonment for 7 years and to pay a fine Rs. 200/- and again in default of payment of fine to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for 6 months. Both the substantive sentences of imprisonment were further ordered to run concurrently.

    2. The appellant, Salim, along with two others, namely, Satish Kumar and Avadh Kumar, was charged firstly for an offence under Sections 392/34 I.P.C and secondly for an offence under Section 397 I.P.C read with Section 392 I.P.C The first charge against these three persons was that on 22-8-1984 at about 7.30 p.m at Pushta behind Adarsh Nagar near Nullah within the jurisdiction of Police Station Adarsh Nagar, they committed robbery by robbing Singh Ram of his diary and Rs. 200/- and also a wrist watch and robbing Tejbir Singh of Rs. 20/-, and the second charge was that at the said date, time and place while committing robbery aforesaid, they were armed with deadly weapons, to wit knives.

    3. The prosecution alleged that Singh Ram and Tejbir Singh were related to each other and that on 22-8-1984 they went to the house of one Narinder at Jehangirpuri in the evening and had their meals there. They left the house of Narinder at about 7.00 p.m and as they were walking back when they reached near culvert, four persons surrounded them. Three of them were armed with knives. At the point of knife, one of the said persons took the watch of Singh Ram and also took Rs. 200/- from his pocket. In that process that person inflicted a knife blow on the left forearm of Singh Ram. In the same very process Tejbir Singh was deprived of Rs. 20/-. The four persons after committing robbery escaped.

    4. The police was informed and they started investigation. Singh Ram was removed to Hindu Rao Hospital. Dr. K.K Gupta, who examined him, found one incised wound on left forearm, posterior aspect middle part 2 cm × 1 cm skin deep. The wound was bleeding at the time of his examination and it was opined that the injury was caused by a sharp weapon. Out of four persons involved in the robbery only three could be apprehended. First accused Avadh Kumar was arrested on 30-8-1984. On his making a disclosure statement, watch of Singh Ram was recovered and seized. Accused Satish Kumar was also stated to have been arrested on the same day while he was coming to the court. The third accused Salim, the appellant, was arrested on 30-12-1984 under the Arms Act. He is also stated to have made a disclosure statement regarding the occurrence in question so as to connect him with the crime. Both Avadh Kumar and Satish Kumar refused to participate in the identification parade. Salim accused was identified in the identification parade held on 4-1-1985 by Singh Ram. When date was fixed for his identification again as Tejbir Singh was not present on the earlier date, Salim accused refused to join the identification parade. After the investigation was complete, the police sent in the challan and the accused were charged as above-mentioned.

    5. In support of its case the prosecution examined in all 9 witnesses and gave up the rest. Statements of the accused were recorded. They denied their involvement. Accused Salim stated that it was on 27-12-1984 that he was taken away from his house at about 8.30 p.m and was kept in the police post Jehangirpuri for four days and thereafter falsely implicated in the case. In support of his plea, be examined his brother Nariruddin as DW 1 who also brought on record a photo-copy of the telegram sent by him to the higher officials of the police when Salim accused was taken away from the house. There was, however, no follow up by him.

    6. By his judgment dated 22-11-1985, the learned Addl. Sessions Judge acquitted Satish Kumar. He, however, convicted accused Avadh Kumar for an offence under Section 411 I.P.C Avadh Kumar was already in custody since 30-8-1984 and by the date of the judgment, he had undergone more than one year of imprisonment while facing the trial. The learned Addl. Sessions Judge, therefore, sentenced him to imprisonment for the period already undergone by him. The accused Salim was convicted and sentenced as above-mentioned.

    7. The only evidence against the appellant Salim is the statement of Singh Ram, PW. Tejbir Singh, the other person, who was robbed, could not identify any of the accused persons. In his statement, Singh Ram said that out of the four persons three were armed with knives and that he could identify only one person who was Salim accused. The witness said that at the point of knife Salim accused took his watch (Ex. P-1) and also Rs. 200/- cash and further that Salim accused inflicted knife blow on his left forearm. He also stated that Rs. 20/- were snatched from Tejbir Singh. Singh Ram also stated that the watch Ex. P-1 was recovered at the instance of Salim from his room in Jehangirpuri-He said the watch so recovered was seized by memo Ex. P-1.A. Obviously, this could not be correct as the prosecution case itself was that the watch Ex. P-1 was recovered at the instance of accused Avadh Kumar from his house, and, in fact, on that premise Avadh Kumar was convicted by the trial court for an offence under Section 411 I.P.C This led Mrs. Ahlawat, learned counsel for the appellant, to contend that no reliance could be placed on the statement of Singh Ram which was contradictory on material point. She said that the witness was mixing up Salim accused with Avadh Kumar accused and that benefit of this should go to the accused Salim. It was also her contention that the incident allegedly took place when there was darkness of night and it was not possible for Singh Ram to identify the accused Salim particularly when in the first information report no description of the accused had been given. She said once the statement of Singh Ram was not taken into consideration, there was no evidence whatsoever to convict the appellant. It is no doubt correct that the appellant has been convicted on the sole testimony of Singh Ram.

    8. But then there is no rule of law that a person cannot be convicted on the testimony of a single witness. I find that Singh Ram is a reliable witness. He clearly identified the accused Salim as the person who inflicted knife blow on his arm and also robbed him. He, however, was unable to identify the other two accused. It cannot be said that it is not possible for anyone to identify a person immediately after night-fall when he has seen him from a close quarter. In the present case, the incident took place at about 7.30 p.m on 22-8-1984. It cannot, therefore, be said that there was darkness at that time. Mrs. Ahlawat also submitted that before the identification parade was held wherein Singh Ram identified accused Salim, the accused had already been shown to the witness in the police station. The fact, however, remains that irrespective of this flaw, if any, witness Singh Ram was able to identify accused Salim. No enmity or other motive is alleged against the witness for him to involve the accused. The wrist watch of which the witness Singh Ram was robbed was ultimately recovered though from the accused Avadh Kumar, who, as noted above, has been convicted for an offence under Section 411 I.P.C In my view, therefore, the learned Addl. Sessions Judge did not commit any error in accepting the statement of the witness Singh Ram to come to the conclusion that accused Salim committed the offences charged against him.

    9. Then Mrs. Ahlawat submitted that in any case no offence under Section 397 I.P.C could be said to have been committed inasmuch as it was stated that the accused was armed with a knife only and that the knife had also not been recovered. She said a knife could not be a deadly weapon and in support of her contention she referred to two decisions of this court both rendered by M.L Jain, J In Balik Ram v. State (1983 RLR 395), the learned Judge observed as under:

    “Knives are weapons available in various sizes and may just cause little hurt or may be the deadliest. They are not deadly weapons per se such as would ordinarily result in death by their use. What would make a knife deadly is its design or the manner of its use such as is calculated to or is likely to produce death. It is, therefore, a question of fact to be proved and prosecution should prove that the knife used by the accused was a deadly one.”

    In Murari Lal v. State (23 (1983) DLT 410), it was submitted on behalf of the accused that the knife had not been recovered and no one knew the size of its blade and unless the size was known, a knife could not ordinarily be classified as a deadly weapon within the meaning of Section 397 I.P.C There is no discussion in the judgment on this submission except that the learned Judge observed that he was in agreement with the counsel for the accused that the case did not fall within Section 397 I.P.C In Shri Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration (AIR 1975 SC 905) the accused was carrying knife in his hand at the time the robbery was committed. There were other accused as well one of whom was armed with a small gun and in fact had fired 3 shots in the air. The Supreme Court held that in order to attract the provisions of Section 397 I.P.C it was not necessary that the accused should have been brandishing the kinef or causing grievous hurt with it. It observed as under:—

    “So far as he is concerned he is said to be armed with a knife which is also a deadly weapon. To be more precise from the evidence of P.W 16 “Phool Kumar had a knife in his hand”. He was therefore carrying a deadly weapon open to the view of the victims sufficient to frighten or terrorize them. Any other overt act, such as, brandishing of the knife or causing of grievous hurt with it was not necessary to bring the offender within the ambit of Section 397 of the Penal Code.”

    This decision of the Supreme Court wherein it is held that knife is a deadly weapon was not referred to in the aforesaid two decisions of this court and the same are not, therefore, a binding precedent. Under Section 397 I.P.C an offender is guilty if he uses any deadly weapon or causes grievous hurt to any person or attempts to cause death or grievous hurt to any person. The words ‘deadly weapon’ are of common use and do not need any definition or interpretation. The words ‘deadly weapon’ have also been used in Section 148 Indian Penal Code. Section 324 I.P.C uses the words ‘dangerous weapons’ in its heading. It says whoever voluntarily causes hurt by any instrument for shooting, stabbing or cutting, or any instrument which used as a weapon of offence is likely to cause death, etc., is liable to punishment. In Lakshmiammal v. Samiappa (AIR 1968 Madras 310), the accused were armed with weapons like knife, hammer, crowbar and spades. It was held that these were undoubtedly deadly weapons. The Concise Oxford Dictionary defines the word ‘weapon’ as ‘material thing designed or used or usable as an instrument for inflicting bodily harm, e.g gun, bomb, rifle, sword, spear, stick hammer, poker, horn, claw’. The word ‘deadly’, according to this Dictionary, means ‘causing fatal injury’. Also, according to this Dictionary, ‘knife’ means ‘blade with sharpened longitudinal edge fixed in handle either rigidly ……..or with hinge used as cutting instrument or as weapon’. As per Webster's Third New International Dictionary a ‘knife” is ‘a simple instrument used for cutting consisting of a sharp-edged usually steel blade provided with a handle’. Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English defines ‘knife’ as ‘a blade fixed in a handle used for cutting as a tool or weapon’. These definitions in various dictionaries can be multiplied. We all understand what a knife means and to categorise it or to fix its size for it to be a deadly weapon may not be appropriate. A knife has also been described as a pocket knife, pen knife, table knife, kitchen knife, etc. It cannot be denied that a knife can be used as a weapon of offence. It can cut, it can pierce, it can be deadly. To say that a knife to be a deadly weapon should be of a particular size would perhaps be not a correct statement. In the present case, the evidence shows that the injury was caused to Singh Ram witness by a sharp-edged weapon and there is a statement that the accused Salim was carrying a knife and it was with that knife that the injury was caused to the witness. It would not be necessary for the witness to further state as to what was the size of the knife to attract the provisions of Section 397 I.P.C, as was contended by Mrs. Ahlawat. This contention that case under Section 397 I.P.C is not made out fails.

    10. Section 397 I.P.C prescribes a minimum sentence of imprisonment for 7 years. The appellant has been rightly convicted and sentenced under the section.

    11. This appeal, therefore, fails and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Salim v. State (Delhi Admn.) .
    (Nov 9, 1987)